U.S. Department of Energy’s Community Benefits Plans Information Session

U.S. Department of Energy
60 followers
Aug 8, 2024
The U.S. Department of Energy’s (DOE) Office of Fossil Energy and Carbon Management (FECM) hosted a webinar that provides a foundational overview of Community Benefits Plans (CBPs), a new requirement for all funding opportunity announcements (FOAs) funded by the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law (BIL) and Inflation Reduction Act (IRA). This presentation includes best practices identified in competitive CBPs, their evaluation and selection criteria, the process and timeline from application to award, and resources for prospective FOA applicants.
welcome everyone and thank you for
joining us for this information session
from the US Department of energy on
community benefit plans for
demonstration and deployment projects my
name is Emily Brooks I'm an engagement
adviser within Doe's office of fossil
energy and carbon management and the
office of resource sustainability and
I'll be sharing this information on
behalf of uh our office myself and my
colleague natina Dobson
first some disclaimers this webinar and
related materials are not rules or
regulations and the recommendations it
contains may not apply to a particular
situation based upon the individual
facts and
circumstances additionally although this
webinar and related materials were
prepared by the fossil energy and carbon
management or fecm office within the
department of energy or
doe this is intended to be generalized
guidance and is not specific to any
funding opportunity announcement within
fecm or any other doe program
office this webinar and related
materials include general information as
well about the relationship between
Community benefit programs or cbps and
doe tribal consultation requirements as
well as doe policies on effective
inclusion of tribes in
cbps however different or additional
tribal consultation or engagement rules
and policies May apply to your situation
if other Federal agencies such as the
Environmental Protection Agency or EPA
are involved in the implementation of
your
program if you have specific Community
Benefit Plan guidance questions please
refer to the funding opportunity
announcement for each specific program
and for additional information you can
visit the about Community benefits plan
page on Doe's
website in this information session
we're going to be covering some Basics
about what community benefit plans or
cbps are and what they include and the
bulk of our time will be spent on
looking at how cbps are evaluated as
part of an application package what are
the best practices uh that we see in
particularly competitive
cvps we'll also share with you the CBP
process and timeline uh from application
through negotiation and
award and then last but not least we
will share with you some resources PPS
are part of Doe's implementation of
multiple executive orders related to
environmental justice deia or diversity
Equity inclusion and accessibility and
Workforce Development we'd like to
highlight two guiding Concepts that
you'll see come up over and over again
in what we're about to present
environmental justice and Equity now
what you see here on this slide are the
most recent definitions from executive
orders released in 2023 but they're
building on previous definition with
which you're likely already
familiar first environmental justice
within the federal government refers to
the just treatment and meaningful
involvement of all people regardless of
income race color national origin tribal
affiliation or disability in federal
agency decision-making and other Federal
activities that affect human health and
the
environment we bolded just treatment and
meaningful involvement because those are
those are the key Concepts here
just treatment means protection from
disproportionate and adverse human
health and environmental effects and
Hazards uh as well as having Equitable
access to a healthy sustainable and
resilient environment meaningful
involvement you can think of as having a
voice at the table and having that voice
be heard when decisions are being
made Equity within the federal
government refers to consistent and
systematic treatment of all individuals
in a fair just and impartial manner with
a special focus on including individuals
who belong to communities that have
often been denied such treatment uh and
this would be folks who are members of
say uh black indigenous and communities
of color uh women lgbtqi plus persons
persons with disabilities uh and persons
who are otherwise adversely affected by
persistent poverty or inequality as well
as people who would belong to multiple
such
communities the role of cbps is to
ensure that the once in a generation
Investments passed by Congress result in
benefits to people and communities
support quality job growth and increase
accessibility to New Opportunities
provided by the clean energy
transition successful implementation of
those cbps means uh we are maximizing
benefits to community ities labor and
tribes ensuring long-term success and
building durable support for
implementation more specifically the
major objectives of community benefits
plans are to decrease project risks and
delays due Community or labor
opposition decrease health and safety
risks to workers and
communties increase participation of
affected stakeholders in decision making
increase opportunities for two-way
communication we'll talk more about that
later increase
communication uh and increase
accountability to affected workers and
communities increase benefits and
broadly shared
prosperities uh Prosperity from
place-based projects particularly to
disadvantage
communities through engaging
stakeholders early and assessing how
projects and programs will impact the
host communities doe seeks to ensure
long-term success and Braden support for
further action and
development now we'll cover what is
included in a
CBP the CBP framework is based on a set
of four core policy priorities which you
see on this slide on the the list on the
left and reflected in the v diagram on
the right those policy priorities are
community and labor engagement investing
in quality jobs deia and justice
40 and as you can see in the image they
they interlock and they build on one
another Comm community and labor
engagement means meaningful engagement
with Community labor and tribal Partners
leading to formal agreements with
accountability to affected
stakeholders investing in quality jobs
refers to creating good paying jobs to
attract and retain skilled work workers
and ensure that those workers have a
voice on the job over decisions that
affect
them deia refers to Equitable access to
wealth building opportunities so these
are things like Partnerships good jobs
uh Recruitment and Workforce Development
Investments
Etc and justice 40 refers to the justice
40 initiative which is a federal
government-wide goal that at least 40%
of the benefits of certain federal
Investments
uh flow directly to disadvantaged
communities as determined by sieges the
climate and economic Justice screening
tool including tribes and we'll talk
more about that
later Community benefits plans are are
composed using the CBP template each
funding opportunity announcement or foa
applicant is encouraged to use this
template included in the FAA to Aid in
the submission of the CBP portion of
their
application the template gives
instructions on the type of information
that an applicant should include so that
they can submit a CBP that addresses all
four of those
priorities in uh in the CBP portion of
the the funding opportunity
announcement for the remainder of the
webinar we'll focus on requirements and
best practices for the demonstration and
deployment version of this template
uh that said the guidance will be um
generalized broadly applicable and we
ask that you please reference the
specific foa that you're applying to for
all of the requirements templates
waivers guidance and so on uh for your
specific
application now we'll get into how cbps
are evaluated and some best practices to
share with you
cbps are a new requirement for all
funding opportunity announcements that
are funded by Bill and Ira the
bipartisan infrastructure law and the
inflation reduction act cbps are
reviewed by subject matter experts
during the Merit review process and they
count for up to 20% of an applicant's
final
score if that project is selected doe
then incorporates the CBP commitments
into the award and the recipient will be
required to implement the CBP as
negotiated during the negotiation phase
we'll talk more about that later during
the life of the award doe also follows
up evaluates the recipient's progress on
uh moving forward on achieving those
commitments so what makes an effective
CBP ultimately it's a priority of do
that cbps go beyond highlevel statements
or promises overall applicants should
strive to explain in detail how they'll
meet actionable goals outcomes and
conduct
implementation and so accordingly across
the board effective cbps are typically
specific actionable and
connected uh so think of this slide as
sort of crosscutting advice uh that
we'll dig into in more detail on
subsequent
slides under specific effective cbps use
Smart Milestones with clear metrics to
measure success and they clearly
identify those communities that will be
impacted by the project and where they
are
located effective cbps are actionable
they identify sufficient resources to
achieve the tasks that are outlined they
reach Beyond a high level or vague
Vision to demonstrate actionable goals
outcomes and
implementation and they provide specific
details for what stakeholder groups will
be engaged when how and to what
purpose effective cbps are also
connected they are uh they include
specific commitments that align with the
CBP templates and that respond to the
specific FAA topic including justice 40
and other doe priorities
they explain how Community engagement
will impact project or program decisions
they make commitments that consider
possible project impacts on impacted
communities and workers labor and
Workforce and tribes we'll talk more
about tribes and tribal consultation in
a later slide they offer substantive
analysis on the volume of community
benefits or when and how they're
expected to
flow and they thoroughly model monitor
or ameliorate environmental
impacts uh we'll use the term smart
Milestones here uh and what we're
referring to is Milestones that are
specific meaning narrow and concrete
measurable meaning they identify the
data that can be used to assess whether
you're achieving your goal achievable uh
meaning they include
benchmarks uh they include time and
resources
available relevant meaning the uh the
goals that have been identified are
connected and time bound meaning they
consider setting uh interim Milestones
towards a larger goal to evaluate
progress along the
way and of course we're looking for
examples of uh personnel and budget to
ensure successful implementation of
these smart milestones we want to see
that they're adequately resourced so for
example if you have have an engagement
activity listed making sure that your
application also
includes the staff to do that engagement
activity uh and that they have the
specific experience of liaising with
communities in the past that they have
the resources to do that and that this
is indicated in their resume or as part
of their
expertise we've also mentioned a few
times the the idea of meaningful
engagement meaningful two-way engagement
this describes an overall approach to
engaging and building relationships with
communities including disadvantaged and
tribal communities that is based on
collaboration trust and
accountability this chart describes some
high level differences in format goals
definitions and project design between
one-way engagement where information
Moves In One Direction from Project
leaders to communities and two-way
engagement where communities have
meaningful participation in information
sharing and project
development now as with the previous
slide on smart goals and adequate
resourcing doing meaningful two-way
engagement well requires significant
time expertise and resources So the plan
and process part of that CBP is really
critical and uh we invite you to
reference this slide later to screenshot
this slide for ideas of how to build on
one-way engagement to make it more
two-way where it is more collaborative
uh where you have project leaders and
communities working together to identify
impacts potential benefits win-win
options uh and opportunities to produce
data and research
together applicants are encouraged to
engage with tribes through cbps and
other means
but can cbps fulfill tribal consultation
requirements the answer to that is no
cbps do not fulfill the requirements for
formal tribal consultation that is a
government toover process between doe
and the tribal government in recognition
of tribal sovereignty award recipients
are required to supply project
information to doe that may be used to
support tribal
consultation tribes have a right to
formal consultation with doe if all of
the foll occur an Indian tribe could be
impacted by a project the impacted
Indian tribe is ferally recognized which
includes Alaska native Regional and
Village
corporations and the Indian tribe is not
a party to the Grant application or
other relevant activity and important to
note here a letter of support from the
tribe or involvement in a CBP does not
determine whether the tribe is a party
to an
action if an applicant determines a
tribe will be impacted by their project
that applicant must provide information
on the project location potential
impacts and how the applicant will
engage with the tribe during and if
necessary after the end of the
agreement and if you have further
questions you can direct them to the
tribal energy steering committee which
cordinates tribal consultation and
engagement across doe programmatic
offices any actions taken by Doe to
engage and consult with tribes uh follow
policy and Order 1441
we have a couple of uh best practices
listed here for effectively including
tribes within a CBP broken up into four
categories of meaningful engagement
transparency and accessibility
protection of resources and equity and
as with before uh we invite you to
revisit this slide screenshot it for
ideas as you build a
CBP under meaningful engagement things
to think about include doing an analysis
to determine which tribes may be
impacted and uh that all appropriate
tribes have been
engaged generic reference to tribes for
example often does not meet the specific
part of smart goals for
cbps can also think about whether
Community meetings are accessible to
tribes uh whether there are specific
mechanisms for incorporating feedback
from tribes and whether there's a
possibility for bilateral agreements
such as tribal agreements uh M us
Community benefit agreements and project
labor
agreements under transparency and
accessibility some best practices things
to think about cultural resources
monitors and Community leaders uh from
those tribes have access to sites and
processes the tribal Community has
access to environmental monitoring data
or support to conduct their own
monitoring status updates are provided
to the
community under protection of resources
buffers are provided for since of plants
sacred sites and other cultural
resources and under Equity Workforce
Development and education opportunities
for tribal members uh perhaps
opportunities to include indigenous
knowledge in Project design monitoring
plans and mitigation measures so again
overall best practices for Effective
inclusion of tribes in a CBP
now we often get the question what are
some common areas for improvement uh
what are some common areas that we would
recommend uh focusing on to to make uh
CBP more effective uh to make it a a
higher quality
CBP here's some of the common challenges
that we
see uh cbps that don't reflect an
understanding of local context or
history for example an understanding of
how this technology has been uh
perceived by a local community how it
has impacted local communities local
Workforce in the past cbps that only
include an Institutional deia plan that
hasn't been uh made specific to the
project hasn't been connected to the
project and how it will be implemented
there similarly a deia plan that focuses
on early career stage only for example
an internship program uh and and not on
a longer term perspective on leadership
as well thinking about uh retaining that
Workforce cbps that have a narrow focus
on certain stakeholder types uh for
example looking at uh one segment of
industry or one segment of the workforce
only cbps that rely on one-way
information sharing again you can
reference that one-way versus two-way
engagement
chart uh other common uh common areas
where we can improve cbps uh if a CBP
has inadequate resources dedicated to
implementation uh not enough staff not
enough hours uh not enough expertise or
not the right expertise are some common
challenges there commitments to
engagement and deia can lack specificity
or accountabil
for example not referring to specific
communities uh that have been have the
when and where identified not referring
to specific tribes or the commitment or
benefit is just not clearly related to
the foa or the proposed
project so how do we uh how can we boost
all of these these elements how can we
address some of these challenges we'll
go into more depth on the following
slides with some examples of effective
commitments and more best
practices and we're going to go through
this uh policy area by policy area using
those four primary policy areas on a
CBP First Community and labor engagement
some examples of effective commitments
here are things like a commitment to
negotiate a collective bargaining
agreement a community benefits agreement
or a CB a uh which is is legally binding
a tribal agreement or a community
Workforce agreement or Good Neighbor
agreement and for the application stage
uh for the negotiation stage we're
looking for anou outlining the
conditions for negotiation of these
agreements second identification of
benefits provided to affected
stakeholders and local community for
example the number of local jobs to be
created the wages paid uh as well as
timelines and remedies for
non-compliance third the establishment
of community advisory councils including
labor tribal and environmental justice
Representatives continuing on with job
quality and Workforce continuity uh
again more types of things we would love
to see in the most highly rated
applications uh for operations phase
jobs commitments to support worker
organizing and collective bargaining
such as a pledge to remain neutral
during any Union organizing campaigns or
a pledge to permit Union recognition
through card check as opposed to
requiring Union
elections pledges to enter into binding
arbitration to settle first contracts to
allow Union organizers access to
appropriate onsite non-work spaces for
example
lunchrooms are a pledge to refrain from
holding captive audience
meetings also commitments to provide
high quality jobs such as 75th
percentile wages or above for industry
and relevant production occupations and
competitive benefits paid training plus
tuition reimbursement for additional
training and the establishment of health
and safety committees with participation
in training of hourly production workers
so again note the the level of
specificity here is quite high again
we're looking for those smart goals
for construction phase jobs commitments
to negotiate project labor agreements or
pla for large construction activity
associated with the project and anou can
spell out the process by which those
plas would be
negotiated commitments to utilize
registered apprentices such as a ratio
of 15 to 20% of work hours commitments
to local hires such as 50% of jobs
commitments to Skilled and trained
credentialed Workforce with a national
Journey card credential and wages above
those required by the Davis bacon act uh
the prevailing wages
there for the deia or diversity Equity
inclusion and accessibility policy area
here's some examples of effective
commitments that we love to see in the
most highly ranked uh Community benefit
plans
identifying minority women and diverse
business Enterprise firms and minori
serving institutions as planned
contractors or
Partners identifying Workforce training
organizations serving disadvantaged
communities underrepresented or
marginalized populations as partners for
recruiting training and or retaining
workers identifying robust and inclusive
Workforce Development Investments
including critical Supportive
Services commitments to support
apprenticeship Readiness and registered
apprenticeships commitments to partner
with or recruit from historically black
colleges and universities tribal
colleges and universities and other
minority serving institutions for
research and development
opportunities and specific Milestones
goals and or metrics related to those
examples those example
commitments the last policy priority
area will go through here is justice 40
and we want to pause for a moment here
just to clarify some
definitions justice 40 is a presidential
initiative that seeks to address
environmental and social injustice by
ensuring that at least 40% of the
benefits of climate related Federal
funding go to disadvantaged communities
and that 40% is not specific to a
project it's not specific specific to a
funding
opportunity uh announcement that is that
is a a broad
goal what you can see here uh is how we
determine that that definition of a
disadvantaged community using the
climate and economic Justice screening
tool you can reference that at the link
above within seist 27,2 48 census tracks
have been identified as Meeting those
criteria for disadvantaged according to
both so
economic uh indicators and environmental
burdens and that constitutes about 28%
of the population the total US
population living within a seeg just
identified disadvantaged community so
these are the communities that we're
thinking about when we when we say
justice 40 uh aims to ensure that 40% of
those benefits of uh climate related
energy and environmental and job related
Federal funding go to those
communities so under that justice 40
section uh of a CBP what are we looking
for as part of the the CBP applicants
for due funding are required to submit a
justice 40 plan which should provide an
overview of benefits that can be
supported by measurable metrics uh and
specifically describe the benefits to
disadvantaged communities that the
project can deliver supported by
measurable mil Stones so this section
must include identifying the applicable
disadvantaged communities where the
anticipated project benefits are going
to flow and how those communities are
characterized uh seist can be used to do
this you can also flush that out by
using additional tools s such as the
department of Energy's disadvantaged
Community
reporter many tools have state level
tools for helping to identify
historically disadvantaged or
underserved communities as well
we're also looking for identification of
applicable benefits that are
quantifiable measurable and trackable
including at a minimum a discussion of
the relevance of each of the eight
Department of energy justice 40 policy
priorities which you can find on our doe
justice 40
page we're looking for a description of
how and when anticipated benefits are
expected to flow to those communities as
well as a discussion of any anticip
iated negative and cumulative impacts on
those
communities now let's check in on the
overall CBP process and
timeline here are the three major stages
of the timeline this is the typical
timeline for Department of energy
competitive funding first applicants
will submit an application for funding
which includ includes the
CBP uh applications are then scored and
the select
determined that moves us towards the the
negotiation phase where a doe works with
the selectees to strengthen their CBP
commitments and reviews the CBP budget
uh here we're looking at strengthening
or clarifying CB Comm CBP commitments if
they're
needed and the uh at this stage a CBP
becomes a community benefits outcomes
and objectives or
SIU and a community benefits reporting
or CBR uh document that are created and
incorporated as part of the award and
that's how the CBP commitments are
incorporated as part of the final award
that's how they move
forward last stage the project
management stage uh progress towards
those Community benefits goals and
Milestones are monitored and enforced
through the SIU and additionally
monitored through the community benefits
reporting or CBR and other
reporting so applicants submit quarterly
reporting uh reports on go noo
Milestones continuing applications uh
and make changes to the cuu and CBR as
needed now let's go over those three
documents the CBP the CBU and the
CBR once an applicant is selected for an
award the doe will seek to ensure the
selecte has completed the community
benefits outcomes and objectives or SIU
table in the provided Community benefits
plan template which is typically offered
at the time of the application
release so starting with the CBP at the
top this is the application document
that consists of up to those four
sections we've discussed community and
stakeholder engagement investing in
quality jobs deia and justice 40 and
contains those commitments milestone
dates names and metrics so this supports
applicants in documenting commitments
and that standard that standard template
uh that applicants use supports the
Merit review evaluation
process during the negotiation stage uh
that is split into two documents the CBU
and the
CBR uh highlevel summary of what those
are here the SIU on the left in blue is
a highle summary of the four sections
that were addressed in the CBP and this
contains just the highlevel commitments
the general time frames the smart
Milestones this is for establishing
accountability uh this is how uh how we
look at progress of CBP goals and
Milestones as part of the um of the
agreeement this is help how we help
establish clear accountability for
Progress the community benefits report
or CBR in the green on the right is
nixel reporting template that contains
specific dates names and metrics this is
a form where the select and Department
of energy can track specific dates names
locations and other metrics associated
with the goals and Milestones that are
provided in the
SEO and this is a machine readable
format that can feed into a dashboard
and track progress of planned and actual
commitments and Milestones and
Associated metrics so again what you
want to take away from this slide is
this is how the the commitments that are
written down within the CBP that are
negotiated during the negotiation
process uh become part of the project
become part of the award and this is how
we monitor uh and evaluate success at
implementation more specifically that
SIU is a publicly releasable executive
summary of the negotiated community and
labor commitments that explains how
those commitments milestones and metrics
align with and contribute to the project
objectives it also contains highlevel uh
commitments General time frames and
smart Milestones from the
CBP uh the C the SIU is included in the
award package it should not include
specific details of the commitments for
example names and dates to allow some
flexibility during the project
management phase without triggering an
award
modification and the overall purpose of
the SIU as award attachment is to
establish clear accountability and
enforce ility for the progress towards
CBP goals and Milestones as part of the
agreement with the select
awarde a CBR or a community benefits
reporting template is a standardized
template that's intended to assist in
tracking the progress of benefits and
commitments during program management
and
Reporting so this is used to track
progress towards planned and actual
commitments and Associated metrics uh
and facil it Ates data collection by
doe last but not least as we bring this
information section to a close we'd like
to share with you some overall uh
resources references and contact
information as you prepare a CBP as part
of your application and again we do
highly recommend that you go back and
re-reference screenshot earlier slides
in this presentation and reference the
slides as well for more detail on those
best practices that we hope to see in
the most effective
cbps first questions where can you find
fcm fossil energy and carbon management
funding opportunities two places the
facm solicitations and business
opportunities page as well as the NL
solicitations and business opportunities
page if you have questions on specific
funding opportunities uh to which you're
considering applying create an account
on fedconnect fedc connect.net to view
the question and answer session for that
specific FAA and you can also submit
additional questions for that foa that
will be answered and updated on fed
connect for everyone to read by project
team members and those updates happen
regularly so fedconnect will will always
be your your go-to your One-Stop shop
for specific
foas if you have uh additional broader
questions for facm projects and programs
you can reach out to the fecm engagement
staff uh including myself Emily and my
colleague natina at the email addresses
listed here for tribal engagement again
you can reach out to the tribal energy
steering committee and for Community
benefit plans At Doe in general we have
a doe CBP
email and additional helpful resources
related to CBP development and
implementation that we've collected for
you uh again we we recommend
screenshotting pausing on this slide to
review the links on the left we have
some doe resources about cbps justice 40
Workforce and Community engagement
Community benefits agreements uh and an
example of a CBP forum and game
developed by the the office of energy
Equity or energy Justice and Equity here
at
doe fecm specific resources you can see
our planning for societal considerations
and impacts uh
document and some external resources
from EPA the Environmental Protection
Agency and a workshop on leveraging
community benefit Frameworks from the
nationaly of science engineering and
medicine for additional
ideas and that concludes our information
session on community benefit plans thank
you for joining
