„Solange die Welt glauben kann, dass die Palästinenser für immer staatenlose Flüchtlinge sind, weil ihnen ein sogenanntes Kolonialreich von den Juden aufgezwungen wurde, ist ihnen das Mitleid der Welt sicher. Das war ihre Erfolgsgeschichte.
Nach dem Angriff der Hamas-Terroristen auf Israel am 7. Oktober 2023 wurden viele von uns zum ersten Mal auf das UNRWA, das Hilfswerk der Vereinten Nationen für palästinensische Flüchtlinge, aufmerksam. Es erhält jedes Jahr Hunderte Millionen Dollar von den USA und Deutschland.
„In den letzten 75 Jahren hat es sich zu einer Organisation entwickelt, die sich für das palästinensische Volk einsetzt. Sie ist ein Lehrbeispiel dafür, wie ein Kunde einen Dienstleister unter seine Kontrolle bringen kann. Da die Organisation das Siegel der Vereinten Nationen trägt, hat sie den Anschein von Neutralität und Integrität“, sagt Asaf Romirowsky, Nahost-Historiker und Co-Autor des Buches „Religion, Politics, and the Origins of Palestine Refugee Relief“.
Das 1949 gegründete UNRWA war als zeitlich begrenzte Organisation gedacht. Wie wurde sie zu einer der größten und teuersten UN-Organisationen? Und wie kommt es, dass sich die Zahl der palästinensischen Flüchtlinge nach Angaben der UNRWA versiebenfacht hat, während praktisch alle anderen Flüchtlinge, die nach dem Zweiten Weltkrieg aufgenommen wurden, umgesiedelt wurden?
Um das herauszufinden, habe ich mich mit Romirowsky, dem Geschäftsführer von Scholars for Peace in the Middle East, zusammengesetzt.
"Es ist erwiesen, dass das UNRWA die Hamas unterstützt. Die Tatsache, dass Hamas-Server in ihrem Hauptquartier waren, die Tatsache, dass Mitarbeiter zu den Attentätern vom 7. Oktober gehörten: Das UNRWA ist keine legitime Organisation mehr, meiner Meinung nach war sie es nie. Für den Frieden ist sie eher ein Hindernis als eine Lösung“, sagt Romirowsky.
„Ich glaube, dass es eine Diskrepanz gibt – und das haben wir in den USA und in Europa schon lange beobachtet – zwischen der Realität vor Ort und dem, was notwendig ist, um Frieden zu schaffen. Ich denke, Frieden ist ein Ziel und sollte das Ziel sein. Aber [...] es muss eine gegenseitige Anerkennung geben. Man hat sich geweigert, das Existenzrecht Israels als jüdischer Staat zu anzuerkennen.“
Die in diesem Video geäußerten Ansichten sind die des Moderators und des Gastes und geben nicht zwangsläufig die Meinung von der Epoch Times wieder.
💎 Spenden für unsere Arbeit an: 👉 Per Paypal und über Kredit: http://bit.ly/SpendenEpochTimesDeutsch 👉 Per Banküberweisung: Epoch Times Europe GmbH IBAN: DE 2110 0700 2405 2550 5400 BIC/SWIFT: DEUTDEDBBER Verwendungszweck: Spenden für EpochTV Vielen Dank! ________________________________________________________________
Wir freuen uns über rege Diskussionen, bitte achten Sie dabei auf eine angemessene Umgangsform! Beleidigungen sind nicht erwünscht. Danke.
Gerne dürfen Sie unsere Videolinks teilen, in Playlists oder auf Ihrer Homepage einbetten. Bitte respektieren Sie unsere Urheberrechte. Danke sehr. ________________________________________________________________
Many people assume that Israel took people's land away to have a right to it.
This is the narrative that caused all the problems. How do you respond to that?
The assumption that Israel has stolen the land or that it has exploited the local population is not true.
There was already a state in the 1930s.
Historically, there has always been a Jewish presence in the land.
You can look at the proposals for the division of the land, which were made before the independence war of 1940.
Even before that, until the beginning of the 20th century, the Jewish community was always ready to divide the land.
The Arabs, however, refused.
Until the partition of 1947, when there was a clear rejection of the ideology that said that there could be no coexistence.
The historical tenor in the Arab-Palestinian narrative still exists today, that this rejection always dominated.
Rejection at any time and at any opportunity for talks about a peace process, whether pre-state or post-state.
That was the actual drive of the Arab-Israeli wars.
The argument was, and this is important for your viewers to understand, that every country that was Muslim is Muslim in perpetuity.
If today's state of Israel was a Muslim country at the time of the Muslim expansion,
then the Arab-Palestinian perspective is that Jews are occupying, quote-unquote, land that is Muslim land.
The narrative of the occupation was a driving force for the Palestinian society and is predominantly psychological.
And I would say it is also predominantly psychological.
If you look closely at the Palestinian identity, I would say that at least 90% of the Arab-Palestinian identity is rooted in anti-Semitism.
There is no detached identity that is entangled and that will allow for coexistence.
So UNRWA takes care of the entire education of the Palestinians?
Primary school education.
Yes, that's right. Primary school education.
So what was astonishing looking at the news in this Telegram group was that many people supported the events of October 7th.
How do you explain that?
UNRWA makes no distinction in the background checks.
So if you are a Hamas member at night and a UNRWA teacher during the day, then the kind of education you teach is Hamas education.
If you investigate, and this is something that the US Congress is doing,
they are analyzing what is being distributed in the Arabic-Palestinian textbooks.
The Mer Turetum is constantly glorified.
There is also the message that Jews come from pigs and monkeys.
There are no maps of Israel.
There is the idea of from the river to the sea and the destruction of the Jews and everything should be Palestinian.
Coexistence plays no role at all.
During the Oslo Peace Accords in the 1990s, it was demanded that Israel and the Palestinian society should change their textbooks.
The Israeli textbooks were already pro-peace, but there was no trace of it in the Palestinian textbooks.
There was no debate about coexistence in general.
This is exactly what we have been fighting for the last 22 years.
Here in the USA and in Europe, we have observed the discrepancy between reality on the ground and what would be necessary for peace.
Peace should be the goal, but there must be mutual recognition.
Israel's right to exist as a Jewish state is being reluctantly rejected.
Arab-Palestinian propaganda and Palestinian propaganda in general dominate every conversation about the history of Israel,
the origin of Israel and the history of the Arab-Israeli wars.
The argument is simplified and broken down to a victim-taker mentality.
The Arab-Israeli conflict is presented as a binary issue.
I find this to be misleading and an injustice for the entire region, which is historically, theologically and culturally rich and where everything is intertwined.
You have to understand who the actors in the region are, what they are trying to achieve and what is actually happening on the ground.
A few years ago, when the Abraham Act came into effect, it marked a normalization between Israel and its Arab neighbors.
This was very significant, but it hardly made a difference to the debates in the USA,
which view the Arab-Israeli conflict and the Israeli-Palestinian relations solely through the lens of the boycott movement.
This is the only lens through which they can understand the topic, and this is insincere.
Not all streets have to go through Ramallah.
Especially in the Gulf states, they told their Palestinian brothers,
we are not always in agreement with Israel, but we can have peace,
work together economically, exchange ideas and cooperate.
They even recommend to their Palestinian brothers to try this as well.
But of course, this was rejected.
In Clinton's memoirs, there is a conversation between Yassir Arafat and Bill Clinton towards the end of his term.
Clinton argued that he devoted eight years of his presidency to the attempt to create peace between Israelis and Palestinians.
Arafat said to Clinton, Mr. President, you are the greatest president the world has ever seen.
Clinton's answer was, no, I am a failure, and you made me a failure.
Arafat said to Clinton, Mr. President, you are the greatest president the world has ever seen, etc. etc.
This was because the Palestinians, as the famous quote says, never miss an opportunity.
They were simply afraid to go through with the matter, because this would affect their central position.
The UNRWA must maintain the symbolism of the Palestinian stateless refugee society.
As long as the world can believe that Palestinians are eternally stateless refugees,
because they were forced into a so-called colonial empire by the Jews,
they are sure of the compassion of the world.
This has been their success story.
I don't believe that the UNRWA can be reformed. The UNRWA must be dissolved.
You have to wean the Palestinian society from the UNRWA.
The UNRWA acts like a shadow government.
It is a big black hole for all education, medicine and social services and other interests.
We have to break the monopoly so that it becomes transparent where our money flows.
Up to the freezing of money by Trump, it was about 400 million dollars in tax money from the USA.
There are alternatives.
I would start by checking the UNICEF, the WHO or other UN organizations to break the monopoly.
You have to carry out a demand analysis.
The UNRWA is not only active in the Gaza Strip, but also in Lebanon,
in Jordan and in the Palestinian areas, in Judea and Samaria in West Jordan.
The UNRWA has many functions.
After this demand analysis, you could actually get to the point where you say,
this is what the demand looks like and the following has to happen.
The fact that Hamas servers were in their headquarters.
The fact that employees belonged to the perpetrators of the attacks on 7 October.
UNRWA is no longer a legitimate organization.
In my opinion, it was never.
For peace, it is more of an obstacle than a solution.