Effects of AGING? 3 Vintages of HAUT BRION!

Fan Wine Cellar
14 followers
In this video, we explore the effects of aging on great wines, specifically Château Haut-Brion, which is a First Growth Bordeaux.
#wineculture, #fanwinecellar
What happens when you age a wine?
And how does an older wine differ from a younger wine?
You can really taste the difference.
In this episode of Our Poor Decisions,
we're diving into a subject
that seems to divide the world of wine nerds
more than anything, aging.
We'll take a look at three different vintages
of one of the world's greatest red wines.
It's the best bottle that we've had on this show so far.
Hope Brium, 2019, 2005, and 1990,
and compare the wines to each other
and discuss what causes the wine
to change so much over time.
This seems pretty nerdy to me.
First of all, there's nothing wrong with being a nerd.
And secondly, I think this is
what wine collecting is all about.
I guess you did build this wine room for a reason.
B, I'm telling you, when you have a great wine
at the perfect age, it's like heaven in a glass.
But not all wine is made for aging, right?
No, not at all.
I'd say, in fact, 98% of all wine
is designed to be consumed right away.
But when you get those very great wines,
and I'm talking about the top wines around the world,
they can age 20, 30, maybe 50 years.
Wow, and so what makes a wine worthy of aging?
And let me guess, you have some information
for our viewers about it?
Maybe.
Wine collectors who store and age wine
do so primarily for two reasons.
First reason is to soften the tannins.
The tannins in wines are that most people experience
as dryness or astringency,
which are more tactile sensations in the mouth than flavors.
It is so much softer.
I think the tannin, the acidity,
they have mellowed each other out a little bit.
And the second reason for aging
is that some wines develop tertiary flavors
that only occur in older wines.
This one's stinky, I think.
And examples of these flavors include leather,
truffle, cedar, tobacco, and earth.
These are different than secondary flavors
that winemakers can achieve during a winemaking process,
such as vanilla, toast, and oak.
How do you feel about me putting these in a cellar
to age for a couple years?
Babe, you are so funny.
Obviously, I'm just giving you a hard time,
but on a serious note,
I'm really, really excited for this experiment today.
I'm so glad to hear that,
because Opryon is probably one of the greatest wines
in the world,
and this is gonna be a really unique experiment.
Opryon is one of the most famous Chateaux in Bordeaux,
and one of the original four Chateaux
considered first growth in the 1855 classification.
Opryon is the only red wine outside of Médoc
included in that classification.
And it was so famous and well-known
that the Syndicate of Courtiers
just couldn't exclude it from the list
that Napoleon III had requested,
and the Chateau was rightfully listed
among the best of the best,
the premier Grand Cru.
Today, Opryon and its sister property, La Mission Opryon,
are completely surrounded by the suburbs
of the city of Bordeaux,
as you can see from this Google Maps satellite photo.
For a reference point,
the Opryon property is about 51 hectares,
or about 219 acres.
48 hectares are planted with red grapes,
45% Marlot,
44% Cabernet Sauvignon,
10% Cabernet Franc,
and 1% Petit Bordeaux.
And the other three hectares are planted
with mostly Sauvignon and Sauvignon Blanc,
with a tiny bit of Sauvignon Gris.
So, Opryon is actually located
right in the middle of the city of Bordeaux.
Yeah, it's really unusual.
And you know what else is really unusual
about the history of Opryon?
What?
So, remember when we talked about Margot
being purchased by a Greek tycoon in the 70s?
Yeah.
Well, Clarence Dillon, an American investment banker,
purchased Opryon in 1935 at the height of the Depression,
and really turned it all around.
And his company, Domaine Clarence Dillon,
which is what it's called today,
purchased La Mission Opryon
and a number of other properties in 1983,
and he continues to run it today.
Is that the same Clarence Dillon
who ran the investment bank Dillon Reading Company,
and then he purchased Dodge in 1925,
and then merged it with Chrysler two years later,
making Chrysler one of the big three in Detroit?
You know about him?
I'm just messing with you.
I read your notes.
Anyways, let's take a closer look
at the three bottles we're trying today.
Not only are we trying arguably
one of the greatest red wines in the world,
we're specifically looking at the effects of aging wine.
Let's start with the 2019 vintage,
which was, by all accounts,
a very good vintage for Opryon and Bordeaux in general.
The Robert Parker's Wine Advocate
gave the wine 98 points,
calling it full-bodied, rich, and fleshy.
The 2005 Opryon is considered by many
to be one of the best wines of the great Bordeaux vintage.
It received 100 points by multiple wine critics,
including Robert Parker.
Last, but certainly not least,
we're trying the 1990 vintage of Opryon.
After more than 30 years of aging,
how will this wine come across compared to the other two?
There is no doubt the 1990 Opryon
is considered one of the great vintages.
Does it opening up a 2019 Opryon
basically go against all of your principles?
Absolutely.
So why are we doing it again?
Well, it's all about the experiment.
We're gonna take a look at what happens when wine ages.
And what are your expectations for the 2019 vintage?
Bea, I'm a little concerned
that the wine may not even be drinkable at this point.
Something we like to do at our show
is to give our wines a little bit time
to open up in the decanter.
In this case, we'll let the wines breathe
for about an hour and a half before we try them.
We also leave the decanters out in room temperature
for maybe 15 minutes before drinking the wine,
just to bring the temperature up five to seven degrees.
Welcome back, Stacey.
Thanks for being here.
Thanks for having me.
Stacey, I gotta tell you, I love this experiment.
It's kind of exciting.
Not only do we have three bottles
of arguably one of the greatest wines in the world,
but we get to see what happens
over basically 30 years of aging.
I'm excited to see what the hype is all about, about aging.
Okay.
We're gonna bring her down our little nerd tunnel together.
All right.
Yeah, this'll be good.
What makes great wine age well?
The big ones you talk about are acidity.
RS, or residual sugar, helps a wine age.
Both of those are really great, and tannins.
So any of those three things in a bottle of wine
is gonna help a wine age well.
All right, so let's start with the color of these wines,
because right off the bat,
I'm noticing that the 90 has got more orange tones.
In the 19, it's really pretty pink.
So one of the things that happens when wine ages
is all of the things that make color
bind together with tannins, with the flavor molecules,
and they kind of fall out of suspension.
So as the wine ages,
we're definitely seeing that progression.
So we have the 19 almost like as a starting point.
Is it even drinkable at this point?
I do think that it is not gonna be a great representation
of what this wine is like, and its peak.
And I agree with that.
All right, well, let's just dive in
and see if we can drink the 19 or not.
I'm thinking I'm not gonna have a problem with it, but.
I don't think I'm gonna complain,
but I think my enjoyment's gonna get better
as we move to the right.
Give it a sniff.
It's got a great nose.
I mean, this is like, it's got tons of flavor in here.
A lot of primary fruit.
It doesn't, it's certainly, you can almost smell the acidity.
Is that even a thing?
Oh, absolutely.
Okay.
So for me, that's why tart cranberry is the smell.
I love vodka cranberry, so.
Okay, no complaints.
Cheers.
Let's try this.
It's a little sour, right?
I think that's that acidity, yeah.
I gotta tell you, this is a lot better than what I thought.
It's still a great wine.
And it also is a huge portion of Merlot,
which is so drinkable early.
And it's so pretty and approachable up front
with riper fruits and plummy kind of notes, floral things.
You can't age a wine that's not balanced from the beginning.
For sure.
And I think this wine is just terrific,
and it's got great balance right now.
100%.
I learned something today that I didn't expect to learn.
This tastes great.
Next up, 2005.
Now we've had a lot of 2005s and-
We've been very lucky to taste that vintage.
It's a great year.
The nose is very different.
That I think is the biggest show
that the age has happened for these two.
The nose on the 05 is very different.
I think let's try it.
Okay, let's give it a shot.
Okay, here we go.
You can really taste the difference.
It is so much softer.
I think the tannin, the acidity,
they have mellowed each other out a little bit.
There it is.
He's still tasting.
This is so good.
It is so good.
Now-
Oh, wow.
But there's also a lot less fruit.
There is a lot less fruit.
So fruit is one of the first things that drops out.
It transforms.
That's how we get some of those tertiary aromas
instead of primary aromas.
Let's try it.
Is it time?
I think it might be.
These two, the 19 and the 05s are different,
don't get me wrong.
Oh, yes.
But this is completely different.
Completely different.
This one's stinky, I think.
Oh, yeah, it's stinky a little bit.
Those are your tertiary aromas, yes.
Right?
Like mushroomy, truffle-y, forest flurry,
kind of like rotting, well, maybe not rotting
isn't a pleasant aroma.
That's what I'm talking about.
Yum!
Yeah, not the most pleasant to sound,
but like forest floor or like that, you know,
you're in the forest and you turn over
the first level of dirt.
You move the leaves and there's that like
real rustic, warm earth kind of smell.
All right, let's try the 1990.
I am so excited about this.
This one probably deserves cheers.
So Bea, remember when I said, have it in a glass?
Yeah.
This is a great wine at the perfect age.
And I know that opium is kind of like the 89
is the year for opium, right?
89 was the year.
And so 90 came afterward.
It's kind of hard to follow up.
So how come you didn't get our viewers the 89 bottle?
I don't have any in my cellar, but I'm working on that.
I'm going to go out on a limb here.
We've had a lot of great wines, right?
On this show, we've tried Screamin' Eagle.
We've tried Margaux.
We've tried Lafitte, we've tried Moton.
The 1990 opium is the best bottle
that we've had on this show so far.
Should I just start drinking beer for 15 years
and let everything age?
Or how do you think about this?
Don't go crazy.
So in conclusion, I feel like this experiment
has honestly taught me a lot.
I wasn't really sure if I understood the hype about aging,
but after trying these three wines,
gradually increasing with age,
I can definitely say that I understand the hype of aging.
It's been fun to taste them.
Thank you so much.
Yeah, the 19 was shocking to me,
but the 1990, oh my gosh, I feel so lucky
to drink a bottle of wine like that.
It's just, it's stunning.
What was your favorite and what'd you take away from it?
Well, I can appreciate each bottle for what it is.
I think that the 90, it was most interesting for me to try.
I love that.
I mean, the 90 blows me away.
It's just stellar.
I don't know that I've legitimately tasted a better wine.
Yeah, 90 is just that good, guys.
So cheers.
Jeff, are you gonna come in here and cheers with us?
And I assume the 90 is the favorite?
Absolutely.
Oh my gosh, absolutely.
All right.
Cheers, everyone.
Cheers.
Thanks for watching.
