Why did Xi Jinping reject large-scale economic stimulus?

Spotlight on China
2K followers
61 Video Views·Jul 26, 2024
On July 23, Bloomberg reported that China's top leader, Xi Jinping, rejected the large-scale stimulus package proposed by analysts, preferring to avoid the past boom and bust cycles.
On July 23, Bloomberg reported that China's top leader, Xi Jinping, rejected the large-scale
stimulus package proposed by analysts, preferring to avoid the past boom-and-bust cycles. During
Xi's first decade in power, policymakers frequently interacted with foreign economists and analysts.
But such exchanges have now become infrequent and less significant. Stephen Roach,
former Asia Chairman of Morgan Stanley, said Xi Jinping is now China's chief economist.
Roach attended a recent meeting with senior officials in Beijing, noting Xi's focus on
creating advanced industries to boost economic growth while stabilizing the sluggish real
estate market. During the recent third plenary session, Xi emphasized his long-term strategy,
declining economists' recommendations to increase consumer confidence and rebalance the economy.
Bloomberg pointed out that this indicates a difference in opinion between Xi and market
economists. Beijing is investing in innovations such as electric vehicles and solar panels,
while economists argue that improved social safety nets are necessary to boost consumer spending.
Xi, however, refuses to use direct relief to stimulate consumption,
maintaining his stance against large-scale stimulus. China's leaders also prioritize
national security, investing $47.5 billion in a chip fund to ensure leading companies
can produce cutting-edge semiconductors, despite U.S. supply restrictions.
Neil Thomas from the Asia Society Policy Institute pointed out that Xi Jinping believes
the pro-market policies in place when he came to power in 2012 led to issues such as debt-fueled
growth. This growing detachment from investors' concerns could result in policies that do not
effectively improve economic conditions. In his bid for a third term in 2022,
Xi appointed loyalists to key decision-making roles, displacing a cohort of trained economists
such as former Premier Li Keqiang. Harvard-educated advisor Liu He was also compelled to retire,
and it remains uncertain how his successor, He Lifeng, will impact policy.
China's reduced engagement with foreign experts is part of a broader trend of decreased openness
amidst growing U.S. tensions. The government has also refrained from releasing unfavorable
economic data and warned analysts against publishing negative assessments, including
the use of terms like deflation. Premier Li Keqiang, who traditionally holds the second
highest position in the Chinese government with a focus on economic matters, has therefore changed
his approach by conducting seminars with domestic economists while excluding foreign experts.
In March, Li broke from the 30-year tradition of annual press conferences for premiers,
signaling that the focus should now be on Xi Jinping.
