Lecture 21

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Aug 10, 2024
[Music]
hello and welcome to another lecture of
classical motion of a single particle
and here we simply continue our previous
discussion on different features of
motion under an attractive inverse
Square uh force field okay so I just
said that we already know that the under
an inverse Square attractive force field
the um trajectory of a particle is given
by simply this equation which is
geometrically the polar equation of a
conic
section and we have already discussed
that conic section can be broadly of
three types elliptic parabolic and
hyperbolic and the fourth uh type if you
want to include that is a circular but
it is a special type of the elliptic
orbit okay and now the point is that we
have already discussed something in the
previous lecture this is just to uh
relate the uh total amount of energy if
the total amount of energy uh is
positive or zero then the system will
the particle will exhibit an unbounded
motion with a parabolic or a hyperbolic
orbit if the total energy is negative
then the particle will show a bounded
motion
with an elliptic or a special case a
circular orbit okay we then also said
that the eccentricity of the conic
section which is given by Small E will
be related to the constants of motion in
this way root over 1 + 2 capital e l s
by m k s here e is the total mechanical
energy and we also said that e is
greater than or equal to Z
okay that is the definition of a conic
section here and here we will say that I
mean that is that is uh following the
definition of a conic section here
because e is actually uh should be
always um at least positive or zero okay
it cannot be negative now I am just
taking this equation once again which we
can also show from B equation or any
other correct way that R is equal to P
by 1 + Epsilon or E cos Theta e is the
eccentricity p is the semil latus rectum
and P and E they are simply uh related
to the uh constants of motion so they
are also constant so I can write the
expression exact expression of e to be
root over 1 + 2 e l s by MK s
and if you remember also I can write the
expression for p is equal to M h² by
KY just writing that H as L by m i can
also write this is l s by MK okay so you
see that these two are also two
geometric constants for my system for
the motion of the particle okay now I
just want to have the estimation of that
if the particle let's say is uh
traveling uh in such a way or is moving
in such a way that the particle is
having some uh R mean and R Max okay so
I am just saying that okay right from
this expression can we simply estimate
find an expression for those R mean and
R Max so p and E since they are
constants the only variable here is the
Theta and you know that so simply from
this expression this is quite easy to
check that R will have its minimum value
when this part will have the maximum
value and when this is maximum that
means the COS Theta will also have a
maximum value what is the maximum value
for cos Theta that is + one and that's
why our mean will simply be equal to P
by 1 + e cos thet is equal to 1 I can go
for the r
Max now R Max is equal to P by 1 then
cos Theta should be minimum huh is the
case where I will have the r Max the
same thing okay this just the opposite
of this case so this will be minus one
and I will have minus E okay now you see
a very funny and interesting conclusion
from that is whenever your system has uh
so now I from from my coordinate
knowledge I know that
Circle
ellipse and then the other two is
Parabola and
hyperbola I
know their eccentricities for Circle
eccentricity is zero that means our mean
is equal to our Max and what is that is
nothing but equal to P because e is
zero okay and you will have a circle
okay so for Circle you will have a
bounded motion where the r mean and the
r Max is both are equal to p and you
have only one turning point and that is
the because this is the local minimum in
the effective potential well okay for
ellipse e we know from coordinate
geometry should
be for a perfect ellipse which is not a
circle should be varying from 0 to one
so it should be a proper fraction
positive okay and that's why this e will
be less than one okay and that is why
you will see that R mean will be equal
to P by 1 + e and which now since this
is a positive quantity 1 + e will be
greater than 1 so this will be something
which
is p by some Kai which is greater than
one huh and this Kai is actually greater
than one so you can actually write that
this should be less than P okay now
again our
Max which is p by 1 minus E same thing e
is positive so this should be less than
one so this fraction will be actually
greater than P okay but both of them
will be finite and that is why you have
a bounded motion although R mean is not
equal to R Max okay for Parabola what
happens we know again from coordinate
geometry e is exactly equal to
1 okay the excentricity is exactly equal
to one now what happens if you have this
then this is R me is equal to P by 2 but
R Max is equal to already Infinity okay
so you have R
mean p by 2 and R Max is infinity so you
have unbounded motion again you see the
results are so consistent with each
other unbounded motion so just for e
equal to 1 okay now you see I am coming
to that okay in a second and for
hyperbola finally you will have e less
than uh I would say sorry I correct
myself e greater than one okay and for
that what happens this one is still our
mean is
finite but this one our Max is actually
less than zero which is is not possible
so this is
absurd okay and that is why this is also
unbounded
motion okay now I can tell you another
important thing that what happens in
circle ellipse Parabola and hyperbola in
terms of energy so when we now know the
uh relation between e and capital E so e
s is equal = to 1 + 2 e l s by m k s if
I say e is equal to 0 this is equal to
zero then I know that 2 e l s by m k s
okay + 1 is equal to Z that means this
is equal to min-1 and your e is equal to
Simply Min - M K ² by 2 L S which is the
if you remember this is the case for the
minimum
potential energy huh and your total
energy simply is given by this one okay
so your e is
negative for ellipse once again I can
just check here you see that already we
know that for TR close trajectories your
e will be negative I am again
crosschecking here from this aspects as
well so if your e square is uh if your e
is less than one then e Square will also
be less than one and
then your 2 e l s MK squ I can write for
ellipse just for ellipse e s is also
less than one so I can simply write 2 e
l s by m k
s is equal to e ² - 1 Which is less than
zero and these all are positive so only
possibility is e is less than zero so
here also e is less than Z
for when e is equal to 1 what happens e
is equal to 1 so you have both sides one
so if it is one then one and one they
will go away so your whole thing this
thing will be equal to zero it is for
Parabola okay and then you can say that
means this cannot be zero L M and K they
cannot be zero so e is zero so for a
parabolic orbit the interesting thing is
the total mechanical energy of always
vanishes okay then finally the
hyperbola okay the parabolic orbit the
total mechanical energy vanishes only
for when we are considering attractive
inverse Square law okay for other laws
they can be there can be different
situations and different conclusions
okay now hyperbola finally hyperbola is
e is greater than one so this quantity
is greater than one so e sare minus one
will be some positive quantity and so 2
e l s by MK squ this fraction will be
positive L squ MK by MK Square positive
so e will be positive so again e will be
positive so you see from this analysis
also again we have cross checked this
energy and the nature of the
trajectories okay so what is the
immediate conclusion that when your
energy to total energy is negative that
means means that the uh potential energy
part the the true potential energy part
actually dominates the true kinetic
energy part okay and when they are
exactly equal to zero that means the
true potential energy exactly equals to
the true kinetic energy and when the
trajectory is hyperbolic then actually
the kinetic energy true kinetic energy
okay um like dominates over the true
potential energy okay because if you
remember the in the energy expression
okay both the kinetic energy terms these
two terms these and these both of them
are actually positive so if the total
energy should be positive then this part
should win if this is zero then this
part should exactly be counterbalanced
by this and if finally this is negative
then this part should win okay now you
think the real situation when we are
talking about the planetary motions all
the planets are moving in elliptic
orbits okay as we know from our
experience okay they are moving always
elliptic or whatever like a little bit
circular circular elliptic whatever I
mean if we if you even forget about this
debate huh whether this is elliptic or
ellip I mean nearly circular okay
whatever but they are elliptic of course
as far as we know that they are inverse
Square attractive law and uh they are
always is moving in the closed orbit
there are some deviations from a proper
closed orbit sometimes but that we
neglect for the time being for this
course uh if you just take this
conclusion then the immediate inference
is that the for a planetary motion the
potential energy the true potential
energy the attractive potential energy
is actually winning over the kinetic
energy whereas if you now think in the
solar system you have several other
members for example a comet which comes
and then the comet vanishes
forever okay it can actually have a zero
or a positive total mechanical energy
where the kinetic energy dominates over
the potential energy finally a very
interesting point some comets are
periodically I mean uh observable okay
so you can see them in an inter of
several years and for those basically
again you have to understand that they
are actually somehow moving in a closed
trajectory so although they are comets
their total energy is negative otherwise
there is no I mean you cannot see them
once again okay now coming to a little
bit more analysis so what I can do
directly just to talk about so you now
know that under which conditions the
trajectory will be eles when it will be
circular when it will be Parabola and
when it will be hyperbola but uh at
least one thing we have to now now we
can discuss different uh situations
already we know under which condition of
energy the trajectory will be a circle
under which condition of energy the
trajectory will be an ellipse where the
trajectory will be a parabola or a
hyperbola Now by case to case we will
try try to analyze in more detail
whether we can actually find the
equations in our uh familiar cartisian
form of those uh conic sections okay so
I will do it uh part for you and you are
asked to do the rest of that so just if
I take R is equal
to P over 1
+ e cos Theta then I can say r plus e r
cos Theta is equal to
P okay and uh try
to a little
bit
okay
yeah then I can simply write so what is
my R in uh cartisian coordinate this is
root over x² + y² + e r cos Theta is a x
is equal to p another constant so I can
just take this one on the one side and P
minus E X on the other side I take the
square of both
sides and I take x² + y Square I squared
them then they will give me p² - 2 p e x
+ e s
x² if you rearrange you will have a very
friendly form form x² 1 - e s + 2 p e x
+
y² is equal to
p² so this is the familiar cartisian
form of the conic sections now we do
case by case so one when e is
zero we know that this term will be zero
this term will be Z so we will have x² +
y² is equal to p² so it will give me an
a circle of radius p and that is exactly
also can be verified from this condition
that it will have a trajectory close
trajectory where both R Min and R Max is
equal to P so only one are possible and
that is p and that is the exactly
consistent with the circle equation of
this circle
okay so
Circle when I will have this I can also
try to find the equation of the circle
from that and you know that is
completely doable and the radius will
simply be p is equal to since we
know the I mean for semiat rectum this
is given by L Square by MK huh so it
will be a radius of circle l s by MK and
what is this if you remember in one of
the previous lectures we said this is
the uh radius of the circle okay for
minimum effective potential
energy case number two when your e is a
proper fraction but positive okay then
what you can do that this thing is not
one but this is something which is
positive quantity this is also positive
how to write that thing so we can simply
write it in a stylish way so we just
write over here that I have this thing
and then I can
say the equation can be written like
this
x² plus 2 p e x by 1 - e s i just
dividing everything by 1 - e Square
which is a positive quantity here for
this case where e is less than 1 +
y² by 1 - e s and then the right hand
side I write in a smart way I just write
p² as p² * 1 - e 2 by 1 - e
s² + p² e s by 1 - e s whole Square okay
if you just if you just add them up you
will simply see that uh just a minute
let me just
check I can write this yes yeah I can
write actually then I have to add
something over here that is this this
quantity yeah I actually have to add
over here this one as well 1 - e s squ
yeah so I just write
this left hand side over here this left
hand side the entire left hand side as
this this terms and the right hand side
I wrote in this way okay here in both
sides I actually have added this term p²
e s by 1 - e square square okay if you
if you simply just want to cross check
you just cross check and you let me know
that I mean whether it works or not not
okay so basically what happens that you
are dividing everything by first 1 minus
E S so this will gives you everything
like this and in the right hand side you
will have a p² by 1 - e s huh and then
you just uh multiply 1 - e squ in both
numerator and denominator then you will
have this term and then in both right
hand and left hand and right hand side
you add this term and this term okay you
just add equally okay what is the
advantage of this thing is that finally
you write those equations as X+ p e / 1
- e s s by
a² + y² by b² is equal to 1 okay
where your a is given by P by 1 - E S
and B is given by P by < TK over 1 - e s
okay and both of them are greater than
zero so this will be greater than zero
this will also be greater than zero so
they are not equal here they will be of
course equal if is zero so this is the
case for an ellipse case for an
ellipse noncircular I just mentioned
that non non circular okay if you follow
the formula for p and E over here and
here then you will finally get finally
we write finally we write can
write a is equal to l ² by m k that is p
by then 1 - e s is nothing but 2
mod of e l s by m k s mod of e means the
positive value of e okay if you take
this you will have equal to K by just
after this cancellations in the
numerator and denominator K by 2 mod e
and B will be equal to in the same way
you do the same steps you follow the
same steps you will have root over L by
root over 2 m mod of e okay I encourage
you to do those calculations once again
right from these expressions and using
their uh using the expression of p and E
separately to reach in to I mean reach
those expressions okay so this will be
an ellipse this will be an
ellipse okay
with semi
major
axis as e
and
semi
minor
AIS as B
and
Center
at Min - P by 1 - e s just this one the
negative of that huh comma zero because
there is nothing in the y1 y coordinate
okay this this is once again the
revision of the coordinate geometry the
task for you will be to check I can also
do the case for Parabola that is also
not very difficult so e is equal to 1
and that is the total energy is equal to
zero so you will actually see the main
equation this equation this parent
equation reduces to this
uh y² is equal to p² - 2 PX which is
nothing but - 2 p x - P by
2 okay and if you have this then this is
once again a
parabola with its
vertex with its vertex
I'm sorry for repeting problem yeah
vertex at P by 2 0 and
focus
at
origin 0 0 okay so you can also check
this from your coordinate geometry book
okay finally the task for
you do the
case
for E greater than one
okay I will be wrapping up this wrapping
up this lecture by finally I mean
stating the three famous laws of Kepler
and for that we just need the knowledge
we have which we have already discussed
that is mostly so Kepler gave his law
Johan Kepler gave his law for an
analyzing or for model I mean describing
the planetary motions and for planetary
motions the first law of Kepler gave so
Kepler's
Law for planetary
motion so we understand that Kepler at
that point he did not have all the
analytical tools at hand but what he
meant that this is the analysis some
laws for the motion under an
attractive inverse Square
law so nowadays if we just relate this
to our knowledge attractive inverse
Square law with
negative e right so that is the case for
planetary motions so the first he said
that okay I'm just writing this yeah so
the first
law
said the
planet the
planets
move in elliptic
orbits which we have now shown
analytically elliptic orbits with the
Sun
at one of
its
fosi I mean there are two Focus points
focal points of an ellipse and uh so the
point is that the first law simply said
that if a planet moves in an elliptic
orbits let's like
this if the planet moves like that then
uh Sun then Sun
should be here so that was his law okay
now it is I I I give you a week for
thinking how can from the analysis which
we have done we have now even the
equation for the ellipse you see how can
you actually think of the sun's position
under this framework can you do that
okay that is a good uh I mean I mean
good exercise to think so here it is a
sun and there's a planet so that was the
the first law so we have actually shown
the first thing that the elliptic orbits
okay that is completely consistent with
our knowledge of the nature of the
trajectory under negative total energy
which says that the uh motion will be
bounded and that's why you will have an
elliptic orbit because the orbit must be
a conic section okay and the second law
again simply said that the r the second
law
yeah Second Law simply said the radius
Vector of a
planet uh
sweeps out equal amount of
area in equal time
okay or you can say equal amount of area
in equal time or sweeps out area at a
constant
rate that means that if the Sun is here
and the uh particle is moving like in a
trajectory like this so
if the initial position Vector was here
and the final was here then I can say
this is r and this is I mean this is
just I mean after some considerable time
if I just say immediately after when it
will have
some R Prime huh which you can say R
Prime is nothing but r+
Dr and this Dr Vector basically is this
Vector which is almost huh uh
perpendicular to that and actually
should be perpendicular because this is
along the tangent of this curve so this
is the direction of the Dr here huh so
then you can say that D of
a which is the area Vector
modulus per unit time so the change of
the area Vector so area Vector is the
area subtended by this
uh Planet okay so let's say in DT time
the area subtended is this part a small
triangle okay and that is D of mod
of area
Vector I know from my knowledge of
vector algebra this is nothing but half
R cross
Dr by DT so this is the small triangle
subtended by R and Dr and they are
almost they are perpendicular actually
so that's why you can simply write there
nothing but half DDT of so R Dr so that
should be actually so R cross Dr will be
the just the cross product in of two
vectors at 90° so this this will be
simply
Rd and what is this Dr if you remember
just for this purpose if there is a
angle Theta so what is that Dr Dr is
nothing but almost Dr is
almost or r d Theta because this is
sorry this is an angle small angle D
Theta so it will be Rd Theta so finally
your thing will be so instead of writing
it like this I can simply write this as
r d Theta
DT okay
and this is the r i mean Rd Theta is
just the Dr part and there will be
another R multiplied so it will be
simply like this and you will have half
r² Theta Dot and what is this this is
nothing but H H by 2 so which is a
constant of motion in any Central force
and that's why this is completely
understandable why second law of Kepler
must be true now for Kepler second law
you see that this is a general
conclusion which is true for any Central
Force whereas the first law is only true
for planetary motion so for the first
law needs the force law to be inverse
Square attractive and the total
mechanical energy to be negative whereas
the second law is much more General okay
but since uh the planetary emotions are
also I mean under a force which is
Central then I mean any conclusion can
also be interpolated so at that time KET
did not have a detailed dactic method
for I mean to reach all these
conclusions step by step that's why he
just postulated those as laws the third
one is the third law of Kepler is also
very special for elliptic
orbits Third Law of
Kepler yeah so it simply says that okay
since we have used this thing already d
a DT
is equal to half r² Theta dot which is
nothing but H by2 or L by 2 m the same
thing I can actually write the a which
is the mod of the area Vector to be
equal to l by 2 m *
t Okay since this is constant since this
is constant I can simply just say uh I
mean this T is the time okay so I can
write like this T okay yeah I can
integrate and I can say when at T is
equal to 0 the area was zero so I can
have this simply linear relation now for
an
ellipse this a is nothing but Pi * a * B
where a is the semi major axis B is the
semi minor axis okay so I can write that
Pi a b will be equal to l by 2 m * T
okay and that's y this T will be 2 m Pi
a by L
okay I will do something which is also
very interesting here I will use this a
is equal to what I just said K by 2
modulus
of e and B is equal to l by root over
let me just check once the expressions
yeah K by 2 modulus of e and B is right
yes L by < tk2 m modulus of e and if you
do simply this you will actually see b²
will be equal to l s by 2
m modulus of e and then you just use
this relation to Simply write b² is
nothing but equal to l s time 2 a by m
k okay now you see there is a square I
mean there's a nonlinear relationship
between A and B here okay I simply use
that one over here just to write 2 m by
L Pi I will write a as a but B I can
simply uh use this relation and I can
say that okay then B will simply be
equal to L by uh < tk2 a by root MK I
can write I can do the same thing over
here I can simply write
root 2 L S by m
k and then it will be e to the
half okay all the other quantities over
here they are just the constant and it
will simply be equal to some some
constant some constant K 0 * e^ 3 by
2 and that is why you
see that okay so of course here you see
there is a point that a whenever you
were talking about the a to be the area
of the total ellipse then of course you
can say my T is nothing but the time
period which is equal to the total T
capital T okay I can call that as
capital T as well and I can say okay
then my T is equal to k0 a ^ 3x 2 and
finally I say t² proportional to e ^ 3
clear so this is the K Plus's Third Law
okay and remember although A and B both
are I mean one is semi major axis and
one is semi- minor axis so the
dependence of t on the B which is the
semi- minor axis is not the same because
A and B they are not linearly related
what will be that dependence for example
if I say t Alpha proportional to B beta
then what will be Alpha and beta that is
you to think okay with that I wrap this
lecture up and you tell me that what
will be the cases what will be the case
for or the reduction for the K plus t
law huh if we simply think of a circle
okay it is simply something you can
easily calculate or you have to do some
non-trivial calculations Circle means a
is equal to B okay thank you very much
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
