Lecture 04 : Importance of Unit Operations - Part 1

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Sep 13, 2024
Greetings. So, I welcome you to the fourth lecture of this course and today we are going
to discuss on importance of unit operations on material recovery. So, in the previous
lectures we have already gone through some of the basic introduction that is necessary
to understand metallurgical and electronic waste recycling, but as we go along we will
now develop some important concepts that are essential to understand how these waste streams
are recycled. In the previous lectures we have also seen the importance of unit operations.
For instance, when we look at a given waste stream, what is our first reaction? When we
think of the first reaction, the first thing that should come into mind is can we separate
out these waste streams into different categories based on their valuable content. So, even before
when we try to jump here, we'd like to go and discuss why it is necessary. Why is it necessary?
So, to put up and to calculate the economic values. So, suppose that we have an e-waste stream that
can comprise of mobile phones, discarded mobile phones of course, PCs and in this we can have
the WPCBs, Waste Printed Circuit Boards and of course, this can come from mobile phones as well.
So, we can have discarded electronics like we can have washing machines, lamps and so on so
forth. What is the first thing that we do? We'll have to identify valuable resources and then we
can just go on and think of the unit operations that will be essential to tap onto these valuable
resources. So, when we think of unit operations, we have put up some numbers, some value okay,
a given stream will have such and such valuable resources. Now, we are trying to grab onto those
resources. So, the first thing that we should be taking care of is bringing down the particle size.
It is possible by crushing, grinding and of course, the size reduction due to these processes,
size reduction and separation. Separation based on these operations, crushing, grinding and size
reduction, sieving, fragmenting the given feed into various size fraction, understanding the
size distribution that is obtained after the crushing and grinding circuit is followed.
After the circuit is completed, we get a wide spectrum of particle sizes. Which particle size
fraction has what type of valuable material? That people can do the further characterization
and then decide the okay, coarse particles have such and such valuable materials,
finer fraction have such and such materials. So, of course, this comes only after the
comminution step. So, one has to think of crushing, grinding, size separation,
size distribution, attaining the size distribution and then the rest of the process can be developed.
A generalized way of estimating how much energy would be required for size reduction can be
given by three important laws. The first one is the kick law. The kick law according to the
kick law and of course, all of these laws are basically governed by a general law which is
stated here, where D e is the energy required for particle size reduction. L is the change,
D L is the change in the dimension, particle size dimension and k could be the constant,
n again is another constant. So, when we think of various laws,
the kick law, the Rittenger law and the bond law will have variations of k and n. So,
for instance when we look at the kick law D e on D L is again the kick law constant
this is the material constant that is involved for the specific material and we will see that
the power here is minus 1. So, when we integrate it, we will reach here. When we look at the
Rittenger law just following on to the same principle D e on D L gives you k r, again this
is the Rittenger law constant, the material constant and this time the power is minus 2.
So, we will have a relationship like this k r f c 1 upon L 2 minus 1 upon L 1 and the final one
is the bond law where e and we will see that this time n is basically minus 1.5. So, it and it and
of course, it is being rearranged. So, we will now try to understand what are the terms in the
bond law. We will see that L is the dimension, E I the E I term that is constant over here,
E I is the energy required, energy required to reduce particle size of unit mass from infinity
100 micrometers and by infinity we mean very large particle size. So, it is we are trying
to bring down the particle size to 100 micrometer and that is the energy required and of course,
this length is in micrometers, L right now is being defined in micrometers. Similarly,
there is a term Q which is the reduction ratio given by L 1 upon L 2. What is interesting in
all of these 3 laws is that they help us in understanding what type of law would be used
for what type of particles because they not it so happens that a single law is not able to
describe what type of energy is required to bring down the particle size of a given feed material.
So, for instance it has been observed that Keck law is more applicable, more useful for
coarser fraction whereas, the Rittinger law is more applicable for finer particles,
finer fraction, finer particle. It also it should be kept in mind that when we look at
the Keck law we will see that the power is minus 1 whereas, for Rittinger law it is minus 2.
Incidentally, the Keck law focuses that it emphasizes that the energy required is proportional
to the change in dimension, the particle size dimension whereas, the Rittinger law focuses
that it emphasizes that the energy required is basically proportional to the generation
of new surface area. So, the power of n changes. Now, it has been observed since people have
tried to collate their experimental data with these laws they found that the Keck law fits
better for coarser particles and the Rittinger law fits better for finer fractions and the
Bond law is somewhere in between. So, all three laws have their different segments where
these can be applied. So, what happens when we are crushing and grinding the particles
and bringing down the particle size? It is to be understood that these finer fractions
or coarser fractions would be used for various intended applications. So, for instance one
would like to go ahead and characterize these fractions and suppose that they identify that
coarser fraction has higher metallic content, metallic values and of course, this is an example.
So, the first thing that would obviously, come to our mind is that let us try and tap
these metallic values. So, based on composition we could think of melting or leaching these
coarser fractions and this would lead to metal recovery. Now, this is just an example. So,
for instance if we have coarser fractions we would like to directly go ahead and use these
coarser fractions may be agglomerated and then just charge it into the furnace for melting and
then recover the molten metal and cast it into various shapes. So, that is again one method of
recovery while the other could be a more route that is directed towards hydrometallurgy where
we could design a leaching setup recovering metals into the aqueous solutions and then
trying to recover various metallic values from these leach liquor. So, this is how one can
devise one can develop a progressive and economical recycling rule. So, what it always begins at the
first step understanding the raw material trying to see what is its worth how to recover it from
the very first step. So, comminution which is basically crushing, grinding, sieving,
understanding the various particle size distribution the initial characterization
done all of these steps are very crucial. Now, when we think of understanding the
comminution scale comminution processes that we have been discussing the first few key tools
that are essential for developing a good recycling route is to understand the key
equipment these key equipment are the crushers and grinders. So, the example of that is being
me is described here we have the jaw crusher and here we have a hammer mill the jaw crusher and
the hammer mill. So, when we think of the jaw crusher we see that this is where we feed and
in this case here we feed our material we see that one is stationary. So, one side of the jaw
crusher is stationary the other one is moving. So, when we see that the when this moving jaw
crushes when it comes closer it crushes the particles and gradually what we get is the
final crushed product and based upon what is the dimension that we want we can adjust the bites.
Similarly, we can we have the roll crushers and other types of gyratory crushers these types of
crushers are used to bring down particle size based on the availability of crusher and based
on based on the type of material that we are trying to crush we can select our crusher most
commonly uses a jaw crusher. So, supposing that we are trying to grind. So, after crushing we
have got a finer fraction and now we wish to grind. So, for grinding operations there are
various types of mills one can think of ball mills or hammer mills or plate mills. So,
a hammer mill is being described here wherein we are trying to understand how finer fractions can
be made more fine. We are trying to reduce the particle size even further because when we are
reducing the particle size increasing the specific surface area we are basically creating more
surface that is available for reaction more surface available for reaction.
So, suppose that this feed which is already finer fraction we wish to have even finer fraction that
is reducing the sub particle size even to let us say 100 micrometers or even lesser 200 micrometers
or even less. So, that type of operation can be done using various types of mills and hammer mill
ball mills these mills are generally used to reduce the particle size. Again the choice of
a good grinding mill would basically depend on what is the type of the raw material. Hammer mills
is basically used for brittle and fibrous materials. So, fortunately when we think of
hammer mills these can tackle these can handle brittle as well as fibrous materials. So,
how does it really operate? Supposing that we are charging our feed from this and these are
basically the outer casing this is casing and these are the hammers. These hammers tend to
rotate in one direction. So, suppose that this hammer mill is operational it is operating right
now and the hammers are rotating. So, of course, these are the and we feed our raw material what
happens is it will get milled between the hammer and the casing and gradually it starts to reduce
in its particle size. So, the particle size are now gradually going to go down because it is
getting crushed between the mill between the hammer mills the casing of the hammer mill and
the hammer that are basically rotating at high speeds. So, and here we have small sieves which
basically allow only a small fraction to pass through. So, the sieves are arranged in such a
way that a given particle size which is lesser than that of the sieve will get discharged and
the rest will continue to get reduced. The rest of the particles will continue get to get milled
so that we get a fine fraction of particles. Now, one has to understand what exactly do we
get after our comminution process. So, we get a coarser fraction which can be characterized we
get a finer fraction and then we characterize it one more time and it is supposing that we
want to grind it further then we would go ahead for various milling operations.
But what happens to all of these fractions one has to go for size distribution study,
when we think of size distribution and separation. So, where so we have seen that we are through with
the comminution process. Now, what are the factors that really govern the size distribution density
of a given material. Again since the materials are different that are crushed or ground so there so
depending on their densities we can have different types of size distribution. Similarly, we will
have shapes, shapes and surfaces. So, it is very difficult to predict the shape and surface of a
given final feed product. One has to study and then they will be able to comment on what type
of surface is generated after the given comminution operation. One speculation here can be made that
suppose that a given material is ductile. The chances of such material to become flattened
is relatively higher when these are subjected to milling operations. Similarly, when we think of
equipment factor we will have sieve area. What are the sieve? This basically is dependent upon
what type of sieves we are using. What is the sieve area? The sieve thickness this depends
upon what type of material was used. Similarly, hole diameter and hole shapes again these are
sieve characteristics. What type of diameter the sieve had and what type of shapes these holes had
through which the sieving operation was carried out. So, based on these we have different size
particles and various separation, size separation can be achieved using these parameters and these
various sieves stacked one over other. So, of course, the coarser sieve will be stacked on
the top and then the finer and then the finest and we will get a various particle size distribution.
The other key unit operations that we had discussed previously involved not just crushing
grinding, but also on the basis of let us say media separation, heavy media separation or we
can also think of magnetic separation. Based on these characteristics one can think of applying
the unit operations and achieving initial material separation. So, we can think of density.
We have jigs, suspensions, flowing film concentration and dense medium all coming
under the density separation segment of material treatment, material pretreatment all again done
in under the segment of unit operations. When we think of jigs the expansion of beds
by repeated pulses, repeated pulses of fluid. So, we are thinking of expansion of beds
by repeated pulses of fluid. So, of course, we will have a fluid and then we have our material
and we will have repeated pulsing of the fluid. So, that the beds of the material are made and
a typical example would be let us say 50 to 300 cycles per minute and this is again an example.
When we think of suspensions selection of fluids of liquids such that insoluble,
insoluble solids are fluidized. So, when we think of insoluble solids that means we will have to
select the fluid in such a way that the material does not get dissolved in it and this mixture,
the suspension is then fluidized. So, that this insoluble material
is separated out preferentially. Similarly, when we think of flowing film concentrators
we have rift decks, riffled decks and shaking tables and we have flowing water.
Preferably the most common fluid that is used is water. We have flowing water and
continuous motion. So, we have the continuous motion along with the stream of water passing
through such that based on these motions the flowing water as well as the continuous motion
which can be in the direction of the water flow and in the perpendicular direction as well.
So, the particles get distributed, coarser particles and finer particles and even finer
particles will be separated out based on the action of these let us say shaker tables.
In dense medium we will have a material of a liquid of known density and these could be of
either aqueous nature or organic nature. So, these could be aqueous or organic fluids.
Just that we need to decide upon the type of fluid that we are using. Of course,
these can be aqueous or organic. One has to think of a density and a fluid of the specific density
and then separate based on these characteristics. Similarly, we will be looking at magnetic.
So, when we think of magnetic separation, the magnetic separation of waste stream
and of course, when we think of waste stream we are already thinking of both type of categories
e-waste and metallurgical waste and again the another assumption that we have made here is
the particle sizes, the particle size is lower slash finer fraction.
So, that the effective separation of magnetic and non-magnetic materials is
efficiently achieved, is possible and is efficiently achieved.
So, the magnetic separation of waste stream can be done in dry and wet conditions.
What do we mean by dry and wet conditions? In crushing and grinding we can also apply
the fluids, the most common fluid for crushing and grinding is basically water.
So, when we do that we will have a wet grinding, wet crushing circuit and a similar operation
can also be done for magnetic separation that is why crushing and grinding and separation
in dry and wet state. So, we will have various drums, drum magnets,
suspended magnets, cross belts and roll magnets. These roll magnets could be made of
rare earth elements. So, these are different types of magnets that could be applied around
a given conveyor belt. So, that the magnetic materials are separated out under the
magnetic fields that are the applied due to these magnets. So, drum magnets, suspended magnets,
cross belts and rolled magnets are commonly used to help and separate out magnetic materials
from a given stream and of course, we are considering both e-waste as well as metallurgical
waste for our studies. In the upcoming classes we will be thinking on the lines of developing new
processes, studying the advanced literature that are present at our disposal
to understand various recycling routes that are present for metallurgical and electronic wastes.
Thank you.
