Communist China Spies on Americans, Engages in Transnational Repression: Panel Discussion

Falun Dafa Information Center
4.3K followers
894 Video Views·Jul 26, 2024
The Department of Justice has unsealed an indictment surrounding an alleged Chinese spy in Florida who has been feeding the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) intelligence for 12 years.
Levi Browde, executive director of the Falun Dafa Information Center, joins retired Brig. Gen. Robert Spalding, former U.S. defense official and attaché to China, on NTD to discuss how the CCP is infiltrating every sphere of American life and targeting all dissidents, including practitioners of Falun Gong.
To discuss this case and the broader issue of Chinese espionage, earlier we spoke with
General Robert Spalding, former senior defense official and defense attache to China in Beijing,
and Levi Braude, executive director of the Falun Dafa Information Center.
General Spalding, Levi Braude, thank you both so much for joining us. Levi, I want to start with
you. The DOJ just unsealed an indictment about an alleged Chinese spy in Florida yesterday.
Now, according to court filings, he was employed by Chinese intelligence in Wuhan for over 12 years.
Just how significant is this case? Well, I think the case is significant because it exhibits that
the CCP's target everyday American citizens and residents. We tend to think of spies going after
other government workers or other spies, and really this shows how the priority that the
CCP places on going after any voice, even if they're sort of everyday citizens or residents,
that is countering the CCP narrative or exposing them on the world stage. So I think it's very
important from that standpoint, but I would also caution that this is a very tiny tip of a very
large iceberg. This is just one case. There are so many other cases out there that we're probably
missing. And General, this was a telecom worker in Florida. Now, you've been warning for years
about the dangers of telecoms, especially when it comes to 5G. How does that play into the way
the Chinese regime conducts espionage, especially overseas? Well, I think people are aware of,
you know, being able to plant certain things in the network to be able to extract data. That's why
there's a big push to get rid of Huawei. But it also extends to the employees. This is not the
time that a Chinese employee, it's happened in Europe as well, has used the telecom resources
to extract data that the Chinese Communist Party wants. And I think most companies aren't aware
that the Chinese Communist Party does a good job of indoctrinating the population. They also have
laws that say that you have to support espionage by law. They will put pressure on family members.
So if you have a Chinese national working in your company, you might think, oh, this is a
great person. They're friendly. But at the same time, they have been taught and trained and they
are pressured to do things that the Chinese Communist Party wants them to do. And Levi,
you actually recently published a piece in The Diplomat emphasizing the internal CCP treatment
when it comes to Falun Gong. Now, did they say anything relevant to this case?
Yeah. I mean, since the very beginning, they've been trying to marginalize Falun Gong and convince
the West, among other things, that it's a tiny little group, that it's been crushed. It's not
an issue. In this article we published in The Diplomat, we primarily looked at the CCP's own
words, linked internal speeches, even stuff they've made publicly available on government
websites and other sources. And we find indeed, again, looking at their own words, that the
opposite is true. Falun Gong for the last 25 years has remained a very top priority to control
the population, to maintain political power, and really retain ideological supremacy. And so I
think that if you look at the substance of what this person did, this is exactly what some of the
documents, including documents from his home province, were instructing him to do. Things
like in-depth investigations, collect intelligence about Falun Gong, and people are supportive of
Falun Gong. So he is conducting actions that are precisely what these leaked documents are
instructing people like him to do. In general, how does how Beijing's
treatment of Falun Gong point to the larger issue of, say, CCP spies and the illicit activities
they do in America? How bad is that situation? Well, it's just as bad as the United States
government allows it to be. So, you know, they're integrated with our companies, they're integrated
in our university system, they are buying property all around the country. And so ultimately,
what happened after the end of the Cold War is that a lot of the controls that we had on the
political process for damaging our political independence and sovereignty, all those
controls were taken off. And so the Chinese Communist Party, as an organization, really
functions very similar to the Soviet Union functioned. And so it is doing, trying to do
the same things that the Soviet Union was doing, which is undermining our republic.
Only now they're fully connected into our society in a way that Soviet Union never had,
and there's new tools like social media, and the internet, and global capital flows that
they leverage. You know, you look at the election that's going on right now, a lot of those donations
because of the way our election system works, a lot of those donations could very well be coming
from Chinese nationals. And so this is a big challenge for us. On that note, both of you are
very knowledgeable about the long arm of Beijing. Given that, General, what is the most effective or
worrisome aspect to you of Beijing's transnational repression?
Well, I think just the fact that we don't understand it, and we don't realize that.
So the Chinese Communist Party has worked very hard to get control over the diaspora.
And so it's not just the people that live within the geographic boundaries of China that we have
to worry about. They have controlled media, they've controlled social media,
using intimidation and force in China on family members to really
camp down on Chinese nationals that are operating outside the country. And that
makes them all, unfortunately, it's sad to say, but it makes them all a vulnerability for
our own political independence and sovereignty.
And Levi, what about you? What is the most worrisome aspect to you of
Beijing's transnational repression?
I think it's their ability to shape our thoughts, or at the very least, control our behavior.
I know, again, typically you think of hostile foreign nations, and we're worried about
either kinetic war, we're worried about certainly capturing our industries,
influencing our government policies. And that's certainly a problem with the CCP
for the reasons that the General just outlined. But I think what's perhaps more insidious,
and in the long term, more dangerous, is their ability to convince our academia, our media,
our policymakers of the narratives that they want to shape, and using social media,
even bridging into our mainstream media. And I think the CCP, as the General sort of laid out,
their goal is really to take down the U.S., I think, without firing a shot. And a cornerstone
of that is making sure they can influence and manipulate how we think about issues they care
about. And they're surprisingly and horrifically effective at that.
And based on that, Levi, give us some specific examples that lead you to that conclusion.
Well, I think the Falun Gong community is a prime example. I mean, if you just look
back in China, the Chinese government itself was praising Falun Gong for its good health,
its strong ethics, and so forth. Fast forward two years later, and suddenly it's a pariah,
it's public enemy number one. It decided to rewrite history because Falun Gong got too popular.
Well, it didn't, as the General just mentioned, it didn't stop at China's borders. And so for the
last 25 years, they've been somewhat successful at rewriting the Falun Gong narrative, the Falun
Gong history on an international stage, convincing our academia, our media, and everybody about
false CCP propaganda narratives. And they've done a very good job at tuning those to the
hot button issues of the United States, so that even our media sometimes pick it up.
So I think the Falun Gong story, what it was back in the 90s, what it is now,
both in China and around the world, is a perfect example of how the CCP can indeed
change and shape a narrative globally. On that note, General, when you were the
attaché to Beijing, you actually witnessed firsthand this transnational repression
on Falun Gong on U.S. soil. Tell us about that. Yes, during Trump's first meeting with Xi in
Mar-a-Lago, I accompanied General Fang Fanghui to Mar-a-Lago. I was there with him on our plane
ride back to New York to change planes to fly to Beijing. I happened to be sitting with some
Chinese nationals that looked like they had bandages on and bruises and scrapes. I started
talking to them in Chinese, asking what happened. They said the embassy people had come and beat
them up as they were trying to protest Xi being in Mar-a-Lago. This is not the first time I'd
seen this. I've actually seen it prior when Xi had come to visit President Biden in Washington,
D.C. This is a big problem. Further to the point of how successful the Chinese Communist Party has
been, they've convinced our entire media that the Falun Gong is some dangerous cult. I think
to the point of being able to control the narratives within our own society, not only
are they physically harassing and beating people, but they're affecting our own media.
It's also the same thing with Taiwan. We use this term reunification as if Taiwan was ever a part
of China. Again, the media has adopted China's words rather than recognizing, no, it's unification,
it's unilateral unification without their desire. This ability to change the way we
say things is very important because the way you say things is the way you think. This is very
dangerous for our political independence and sovereignty. We need to get that influence
out of our country. Given what's at stake here that you both just laid out, Levi,
what can people do about this? First of all, I think it's important that the government and
authority figures speak out. America is the great marketplace of ideas, but if the CCP is the only
one bringing a bunch of sour apples to the market and we don't provide a fresh, honest alternative,
they're going to adopt that. That's what people are going to buy. I think that's exactly what
the general is talking about. Just this last week, it was the somber anniversary,
the 25th anniversary of when the persecution started. We had the State Department making
statements supporting Falun Gong. There are many other voices in Congress. That's important because
those voices need to weigh in on this marketplace. There's struggle over the terminology that the
general talked about and the broader ideas that come from that. Our government, our leaders need
to weigh in because if they're absent from that, the CCP is going to control the narrative.
I think that's the first thing. The second thing is we have something called the Falun Gong
Protection Act, which has just passed by the House and it's before the Senate. Now, this is
a piece of legislation that doles out real punishment. We need to get this through the
Senate, get it onto the President's desk to sign, so that we can actually have the legal authority
to the extent that we can via sanctions, asset blocking, things of that nature,
go after high-level, if necessary, high-level government officials, military leaders in China
that are actively persecuting Falun Gong, going after the diaspora here and really being behind
the transnational oppression that's affecting our entire country.
General, what steps would you like to see implemented to counter this
transnational oppression and elicit spying by Beijing on U.S. soil?
Recognize, again, we're in a competition for ideas and how things are said are so important.
The Chinese Communist Party has access to Chinese language media here. They have things like TikTok.
Those things need to be eliminated. We actually need to bring back the U.S.
Information Agency that used to do public diplomacy, so that we have an
amplified voice, not only domestically, but internationally. We need to get the American
message out there. Today, we're a share of what we were during the first Cold War.
We're in the second Cold War, and it's a digital Cold War. It's an information war,
and it's using all the tools of Silicon Valley and the media. We need to understand those tools.
Our political parties are actually well adapted to that environment because they fight each other.
What they need to realize is the parties that are really the enemy is the Chinese Communist Party.
They need to bring some of those tools into how the United States shapes its policy with regard
to information warfare. The Chinese Communist Party is waging information warfare, psychological
warfare on a global scale because of the tools that Silicon Valley and modern technology has
brought to this new digital Cold War. General Spalding, Levi Browdy,
thank you both so much for joining us. Thank you.
