FG42 Type 1 [Prototype] to 500yds: Practical Accuracy (The literal pain of small arms development)

Sunday Enjoy
2 followers
2 Video Views·Sep 22, 2024
This video is brought to you by Slate Black Industries. For grips and accessories,
visit slateblackindustries.com. So I've got to be crystal clear here. These are reproduction
FG-42 prototypes, meaning that Rick Smith had reverse engineered these from FG-42 blueprints
that don't exist, since the RAF was doing a lot of work back then. But his production line
currently has very few reliability issues, as evident on Ian from Forgotten Weapons and Carl
from InRange running both of these, their Type 1 and Type 2s, in multitudes of desert brutality or
brutality matches. But the prototype does exhibit issues, and those issues sometimes are more
interesting to learn about potential downfalls in systems designs. And to us, that is worth
documenting and delving into. But without further ado, we'll see you on the course.
All right, I'm on 150. Please don't break the target.
I'll tell you this, this trigger is extremely difficult to squeeze.
It's, uh, have you ever shot an open bolt machine gun?
Like a belt-fed or something? Yeah, yeah. It's, it's like a belt-fed machine gun.
Okay, 200. Impact. Can't really tell. Sorry. 250. Dead on.
Ready? Yep. That's a nasty, nasty misfire.
Yeah, the, the way, the way the bag is, it keeps on riding right here. And then when it,
because you know, look at, look at this. Watch the charging handle. It impinges,
once it impinges upon that, it's already having a hard enough time touching off some of the
machine gun primers on this thing. If you have a little bit of impingement to kind of hold that
firing pin. Where it's not hitting with its full weight. Right. It's just not going to touch it
off. Yep. All right. Well noted. Ready? Yep. Impact. All right, I'm on it. 300.
Impact. Dead center.
Impact. Left half.
Impact. That was on the right half. Okay. Yeah. I adjusted it to the right. I just didn't know
how much it would go. Yep. You've got to keep in mind when this thing was designed,
there was no assault rifle. There was no, I mean, there was select fire, like the Thompson
submachine guns and stuff, but those were all open bolt select fire. FG-42s are closed bolt
on semi and open bolt on full auto. It just comes down to the way they designed it. And
we'll go over a little more on why that can turn into a liability issue
in the longterm. However, it's still an incredible weapon.
Okay. Just off the left edge. That's the elevation though. Hold that elevation. Okay.
That looked to be just underneath it. Okay.
Just off the left. Impact. Ready? Yeah. Impact. Dead on. Okay. So that's the second one. Yep.
not to basically keep it away from that bag as much as possible on the charging handle.
Impact. Okay. Okay. 500. It ejected, right? A second ago? Yeah. Nope. It ripped the rim again.
Might I suggest a bit of oil into the chamber? Jeez, dude, that's really deep, man. You know
what? Yeah. Just put it on the casing. I have a suspicion on why the paratroopers decided,
yeah, we'll use our Karabiner 98K. Old guns, eh?
Just underneath it. Six o'clock. Okay. Three o'clock.
One o'clock. Fuck's sake, dude. Our rate of fire is now the equal of the 98K. Below. Below,
correct. Below the 98K. Right by almost a half a target. Oh, fuck's sake, Josh.
Hey, got it.
Bing. Hey, Josh, I want you to, oh, of course, misfire on the last shot.
This trigger is worse than any M240 Bravo or 249 I've shot.
It is a classic. It feels like an open bolt machine gun trigger, except you don't have a
lock. I guess it's kind of like an open bolt submachine gun because it's got a short throw
up to it, but the trigger pull is so much worse than any open bolt gun that I've shot still.
Here, I want you to. Okay, I want you to experience it. So where were you holding,
you said? Basically on the top edge of the target. If you go in between the 500 and the left target,
you'll hit it. Are you sure the safety's not on? Oh, yeah. In fact, I'll tell you the quirk about
the safety later on. It could induce a fatal jam by using the safety. You're joking, right? No,
no, I'm not joking. That's what I was working with all the way through.
Hit. I mean, that is a hilariously heavy trigger. Yeah, that's probably like 25 pounds, right?
Yeah, that's like comically heavy. You want someone to die, that's why you give them a
trigger like that. Okay, so shall we move to the debrief? Yeah, let's do the debrief.
A bit of frustration in the air, yeah? Yeah, yeah. So welcome back. We saw a significant
amount of stoppages, but that was actually after we did already a lot of work on the FG-42.
The requirements that the Luftwaffe had for the FG-42 was that it had to be lighter than
a 98k, shorter than a 98k, shoot in semi-automatic and fully automatic,
but they wanted the semi-auto to be closed bolt and the fully auto to be open bolt for cooling.
That is in of itself is a serious series of impossible requirements, but they pulled it off
in form of the FG-42. So I've got to emphasize that this is the prototype model from Smith
Machine Group, i.e. it was their model that they had to develop their entire reproduction on,
serial number 001. And that's important because obviously we know that the production model for
Smith Machine Group works. Ian and Carl have shown the FG-42 in many of their videos in both
in-range and forgotten weapons, and they don't seem to have an issue. When you look at the
design, it almost looks like their engineers took a belt-fed machine gun and make it fire
open bolt, full auto, no issue, because that's how machine guns work, but also give it an extra
function to where when it switches to semi, you're able to get some type of semi-automatic function
with that much of a bolt travel to fulfill the closed bolt semi-automatic requirement that the
Luftwaffe had set out. And now that this is a semi-only civilian legal model, we are stuck with
the less desirable firing position. So it is my thought that if I were to shoot this, I would
rather shoot it on open bolt and just shoot it like it were a machine gun. But we live in the
state as it is, and we cannot have those easily transferable unless we have 350k in the year of
2021. However, let's look at the first issue of ignition. More so, is the ignition reliable?
Okay, so there are some design quirks of the FG-42, and one of those design quirks is that
it shares a recoil spring with the ignition, the firing pin ignition spring, meaning the same
spring that makes the entire rifle cycle also ignites the primers. That induces some unreliabilities
when you're talking about harder military primers. Let me explain. Let's look at some of the
contemporaries out here. This is a Kar98k. The 98k obviously does not need to be cycled,
it needs to be cycled by hand, so it doesn't need a recoil spring to help the entire system go
push back and strip around because your arm does that for you. Now that gives it an ability
to reliably only use one main spring in here for the weapon's ignition system, which is a firing
pin spring right here. Firing pin spring pushes the firing pin up, that is its sole purpose,
and it does that very reliably. So, what else? What else did people come up with?
Another contemporary would be the American M1 Garand. Now, the M1 uses
an op rod spring, an operational rod spring, to move the entire system front and back,
and for ignition it relies on a hammer that has another spring pressing it forward.
That gives it reliable ignition and separates it from the recoil assembly,
which is right here. This is a spring that keeps the action cycling front and back.
So, you have reliable action with a reliable cycling with a reliable
ignition system. Is there no way? Is there no way of doing a striker style
ignition system? And I would say there is a way. And so, we look at the later, not contemporary,
Czech VZ-58. Now, the Czech system uses an interesting striker type firing system.
You will see that the recoil system on top is separate from the ignition system on the bottom.
If we look at the FG-42s, the system comes apart actually fairly easy. And right here,
this spring both actuates the ignition system and also serves to cycle the weapon.
On paper, that is simplifying the process,
but in reality, on operations, that induces some issues with reliability.
Either you would run into an issue with the primers, with the primers not being
struck hard enough so you get a failure to ignite, or it's because of the increased
recoil spring strength, there is not pushing, there's not enough gas being pushed into the
system to cycle it, which then either produces an issue with failure to eject or just entirely
failure to cycle itself. So, there is another issue that we need to talk about.
So, evidently, this is an issue that when we filmed the video, we did not know has already
been fixed, but evidently, the triggers have been fixed. We'll get it back and we'll see how it works.
The trigger. So, I want to talk about this. Okay. Because during the shoot, you were like, oh man,
the trigger, bro, it's so bad. And I'm like, yeah, all right, Henry, like shut up and shoot the gun,
please. So, then Henry forced me to shoot the gun. And you guys saw it. And I think I got down behind
the gun, and I applied what would have been, you know, maybe 10 to 12 pounds of pressure, enough to
break a standard mil spec trigger. And nothing happened. And I even, you know, prepped my body
for it. You know, the 8 mils discharge, I even prepped for it going off. And nothing. Do it again.
Nothing. You even asked if the safety... Henry, is the safety on this gun? No, it's not. Like,
are you sure? Because it really feels like it's on. And then finally, I don't know, I must have
applied north of 18 pounds worth of pressure. I don't know. I don't think a trigger gauge could
measure that. It was extremely, extremely tough trigger to pull. I mean, to start this off,
though, the trigger feels like a machine gun trigger. It feels like you're shooting an open
bolt machine gun with a bad open bolt machine gun trigger. Like, I've shot 240 Bravos. I've shot
M2s. I've shot... Well, that's a butterfly trigger. I've shot 240 Bravos. I've shot M2s. I've shot 249s.
I've shot MG3s. Those triggers are usable. Those are machine gun triggers, but they're still usable.
I mean, it's not impossible, but the way it's just designed, it has a really harsh trigger on it.
It's not just a really harsh trigger. It is an impossibly difficult trigger. I cannot imagine
a situation where if this is my actual fighting firearm with a trigger that actually weighed that,
that I would shoot this on semi-automatic. So, if we were in Fantasyland, and police officers
were issued these things, and the police officer opened fire on a suspect, it would not be,
Officer, did you intend to fire? Yes. Yes, I absolutely intended to fire. Yeah, this is the
New York... This makes the New York triggers on the Glocks sound like a joke. Like, this legitimately
is the stiffest trigger I've ever felt on a firearm by not just a little, but by a huge margin.
So, with all that said, we're still able to hit shots. You just have to be very, very deliberate
about what you're doing. It requires, I mean, it requires a lot of practice behind it. Honestly,
I mean, you need to make sure... You need... If you're okay with this,
just apply this type of... The H&K type of trigger by threefold.
Yes.
Now, on the onset of this particular rifle on range, we saw it, and we thought it was a failure
to extract. For some reason, cases, fired cases, would just stovepipe in the chamber, and it would
not be able to extract them out. We thought maybe this was an expansion rate issue, but that didn't
make any sense because we were shooting all military specification 8mm Mauser. Then, in
conversation with Carl over at InRange, we thought maybe it's because we were shooting World War II
spec steel-cased 8mm Mauser, and those steel-cased cartridges were indeed recycled World War II
German 8mm Mauser cartridges. Now, these steel cases, in many times, on the Eastern Front,
were relegated as secondary use by MG42 gunner because of the lack of reliability.
So, Carl over at InRange sent over a lot of 8mm Mauser sniper-grade ammunition,
the Yugo sniper ammunition. It still had the same issue. We then cycled it with Yugo standard
8mm, still had the extraction issue. Ecuadorian 8mm Mauser still had the issue. Handloads still
had the issue with extraction. For some reason, if you look at the photos I'm showing, that one
cartridge would get death stuck inside the chamber. You would have to yank the bolts back,
stick a cleaning rod in it, and jam it against something very, very hard in order to pop the
casing out. In combat, that would have been a kiss of death. So, we were wondering, maybe
the extractor cannot pull it out. We racked our minds on this. It took us months of trying to
figure this out, but in a conversation with Rick over at Smith Machine Group, they actually figured
out early on and did not realize that we had the prototype, which still had the issue. The issue
was with the ejector. So, essentially, when your cartridge was extracting, it would extract, but
because the ejector didn't push it out, the bolt would jam it straight back into the chamber. Of
course, you have a very heavy recoil spring. I'm talking extremely heavy, heavier than machine guns
recoil spring, jamming it back into the chamber. So, there was no extracting that afterwards
because your casing had already expanded, and you're pushing all that force behind it
to jam it into the chamber. The next round would no longer be able to properly load once you recycle it.
It ejected, right, a second ago?
Yeah. Through this, nope. It ripped the rim again.
Might I suggest a bit of oil into the chamber?
Jeez, dude, that's that's really deep, man. That is a serious issue, but obviously FG-42s
later worked, and obviously a lot of these reproduction FG-42s still work. They have
no issue with ignition. They have no issue with ejection, but this video took a significantly
longer time to produce because we had to figure out exactly what was wrong with it,
and at the end of the day, we didn't even figure out all the issues.
Rick Smith figured out the last piece of the puzzle, which is why it's going to head back to
Rick, and we hope to see it back on the range in the year 2022, and we'll be doing a little bit
more evaluations on the Luftwaffe FG-42, and as much of a pain as it was going through this project,
I think it reminds us that arms development is not always easy. It is not a cakewalk,
but one thing we can take to heart on this one, accuracy, that we all thought was going to be an
issue for the FG-42, because again, from the Aberdeen Proving Ground papers, these things
were quoted to have something like 5 MOA, but if you think back at it, even the 98K's acceptance
was around 4 or 5 MOA, so presumably the ammunition back then that was issued to German
troops were just not that extremely accurate. So now using modern loads, the FG-42, if it can have
the ejection figured out, if we can have reliable ignition, it could still be very accurate.
It still has an extremely heavy trigger, and it still has some of the characteristics of a rifle
that basically has elements that are not adopted into current use. You look around,
there are not many rifles that share both the firing pin ignition spring with the recoil spring.
There's a reason to that, because ignition should be kept separate from the recoil,
otherwise you introduce unreliable results into a system when it relies on the gas operation.
But as I digress, I'd like to thank Rick for loaning us the rifle. I'd like to thank Ian
over at Forgotten Weapons for helping us connect with Rick. I'd like to thank Carl over at InRange
honestly a lot of the conversations of troubleshooting I worked with Carl,
and he even sent us a lot of very difficult to find Yugoslavian sniper ammunition.
So at that, we'll end this year's video, and we look forward to next year in 2021.
2022. God, 2021 is gone. So, Merry Christmas, Happy Holidays, we'll see you next year.
Anything modern that we review, we get people saying that potentially we are paid for this.
That's not the case. We're not getting paid anything for this. This is not our rifle.
This is purely out of our historical interest to the FG-42 system. And in fact, this is also
a T&E item for us to help Smith & Smith Machine Group identify potential issues
with this serial number 0001 of their FG-42 line. So yeah, I mean at the end of the day,
you just want to make it very clear that we are actually impressed by the work that went into
this and how accurate it ended up being. Subscribe to our newsletter at slateblackindustries.com
where you can get updates on 9-hole review publications and access the practical accuracy
scoreboard to help you argue with people on the internet on which rifle performs better on the
We maintain this newsletter to be majority gun content with 9-hole reviews updates per
every email with less than 33% marketing content. Subscribe today on slateblackindustries.com.
1-6. 15-9-2. 1-Victor, 2-Fax.
