Community Benefits Plans: From Concept to Implementation

U.S. Department of Energy
60 followers
Feb 1, 2024
This Office of Manufacturing & Energy Supply Chains (MESC) webinar presents an overview on the keys to successful implementation of a Community Benefits Plans (CBP). DOE requires a CBP for all BIL and IRA Funding Opportunity Announcements and loan applications. This webinar will provide a guide to help you reduce risks of opposition and delays, while maximizing benefits and long-term success. In this webinar, you'll learn about the four CBP priorities:
1: Justice 40,
2: Job Quality and Workforce Continuity, and
3: Diversity, Equity, Inclusion, and Accessibility,
4: Community and Labor Engagement, and more.
Get help understanding the purpose and goals of the Community Benefits Plan and where to go for technical support.
we're all here okay sorry uh sorry for
the technical difficulties uh with this
what I'm going to I'm going to blame it
on the platform um I am betney Jones I'm
really happy to be here today thank you
Hank for inviting me uh I'm gonna share
some slides with
you about Community benefits plans and
specifically uh what we're looking for
uh as it relates to jobs Workforce and
labor
engagement so let's see if this
[Music]
works hopefully you can all see that our
moderators will tell me if you
can't so looks great thank you okay
great so by way of introduction uh my
name is betney Jones I'm the director
for Doe's office of energy jobs and also
labor adviser to secretary granholm the
office of energy jobs was established at
the beginning of the B Administration to
ensure that this clean energy transition
for which we have these historic
Investments which you're the lucky
recipients of uh will lead to high
quality jobs meaning above average wages
and benefits worker protections health
and safety investments in Education and
Training and really generally lead to to
broadly shared Prosperity uh to
demonstrate that with this energy
transition and we work specifically to
execute the policy of the federal
government to support worker organizing
and collective bargaining in the energy
sector make sure that workers have a
free and fair chance to join or form a
union and that's one measure of of job
quality
Advance okay so the objectives today um
first of all uh congratulations to all
of you for being selected for what is
pretty competitive funding that is uh
and the proposals are assessed along all
sorts of uh criteria technical criteria
Financial feasibility commercial
feasibility all these things but also uh
and something that's new for doe is the
is the community benefits plans that you
put together and so what I want to take
the opportunity today to do is to review
the the purpose of the community
benefits plans and how it's designed to
really support
effective project
implementation and then to help um go
through at a slightly deeper level uh
what's important in terms of quality
jobs diversity Equity inclusion and
access community and labor engagement
and the resulting accountability to
those stakeholders and then I have uh
some you know where to go for more
information we can't cover everything in
an hour uh where to go for no cost
bespoke individualized technical support
we have a contract with UC Berkeley for
that and uh and then we have time we'll
have plenty of time for Q&A and
discussion so save your
questions and uh and we'll open it up
when I finish going through these
slides so first about cbps hopefully
some of this is redundant for a lot of
you um the purpose behind cbps is that
uh as we shift as an agency from an R&D
organization to a deployment
organization an infrastructure agency we
really have to think differently about
our work and we know that there's some
keys to successful implementation that
go beyond just the technology Merit like
the merits of the technology or the the
the business um the business case that
you have for your product um because
these projects once once they get to the
implementation phase they're place-based
in communities with real impacts and the
community's impacts that can be positive
or impacts that can be negative and uh
and cause opposition or delays to your
project and so the way that we've
designed the community benefits plan is
really to reduce any of those risks of
implementation and really maximize the
benefits uh to affected stakeholders as
well as to you and your investors
maximize the benefits in a in a way
that's broadly shared uh and in so doing
kind of build support for more of these
types of Investments and project ensure
long-term success not just of your
project but of this transition generally
and that by building in these Community
benefits and RI mitigating risks that's
how we're really building support for
implementation demonstrating that this
transition can work for everyone and so
I put up there the the secretary's quote
which articulates this virtuous cycle
the more people realize the benefits of
these historic Investments uh the more
support we will get for more of this
kind of uh this kind of policy and these
kind of federal
Investments so uh just to recap the doe
requires a community benefits plan for
all Bill and Ira uh and uh uh Grant and
Loan uh projects and these are based on
the administration's policy priorities
specifically the
administration's equity and Justice
priorities and the administration's
priorities around creating good quality
jobs that are accessible to uh to
workers including those already in the
energy industry and those who've been
long left
behind um these are intentionally
flexible uh to
make sure that these Community benefits
plans um facilitate maximum success for
your project mitigate risks that are
specific to your project and maximize
success um but in order to work within
that flexible system the community
benefits plans commitments need to be
and at this phase that you're in now
need to get increasingly specific
actionable and measurable at the time of
The Proposal you're putting some thought
down it's sort of conceptual at this
stage and going forward we're really
trying to solidify and specify and put
more meat on those bones um so cbps were
scored as part of your proposal about I
think 20% for both of the programs that
we're talking about today and uh and
that's that's significant uh you know it
can push a project above or below below
that that cut off threshold and so these
are really important it just indicates
how important this is to uh project
successful project implementation and
then at this stage going forward the
commitments that you made in your
proposal phase get strengthened get
solidified in order to really realize
those benefits and then they become part
of the contractual
obligations uh as a as recipients of
Federal funding so uh bit more on that
we're looking for smart uh commitments
specific measurable suable realistic and
time based um as I already said these
were valued at you know 20% of the score
of the proposals and then they become uh
required uh contractual obligations
going forward and then over the life of
the award doe will collect data from you
collect reporting data evaluate progress
and this factors into different go noo
decision points about uh relative to
continued funding so the community
benefits plan has four priorities I
think you know this so I'm not going to
spend a lot of time on it justice 40 is
really how are we ensuring that benefits
ACR to disadvantaged communities this
isn't just about being placed in a
disadvantaged community there can be a
lot of ways to distribute benefits to
disadvantage communities sometimes those
aren't even Geographic
designations um job quality and
Workforce continuity the goal here is
really how are we creating good enough
jobs high quality jobs that will attract
and retain skilled workers in what is
today like rather tight and competitive
labor market so we need to be
considering that upfront and also how
are we investing in workers to ensure
success of this energy transition long
term uh on the diversity Equity
inclusion and access we're really
looking for how to ensure Equitable
access to the wealth building
opportunities created from these
Investments meaning access to good jobs
or business or Contracting opportunities
and then on the community and labor
engagement side what we're really
looking for here is accountability not
just to doe not just to the taxpayers
but the communities and the workers
involved in the project affected by
project
implementation and so yet what we will
require reporting uh over time and it
will factor into our go no-go decision
points we recognize that the real impact
and the real accountability is to the
stakeholders affected by your project
and so that meaningful engagement is
really looking what we're really looking
for is that that engagement will lead to
enforceable Community benefits
agreements or Community Workforce
agreements agreements with Partners in
the community and that's really
important uh again for accountability
for transparency for ultimately building
support for your project so
understanding what the community wants
what are the what are their concerns
Returns what are the benefits that
they'd like to see these are all really
important things um for you know
mitigating any risks of delays or
stoppages or
opposition so I'm going to focus a bit
more on the job quality and Workforce
continuity parts of the community
benefits plans and thanks for putting in
questions we'll address those at the end
um so save them uh so what we're looking
for at this stage is really you know
detailed commitments on uh on the
quality of the jobs that you're creating
and a good indicator of job quality is
above average wages and benefits we're
really looking increasingly at that 75th
percentile in above uh as reported by
BLS for the for the industry and the
occupation um that's what sort of
signifies good quality jobs and in this
really competitive labor market where
we're not only competing your project
isn't only competing with other uh
Employers in the energy sector but also
other sectors completely we really need
to attract you know indicate to workers
that these are jobs that they're going
to want that they're going to want to
stay in and high uh wages and benefits
do that second we're really looking for
Investments employer Investments and
also Partnerships and Workforce
Education and Training some of these are
new technologies that we don't have
really coherent training programs for so
we're looking at how do we connect
Workforce Development uh Workforce
Education and Training to the project at
hand and support Pathways for worker
advancement so that we can really grow a
skilled Workforce as we're implementing
then health and safety is just really
key and we know from experience that
worker participation in health and
safety plan design and implementation
really leads to better
outcomes um and then finally and and
significantly what is the affirmative
support for worker organizing and
collective bargaining it is the declared
policy of the US federal government to
support worker organizing and collective
bargaining to make sure that there's a
balanced uh playing field between labor
and management is of course workers
Choice whether or not they want to form
or join a union but how employers
respond to that choice or facilitate
that choice is pretty important and so
this is a really high priority of the
the administration and we're looking for
pretty strong uh commitments to do that
again flexible um but we do want to know
that workers rights uh are being honored
and
protected and then on the Dei a as it
relates to jobs we know that workers
there's workers who really Bas face
barriers to employment uh there's
there's systemic barriers access to
Transportation access to child care
um other barriers that workers face and
so we're sort of we're looking for
employers to think well what can we do
to reduce some of those barriers and
ensure that we're recruiting and hiring
a more diverse Workforce and that can
really happen effectively through
Partnerships with community- based
organizations labor unions community
colleges but also through benef benefits
plans like the provision of child care
or child care support or access to
Transportation Transportation vouchers
how do you reduce some of those barriers
that workers
face um so I sort of already went
through the importance of community
engagement and what we're looking for
there really meaningful engagement that
where you understand what do
stakeholders in in your care about what
do they want to see and how can that be
formalized in Legally enforceable
agreements with the community where
you're making commitments they're making
commitments and
there's um baked into these Agreements
are sort of remedies for non-compliance
your committing things communities
committing to things what happens if it
goes south and so these uh these
commitments can look like there's a wide
range of of uh of agreements Community
benefits agreements um uh uh Good
Neighbor agreements Community Workforce
agreements uh project labor agreements
also can include many of these benefits
to the community so again lots of
flexibility
there so to go a little bit deeper on
the job quality and Workforce continuity
I thought it might be worth just um
defining Workforce continuity it's
really about minimizing risks that would
contribute to work stoppage stop
stopping or work force shortages and so
work stoppages can occur to health and
safety incidents due to unsafe working
conditions or inadequate training uh
strikes lockouts or disagreements that
go
and or Workforce shortages and those can
occur due to high turnover and
insufficient recruitment low quality
jobs that lead to that higher turnover a
failure to retain a skilled Workforce
insufficient investment in skill
development insufficient recruitment uh
inadequate upskilling programs for
incumbent workers and then those
barriers to to uh to education and
employment that are keeping some workers
on the sidelines and so these are the
things we're trying to minimize uh
through asking for a job quality and
Workforce uh continuity
commitments so on job quality again
looking for support for worker
organizing and collective bargaining
this can but does not have to be a
pledge to remain neutral in the face of
a union organizing drive a commitment to
recognize um when a majority of workers
sign Union cards that's one opportunity
for Union recognition the other of
course is to do a nrlb election um card
check is the is the friendlier approach
for employers and then those commitments
to the high wages and commencement
benefits worker involvement in health
and safety plans investments in
Education and Training and then
Workforce continuity for construction we
have a bit more of a nuanced and uh
prescriptive approach although again
there are options for large construction
projects and I'll go into a bit more
detail we're really looking for
commitments to negotiate project labor
agreements which are sometimes also
called Community Workforce agreements uh
detailing local hire commitments and
opportunities for the local
Workforce uh and in lie of a project
labor agreement which checks for us a
number of boxes to to mitigate Workforce
risks associated with large complex
construction projects uh there's a
there's um a framework for a Workforce
continuity plan and I'll go into a
little bit of what that looks
like so for construction some of the
risks and challenges associated with
large construction that we're looking to
mitigate are delays in the project
timeline unexpected increases in Project
labor costs coordination challenges
across multiple contractors and
subcontractors compliance with federal
labor wage and equal opportunity laws
including Davis bacon compliance which
applies to all of our bill funded
projects um availability of an
appropriately skilled and trained
Workforce labor disputes public and
worker health and safety and so typical
project labor agreements tend to address
all of these risks and so they provide
for us a very strong indicator that
these risks are being mitigated that
there's a plan Upfront for addressing
and mitigating those risks in addition
to the risk mitigation there's often a
lot of other community benefits that can
be baked into a project labor agreement
so it checks multiple boxes it's a very
elegant tool and I think uh if you're
looking for sort of ways to
minimize um uh if you're if you're
dealing with constrainted capacity like
most of us are in this uh era uh a
project labor agreement is is sort of a
turnkey approach to to check a number of
boxes in one Fell Swoop um if there
isn't a project labor agreement we
really need to look for another way of
other ways of uh of being assured that
these risks are being addressed um I
will when we send out these slides
you'll have a link to really more
information about project labor
agreements there's a lot of
misinformation out there the Department
of Labor put together a really nice
guide um doe has some resources in
technical assistance which I'll show you
later um but uh but I would just say uh
plas are not something to be afraid of
um they're also like very very flexible
Tools in your
concerns uh whatever they may be uh
canot can can usually be addressed in
the negotiation of those agreements and
so um so they're they're
non-prescriptive um it doesn't mean that
all of the workers have to be Union it
doesn't mean that all of the contractors
have to be signatory uh they're just
agreements for how uh how the how the
the project proponent is going to
mitigate those risks and ensure that
they have a skilled Workforce so there's
actually quite a lot of benefits to
developers and contractors of these and
I think the do resource
does a nice job of going through
those um in lie of a pla uh the federal
government and other agencies have used
this Workforce continuity plan so this
is fairly standard across agencies um
and it just details bullets for some of
those things that would otherwise be
addressed in a project labor agreement
um I think it's more work probably to
develop this um it's going to require
more
uh more thinking because it's not as not
as TurnKey but uh but it is an
alternative to ensure that you're taking
steps to to mitigate risks that we're
concerned about as stewards of taxpayer
money um on the operations
side uh I mentioned earlier that we're
really looking for those commitments to
support worker organizing and collective
bargaining um and uh and this is a
non-exhaustive list
um but we what we're asking for is
commitments to to to some of these
things uh commitment are remain neutral
a commitment to permit Union recognition
through card check if a if workers
decide to unionize a commitment to to
settle a contract with them um sometimes
there's delays there um some friendly
employers choose to allow Union
organizers access to lunchrooms and
break rooms and access to to talk with
workers um and then this kind of goes
along with neutrality but just
refraining from um from hiring
contractors or forcing employers to come
here uh the or forcing workers to come
here the employer uh position if it's
try if it's opposing Union organizing
and one of the laws uh governing uh
recipients of Federal funding is that
federal funds can't be used to support
or uh oppose Union organizing drive so
that's important to recognize that some
of these things you have to be very uh
careful anyway is a recipient of federal
funding that you're not using any uh any
of the funding from this project to uh
to oppose Union organizing uh so again
this is a non-exhaustive list of bullets
but it gives you a scense of some of the
stronger commitments that we're looking
for and then again those specific
commitments around wages and benefits
uh training
Investments uh and the health and safety
thinking about health and safety with
worker
participation so to get to uh some of
the additional details I put the
Department of Labor uh pla site um
earlier in the slides doe also has
resources we have a community benefits
plan template maybe this has already
been shared with you but it really is a
designed to make it easier for you it's
sort of like a check boxing box checking
like yes we will do this yes we will do
this um uh but to give you plenty of
these examples uh so you don't have to
kind of start from scratch in the
thinking and then we also provide and
continuously update uh frequently asked
questions which has quite a lot of
guidance suggestions recommendations for
how to address some of these goals and
priorities and then what we're coming
out with soon is a toolkit there's we
have an existing Community benefits
agreement toolkit from about 10 years
ago um maybe 12 years ago we're looking
to update that to one just update links
and whatnot and then also to expand it
to the community and Workforce
agreements that we're looking for now so
it's not just Community benefits
agreements but a more expansive Guide to
the types of enforceable
agreements uh that we're looking
for so in terms of of technical
assistance we have a contract with UC
Berkeley Labor Center to provide no cost
technical assistance to stakeholders
interested in developing and
implementing the job quality and skilled
Workforce components of the community
benefits so if you want um if you want
guidance you know specific to your
project they have a network of of real
experts across the country so depending
on what your issue is or your question
is they can connect you to an
appropriate uh person and the link uh
they have an intake form uh which is
linked from this uh link on this
slide and with that uh I will open it up
to to answer questions and uh clarify
anything
thanks just a reminder that by
participating in the Q&A session um the
the webinar today is being recorded So
you are allowing your questions and or
your voice and photos or videos to be
recorded I saw some questions coming
through the chat so if it would be
helpful I can just start
with with some of those sure betney
please go ahead and I also have um
elevated Heather rhods and Tom glass who
each had their hands raised oh great
okay well let's start with those
then
Heather
or Tom maybe they're having some AV
issues I'm here I'm good I I thought you
were gonna start with her so I was just
yeah I she I can't hear her so why don't
you go ahead Tom yeah no problem so you
mentioned Community benefits during the
award period um and and I'm assuming the
award period you're referring to is
whatever your budget periods are over
the next you know two years whatever it
happens to be is there an expectation on
when the the benefit portion is supposed
to commence is it at the end of it what
you know when the project is is near
completion or is the intent is that
obviously we're going to make inroads
during the process but is Our intention
to be
already uh donating or committing to
these organizations uh early on in the
process uh I don't think
donating um I do think engaging like I
think it's important at this stage to be
talking to uh labor and Community
representatives to understand to to
convey information about your
project understand their
concerns understand their wishes um and
really engage in a process with them so
that once uh once everything in terms of
the grant
agreement is signed sealed and delivered
then you at that point you hit the
ground running and so there's quite a
lot to to figure out
process-wise and once the you know once
you're selected and go into this
negotiation phase that's a really good
time to be engaging in that
process yeah okay I I just want so the
reason I I mentioned donating is because
part of our community benefits is actual
charity and nonprofit philanthropy um
but yeah I understand the labor portion
of it is going to be something that
we're involved in you know as part of
the startup so yeah that that that part
of it is built in I was asking I guess
more from from the you know depending on
how your project is set up yeah so I
mean I think that the the donating to
charity organizations that's not as much
what we're looking for I mean if that's
a negotiated
uh result of a community benefits plan
then that's that's a different story but
we're really not looking
for uh funding recipients to to just
make
donations um as a box checking exercise
especially if that donation isn't really
related to project success so you'll see
that a lot of things that we're asking
for it's not just making unrelated um
donations to I'm not saying you're doing
this but you know to a food bank or an
animal shelter or something it's really
to connect it back to project
implementation yeah yeah no no
understood I understand that part
because yeah we have we have all those
other dynamics that obviously has to
start during the process so I just
wanted to have some clarity on that so I
do have other questions I'll let he go
thanks
okay looks like we've got Heather's
audio back Heather I'm GNA send you an
un
request sorry about that can you hear me
yes uh so um since you mentioned the 20%
on the scoring I'm wondering if that is
a benchmark or is there any guidance as
to uh sort of the portion of the federal
dollars that are devoted towards the um
the tasks under the CBP
um there is not I mean all of this is
going to be Project Specific and what is
going to be important to advance uh
successful implementation of your
project so I wouldn't I I don't the the
20% for scoring that's uh water under
the bridge at this point that's how you
got here um but in terms of thinking
about uh using a percentage of the
project budget for Community benefits
that is going to be that's going to just
depend on your particular situation um
in some
ways you could not spend a single
additional dime on community benefits
plans um because what we're looking for
is you know um uh on uh on
uh um sorry I'm like a Str going to come
up with the right example
uh we're just looking for like
information about your business model
like how are you going to attract and
restain a skilled Workforce if you're
saying that um well we now like we're
not asking you to pay higher wages just
as part of a community benefits plan
we're asking you to think about the
wages you're paying as part of your your
project plan your project implementation
plan and likewise benefits to
disadvantaged community
can be things like red reduction of
pollution access to the jobs that you're
creating
anyway um and the same with Dei it's
like how are you doing the work you're
doing and it's not so much related to
how much money you're spending I don't
think how much money you spend on this
is the best indicator of success it's
how engaged is the community in the in
the projects
implementation and that you know well
you might might need a little bit of
Staff resources to put time into that it
doesn't automatically mean that you have
to pass money through to some charitable
organization in the
community Heather did that answer your
question yeah go
ahead you have your hand up again yeah
sorry I didn't know how to re uh re
unmute myself but um just a little
followup in terms of the 40% um benefits
flow are we going to be tracking that um
on a dollar basis so we need to figure
out ways to to make sure we see that
much of the award money as benefits to
disadvantaged communities no no no you
won't track that and and actually the uh
the 40% is um is an Administration wide
goal and wide goal and so it's not
necessarily um like it doesn't
necessarily flow down 40% exactly to
every individual project um of course it
is important what it indicates is that
is it it is important to think about how
benefits are flowing to disadvantaged
communities but again those benefits
might be access to jobs or access to
training or opportunities for minority
contractors to participate and so it's
not uh tracking those benefits or
pollution reduction so tracking those
benefits it's not about tracking
specific dollars okay that was okay cool
yeah and then just uh logistically since
we have deadlines coming up um some of
the links you were sharing earlier uh
how soon can we get access to those and
will you have any kind of Q&A from this
for
us um like a written Q&A like a
transcript of this of this
conversation
sure um well this recording will be
provided we can also send out the slides
I right after this uh and so you'll have
those access to those links and um great
I I can drop my email in the chat if you
and I can email you them directly as
well we want to make sure that you have
access to the resources that you need
great okay thank
you
y other questions that people want to
ask um verbally otherwise I can go to
the what's written in the
chat may I is is it my turn now sorry it
is we have a few more folks betany I'll
be fing them up through okay well thank
you so much for pushing this uh uh for
us it's I really appreciate your efforts
one one uh uh doubt that I have is how I
mean if you could elaborate a little bit
more on the flexibility to adjust the
community benefits plan as as we go on
we really believe in a in a strong
Community participation I I would say
you if you if you don't have the
community proud of what you are doing I
always believe on this thing you you can
have whatever licenses you want you
never going to get a business so we we
really want to do the best we can in
terms of community Benefit Plan uh and
in uh but and we have obviously as part
of our application uh what we believe it
is a good community plan uh to be
implemented where we we are going to be
now uh we obviously don't know we
granularity all the institutions there
and uh and we may find out others so
would it be possible to allocate
resources as as we commit with a with a
community Benefit Plan without
specifying precisely which institutions
and which plan so we have a we have a
way to adjust this on the goal or you
want to have the plan cast in concrete
before we sign the agreement how how
much how how much flexibility would have
to to adjust this on on the goal
yeah um that's a really good question um
so we are looking over this period of
negotiations to make these plan to turn
these plans that were submitted at the
time of a proposal that were more
conceptual into something more concrete
so that once the contract is signed then
the implementation of that plan begins
and so it's pretty important to ident
identify stakeholders and at least a
process for how you going to work
together um like anou is a good uh would
be a good interim step say like I'll
just use um as an example Community
Workforce agreement maybe you don't know
the exact location of your project um
and so you
can't you can't actually sign a project
labor agreement or community Workforce
agreement yet anou outlining how you
would negotiate that and with whom would
be a good indicator of
progress that then once the everything
is signed and finalized in terms of your
Grant uh
agreement then you're executing on
thatou and so we can't uh like there's
certain things that are unreasonable to
do at certain phases um for example if
you don't have uh if you have to build a
facility then you then you're not going
to have um you're not going to have your
permanent Workforce for a while but you
can still think
about uh actions that you'll take to
ensure opportunities for local and
disadvantaged workers as you
build when you're ready to hire that
permanent
Workforce and it's important to make
those things very concrete and specific
and measurable in this negotiation phase
because that's
where um because because then you'll
have these
Milestones on the implementation that we
can check on but if you wait till
implementation to develop the milestones
we we lose the uh the accountability
these things are you know the community
benefits plans are important they're
scored there were things proposed at the
application phase those are the things
that we're looking to solidify and
strengthen now before implementation
begins okay perfect thank
you looks like Chuck is up next yes
thank you for for taking my questions
are these charts available to us after
the
webinar yeah we will make these slides
available okay okay thank you and then
is pla only during construction phase of
the project or will it be required
during the operational phase that's once
we get into a pla is
construction yeah a pla is a unique uh
type of agreement uh that is used only
in construction it's a preh hire
agreement the time to really think about
and start discussing a pla is really
before you have an EPC or general
contractor
hired um it's early early early in the
stage and part of the reason for that is
um that there's a lot of construction
happening right now doe funded private
funded other agencies are funding it lot
of competition for workers a
pla uh a commitment to do a
pla uh starts the Workforce Development
process letting more people in to
registered apprenticeship so that by the
time that cons ruction activity begins
we can we're assured that there's going
to be a Workforce available it really
solves that uh that problem or concern
around where you're going to find
available workers but it's only a pla
only ever applies to
construction okay and then uh you
mentioned about uh resources available
with the UC Berkeley now do we have to
go through doe to contact those
resources or how do what's the process
for that yeah they have a um I can
actually drop the link in the chat so
you have it outside of the
uh slides that we'll share uh they have
a an intake form so you can did that go
through yes that did go up okay I didn't
see it um yeah they have an intake form
so you can
connect said they have a big network of
technical assistance providers so
depending on your question or issue they
can connect you to the to somebody who
can work with you more
directly okay and that's um that's just
that's just because you know some of
this is new like it it can be helpful
just to have sort of a neutal party um
where you can
ask silly questions or not silly
questions but just somebody who is a
real expert who can walk you through um
best practices do you there's a question
in the chat about providing best
practice rest best practice examples doe
isn't allowed to do that um but that's a
good question for a technical assistance
provider so that they can give you
specific examples that might be
appropriate for your
project and um I think January 4th or so
is what has been uh given to us uh to
submit the community benefits plan um
would there be any further leniency in
that date or uh is that pretty much set
in
stone yeah uh yeah this is Hank uh
coming on B I can answer that yeah for
now let's shoot for that fourth date the
fourth is the one we want to get the our
versions back because it does you no
good to wait to submit it later uh let's
see what let's see what you have on the
fourth and then we'll work from there is
that okay
bany
yeah this is uh this is a from what I
understand and Hank is Hank is the the
messenger is the this is an iterative
process correct right I mean we're
trying to do something new At Doe a lot
of this is new for you guys and so
there's there's just some back and forth
um and that's what we've seen with other
projects too so the fourth is a is an
important interim deadline um but there
will be uh for iterations of what you
submit and just to re I can't say enough
uh what betany said is 100% accurate
right first and foremost what you said
in the application you were going to do
you have to do and whenever we the
thought is that
between that time and this January 4th
as much of what you could solidify
solidify and and and if you can't
solidify at all we have to discuss that
in your community benefits about how
you're going to how you're going to
solidify it if you can't solidify
something quickly but there has to be
measurable parameters and I'll go back
to the single statement if you said you
were going to do it you have to do it so
you're that that uh updated Community
benefits plan you're working on now has
to reflect what you've already said
you're going to do and if you over this
time you you figure out that you can do
more it would document that more as well
okay yeah figure out if you can do more
or put more meat on the bones like
sometimes there's uh you know it's
moving from the conceptual to the the
implementable um the other thing that
I'll say and I can't remember which
question this might be a response to but
talking to community organizations who
do have a lot of experience on
negotiating Community benefits
agreements or talking to labor unions
about plas it they say it usually takes
three
meetings like before you really start
speaking the same language and
understanding the win wins and the
partnersh ship
opportunities so reach out to folks like
there's just reach out to folks like
that's what we're asking for is that
those meetings are starting to happen
and that those convers like people are
starting to kind of speak the same
language and understand you know
Community understands your project you
understand what they have to offer to
improve your project or what they're
looking what they're concerned about uh
you just can't get there without having
those conversations
looks like Jason is up yeah can you hear
me um yeah so I uh you mentioned that
project labor Agreements are appropriate
for large construction projects um and
I'm wondering if you could quantify
large uh because I think our our project
is maybe a little smaller than some of
the others um so I'm wondering if it's
appropriate for a project of our size
yeah I mean it it a project labor
agreement would not be appropriate for
anything under you know $5 million for
sure and that's a very like that's
probably too small
because if you think about here's a
here's the rule of thumb I use for
construction for every million dollars
of the construction project you need
about five workers and so if your
project is $5 million you need 25
workers like that's not going to be
particularly hard to find right um but
for larger construction projects and the
federal government uses now with this
new executive order $35 million were
required to do anything any federal
construction project over $35 million
under a
pla but um
but it it's it it has a bit to do with
the size because like I said how many
workers are you going to need uh and it
also has to do with the you know there's
an opportunity cost of negotiating full
agreement for a small project but it
also has to do with the complexity of
the project in two ways one how what is
the skill level of workers that you need
because a pla is a good you know very
good way to ensure that you're going to
get this the highly skilled workers that
you need that are sometime where you're
competing a lot um and two how many Subs
are you going to need how many different
contractors and Subs are going to be
involved in the project because a pla is
a very elegant way of managing the work
across multiple Subs um and minimizing
any conflicts associated with that so
it's size of project and I would say
just because it's the federal threshold
35
million but if if you have a project
that's 25 million but quite complex then
that a pla might also make sense
there great thank you and so if it if
it's lower than that 5 million threshold
um how how would you suggest that we um
address those
requirements yeah if it's lower than
that five million threshold then a
Workforce continuity plan is not going
to be very hard to develop because you
just don't have a really high demand for
workers and you're not going to have a
lot of complex a lot of complexity to
manage on that
project um and there it's we're more
looking for you know compliance with
Davis bacon laws and just mainly
compliance with the existing statutory
requirements and even like if you have a
project that's $5
million it's kind of too low even to
require um or to like create
opportunities for local workers ERS
right because you just again you need
for that kind of project need 25 people
what I mean maybe you could say okay
five of them will make sure come from
the local community or 10 of them but
it's just it's not huge
numbers where you know it
doesn't a pla would be
Overkill um you're not there's not a lot
of community there's not a lot of
economic benefits coming out of a small
construction project that you have to be
concerned
about great thank
you anyone
else
Julie yep can you hear me yeah um so I
guess I just had a question you started
to kind of answer it but I just wanted
to clarify um on the community benefits
plan temp template which we we know we
all have this um upcoming deadline of I
think January 4th um you know and then
and the holidays coming up like you know
you had mentioned that these take take
several meetings and and we've been
having meetings like ever since we
actually applied we've continued to have
these meetings but we're constantly
getting introduced to new organizations
and starting new relationships like and
I know you're saying like an iterative
process but like it this seems pretty
specific um so I guess I just when you
know as I look at the the deliverable
for this first deadline like how
specific do we need to be
here I mean the
template um what what I think is nice
about the template is you can delete the
stuff that's not relevant to your
project and then provide specificity
where you have it um I can see the
situation that you're dealing with if
you're constantly getting introduced
you're just like juggling all the these
relationships and you don't really know
what's going to move forward that sounds
difficult I mean that sounds like
something I would ask for yuss
Berkeley's help with okay um figuring
out kind of where to go with all of that
um I I guess the only advice that I
would provide is
really connect the specificity
to to what's going to support um your
project success you might be getting
introduced to a lot of organizations
that are sort of peripheral okay that
and so just think about affected
communities which could be which could
be very you know differently defined for
different projects and
affected um workers which represented by
usually
unions I mean not only but usually or
there's sometimes Workforce Development
organizations that or community colleges
that could provide uh you know that
could be good partners for for training
people for your permanent jobs so just
and and you know I'm not really going to
I'm not providing much detail on justice
40 I'm the expert for the jobs and
Workforce stuff and I the advice that I
would provide is just connect it to your
project
okay okay I mean I guess it's a good
thing right because the community is
very engaged but it's it is it does get
a little bit overwhelming when um yeah
um Julie one thing and I I think
Berkeley can provide you more details on
this but one thing that we've heard when
we have talk to people who've done
really effective Community benefits
agreements is to manage multiple
stakeholders you form a committee yes um
and then you kind of spell out the Rules
of Engagement for that committee and
participation for that
committee um so that people who are
interested have a voice but you're not
having to interact but then the
committee has a representative that you
engage with yeah actually did start that
formation so so that's super helpful I
just think that like you know that's
starting and then you know the Cadence I
think we're having like weekly or
bi-weekly meetings but like again we're
pushing up here against the end of the
year so it's kind of trying to cram all
that and make sure we get all the
information we need before that first
submission I think we can take Tim's
question and then I have to hop for
another call
apologies I just wanted to get some
clarification on the earlier statement
of you know it takes three conversations
and you're encouraging to have those
conversations I I didn't pick up um the
with whom part can you clarify oh well
it would be yeah so either with um
communitybased organizations that have
experien negotiating Community benefits
agreements or with labor unions like the
building you know at this point it would
be construction for most projects unless
your facility is already built and
you're hiring staff but with the
building the local Building Trades
Council um or the North American
Building Trades unions like with those
worker representatives so just whoever
the representatives are of community
worker
stakeholders the tribes too if that's
relevant for for where you're
located all right well thank you all I'm
sorry that I forgot to mention is uh
that this was recorded at the beginning
but I think you all know that this is
recorded at this point Thank
congratulations for you all being being
in this process and thank you for the
really good
questions that you've asked over the
past hour and um reach out to Berkeley
and I will drop my email in the chat too
or Hank can uh can connect us if you
have any followup
questions thank you betany and thank you
everyone
