Committee vote on I-2111 (prohibiting state and local income tax)

Washington State House Republicans
23 followers
Mar 1, 2024 #waleg #fixwashington
The House Finance Committee takes executive action on Initiative 2111 (prohibiting a state and local income tax). The initiative passed the committee by a 7-5 vote. #waleg #fixwashington
For more information on I-2111, view our summary of the initiative here: https://houserepublicans.wa.gov/i-2111/
good
morning welcome to house finance we'll
be executing House Bill
2111 staff we'll give the briefing um
initiative
2111 prohibits the state counties cities
and local and other local jurisdictions
from opposing a tax on any form of an
individual's gross income for the
purposes of the initiative gross income
has the same meaning as provided in the
federal tax code the effective date is
90 days after the German Obsession which
is passed there are no
amendments thank you so much are there
any questions for
staff seeing none we are going to break
for caucus um I expect that we will
return at
8:45 where it
EAS welcome back to house
finance we are back in
order Vice chair
Street
I move that house initiative
2111 be reported out of committee with a
doe pass recommendation it's been moved
and seconded that house initiative 2111
be reported out of committee with a do
pass recommendation are there
amendments there are not discussion
representative
Jacobson thank you madam chair so
recommending a yes uh this initiative is
the culmination of a lot of signature
gathering at fairs and hard work on the
part of many people and I'm glad that
this is being brought forward Washington
is only one of nine states that does not
have an income tax and it gives us a
competitive advantage in many ways um
states that don't have an income tax
Tennessee Florida Texas have been
enjoying an influx of people and
commerce and and it's just
generated uh good Economic Times for
them um we have 11 times
voted against an income tax in this
state we have a long history of not
wanting an income tax since
1934 um and indeed our
constitution uh because of the
uniformity Clause because we can only
tax property at 1% and evenly up to
1% and income is considered property a a
progressive income tax in this state
would actually be
unconstitutional and so to honor the
will of the 435,000 people who signed
that initiative um I think we should
give this a vote and I for one am voting
yes on this thank
you thank you so much
um I too will be a yes on this
particular um initiative a couple things
one um it was made very clear by the
testimony that we heard uh earlier this
week that this particular initiative um
does not touch or change any of our
current taxes or tax statutes uh that
was very important to me um also for
future Tax and Revenue options or
opportunities it does not hamper that as
well um as our as uh representative
Jacobson pointed out we don't have an
income tax um we as a body since I've
been here have not considered or thought
about an income tax um this initiative
seems uh frankly unnecessary in a lot of
ways but I understand that sometimes the
unnecessary um becomes what you're
dealing with at the moment and so as a
result um I will be a yes what I will
say as chair I know that not everyone uh
on the committee will be a yes in this
moment um but as chair I've tried to be
very fair in looking at this initiative
from the people um having a hearing
calling balls and Strikes making sure
that the process is done that's that
sort that informs my yes on this um but
I will say for the the people of our
state this is an initiative that truly
as we say as I say yes to it there will
be no changes um to our current tax
statutes or tax laws um nor is this the
result of anything the legislature had
considered in terms of taxing uh taxing
income so uh again a yes but um still
thinking this is a little bit
unnecessary further
comments seeing none oh did you want
okay I just you know representative
Willcox thank you madam chair and uh I
want to start by uh complimenting you on
the hearing that you presided over that
that was a high stress hearing uh there
were some some I don't know some things
that
um maybe were technical problems but I I
thought that you handled those with with
Grace uh you had some tense moments in
that hearing and I thought I don't think
I could have handled that uh like uh
like you did and uh this was a fair
hearing I've talked with Ed about that
too when when people uh decided not to
uh testify he thought that you were
being being very fair and uh making
every effort to get people on and uh
that hearing kept the initial comments
to a minimum so that we could have lots
of public input I I want whoever watches
this to know that Republicans and
Democrats both felt like that was a a
fair hearing um I listened to your
comments about this being uh an
initiative that maybe doesn't make uh
much difference uh it turns out that's
not the only thing that we voted on this
year that won't end up making a
difference we have a lot of bills that
are like that so I don't think that
disqualifies this in the least and it
may be that it was no one's intent to
offer uh an income tax uh this year and
may maybe there's no cities that want to
do that too I can't read their mind but
the fact that so many people out there
thought that there was uh is an
illustration I think of the disconnect
that we had have and uh whenever we have
an opportunity to let voters know that
um despite our faults uh we're going to
listen to them I think that's uh an
opportunity that we ought to be taking
and I appreciate the fact that this
committee is doing that
now thank you so much seeing no further
discussion staff will call the
role
representative Berg Berg votes I
representative Berg votes I
representative Street no without
recommendation representative Street
votes nay without recommendation
representative
orcot right
excused representative
Jacobson
yes representative Jacobson votes I
representative
Bernard Barnard votes I
representative barard votes I
representative
chop representative chop votes nay
without recommendation Representative
raml no without recommendation
representative raml votes nay without
recommendation representative Santos
Santos votes no without recommendation
representative Santos votes nay without
recommendation representative Springer I
representative Springer votes I
representative
Tai yes representative
Wallen representative will Cox I
representative will Cox votes I
representative Wy Wy votes I
representative Wy votes I representative
Tha no without recommendation
representative Tha votes nay without
recommendation any member wishing to
change their vote on the standing
committee report form please do so
verbally staff will announce the vote
Madam chair we have seven I's five Nays
and one excused by your vote initiative
2111 is reported of committee with a due
pass recommendation house finances
adjourned
