this third generation Chinese American
comedian tries to order dim some in her
broken Cantonese and it is going viral
yeah let's run the clip from Christina
Wong right got my list my cheat sheet
I'm going to do this been rehearsing all
yesterday this morning got to I want to
order di suon CES and not get yelled
at here we go here we go gu
um
yeah
[Music]
[Music]
okay
yeah tell tell she has a Ste Okay so we
let that that's it then
okay she's going to slam the money or
not see if she SLS
it that went that went better than
anticipated but now we're going to try
to do this
again
uh yeah we did it we ordered minimal
humiliation we did huh
Mommy okay so emotional it so
emotional oh my goodness I can relate I
can relate it really takes me back to
when I was like 12 13 14 years old and I
had to take the phone calls overseas you
know and uh it's just like you're hiding
behind couches you're feeling
embarrassed bashful ashamed and you
don't even know why and I will say this
this is kind of like a hard video to
watch in some ways not really just cuz
the Cantonese is so bad but it's like it
encapsulates something real and I think
that that's why it's going viral yeah is
this something that embarrasses you
using your mother tongue also canones is
one of those dialects that is extremely
popular but is kind of slowly I want to
say dying out right because you can't
really learn it in school obviously a
lot of high schools nowadays in 2024
offer Mandarin even in high school right
right right so anyways guys we're uh
going to cover this all give you our own
perspective being uh you know some
Cantonese Americans ourselves please hit
that like button check out other of the
hot B boys and also check out SMA sauce
this is easy to say David you'll have no
trouble saying SMA if you want to say
with the tones small and not only that
if you are Cantonese or even if you're
toysan Andrew this is not too spicy it's
going to be flavorful a flavor
enhancer um anyway guys yeah so she's
third generation Chinese American does
that automatically excuse her Kanto
because she's from like the San
Francisco area where there's a lot of
third fourth fifth even sixth generation
people Ander from the Gold Rush day it
is a different situation right it's if
you're second gen the onus is on you to
speak your parents mother tongue way
better than if your parents are from
America and you're learning your
grandparents mother right right right I
would say you know I don't want to judge
her cuz my cantones is not very good
better than this though but it is better
than this and I would say considering
she grew up in SF and she's Cantonese I
I would have expected a little bit
better but it is also third gen though
it's also funny yeah you're right she's
third generation so um uh so maybe
obviously her parents spoke to her in
English growing up but I guess David my
opinion is what I loved about this video
is that Christina went and did it she
went and did it and she struggled
through it and you should always
struggle through it why not it is fun if
you're going to Chinatown and Chinatown
let's say is your enclave right speaks a
lot of Cantonese Mandarin toysan right
other slightly different dialect would
say the primary dialects I mean it's
changing now but would be toysan and
cantones toon is considered a subdialect
even though it's debatable and you
should just do it you know why because
you're Asian-American you got to grow
thick skin have fun with it it's not
that big of a deal I think restaurant
workers shame you a lot less nowadays I
used to get shamed way more like eight
years ago trying to speak it nowadays I
think people understand what you're
trying to do they're like oh yeah yeah
yeah okay you're trying to struggle
through it okay just keep going what
that you are trying to connect with some
sort of identity that maybe you are
wrestling with and it just shows you
respect the culture that you still want
to try even if that's the only time you
try that week you're at least trying
because you know what you're not an NPC
you are you get to be a main character
and you get to take up the waiters time
and they have to talk to you in that
dialect well not only that they're paid
by you so they going to be
like that that would be like why would
you why would right no I you did used to
hear that back in the day but I feel
like nowadays the workers are just happy
that you're trying uh Andrew you had an
experience the other day you were in
Chinatown and you went to a Taylor a
Taylor I went to uh shout out to miss
Chen Taylor you know FJ lady um but she
only speaks Mandarin and her English oh
well fujin too yeah fujin sorry fujin
Mandarin and and barely English but I
thought I I thought I was hoping she
would speak more English because I could
understand her English so I said hey
your English is okay
do so originally you're starting off in
Mandarin yeah actually I'm trying to see
if she could speak English cuz I know
she speaks a little bit right but she's
just like you know this is essentially
the conversation in Chinese she's like
no no no no my English is not good so I
just speak in Chinese and I was like all
right fine and it was like it was taking
a lot longer to figure out cuz you're
like talking about tailoring and the
prices and like I prettyy much got most
of what she was saying
K is smaller larger you know hin you
know blah blah blah like the the words I
know and uh it was embarrassing but
honestly I walked away from it I was
like feeling even though I had a bust
out Google translate once on the app uh
I was still grateful for the opportunity
I thought Miss Chen was very nice she
was very forgiving do you think she
appreciated that you were struggling
through with with pretty bad Mandarin
but you you got through it I think
they're okay with it I think they're
okay with it do you think that this
extreme shame is really more typified of
the 40-year-old Generations in up where
they're like they're so ashamed but
they're also not doing I guess in a way
the work to learn it like is that a
weird combo to be so ashamed of
something but not ashamed or feel enough
incentive to go and learn Chinese right
yeah I'm just I'm just trying to tell
people man you're not the only one that
sucks at your mother tongue you're not
the only one that sucks and you're not
the only one that sucks and is trying in
public so just do it and be confident
because this is part of if we are do not
have thick skin as asian-americans none
of our C culture will continue none of
it it will not because it's going to be
a clunky transition cuz we're not like
the embodiment of cuz then you don't
want to say asness Chinese New Year's
coming up oh if you're so bashful then
don't
say don't say like don't I I always
don't I don't really like it when abc's
on say happy Lunar New Year I'm like ah
man I would not say that yeah just say
it if you know how to say it it's all
good you don't got to say necessar just
say you don't got to
say if you own anything in this life you
got to own up to your culture that
you're born in all right how much of it
is it that this older generation really
missed out on the Tik Tok the YouTubes
and the Instagrams cuz you know you
could follow all these like and you can
follow follow subtle Kanto traits on
Instagram there's a whole cantones
subreddit that'll teach you all these
interesting things you can open up CN
hoopers and watch all these guys like
beat all these white and black guys at
oneon-one I'm saying the 40-year-olds
they never saw any of them sure sure
everybody's got excuses sure everybody's
got excuses don't they right nowadays I
guess it is true that you can open up a
AI meme Amber you could see Internal
Affairs dubbed over they're drinking a
boba they're doing that hidey loud dance
or whatever you know and uh you know
what David I've been you know how you
can bomb as a comedian you bomb a set
right it means you're not doing well
when you do comedy and it is cringey
when I've been bombing Chinese for a
decade you've been Joe coing at the at
the I've bombing so to me I got thick
skin now and I'm confident and at least
what I know and I know I might bomb
again but you know what that's somewhat
comforting hey Andrew bombs away yeah
bombs away um yeah I just always tell
people don't live like it's 1995 here
I'm going to run two clips of
interesting Cantonese type material from
Reddit don't know what makes my
Cantonese so distinctly Vietnamese to
other people's ears I know exactly what
she's talking about because my family is
also chinese vietnamese after being
exposed to so many Chinese Vietnamese
people in my life I've picked up on a
few key differences between the canese
spoken by by people who are in China and
Hong Kong versus those who live in
Vietnam mind you this is just my
observation from my experience and I
might not apply to every chinese
vietnamese person so feel free to add on
if you notice any other differences but
key difference Number One Chinese
Vietnamese people tend to emphasize the
uptone when they speak canones and this
mimics how it sounds in venies few
examples include fish G banana Chey baby
b so in cantones to go home would say
fine okay but chinese vietnamese people
would say fine okay fine okay hear the
difference fine okay fine okay and
speaking of that it leads me to key
difference number two Chinese Vietnamese
people have different phrasing let's use
the same example fine okay chinese
vietnamese people would also say fante I
have only heard chinese vietnamese
people use that phrase if you say fante
to anyone who is from guango or Hong
Kong they will look at you funny
speaking from experience key difference
number three chinese vietnamese people
have a hard time pronouncing the ending
of Cantonese words for example to take a
shower it's ch but that's too much of a
strange for Vietnamese people to say
instead they would say something like so
long or some variation of that another
example is Hong Kong Hong Kong versus
Hong Kong key difference number four
Chinese vietamese people have different
syntax or sentence structure and this
structure mimics vietamese
for example in Vietnamese if you want to
ask somebody if they want something you
always add the word at the end of the
sentence like do you want to
eat means no so it literally translates
to eat no when you want to ask the same
thing in canes you have to say sick sick
and that literally translates to eat or
not eat but chinese vietnamese people
would say sck mo mo in Cantonese means
no so sik MO
and same structure instead of saying s
SI they would say sigo do you like it in
cese in Chinese Vietnamese people would
say mimicking the in Vietnamese and key
difference number five different
particles particles are words that can't
stand alone but they are added to
sentences to give it meaning the phrase
really translates to in Cantonese being
the particle in Chinese Vietnamese
people might say something
like and six different pronunciation to
say that's mine in canes he would
say Chinese Vietnamese people would
say instead of so overall chinese
vietnamese people speak cese in a
harsher sounding way do you agree what
do you
think most work language in the world
what's your pronoun what pronoun like in
your language how do people address you
K
pronoun how do you say he she nonbinary
gender neutral transgender gender
fluid so everyone is yes and
also and also these
are these aren even living things you
don't believe
me all right Andrew let's just get into
the comment section um somebody just
said man I love this as an ABC who
struggles with Cantonese it's just good
to see you don't have to sound perfect
you just have to try but other people
were like oh my goodness I was getting
secondhand Panic through the screen just
listening to her and other people said
oh my goodness you hurt my ears with
your horrific
cantones um yeah everybody has different
reactions to things but like you said
how how did you work over that shame to
the point where you just like you just
did it I just had fun with it man you
got to make it fun if it's not fun
you're just not going to do it right hey
the comedians that really get through
bombing Andrew they're the ones where
they almost start to enjoy bombing yeah
you got to just take it you got to take
it man um somebody said yep when you
practice cantones and then you get hit
with straight toan because the lady
answers her originally in hoan va hoan
va and there was a lot of debate is
toysan a dialect of Cantonese or is it a
different language there was a debate I
don't know is it someone ask a linguist
it it's actually it's actually a gray
area cuz it's pretty similar to Kanto
but it sounds a little different but if
you only speak toysan and you speak it
really fast it's true somebody from Hong
Kong is going to struggle to understand
you even though they might get the
general meaning all the details might be
wrong um somebody say perhaps it's a
dialect why don't you just watch more
Kanto films with the subs on this is how
you do it um all right here's the thing
about watching films man if they're
talking about some complex stuff I
realize you got to watch a ton of it for
you to absorb it because you're not they
don't speak the way you're going to
speak right right right TV show is even
more regular movies tend to be very like
contextual to like an era or like a
formality there's just I would say
there's a lot of the Instagram Pages do
a great job of telling you quick easy
phrases that you're going to use in
everyday life so for example like let's
just play this one about how Curry they
they say in Cantonese Curry is used for
everything so that's why it's so woke
it's like a pronoun yeah lady all
pronouns c um for me I think a good way
at least for like a younger guy would be
like listening a pg1 if you want to
learn Mandarin Andre has like a very New
York style of rapping but in Mandarin JB
is a half Filipino half HK rapper and uh
here's a clip of us rapping in
[Music]
Mandarin no need for the ktvs cuz I do
the damn thing regardless of the time
zone accomplish anything that I put my
mind on Make It Happen even in the no F
you just trying to keep a charge on your
iPhone somebody said oh my goodness I
can't believe she really tipped him 5
cents cuz I guess she only tipped him 5
cents in the video for the take out dim
suum oh well if she's taken out but yeah
I guess 5 cents is you might as well you
either tip him like 50 cents or you tip
him nothing she really is old school man
that's true old school SF Canton e toce
on EES to be honest um somebody said
they're not yelling that's just how we
talk when we're in our own spaces so
this was a lot of discussion about like
why does it seem like she's like barking
at her when she's
like H you know what I mean um I'll say
this I think a lot of cantones sounds
like yelling but I actually don't think
it's all canones I don't think you have
to you don't have to yell to speak
Cantonese I don't think that's true
that's a stereotype that's like saying
oh you that like you're not talking like
this you're not like this type of it's
it's just a probability feel angry I
don't agree with that um somebody said
if they want to get mad screw them I
don't care I just want to speak English
why don't you guys adapt or go back huh
this was from ABC Andrew who was is
clearly mad at having the feeling the
need to speak Chinese to other Chinese
immigrants so yeah this guy said you
know I got discriminated by Kanto
speakers as somebody who only speaks
Mandarin when I was growing up deep in
the Canton Zone and I was just like
listen guys this whole beef stuff it's
like it depends on how deep in those
worlds you grow up but yeah I get it
some people live their life in like tiny
fishbowls across like three streets in a
city right like they're not even living
in the entire city um somebody said you
know I lost my ability to speak Chinese
and Viet enemies as I got older some
people are saying reclaim it some people
are saying it doesn't matter for Modern
Life because why would you need to if
cuz people were saying all right why
does this lady Christina Wong feel so
ashamed but the only thing she's
ordering is food she's not like lean
learning any philosophies or deeper
knowledge what is the point of people
connecting with their parents or
grandparents local dialect well maybe
you feel like uh maybe Christina has
feels like that she hasn't done enough
in her life to be proud of being Chinese
or has whatever hasn't done enough for
the culture or now she finally realizes
that Cantonese is uh the number of
cantones speakers and dwindling right
cantones schools is dwindling so yeah I
mean whatever the incentive is um but is
it true that to get high level success
in America she'll never need to know no
no no of course I mean high level of
success just be white why that's the
only thing you need be white passing in
your mannerisms particularly a rich
person is really benef Brown and
something blonde like and they just be
white I guess that would have you would
put yourself in the the best position to
achieve but you know you got to do
things for the culture and again you got
to own up to your culture because if you
don't own a house you don't own anything
else in this world what do you got you
got the culture you were born into so
you got to own up to it and plus I do
think all these little like embarrassing
moments in your life they build up to
make you
stronger so you are saying that is it is
it to communicate yeah I I would say I
think for some people they would need to
answer the question is it to communicate
with what's considered like your
motherland tribe your laja you know what
I mean like where you trace your
ancestors back to that specific Village
then maybe she should speak toysan
instead of Kanto some people were in the
comments were like yeah learn toysan V
to maintain that but it's like that's
already Vanishing Kanto is already
Vanishing in relation to I'll tell you
this if she wants to really be on the
good side of these to on people go learn
some toys on and let them know that a
third toys girl is learning toy and that
would be even more impressive yeah they
would probably be like really feel some
sort of connection H heck you know
uh do was is it do do I don't know I
think that's it yeah something like that
see I know a few anyway guys let us know
what you think of this video in the
comment section below like I said I feel
like the 40-year-olds they relate to it
so much but you know what's different
about the people younger Andrew they got
exposed to a lot more content because
you can follow like learn Kanto from
this 20-year-old kid who's like really
goofy right now on Instagram and you can
see that content on your algorithm every
day right right so I just think that for
the 40 year olds I guess what I would
say out there is go to Tik Tok go to
Instagram go to Reddit follow whoever
you need to follow stream whatever
scenes you need to stream online because
definitely like it's a real video but
it's hope it's a place that I would hope
a lot of asian-americans will not need
to be moving forward right all right
everybody let us know should you keep
struggling through with your mother
tongue when you're ordering food should
you always do it my take is that you
should go and try keep doing it have fun
with it yes there is a point where you
are wasting everybody's time I get that
but take it to that point you paid for
that experience you paid for it you paid
for that experience well you paid for it
with money and you also paid for it with
your identity yeah all right guys uh
thank you so much for watching please
hit that like button check out smalla
sauce and until next time we out
peace