TRAPPIST-1 is one of the most interesting systems out there. JWST did observe them but we still don't have the results from all of them. Why is that and when can we expect to know something about their atmospheres? Finding out in this interview.
00:00 Intro 02:00 Looking at TRAPPIST-1 with JWST 05:21 Planets around TRAPPIST-1 14:10 TRAPPIST-1d 23:28 Premature announcements 32:21 Alternatives to TRAPPIST-1 37:16 Other detection methods 43:19 The next gen instruments 51:44 Current obsessions 58:01 Final thoughts
⚖️ LICENSE Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
You are free to use my work for any purpose you like, just mention me as the source and link back to this video.
trapis one from the moment of its
Discovery astronomers knew they had
found something incredibly special seven
Earth siiz worlds orbiting around a red
dwarf star several of which were within
the habitable zone it was closer
brighter easier to distinguish these
planets than any others that had been
seen before and immediately went right
to the top of the list of the most
intriguing and interesting places to
search for atmospheres around exoplanets
and potenti
signs of conditions that could be
habitable and Incredibly this is the
kind of planetary system that is
observable by the James web Space
Telescope and this is one of the goals
of the James web Space Telescope is to
understand the atmospheres of exoplanets
so it's not a surprise that a
significant amount of time was put to
observing the trapis one system but here
we are more than 2 years since James web
began operations many observations have
been made of the trapis one system and
yet we don't have a satisfying answer to
what those planets are like and I get so
many questions from my audience about
this and so today I'm going to bring you
answers my guest is Dr Julian dit he is
a professor of planetary science at MIT
and works with the disruptive planets
group he and his team have developed a
road map a way to comprehensively study
the atmospheres of the trapis one system
as well as other planets orbiting around
Red Door stars to in a very efficient
manner build up a ladder of
understanding to get to the point where
we can know once and for all are these
the kinds of planets that could
potentially host life so enjoy this
fascinating conversation with Julian
dwit if you want to know what's
happening with trapis 1 this is the
interview you're going to find out the
answer all right enjoy the interview
Julian what was it like when you first
looked at the spectral data from jdst at
the atmosphere of an exoplanet compared
to your experience in seeing it with
other what Spitzer other other
telescopes yeah so the experience was
that we it was so obvious that we just
enter a new era in terms of data science
not only the number of point that we
have per wavelength spin or per color
point if You' like but also the
Precision was just incredible so it was
clear to us that what we'll be able to
say about these planets and their Stars
also uh will be well beyond what we
haven't done before I mean I think about
you know we see the press releases
coming from NASA and from other
scientists saying the presence of carbon
dioxide and carbon monoxide and methane
and water vapor and all these kinds of
things in the atmosphere of an exoplanet
from someone who looks at the data and
sort of thinks about the confidence
levels and the you know how how certain
does this this stuff all feel to you now
yeah so the detections of molecules have
for for most of what we've done being
very solid even before gems web right
detecting molecular molecule molecular
Fus is quite an an easy thing to do um
however the challenge that we started to
face is associated this fature that
we're detecting with a number density
like how much of that molecule really is
there and and that is that is a bit
challenging but in terms of detecting
CO2 Det like S2 and so forth these
molecules are there and these are
molecules that were otherwise you know
Out Of Reach so now with gems web we can
easily detect this molecule and that's
exciting so I guess that's kind of two
parts so that that with James web now
there are molecules that were previously
Out Of Reach that are now within reach
you said sulfur oxide What are some
other examples of the molecules that are
now in reach and maybe hopefully will be
in reach with James web wow um that's a
great question question I did not
prepare it for but a lot of them the
reason is simple um so the most of the
spectral analysis we were doing before
were in the wavelength range with Hubble
Space Telescope between say 1.1 to 1.7
Micron and now with jwst and and there's
shorter wavelength we could do with HST
but now with jwst we're really going
much further into the near infrared
which allows us to really detect
molecule because that's where they
vibrate that's where they interact the
most with with light and so one that's
just coming to mind on top of the one
you already mentioned you know CO2 SO2
is for example ozone which is such a
cool molecule that also absorb around
around five Micron but there's a bunch
of molecule happening like happening to
absorb light in that wavelength range so
as we're going further and further into
the infrared with a big telescope we can
do atmospheric analysis and reveal a
wide range of molecule that were
otherwise unaccessible and and so part
of the I guess the limit is the
wavelength so Hubble you know near
infrared but as you say it only goes
into a couple of microns it doesn't go
all the way deep into near infrared the
way James web but also just the size web
is seven times bigger than Hubble it's a
monster the clarity that you get in
those wavelengths that you could never
observe with a large telescope before
these all come online now exactly so I
want to talk about the Trappist system
because I just get so many questions
from my audience about what is the state
of the planets around trapis 1 so I'm
just going to pass that question on to
you I mean we're all pretty familiar
that that the first two planets B and C
have been have been rendered airless
thanks to web but what do we know so far
about the system what is the state of
trapis one is is that okay if I start
challenging that first assessment of the
in planets oh yeah that's great please
challenge it let's start with that let's
start with that um okay so what has been
done for the inner planets um what has
been published for the inner two planets
is that
the one emission um photometric points
or actually two depending on which
planet we're looking at um suggests that
they would be airless but uh because
it's not a spectral analysis but rather
two points at two different wavelength
there's not much information really um
that that can be extracted from that and
since this paper that you're referring
to claiming that this could be
Associated to the lack of atmosphere
have been uh pushed out other papers I
followed by showing that there's
actually a wide range of atmospheric
models that could still be consistent
with the data observed so in other word
um the assessment that there aess has
not been conclusive other programs has
been have been going on and there are
papers currently um being worked on that
that push the analysis further notably
by getting a full face curve so what has
been done so far to put this uh you know
further into context I'm sure your
audience knows about that but still um
it's been looking at the um brightness
temperature of the planet so how hot a
planet is by looking at the flux drop
when the planet pass behind its star
okay now if the planet was without an
atmosphere you would expect the dayite
to be quite hot because there would be
no atmosphere moving heat from the day
side to the night side okay and so the
experiment that was done is let's look
at different uh wavelength photometric
band so there's no spectral analysis
there and let's see how hot the planet
is and if it is hotter than what we
would usually expect if there's an
atmosphere then we can come to the
conclusion that there is no atmosphere
it can be more complex there can be
situation where you can still have a hot
day side while having an atmosphere and
so a big program that has been ongoing
or that a big observation that was done
earlier this year was to look at a whole
face curve of the planet so that then
you can actually talk about hro
distribution right because you have
information about the day side during
the eclipse but as the planet turn
around its star and you monitor the
whole flux coming from the system then
you can talk about what's going on also
closer to the night side and so these
studies are actually going to help us
bring this to an end bring this to
closure because they are going to tell
us what's going on with BNC so that's
for BNC should return to the rest of the
system
well I want to just sort of just make
sure I totally understand that so is it
really just like in that first round of
observations the people making those
observations whoever had booked the time
with with web had as much time as they
could get and you didn't get a
conclusive answer out of a short amount
of observations and so now to do another
round with a longer observation you
should be able to get to a conclusive
answer so yeah exactly yeah it's
basically you know we've build we're
building the plan as we try to fly and
it's understandable right to step bicep
we we a few years ago we thought that
just getting the eclipse would be
sufficient to tell us if there's an
atmosphere and now that we have the data
and we try this really complex you know
Global circulation model to try to get a
sense okay is it actually certain that
it means no atmosphere realize actually
no it's a bit more complex that that so
we have to go back and ask for more
observation so that we can keep on
fine-tuning the Anis and disentangling
with more and more
certainty yeah I analogy I I like to
think of is back when the when the
Russians when the Soviets were exploring
Venus with the venea program they didn't
know how bad the atmosphere was and so
they just had to send probe after
probe building it stronger and stronger
and it would you know it could only
reach a certain depth and they would
lose contact with then finally after
they really truly appreciated how
difficult this process was had the you
know and they they were able to get some
images from the surface and so it's like
you think you're going to get what you
need because the time is so precious on
web until to ask for any time you know
it's a big ask Y and so I'm sure they're
like what's the minimum amount of time
that you need to get to do the sign if
if you'd like we can really talk about
this difference so we can be
quantitative right an eclipse takes
about five hours and you need you need a
few of them to be able to build up the
the signals ratio the the scientific
confidence right a face curve a face
curve is an hour is about 70 hours right
so it's it is indeed a much bigger ask
to get to that point and so you're right
it's really a matter of time like the
the key resource that's limited here is
time and so you do you you you minimal
minimum ask to move one step forward and
then you see where you're at and then if
you need to move another step you might
need something bigger and that's the
whole point the whole idea behind the
road map is to really peace meal
everything that needs to be done but
what allows for key deliverable so that
we can sit assess where we at and then
plan the next step and so it's it's
really the idea behind the road map and
and are are those the actual numbers
like it was 5 hours to make that first
observation of trapis 1B and now it
looks like it's going to need 70 hours
or is it is that just like a yeah these
are the numbers so multiple so those
numbers so for trapis one one eclipse or
one Transit takes about five hours and
then you have you know for for Tris 1B I
think four or five um Eclipse were
obtained to get to that that first paper
but then the full rotation curve is
about 70 it's about 70 hours so that
gives you an idea of how much time has
to be spent and the face curve has been
observed so it's something that actually
has happened that that 70h hour
observation has been made yeah it has
been made M and is is it still in
embargo right now the results
definitely okay all right um yeah I mean
that's a big ask to get 70 hours on on
web I know I've talked to many
scientists and they talk about the
productivity of it in just an hour and
to say why we need for 70 hours please
for one planet in a system uh yeah I can
see why you take these steps tentatively
that that's great I mean this is the
most satisfying answer that I've had in
in you know in sort of going down this
journey if you really think about it and
really unpack the the core mission
or the core goals of gems web one of
there are four of them and one of them
relates to origins of life right and
trapis one by far is the only system we
have right now that can help us or hope
to answer somewhat questions related to
that theme beyond the solar system
Beyond the Edge of the solar system
right there's no planetary system like
it and like there's no like you can go
to the road map and look the first
figure it shows how trais one is well
beyond any other system so it it is the
only system we can we can hope to
leverage to try to provide a sense of
success to gem web's fourth core mission
that relate to the origins of life so so
it isn't that much when we think that
you know thousands of hours are given
each cycle to different program so if
25% of the goals of gems relate to that
then 25% of these 5,000 an hour could be
invested in that theme at least and a
fraction of that significant fraction of
that should go to trais one so it's not
that much right right of course um is
the same story for the next one c b and
c I would I would just put them in the
same package in fact the observation
that was made the face curve is an
observation that's made when B and C
have U eclipse at the same time so we
have a join face curve of the two of
them so the the idea was to leverage the
two of them so that we can at once
constrain their their properties and and
I'm sure you'll hear about the the
outcome in in the coming months when
were those observations made the
observations were made at the end of
2023 right so I'm just like checking my
watch thinking about the Embargo time so
we' got a few more months left okay um
all right let's move on let's talk about
D oh sorry yeah D sure yeah so for so D
so D is special in the sense that it's a
small planet
and you could
technically do an assessment of its
atmosphere with only two transits so two
Transit observation if they are done
well and you're not dealing with Stellar
contamination something I'm going to
talk about later you you should be able
to do it uh and as a results
um you know people people pitched for
that so observations were taken um but
still not published and and you'll see
that there's a pattern there right for
for most of the planets but B andc
there's still no paper out there and
that relates to the fact that um we
simply underestimated or did not account
for the effect of contamination when we
when we pitched our programs um and so
you know I don't want to say that we
have over promised and underd delivered
as a community but there is a bit of
that I think we programs went through
without accounting for
the the most recent knowledge of what
could be limitations and and now we're
paying the price for it to some
extent so let's talk about this problem
then what like what when you say Stellar
contamination what are you talking about
great so um remember talk about this
like half roten Apple being a star and a
planet passing behind it well when the
planet pass in front of the star it's a
Transit and when that happened there's a
small fraction of the Stellar light that
goes through the planetary atmosphere
for a long time most of the community
thought and have appreciated the fact
that there was information about the
planetary atmosphere there and we call
it a transmission Spectrum but that was
misleading because there's also
information about the star in that
Spectrum so it's not just a spectrum in
transmission there's more to it why
because when the planet mask part of the
star it's masking a part of the star
that's not necessarily with the same
emission spectrum as the whole star and
when we do exoplanetary sence we use
relative measurements we look at what's
going on outside the transits and use
that as a reference for what will be
inside Transit but if the out of Transit
so the hemisphere aage spectrum of the
star is not exactly the same than the
cord that the planet is masking there
will be contamination there will be
information from the Star bleeding into
that transmission Spectrum which means
we have to find tricks to disentangle
between the signal from the planet and
the signal from the Star and that's
where we're facing a new button lck
right right and is that just an issue of
understanding the Dynamics between the
star and the planet or is it just more
time it's really understanding Stars
better it's really an issue with how
much we know about stars and and we know
quite a it's just that now we need to
know much better if we want to do you
know optimal science with jams web so
what's the tool to learn more about
stars is it web or is it are there other
instruments out there that are yeah that
are that can help us understand that's a
that's a fantastic question I'll have to
say humbly that this is something we're
still you know reflecting upon as we
speak we building strategies we testing
them and we think of new instruments
there's there's different approach that
needs to be taken in parallel because we
need to try them now so they can pay off
as soon as possible so we can Implement
them while J J swap is still you know up
and going some of them r on um upgrading
our Stell models and fortunately the
community has embraced that and you know
for example recently an ERC Synergy
Grant so 10 million euros were invested
in supporting efforts along that line so
we need to upgrade our models but if we
want to upgrade our models we also need
some gr rules so because we need to to
provide reference to confirm that they
they are solid and so in parallel other
efforts are being driven towards um
empirically driven or derived
constraints so it's really data driven
and that's some of the thing we do as
well um so that means trying to find
ways to understand the star better so
one of the strategy we've developed
recently in this group is to do time res
spectroscopy so if you have a star and
we allow it to rotate and we study it
with gems web for example um there is a
way to identify different features on
that star and derive empirically their
emission spectrum and then what we can
do you know back in the day when they
they built this library of um emission
Spectra for stars right what we could do
this way with web we could build a
library of emission Spectra for faul for
spots for different features on stars in
a way that's completely data driven and
then we can use that to inform models so
that these are the kind of strategy
we're trying to implement understanding
how models can be pushed further how
instrument like gemwood can use
instrument from the ground at much
higher resolution so that's where the
community is at mapping out the realm of
possibilities and moving forward and
implementing there's a lot of you know
try yeah I mean I think about how little
we know about our own star and it's
right over there um but but at the same
time I know a lot of telescopes like or
missions like Tess for example are
turning out to be surprisingly useful
for observing not just where there are
planets but also the stars that are in
in that field and are finding a lot of
minor variations in Stellar brightness
and are helping with Astros seismology
and and and things like that and so I
guess it's sort of needing to look that
deeply into what these you know how
these Stars operate to then be able to
detangle the planets from the stars in
the field exactly exactly yeah yeah so
based on what was learned with the
amount of observing time and sort of
what the plan was you know you you said
that the the observation's already been
done for for D
um do you think that this time around
enough observing time was done to get a
more conclusive answer about about D so
so the observations were done for for
some of these planets it doesn't mean
though that they were done in such a way
that the Stellar signal can be
adequately removed from the planetary
signal right it could be that there's
only so much we can do with this data
and and that that is our our main
concern and that is why we we wrote that
road map because really we don't want
people to be underwhelmed by
results simply because the design may
have been suboptimal and so and this is
really why we want to provide this road
map so people keep in mind the long-term
goal and understand that these are steps
that needs to be taken and if at some
point we took a wrong step it's okay to
go back to square one or wherever we
were and then try another step and I
think this is probably how we might have
to look at some of the cycle one
observation and as we move forward we
need to be comfortable with having to
double down in order to make things work
and that's typically what we have to
look at I think orders of magnitude if
say you need two transits if you don't
have Stellar contamination to take care
of D once you start accounting for
Stellar contamination you need to
significantly increase your Baseline but
you also need to gather more transits to
make sure that you understand at each
each Epoch C contamination good enough
to really get to the atmospheric signal
so it's just a different way to look at
how we gather the data considering that
now there's a whole other player which
is the contamination another signal that
we have to understand together with what
we're trying to get to the planetary
signal are there other possible sources
of error that you're concerned about
Beyond just the star itself are we
talking about trapis one or ex yeah I
mean I mean even just say m dwarf
planets in General trying to get some
kind of ground truth about them sure MWF
plans in general the other big piece
relate to flare and flare is still St
activity right but flares are
challenging I mean they're great because
you know it helps us understand the
starb it's still information yeah um
yeah they're cool but the yes but they
are challenging because they are you
know they are very time dependent if you
think about what I was talking about
Stellar contamination from the beginning
of a transit to the end of a Transit the
stock rotates a tiny bit you know it's
it's it's negligible and these spots in
future evolve small like not that much
um so once we have developed a framework
either through improve models for the
emission spectrum of these different
features or through a new data analysis
technique like having a whole rotation
curve with a star that gives us the same
thing an emission spectrum for each of
these different component once we've
done that should be okay to take care of
them right once we've done that it's
good but flares they come and go in a
matter of you an hour or two and so this
transient Behavior makes it just a bit
more challenging to navigate we will
find ways to navigate you know to handle
them but it's it's another piece to
account for yeah yeah yeah I think about
when doing astrophotography and you take
a a bunch of frames good good good
airplane good good good right and you
have to throw out the airplane one as
long as you took a lot of frames then
you'll get what you're looking for and
so in your case it'll be good good good
flare good good good um so like I've
done tons of reporting on
various discoveries in space astronomy
and I think about a lot of the premature
announcements of the detection of life
or even of conditions for life or all of
that and it
is it feels like it is this sort of
thing that haunts the astrobiology
community the extraplanetary community
that you think about the Viking
experiment you think about the Allen
Hills meteorite you think about the
discovery of phos and Venus like I could
just go on and there was a really
excited announcement and everyone was
breathlessly excited about this and
then more sober conversations were had
and we sort of reached a level of of
understanding about where things were
and it feels to me like the exoplanetary
community is deeply aware of how this
conversation can get off the rail
if it isn't approached very carefully is
that is that like a like a sense in the
community I would agree with that
understanding
yeah yeah okay all right that's good
enough um all right well on that though
you tell
me well no no I mean I think that's it I
mean I
like I I think people really want the
answer to this question like did you
find an atmosphere on trapis De you know
is their life there and and I think the
fact that the answer is taking so long
is because people are trying to be
really careful about the answer that
they give that's the impression that I
get and that you don't want the quick
answer the people want this answer you
don't want the quick answer you want the
right answer and sometimes the right
answer is going to take longer and
that's I mean even if we were to take
the Optima Road like the the one we we
crafted in the road map it's still yeah
it would still be a good five years away
like so describe the road map like what
is the plan yeah So the plan is let's
say we have a planetary system like
trapis one like multiple planets um
around an M dwarf and that's how we
expect them to be like the like peas in
a pod right and it's really only
terrestrial planets around mwar that we
can use to search for signs of habit
well first atmosphere and then
habitability or inhabitability so for
sure that's what we're talking about um
so imagine we find a system like trapis
one or say trapis one first thing we
want to do is to assess the to which the
inner planet are warm enough so that we
can use emission spectroscopy to assess
the presence of an atmosphere two
options right for these inner planets
either they have an atmosphere via
emission spectroscopy or it's
inconclusive or not really so if they
have an atmosphere then it's Bingo right
if the inner planet of a system like
that have atmosphere very likely the
other ones have two so that becomes a
high priority to targets right and then
we can start diving in and and we move
towards characterization if they don't
what we've been pitching for and we
imple implementing that now actually we
just implemented that on on July 9th for
Transit double transits what we can do
is we can use one of these planets that
we know to not have an atmosphere and
catch multitrans event so that when that
planet that doesn't have an atmosphere
Transit all the spectral information
that we have in transit is actually the
information we're seeking the
information about Stellar contamination
so we can use that as an anchor to then
correct for whatever it's going on in
the transit of the planet for which
we're searching for atmosphere and we
can use that to correct for this the
Stellar effect that makes sense so
that's that's one of the other technique
I was mentioning before before I talked
about the the rotation of the star to
try to understand the star better what
we can do we can catch Windows where we
have back-to-back transits with the
transits of a planet that we know not to
have an atmosphere and we can use that
then to correct F contamination um and
the cool thing about planets around M
dwarf is that they on very very short
period And so backtack Transit happens
frequently believe it or not in trapis
one I talked about this 5H hour window
to get a Transit right and to get some
baseline well 46% about you know one
Transit out of two happen within five
hour of another Transit so if instead of
targeting small windows and having small
programs we do big programs and we
really Target this back-to-back Transit
window we get two transit for the price
of one and on top of having two transit
for the price of when we actually have
information to correct for Cellar
contamination so with that approach what
we can do we can get to step two which
is doing transmission spectroscopy and
for each of the planet in the system
assess if yes or no they have an
atmosphere right and this typically for
M dwarf planet takes about 10 transits
give a take you like 10 20 but that
order of magnitude 10ish transits so
that means that if we were to spend if
if we invest that time well the 10
Transit is smaller on a aage because we
can get these back toback transits and
you don't have to spend 10 Transit on
each planet individually of course right
you can have this there are some windows
where you can have five Transit back to
back in a matter of 10 hours for tapis
one just so just so we clear in some
some instances it's all right so once
we've done that we reach a step where we
can say is there an atmosphere that's
worth looking at it doesn't mean that
for sure we'll be able to assess with
stand Transit the presence of any
atmosphere but for some atmosphere there
might be so thin or challenging to to
detect in transmission that it's not
worth going down the rabbit hole of
investing 100 transit to search for key
atmospheric signature right is more like
just wait for the next generation of
telescope you've done good enough um but
if you find some of the signals then
it's definitely worse spending hundreds
of transit to get to indepth atmospheric
characterization and that's when you can
start finding signs of habitability or
signs of inhabitability but getting to
100 Transit on trapis one planet will
take quite a few years if we really just
invest on getting those but it will be
worth it so that's the the high level
view of what the road map would be about
yeah how much time is 100 transits yeah
100 transits would be you know give or
take 500
hours right so a big a big chunk of time
yeah but is it I understand one4 of I
know one4 of James web's goals you know
to answer the most fundamental questions
that Humanity has ever asked is that
that that doesn't seem like a big ask so
actually it would not even be that right
um if I'm not mistaken and we can
correct the number once we do the edits
um I think it's typically of the order
of five to 6,000 hours allocated per
cycle right so if you do these 500 hours
over the course of it's probably spread
over five years it's basically a 10%
well no it's it's not even a 10% ask
it's a 2% ask mhm yeah right so it's
that PCH yeah no I I and I'm sure if I
had the entire astronomical Community
here in the in the room with me we could
have a very spirited debate about how to
allocate time on James web to all the
different priorities that have been uh
assigned to this telescope I mean it's
just it's so precious right now every
moment that it gets used and now here is
a real challenge that we that we're
facing we've not talked about this yet
is that unfortunately part of the
community early on has been
convinced convinced you know not even no
room for doubt and and and discussions
about this that planets around mwar just
don't have atmospheres because they are
very active early on and so forth and so
forth and so forth and
and that that is part of the challenge
if if some people get um you know
convinced with without without room for
investigation then then it can be
challenging to convince the community to
allocate towards such a goal uh an
important amount of time
but that's a relatively straightforward
question to
answer once and for all I mean get the
null result like if it is null result
that's important and we should get it so
that we can move on to the next plan but
to because there these are the easier
planets to observe and so if we can and
there are they do have atmospheres and
we can detect potential bios signatures
it makes sense to linger on them for as
long as is required so I I you know and
that seems like the rational approach
you know we we are in cycle 3 and there
is no plan to have this consistent look
at the topest one system but now there's
a road map so so it's should be
clarified um what I mean you talk about
trais as this
unicorn in our discoveries of exop
planetary systems is there really
nothing that is as good as Trappist for
terrestrial tempered Planet no not not
not for now now there are missions and
and that's some of thing we contribute
to that are aiming to find other planet
like it so trapist one was finded with a
prototype teles prototype telescope
called trapist right um and then out of
that success uh another Consortium with
another Belgian name was founded uh the
speculo Consortium so tapies for the
beer speculo for the cookie and um the
goal was for trapis to look at 50 star
like trapis one and search for planets
and trapis one emerg speculas is doing
that for a thousand stars a thousand
Ultra COV Stars right and but so far
speculas hasn't found speculas hasn't
found another one yet no and it is by
far when you think of um you know signal
amplitude but also signal
um SAR to those ratio so the the
certainty of the information that you
get it is by far much better than than
any system in that in that size regime
and again I would refer to figure one in
the road map that really highlight that
well like if you if you plot all of the
planet known in that regime what you'll
see and you will really see diagonal in
in that plot that shows temperature of
the planet versus the signal that you
can expect and you'll see um late M
dwarf and at the top really just trapis
one as the the best system for which you
can study terrestrial planet in the
temperate regime and then as you go
further down and further down you see
that you just look at different Stellar
type because it's really the Stellar
type that defined the planet to Star
Raya ratio and the information content
directly scale as the planet to star
size ratio arraya ratios so only the
smallest of the smallest stars allow you
to study these terrestrial planets
that's it and trapis one is the only one
known in that regime wow um and I know
that there was a paper that
we uh published on uh about six months
ago and someone had done some
atmospheric modeling of the rest of the
trapis one planets and although the
first two probably received too much
radiation the chances of an atmosphere
get pretty good as you get farther away
from the Star so what are you expecting
to see in terms of atmosphere based on
the models that you've seen I don't
expect anything remember what we're
talking about about that's the thing I
mean I'm just I I just want to be my my
stand on this is just same as F model
right we can we can put like Millions
into upgrading our Stellar models we
also need Grand truth in order to to
ground these models into truth and so we
can have this super complex you know
geophysical models for these terrestrial
planet around Stars completely different
from ours formation process completely
different from ours amount of volatile
completely different from what we can
expect here age you know it's an 8
billion years old system much older than
ours so with all of these different from
our statements um you know I I just want
to keep an open mind and we can get the
data so I would rather be just let's get
the data and then let's talk yeah I mean
I think if if it does come back airless
if all of the worlds come back airless
and if Other M dwarf planets that are
observed also come back
airless what do you think that says then
it
provides no I mean I think this is where
we posst because you know one one of the
one of the things we're interesting in
in one of the question we're interesting
in answering with this system is first
let's acknowledge that the Milky Way the
planetary solar population of the sorry
the Stellar population of the Milky Way
is dominated by these M dwarfs right and
we know that these M dwarf can produce
planets and quite a few planets in some
instances so what it means is that the
terrestrial planet population of our own
Galaxy is by far planets like the trapz
one more so than the one that we find in
an or solar system which begs the
question are all of these Planet airless
rock or habitable Oasis so if you have
in a large enough sample not just around
trpis one but other star like it may be
more or less active so we have a we have
an understanding of how activity level
flaring spottedness and so forth may
affect uh the capability of a planet to
replenish a secondary atmosphere if we
have done enough of that sampling at
some point we can come to a conclusion
but we need to do that sampling we
cannot rely on models to drive this
understanding and and they are vastly
easier to observe than earth like worlds
around more sunlike stars it's simple
with current technology fruit it's it's
not even that they are easy is with
current technology they are the only one
we can actually hope to study I mean
trapis is lined up nicely between the
planets and the are lined up in front so
they transit in front of the star from
our perspective and there must be other
interesting systems out there just not
lined up perfectly so what future
methods
of that you we talked about that chain
you talked about before like the
detection method what other methods of
detection are you excited about as sort
of future as Next Generation ways of
finding more planets yeah I mean the the
the next next Generation really will be
direct Imaging and and maybe if I can if
I can go back on the on the discussion
about habitability of course there are
system that are of interest for
astrobiology with gem swb that would be
more with super earth right like right
now the focus was on teral planets but
there are system with star that can be a
bit bigger like we were talking about
the planet to Star ratio if we are
comfortable talking about searching for
signs of habitability or inhabitability
around planet that are super Earth so we
don't really know if they can you know
be habitable like the Earth is because
we really have only one sample and it
happened to be an earth-sized planets um
then we can go to system around slightly
bigger Star right and and that open the
door to discussions for of of other
planetary system that depends if you
want to go there or not but there is
room to do what we're talking about for
other stereotypes and they come with
their own challenges right there will be
less Stellar contamination in some
instances there may be more Stellar
activity um but there is room to do
something there but if we really move
further down and we look at the the next
missions it will be or the the next
technique that will really help us do
this at a at a population level because
we won't be limited you're right by um
by geometry having the planet needing to
to Transit then we're looking for direct
Imaging but direct Imaging is going to
be a challenge for these for these MWF
systems right because as we just talked
about there these plets are very close
to the star because the star is very
very very faint so the planet to be
habitable then it to be quite close to
the star to have of flux coming from the
planet from the Star so that mean that
they are really compact right the seven
planets of trapis one they are if I'm
not
wrong eight times the the furthest away
is eight times closer to trapis one than
Mercury is to the sun that's how packed
the system is right and if you think of
all and I'm sure your your audience is
used to to see this detection uh charts
if we were to do direct Imaging we will
find the Jupiter the Saturns in in a
sunlight in a in a system like ours but
finding the the Earth the Mars will be a
challenge Venus maybe if it's bright
enough so think that even closer to the
star forget about it so direct Imaging
will be great for analog to our system
but for system that are and system it
will still be a challenge in most
instances so whatever we do that might
be the PA forward even when we start
doing direct Imaging Transit
spectroscopy for these mdo systems but
but you say like finding worlds like the
Earth like it's a bad thing oh no did I
say that no no no no but you know that's
my joke here is that is that I think
that that the direct Imaging technique
will be a lot more effective for finding
worlds like Earth worlds like Jupiter
finding things that are a lot more
analogous to our own solar system like
we have this really distorted
perspective of what planets exoplanets
are like compared to the sun because
we've all that's been found is the Lohan
fruit the stuff that is enormously hot
and orbiting around its star at a you
know a fraction of the distance of
mercury because it makes lots of
transits um and then the things orbiting
around M dwarfs because the difference
between the brightness of the star and
the planet are very similar but I think
the this is what has to be observed
because this is what's the easiest to
observe we're pushing the limits of our
current technology so you I want to go
back to direct
like what is the pathway forward with
direct Imaging that gets us a more
reasonable understanding of what's in a
planetary
system well so okay you're right that
there's observational bias all over the
place right and and as we move to the
next generation of Technology we keep on
widening the parameter space that we can
explore uh and direct Imaging would
really provide a huge step forward from
from from that perspective so I do think
that I mean I I can't say what would be
next it would just be getting closer and
closer and closer to the star so we'll
be reserving more and more of that um
but that's bigger bigger telescope then
right is that it it's bigger and bigger
in telescope or aerometer or a neter or
whatever like some baseline a larger
Baseline and that's that's it I mean
what what's next I mean if if you think
doing in the
infrared yes
yeah because that's again that's where
most of the spectral information is for
the planets for molecules this is where
there are most uh most present and then
there's emission as well if you want to
see them further away yeah there's a
combination of the two right and and the
distinction in the brightness of a
planet and its star is is easier to
resolve in infrared compared to visible
light for example exactly so this this
is where we're going I mean one of the
challenge with d you know direct Imaging
is is that in terms of design as a
community we would have to ask ourselves
are we going to try to fly single
aperture instruments that have you know
tens of meter in aperture or we're
trying to move towards a design with a
fleets of meter siiz telescopes but this
is really the path forward fall but now
we're talking of you know like 20 plus
years on the
road I I don't mind okay
well what what does it look like what do
you what do you think that because I
mean if if we're if you know this is the
goal of humanity to understand our place
in the Milky Way to understand are place
in the cosmos it's a worthy goal so what
does the
instrument that gives us the answer look
like do you think the one that that
images worlds or images other stars
picks out the
planets you know provides promising
candidates to other scopes for more
detailed observations like the hab world
like what is the oh the the Kepler or
test of direct
Imaging yeah you see
I'm you're putting me on the spot here
um I I don't know yet if the habitable
World Observatory is the optimal design
for that like something that might be
worth exploring and I I won't go into
detail but you know a project like
notilus have you heard of
notilus you have yeah okay yeah so so
you know designs design that are I mean
more
transformative from from that point of
view than than uh H can be simply
because of the the limit on the aperture
yeah sorry I just want to make the
distinction right like the habital
worlds Observatory is the
corow
of of once the planets have been found
by Kepler and Tess then you bring on
something like the hab worlds
Observatory to make observations on a
couple of Worlds that are the best
candidates the ones that you can really
get that spectroscopic data on the
atmospheres but I think about just the
finding just the knowing are place in
the COS how many of these STS the
detection as opposed to the
characterization right what is the
because I then I was going to ask you
about the characterization but first I
just want to talk about detection what
but I think it's the same instruments I
I do I do think that fundamentally we're
looking at the same at the same
instrument right the which which Mission
would you would you use so the the an
that you make is great and at the same
time the the detection mission that you
mention are our Transit
mission right M and so no I want a
direct Imaging Mission exactly but the
thing is if you do a design for direct
Imaging Mission you do a design
that's your design is already half the
way to something that's also good for
characterization so why do two separate
thing and though that that was my that
was a the answer to the question I think
you package that as one
thing okay so convince me that I think I
just did why do two separate things no
no but like why I guess why why why is
the detection I mean why is why is there
Tess in cor why is there why is there um
Tess in aiel right like why are there
there are two different missions one is
great at at staring at a big chunk of
the sky and finding all of the ones that
have interesting planets orbiting around
them and another one is used to make
very detailed observations on the known
planets to learn more about them why in
when it comes to direct Imaging why why
do those become the same Mission again
yeah so this is where I'm stepping out
of my ARR of expertise so I would take
everything I say for your audience to a
grain of s totally yep yeah everyone
listening everyone you know the Press
people Yep this is n this is nonsense
this is we you know we've just cracked
open beer in front of us and a bunch of
specul crackers and we are now having a
uh a just a free floating conversation
here
yeah so um in order to do direct Imaging
you're going to have to have this large
collecting area and so from the point so
just to resolve the planets away from
its star you're going to need to have a
significant correcting area which is
different from what you're looking at
when you do transits Transit I mean
think about the aperture of test right
these are 10
in aperture and that's enough to see the
star being masked so what you're looking
for is an effect on something bright
when you do transmission or Transit
detection when you do direct Imaging
you're looking for the flux from the
planet which in and of itself is very
tiny but on top of that you need to have
an aperture that's big enough to collect
that tiny amount of flx and dangle from
the Star but also and most importantly
you need to have it big enough so that
you have a special resolution to start
hoping to be able to mask the thing
that's next to it that's billion times
bright yeah depending on the planet
you're looking at but I think that's
significantly brighter next to it the
star so just out of sheer design
necessity you detention technique is
already requiring you to have this large
aperture so this is usually the
requirement to move towards
characterization so I think out of sheer
necessity you already have a design that
isn't that far from what you need later
to do characterization so that's that's
how I would think of it right but when I
think about an analogy of say Kepler
like with Kepler it was staring at this
one spot in the sky and of course its
reaction Wheels failed and they had to
change the mission but they were staring
Rock Solid at this vast field looking
picking out all of the changes in
brightness across all the stars that are
happening but obviously if you're going
for direct Imaging that's not going to
work you need because you've got all
these Stars so you somehow need to have
chronographs across all of the stars in
your field of view
so that you can pick out the planets
okay am I am I is that correct that is
that is is that impos I guess and so was
anybody thinking about this is this
impossible I I think a lot of people are
thinking about this yeah yeah okay so I
don't think it's impossible no no no I I
do think that there's a good
understanding that this is where we have
to go as you correctly highlighted the
approach that we currently use is based
on our technology which induc mation and
so we're going for transiting system
which is great because again we we need
to we need to have the community moving
but ultimately what we need to do is
direct Imaging because most of the
systems are not transiting um so we we
know we have to go there so we will have
to design the technologies that answer
that problem so we will get to that
place yeah and I think the when you
think about say the groundbased
telescopes like the extremely large
telescope that's in development you
think about the hab World Observatory
these are
you know they will they will be able to
look one star at a time carefully mask
the light from the Star attempt to see
the planets orbiting around it and and
so then I guess I'm kind of leapfrogging
to what comes after that right so I
understand that it's a it's a fairly
large speculation let let's you know the
good thing is also it's worth
highlighting because you know it seems
overwhelming to think that you can only
do one system at a time in comparison
into Kepler that was just staring right
but the difference is that you you just
need snapshots for the
detection right like test Kepler they
have to stare and just wait for a
transit to happen for direct Imaging you
take snapshots and then you see if there
are some point source and how they have
moved and then you can derve the orbits
so you can go from one St into the next
and you can do many of them overnight if
it's ground based or many of them over
the course of a day so I think that's an
important distinction to make which also
goes back to what we're talking about
got to collecting collecting your area
right you could afford to go to a small
aperture with test because you're
staring and so you can bend on on big on
big amount of time to collect photons
but there is a big aperture that you can
then use for characterization you can
just take snapshots and then see if
something comes up and then if something
comes up you can use your big aperture
and do a stare to gather the data so
it's a got it got it I understand it so
you're um like again back to the
astrophotography like I can take a 5-c
exposure of Andromeda and I can detect
the presence of Andromeda or I can do a
12h hour stacked exposures of Andromeda
and see all of the Dust lanes and all
that by just coming back with the same
instrument and just collecting more
photons okay I I understand now I'm
convinced um Julian what are you
obsessed with what I'm obsessed with um
I'm really obsessed with how much we can
learn about ourselves by looking for
plans around other Stars really that's
really that's really the reason why I
moved to to this field uh so by training
I'm an engineer in aeronautic and
Aerospace and at some point I drifted
away from Planes and Rockets and
satellites because actually that's when
I I came to MIT first um Sarah Seager
introduced me to the prospect that at
some point we may find terrestrial
planets and we may be thinking of
searching for signs of atmosphere and so
forth around them uh and I got convinced
by the fact and excited by the fact that
I just just feel like so much is
happening to humanity right now if we
get to a point where we can have this
profound Paradigm shifting experience
like you know really help people Embrace
that we really on our space odyssey then
it's totally worth it so that's that's
what I'm excited about because I feel
like I started this journey now 14 years
ago and I feel like we just a few years
I mean within the decade that's coming
we're going to have incredible
experiences coming from astronomy and
you've seen the news related to Mars
recently right I mean they they don't
say what's going on with perseverance
they don't make the statement that's
something has been found but there's
something really exciting happening
there so I feel like both in the solar
system and outside of the solar system a
lot is happening which is good
considering everything that's happening
on Earth so it that's what I'm excited
about yeah I mean there it's amazing how
many separate pathways are being
explored simultaneously whether it's you
know sir Seager is involved in this
mission to Venus to explore the atos of
Venus and then there's the the work
that's being done by seti and then
there's the work that's being done on
the surface of Mars and then the Europa
Clipper is preparing for launch to look
for plumes to Europa and people are
making better observations of intellus
and of course is the work be done with
James web yeah I could probably list out
20 different paths that people are
searching for signs of Life out in the
universe and that really feels
transformational
that 20 years ago it was something you
didn't talked about and there was no
funding made available to the
astrobiologists and seti and any of this
kind of stuff and now suddenly not
suddenly slowly
inexorably
the it's always been a scientific
question all along and and now the
funding and the effort and the respect
is being delivered to the community to
try to get an answer to what is possibly
the most profound question Humanity has
ever asked is our we alone in the
universe exactly and I feel like it's
coming you know it's very timely at a
time in history where a lot of
challenging are emerging and I'm not
going to talk about geopolitics but I'm
just going to talk about say AI right AI
coming in and that is going to transform
disrupt the the job market right and in
economies where people have developed a
sense of self and a sense of value
that's directly tied to their job coming
to a place we can have at the same time
answer to these profound questions you
know are we alone Universe what does it
mean to be a sunon being the dominant
sunon being on this planet I think these
things are just going to have an
interesting and longl Lasting effect on
on our society so that's really what I'm
excited about you know I would ask you
which of those Pathways you think is
going to bear fruit first but I'm
assuming just by the career as an
aerospace
engineer working in exoplanetary science
you've sort of chose in your youve
placed your
bat uh wow that's uh
[Music]
I would not say that I would really not
say that yeah I do I do think that in
terms of life
elsewhere in the solar system we have
much higher chances but I think that
each are going to have their very
different impact on on on our societies
I you know very unlikely that we find
sentient beings in our solar system I'm
going to say very unlikely but I'm not
going to put bets on that um and so I
would say a lot of people are not
necessarily going to resonate with or as
much with the fact that say we find
microbia life on on Mars for example
right like it's going to have an impact
especially if we start connecting that
to our own tree of life it's going to
have an impact not denying that but it
seems to me that um intelligence life is
probably what people are going to click
with uh more so than just microbar life
and and that's most likely going to be
related to findings outside the solar
system yes yeah yeah but I mean but then
for example trap us sorry James web able
to detect the presence of
chlorofluorocarbons in the atmosphere of
trapis one like that would be that would
tell us I mean that's a cool thing with
technos signature technos signature
there's no I mean it's very unlikely
there's a false positive right I mean if
you think of how life evolved life
basically does advance chemistry but
it's still geochemistry which is why
it's difficult to say is it life it's a
weird chemical process that we don't
know yet but if you have a techno
signature like CFCs and so forth
right it's easier to detect intelligent
life than it is in some instances to
detect just
life yeah absolutely fascinating it's an
exciting time one way or the other we
will know an answer in our lifetimes
whether there is life or in in it or in
an increasing bubble around us there's
no life and both are in you know in the
words of of Arthur C Clark equally
horrifying so I think it's a it's a
fascinating time to be to be watching
this journey unfold and to not know the
answer is is exciting to me because I
want to find out the answer it's like
watching
the a big game and we're right at that
last moment yeah of seeing who's gonna
win or lose so we have to stay healthy
and we have to take care of ourselves so
we can just you know live to that point
yeah yeah exactly exactly well Julian
thank you so much for your time and good
luck with uh finding atmospheres on the
trapis one planets my pleasure thanks
for having me I hope you enjoyed that
conversation with Julian DT I'm going to
talk about some of my thoughts but first
I'd like to thank our patrons thanks to
Abe Kingston Adam Schaefer Andrew Gross
Bill David Gilton and David matz Dennis
alberty Dustin cable Jeremy murn Jim
Burke Jordan young Josh Schultz mozo
Paul robox Steven kraki Steven fer money
and Vlad shiin who support us at the
master of the universe level and all of
other supporters on patreon this
interview really filled in some missing
pieces pieces in my understanding and
knowledge about the state of observing
planets around red Ro Stars why haven't
we found out any information about the
trapis one system from the observations
of James web and you know it really is
about getting a good answer not the
quick answer and I think the answer we
want is well did you find atmospheres or
not well the results are inconclusive
that doing the kinds of observations
that it's going to take to get a good
answer is going to take more time and
that's going to take more study it's
going to take more time dealing with the
data and it's going to require making
sure that you've got the right answer
and not just the quick answer that's
then going to lead to arguments the
kinds of things we see over like the
Viking experiments which were
inconclusive and people have been
arguing about them for for decades and
so I think we know better now we know
that if something really interesting has
been found you've got to be sure and
you've got to be able to back it up with
really high confidence data and this is
the road mapap this is the plan so we've
got to be patient I can be patient I
hope you can too all right I hope you
enjoyed this conversation and we'll see
you next time