Lecture 07

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Aug 2, 2024
[Music]
good morning uh before we uh start I
want to tell you that the homework first
homework will be uh uh put on canvas
today after the
class uh you have uh until I believe uh
February 7 to complete the uh homework
and submit it on
canvas um under
assignments uh the homework is uh
supposed to be done in groups of three
so we have created the
groups so you will also see with your
homework this uh uh spreadsheet uh that
or or PDF file that will will uh give
you that will tell you which group you
belong
to and uh
also there is uh one more thing that uh
we'll be giving you which is a list of
uh IP
addresses list of IP addresses that will
be so this will be a list of IP
addresses each of you will be working on
a different IP address so you have to
find your role number and see which IP
address you are working on okay and the
homework will be based on the different
phases of the uh
killchain uh the lockhead Martin
killchain and uh we'll do another
homework we'll uh probably in next few
days we'll also uh put up another
homework which will be again due um a
week later uh which is about uh based on
the attck framework and mapping uh
reports cyber incident reports to atck
framework so those are the uh two
homeworks that will be due before the
midterm exam and I believe the midterm
exam schedule is not out yet but it will
be out soon it should be around 24 23
some uh February or something so uh so
accordingly uh you have to uh
prepare all right so now before so uh I
I uh I had recorded the uh lecture for
Last Friday on on Thursday and that
lecture I received the lecture only
yesterday so I put it up yesterday
afternoon and uh I hope that uh you got
a chance to watch it so I have uh to ask
you couple of things uh before we
proceed like
so go to
m.com and use this code 1483
2321 and uh answered the questions
before we
start
so at least somebody has watched
it okay
[Music]
give it another
minute so not yet sir close to uh yes
neck and neck those who haven't watched
um this one did you watch the previous
one
okay this classes 91 students but I'm
always seeing like uh less than 50 uh
even less
students so the midterm will be uh the
time when we'll see what
happens okay so uh I see uh that it's
kind of uh sampling Wise It's kind of
half and half so I would uh uh ask you
to watch but now the problem is that the
next few questions might be difficult if
you haven't watched the video so let's
see true or false so the whether this
statement is correct hash value as
indicator of compromise is not
robust dtp as indicator of compromise is
not robust and IP address as indicator
of compromise is not robust which ones
are correct and which ones are incorrect
okay so hash value is basically used for
identifying the malware right or a
document right so um when we say
something as an indicator of compromise
what we mean is that let's say somebody
gets attacked or some company like uh
semantic or virus total they come to
know of a malware and they tell
everybody that hey there is a malware
going on and this is the hash of that
malware so everybody will then have that
check for that hash right so they will
be always searching for any file that
comes with the same hash and then reject
that file right now how easy it is for
uh the malware writer see when this
information is broadcast the malware
authors also will know right the Mis
scant will also know that this hash is
now commonly known so how hard it is for
the uh person to change the
hash he has to just change a bit in the
malware file right so malware file uh
headers will have a lot of space where
you can make a small change without
changing anything about the malware and
the hash will change so as an indicator
of
compromise hash values are not that
reliable
right so attacker can change the hash
value easily and therefore if you are
just looking for that hash value you
will probably be fooled right as a
defense it works sometimes but it does
not necessarily mean that the attacker
will sit quiet and let everybody detect
him by that hash value he will change
the hash value
right now when the threat intelligence
company says here is a threat actor
which uses is these TTP like this
tactics techniques and
procedures and as a Defender you are
detecting what the ttps what kind of
activities are happening from outside to
into your system what tactics and
techniques are being
used and by that you can see whether the
one that the threat intelligence company
is talking about is actually attacking
your system or not right now once that
information is known
it is still very difficult uh it is
difficult for not impossible but
difficult for the attacker to overnight
change its TTP because it has created
see you have to hone the skills for
attacking a system using a certain
techniques and certain type of tactics
so you do not want to give up on all the
research that you have done to develop a
TTP to attack so you will eventually
change but you will not change overnight
therefore it is rather robust as
indicator of
compromise now IP address again similar
to Hash value if the threat intelligence
company tells you hey here is an IP
address that is being used by threat
actors as a command and
control or as a originator of a
spam you will block it in your firewall
right but the attacker can easily change
that IP address they will just change
the server from which they are doing the
activity or they will change the DNS
resolution from one IP address to the
other so therefore it is not very robust
but it is more robust than hash value so
those of you who have watched the
previous lecture the last pre-recorded
lecture they will recognize this as the
Pyramid of pain right so this is the
pyram this is from the Pyramid of pain
right so uh you go and look for that
part of the lecture pyramid of pain now
here is an easier question
how many tactics are there in the at and
CK
Matrix okay so I would have taken um
both 12 and 14 as answers atck has two
pre attack uh tactics
reconnaissance and uh development of uh
payload and then there are 12 others
like starting from initial access
execution
uh you know privilege escalation
persistence lateral movement Etc so 14
it is allog together but uh in usually
in the metric they show 12 at the from
the initial access tactics but there are
pre two pre attack tactics which is
reconnaissance and uh development of the
payload so that's why it's 14 so 14 is
correct 12 is also sort of correct right
11 and 13 are probably just random
choice right I don't see uh where you
got that so which of the following is
not a use of uh at and CK
right so we have uh remember it's we are
asking not a
usage okay so it's going in the right
direction so uh in the lecture
pre-recorded lecture we discussed this
different uses of uh at and CK of course
authentic ation is nothing to do with
tactics techniques and procedures so
obviously this is an obvious uh answer
so when you hear about ap28 so we have
mentioned apt28 many times so so I want
to know how much you remember so what do
you what do you remember uh what what
what comes to your mind when you think
about APD
28 okay
so it's like Donald Trump Russia right
so so it's a Russian uh thread
group you know and then you can think
about uh you know it's a state sponsored
government sponsored um it has been used
by against the uh US
Government um things like that uh it's
not Chinese or Iranian so A2 is a very
well-known thread group for from
Russia okay so uh last
one what comes to your mind when you
hear EP
3
goind
Corona Korea
yeah so ap3 is a Chinese thread group so
most of you seem to uh know that some of
you think it's Iranian and some think it
is
Korean now first of all you know that
there are two koreas right this Korea is
not a single country there is South
Korea and North Korea right and North
Korea has very well-known thread
groups um like Lazarus group or
p37 but uh this is not one of them
and uh that doesn't mean South Korea
does not have thread groups it doesn't
mean us doesn't have thread groups that
doesn't mean India does not have thread
groups there are but usually we talk
about because most of our threat
intelligence companies are us-based we
normally talk about uh Chinese thread
groups Korea North Korean thread groups
we talk about uh uh Iranian thread
groups we talk about uh Chinese thread
groups and uh North Korean thre groups
and so on but there are thread groups
associated with every government
right so so if you go to the attack.
m.com or and then you look through the
thread groups you will find Pakistani
thread groups you will find Indian
thread groups and so on so forth right
so uh APD 28 is also called Fancy Bear
right so can you imagine what the Indian
thread group is named after which animal
no
what
no uh well well there may be one uh but
there is one with the wellknown was with
elephant
yeah okay so that's let's go back to the
second part sub module of
ATC so in the previous classes we talked
about what ATC is all about what are
tactics and what are techniques and and
uh tactics and techniques are can be
found on the at CK knowledge base which
is very well documented knowledge base
uh at the attack. miter.org and so on
now the the question is that what is it
good for right so we said well it is
good for several things right so we said
it is it helps us identify threats or
thread groups uh it helps us
compare two thread groups it helps us to
emulate adversary to see what an
adversary does by going through the
various tactics and so on and then in
general it helps us to understand what
an attack is uh how it gives you a frame
of mind in through which you have you
look at it's a lens through which you
look at an attack so an attack does not
happen like you know just uh you know
just you send a fishing email and you
you get your computer gets compromised
and that's it it's not like that right
so thread groups want to do lot more
once they compromise your computer they
want to create persistence they want to
create um you know literal movement they
they will move to other machines they
will try to do data collection they will
try to do uh data exfiltration they will
try to do credential access all kinds of
stuff right so so it gives you a handle
on how to describe an attack so most
attacks can be described as you know as
a sort of like a sequence of tactics and
then also identify which techniques were
used to implement that tactic right so
so now what happens is that when uh
these companies like recorded future
fire or
mandant um Microsoft Google uh security
labs they all uh uh you know have
sensors all around the world right so
they collect data from various locations
like traffic internet traffic and so on
and from that they try to figure out
what is happening so not only it it
tries to understand uh an attack that
has been already reported and uh maybe a
mandiant has been called in to do
postmortem analysis and so on but they
also do uh observe the uh internet uh
for various uh types of traffics and
activities the malware
that are uh you know discovered and all
that and they try to make sense of it
and they create this threat reports so
these threat reports uh are often uh
then then published as part of their uh
um I would say uh you know free uh you
know service to the community so you
will find that recorded future publishes
threat reports uh uh the Mond publishes
threat reports m
publishes threat reports uh and so on
and so forth so this uh threat
reports uh have all the description like
this is how the initial access happened
it came through a uh came through a you
know lock forj vulnerability or it came
through a spear fishing and and things
like that then they will say that okay
the the malware the first payload that
came in that exploited so and so
vulnerability to do a privilege
escalation this then they will say that
after the privilege escalation they
actually went for the file that contains
the hashes of passwords and then uh they
actually send it to their command and
control server at so and so IP address
where it was uh this hash file was uh uh
you know they tried to do a dictionary
attack or rainbow attack on this hashes
uh discovered some credentials then they
use this credentials to get into the the
system and things like like that so they
will give a very elaborate description
of what all happened right
now once you have that uh as a as a
Defender what what good is it right so
uh I uh I subscribe to a number of
different uh cyber security news sources
and every day I get uh I get to read
like 5 6 7 8 uh such threat reports
right so so uh what do I do with that
information okay so it I can I can talk
to talk about it to others that hey do
you know that this happened or that
happened and it may give me an idea that
oh this also can happen things like that
or it can give me an idea that this
particular uh
vulnerability is there in the um you
know Windows Office so I I better think
about uh patching it and things this
kind of knowledge I can get but as a
Defender I have to get get more out of
this right so to get more more out of
this I have to basically figure out how
can I use this information to actually
defend my infrastructure right so there
there could be many ways to do it one is
you take bits and pieces of indicators
that are in that report like there are
some IP addresses in that report so I I
collect those IP addresses and I tell my
firewall guy that make sure that these
are blocked right I I I see that certain
uh uh certain versions of Windows are
are are exploited so I tell my uh system
administrator or asset manager that make
sure that none of our uh uh machines
have that version of Windows uh it
should be patched immediately so I can
use bits and pieces of that information
or indicators for uh for uh doing some
security but that's not very systematic
right so what what is the way to do
systematic uh utilization of such
reports right so you have to extract
this information in such a way so that
you can actually uh use this as an
designing your defense in a systematic
way or checking your defense in a
systematic way to see whether your
current defense will be able to uh uh
you know stop or detect if these things
happen in your system and also there are
there there is a uh threat intelligence
exchange for format called sticks so
sometimes I can I can actually put it
into this sticks format it's actually
kind of like a uh meta programming
language in which I can put all this
information and then many of the modern
tools like firewalls and intuition
detection systems and endpoint detection
systems they actually understand sticks
so if you if you give a new sticks file
to them they will make sure that those
indicators are actually uh used for
blacklisting or white listing or
whatever they want to
do so therefore uh what we want to learn
in this sub subm module is how to take a
report finished report what we call
finished report a report that has been
published about a threat uh uh action
activity by a uh well-known uh threat
intelligence company and how to map it
to ATN CK right so that is the first
thing we want to do right
so again to remind you that we started
with what is ATN CK now we are going to
learn how to uh use the finished cyber
incident report to map to ATN CK then
we'll see that how to uh map raw data
that sometimes there is no finished
report of an incident it may have
happened to your organization so you
have indicated various kinds of uh raw
evidences that this happened like some
logs and some some malware samples that
you collected uh there may be some extra
files created inside your system you
found that some IP addresses were
contacted which you don't recognize so
you use those information and map to
atnc so that's harder but that is a that
is what you most probably will do most
of the time you will not get a you know
completely uh finished report so that
we'll do in the next module next sub
module then we'll show you the tool that
uh miter design call at and CK Navigator
and then we'll see how the defense
recommendations are done based on the
mapping that the mapping that we have uh
created so the basic idea is that cyber
threat intelligence right so to defend
your organization uh cyber
infrastructure you need to know many
things right so who is attacking us
right not every kind of organization is
attacked by every thread group right so
there are certain thread groups focus on
certain sectors uh certain uh
geopolitical region and and so on so
forth right so who might be attacking
you and what their motivations are which
which will give you an idea about what
they might be uh actually after like is
it data or is it to extract money from
you through ransomware or is it just to
create disturbance or denial of service
so you have to know what they might be
uh
wanting then you have to understand uh
what is the frequency and volume of the
attack uh what are the attack surfaces
that they actually uh exploit right is
it like internet facing services that
they're exploiting or is it a uh are
they doing a supply chain compromise or
are they stealing credentials of
legitimate users and get uh get into
your system what is the what surface
they're uh attaching themselves to to do
the first
access and then you have to understand
the uh tactics that they are using and
then uh what techniques they're using to
implement the tactics then what
procedures they are following to
actually implement this tactics then uh
what kind of malware they're
using uh what is their command and
control
infrastructure uh and then any other
indicator of compromise like hashes and
other artifacts URLs files uh digital
certificates all these things so if you
have all this information it's easier
for you to actually defend against at
least that adversary doesn't mean you
are going to defend against other
adversary but for any adversary if you
have so much information then you can do
better with with against that adversary
for sure at and CK and threat
intelligence uh so at and CK actually uh
uh is about adversar Behavior right so
tactics is a sequence of tactics is
basically their behavior unfolding right
this is what they do first and second
and third and so on
so structuring the threat intelligence
uh you can structure threat intelligence
in many different way you can give it as
a text you can give it in the form of
sticks file you can give it in terms of
uh ttps so so what it is saying is that
uh uh structuring the CTI with respect
to uh this uh tactics techniques and
procedure will allow you to do a compare
different thread groups uh check your
defenses which groups uh what defense
works against which groups and so on and
the other thing is that when you are
talking to a
fellow uh uh you know security
professional uh if you try to describe
something in in in natural language that
uh this is what this thre actor does it
may be interpreted differently by
different profession this the Security
Professionals but if you use the common
language common vocabulary in terms of
te tactics and techniques
then there is no space for
ambiguity so for example uh let's say
ap18 it uses uh it steals credentials
maybe from various uh places and then
they log into external remote services
so if you have a remote login into some
system uh they somehow compromise your
uh compromise your credentials and then
they use that and pretend to be imperson
at you AP 29 also uses uh compromise
identities to access networks through
VPN and Citrix and
ap41 also compromised billing or payment
services using uh VPN access between
third party and the main uh targeted
payment service so in all these
cases you you can describe all this but
uh one thing that uh a person uh the
Security Professionals who are uh
familiar with atck if you say that
they're all using t11 33 that is using
remote exter external remote service to
penetrate your system making the initial
access they will all understand the same
thing so that basically saying that the
use of a common vocabulary in you can
you can Define your own
vocabulary but that vocabulary may not
be known to your colleague or another um
security expert in uh in the same uh
sector with whom you are exchanging
information but if you do this in in
terms of vocabulary that is common then
you can actually make more sense to each
other and and that will be useful and
helpful to each other so mapping from
finished report to at and CK so uh so as
I said that lot of people think of uh
threat intelligence as just indicators
of compromise right so now indicators of
compromise can be many types like hashes
are indicators of compromise IP
addresses are indicators of compromise
malware uh samples are indicators of
compromise uh URLs are indicators of
compromise certificates could be
indicators of compromise so so what is
an indicator of compromise so if there
is a compromise in one place and you
collect various artifacts from that
place and make it known to everybody
that if you see this hash and if you a
file with this hash if you see a the
malware fragment like this or if you see
a communication going to this URL or if
you're going to see communication uh
going to this IP address then you know
that you are also compromised by the
same thread actor right so that's why
it's called these things are called
these digital artifacts are called
indicators of compromise now indicators
of compromise uh when you give it in
terms of digital
artifacts uh if you have seen the
pyramid of pain you'll see that most of
it for the attacker to change this
indicators is not that difficult right
but if you if you share the threat
intelligence in terms of
ttps then as I said that the ttps are
more difficult to change overnight
because it requires a lot of time and
investment uh to actually come up with
the techniques and tactics that will
work on a particular Target now you
cannot overnight change that TTP uh you
know without investing more time and
money into it so therefore uh this uh uh
TTP based sharing of intelligence is
good now sticks as I said is is a format
by which you can share threat
intelligence and noway it is being done
more and more because uh even our
certain uh Indian uh computer Emergency
Response Team or our ncic they also
share threaten intelligence in sticks
format so if you have the right tool
like the the your firewall Etc are can
actually ingest sticks format and
automatically configure itself to stop
those indicators that's good that's
that's that that's what is being used
more and more so sticks is a something
we'll be uh discussing lot more in the
later in the class but all these things
uh you know not withstanding all these
things we can still uh you know uh use
atck mapping of threat
incidence uh and use that to disseminate
the information to others who also can
then use it for uh making sure that they
are protected against this techniques
and tactics right so there are uh 14
tactics as we saw and then there are
more than 300 techniques and the
techniques database keeps increasing
right so now the question is that uh how
do you go about doing
this so how do you map the uh incident
report to atck tactics and techniques so
first of all you have to uh read the
report and figure out what all things
that adversary did what he did first and
what he did next what he uh did after
that and so on and then you get the idea
about the behavior of the adversary what
the adversary was
doing now some of the beh behaviors you
may not immediately know that oh this is
this tactic they're using right so in
the beginning once you become very
experienced with this you will
immediately say oh this is this tactic
and this is this technique right but it
will take some time to get to that level
so you have to do some research right so
you have to go to the at website and do
a search like you say some Behavior you
do the search it will give you all kinds
of tactics and techniques that might be
relevant to that behavior
so you have to then figure out which one
is a good uh fit then you have to
translate the behavior into uh one or
more tactics and then figure out which
techniques have been applied to achieve
that tactic and then uh once you have
done that once you have completed the
whole mapping you then ask another
analyst to do the same and then compare
because uh everybody has a different
understanding of this this is not
exactly science this is more more like
expertise based uh kind of uh
mapping now this mapping as I said is
can be from the finished report or from
raw data now in this in this subm module
we are talking about finished reports so
we'll focus on finished
reports so to understand the behavior of
the adversary first thing you do is that
you focus on the verbs right so the
verbs will tell you you what the
adversary is doing right so what did the
adversary do uh on the system once it is
compromised right or how did it get the
initial access or how did it find the
vulnerability that it exploited how did
it create the persistence or how did it
do the privilege escalation how did it
become the root user basically uh
whether it uh exfiltrated data or
whether it uh changed any settings or
whether it used a uh malware
uh what kind of information it look for
or exfiltrated this kind of stuff you
have to ask yourself while reading the
report so here is a fragment of a report
and this report is actually in this uh
here is a hyperlink uh when you get the
slides you will find this hyperlink so
you will find this report from
mandiant and uh this is just to show you
an example about how do we go about
finding the behavior of the adversary so
so here you see that uh
here that particular CV was
exploited it's a it's a kernel
vulnerability uh and if you exploit this
it will give you the root AIS so you can
see that in the and this is the this is
middle part of this report right so we
are not going from the beginning this is
just to show you how you actually go
about doing this
so you'll say okay so uh it is
exploiting a particular vulnerability
and uh it is getting root
access now then it says that uh there is
a malare
component uh which uses certain command.
exe with a particular command who who am
I to figure out whether it is running as
root or not right so who am I will tell
you whether it's root or not and if it
finds that this is system
then it creates a task a scheduled task
so it's a scheduled
task is being created right and this
schedule task will run this test.exe
malware right so this is what is
happening with the persistence creating
persistence so here we saw privilege
escalation how it did privilege
escalation here we see how it created
persistence now you see that then then
it says when this malary is executed it
first establishes a sock socks 5
connection to a particular IP address
outside using the TCP Port
1913 and then it uh gives a connection
request with a specific uh
code and and make sure that the server
responds with a specific code it is
basically a kind of a handshake right so
what this is trying to do this malware
is trying to EST establish its
connection with command and control
right so in this little fragment of this
report we are finding a privilege
escalation we are finding a um
persistence and we are finding a command
and control so three tactics are easily
visible there may be more but this are
very easily
visible now so this is where you
actually are finding the behavior right
so we are just showing you one snipp
here then now if you do not know what
this Behavior so let's say you you see
that uh that it is connecting using sock
five socks 5 uh to an unknown IP address
and you do not know that that is that is
the command and control tactic then you
have to do research right so you have to
go to the uh attack database uh and
search for uh this behavior and it will
probably give you a number of choices
and then you will have to pick which one
is uh the right Behavior Uh right tactic
describing that
behavior so you can also do external
searches like what is socks socks is
basically uh is a proxy server so if any
of you have used any kind of a web proxy
like for example barp su barp su is a
tool for uh creating a web proxy so that
all web traffic from your browser goes
to the proxy and that's where it gets
external entities only can see the proxy
not your browser so all the uh
encryption SSL TLS terminates at the
proxy and therefore you can see the
traffic between the proxy and your uh
browser in PL text right so that's how
we actually do debugging of web
applications and so on right so so socks
5 is the one the protocol that is used
for uh that kind of
proing see the the the the different
malware uses different protocols for
connecting to the command and control
right some some may use HTML uh sorry
HTTP protocol some may use some DN even
DNS protocol and some could use uh uh
application Level protocols right so uh
so in this case this is using a socks
five protocol and it is using a rather
un non-standard Port 1913 1913 so you
might actually look for uh details so
here is a website called SG security
where you can actually find about all
the ports that are normally what what
services use those ports right now
remember that one to uh port number one
12124 are standards right so standard
ports those ports are used uh for uh you
know specific Services most of them but
1913 is outside that range so it is
actually rather custom Port right so
this uh whoever wrote that test.exe
malware they they decided to use this
port right now if this malware was
inside I canut in your
machine on the itk network will this
work 1913 Port is it open or closed
actually it doesn't matter because
unless explicitly our firewall stops
this port outgoing will always go right
anyway so now you have to translate the
behavior into tactics so uh the good
thing about translating Behavior to
tactic is that you have only 14 choices
right uh you know you cannot go very
wrong very far like nobody will say uh
well initial access confuse initial
access with uh let's say privilege
escalation it's it's not um easy to make
such confusion so so tactic finding is
not that difficult
so here uh for example this one uh the
one this is basically a uh you know
snippet from the one that we showed
before and here you see that this can
easily be uh attributed to command and
control tactic right so this is this was
easy the harder part comes when when how
to find the techniques because there are
300 plus techniques right the good thing
is that not all techniques relate to all
tactics right every tactic has a set of
techniques some techniques actually are
common
between uh multiple tactics but few of
them so if you know what tactic you have
identified then finding the technique
would be not searching for the all 300
but but the subset that applies to that
particular
tactic so uh so you have to look at the
techniques identified in the attack
metrics for identified tactics so uh so
if you have done the tactics correctly
then you have uh narrowed your uh
possibilities and then uh you do this
website search and all that stuff and
some behaviors may not have an existing
technique right so in that case uh you
you actually may
report a particular new technique that
you have discovered to uh attack. m.org
and your name will eventually if they
accept that your name will be showing up
in that page right so who who
contributed to that that technique so in
this case uh you have command and
control and then uh there are two
techniques that seem to be working here
that is uh custom command and control
protocol they're using a custom command
and control protocol and then they're
using a uh
well not a commonly used Port but it is
rather uncommonly used Port right
19113 so it's a standard non-application
layer protocol so that is
t1075 so when you say socks 5 connection
it's not a non-standard protocol it's a
it's a well-known protocol right but it
is not at the application layer many
times we design an application layer
protocol which eventually uses the lower
level like tcpi Etc but but we uh look
at then in that case we'll see a custom
we'll see a custom protocol but this is
a standard non-application layer
protocol and it is also used as a
connection proxy so that is
t1090 and this is uh there are two
alternative commonly used port or
non-common used Port uncommonly used
Port so here
t165 will be the more appropriate
because this is not a commonly used Port
right Port knocking is not at all uh you
know the thing here right so when you
search on Port on on the attack website
it gave you a number of techniques some
of which are totally absurdly uh
unrelated like Port knocking in this
case is not related right but you have
to know that right so otherwise you will
be
confused so you then go and repeat this
procedure so uh so you basically uh do
this process
again and again on all the verbs so here
you will see that uh after you finish
you will recognize previlege
escalation uh exploitation of privilege
uh exploitation for privilege escalation
was the technique also it executed so
therefore it's a command. exe so it's a
command line interface it also does
Discovery by doing whoi so there is a
system owner user Discovery technique it
also creates persistence by scheduled
task so scheduling task schedule task is
the
technique so command and control uh was
used here and with a standard non-
application layer protocol and
uncommonly used Port so after this only
this six lines you find three tactics
and at least U you know six seven
different techniques being used right so
this is uh how you have done it now with
don't have time to do this exercise in
class so I will I'll ask you to do this
uh and we'll ask you about it tomorrow
there is a particular finished
report by cyber reason called Cobalt
Kitty report there are two PDF files
here one already highlights the verbs
and the other actually and and and has
tactic hints so one version of the PDF
has tactic hints which can help you and
the other one is highlights only which
highlights the verbs you have to know
the tactics but you also have find the
techniques for each of these right and
once you have done that uh you actually
can uh compare the results with your
friends uh and uh uh we'll we'll discuss
this in the next class uh and see how
you do it okay and this will be similar
problem will be your second homework so
you better try to do it
right okay
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
