5 Video Views·Mar 9, 2024
Enlightenment scorn and Romantic admiration
During the 17th and 18th centuries, a number of thinkers argued that Western Europe after the 15th century had surpassed even antiquity in its discoveries and technology and had thereby created a distinctively modern world. Their views, which were sharpened by Enlightenment critics of earlier European political and religious structures, did nothing to change the image of the Middle Ages. Voltaire, in his An Essay on Universal History, the Manners and Spirit of Nations from the Reign of Charlemaign to the Age of Lewis XIV (1756), savaged the Latin Christian and the reformed churches for their clerical obscurantism and earlier rulers for their ruthless and arbitrary use of force. Edward Gibbon, the English historian whose great work The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire (1776–88) begins with events in late antiquity and ends with the fall of Constantinople (the capital of the Byzantine Empire) to the Ottoman Turks in 1453, categorically attributed the beginning of that very long “decline and fall” to “the triumph of barbarism and religion,” thus contemptuously characterizing the entire period from the 5th to the 15th century.
The Middle Ages in modern historiography
With the extraordinary growth of the academic discipline of history in the 19th century, the history of the Middle Ages was absorbed into academic curricula of history in Europe and the United States and established in university survey courses and research seminars. Journals of scholarly historical research began publication in Germany (1859), France (1876), England (1886), and the United States (1895), regularly including studies of one aspect or another of the Middle Ages. Historical documents were edited and substantial scholarly literature was produced that brought the history of the Middle Ages into synchronization with other fields of history. The study of the Middle Ages developed chiefly as a part of the national histories of the individual European countries, but it was studied in the United States as a pan-European phenomenon, with a focus after World War I chiefly on English and French history. The growing influence and prestige of the new academic and professional field of medieval history were reflected in the Monumenta Germaniae Historica (“Historical Monuments of the Germans”), a research and publication institute founded in 1819 and still in operation in Munich, and in the eight-volume collaborative Cambridge Medieval History (1911–36). (The latter’s replacement, The New Cambridge Medieval History, began to appear in 1998.)
during the 17th and 18th centuries a
number of thinkers argued that Western
Europe after the 15th century had
surpassed even Antiquity in its
discoveries and technology and had
thereby created a distinctively modern
world their views which were sharpened
by Enlightenment critics of earlier
European political and religious
structures did nothing to change the
image of the Middle Ages Vol in his an
essay on universal history the manners
and spirit of nations from the reign of
charag to the of Lewis I 14th
1756 Savaged the Latin Christian and the
reformed churches for their clerical
obscurantism and earlier rulers for
their ruthless and arbitrary use of
force Edward Gibbon the English
historian whose great work the decline
and fall of the Roman Empire
1,776 to 88 begins with events in late
Antiquity and ends with the fall of
Constantinople the capital of the
Byzantine Empire to the ottoman Turks in
1453 Cath categorically attributed the
beginning of that very long Decline and
fall to the Triumph of barbarism and
religion thus contemptuously
characterizing the entire period from
the 5th to the 15th
century but as Gibbon's own work showed
not only had the term and the often
pejorative idea of the Middle Ages been
shaped in the 16th and 17th centuries
but so had the critical and Technical
standards of modern historical
scholarship some Enlightenment thinkers
even became interested in earlier
periods of European history their
attraction to the Middle Ages paralleled
the respect for and interest in the
period shared by many ideologically
conservative rulers Nobles magistrates
and
churchmen but the historians also began
to apply critical techniques to their
investigation of the Middle Ages the new
scholarship on the period was animated
in the late 18th and early 19th
centuries by historians imbued with
ethnic National sentiment and with a
conception of historically ethnic
communities especially in Germany and
England that lacked a recognized past or
had only a peripheral past in
traditional histories of the Greco Roman
World during the Romantic Era an
affectionate and sentimentalized
portrait of the Middle Ages emerged that
was usually no more accurate than the
polemical characterizations of
Enlightenment
writers such views contributed to the
myth that 19th century nation states
were composed of ethnic groups that had
remained unchanged and had occupied the
same territory for long periods or had
once occupied territory that was now
inhabited by other nation states these
arguments became powerful and dangerous
political forces in the 19th and 20th
centuries although research in the late
20th century dismissed them as political
fantasies not all 19th century
historians were appreciative of the
Middle Ages although the French
historian Jules miket at first praised
the Middle Ages as the time of the birth
of France his increasing political
liberalism led him to shift his
admiration to the 16th century virtually
coining the term Renaissance in the
process of appropriating it for France
in 1860 the Swiss historian Jacob
Burkhart published his the civilization
of the Renaissance in Italy a work as
widely read and influential as that of
miket despite romantic Nostalgia and
increasingly disciplined scholarship the
work of miket and burkard served to fix
the opposition between the Middle Ages
and the Renaissance in the modern mind
generally to the disadvantage of the
former these views were sharpened by
19th century anticlericalism especially
anti-roman Catholicism although they
were countered by equally learned
Catholic
apologists with the extraordinary growth
of the academic discipline of history in
the 19th century the history of the
Middle Ages was absorbed into academic
curricula of history in Europe and the
United States and established in
University survey courses and research
seminars journals of scholarly
historical research began publication in
Germany 1859 France
1876 England 1886 and the United States
1895 regularly including studies of one
aspect or another of the Middle
Ages historical documents were edited
and substantial scholarly literature was
produced that brought the history of the
Middle Ages into synchronization with
other fields of History the study of the
Middle Ages developed chiefly as a part
of the national histories of the
individual European
countries but it was studied in the
United States as a paneuropean
phenomenon with a focus after World War
the first chiefly on English and French
history the growing influence and
Prestige of the new academic and
professional field of medieval history
were reflected in the monumenta germani
historica historical monuments of the
Germans a research and publication
Institute founded in 1819 and still in
operation in Munich and in the 8 volume
collaborative Cambridge medieval history
1911 to
36 the latter's replacement the new
Cambridge medieval history began to
appear in
1998 most Scholars of the 19th and early
20th centuries accepted the view that
history is largely a story of progress
in which occasional periods of decline
such as the Middle Ages are succeeded by
periods of renewal the most articulated
attack on this view was by the American
medievalist Charles Homer H Haskins in
the Renaissance of the 12th century 1927
which applied michelet's and burkhard's
term Renaissance to the 12th century
rather than to the 15th or
16th although the teaching
responsibilities of academic historians
of the Middle Ages still generally
reflect either the original tripartite
division of European history or the more
recent and more common quadripartite
division
ancient medieval early modern and modern
most Scholars specialize in only very
small parts of a very long period
with the emergence of late Antiquity as
a distinct field of research and
teaching since the mid 20th century the
early part of the conventional Middle
Ages has been rethought and Rewritten
the distinctive postclassical period of
late Antiquity is now considered the
medium through which ancient GRE Roman
Traditions were passed on to later
Europeans the older image of a classical
Antiquity despised by World rejecting
Christians and wiped out by Savage
barbarians is no longer credible
historians in the late 20th and early
21st centuries also debated the
existence of a rapid and extensive
change in European Society at about the
turn of the second
Millennium some Scholars following the
pioneering lead of the French historian
George duie argued for a rapid mutation
chiefly with regard to the development
of new kinds of lay and ecclesiastical
power over agricultural labor and the
simultaneous restructuring of
aristocratic lineages in the 11th
century others maintain that a gradual
transformation of society and culture
occurred over a longer period of time
beginning earlier than the 11th century
these debates influenced the concept of
a Long Middle Ages mentioned above with
the emergence of the concept of early
modern history roughly from 1400 to 1800
the Middle Ages the Renaissance the
reformation and the Scientific
Revolution were subsumed into a period
extending from the late 14th century to
the 18th century the the creation of
specialized scholarly conferences
historical journals monograph series and
thematic collections of scholarly essays
has reflected these changes in the
configuration of the
period Scholars also rethought the
nature of change in different parts of
Europe they recognized the problem of
the obvious differences between those
European lands in late Antiquity that
had once been part of the Roman Empire
and those that had not and therefore got
their romanism and Antiquity
secondhand they ALS also revised their
understanding of the relations between
the older Mediterranean World large
areas of which entered the Byzantine and
Arab Islamic cultural orbits and
Northern Europe in addition Scholars
examined how Roman culture exported
itself to peripheries on the North and
East through a form of colonization that
culminated in the absorption of
originally peripheral colonies into an
expanded core culture Middle Ages
remains both a commonplace colloquial
term and the name of a subject of
academic study but the history of the
term and the current debate about its
temporal and spatial application and
appropriateness is a reminder that
historical periods are cultural and
social constructs based on later
perceptions of the past that human life
often changes quite rapidly within
labeled periods however designated and
that the dialogue between continuity and
change is the historian's primary
intellectual activity