Lecture 08

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Jul 26, 2024
[Music]
hello in this lecture we continue our
discussion on the concept of equilibrium
In classical mechanics so in the last
discussion we were talking about the
general concept of equilibrium and we
showed that I mean we uh like introduced
the concept that the equilibrium is a
state of compromised UNP perturbation
that means compromised state where you
have several efforts for pering the
state of motion but somehow since they
are balancing each other for for some
points in space during its motion huh
then for I mean for that point or some
for those points I would say like some
some points sometimes it can be more
than one points but not all all the
points if at all the points it has zero
uh force acting on this then it is
exactly I mean identical to a force free
situation but here we the equilibrium is
very much interesting in the framework
of classical mechanics when at some
special Point uh in the uh in the field
of movement of the particle the
situation arises where the Vector sum of
the of all the forces becomes zero and
that is why you and at those Point
specially the system actually it
experiences a special condition uh just
like a force free particle okay and this
is called the state of equilibrium we
will actually now we'll try to uh
introduce you somehow uh we this this uh
situation with a very concrete examp
example of that of a raindrop so you
will see that when a raindrop comes from
sky and somehow at some height it get
condensed to become uh water drop I mean
the size initial size is actually very
small and although we know uh from our
knowledge that raindrops actually they
gain masses as they are falling but uh I
mean I can just for the sake of
Simplicity I can think of a situation
where the mass is not that much changed
so the assumption
is
raindrops
mass is
fixed and another point is that it is
actually falling exactly under the
effect of two forces one is the gravity
which is pulling it downwards and
vertically downwards so I can think of
so you see like the phenomena is
actually very close to the art surface
and that that's why you can just think
of a just like this as a plane and a
raindrop is just moving like this and
you can think that is just a vertical
straight line which is uh directed
downwards so you can think this is your
z cap Direction which is uh in the
downward Direction that's exactly what I
presented over here and then you can
think that it starts from some zero
velocity and after some time it has an
arbitrary velocity
VZ and this is the velocity which is
actually changing and uh it can have
actually some velocity in the other
direction that we are now for the for
this problem we are neglecting and we
are simply thinking that it has just a
velocity uh acceleration in this
direction now as I said that it has more
than one actually two forces in action
uh for its motion one is this
acceleration due to gravity and uh so
the force will be actually so mass of
the particle mass of the
Raindrop times G and uh another
assumption here is that the rain drop at
this point has so small size that it can
be uh treated as a particle so rain
drop is a point particle
okay and that is why we are discussing
this problem in this course okay so uh
first of all it is actually moving
downwards with an acceleration which is
AMG and here I'm just writing scaled G
because we know that the direction is JC
Direction I mean z cap
Direction and then another Force which
is actually affecting the motion of this
rrop is the viscous drag
so viscus
drag of air now what is the source of
this viscous drag of air that is beyond
the scope of this course but we are just
thinking that since air is a continuous
medium it always can have uh I mean
effect on the motion of some particle
now you see there are some contradiction
between this uh viscous drag of air and
the assumption that the r drop is a
point particle because if it's a point
particle then it doesn't have a size but
on the other hand viscous drag actually
comes into play only when particle is of
finite size because you will see that
whenever let's say you have some fluid
let's say air and a ball is moving like
this then actually viscous drag comes
into play due to this principally due to
this surface of contact between the ball
and the uh fluid if the surface of
contact is negligibly small zero then
there is the viscosity is also very very
less okay that you can actually think
that whenever you have a very small
particle which you just uh I mean which
you just leave like this and this
particle easily falls down but if you
have let's say a sheet of paper it
doesn't fall down very easily or very
quickly actually it flies because you
see that due to its area of contact
large area of contact with the air the
viscous drag which is acting on this is
larger okay now for the Simplicity for
the sake of Simplicity we just think
that okay it has some area of contact
but somehow this is for our case still
can be thought to be a particle and
actually I mean I will cover a little
bit of system of particles at some time
and you will understand whenever you
have a motion let's say the randr has
some I mean finite size and it is since
uh it is consisting of many particles
actually infinitely many particles but
all of them are in this particular
motion all of them are actually
performing or undergoing identical
motion actually this whole system can be
replaced by a single representative
particle which is called the center of
mass of that particle that I will come
later but just to tell you that I mean
apparently there is no severe
inconsistency in those assumptions
that's what I was trying to say so now
you have a point particle Point raindrop
but it is actually moving under G it is
experiencing viscous drag for the sake
of Simplicity once again I can model the
simplest model of viscosity I mean uh
Air drag which can be given me something
like this some proportional to VZ and
that I take the proportionality constant
to be Alpha so Alpha VZ and now if you
write the equation of Dynamics for this
particle just along Z Direction it will
simply be M D2 Z
dt2 which will be equal to mg minus
Alpha VZ okay now you see here this this
thing in
general is very interesting because you
can always think of a situation where
this is zero but none of them are
individually zero okay but somehow you
see that when they are exactly balancing
each other you have a uh Force I mean
you have a net acceleration which is
zero okay but again uh what is the
potential what is the total mechanical
energies of this particle so I can also
write this equivalently as M dvz DT is
equal to
mg and I can actually write this
as Alpha
VZ and then I can write
M VZ time
dvz
DT and I can actually write this as mg
so uh there will be an a VZ so I am
multiplying everything by uh multiplying
by VZ both cases so there will be VZ dvz
DT VZ minus Alpha VZ squ and again
although this is easy but this is still
interesting the DDT
of M VZ squ by 2
plus
mg Z
because you see VZ is also DZ DT that
you cannot forget here okay and this
will come like this and you can actually
think this thing to be uh so actually
this is there will be a minus sign here
I sorry for this there will be a minus
sign here
yes and you will see that this will be
exactly equal to minus Alpha vit Square
which is of course less than zero now
because Z is actually taken downwards so
minus Z is actually positive in our case
so this is nothing but the total
mechanical energy now DDT of this is
less than zero so the energy is not
conserved energy is not
conserved okay Al although you can have
a situation where this two balances
these two balance each other to have a
zero acceleration now when they will
balance each other I mean this is also
very easy to understand when you
have mg is equal
to Alpha VZ or VZ is equal to mg by
Alpha at this point you see what happens
that this one balances this one and this
has zero acceleration now this is not
the end of the story what is the
observation the observation is very
important once you have this velocity
then at that instant or at that point of
time or point of space as well because
you see here time and space they are
actually
monotonically uh related with each other
so you see that once VZ has this value
then at
some height Z from the initial point it
has and with this VZ so when this height
is let's say I would I would call that
Zed star and
VZ uh
star okay I can call that V Star
actually okay if there the values of uh
the position and the velocity of the
particle then suddenly it has zero
acceleration once this has zero
acceleration what happens that you see
that this one is a constant force now
since at this point it has zero
acceleration which is exactly equal to
this and it has zero uh so so you see
that VZ at after this point will not
change if VZ will not change because dvz
DT is zero then this Dr force will also
not change and this is a constant force
so if at this point at Z star and VZ
star this one start balancing this one
the balance will be remaining true or
valid uh during the rest of its motion
so once again so once so once the VZ has
a specific value which is exactly equal
to mg by Alpha then this part is zero
and then VZ cannot increase or decrease
any longer and then what happens that
this Alpha vit is fixed in this value
now what is this special value so Alpha
vit is fixed at Alpha vit star value now
what why this value is special because
at this value this is exactly equal to
in magnitude uh is equal to
mg okay and they are actually
vectorially equal and opposite this one
and this one and they are balancing each
other once they are equal and opposite
and since after this point this will not
increase or decrease anymore the balance
will be locked so this will be a locked
situation so for the rest of the motion
of the particle the particle will always
fall with this velocity VZ star and this
is known as so I just write over
here with a different ink terminal
velocity now what is the interesting
point about terminal velocity if the
terminal velocity was not there huh then
actually what happened the particles the
raindrops which were coming from very
far they could always I mean uh continue
accelerating and finally the velocity
and the momentum with which they would
hurt us would be much greater and we
could have some effect now you see due
to this terminal velocity after some
distance covered the velocity is limited
to some terminal velocity and and that's
why uh when we receive the raindrops
they are not that much heting okay they
are not that dangerous okay on the other
hand at this point I would like to
mention there is another very
interesting effect the effect
of the changing mass of the Raindrop
that we have neglected here just to tell
you the equilibrium but if you have a uh
raindrop which is actually physically
much more reasonable which is gaining
mass so due to that gaining mass if you
do uh properly use Newton's law you will
see that in gaining mass basically
actually tries to reduce the velocity of
a particle okay so and in that sense
that gaining mass also can try to act
like a dissipative or drag Force now you
see that if you have one conservative
force field and two dissipative force
fields huh so when the equilibrium is
reached then the equilibrium will be a
little bit different that is that will
be a balance between the conservative
field that is the acceleration due to
gravity or the force due to gravity and
the Air drag force and also another drag
type of force due to the change of mass
if you make the vector sum of all these
three things to be equal to zero then
only your dvdt you can think of a system
where your I mean situation where your
DVD May reach some uh I mean I mean May
reach zero and your velocity reach and
the velocity of the rrop actually
reaches uh the terminal velocity and
actually it is sometimes seen that
actually the terminal velocity which you
can calculate by just this simplistic
formula is a little bit greater than
what actually it is also received
practically and one possibility is and
one reasonable possibility is that the
that is due to to because the rain drops
are also gaining mass with time okay so
this is and of course the realistic
situation is different it has so
different shapes and it is not spherical
sometimes it cannot be just represented
as a single point sometimes many
raindrops can coales and make a I mean
uh larger shape which no longer become
symmetric just just that I was just
telling so many things will be there
then also air can have some other type
of effect air can move huh so all these
possibilities are there here we are just
thinking that the particle is moving and
air can ALS air don't have that much of
movement okay but if air is moving in
just this direction uh in in the
horizontal Direction there is no effect
but if it is moving in this Z Direction
upward or downward somehow locally if
you have some movement then actually one
can take care of uh in the the simplest
case if the air is moving roughly at
constant speed then you can actually do
this uh whole analysis like this but
then you have to just take a uh origin
shift that means you have to now work
with the relative velocity of the
Raindrop with respect to the air huh
those things you have to take into
account okay so you see this was a very
important concept to impart now I am
coming to this uh concept of equilibrium
and potential okay so as I said that in
the at the very end of the last lecture
that whenever you in the in one
dimension so I just write in 1
D okay if you have U is the potential so
of course at equilibrium we expect so
equilibrium point is the x equal to x0
point and we will expect this equal to
zero
and to U dx2 greater than zero or D2 U
dx2 Less Than Zero but of course always
evaluate at that point that is very
important we said this is stable
equilibrium stable equilibrium this is
unstable equilibrium today we will try
to understand why they are called so
okay so for that what we will do we will
First Take again the Newton's law so
what is Newton's law Newton's law is m d
d2x
dt2 is equal to minus DX okay now at x
equal to x0 at x equal to
x0 M d2x
dt2 at x equal to x0 is zero because as
du DX at xal to x0
is0 that we know now if I partur the
particle a little bit a displaced a
little bit by a small push okay so that
I am not giving very I mean uh giving
considerable amount of energy so that
the particle is I mean parter being much
that mean that means the particle does
not have any finite displacement it is
only infinite decimally small
displacement so that is very important
here for the analysis I part of the
system from x0 to x0 plus Delta so Delta
is my new variable although small this
is the function of T and that is why you
still have a meaning for dxdt and DX d2x
dt2 which will be actually so if I do
that then actually your DX DT so this is
a constant point you know fixed Point
okay I mean this is the point which you
already know known aiori so DX DT will
simply be D Delta DT and that Delta is
something you can change but it should
always be small okay that is something
very important so the assumption is
Delta should be very very small with
respect to X zero at least okay I mean
this is not maybe uh I should not say
it's x z but because x z can actually be
thought to be zero as well so this is
not a reasonable approximation sorry for
that I mean so Delta should be in
general a very small quantity okay which
is somehow what is the meaning of this
small quantity that means I can apply so
Delta is small
enough so
that I can perform
a tillered
expansion with it okay that is exactly
the requirement now if you do that
basically what you will find that okay
here I have just made this for another
formula I can do here no problem if
you'll make this you will actually see
that your U which is now U of X and
which is nothing but U of x0 + Delta
will be equal to U of x0 plus du DX
evaluated at X = to x0 *
Delta plus half D2 U
dx2 evaluated at x equal to 0 * Delta
square plus some higher order terms Now
Delta is so small that we will not go
above the second order terms okay now
this one is something which is a
constant this is the value of U at x z
now you can simply say that this
constant I can always choose I mean I
can always choose to be zero so that my
U of interest will be actually not U
exactly but U minus some constant I can
call this as u0 okay then that is not a
problem then I can make that u0 to be
zero or I can say that U minus U will be
my U okay in both cases the analysis
does not get affected and you will
actually see that your ux so what you
see your ux will be equal to these two
terms now again at x equal to x0 by the
definition of equilibrium this term
vanishes because this term
vanishes okay and if this term vanishes
at x equal to x0 then the only term
which is meaningfully surviving is this
term so that will be equal to then half
D2 U
dx2 Delta squ now you see if we say
that this is evaluated of course at x0
if we call that this this thing if we
call this thing to be K okay and we say
that K greater than zero and K can be
also less than zero then we will
actually check that these things these
things are nothing but these conditions
so in a sense we are saying that when K
is greater than zero then I have stable
equilibrium and when K is less than zero
I have unstable equilibrium okay but the
original question Remains the Same why
should I say that for that I will just
take a place over here and I will make
some small calculations okay you will
easily see that so what happens when
your ux is actually half K Delta
squ okay I have just written this sign
because we have neglected the higher
order terms then your FX is actually
minus Delta because now uh FX is nothing
but so FX is nothing but minus du D
Delta because Delta is the only variable
part in X x0 is not uh meaningful here
x0 is just a constant and
then the Newton's law said Newton Second
Law says that what will be the equation
of Dynamics for the particle it will be
M
Delta double dot or D2 Delta plus dt2
sometimes as I said dots are for DDT
okay plus K Delta is equal to zero so
you see uh because because this is
nothing but FX and or F Delta which is
nothing but minus K Delta so this plus K
Delta will be zero now if K is greater
than zero we know the solution
is oscillated
so that means that if K is greater than
zero if you part up the particle a
little bit with respect to its original
point or position of equilibrium then
the particle will
simply perform a simple harmonic
oscillation okay and that is how a
position of stable equilibrium is
defined on the other hand
if K is less than zero
then the solution will be solution of M
Delta dou dot + K Delta will be is equal
to zero will be
Su Delta is equal to Su a e to the power
some constant which is the root over
minus K by m actually will be there then
t + B e^ minus < TK K by
m uh t Okay so this is either either
your displacement after some
perturbation small paration either your
displacement is exponentially increasing
with time or it is exponentially
decreasing with time huh so in both
cases we are talking of unstable
equilibrium
so you
see
if the equilibrium position is such that
a small
perturbation on that equilibrium
position huh would lead the particle to
perform small simple harmonic
oscillation with respect to the
equilibrium point then we call that
stable equilibrium position okay so this
is the case stable
equilibrium if the particle either goes
directly to kill its displacement and
and very very fast like this or it
increases very fast its displacement
from the equilibrium point in both cases
we talk about unstable equilibrium okay
now you'll see that in most the in in in
natural systems most of the times we say
that for a stable equilibrium system if
you just part of the particle then the
particle will actually come back to its
initial position that's not the correct
interpretation the particle if you
parter with some energy then the
particle will actually in an ideal case
where there is no viscous or drag
effects or dissipative effects the
particle will forever U perform a simple
harmonic oscillation the particles most
of the time they actually come back to
the only initial position after some
oscillatory motion with decreasing
amplitude that is because of the natural
viscous forces okay so before ending
this lecture I just going to discuss a
little bit this problem that is somehow
an easy problem and you will actually
check this thing so what is the uh type
of motion or what is the I mean this
equilibrium points of equilibrium and
the nature of equilibrium when a
particle is just moving under this
potential uux is = x² by 2 minus x 4x 4
now you see here there is a potential
function so which I can write Y is equal
to U of X so that is the potential
function and here I plot this as a
function of X so
when X has very small values then this
term is negligible with respect to this
term this term dominates and you have a
parabola so that's why points which are
close to zero huh and not the large
points you have something like a
Parabola over
here y u is = to x² by 2 when the large
values are coming for a large values of
X in both negative and positive and
negative sense huh you will see that you
will have something like these things
will be somehow start dominating and at
some point it will actually balance this
thing so that ux becomes zero and then
finally it makes the whole ux uh then it
dominates largely in such a manner that
finally you will see that ux becomes I
mean will tend to minus infinity in both
the cases when X is increasing towards
positive infinity or this is the case or
X is tending towards negative Infinity
in both the cases you will see that U
will be actually tending polom I mean uh
uh in the power of four okay to this
negative Infinity now you will also see
due to this type of potential curve we
have three possible regions uh three
possible points actually not regions but
three possible points which can act as a
maximum or Minima we can actually
confirm that just by doing this small
calculation so du DX is equal to x minus
X cub and we know for equilibrium DX
should be zero so we know this equation
has three Roots okay one is x equal to 0
another is so because okay I can just
write x uh 1 - x² is equal to 0 so
either x equal to 0 or xal to+ -
one okay so at those three points it
will have some maximum or minimum okay
so if you just now calculate d2x d D X2
sorry D2 U
dx2 then it will be again uh 1 minus
3x² now this will be
somehow I just use this in yeah this
will be somehow equal to 1 at x equal to
0 because as x equal to 0 this is one
okay at X is equal to + - one in both
cases you will see that this will be Min
-2 so -2 at X = to +
-1 so we can actually uh cross check
that really at X is equal to 0 this has
a minimum and at x equal to+ minus one
so we now know this is minus one point
and this is the plus one point huh it
has two maximum okay now you see that uh
we can easily now think that okay so
these are the points uh of equilibrium
and this is the stable equilibrium point
and this is the unstable equilibrium
point the same for this unstable
equilibrium point and now you will
actually think of another point that is
uh what will be the value of U at those
points and are they really the I mean
the minimum or maximum that that is
another uh step further but just at
least to understand what will be U okay
so if I just say that what was what will
be U so U of X for x equal to 0 will be
zero
so you you you see here that is the
point so U will be exactly equal to zero
here okay so at at uh at uh I mean how
to say at X is equal to 0 now at x equal
to 1 or minus one because this is an
even function this will be symmetric
okay so
uux at x equal to +
-1 you will have actually uh so half
minus 1X 4 which is 1x 4 which is
nothing but 0.25 so this will be
actually in this thing
0.25 now you see the only point I was
trying to to say you know that ux the
minimum value of ux is actually minus
infinity over here
but I am deriving here that this one is
the minimum okay and this is
zero but I mean is this contradictory
the answer is no we are just defining
the points of stable equilibria to be
those points which are local Minima okay
you see that
in this locality when you have two Min
maximum values and these two are
actually separated by a minimum so in
this local region okay or even in this
locality or you can say that okay I can
take even this domain from this to this
okay where I mean in this domain I can
see that there is one point which is
really the minimum Point huh and this is
minimum this this cannot be minimum
because after that it is also decreasing
but here you see this is the minimum
point because just before and after this
the U function increases okay so that is
that's that is why this is a local
minimum and a point of uh equilibrium is
stable equilibrium uh if the point is
just a local minimum it can be a global
minimum as well but this is not
necessary okay on the other hand for the
unstable equ ibrium as well it should be
actually either local me I mean it
should be just either local Min maximum
or Global maximum but at least local
minimum will be sufficient okay if there
is no other minimum then Global and
local they are the same thing okay thank
you very much
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
