The Cardinals Are a FAILURE With The WORST Manager In Baseball
iTalk Studios
908 followers
Download the Gametime app (https://gametime.co/) and redeem code ITALK for $20 off your first purchase (terms apply)
The Cardinals Are a FAILURE With The WORST Manager In Baseball
#mlb #baseball #sports
LG Store Link - https://bit.ly/iTalkStudios_LG
Amazon Store Link - https://bit.ly/iTalkStudios_FireTV
iTALK STUDIOS INSTAGRAM: https://instagram.com/italk.studios?utm_medium=copy_link
iTALK STUDIOS TWITTER: https://twitter.com/italkstudiosyt?s=21
iTALK STUDIOS SECOND CHANNEL: @italkstudioslive
There's some real good leaders, there's some real good, there's some real good players in there.
There's gonna be some tenacious cardinals in the clubhouse next year.
It's time.
A new era is here.
This is where it all starts.
If by this, you mean sucking, then yeah, although the cardinals were also bad last year.
So this isn't really the start of anything good, more so the continuation of…
Shit, boy!
Shit!
It's the opposite of the way things used to be.
the glory years. So welcome all of you to the ones subscribed and the ones not yet subscribed and when
I mention the glory years I'm not even referring to that long ago. I mean this was a team most
organizations strived to be like with the San Francisco Giants seem to be the only team that
had full immunity of this devil magic. Other than that the Cardinals had a field day with ripping
the hopes and dreams from other good teams in the postseason. They developed pitching well,
they had amazing homegrown hitters, some even being hall of famers, they had it all. And they
to put it simply played good baseball. They did seemingly everything right with their fundamentals
and just everything. This entire 2024 St. Louis Cardinals team feels like a culmination of the
failures being built by the franchise over the last several years. Their inability to build any
hitting, a manager that thinks he's really cool but really is the biggest hard ass in the game,
the farm system is bottom tier despite having several top 100 prospects. Prospects that have
a damn good chance of never reaching their potential because this organization apparently
doesn't know how to do such a thing with their homegrown players. The over reliance on declining
veterans that aren't pulling any Benjamin Button moves up their sleeve anytime soon. I mean when
you're building a starting rotation with an average age of 40, I mean 35 years old, you know this
isn't a roster that screams future and talent that will be here terrorizing the league for years to
come. And this is a good place to start, the rotation. They're all past their primes if they
ever even had one. It's not like they're getting any star or future hall of fame caliber pitchers
despite being older. I did like the Sonny Gray signing as anyone would or should, he's one of
the better pitchers in baseball and someone who I think may be the most underrated pitcher in
baseball. But a rotation full of guys in their mid to late 30s isn't sustainable clearly. But I do
see the vision, at least for this year 2024, build a rotation full of veterans who eat innings with
a really good bullpen to back them up. And with just about the only time you'll ever hear me
credit the Cardinals in this video, this actually has mostly worked out. Bullpen really has been
amazing, at least to start. Ryan Helsey has been one of the best relievers in baseball since 2022.
They have Andrew Kittredge now, who was good with the Rays for many years, it's actually his first
year outside that organization. Ryan Fernandez, someone who had never pitched in the big leagues
before this year, has been really good. And then they have a couple of lefties with Jojo Romero,
who's been really good so far, and Matthew Liberatore. And it's not even that the rotation
has been that terrible either, it's just not at all deep. And you only have so many truly reliable
guys to start with. Myles Michaelis hasn't been good dating back to all of last year. The dude
eats innings, he makes a start. That's never the issue. The issue since 2023 has been the quality
of those innings. And spoiler alert, those innings have been as useful as Thanos at the end of
Avengers Endgame. And speaking of the word game, if you want to go watch the Cardinals lose, whether
you're a fan of the team or want to see your team beat them, I have a deal to help you get tickets.
With the MLB season fully completely off the ground running, that means you should go to some
games. You should get some tickets, but tickets can be a hassle to get. Seeing if you get a good
deal, a bad deal, it just it can get very annoying. And I get that. But you don't have to worry about
that issue with Game Time, which is a fast and easy way to get tickets for everything you want
to go to. Sports, music, games, concerts, any type of thing you like. It has great last minute deals,
all in prices, views from your seat, and their best price guarantee. Game Time really helps with
finding good last minute deals. It just makes it cheaper, less stressful. You find the lowest price
as possible with event cancellation and job loss protection too. So you don't really have to worry
about anything. It's done all of that for me. It's really made the process easy. I honestly can't
complain. Game Time has only really helped me this MLB season. We're only a month in and it's really
helped me big time. It's just really straightforward and tells me exactly what is and isn't a good deal.
It really is cheap and it can be even cheaper for you. So here's how you do it. All you need to do
is download the Game Time app, create an account, and use promo code ITALK for $20 off your first
purchase. Terms apply. Once again, download the app, create an account, and use promo code ITALK
for $20 off your first purchase. Terms apply. Sonny Gray is good. Lance Lynn and Kyle Gibson have the
ability to at least be decent. Again, the Cardinals didn't build the rotation with the intent on any
of these guys necessarily being a Cy Young competitor. They really are relying on veterans
just doing their job, getting enough innings to hand off to a really good bullpen. And that's
kind of worked, at least a little bit. At least a start. But again, it has as much depth as literally
any character in a Timey Waizu movie. And so any pitcher getting hurt and having to miss time is
more than not ideal for a rotation built like this. And even in the bullpen with a guy like
Matthew Liberatore and the way he's been as a Cardinal overall, I would argue no matter what
he does, it's just disappointing considering the circumstance it took to even get him to St. Louis
in the first place, which leads us to the next thing. The fleecing. The St. Louis Cardinals have
gotten fleeced harder than any bank robbery you can do in Grand Theft Auto. I mean, you know the
saying. Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me seven times, shame on me because it's pretty clear at
this point that you can count on this front office making good trade decisions as much as you can
trust Joss Whedon to make a good movie. You can't. When the Marlins were starting their rebuild to get
into the current era that they're in that now has to rebuild, the Cardinals took the opportunity to
trade for Marcel Ozuna. Ozuna has since gone on to be one of the game's best hitters in the last
two seasons. The issue is neither have been with the Cardinals and he was traded there a long time
ago. He hasn't been on the Cardinals in five years. He was there for just one year, 2019, where he was
pretty good, but what the Cardinals gave up far outweighs anything they got from Ozuna that year.
Zach Gallin and Sandy Alcantara, both guys who have of course gone on to lead separate rotations
with Sandy winning a Cy Young award in 2022. Fast forward to December of 2019 and the Cardinals
would trade away struggling hitter Adolis Garcia to Texas for cash considerations. Garcia has gone
on to hit almost a hundred home runs over the span of three years, made two all-star teams,
and helped lead the Rangers to their first championship in franchise history, winning
ALCS MVP in the process. And cash considerations hasn't really done much for the Cardinals. He
hasn't been very productive. Let's skip forward to January of 2020 and that's when the Cardinals
traded Adolis Garcia's best friend and former roommate, Randy Arrozarena, for prospect Matthew
Libertor. Most of you probably understand why I said what I said earlier about Libertor by now.
If not, let me spell it out for you. Sportingnews.com has an article and I wanted to point
out a specific paragraph in said article. The Cardinals traded Arrozarena and first baseman
slash outfielder Jose Martinez to the Rays in January of 2020 in exchange for pitching
prospect Matthew Libertor. At the time, the deal seemed like a savvy move by the Cardinals.
I'll sum it up better this way. The Red Sox traded Babe Ruth to the Yankees in January
1920 in exchange for cash. At the time, the deal seemed like a savvy move by the Red Sox.
Randy Arrozarena immediately showed what the Cardinals were trading away. Becoming the
postseason leader in home runs that very October, winning rookie of the year the next year,
becoming an all-star in 2023. Meanwhile, Libertor has been a decent middle reliever.
Now this one is more respectable, at least as of now, considering Andrew Kittredge has been
a very good pitcher to have in your bullpen. But me thinks the Cardinals should just stop
trading with the Rays. The guy they traded away this time, Richie Palacios, is already showing
some promise and potential at being an everyday solid big league bat. Deja vu. Tyler O'Neal has
struggled bad the last couple years while also being hurt. Cardinals trade him to the Red Sox
and he's been one of the best and most powerful hitters in baseball to start 2024. And then you
have the players the Cardinals didn't trade but let go to other teams and free agency only to
be better than they were in St. Louis, like Jordan Hicks specifically, who's become a really
good starting pitcher now. Specifically on the topic of O'Neal and Palacios and Rosarena and
Garcia, that leads us to the next Cardinals problem. St. Louis being as good at developing
hitters as they are reducing the city's crime rate. Now I'm no hitting coach or coach of literally
anything, but when you constantly have a flow of hitters who don't find success or reach their
full potential that you then trade or move on from them only for them to find that success
and potential in other organizations, I think your organization is just really bad at developing
hitters. Just a theory, though. We already went over Garcia, Randy, and Palacios and O'Neal is
something Cardinals General Manager John Mosalak even predicted and joked about over the offseason,
saying with a grin that O'Neal will probably get MVP votes on the team he's traded to before
acknowledging they've made mistakes with trades, but saying that they're human and they're not
going to bat 1,000. Which is totally fine. You may not bat 1,000. Nobody will. That's okay.
The issue is when you're batting 100. And speaking of Tyler O'Neal and his final days as a Cardinal
leading to his redemption in Boston, that leads us to the next issue. The manager. I didn't know
anything about Oliver Marmell when he was strangely hired to replace Mike Schilt after leading the
team to the postseason, and I still don't know too much other than the fact that he's probably
the last manager I'd ever want to play for. He seems to call every one of his own players out.
He gives off this vibe that he's the man, that he's the coolest guy in the room or field or
wherever the hell he is. He's disrespectful, even to literal old security guards who mean no harm.
Oh, and yeah, the team sucks with him. That's kind of important too. Last year,
Marmell went all in on Tyler O'Neal for not hustling around third base on a play at the
plate. Yeah, we got a lot of guys playing really hard. That's not our style of play as far as the
effort rounding the bag there. Um, saying that they have a lot of guys playing really hard and
that's not their style of play as far as the effort rounding the bag in that instance,
calling it unacceptable. O'Neal didn't take too kindly to that, fighting back a little against
what his manager said by saying he's out there every day grinding his ass off and giving it his
all and trying to stay on the field for 162 games, while also acknowledging that he's got to get a
better jump next time and get around the base a little quicker to be safe next time. So I think
O'Neal was just thinking he had a rough time getting a good jump rather than the idea he
wasn't hustling, saying he was trying to take a tight turn. And when watching what he did,
it doesn't really seem like someone who isn't hustling. It's not that blatant. And I mean,
look at how he's built. It's pretty blatant that he wouldn't be a very fast guy. And what's also
blatant is what Marmol did this season, specifically calling out Paul Goldschmidt and Nolan Gorman as
guys who aren't hitting doubles and homers, that they just aren't hitting basically. And although
that is true, Marmol just seems very unprofessional with the way he handles things like this. We all
know those two guys aren't hitting, guys who are supposed to be your two best hitters, but it's
not like they aren't trying. I'm no manager, obviously, but wouldn't it be better to keep
something so direct like this in-house rather than publicly dragging their names through the mud?
The best thing Marmol has ever done for this team was get ejected in a game recently,
which led to the Cardinals coming back to win. He had to leave the dugout, so they won.
How's that contract extension you gave to Oliver Marmol before this season looking right about now?
Just like Paul Goldschmidt, all of a sudden, which has to be the most bizarre thing this season.
From his rookie season on, Goldschmidt has arguably been the most consistent hitter in
baseball. He's that amazing. He's rarely dealt with injuries, has been so reliable to stay on
the field, has never had an OPS below 800. From 2011 through 2023, his first 13 years in the
league, Goldie had a career 908 OPS, 7 all-star appearances, 4 gold gloves at first base, 5 silver
sluggers, an MVP award. I mean, there hasn't been any sign of injury or crazy regression,
at least not to a point where he's unplayable. His 2023 season was a drop-off from his MVP 2022
season, but he was still continuing his run of being the most consistent hitter in baseball.
This year, the drop-off and sudden collapse is so bizarre that it's like Paul Goldschmidt died
and some decoy or humanoid took over. Because whoever this is looks like Paul Goldschmidt,
but he's most certainly not acting like Paul Goldschmidt. Paul Goldschmidt doesn't look like
a pitcher trying to hit. He never has. Yet all of a sudden, he's now ungodly awful. And yes,
regression comes with age, but not this bad and this drastic. Nolan Arenado has also shown some
decline, not as steep as Goldie, but the overall idea that the Cardinals need to rely on these two
guys is similar to the idea of how they built their starting rotation. It's not sustainable.
It doesn't show any sign of a promising future and long-term window at winning, as you're relying on
aging veterans who may never be what they once were. They probably won't. And it also doesn't
help that nobody else is hitting other than Wilson Contreras, who, oh yeah, broke his arm recently.
And a couple of the Cardinals new guys, Jordan Walker, who's in his second year, and Victor Scott,
who's a rookie, both hitters, both had to be sent down to AAA. Jordan Walker was once the fourth
best-ranked prospect in not just the Cardinals organization, no, in all of baseball. It's only
a matter of time before they both get traded to other teams and start thriving. That's how this
tends to work, right? I mean, trusting any promising hitter in the hands of the St. Louis
Cardinals to develop is like trusting Jeffrey Dahmer to babysit your children at this point.
So where the hell do the Cardinals go from here? Blow it up. What they have going right now is
clearly not working for any aspect of the organization. They're in the top half of
payroll in baseball, yet have a terrible team. The farm system, like I said earlier, is in the
bottom tier. The front office has been losing virtually every trade that they make. They can't
seem to develop hitters into what they're supposed to be. It's time to start over, and it starts in
the front office. Get a new leader there, a new decision maker, get a new manager, start billing
to a better and younger team. All things easier said than done, obviously. And I'm certainly no
expert on anything, but it's clear what they currently have just isn't doing it. Especially
when you see the potential the rest of the division has and is already showing. Potential
to be good this year, and for years to come. So this new era you speak of may just be dead
on arrival. Let me know what you think. Thank you for watching, and I'll see you soon.
