What happened at the earliest stages of the Universe and what is it expanding into? Can they just put a telescope inside a Starship? Why do I like the NIAC program so much? Answering all these questions and much more in this week's episode of Overtime Q&A.
00:00 Start 00:35 What happened in the earliest stages of the Universe? 02:56 What is the Universe expanding into? 03:57 Did it happen now or in the past? 07:48 Could we put big telescopes in Starship? 08:52 What was the source of energy of the Big Bang? 09:44 Is a quasi-star a good explanation for black holes? 12:35 Will the ELT do infrared? 13:57 What would a starquake do to Earth? 15:49 Does Io have tectonic plates? 16:29 Why do I like NIAC so much? 18:13 How do we get JUMBOs? 19:59 Why can't we see beyond the CMB? 21:07 Could you ride a black hole's polar jets?
⚖️ LICENSE Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
You are free to use my work for any purpose you like, just mention me as the source and link back to this video.
what happened in the earliest moments of
the universe what is the universe
expanding into and how do astronomers
think about events happening in the past
all this and more in this week's
overtime question show hey everyone so
we're still on our live stream Hiatus
and so we are going to bring you another
episode of questions from overtime these
are the questions that got asked after
we stopped recording and just continued
on with the live stream bunch of
different questions a lot of astronomy
related questions I think you really
enjoy them so enjoy this next episode of
the overtime question show these came
from late October animal goyal can you
explain to me what happened in the early
stage of the universe and why we can't
see until the actual size of the
Universe I mean there's so many things
that happened the beginning of the
universe if you go like right back you
know like the best way to think about
what happened in the early universe is
just run the existing Universe backwards
like right now we look out in space and
we see galaxies that are moving away
from us and so if you were to
turn this backwards then you would see
galaxies coming towards us and
eventually the galaxies would all be in
the sameish location and so this time
was when the entire universe was so kind
of hot and dense that you didn't have
stars and galaxies you just had the
whole universe was like the surface of a
red giant star so just imagine
everywhere you looked it was just this
red glow because everything was about
3,00 ,000 Kelvin and then if you go
earlier and earlier back into the
universe like that's about 380,000 years
after the big bang but if you keep going
just a few minutes after the big bang
then everything in the entire universe
was as hot and dense as the core of the
Sun and so for about 20 minutes you had
nuclear fusion happening and hydrogen
was being turned into helium for like
like I said for about 20 minutes the
ratio that we have today of 75% hydrogen
25% helium that was all formed when the
universe was like the core of a star and
then earlier than that and fundamental
forces in the universe like the strong
and weak uh nuclear force merged into
one type of force and then merge with
electromagnetism and you can keep going
back there's there's a lot of books was
it um the first 6 minutes I think is the
book anyway there's a lot of really good
books that tell you sort of what
happened why can't we actually see the
actual size of the universe because we
can't see before the beginning of the
universe and the beginning of the
universe is that you know light has
taken 13.8 billion years to reach us
that is the farthest that we can see is
the longest that light has been able to
travel to us in the future we will be
able to see more of the universe because
light more light will have arrived at us
but um but we can't see before the
beginning of time ba Ali I'd like to
know what the universe is expanding into
if that Mak makes any sense yeah we get
that question a lot um and so the
universe isn't expanding into anything
so like there's two possibilities right
one possibility is that the universe is
infinite and so like what that question
doesn't even make sense right like like
what is the infinite universe expanding
into well it's just it's infinite and so
you can't say oh well it's expanding
into something the other possibility is
that the universe is finite and if the
universe is finite it
wraps and so you can kind of imagine
that you know if you go in One Direction
or another direction right you're going
to wrap back to your original location
and so there's no outside of everything
you know people sort of Imagine in their
mind this sphere that is expanding and
and maybe it's expanding into some kind
of other stuff but that's not right
licky poo science communicators often
talk about how looking further into
space is looking back in time but isn't
that directly contradicting the theory
of relativity what we see now is what is
happening now yes sort of so because of
Relativity when events
happen happen at different times
depending on the Observer it's like the
classic example of this is like when I
say this star just exploded and then I
get someone saying well actually
that star
exploded uh 10,000 years ago and we're
just seeing the light from it
now and and I'm like
okay smart guy when did it explode for
the person who's close to the super
massive black hole and is experiencing
enormous amounts of time dilation when
did it explode for the cosmic R is
moving at 99.999% the speed of light and
is experiencing enormous amounts of time
dilation in the other way when did it
happen to the people who are on the far
side of the universe who could have
experienced up to 30,000 years of time
dilation compared to us on this side of
the Milky Way when you are aware of an
event happening depends on the amount of
gravity that you're in and the speed
that you're going and so you can't say
that a thing happened this many years
ago because it depends on your Ober
Everything's Relative and so you can
only say that it happened you were only
made aware of it
now and so then you can say that the
Supernova exploded because you are like
obviously it happened in the
past but you had no information about
that until you see it and so this this
idea of like the speed of causality that
that events can only move through the
universe at the speed of of light and
when you experience that event happening
depends on your local frame of reference
and so it does not make sense to say
that this thing happened 10,000 years
ago it makes more sense to say like it
is more logically correct to say that
this thing happened
now even though you're seeing it after
it happened than to say that it happened
10,000 years ago because when you say it
happened 10,000 years ago then you have
to say compared to what compared to who
compared to where compared to when
compared to what speed compared to what
gravity well right like it like it just
goes on forever but it drives people
crazy when you say that and so like I
don't say it very much because I'm sick
of people will actually in me uh oh my
God is this what it's like to be around
me um I have to ask my wife um yeah and
so you just kind of
go okay okay the
light has been you know the look back
you talk about the look back
time but that's actually inaccurate that
the most accurate way is to is talk
about the speed of of causality speed of
communication in the universe so anyway
it's uh I find that funny and that
people ask me like what's the thing
what's the misnomer that most
exasperates you and it's that right
because I'm trying to be more accurate
and somebody is willaing me and they're
wrong and now I have to have an argument
about that but what what can you
do so you're right licky you're exactly
right but you can never tell anybody
because it's not worth the fight bravo1
Elon mentioned placing a telescope
within Starship with a bigger mirror
than that of Hubble thought yeah it's
theoretically possible Starship has a 9
meter fairing you could you could Jam an
8 telescope inside Starship with like
additional Hardware outside of it so you
could fit like a mirror with the size of
James web but just in one you know one
optically ground perfect mirror and like
when you think about the mirror lab
where they build those mirrors for the
large mellin telescope or the Gemini
North and South they're all 8.4 meters
like that's the perfect size like the
they know how to make mirrors so you
could build you have the mirror lab
build you a mirror then you could put
that on a space telescope and put it
inside Starship and fly it you know
Starship will launch whatever 100 tons
to orbit so you could build a space
telescope that would be fat and heavy
and you could do it so like what am I
like put up or shut up Elon like like
can people fly today on you know when
when will we be able to do it that
sounds great make it happen how's that
coming Cosmic web what energy caused the
big bang and what role did Dark Energy
play in the very beginning we don't know
what what set the events of the Big Bang
in motion what was the source of the
energy that set all this in place we're
here so we know that it happened but
really our math can only go back to the
point where the weak nuclear force the
strong nuclear force and the
electromagnetic force were all one force
we don't know what happened before then
and this is like like we don't know how
gravity tied into those forces and and
so and we don't know what was the source
of like all that in the first place so
unfortunately right now and we may never
know and that's okay right like like
sometimes there's just stuff that we
don't know the answer to and we just
have to say I don't know this guy is a
black hole star or quasi star considered
a likely possibility in astronomy or
just an interesting Theory I mean the
whole way that astronomy and science
Works in general is you come up with an
interesting Theory and then you try to
accumulate evidence for what that thing
is and so for
example the theory says that when a star
with many times the mass of the Sun dies
and is no longer putting an outward
force of from the fusion then the outer
layers collapse Inward and you get this
Supernova and a black hole forms or a
neutron star and we see neutron stars
out there in space like we can detect
them they're rotating we don't think
about pulsars magnetars like we know
neutron stars are forming and yet
neutron star Stars only go up to a
certain size certain mass and then
there's nothing beyond that certain
point so like either the stars that are
more massive when they die they're just
blowing themselves apart or they're
turning into black holes but astronomers
wanted to know that these black holes
were out there and so they gathered
evidence and so the first black hole
that shaas found was called signis X1
and this was a black hole that was an
orbit around another star and the black
hole was siphoning Material off of its
partner star and throwing radiation into
space that astronomers were able to
detect in a very specific wavelength in
x-rays which matched what you would
expect to see if a black hole was
feeding on a star but that's not enough
astronom kept going the theory was that
there were super massive black holes at
the heart of the Milky Way and
astronomers were able to use infared
telescopes to be able to see stars that
were moving around the heart of the
Milky Way like comets going around the
Sun and they were able to measure the
mass of this invisible spot like there
was nothing there and they were able to
measure the mass at 4.1 million times
the mass of the Sun and so that was more
evidence that black holes are real and
then the Event Horizon telescope was
able to actually image The Event Horizon
of the black hole the heart of m87 as
well as the black hole at the center of
the Milky Way galaxy with Incredible
resolution and so and you could actually
see the shape of the Event Horizon and
match that against the theories
predicted for what a black hole of ENT
Horizon should look like you know think
about Interstellar and you got this
match and so just the evidence continues
to build like could they be wrong sure
they could be wrong but every time more
evidence is gathered the more we know
that these things are real like I don't
think there's very many people out now
who would say no black holes aren't real
you'd be like well how do you explain
these
x-ray um stars how do you EXP explain
the Stars moving in the middle of the M
how do you explain the pictures taken by
the vent Horizon telescope how do you
explain like it goes on and on and on
Brian Walker will the elt do much
infrared observing so the elt that's the
European extremely large telescope this
39m telescope that is under development
by the European Southern Observatory and
it's going to be operating out of Chile
later on this decade and it will be the
largest telescope ever built and sort of
the prototype for the extremely large
telescope is the very large telescope
and these are the collection of 8 m
telescopes also in Chile and they are a
near near infrared telescopes as well as
optical telescopes so they can both
observe in the near infrared and in the
optical regions so yes the extremely
large telescope will also be able to do
that near infrared astronomy in addition
to visible light astronomy I'm not sure
like what the breakdown is going to be I
mean different kinds of targets require
different wavelengths and so I'm not
sure like how much it's going to be
doing but it definitely will be one of
the primary ways that it's observing the
sky INF Fred is really good for finding
say uh exoplanets around newly forming
Stars you know a lot of the observations
the direct observations of exoplanets
that have been done have been done in in
infrared and so like some of the most
exciting images that we're going to try
to see will be planets around stars and
that's going to take infrared YouTube
Joseph WM What would happen if a
starquake hit Earth would it cause a
mass extinction and if so what would be
the subsequent disaster and effects and
what things would it create so a
starquake is when a neutron star crust
crunches down and like you would think
like okay a neutron star it is this ball
of neutrons that is reached its final
size but that's actually not true
neutron stars have layers um and so
maybe they're going to have these
neutrons at the core layer but maybe
they're going to have some kind of fluid
around that made of neutrons and then
maybe they're going to have like regular
particles around that some kind of like
atmosphere but mashed down and neutron
stars are cooling as they age and as
they cool they shrink and so you can get
almost like plate tectonics like as the
neutron star shrinks you're going to get
things kind of crunching down inside of
it and you get this release of radio
waves like like an enormous amount of
energy is released off the surface of
the neutron star it interacts with the
magnetic field and you get this release
of radio waves that tells you that this
starquake happened and like the best
tool that we have to be able to observe
this there is the nicer instrument
that's on board the International Space
Station it has been able to observe
starquakes happening on neutron stars I
can't imagine a starquake having any
impact on earth like like sure if we
were in orbit around a neutron star when
this happened then that would be problem
but neutron stars are hundreds of light
years away from us and so I wouldn't
worry about it if we were in orbit
around it then it would be a blast of
high energy radiation that would strip
away the ozone layer and so you have
increased amounts of radiation that are
able to reach the surface and
theoretically can cause a mass
extinction event Uncle Eric do you think
that IO has tectonic plates I don't
think so IO is more like hotpots like we
have hotpots on earth like the Hawaiian
Islands where you've got this Gap in the
crust where magma is coming up and
you've got volcanic activity on the
surface of IO and it's thought that
that's what you have on Venus like Venus
never had tectonic plates instead it had
occasional hotpots and so you would have
volcanic activity on the surface of
Venus and then every now and then maybe
Venus turns itself inside out and like
maybe that would happen on iO as well
but I but I am not aware of EV any
evidence that says that IO has Tik
plates Jr cord your nyak coverage this
year was some of the most fascinating
interviews you've done when will the
2024 niak grants be decided you know
have any interesting projects vying for
next year's grants the niak grants
are they usually come out in the
beginning of the year so February I
think but there's like a conference that
happens in
November and they have a teleconference
and so I sign up for the teleconference
and and listen to all the presentations
and then I worm my way into the hearts
of all of the people who are going to be
giving presentations and then I try to
do interviews with them it's such
fertile ground like you I'm so
fascinated to talk to these people about
the research that they're working on the
technology that they're they're
proposing every one of the ideas is just
like so out of the box and for me like
that's what NASA should be is more of
that right
less space stations and more Fusion
drives but understand that you know
there's there's constraints and and
deliverables and so on but um but yeah
it's it it's always baffled me that that
other people don't report on it in the
same way and and this year was the first
time that we tried to get them all like
I've you know if you look back I've I've
interviewed I've even interviewed the
director of nyak
um and so each year I try to sort of
bring I should like every year I should
have the KN director talk and then we'll
do the series of interviews um but maybe
that'll get more pressure cuz I only get
about half of them responding to me and
I need them all like it's not I want to
collect them all and so they need to
understand that if they talk to me then
then this will be valuable for them and
we will be able to help them promote
their stuff David Baker have any of the
models been produced that explain the
pairing of these jumbos that have been
discovered so the jumbos these are the
Jupiter oh I forget the acronym but it's
like the Jupiter rogue planets that were
found in the Orion Nebula and 9% of
those rogue planets were in binary
configurations so you've got two
Jupiters orbiting around each other
what's the model I mean like like to
find one okay great it was kicked out of
of a planetary system and now is
floating free it was kicked out of the
house but to find two in orbit with each
other then they they probably either
either through some weird three body
interaction that got them into orbit
around each other or they formed
together from their own little mini
protoplanetary nebula and just went
straight into gas giant you know super
Jupiter form so it's like it's so
exciting like finding these objects in
the Orion Nebula is one of the most
exciting discoveries of the year and
astronomers are going to be digesting
this for decades like I wouldn't be
surprised if somebody comes up with a
new type of telescope that's able to
detect the Pres presence of of rogue
planets Jupiter Mass objects out Across
the Universe like we're starting to get
this sense this whole new paradigm that
there is another class of objects out
there these rogue planets and they are
incredibly common they're everywhere and
knowing where they are and how they
formed and where their movements are and
how they get kicked out of solar systems
like there's so much meat to be uh
digested there that I think we're going
to see a lot of exciting work so just
like like don't panic we're right at the
very beginning of this bill sidel
probably a dumb question but here it is
if we can detect or see the CNB and the
CNB is the farthest object that we can
see how is it that we cannot see the
galaxies that are out of our visible
Horizon the CMB is the earliest thing
that we can see you know the light has
been traveling for 13.8 billion years to
reach us and there was just there was
nothing before that to reach us so like
if the Universe goes on forever and you
could instantaneously just move yourself
a billion Lighty years in any direction
you would see Galaxy's Close to You
Galaxy's red shifted away from you
quazar is at the farthest reaches and
then you would see the CMB and if you
moved 50 billion Lighty years in in One
Direction like well beyond what is our
observable universe you would see
Galaxy's Close to You Galaxy's red
shifting away from you quazar is at the
very limits of what you can see and then
the CNB like you will always see the
same thing but just different galaxies
you know different different players in
the in the playing different roles but
but at the end you just see the same
thing because it's about the amount of
time that light has taken to reach us
Eerie could you ride a black hole's
polar Jets yeah in theory Sure um you
know there have been proposals for
having
futuristic ways of using the solar wind
coming off of the Sun as a propulsion
system as well as like using an electric
sail that will interact with the with
the magnetic field of the charge
particles that are coming off of the sun
and the Sun is like nothing compared to
a black hole's polar Jets I mean they
are going at like while the sun solar
wind is going at hundreds of kilometers
per second these polar Jets coming off
black holes are going close to the speed
of light and so they would be probably
the best like like the most
efficient like most powerful propulsion
system you can possibly imagine out
there in the universe they're just
waiting for us to get to them all you
have to do is get to a
quazar that is sending out polar Jets
which you know could be a challenge now
I'm going to continue on with the book
club what I am doing for my summer
reading but first I'd like to thank our
patrons thanks to Abe Kingson Adam
schaer Bill David Gilton David matz
Dennis alberty Dustin cable Jeremy
matter Jim Burke Jordan young Josh
Schultz mozo Paul Robo Steven kasaki
stepen fer Munley and Vlad chiplin who
support us at the master of the universe
level and all our patrons all your
support means the universe to us last
week I said what I thought was the best
science fiction book which is fire upon
the deep and so I wanted to continue
this journey with verer ven's work and I
read Rainbow's End which is a book that
had been on my shelf for a while and I'd
never gotten around to it and the story
is of a man who was suffering from
Alzheimer's who a cure is invented and
he sort of wakes up from being in this
hazy state for a long time and realized
that the world is vastly different from
the one that he got sick into and that
is just like one part of the story and
then there's like potentially artificial
intelligence and people grappling with
new technology as it's approaching the
singularity and it wasn't as good as
fire upon the deep but it is a really
interesting book and when you think
about when it was was written it was
written in 2006 so it is almost 20 years
old and was written just before the
smartphone Revolution so a lot of the
technology that ver vinge predicts some
of it is just eerily correct and others
is a little L and we're not quite there
yet but still I thought it was a
fantastic book and I highly recommend if
you want to continue reading if you
enjoyed fire upon the Deep look into
some of his other writing uh this week
I'm going to be reading Aurora by Kim
Stanley Robinson which a lot of people
have been recommending to me so I'll let
you know how that went next week