my TOP 10 murder mystery books OF ALL TIME! 🔪🩸💀 (2024)

megwithbooks
324 followers
22 Video Views·Sep 23, 2024
so if I'm here with my hat on in my
dad's jacket we know we're going to be
talking about a Mysteries and today I
going to be doing an updated list of my
top 10 murder mysteries I last did this
list I've only done once and I Did It 2
and a half years ago so I feel like
that's enough time the list has changed
somewhat some of it's still the same cuz
there's still some bangers you know some
Classics on there but we've got quite a
lot of new books when I last did this
list there was some four stars on here
cuz I'm so picky with M Mysteries there
was I think two or three books at the
bottom of the list that hadd given four
stars maybe one 4.5 this time it's all
absolute five stars and all books I
absolutely recommend I have grouped some
series together otherwise this list
would be quite repetitive but shall we
just get into it or my favorite Murder
Mysteries the murder mysteries I'd
really recommend if you're looking to
get into murder mysteries if you've
never read them before this is where I'd
recommend you start and we're going to
go from number 10 to number one should
we do it I'm so excited let's get into
it okay coming in at number 10 is our
first from the queen of crime it is
death on the Nile by Agatha Christie one
of my I love these additions I love oh
they like speak to me I love these
additions of the AG Christy books and
this is not the last AG the Christi we
shall be seeing on this list there's one
more a Chris this list so this is my in
my top two a Christies and Death on the
Nile is an interesting one because
obviously it's very we all kind of know
the general Vibe of this there's a boat
on the Nile and there's a murder
and farro is going to solve it and this
is an interesting one because in
contrast to the uh other AGA that we
have on this list I wouldn't say the
twist in this is anything special right
I wouldn't say it's shocking right when
you compare you the talk about the other
e or like something like M of Roger
arroy which was on the list last time I
did this has a wonderful twist this this
twist is like fairly forgettable however
this is one of those books that Christy
does the atmosphere and the setting so
well and it just makes I love theatrics
to a mder that's why it's fun right like
as someone who grew up loving I did
drama I did like acting I love her
production you know there's something
about some of these settings that Agatha
does and I'm sure that I've got many
more to read that just feels so Camp
it's Camp it's Camp I don't know what to
tell you and you know this comes from
her traveling with her second husband
who was an archaeologist and she
traveled to Egypt she traveled all over
the world in that period of her life and
there's a lot of books that reflect that
and I just think she captures a time and
a place so so well and is so vivid and
the Mystery in the murder is good as
well but this one for me is just very
solid overall like for example if we're
talking about the murder of Roger akroy
I don't love the majority of that book
but I think it's one of the best twists
in a murder mystery ever like her
writing that revolutionary like it's
it's an amazing twist whereas this one I
just really enjoyed the book throughout
we've got a lot of interesting
characters we've got kind of like a love
triangle there's like a couple in the GU
EX on the boat and there's just a really
interesting Cass of characters um that
she does really well so yeah I really
really enjoyed death on now coming in at
number nine is a really fun one it is
True Crime Story by Joseph Knox so this
one is mixed media it's all told through
interviews in the early hours of
Saturday 17th December 2011 Zoe Nolan a
19-year-old Manchester University
student walked out of a party taking
place in the shared accommodation with
she had been living for 3 months she was
never seen again and this is all a
series of interviews with her friends
and family trying to piece together what
happened to her and firstly just love
mixed media I love mixed media I did
listen to AUD book for this and it is
full cast so I would recommend that but
like similar to dais Jones the 6th which
I spoke about recently it doesn't say
who it is at the start of every time
they start speaking so you have to kind
of remember voices if you're just audio
booking it so I would recommend for like
a full experience having the audio book
and the physical I don't recommend that
a lot even know I do that a lot a little
bit of a bad habit I don't recommend
that cuz it's obviously like expensive
getting both but I think this is one
where that would really benefit the
story and this is one's a really
interesting one cuz not only is it
interviews but there's these emails and
Joseph Knox is a character and there's
like a there's a Publishers note at the
beginning from penguin Random House like
clarifying their position with Joseph
Knox and he Joseph Knox comes into the
story at certain points she's an icon
she's a legend and she is the moment now
come on now and it's just such an
imaginative fun way to tell a story I
I'm just a sucker for it I'm a sucker
for mix media I'm a sucker for like
breaking the fourth wall I just love it
I love it I love it I love it I thought
the reveal of the murder mystery was
really really good I thought the
characters that were picked were very
interesting hearing from their
perspectives but yeah I just had a lot
of fun with the way this was told and
the different elements to it and there's
like emails with notes and stuff
redacted and crossed out and I really
enjoyed kind of like the university
setting it's kind of scary like you know
a young girl off at University for the
first time like stuff can go wrong
easily and so you're just like I don't
know I just thought was an interesting
setting the hat is falling off and I'm
getting hot in this jacket let me just
air it out a little bit coming in at
number eight is one by one by Ruth wear
this is probably my favorite Ruth wear
and this is her most murder mystery book
I feel like people did not get this when
it came out and I'm deeply upset because
since then she is not writing M
Mysteries well I one is it one perfect
couple release this year I have a bit of
Hope with that one I'm not going to lie
to you there's something about that one
that gives me a little bit met mystery
tease but this is her most like Christy
inspired meta mystery and we're
following these characters who go on a
company Retreat to this Ski Lodge ski
Village they are all in this Lodge
together you find out at the beginning
there's a there's a news article from a
BBC website that four people have been
found dead so you're trying to figure
out obviously who it is and I just loved
this I love this you're reading from a
few different perspectives this one's an
interesting of mystery cuz cuz you know
from a certain point who it is right
there it's like they're getting killed
off one by one it's kind of and then
they're went uninspired but like not
scheduled killings which I don't like so
I like this they n retelling but what's
interesting is you know from a certain
point who that is so it's a little bit
different than some Murder Mysteries and
how that builds the tension is so good
it's so good I just wish Ruth would do
more stuff like this cuz she had you
know an unlikable Rich Cass of
characters that you kind of love to hate
that you don't mind who do and that's
fun isolated setting they're stuck in
this house together I just really really
enjoyed it I would love her to do more
stuff like this this one I remember like
people not enjoying it I remember it
being like quite a controver not
controversial in terms of like
problematic but controversial in terms
of people having different opinions and
I was just looking at them like you just
don't get what she's doing here you just
don't get how she's paying homage to X
Christy you don't get it if you get it
you get it if you don't you don't if you
know you know and if you don't know like
I honestly feel bad for you like sorry I
really really love this one this was on
the list last time and it's retained at
spot number seven is the mysterious case
of the Alon Angels by Janice halet Janet
is more for me that's like almost bigger
than some of her Parts I just love what
she's doing with the murder mystery
genre like for me she's up there as one
of my favorite murder mystery authors I
loved the twiford code twiford code is
another interesting one it's similar to
the Mur the murder of Ro Arro which I
gave both them 4.5 stars but like I
don't love love love the entire book but
an amazing twist like one of the best
twists ever I love the Twist and the
triod code but anyways this one is about
a cult where there was a mass un Al
living like 20 15 18 years ago 18 I
think 17 something like that years ago
and there was a baby who people had seen
around the cult the mother and the baby
disappeared into the care system and
we're following two journalists as they
try to piece together what happened
because the baby is going to be turning
18 so people want to interview them now
that they're an adult and this is
another mixed media it's my favorite
jist palette because it's a variety of
mixed media we have emails we have you
know um audio transcripts we have text
we have a script that's really
interesting there's there's a lot of
different forms of mixed media which I
really enjoy my issue with like the
appeal By Janice halet was that it's
just emails and that can get a bit
repetitive but there's a lot of layers
to this one and this to me is her most
recommendable book I think the twia code
I can understand why some people don't
like it the appeal a lot of people enjoy
it but for me was a bit debuty whereas
this one I feel like she's worked out
the Kinks in this kind of mixed media
format and I just loved it I loved the
Journey of reading this book it's unput
downable I will say you need to read
this book pretty quickly I think I read
it in two or 3 days and like 3 days is
your max like you need to read it
quickly because there's a lot of threads
there's a lot of little hints being laid
very cleverly that you're trying to like
you feel like you're trying to hold
together um which is amazing like I want
there to be a lot of little scattered
parts of the book that you're trying to
put together I'm like Scooby and Shaggy
I'm solving a mystery but I think if if
you read it over a longer period of time
you would struggle and the book would
not have as much of an impact it
wouldn't be as enjoyable cuz you're like
what like you're trying to remember lots
of different things so I would save this
for a time when you know you can read it
pretty quickly in a couple of days
because otherwise I think the reading
experience would suffer coming in at
number six is an absolute classic and it
is a good girls guide to Murder By Holly
Jackson I think our only ya on this list
and listen I know I did a video recently
talking about how much I hated the
adaptation hopefully Holly Jackson did
not see that me when Holly Jackson
confronts me over saying the show was
I do not ever remember saying that
you but it did quite well in the
algorithm so I'm a bit concerned that
she might have done Holly I'm sorry if
you're out there but I love your writing
I love the books in this I'm sure many
of you know we're following pip as she
tries to solve what happened to Andy
Bell who was a girl who went missing
presumed dead in her town and people
believe that the boyfriend did it
there's like a vague kind of confession
but pip doesn't believe it's true and
this is another mixed Med oh my God
there's so much mixed media I think this
is this is our last mixed media guys
this is our last mix media I just love
it I love it in ROM Mysteries and I mean
I don't want to sound like a broken
record talking about how this book is
amazing and the show was but like
just what this book does is so good the
way the mystery builds the way that pip
grows as a character throughout the
series I just love I love the series I
love it love it I'd only call the first
book of murder mystery the second book
is more of a missing person mystery and
the third book is like a thriller it's I
mean the third book's incredible the
third book is probably my favorite in
the series but it's not a m of mysteries
it's not on this list and yeah the mixed
media in this is amazing like like I
love the interviews we're get into
another book about interviews actually
in a second but I love the interviews in
this and they just they ruined it in the
show they ruined it the the interviews
were like two SEC two questions in the
show for like 30 second oh pisses me off
oh let's not talk about it but the book
is amazing the book is amazing the
series is amazing I cannot recommend it
enough The album's Amazing song to song
I can't stress it enough you guys should
definitely pick it up if you haven't
already I feel like probably everyone
has by now but it's so good then very
interestingly coming in at number five
let's talk about it guys is a book that
I believe was number one last time I did
this list and there's books on here that
were lower than it that were lower than
it last time I did it but I just don't
think this is stood the test of time for
me quite as much as some of these other
books and it's the guest list by Lucy
Foley for a long time I had a lot of
like an attachment to this book cuz this
is one of the first M Mysteries I ever
read I can't remember if I read this or
the book that's second I keep I keep
referring to in this video I can't
remember which one I read first but this
was a very formative reading experience
to me I did a I remember did a video
where I um I read Murder Mysteries and I
read this the hunting party and
something else maybe I read The Strange
Case zam's daughter for that video as
well even though that's not a met
mystery but I kind of thought it was
from the description I remember I went
to the talk for this at Le see Foy did
and this was before it even blew up
because the Hunting Party wasn't super
successful so she was still like you
know this book hadn't had the success
that they went on to have and here's the
thing I Love Lucy Foy I don't think this
is hold held maybe if I reread it and I
have reread it and I don't think I loved
it as much but it's a very formative
book for me in terms of my reading
journey and I do really love it it is a
wedding where we we read from the night
of the wedding first and there's a body
that's found in the first chapter and
then we go back to like the day before
the wedding and lead up to it with kind
of flash forwards the night of the
wedding but predominantly the story is
leading us through and we have as always
with Lucy Foley a lot of different
perspectives that are archetypal that we
have like what are some of their what
are some of their names jonno jonno is
the best man we have the bride we have
the wedding planner we have the plus
one yeah so we have all these different
perspective the Bridesmaids we have all
these different perspectives that we're
reading from and Lucy Foley just ases
unlikable rich people so well that you
don't mind getting murdered I that's
like my one of my favorite genres of
murder mystery unlik rich people getting
murdered she does it so well and the
story lines the twist in this this is
like one of the first like real twisty
books I read and I was Gaga chondra
these twist upon twist upon twist so
good I the atmosphere on this it's like
oh this island where there's a storm as
the wedding's happening and like don't
know you don't even know who's dead I
think that's such a great thing about
this book like you're trying you don't
even know who's dead and so you really
got so many different questions this is
still my favorite Lucy Foley but I'm
hopeful I haven't heard heard a ton of
things about the midnight Feast actually
I need to go look at seeing some reviews
what people have thought about it Lucy
froley does have a soft spot for me as
one of my favorite murder mystery
authors I just think she does it so well
she gives me that classic murder mystery
so well I really love these archetypal
characters that's like Peak murder
mystery for me like cludo you know in
cludo you have those characters that are
like different archetypes it just it
fills me with such Joy so this has moved
down in terms of like what I would rank
now but I still still love it now the
next one is as far like I'm quite strict
with what I allow on this list in terms
of being a murder mystery I don't really
allow missing person Mysteries I don't
allow like more Thriller stuff like I'm
quite strict with it you know this next
book is is as far as I'm allowing to go
in terms of in terms of why what's
happening here because this one you know
who's committed the murder from the
start the the mystery is why the murder
has been committed and what people could
be behind behind the reasonings of that
person committing a murder and it is
Wrong Place Wrong Time by Jil McAllister
I love this book love love love love
love love love love this book The Plot
the the synopsis just came out for Jill
Mel's next book I still haven't read
just one missing person let's not talk
about it but um her next book is about a
woman who's like taking her hus taking
her kids to school she reads on new has
a hostage situation at a local bank her
husband is the one holding people
hostage that she had no idea that he
could even it sounds amazing guys it
sounds amazing comes out in January I'm
so excited so in this one of more woman
witnesses her son commit a murder I've
told you about this so many times but
she she seems to Comm murder she's
horrified she goes to sleep at night she
wakes up it's the day before go to sleep
wakes up the day before that so she
keeps going back in time sometimes she
skips like a week at First it's a day a
day day a day when it's closer in time
but then she starts skipping you know
further further expenses of time and I
loved this it's such a fun speculative
this is only really the only speculative
um murder Myster having this well like I
said you know who commits the murder but
it's her trying to figure out why her
son did that and like you're you're
figuring out the chain of events and the
people that play a role in that
happening if that makes sense so I would
you know it's close isn't it it's close
but I do love this book The Rules don't
apply I love this book I love what jul M
does in this and it really is just a
wonderful heartfelt book where it's
about a mother's love for her son and I
thought and also you know love for other
family members there's a there's a story
line with her dad that is very
emotionally impactful but really just
what woman will go to the extents that
she'll go to to look after her son and
to figure out why he did what he did I
loved I loved I loved I loved I loved I
loved so I I I am so this is the only
the only GIC alist I've read so I need
to get into some more I need to read
just another missing person her new one
sounds so good but I love this one so
we're into the top three guys this is
very exciting I think you guys can
probably guess what a lot this is coming
number three we have the first of the
series that I mentioning and it is the
lady Hard Castle mystery
series these are probably my three
favorite favorites in the series we've
got in the market for murder which is
the third don't ask me what numbers
these are the burning issue of the day
and Def on the seaside but I think I'm
like nine or 10 I wish they had numbers
on them um into the series now and this
is my favorite cozy mystery series by
far we're following I need to read
another one I'm like craving it oh maybe
I'll do
that I'm not going to say anything you
naughty naughty you teasing me you
naughty
naughty We are following lady Hard
Castle and her made flow as they solve M
mystery together it's set in Edward in
England it's set oh my God I'm actually
I get emotional talking about this
series I don't know why I love it so
much it's so comforting guys I love it
love it love it love it love it but
they're in this quaint English Village
little Littleton cural and you've got
like by now we've got this cast of
characters in The Village who you know
so well and they're just solving murders
baby they're just solving murders and
I'd love it why did I get so emotional
they series I just
adore hard to talk about it really is
incredible
if you're going to read them listen to
the Audi book the audio book narrator is
incredible the I own the books
cuz I love them but you don't need to
these are just like these are like self
they're not self-published I think it's
one of the Amazon Publishers that he
publishes them through but you don't
need to own the books you can just
listen to the audio the audio book guys
it's so good this narrator is so so so
good so good so so so good I can't
explain to you how good this narrator is
and I just I get like it get makes me
emotional thinking about this I don't
know why I just love them I love this is
like my it feels very special to me I
just love this series and they're just
quaint little Murder Mysteries and
they're such good palette cleansers and
you know I don't give every book in the
series five stars I think a lot of them
they're usually now for me a 4.5 or a
five I just really adore this series I
really really adore this series and I
cannot recommend it enough coming in at
number two is one that I've mentioned a
lot in references to other books but it
is MD on the oran Express by Agatha
Christie 10 out of 10 I love it this to
me is my favorite christe that I've read
so far I'm ganking them slowly I would
like to read another Christie at some
point this year but yes this is actually
I think the first chrisy ever read I do
want to reread this at the end of the
year maybe like after Christmas in that
kind of like weird time between New Year
and Christmas I would like to reread
this um because I haven't read it in so
long and I'm up to this point now in the
prro series like this would be the next
one for me to read and culturally a lot
of you know the synopsis of this book
there's a murder on the train on the or
Express there's snowed in and the
murderer is on the train with prro and
the other guests and he is figuring out
who it is now I've mentioned few times
before the majority a bulk of this book
is prro sitting down and doing
interviews with each person you're going
to love it or hate it I find usually
people some people love every chrisy but
I find people either love and or dislike
merge on your Express and then there
were none I don't love and then there
were none because I don't like the
scheduled killings like I don't know
like knowing someone's going to die in
the next page like I want it to be a
surprise and it's more Thriller almost
and then there were none so there's more
like excitement there's more more Pace
whereas this one it's very analytical
and it's very him sitting down all these
people and you're trying to piece
together the stories that they're all
telling and find the lies and like I
said when I alluded to this earlier an
incredible twist Ah that's
history an incredible twist so far the
best twist ofaces I've read are this and
murder of rer arroy but this one if you
don't know it like please please read
this soon so that you if you have not
yet got spoiled for this twist cuz it's
quite inform qual read this soon so you
can read it having not get spoiled for
the twist cuz I feel like at some point
you will I read it not having been
spoiled for the Twist and I just loved
it I loved I think it's ingenious I love
I Christie's mind so yeah I do want to
reread it soon but I just love a
Christie they're just so well written so
fun but easy you know they're not super
long they're pretty easy to get through
so I do want to read another Christie
soon and then number one on the list we
have the Thursday Murder Club series it
wasn't going to be anything else was it
for me my favorite are the first and the
last the last is my favorite so far in
the series but probably not cuz of the
murder mystery if I'm being completely
honest with you my issue is I read
numbers two and three oh I read
numbers two and three like back to back
almost I read them like a month apart
whereas everything else have had a year
between so I honestly cannot remember
the difference between two and three I
need to do a reread at some point maybe
next year when the fifth comes out but
um I I can't remember the difference but
for me number one I think the mystery is
great the mystery out of all of them
stands out for me in this one I think
the murders are really fun the way the
gangs start to come together and there's
also a few moments that made me cry
number two and three don't really make
me cry number four dear
God if you want to
cry yeah yeah yeah this is what trauma
looks like I'm sure you all know what
this series is following a group of
elderly characters who live in a
retirement home who solve Med Mysteries
and not only is it a great murder
mystery but Richard Osman my guy I love
this man so much the way that he writes
human nature and drills down into what
makes us tick and what what we love as
humans the small the minutia the kind of
mundane everyday stuff that people don't
talk about I think he's in incredible
incredible I I just can't describe to
you how he reflects human nature but how
the humor in these books they're funny
they're light-hearted they're joyful but
this
one dear God like it is so emotional you
I I have not cried like this a book I
can't remember another book that I have
cried probably to this extent maybe like
the traveling cat
Chronicles that's up there but like
screaming crying screaming crying
screaming crying throwing up like it's
it was amazing it's an amazing book it's
an amazing series I'm very excited for
his new release this year we solve
merges which will probably be on this
list next time we do it hopefully but um
yeah I just think grard Osman five star
five star always to me I just love this
series so much if you have not picked it
up yet please please do I've heard if
you're not from the UK the audio books
can be helpful because there's a lot of
like Niche UK references like to I don't
know the chase the show The Chase or
like Great British fake off or something
there's like some British references you
might not get and I I've heard that the
Audi book can help with that um kind of
like understanding the context of what's
going on just the way things are said
but I personally just read these
physically and I love just reading them
physically but yes I love I love I love
I love so there we go everyone that is
my top 10 murder mysteries we'll
probably do this list again in two and a
half three years I think that's a good
amount of time between doing them cuz I
have to keep it updated cuz there's ones
on that list that are you know that
aren't aren't up to date so um yeah I'd
love to know what some of your favorite
murder mysteries are I'm always looking
for more murder mystery recommendations
like I'm a picky girl there aren't a lot
there's probably only like 20 murder
mysteries out there if we're like
including different books and series
that I've given five stars like I'm
quite picky with it so I'd love to know
some recommendations of ones that you
guys have loved let me know if you've
read any of these on my account and what
you thought of them I'd love to know
like I love hearing people's experience
with books that I've recommended and
what they thought of them like so many
of you reach out to me about the lady
Hard Castle series it makes me so happy
when you guys love them like I'd love to
know your guys' opinions but thank you
so much for watching and I'll see you
very soon in another video bye
[Music]
