Welcome to Middle Ages Wiki! Today we will learn about Church and Heresy: The Medieval Struggle.
🏰🔍Step into the medieval world with us as we unlock the secrets of the "Middle Ages Wiki."
Join us as we explore the highlights of middle ages life, from the noble pursuits of knights to the tumultuous events that shaped history. Whether you're a history buff or simply curious about the past, there's something for everyone in the pages of the "Middle Ages Wiki."
Subscribe now for a journey through time and let's embark on an adventure to uncover the wonders of the middle ages.📜✨
🏰⛪️🔥 Dive into the tumultuous world of the 13th century in our latest video! ⚔️💰💀
We explore the vibrant yet challenging life in Medieval Towns, uncovering the roles of social classes from servants and merchants to powerful clergymen and notorious heretics. Discover the Church's struggle against dissenting beliefs like those of the Cathars and Waldensians.
Witness the drama of the Fourth Crusade, its unintended consequences, and the impact of Pope Innocent III's powerful reign. From daily life to religious conflict, we unravel the tapestry of Medieval Society and its complexities. ➡️ Watch now to journey back in time! ⬅️
13th century towns even the biggest
often had substantial numbers of people
involved in agricultural production the
equivalent of modern vegetable gardening
but also more extensive husbandry like
viticulture and exploitation of
marshlands the morray District of Paris
was once a major area of rural
exploitations within the judical
boundaries of the city it was not always
the case that people who exploited such
resources could claim citizenship for
citizenship or
freemansherlock wealth in that it
usually had to be purchased at least
initially it might be inheritable
thereafter poor people in any case could
not purchase it and thus they were
deprived of some of the benefits of town
life enjoyed by their betters such as
immunity from certain kinds of taxes or
freedom of Commerce in the marketplace
domestic servants who were never
citizens were also excluded from the
full benefits of urban life domestics
often recruited from the countryside
served in the households of every
important family bgeo or aristocratic
and in those of urban ecclesiastical
establishments as well for Lay people to
have a house full of servants was a
badge of honor the servants received
food lodging and some degree of
patronage and support as for example
when they needed a dowy in order to
marry but they also encountered the
possibility of physical and sexual abuse
in Lay households it is very hard to put
a figure on their numbers incomplete
figures suggest how however that the
number of servants in an ecclesiastical
establishment could exceed the number of
priests monks or nuns housed there the
personal needs of elite Urban residents
were met not merely by household
servants but by others with more
specific skills the rich had recourse to
doctors although like sick people in
many circumstances they would turn to
alternative medicines and healing Cults
as well wealthy women turned to midwives
when in labor midwives also attended
middle and lower class women who could
afford them the really poor mother to be
if her immediate family did not have
money to procure the service of a
midwife might typically turn to female
kin and friends for help at birthing
time or again to local shrines charms or
tonics that promised help in child birth
wet nursing was widely practiced in the
south of Europe particularly in the
north Italian towns the nurses usually
lived in the outskirts of a town and
receive the child an income and regular
visits from a family representative
why the disparity exists in 13th century
reports between the routine employment
of wet nurses in Northern Italy and the
Rarity of their employment elsewhere
particularly in northern Europe has
never been answered satisfactorily both
Northerners and Southerners showered
affection on their children both seem to
have believed that they were doing the
right thing two principles may have been
fighting for superiority were the
benefits of Mother's Milk outweighed by
the harshness of the urban environment
in the life of the infant more work
needs to be done on this issue like
birth death demanded a Specialized
Service two certain women either as
volunteers or for a pittance came to
constitute a kind of cast they would
prepare the dead body for burial by
washing it and shrouding it these or
other women especially in Latin Europe
also served as professional mourners and
Whalers a practice derided in some later
sources family members of The Departed
paid or endowed monks and nuns to pray
for the deceased funeral and burial fees
were frowned upon by Elite clerical
commentators as unseemly but they were
most assuredly being paid to get value
often meant to lay out considerable cash
all the people discussed so far had
something of an honorable place in
medieval Urban Society even though there
might have been those like priests
seeking exorbitant funeral fees who were
prone to abuse it but there were other
categories of urban dwellers whom Elite
commentators regarded as the detritus of
Society these were the Beggars thieves
and fences immigrant day laborers and
prostitutes medieval attitudes towards
poverty are as complex as those towards
sickness few people for example wanted
to be sick but what did it mean to be
sick on the one hand the rain fell on
the just and the unjust alike the
biblical job was a just morally healthy
man but he suffered terrible physical
illnesses one's moral state it seemed to
follow had little to do with one 's
physical health on the other hand the
same Bible offered examples of God
striking individuals with disease and
whole peoples like the Egyptians with
plagues on account of their sins to give
a concrete medieval example a leper was
to be pitted as a type of the suffering
Christ the biblical Lazarus considered a
leper by medieval commentators rested
after death in heaven Abraham's bosom
yet Aaron's Sister Miriam suffered the
Affliction of leprosy at God's command
for presuming to challenge Moses's
leadership the lepers social death and
increasingly over the course of the
century exclusion from healthy society
and thousands of medieval leprosaria or
Lazar houses owed much to this vignette
so it was with poverty monks praised it
they typically meant voluntary poverty
signified by a rich person's Act of
heroic renunciation but ecclesiastics in
general also spoke of the Blessed poor
without implying that their status was
voluntary
then again there were Those whom a later
age would call the undeserving poor men
and women who worked Eed out a living as
best they could yet suffered deprivation
were worthy of pity women and men
outside of any religious vocation who
begged for their daily bread did not
work drank themselves into torper hired
out their bodies for sex stole when they
could not accumulate enough from begging
they often overlapped in the big towns
with new immigrants an from the country
or from more distant regions in the
1230s the brittans of Paris with their
funny sounding Celtic language or bad
French as native parisians regarded it
had a nasty reputation as troublemakers
every major town in medieval Italy
seemed to have its English [ __ ] at
least prostitutes as medical Theory
would have it were not good breeders yet
the fact of abandoned children some
almost certainly prostitutes Offspring
others the babies of raped servants
would move ecclesiastics like Pope
Innocent III to support the
establishment of founding hospitals in
Italy in just these years of the early
13th century Society it must be said was
not supposed to be so complicated German
ministerials surfs with the powers and
authority of knights and what of the
inmates of the military orders were they
Knights or monks Merchants who
specialized in the exchange of goods
rather than in the labor of their own
hands was their activity proper to be
considered work at all worse still were
the money lenders a lot of whom were
Jews they so the indictment ran
exploited the poor elevated themselves
by wealth above productive and honorable
groups of men and women and even sold
time which was a gift of God and ought
not to be sold Lind Christ had said
hoping for no gain in return yet the
deniers of Christ often with the
Toleration of Christian princes were
disobeying this command apoll ologists
had answers for some of these problems
but it was a messy World things were
supposed to be simpler Christendom was
supposed to have three orders those who
prayed those who fought and those who
worked with their hands merchants and
their Commerce markets and the cacophony
of Hawkers Street children at play and
cut purses jongler with filthy songs
were an ugly fact of urban life to
ecclesiastical conservatives who
endorsed the three orders ideal of
Christian Society the 12th Cent had been
a marvelously creative period even
conservatives might have admitted save
for the growth of towns of their sinful
marginal populations and of a money
Economy based on filthy lucer Bernard of
clairo condemned Christians who polluted
themselves in money traffic as quasi
Jews but name calling was hardly an
effective response to the complex
changes that had taken place over the
past 100 years the pontificate of
innocent II 1198 to 1216 marks a
decisive stage in the history of the
papacy and to some extent in the history
of the western church and society as
well the pontificate would have been
important even if it had not been
crowned by the fourth leran Council of
1215 but the council introduced and
ratified enormous changes in
ecclesiastical life and had an even more
far-reaching effect through the
application of its decrees to the
secular world we begin with the
background to the great Council
including a general consideration of
Innocence Rule and the political and
religious issues with which he had to
deal and then proceeded to a look at the
work of Lin 4 and its consequences
lothario de Segi ascended the papal
throne in 1198 as Pope Innocent III at
the age of 37 he was a Scion of an
influential Italian Noble lineage and it
was to be expected that he would rise to
some important Post in ecclesiastical or
secular Administration he had had a
splendid Education First in a Roman
Monastery then at the schools of Paris
where he studied theology he had a
considerable amount of legal knowledge
two that whether he was a Canon lawyer
has recently been questioned he moved up
rapidly in the ecclesiastical hierarchy
and became a cardinal in 1190 in his
late 20s while still a cardinal lothario
published his most famous book on the
misery of The Human Condition also known
as on the contempt of the world which
was by medieval standards a bests seller
a characteristic passage suggests the
tastes of a different age man has been
formed of dust clay ashes and a thing
far more vile of the filthy sperm man
has been conceived in the desire of the
flesh In the Heat of sensual lust in the
foul stench of wanness he was born to
labor to fear to suffering and most
miserable of all to death his evil
doings offend God offend his neighbor
offend himself he defiles his good name
contaminates his person violates his
conscience through his shameful acts his
vanity prompts him to neglect what is
most important most necessary and most
useful accordingly he is destined to
become the fuel of the Everlasting
eternally painful Hellfire the food of
the voracious consuming worms his
Destiny is to be a putrid mass that
eternally emits a most horrible stench
these rather pessimistic views of man's
Destiny did not stop lothario from
pursuing an energetic and he would have
said virtuous career in the service of
God from the moment of his accession to
the papal Throne he pitched himself into
the struggles that were plaguing the
church the premature death of Emperor
Henry V 6 left the hoen stalen line of
German rulers with a child Frederick II
as successor innocent took the
four-year-old boy under his protection
at the request of Henry's Widow constant
the daughter of King Roger II of Sicily
Roger had left a son who ruled after him
William I and this son had left a son as
well William II the problem was that
William II had no legitimate direct male
Heir so that his aunt had the strongest
claim to Sicily on his death in fact an
usurper named tankred William II's
illegitimate son seized power and for 5
years tried with the help of Baron's
loyal to him to prevent constant's
accession it was only after Tank's death
that constant's husband successfully
asserted her rights and in 1194 assumed
the RO royal title himself as king of
Sicily the young Frederick therefore who
was the Pope's Ward was the putative
Heir in Germany and after his mother
died in 1198 in Sicily as well if he
became emperor he would also nominally
be the ruler of Northern Italy innocent
III used the opportunity presented by
the situation to strengthen papal
control over the patrimony of St Peter
the broad s of lands in central Italy to
which the papacy laid quite disputed
claim he he also opposed those who
resisted the child Frederick's accession
in Sicily a commitment that commanded
his attention for several years as
Sicily drifted in and out of Civil War
and succumbed to a debilitating
factionalism in the end however his
desire to see Frederick safely on the
Sicilian Throne was rewarded in Germany
the situation that innocent faced was
equally complex because despite
Frederick's status as Henry IV's son the
German Throne was elective and there
seemed no good reason to elect a child
whatever his lineage woe to thee o land
when thy King is a child was a favorite
medieval text in the event in 1198 there
was a disputed election of two adult
male candidates innocent favored aotto
of Brunswick rather than Philip of
swabia in part because the former
promised to ratify papal claims in Italy
but civil Strife racked Germany for
years and Philip usually had the upper
hand following Philip's murder in 128
Otto seemed secure but reneged on the
promise that he wished he had never
given to innocent in the first place
namely to accept papal Territorial and
jurisdictional claims in central Italy
in reaction innocent excommunicated Otto
and engineered the election by disident
German Lords of his Ward Frederick as
German King it would be many years
before Frederick made good his claim
even though he went immediately to
Germany and almost never relented in his
military pressure on Otto indeed the
Pope was dead before the definitive
resolution of the German situation in
the 1220s but his candidate Frederick II
did emerge the Victor if problems in
Sicily Italy and Germany were of near
constant concern to innocent III he also
faced other difficulties that demanded
his attention and radical remedies the
Crusades of the 12th century had been
uneven in their results but generally
unsuccessful the loss of Jerusalem in
1187 was a particularly bitter blow
Richard The lionheart's Crusade the
Third Crusade had gone a long way
towards stabilizing the situation but
Jerusalem continued in Muslim hands and
the position of the Crusader States
remained vulnerable the pope almost
immediately after his election thus
authorized a new Crusade for which
preparations culminated in 122 the
target of The Fourth Crusade was Egypt
which military forces of the Crusader
Kingdom had tried but failed to conquer
in the 12th century the contract for
ships went out to Venice when the
Crusaders including count Baldwin the
9th of Flanders arrived in Venice they
were ill prepared to pay for the ships
500 in all Venetian negotiators
persuaded many of them to join in an
attack on Zara an Adriatic seap Port
that had gone back and forth between
Byzantine Hungarian and Venetian control
in the two previous centuries meanwhile
a claimant to the Byzantine Throne a
popping J named Alexius who was a nephew
of the reigning Emperor also named
Alexius and the son of a deposed Emperor
met with the Crusade leaders made a
spirited case for the legitimacy of his
claim to the Byzantine Throne indicated
his willingness to accept papal
Supremacy over the Greek church and
urged them to advance his efforts to
gain the throne in return for the
Empire's support for their expedition to
Egypt some Crusaders demurred on both
issues indeed some of them including
Simon De monford who was to play an
important role in another of innocent
projects found the funds to go to the
East and prosecute a much reduced
Expedition against the Muslims when the
pope heard of the planned Onslaught on
Zara he dispatched a letter prohibiting
it but it arrived too late to prevent
the attack the majority of the Crusaders
therefore with the paple leggets
approval besieged and took Zara in the
Autumn of 122 in July of the next year
they landed on the outskirts of
Constantinople and along with their
Venetian allies launched an attack on
the city in the confused situation the
emperor Alexius III fled and restored
the throne to his deposed predecessor
the younger Alexius blind father who
entered negotiations to bring their
attack on the capital to an end while
some of the young Alexius Latin allies
pursued Alexius III and began the
pacification of substantial Greek
territories he himself entered
Constantinople and received the Imperial
purple as Alexius IV a condition his
Latin Entourage imposed on the city
before they agreed to remove their Camp
outside only a few months into his brief
Reign rioting and Rebellion broke out
against Alexius IV gangs of Greeks
murdered Latins Muslims in the city for
trade suffered at the hands of the
westerners and a terrible fire started
by the Latins consumed large portions of
the City Rage among both the Greeks and
the Latins centered on Alexius the
sources that depict him as a deuchi may
be biased but there is no doubt that his
early and open association with the
Latins and his nominal subordination of
the Greek Church to papal Authority were
deeply resented no love was lost either
between Alexus and the Latins being
robed in the Imperial purple went to his
head and he treated his allies with
something approaching contempt moreover
they feared for their lives as a result
of his inability or unwillingness to
protect them and so they recalled the
troops who had been pacifying the
countryside finally there was a nativist
coup in the city and the new emperor was
murdered the Crusaders from their their
camps outside the walls witnessed their
hopes for military and financial support
which had already been dimmed because of
Alexia's attitude begin to evaporate
Before Their Eyes they decided to take
charge of the situation themselves and
on April 9th 124 following confession
and mass according to the Latin right
attacked the city disaster after
disaster plagued them in their
skirmishes and assaults even nature
seemed to be against them contrary winds
made support from the see nearly
impossible why they resumed the attack
at all after an interruption of a few
days is unclear certainly clergy
preached the Justice of the war the
Crusaders and the venetians had been
betrayed harassed many killed the Greeks
hated them and were disloyal to Rome God
was testing his holy Army and they must
meet the test on the 12th of April they
resumed the attack against devastating
odds managing to breach the walls and
open the gates of the city wreaking
havoc as they rushed through the streets
when darkness fell the situation was
still uncertain the smell of burning
flesh and the noise of the collapse of
buildings weakened by the Flames
permeated the city as destructive fires
spread in the aftermath of the
afternoon's murderous Street battles
substantial Greek forces that might have
saved the situation for the byzantin
decided instead to abandon the capital
as day dawned the Crusaders and
venetians discovered that they were
masters of a smoldering yet still great
City they took their Revenge The Spoils
of War would soon find their way to
castles and churches in the Latin West
they elected count Baldwin the 9th of
Flanders as Emperor and proceeded to
enforce Latin authority over the Greek
people and the Greek Church in
Constantinople and wherever else they
could establish it in Greece the
archipelago and Asia Minor the pope who
was genuinely dismayed by the fate of
his crusading project decided to accept
the outcome as the will of God it seemed
seemed as though the churches would be
definitively United and there was hope
that in the future the Latin Empire of
Constantinople would provide a base for
sustaining the Crusader settlements in
the Holy Land meanwhile in the heartland
of Southern France and Northern Italy
there was a situation as confounding as
the succession crisis in Germany and
Sicily in the strange course of The
Fourth Crusade why heresy was or
appeared to the popes as particularly
widespread in southern Europe especially
ledok has never been answered with
complete satisfaction perhaps as one
argument goes the dicese in ledok were
too large for efficient Administration
giving dissident groups a chance to
flourish there rather than elsewhere
perhaps the aristocracy in this long
stateless region patronized as leaders
of the church those who supported them
in their political squabbles with little
concern as to whether these men would
pay much attention to curbing descent
what is certain is that in the 12th
century several groups or sects of
Christians and langed and the
neighboring lands began to claim a more
authentic understanding of the faith
they did not all share the same beliefs
some like the humiliati were insistent
on the superiority of the simple life
and the necessity to preach the gospel
of Love even if they maintained their
lay status yet the humiliati were also
willing to live in endowed fraternal
communities that provided a modum of
institutional control on the pattern of
monasteries and did not seem to
represent too great a breach with
Catholic practice
others wished to renounce all worldly
possessions rejected or at least cared
little about institutional life and also
demanded to be allowed to preach whether
they were ordained to do so by the
visible church or not those of this
persuasion often called waldensians
after one of the most devout among them
wdez a rich Merchant turned poor man of
lions did not all break irrevocably from
the church although a blanket
condemnation of lay preaching had been
imposed in the 12th century in the third
allowed it under local license and to
particular groups these included the
rehabilitated humiliati whether lay or
ordained as some were and also those
waldensians who retained their Orthodoxy
only those waldensians who stubbornly
rejected Priestly Authority and over
time much more of the Catholic
sacramental system and penitential
theology including Purgatory came to be
regarded as Heretics much more serious
in innocent view even than the unre
repentant waldensians were the cathers
for their disagreement with the visible
Church ran deeper the overwhelming
weight of recent research has been to
emphasize that not all caths were the
same but almost any selection of the
various views they held was repugnant to
Orthodoxy the range of their beliefs
comprehended rejection of the Old
Testament and indeed of the traditional
Unity of God in favor of dualism the god
of the Old Testament was the god of the
visible created world a world of evil
the god of the Old Testament was evil
opposed to him was the god of the New
Testament a spirit unsullied by created
matter Jesus some sort of manifestation
of the good God's will could not have
been a corporeal being he only appeared
to be so and could never have suffered
and died an allegation that undermined
the Redemptive Theology of Catholic
Orthodoxy including the central thesis
of vicarious atonement he died and thus
paid for our sins moreover compound ing
the cather's heresy in Catholic eyes was
the fact that they taught their
abominable doctrines at least in part
through an organized group of teachers
there seemed to be in this sense a
competing cathart Church