Optimizing nutrition for health and longevity (AMA 66 sneak peek)

Health Longevity
19 followers
7 Video Views·Dec 10, 2024
Hey everyone.
Welcome to the drive podcast.
I'm your host, Peter Atiyah.
Peter, welcome to another AMA.
How are you doing?
Doing, doing very well.
Thank you for having me back.
I am always happy to have you.
What I haven't talked to you yet today.
So what kind of mood would you say you're in today?
Oh, well, given the subject matter, surprisingly, um, good mood and,
um, you know, I've taken a couple of beta blockers before, so I'm, I'm,
I'm just, I'm riding the cool wave, man.
That's good.
I was curious if we were going to get diplomatic Peter or
spicy Peter on this episode.
Oh, no, actually.
To be determined.
Yes.
Perfect.
So for today we are covering a topic that as you hinted at is not one of your
favorite, but we probably get asked the most amount of questions on in some form
or another, it's a massive topic, it's nutrition, and we've done a ton of
podcasts on this ton of newsletters on this.
And so we're not going to be able to cover everything as it relates to
nutrition, but what we did is we pulled the most common questions, themes that
we get asked and we pulled them together for this episode.
So we are going to talk about nutrition.
It's relationship and weight loss and weight management, how you think about
it compared to exercise, like the complexities of nutrition research,
which is why often when we send emails, tearing apart studies, they are
typically on nutrition, what you think of as quote unquote, the best diet.
If we can even answer that, how that's different from a healthy person to
someone who's trying to manage chronic disease, how people can think about
choosing the best diet for themselves.
Obviously we can't do nutrition without protein, which is one thing you do
genuinely like to talk about, and we'll also hit some other hot button
issues such as processed food.
So without that, so with all that said, anything you want to add before we get
rolling?
No, let's jump into it.
Perfect.
Starting off nutrition, why do you hate talking about it?
Well, look, it wasn't always this way.
There was a day when I really enjoyed talking about nutrition and writing
about nutrition.
In fact, I sort of, uh, you know, you could argue I cut my teeth on that,
right?
That was my very first foray into doing anything publicly back in 2011 was
blogging and it was blogging mostly about nutrition.
Um, but I would say there are a handful of reasons that, that my, my interest
in continuing to obsessively talk about it has sort of diminished.
So, you know, you've alluded to some already.
So the, the problem with nutrition, uh, research is that, um, it doesn't really
lend itself to having a rigorous discussions on the topic.
I read a really interesting and timely article the other day on LinkedIn.
Um, and it was titled something to the effect of food can't be medicine until
we can research it like medicine.
In fact, we should, we should link to that article in the show notes.
Um, and it was, I mean, it was so spot on, right?
It's like everyone loves to probably misquote Hippocrates with the let food be
thy medicine line.
Um, and yeah, it makes sense in a way.
They're molecules.
You put the molecules in, they clearly have an effect on your body.
The problem is there's no relationship whatsoever between food and medicine.
Um, the nature and the nature of which we can do controlled studies with medicine
is completely different.
The homogeneity of medicine, right?
If we're going to study a medication, um, you're getting the same molecule every
time.
And that's the one molecule that you're, you're studying, right?
I mean, there are a few exceptions to that.
If you're taking, for example, desiccated thyroid hormone, where you have kind of a
hodgepodge of pig thyroid gland mixed up.
Yeah, it might, you might have your, you're getting some T3, some T4, some T2,
et cetera.
But for the most part, when you take a drug, you're taking a single molecule.
That's obviously not the case with food.
Um, and then, so, so all of that, notwithstanding the real issue I have,
cause that's just, I think a function of a food, what, what sort of rubs me the
wrong way is that the ratio of certainty with which people speak about this subject
matter to the quality of data.
So take that as a ratio.
So on the top, you have certainty on the bottom, you have quality of data.
Um, you, you know, that is really, really low.
Um, pardon me, really, really high.
That's a really big number.
Meaning there's people have tons of certainty despite a paucity of data, um,
or quality of data.
You don't have a paucity of data.
You have a paucity of quality data.
Um, and I've never seen, I've just, there's nothing that compares to this, right?
So like there is no discipline of science or engineering for which our magnitude of
certainty is so high relative to such poor quality data.
Um, and then I think the final point I would make of many, but I don't want to
spend the whole time on this, is that the zealous extremes and the cultish religious
buffoonery that goes on in this space is just very off-putting to me.
Um, and, um, so, so whether we're talking about one end of the spectrum of carnivore
to vegan, when people speak about their diet as the one true diet, uh, I find it
very off-putting, which is not to say that a person who's vegan is off-putting.
I mean, I've met many people who say, look, this is kind of the thing that works for
me and, or this is my belief system.
I just can't bring myself to eat animals.
And I'm not saying there's anything wrong with that.
What I'm saying, what I'm talking about is sort of the, the really cultish people
who will tell you with absolute certainty that if you are eating anything other
than this diet and this diet can be any diet, um, that, you know, you're going to
go to hell basically.
Like there, you know, there's a, there's a warm place in Hades that's waiting for
you.
And of course they're not saying that, but the point is they're, they're speaking
with such conviction about something for which such conviction is impossible.
What do you think caused you to make a switch on nutrition?
Right?
So you kind of hinted at, you kind of cut your teeth on this subject when we met 12
or so years ago, you were deep in this subject.
Was it a slow progression or do you think it was like a more of a quick switch?
No, I think it was pretty gradual.
I don't, there wasn't like, there's not a moment I'll point to that says when that
happened or when I read that one study or meta analysis or article, I had to change.
It was, I think it was in part maybe as my clinical experience grew and I saw more
and more patients and realized more and more the complexity of nutrition, um, and
the heterogeneity of people's response to different nutrition.
In other words, how 10 people could respond in six different ways to, to, to
given nutritional inputs that you start to realize, um, well, a couple of things
are true, right?
One is that the, the, the body is remarkably adept at, um, sort of dampening
the effects of nutrition, right?
So it's like, um, you know, if you think of an engineering system, there are some
systems where when you put a signal in to the box, the box amplifies the signal.
So you, you put something in that's a two out of 10 and it, it amplifies it to
like an eight out of 10, right?
Um, and sometimes you want that.
Sometimes you need a signal amplifier.
Um, but then you have the opposite is true, right?
Where you put something in and it dampens the signal.
So you put something in, that's like a blinking eight out of 10 and the
thing gets attenuated, it gets dampened.
It comes out at a two out of 10.
And in many ways, the body is that way with nutrition.
And so a lot of the things that people pontificate about on the margins, um, end
up being really not that important.
And, and I've talked about this a bunch and maybe we'll even speak
about it a little later today.
But this, you know, once you get beyond, beyond total energy consumption, uh,
or total energy content of the food, total calories, protein content, and the
essentials within, uh, minerals and nutrients, most of the rest doesn't
matter that much, the body's pretty resilient.
You have to hit certain minimums on fat, um, to, to avoid severe malnutrition
and, and sort of problems that occur there.
Um, carbohydrate tolerance is staggeringly variable, right?
You can get away without eating any carbs and still function.
And you can get away with eating a ton of carbs and still function.
Uh, and so, so that's actually kind of amazing is our variability on
that one particular macronutrient.
But beyond those big principles, there's very little that can be said
with high certainty, um, and one might even ask the question,
how much really, really matters.
I mean, we're now talking about fourth and fifth order
terms on a polynomial here.
Um, and those don't tend to really sway the outcome because the first, second,
and third order terms are really clearly set.
And so I think the next follow-up question would be what measures of
health, if any, that relate to nutrition, can an individual monitor on their own
to kind of understand, you know, where they're at health wise?
Well, I think there are many, right?
So obviously nutrition plays a huge role in anthropometric data.
Um, so, you know, using a DEXA scan, which will tell you how much lean
mass you have, how much body fat you have, and if the scan is calibrated
correctly, at least give you a good estimate of how much visceral fat you have.
Um, that's a great, um, readout of nutrition.
Uh, you could go even detailed in that and, and actually do scans of the liver
specifically to look for liver fat, also a fantastic readout of
nutrition, uh, quite specifically.
Um, you could look at biomarkers that, uh, pertain to metabolic health and
specifically to glucose regulation or glucose homeostasis.
So if you look at either impaired or, um, uh, you know, enhanced glucose
disposal, uh, and other markers of metabolic health, this is everything
that would range from how your CGM performs, your hemoglobin A1C, um,
things like uric acid, things like, uh, liver function tests, uh, your
oral glucose tolerance tests.
All of those things are going to be very important readout states of nutrition.
Now, of course, um, you know, the, those, those markers are also
readout states of other things.
They reflect your sleep and exercise quite a bit as well.
Uh, but there's no doubt that those are reflections of your nutritional status.
Um, in some cases we would say otherwise unexplained inflammation could,
could probably be driven by nutrition.
Um, we certainly see that outside of very extreme examples where, uh, you know, for
example, celiac disease is a pretty extreme and specific case, but even
absent something like celiac disease, there's clearly an intolerance to wheat
on the part of many people.
And it only shows up in, uh, a biochemical assay that, that surveys for, for, uh,
inflammation such as a, uh, a C-reactive protein, um, or a slight change in the
white blood cell count or things of that nature.
And, and we know this because when we do kind of the, you know, empirical, you
know, elimination, selective elimination and reintroduction of these things, we'll
see those inflammatory markers move.
So, uh, there's no question that food plays a role in, in that as well.
Um, and then obviously we can measure, uh, certain deficiencies and, or excesses,
uh, in, in the blood most commonly, but also in the urine or even in the hair.
So in other words, you could, you could give you an example, right?
You could see a person who is, you know, B12 deficient, that's a very common
finding in people who don't eat meat.
Uh, and similarly, you can see an excess of mercury, which would be considered
quite toxic if it gets to a high enough level for someone who, for example, is
eating a lot of seafood and especially seafood that is coming from really large
fish who are high enough on the food chain that they're eating a lot of other
fish and accumulating mercury themselves.
So I would say like probably those would be the big four categories of things
where nutrition is, is easy to read out in, in testing.
And one of the questions we see come through a lot is kind of the relationship
or the difference between nutrition and exercise as it relates to weight loss,
weight maintenance, or gaining weight.
What do we know about kind of those two things, nutrition and
exercise as it relates to weight?
Thank you for listening to today's sneak peek AMA episode of the drive.
If you're interested in hearing the complete version of this AMA, you'll
want to become a premium member.
It's extremely important to me to provide all of this content
without relying on paid ads.
To do this, our work is made entirely possible by our members.
And in return, we offer exclusive member only content and benefits above
and beyond what is available for free.
So if you want to take your knowledge of this space to the next level, it's our
goal to ensure members get back much more than the price of the subscription.
Premium membership includes several benefits.
First, comprehensive podcast show notes that detail every topic, paper, person,
and thing that we discuss in each episode.
And the word on the street is nobody's show notes rival ours.
Second monthly ask me anything or AMA episodes.
These episodes are comprised of detailed responses to subscriber questions,
typically focused on a single topic and are designed to offer a great deal of
clarity and detail on topics of special interest to our members.
You'll also get access to the show notes for these episodes.
Of course, third delivery of our premium newsletter, which is put together by our
dedicated team of research analysts.
This newsletter covers a wide range of topics related to longevity and provides
much more detail than our free weekly newsletter.
Fourth access to our private podcast feed that provides you with access to every
episode, including AMAs sans the spiel you're listening to now and in your
regular podcast feed. Fifth, the qualities,
an additional member only podcast we put together that serves as a highlight reel
featuring the best excerpts from previous episodes of the drive.
This is a great way to catch up on previous episodes without having to go back
and listen to each one of them. And finally,
other benefits that are added along the way.
If you want to learn more and access these member only benefits,
you can head over to peteratiamd.com forward slash subscribe.
You can also find me on YouTube, Instagram, and Twitter,
all with the handle Peter Atia MD.
You can also leave us review on Apple podcasts or whatever podcast player you
use.
This podcast is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute
the practice of medicine, nursing, or other professional healthcare services,
including the giving of medical advice. No doctor patient relationship is formed.
The use of this information and the materials linked to this podcast is at the
user's own risk.
The content on this podcast is not intended to be a substitute for professional
medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment.
Users should not disregard or delay in obtaining medical advice from any medical
condition they have,
and they should seek the assistance of their healthcare professionals for any
such conditions. Finally, I take all conflicts of interest very seriously.
For all of my disclosures and the companies I invest in or advise,
please visit peteratiamd.com forward slash about where I keep an
up-to-date and active list of all disclosures.
Thank you.
