Michael Bright on The Federal Reserve, Housing Market

Finance Fortress
301 followers
2 Video Views·Mar 21, 2024
Michael Bright, Structured Finance Association CEO, discusses the Federal Reserve deciding to hold rates steady and if they are running the risk of forcing the US economy into a recession. He also talks about the concern with the housing market, the housing supply problem, and commercial real estate. Michael Bright speaks with Kailey Leinz and Joe Mathieu on Bloomberg's "Balance of Power."
Is the Federal Reserve running the risk with higher for longer of forcing this economy
into a recession and an eye on the housing market, which I know you're watching?
Yeah.
Well, I think that they have to take that risk.
I mean, I think that I've been in the camp that they are going to stay a little bit higher
for longer.
I noticed that, you know, the dot plots today suggested three cuts, but on the precipice
of only suggesting two, it's very clear that they're doing exceptionally well on one side
of their mandate.
Unemployment is very, very low, and that's great.
CPI and PCE continue to be sticky high.
I think the Fed actually faced potentially a credibility crisis last year with their
miss in terms of thinking that inflation would be very transient.
So they really had no choice.
I think they're going to need to, you know, continue to watch the data.
But it could tip the economy into a recession.
It's been a very anticipated recession that the yield curve has been planning for, that
markets have been planning for.
It's yet to arrive.
But I think they're doing the right thing by staying the course and looking at the inflation
data as it comes in.
Well, of course, there is no shortage of political commentary around Federal Reserve policy.
And what you've consistently heard, especially from progressive lawmakers initially, was
concern that rates were going to stay too high and it was going to impact the labor
market.
When it was clear that labor market impact wasn't happening, it seems that a lot of that
messaging has now shifted to housing and the fact that it's very unaffordable, that mortgage
rates are incredibly high.
How much concern do you have about where we are in housing right now and how much risk
may be out there?
Yeah, for sure.
This rate lock effect is a real thing where people have three and a half percent mortgages
and so they don't want to sell their home and they're kind of stuck in their house.
And so inventory is very low for the last two buying seasons.
Just anecdotally, you drive around, you know, Maryland, Virginia, D.C. area, you see no
for sale signs.
Oh, believe me, I know it's tough.
This year I came in optimistic.
I said people have to get on with their lives, right?
People have things that change.
They can change jobs, they can move, et cetera.
So this has to be finally a breaking point.
Well, the weather's pretty nice and I'm still not seeing any for sale signs out there.
So the rate lock effect may have a little bit more time to run.
As far as the rate impact, if we can find a little bit of a range, which I think that
we have, so 10-year note spiked to five, but then it kind of came back down in the 4.3
area and it's sort of holding steady in that regard.
If that continues, mortgage spread should come in a little bit and that could be a little
bit of relief on the rate front.
But it's really a supply problem at the end of the day.
We heard from the White House on this and the president's out with a series of proposals
to try to unlock some of the stuff we're talking about in the housing market.
Kayleigh and I spoke with National Economic Council Deputy Director Daniel Hornan about
this.
We discussed what needs to happen to improve the housing market.
This is the view of the White House.
Let's listen.
I think we really need an approach on housing policy that goes at putting incentives in
place to add to the supply of housing.
So his plan that he's sent to Congress would lead to the construction of two million homes.
But we also need to take action that goes at unlocking the housing market.
But of course it takes time to build two million homes, to get them cleared, to get them permitted.
It takes God knows how much time to get anything past Congress.
So is there anything that this administration can do now?
They're working around the edges.
I mean, they're trying to make some things cheaper and I think this realtor settlement
could be a game changer in terms of cost.
But again, he's right and I agree it is a supply problem.
I think not having housing supply in the infrastructure bill that did pass when the president first
took office was a major miss.
I don't have any particular party to blame for that.
I just think that that was a real mistake.
Everyone has known that this has been an affordable supply problem for a very long time.
A lot of that is at the local and state level.
It looks like the president is making some pitch for tax credits and subsidies to try
and encourage the development of low income housing or at least affordable housing.
All of that is good, but the nimbyism is real.
This is a pretty sticky problem.
I do worry that we may be entering almost a European style generational shift here where
kids live with their parents until their 30s and it takes a long time to get that first
home.
I really don't want to get stuck in that trap, but it would take a pretty concerted national
effort to build housing supply.
And of course, this is all in the residential real estate realm, but there has been a lot
of concern in commercial real estate as well, including increasingly in commercial real
estate CLOs, collateralized loan obligations.
Basically you bundle all of this risky debt together.
And yet in just the last seven months, according to our reporting, the share of troubled assets
held by these CRE CLO products has surged fourfold to more than 7.4%.
Should we be concerned by that?
Well, I think commercial real estate is a broad term.
So office space is obviously struggling quite a bit, and it's still very unclear when that
finally works its way through the system.
Anecdotally, we're in a lease that we've been in as a seven-year lease, and we still have
two years on it, so we're paying a run on time, but I guarantee you we're going to look
for a cheaper lease when that changes.
So it's a slow moving train in the office space sector.
Hotels, leisure, industry, shopping centers, moving up the suburbs, those commercial real
estate products have been doing very well.
So I'm not in the camp that there's some sort of ticking time bomb out there.
I think people have been looking for this shoe to drop for a very long time, and it
hasn't.
That doesn't mean we shouldn't be vigilant and continue to watch it.
I think we just have to work through this sort of structural shift that we're going
through in society in terms of the way we relate to work from office, working downtown.
Downtowns are obviously dealing with a lot.
I think crime, especially in D.C., this has been an overhang on some of these things.
So you've got a lot of macro factors that are at play here that all need to be brought
to solution in order to avoid anything catastrophic.
But it's worth watching.
I just am not in the camp that this is an immediate threat.
