50,000 women. 30 years of follow-up. The results of a new study are in: learn the truth about how your protein intake will affect your long-term health. What kind of protein should you consume? How much? And what difference will it really make on longevity?
In Episode #318, I’m unpacking the results from the new study in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, “Dietary protein intake in midlife in relation to healthy aging - results from prospective Nurses' Health Study cohort”. This new study from researchers at Harvard University and Tufts University has been regularly misinterpreted online, and in this episode, I’ll set the facts straight.
We cover: Introduction to Protein and Longevity (00:00) Study Overview and Methodology (01:24) Key Findings on Protein Sources (05:33) Lane Norton's Review and Critique (06:38) Analysis of Different Protein Types (10:02) Practical Recommendations for Protein Intake (18:47) Conclusion and Final Thoughts (22:09)
If you have any additional questions you would like answered in the future, let me know in the comments.
The best way to support the show is to use the products and services offered by our sponsors. To check them out and enjoy great savings, visit theproof.com/friends.
Enjoy, friends. Simon
This episode is brought to you by:
BON CHARGE Enhance skin health, increase collagen production, and reverse sun damage with BON CHARGE, my choice of low-level light therapy. Holistic, evidence-based, premium products for healthier skin. Get started at http://boncharge.com/ and use code THEPROOF for a 15% discount.
Momentous My go-to supplement brand for protein and creatine is Momentous. Get 36% off subscriptions, and 20% off one-off purchases, by using the code LIVINGPROOF at checkout at livemomentous.com
Eimele Eimele Essential 8 is a comprehensive multivitamin that is scientifically formulated to complement your plant-rich diet, increase and sustain your energy, and support the immune system, as well as heart and brain health. Head to http://eimele.com/ and use code SIMON at checkout for 10% off your first order.
38TERA Consider 38TERA's DMN-01 prebiotic supplement https://38tera.com/ a daily multivitamin for your gut. Formulated by yours truly and gastroenterologist Dr Will Bulsiewicz. Use code THEPROOF for a discount at checkout.
WHOOP Whoop, the most advanced fitness and health wearable available. Your personalised fitness and health coach to recover faster, sleep better, and train smarter. Claim your first month free on join.whoop.com/simon
Want to support the show? The best way to support the show is to use the products and services offered by our sponsors. To check them out, and enjoy great savings, visit http://theproof.com/friends. You can also show your support by leaving a review on the Apple Podcast app and/or sharing your favourite episodes with your friends and family.
What if I told you the type of protein you eat
could have a profound impact
on your risk of chronic disease, physical function,
and mental health as you age?
Today, we're diving into a brand new study
looking at protein and longevity,
or healthy aging as the researchers put it,
with the aim of helping you
make evidence-based protein choices
that help you get into your 60s, 70s, and 80s
in good physical condition,
fit and strong without chronic disease,
and with good mental health.
In addition to walking you through the study design
and what the researchers found,
I'm going to address Lane Norton's review of this study.
Many of you sent me his review on YouTube,
so I thought given the interest level,
and in the interest of spicing things up a little bit here,
I'll add some commentary along the way
where I agree with Lane and where I strongly disagree.
In fact, I'll even underscore a few places
where I believe Lane has either
completely misinterpreted the data
or accidentally overlooked it.
That's right, Lane, in this video, I'm calling you out.
To be clear, Lane's a legitimate science communicator.
He has a PhD, and my interactions,
both during podcasts and on email with him,
have been nothing but pleasant over the years and positive.
So I'm going to do my best to stick to the facts
and show you why I interpret the data
from this study differently to him.
I'll be coming after the claims, not the man.
I think it makes sense to fill you in on the study itself
before we go through Lane's central claims.
The study title was Dietary Protein Intake in Midlife
in Relation to Healthy Aging,
Results from the Prospective Nurses' Health Study Cohort.
It was published in the American Journal
of Clinical Nutrition a few months ago
by a group of nutrition scientists
from Tufts and Harvard University,
including previous guest on this show, Dr. Walter Willard.
It's an observational epidemiological study
called the Nurses' Health Study.
That followed almost 50,000 American-based women
for more than 30 years.
At the start of the study,
these women were on average aged in their late 40s.
So by the time this latest analysis was conducted,
the average age of the subjects still alive
was presumably late 70s.
The researchers were interested
in how midlife protein intake affected healthy aging
in this female cohort.
They assessed total animal, dairy, and plant protein intake
from food frequency questionnaires.
Importantly, these food frequency questionnaires
were validated against seven-day food records
and repeated every four years
throughout the study follow-up period.
Often when people claim
that food frequency questionnaires are bogus,
they are unaware that they can be validated
against weighed food records to ensure that they're reliable.
And while some studies
only conduct a food frequency questionnaire at baseline,
good long-term observational studies routinely conduct them
to ensure any changes to diet are captured.
In the scheme of things,
this was a good observational study.
This next bit is super important for you to understand.
Remember, the researchers wanted to see
how protein consumption total
and from these different sources affects healthy aging.
How were the researchers defining healthy aging?
Healthy aging was what's called a composite outcome
made up of four individual outcomes.
Number one, being free from 11 major chronic diseases.
These included cancer, type 2 diabetes,
myocardial infarction,
coronary artery bypass graft surgery,
or percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty,
congestive heart failure, stroke, kidney failure,
chronic obstructive pulmonary disease,
Parkinson disease, multiple sclerosis,
and amyotrophic lateral sclerosis.
Number two, having no impairment in memory.
Number three, no impairment in physical function.
And number four, being in good mental health.
The researchers looked at this composite outcome
and also looked at each of these four outcomes independently.
That's important because it could be
that protein affects these four outcomes differently,
which you may not appreciate
if you just look at the composite outcome.
For example, what if protein improves someone's odds
of having no impairment in physical function,
but it increases their risk of developing chronic disease?
You may not appreciate that
just by looking at the composite outcome.
So the researchers provided data
for the composite outcome, healthy aging,
and then each of these four outcomes individually.
They also went a step further
and did a substitution analysis,
which looked at what happens
when you replace 3% of calories from total protein,
animal protein, dairy protein,
or plant protein with other nutrients.
Importantly, the researchers really did a good job
adjusting for potential confounders,
other variables that may affect the results,
like differences in BMI, exercise levels,
smoking, alcohol consumption, sugar sweetened beverage intake,
energy intake, et cetera.
They even adjusted for fruit and vegetables
in a sensitivity analysis, which we'll come to.
That's not just my view.
Lane actually complimented the authors on this too.
Now you can say, well, Lane, this is epidemiology.
It is, but I got to tell you,
they did a pretty darn good job
controlling for a lot of variables here.
It was a lot of follow-up and it was a lot of people.
This doesn't mean the study
is as controlled as a clinical trial,
but it's a hell of a lot better
than many long-term observational studies.
And you aren't going to get a clinical trial
that runs 30 plus years.
So for this question,
how protein intake affects healthy aging over decades,
it's really the best we have.
Before we get into the results,
I want to share a few other interesting facts
about the subjects in this study.
People who ate more animal protein
on average ate more vegetables,
exercised more, drank less alcohol,
consumed less energy, ate more fish,
and had a higher diet quality score.
Often when observational studies are spoken about,
people say, yeah,
but people eating more animal foods were unhealthier
and they weren't eating a high quality diet.
You can't really use that argument in this cohort.
It's why the researchers originally started this cohort
on female nurses.
Compared to the general population,
they are a health conscious group,
not a group of people eating hot dogs and pizzas
as their primary sources of animal protein.
In fact, I'm showing on screen now
for those watching on YouTube
that approximately 90% of animal protein intake
was from beef, chicken, milk, fish,
seafood, cheese, soup, eggs, and yogurt.
Just 4% was from pizza and processed meats.
Those eating more animal protein did have higher BMI.
That's likely due to more lean mass,
higher protein intake, and more exercise.
Let's take a look at the results.
Starting with healthy aging, the composite outcome.
This is the data that Lane spends most of his time on
and uses to suggest that this paper is a win
for protein, total protein, animal protein,
and plant protein.
That is pretty much his message, as you can see here.
My overall take home from this is that,
one, protein is not this evil nutrient
that people have made it out to be.
Two, it may be important for healthy aging.
It is true when looking at the composite outcome
defined as healthy aging,
total protein improved odds of healthy aging by 5%,
animal protein by 7%, dairy protein by 14%,
and plant protein by 38%.
I can see how Lane and others may look at this data,
which I'm showing on screen now from table two in the study,
and think this is a win for protein in general,
with some extra support for dairy and plant protein
over and above other forms of animal protein.
What Lane failed to mention
was that when the researchers also adjusted
for fruit and vegetable consumption
to get a better look at the independent effects of protein,
only plant protein was associated
with significantly higher odds of healthy aging.
Total protein, animal protein, and dairy protein was not.
I asked Dr. Matthew Nagra why he thought adjusting
for fruits and vegetables was important.
Here's what he had to say.
Adjusting for fruits and vegetables is important
if the goal is to identify the benefits or harms, perhaps,
of higher or lower protein intake.
And this is particularly exemplified by this study.
So if we look at those consuming the most protein,
they also scored nine points higher in diet quality
on a 100-point scale.
They scored, or they consumed,
about five more servings of vegetables per week,
and none of that was considered in their main model.
So in their main adjustment model,
yes, they considered physical activity,
they considered smoking,
but they just didn't consider overall diet quality.
Now, the reason that's important
is because we don't know if the benefits of animal protein,
so to speak, are due to them just eating more vegetables,
or if there is something inherently beneficial
to consuming more protein,
whether it's from animals or plants.
And as you've already mentioned,
when they did adjust for fruits and vegetables,
which is essentially leveling the playing field,
so comparing people consuming
the same amounts of fruits and vegetables,
but more or less protein,
those who consume more protein from animal or dairy sources
did not see significant benefit,
but those consuming more plant protein still did.
So this tells us that there are, perhaps,
some benefits to choosing more plant protein,
but not necessarily to choosing more animal or dairy protein.
And what's really ironic about that
is that those claiming that there were benefits
to animal protein,
well, in reality, the supposed benefits
may actually be due to the fact
that they were eating more plants.
And if I were to speculate
on why these plant protein sources may have been beneficial,
we have to consider foods like legumes, tofu, nuts,
and so on, which come packaged with some fiber,
phytonutrients, they don't contain any cholesterol,
and they're typically lower in saturated fat
than the alternatives,
which can all help drive those additional benefits
to consuming more of those foods.
While all of that is interesting,
I find this next bit of data even more interesting.
Lane states multiple times in his video
that higher total protein and animal protein intake
was associated with less risk of chronic diseases.
Here's an example.
And a lot of people have made claims
that protein could contribute to various diseases
like cancer, heart disease.
I mean, this study doesn't really support that
because people who were eating higher protein intakes
had lower rates of these.
That is simply not true.
If we look at table three,
the researchers show the effect that total protein,
animal protein, dairy protein, and plant protein
had on the four individual outcomes
that make up the healthy aging composite outcome.
In column two, we can clearly see
that every 3% energy increase
from total protein or animal protein
is actually associated with 5% lower odds
of being free of chronic disease.
In other words, higher total protein intake
and higher animal protein intake
was associated with more risk of developing
one or more of the 11 chronic diseases
that I read out earlier.
Whereas dairy and plant protein
did not increase risk of developing chronic disease.
And I quote from the paper itself on page 274,
total and animal protein intake
were significantly associated
with higher chronic disease risk in all models.
However, dairy protein and plant protein intake
were associated with higher odds
of absence of chronic diseases.
It's right there in the paper,
a reminder for scientists and science students
to look beyond the abstract
and really take the time
to think about the outcomes measured
and what the data means for yourself
before reading the author's discussion.
Allow me to introduce you to Momentous,
my go-to supplement brand for all things protein and creatine.
It's pretty easy,
especially if you're not tracking everything that you eat
to fall short of the optimal daily protein intake.
To help reach my daily protein target,
I compliment my diet
with one and a half scoops of Momentous' chocolate
or vanilla chai plant-based protein,
for 30 grams of protein and all essential amino acids,
which supports muscle growth,
hormone and collagen production, skin health and recovery.
I also consume 10 grams of Momentous' creatine daily
to enhance energy production, muscle strength,
bone health and cognition,
with studies now showing the benefit of creatine
on short-term memory and intelligence.
I'll do anything for a little extra brain power.
And what's really cool
is that both products are NSF certified.
This certification is the only
third-party certification program
trusted by the likes of the NBA, the MLB, Ironman, et cetera.
With this, you can be confident
that Momentous' protein and creatine
are free from unsafe levels of contaminants,
prohibited substances or masking agents,
and that what is on the label
actually matches what is in the product.
For discounts on these supplements,
visit livemomentous.com and use code LIVINGPROOF
for up to 36% off on subscriptions
or 20% off one-time purchases.
That's livemomentous.com with code LIVINGPROOF at checkout.
If we are thinking about chronic disease
as an outcome of interest,
this is a clear win for dairy and plant protein.
I'm almost positive Lane overlooked this
because later he says this about protein and disease.
I wouldn't really be worried about protein.
Literally, almost all the research
showing protein to be bad
is mechanistic in nature in animal models,
oftentimes in knockout models that are genetically altered,
or it's connecting random dots through epidemiology
and torturing data apart.
Now you could say, well, Lane, this is epidemiology.
It is, but I got to tell you,
they did a pretty darn good job
controlling for a lot of variables here.
It was a long follow-up and it was a lot of people.
Now, if he sees this video,
given that he's clearly stated it's a good study,
not a study where data has been tortured,
he has a logical inconsistency that he needs to clear up.
From my perspective, he kind of has to accept this data
and reevaluate his position and recommendations.
Also interesting from table three,
I want to draw your attention to is column four,
which looks at physical function limitations.
Here we can see that animal, dairy, and plant protein
all associate with higher odds
of not having a physical limitation.
That's a good thing.
But the magnitude of this effect
varies greatly between these protein sources.
For every 3% increase in energy from animal protein,
there was a 5% higher odds of not being physically impaired.
From dairy protein, there was 8% higher odds
of not being physically impaired.
And from plant protein,
there was 41% higher odds of not being physically impaired.
And let's not forget about mental health status.
Lane completely left this out of his video.
For every 3% of energy increment from plant protein,
there was a 16% increase in odds
of having good mental health status.
The same could not be said for total, animal,
or dairy protein.
I'm not exactly sure how Lane overlooked
all of these data points,
because during his video,
as he reads out the results
for the healthy aging composite outcome,
he actually has on screen table three,
which I just referred to for quite some time,
which shows the results
for each of the four individual outcomes.
This table, to summarize, shows us total and animal protein
associated with higher odds of developing chronic disease.
Plant protein was associated with the lowest odds
of becoming physically impaired.
Plant protein was associated with higher odds
of having good mental health status.
Total, animal, and dairy protein was not.
All of that is missed if you just focus
on the healthy aging composite outcome.
Now, some might argue the effect sizes are relatively small,
but keep in mind that's just per 3% increase in calories
from these sources of protein.
Given the average adult in the USA
gets 70 to 85% of their protein from animal foods,
it's quite conceivable that someone could substitute
6 to 9% of their total calories
from animal protein for plant protein.
Lane actually made this point himself,
which brings me to the substitution analysis in this study.
In figure one, the researchers use forest plots
to show what happens to the composite outcome,
healthy aging, when you replace 3% of calories
from various nutrients with total protein,
animal protein, dairy protein, and plant protein,
real-world swaps that you or I may contemplate making.
Lane seems to think these four images again show
that protein, regardless of source,
is better for healthy aging
than almost every other nutrient,
except polyunsaturated fats.
What he doesn't make clear is that replacing calories
from refined carbs, carbs from whole grains,
or saturated fat with animal protein
did not significantly improve
someone's odds of healthy aging.
I looked at, you know, did the substitution
favor protein or not favor protein?
Some of the effects weren't significant,
but I gotta be honest, when you look at the forest plots,
it almost favors protein with every single one.
The one nutrient that total protein, animal protein,
and dairy protein were either the same as
or a little bit worse than was polyunsaturated fats.
But Lane, replacing calories from refined carbs,
carbs from whole grains, or saturated fat with animal protein
did not significantly improve
someone's odds of healthy aging.
Each of those were non-significant associations.
I'll say that one more time.
Replacing calories from refined carbs
with calories from animal protein
did not significantly improve
someone's odds of healthy aging.
While you could say it trended towards a small benefit,
it was not significant, as shown in the supplement.
Dairy protein did slightly better than animal protein.
At least replacing refined carbs with dairy protein
increased odds of healthy aging.
The real story is what you see
in forest plot D in this figure.
Replacing 3% of energy from animal protein
with plant protein improved someone's odds
of healthy aging by 38%.
And replacing 3% of energy from dairy protein
with plant protein improved someone's odds
of healthy aging by 26%.
And this is the biggest problem I have with Lane's position.
He seems to use this study as a way of saying
that all protein is beneficial,
without making it clear to the listener
that really what this study shows
is that you should be eating more plant protein
and less animal protein.
So in summary, let me share three important takeaways
from this study.
Number one, animal protein was associated
with increased odds of developing one or more
of the 11 chronic diseases.
You can see that in table three.
Number two, animal and plant protein were associated
with not having physical limitations.
But while animal protein increased someone's odds
of not being physically limited by 5%,
dairy protein did so by 8% and plant protein did so by 41%.
You can also see that in table three.
Number three, and perhaps most important,
replacing 3% of energy from animal protein
with plant protein increased one's odds
of healthy aging by 38%.
You can see that in figure one and supplementary table four.
With all of this in mind,
I really do not see how this study
is positive for animal protein.
And if it is, it's dairy protein,
not animal protein in general.
Later in the video, Lane brings up sarcopenia.
One of the biggest detrimental effects
during aging is sarcopenia.
In fact, after age 65,
you can tie many, many, many deaths
back to a lack of muscle mass.
I agree with Lane that sarcopenia is a real problem
and that protein is important
for avoiding age-related muscle and strength loss,
that we need to keep people physically fit and active,
and that skeletal muscle and being strong
can help someone avoid chronic disease.
But I don't think Lane is appreciating the fact
that chronic disease itself is a huge risk factor
for living a sedentary lifestyle
and developing sarcopenia in the first place.
When people get cardiometabolic issues or cancer,
they become less active.
So this is a bi-directional relationship.
That's why, in my view, you need to be optimizing
for both chronic disease risk and physical function
to truly promote healthy aging.
Remember, animal protein in this study
was associated with increased odds of having chronic disease
and plant protein was associated with the highest odds
of not being physically impaired.
That's some of the key data points
that Lane seemed to overlook.
Accordingly, based on this study
and the wider body of evidence
looking at cardiometabolic disease,
the best way to optimize for chronic disease
and physical function is to ensure that,
number one, you get a good amount of protein
in your diet each day,
in the vicinity of 1.2 to 1.6 grams per kilogram.
Number two, have a bias towards plant protein sources.
And number three, do resistance training
two to three times per week.
Now, how is the average person doing
when it comes to these three things?
That is a great question.
Let's go back through those three points.
So for number one, the average adult
gets about one to 1.2 grams of protein per kilogram.
So there's moderate room for improvement or optimization,
especially for elderly or vegetarians or vegans
who tend to fall at the low end of that range.
Number two, 70 to 85% of the average adult's protein
comes from animal protein.
So lots of improvement here.
Number three, about 70% of adults in the USA
fail to meet resistance training guidelines.
Again, lots of room for improvement here.
So most focus really needs to be
on doing resistance training
and replacing calories from animal protein
with plant protein.
Then we'll be moving towards a society
that has a lower cardiometabolic disease risk
and lower risk of sarcopenia and physical impairment.
Does everyone need to stop eating all animal protein
and become vegan?
No, of course not.
And that is not what this study shows or my position.
But dialing back animal protein for plant protein
is a favorable move.
Not just because of this study,
but plenty of other studies,
like this meta-analysis of 31 cohort studies
I'm showing on screen
with a combined total of over 700,000 people,
whose conclusion was intake of plant protein
can be increased relatively easily
by replacing animal protein
and could have a large effect on longevity.
For those of you who are eating some animal protein,
and I'm drawing from this recent Harvard study
that we've discussed today and the broader literature,
fatty fish, eggs, and fermented cheese slash yogurt
would be the best animal proteins to include
from a cardiometabolic health point of view.
A pretty sensible set of guidelines to refer to
that summarize this and more,
the Danish dietary guidelines.
So there we have it, friends.
As I said at the outset of this episode,
I really do like Lane.
I've learned a lot from him.
I think he adds great value in this space
and genuinely think he's a good dude
and seems willing to evolve his views over time.
So maybe he will hear,
or maybe he can tell me why he disagrees
with my interpretation of the data.
Or maybe he can just tell me to go off.
Anyway, thanks for tuning in.
Hope that was helpful.
Let me know in the comment section on YouTube,
or alternatively, you can leave a review
on the Apple or Spotify podcast app.
And I will see you soon.