Scientists Reveal Near Mythical Genetic Origins of Greeks

Ancient Europe: History, culture and Humans
93 followers
For over a century, archaeologists have been trying to figure out where the Bronze Age
Minoan and Mycenaean cultures came from.
To help solve this mystery, scientists looked at the DNA from 19 ancient people, including
Minoans from Crete, Mycenaeans from mainland Greece, and their eastern neighbors from southwestern
Anatolia, modern Turkey.
They found that the Minoans and Mycenaeans were genetically alike, sharing at least 75%
of their ancestry with the first farmers from western Anatolia and the Aegean.
The rest of their ancestry came from ancient groups in the Caucasus and Iran.
However, the Mycenaeans had some extra ancestry that the Minoans didn't, which came from
hunter-gatherers in eastern Europe and Siberia.
This extra ancestry likely came through people from the Eurasian steppe or Armenia.
Modern Greeks are similar to the Mycenaeans, though with some mixing in their early Neolithic
ancestry.
Findings suggest that while the people in the Aegean region were connected over time,
they were not completely isolated from others before and after their earliest civilizations.
Research on ancient DNA has shown that the ancestors of early European farmers were similar
to Neolithic people in Greece and western Anatolia, starting around 7,000 BCE, but what
happened in these areas up until the Bronze Age, a crucial time in Eurasia's history,
is not entirely clear.
There is some genetic evidence of migrations from the east, Iran and the Caucasus by around
3,800 BCE, and from the north, eastern Europe and Siberia, bringing ancient north Eurasian
ancestry to all modern Europeans, however it's still not known exactly when or how
these migrations affected the Aegean region.
During the Bronze Age, two important cultures developed in the Aegean.
On the island of Crete, the Minoan culture, named by Arthur Evans, became Europe's first
literate civilization and is considered its first major experience of civilization, however
the Minoans used scripts like Linear A and Cretan hieroglyphs that we still can't read,
so their origins remain unclear.
Equally important was the Mycenaean culture of mainland Greece, where people spoke an
early form of Greek, written in the Linear B script.
There was some Minoan influence on mainland Greece and later the Mycenaeans occupied Crete,
but it's unclear how closely related the mainland and Cretan populations were genetically.
Greek is related to other Indo-European languages, and theories about its earliest speakers range
from the 7th millennium to around 1,600 BCE, suggesting different levels of population
change over time.
Using ancient DNA data from across the genome provides fresh insights into the people of
the Bronze Age, who were first recognized through the stories and historical records
of figures like Homer and Herodotus, and later through archaeological digs and studies of
ancient languages.
More recently a bit of information came from ancient mitochondrial DNA studies.
Scientists now aim to answer several key questions.
First, do the terms Minoan and Mycenaean accurately describe distinct genetic groups, or do they
hide a more complicated mix of people who lived in Crete and mainland Greece?
Second, how were these two groups related to each other, their neighbors in Anatolia
– modern-day Turkey – and other ancient populations across Europe and the Near East?
Third, can understanding their ancestral origins help us better discuss how their cultures
began?
And finally, how are the Minoans and Mycenaeans linked to today's Greeks, who live in the
same area?
Scientists collected DNA data from 19 ancient individuals.
This group included 10 Minoans from Crete, dating between 2,900 and 1,700 BCE, from places
like Moni Odigetria in southern Crete, and a cave in the Lysithi Highland Plain in eastern
Crete.
They also studied four Mycenaeans from mainland Greece, dated between 1,700 and 1,200 BCE,
from locations on the western coast of the Peloponnese, Argolis, and the island of Salamis.
One more sample from Ammonoi in western Crete comes after the Mycenaean culture appeared
on Crete.
The dataset also included a Neolithic sample from a cave at Diros Bay in southern Peloponnese,
adding to other samples from northern Greece.
Finally, scientists studied three Bronze Age individuals from around 2,800 to 1,800 BCE
in southwestern Anatolia, adding to the understanding of genetic changes in Anatolia after the Neolithic
and Chalcolithic periods.
Scientists then analysed ancient DNA and compared it with DNA from present-day West Eurasians.
They found that the Minoans and Mycenaeans were positioned in the middle of this genetic
comparison, with connections to ancient populations from Europe, the Caucasus, western Asia, and
early farmers from Europe and Anatolia.
The DNA from people in Bronze Age southwestern Anatolia showed a mix between Anatolian and
Levantine populations, with connections to populations from Armenia, Iran, and the Caucasus.
When looking deeper into the genetic makeup using a method called admixture, scientists
found that both Minoans and Mycenaeans had a specific genetic component that was also
found in ancient Anatolians and people from the Caucasus and Iran.
This component was not seen in earlier populations from Greece or Europe, but appeared later
during the late Neolithic, likely due to migration from the Eurasian steppe.
Further tests showed that Minoans from different parts of Crete were genetically similar to
each other, while Mycenaeans had less in common with earlier populations from the Levant,
Anatolia, Greece, and Europe.
Bronze Age Anatolians, on the other hand, had more in common with ancient populations
from Iran and the Levant than with ancient Europeans.
These tests indicated that Mycenaeans had mixed ancestry from both early European farmers
and populations from Iran or the Eurasian steppe, unlike the Minoans and Bronze Age
Anatolians.
Scientists studied the DNA of people from the Bronze Age to figure out where their ancestors
came from.
They found that most of the ancestry, 62% to 86% of people from ancient Greece and Anatolia
modern-day Turkey, came from early farmers in the region.
However, they also had some ancestry, 9% to 32%, from groups in the Caucasus and Iran.
This eastern ancestry was already present in central Anatolia before spreading to other
regions.
Scientists also found that certain DNA markers, specifically Y-chromosome haplogroup J, were
common among Minoans, Mycenaeans, and people from southwestern Anatolia, but not in earlier
populations from Greece and western Anatolia.
For the Minoans, their ancestry was mostly from early Anatolian farmers, with some influence
from the east.
The Mycenaeans, however, also had some ancestry, 4% to 16%, from hunter-gatherers in eastern
Europe and Siberia.
In some Mycenaeans, like those buried in royal tombs, this mix was the same as in other Mycenaeans
buried in regular graves.
To explain how these genetic influences came about, scientists considered the possibility
that populations from Armenia, a region near the Caucasus, mixed with early farmers in
both Crete and mainland Greece.
Another possibility is that after this eastern ancestry arrived in Crete and Greece, the
Mycenaeans mixed with people from the northern steppes, large plains in Eurasia.
This would explain why the Mycenaeans have a bit of this northern ancestry that the Minoans
lack.
Scientists tested these ideas by comparing the DNA of known populations and running simulations.
The results supported the idea that the Mycenaeans were a mix of different ancient groups, while
the Minoans were more closely related to early Anatolian farmers, with some eastern influence.
The spread of northern ancestry from mainland Greece to Crete might have been blocked by
geographical barriers, leading to differences in DNA between the two regions.
This separation could have been in place even before the Neolithic period, around 7000 BCE.
Alternatively, both northern and eastern ancestry might have arrived in the Aegean region any
time between the early Neolithic and the late Bronze Age.
By studying more ancient DNA from before the Bronze Age, scientists could better understand
when these ancestries entered the region.
However, the Neolithic samples from Greece don't show either type of ancestry, suggesting
that the mixing likely happened between 4000 and 2000 BCE.
There's no evidence of migration from Egypt or Phoenicia influencing the Minoans and Mycenaeans,
so their cultures weren't started by these groups.
Instead, smaller groups from the east or north might have mixed with the local population
and contributed new ideas and traditions during the Bronze Age.
Scientists used genetic data to guess what ancient Europeans looked like since they didn't
leave visual records.
The people of the Bronze Age Aegean, however, left behind colourful frescoes and pottery
showing mostly dark hair and eyes.
Genetic analysis confirms that these images likely matched the real appearance of the
people back then.
When comparing Bronze Age DNA with modern people from the same region, scientists found
that Mycenaeans are most similar to present-day Greeks, Cypriots, Albanians, and Italians.
Modern Greeks sit between ancient European and Near Eastern populations in the genetic
analysis, similar to Bronze Age people, but not exactly the same.
This difference is because Neolithic farmers share fewer genetic traits with modern Greeks
than with Mycenaeans, likely due to more mixing with other groups later on.
The Minoans and Mycenaeans, who were studied from different locations in Crete and mainland
Greece, showed a high level of genetic similarity, indicating that these two groups were genetically
consistent.
The differences between them are minor when considering their overall strong resemblance
to each other and to the people of southwestern Anatolia.
They share both the local Anatolian Neolithic farmer ancestry and the eastern Caucasus-related
genetic influences.
However, there are two important questions that future research needs to answer.
First, when did the shared eastern ancestry of the Minoans and Mycenaeans first appear
in the Aegean region?
Second, is the northern ancestry found in Mycenaeans the result of gradual infiltration
into Greece, or was it brought by a rapid migration similar to what occurred in central
Europe?
Such a migration would support the theory that early Greek speakers, known as Proto-Greeks,
were part of a larger movement of Indo-European speakers from the steppe.
However, the lack of northern ancestry in Bronze Age samples from Pisidia, where Indo-European
languages were historically spoken, raises questions about this connection between genetics
and language, indicating the need for more genetic samples from ancient Anatolian speakers.
Regardless of the answers to these questions, the evidence of at least two migration events
into the Aegean, in addition to the spread of early farming and before the Bronze Age,
along with further population changes since then, supports the idea that the Greeks did
not emerge suddenly from prehistory, but rather developed gradually over time.
In summary, while the Minoans contributed to the genetic makeup of the ancient Greeks,
it is the Mycenaeans who are more directly connected to the ancestry of the ancient Greek
people, particularly through their additional northern and eastern genetic influences.
The epic tales of Homer, such as the Iliad and the Odyssey, set during the time of the
Mycenaean civilization, now seems to bring myth closer to reality.
Please like and subscribe for more such videos.
Thanks for watching.
