Why Risk It? No Dragon Rescue! NASA Starliner to Coming Back With Astronauts...

GREAT SPACEX
1K followers
40 Video Views·Jul 11, 2024
exciting news NASA has officially
confirmed star liner's return plan after
significant controversy however the
Intriguing detail lies in NASA's
implications regarding Dragon
highlighting the continued importance of
spacex's spacecraft what decision has
NASA recently made regarding Starliner
and dragon join us as we delve into this
crucial update on today's episode of
great SpaceX hard to get it up and now
can't get it down this succinctly
captures Boeing Starliner current plight
following numerous delays in June due to
a helium leak and Thruster issues July
brought further disappointment with an
indefinite schedule amid mounting
frustration NASA convened a crucial
online meeting on July 10th to discuss
Starliner future particularly its return
plan this meeting yielded significant
insights first and foremost let's
address the burning question on
everyone's mind how will the two
astronauts return in a significant
Revelation the agency stated and and
then you know after that we've talked
about the beautiful thing about
commercial crew program is that we have
two two vehicles two different systems
that we could use to to return crew and
two vehicles and two different systems
perhaps you're as intrigued As I Am by
NASA's implication the vehicle in
question is likely spacex's dragon in
fact it can only be dragon as there are
current curently no other viable options
for NASA and Boeing to consider this
acknowledgement finally confirms what
the entire world suspected dragon is now
an essential part of the plan to bring
astronauts safely back but stay calm
because the AFF forementioned statement
does not confirm that Dragon will
definitely fly to rescue the Starliner
crew according to this statement Dragon
will only serve as a backup solution
officially added by NASA to be ready for
emergencies NASA clarified this point in
another statement St
so so we have a little bit more time to
go through the data and then make a
decision as to whether we need to do
anything different but the prime option
today is to return Butch and sunny on
Starliner they even confirmed uh there's
really been no discussion what sending
another Dragon uh to to rescue the
Starliner crew this indicates that while
NASA has considered Dragon they remain
committed to trusting their own system
so is this the right choice according to
NASA's recent updates they opted to
delay the return schedule to thoroughly
assess issues with Starliner however
their plans didn't unfold as expected
during discussions NASA officials
acknowledged that ground testing of the
reaction control system or RCS
propulsion at NASA's white sand test
facility in New Mexico failed to
replicate the conditions experienced by
the thrusters in Flight specifically
Steve Stitch NASA's commercial crew
program manager disclosed that Engineers
employed heaters in attempts to simulate
the thermal conditions encountered
during firing and sun exposure
ultimately he concluded um the
temperatures we've been able to achieve
are not quite what we would have hoped
for uh based on the flight data he added
that the structures on the Starliner
service module known as dog houses which
house the thrusters May retain more heat
than previously thought Engineers are
currently evaluating whether additional
tests will be necessary before shifting
Focus to modeling the Thruster
performance for the spacecraft's
departure it's worth noting that the RCs
thrusters are less intensively used for
station departure and deorbiting with
the actual deorbit burn performed by
separate larger thrusters this is
another setback for NASA and Boeing
earlier this month both parties decided
to indefinitely delay the schedule to
simulate the Starliner incident on the
ground this was intended to provide a
better understanding of star liner's
current issues and enable immediate
repair Solutions as well as better
preparation for the future unfortunately
this effort did not yield the expected
results but somehow they are still
confident that Starliner can return home
safely in the event of an emergency with
the problems highlighted there's no
reason at this time for me to believe
that and I think many people share my
concern about the return journey of the
two astronauts so if the decision
remains when will Starliner return in
NASA's latest update the agency said
NASA and Boeing continue working to
increase their understanding of the
Starliner spacecraft propulsion system
before the return of agency astronauts
Butch Wilmore and Sunni Williams to
Earth from the International Space
Station teams are conducting ground
tests at the agency's White Sands test
facility in New Mexico using a new
reaction control system Thruster
previously planned for use on a future
Starliner flight during that
teleconference Steve Stitch estimated I
think some of the data suggests
optimistically maybe it's by the end of
July Mark nappy Boeing's vice president
and Commercial crew program manager
highlighted ongoing efforts by Engineers
to address over 30 specific issues
related to both Thruster problems and
helium leaks with more than half already
resolved the remaining are slated for
completion by the end of next week
future tasks involve conducting
additional tests on flanges and seals
within the propulsion system to pinpoint
the root cause of helium leaks nappy
initially suggested that some seals
might be undersized and require
replacement on thrusters designated for
the upcoming Starliner Mission though he
later clarified this point during the
discussion regarding Mission completion
and return timing both parties
emphasized that it hinges on engineering
progress and the schedule of the Dragon
crew 9 Mission currently set for Mid
August with the International Space
Station facing capacity constraints
Starliner must then undock soon to
accommodate crew 9 thus any delay must
not exceed this deadline as we're now
Midway through July there's only half a
month until Steve stitches targeted date
and a month until the crew 9 schedule
this leaves NASA and the Boeing team
with limited time to resolve everything
they've even accelerated their efforts
to complete all tasks ahead of schedule
in case starlander cannot be repaired if
if necessary NASA will need to
coordinate with SpaceX to launch a
dragon for potential Starliner astronaut
rescue followed by the crew N9 Mission
such critical schedules require careful
Planning by NASA and preparation by
SpaceX for both the launch vehicle and
spacecraft what are your thoughts will
Starliner return as planned please
comment yes or no below to join the
discussion don't forget to like share
the video and subscribe to the channel
for more updates on SpaceX and the
Aerospace industry once the decisions
are finalized ized we'll await Boeing
and NASA's next steps now let's peer
into the future to see what lies ahead
for this spacecraft indeed the path
ahead promises to be fraught with
numerous challenges and intense
competition Starliner current
performance suggests it faces formidable
rivals in the field as mentioned earlier
following Starliner return SpaceX is
poised to launch its ninth crew resupply
mission SpaceX has already completed
nine official missions under NASA's
commercial commercial crew program along
with one demo Mission all within a span
of fewer than 5 years furthermore dragon
has successfully conducted four
additional private missions and 30 cargo
missions these figures underscore a
substantial disparity between the 2.6
billion Powerhouse and the $4.5 billion
dud looking ahead when NASA plans to
bring Starliner back spacex's Dragon
will embark on a significant Mission
Polaris Dawn this challenging endeavor
that involves a space walk will once
again highlight dragon's superiority
over Starliner if the demo crew mission
encounters delays it's uncertain when
Starliner could undertake a similar
Mission possibly extending into the next
decade or Beyond looking forward to
early next year dragon is scheduled to
launch the crew 10 Mission roughly
coinciding with Starliner 1 this stark
contrast highlights the significant Gap
that has emerged in just a few short
years I'm confident crew 10 launch
before Starliner 1 and if you agree
please comment 10 below when compared to
SpaceX Boeing's Starliner faces daunting
odds even in comparison to other
competitors Starliner doesn't
demonstrate a clear path to Victory I
want to highlight Dreamchaser the new
space plane from Sierra space despite
not having launched yet this doesn't
diminish its potential compared to
Starliner while Starliner has faced
numerous developmental challenges
leading to schedule delays Dreamchaser
has shown promising test results its
current hurdle lies in coordinating with
its launch vehicle the Ula Vulcan
ultimately the true assessment of
superiority will come after its official
flight personally I believe Dreamchaser
could outperform Starliner if Boeing
doesn't resolve its issues properly this
is the future Boeing and its spacecraft
face they've entered a competitive race
and must now Forge ahead much hinges on
the outcome of the cft-1 mission with
the decision made we await developments
in the coming weeks above all I hope
both astronauts return safely after what
promises to be a tramatic journey aboard
the Boeing spacecraft well folks that's
about it for today's episode thank you
so much for tuning in and as always this
has been Kevin from great SpaceX until
next time keep looking up
