was this an Asian on Asian hate crime or
is the internet just looking way too
much into this yeah let's run the
[Music]
clip
[Music]
why throw your middle finger huh why you
throw your middle finger you told me
[ __ ] me yeah what the [ __ ] are you doing
you dumb ass who here ass [ __ ] go back
to [ __ ] China
[ __ ]
all right Andrew you guys saw it this is
an incident that took place in Elmhurst
Queens over literally what seems like a
super trivial parallel parking incident
and uh yeah there's so many discussions
taking place on the internet and there's
a non-asian discussion as well as an
internal Asian discussion so we're going
to get into it break down all the angles
make sure you like subscribe and turn on
your notifications uh also check out
smalla sauce it is our very own chili
oil shipping out right now uh I guess
David I guess this is surprising because
this is an Asian guy and we we can only
guess what type of Asian he is but we
know that the woman is tied well I'm
assuming he's Korean most people think
he's Korean that's what the comment
section said that's the demographics of
Elmhurst possible yeah I believe the
lady for sure is Tai but she could be
what like Chinese Tai right so she's
speaking Tai and then basically he tells
her to go back to China calls her a dumb
you know be and tells her to go back to
China twice so it's like this phrase go
back to China is only something that you
usually hear from non-asians saying it
to what they think is a Chinese person
now we have an Asian American who is
cursing at a Asian immigrant who is
actually Thai Chinese but basically
being treated as Chinese right right
right so basically the internet was
confused some people were saying this
happens in my community as well amongst
like African versus black black versus
African imated Latinos that are second
third fourth gen versus first gen and
other people were just confused
obviously within the Asian Community
there were some discussion of like oh
man Koreans always talk trash about
Chinese or somebody was saying but why
do is this seem like Chinese are less
assimilated or maybe don't follow the
rules as good as for example Koreans so
there was a bunch of discussions um we
don't know the details I'm not trying to
dox this guy but obviously this was very
poor form on his part regardless of what
happened during that incident Andrew
this guy is looking bad right now yeah I
mean this lady's trying to park maybe
she stops a little suddenly maybe she
backs up a little bit too quickly she's
clearly just trying to park this happens
all the time in this area parking is
very hard to find in New York City and
this guy's totally overreacting like to
me my overall take is this guy is wrong
for this obviously uh he obviously has
some like anti-chinese feelings in his
heart even though he's probably of a
different Asian possibly Korean it's
probably not from Elmhurst realistically
cuz if you grew up there you know what
it is Andrew Elmhurst is half Latin half
asian there's a lot of immigrants there
there's probably a lot of driving that
doesn't fit your uh New Jersey
sensibilities from the suburbs I mean he
has frustrations in his own life and
he's totally projecting his anti-chinese
feelings onto this lady uh which he
thought was like from China but
basically it's he's wrong lot Andrew
were surprised that he came out of the
car and confronted her because men
typically do not confront women let
alone elderly women and he has a
Christmas sweater Crocs and like a kayak
hitch on the top of his RAV four which
just super doesn't fit the profile yeah
yeah I'm no he's he's got a temper and
uh obviously this lady you know got
honked at he swore at her she flipped
him off then he stops and gets out of
his car getting out of your car is
pretty aggressive that's an aggressive
move man especially in New York City
depend if he was in the Bronx Andrew he
would not do that yeah no he would stay
in his car and not even turn his head I
mean um yeah I want to preface this all
the discussions by saying that like this
does happen within immigrant communities
sometimes the more assimilated ones uh
that have been here for andw one two
three generations they judge the people
who just came over right due to what
behavioral difference or some sort of
perceived behavioral difference it's
almost like even if the same thing
happened with an American you perceive
it differently you perceive it because
they're an immigrant it's because they
don't know what to how to live right
yeah it's almost like you know you'd
think that all Asians just because
you're ethnically Asian or you seem East
Asian or whatever you're all on the same
page but it's actually more about are
you on the same page about assimilation
because it doesn't really matter your
race as much if my neighbor is Latino or
my neighbor is an African immigrant and
I'm Chinese American but we're on this
same page about assimilating together to
be to live this American dream then
we're actually going to be more on the
same page than this guy and this woman
right you know what I mean and and
that's what one thing that I think
people need to realize is that nowadays
with as many Asian and different races
of people it's not so much of just your
bloodline and just how that's part of it
that's a large part of it and sure maybe
this Tha lady and this alleged Korean
guy might team up if it was like if she
was getting beat up by like you know a
non-asian or something then he might
jump in but when there's interactions
amongst each other it now comes down to
more like oh you're not assimilating
like me you're an immigrant like me you
need to go back to China because you're
not doing a good job of being an
American right I mean I we we don't know
we don't know the details we don't even
know who this guy it seems like he's
saying this is my guess he's probably
from Suburban New Jersey he's not used
to driving in Queens he's going to a
holiday Christmas party that's what it
looks like like and he's not like he
doesn't understand in the city the move
that she pulled it's not really that
crazy like she turned on her blinkers a
little late but that's almost like how
people drive in the city because the
parking just pops up on you yeah just
stressful to drive in compact areas yeah
so I actually don't think that her
driving was like super crazy it wasn't
certainly like swerving through the
streets of Bangkok or anything like that
but it's like he had a crazy
overreaction like you said he he might
be having a bad day and mentally he
might have been on the fritz anyway
Andrew let's let's just get into the
comment section somebody said Asians are
probably the most racist against
themselves he was probably Korean or
Japanese they hate the
Chinese but why do they hate the Chinese
let's we can all I know we all joke
about Koreans not liking Chinese or
Japanese looking down on Chinese
whatever like obviously it's are rooted
in some history and some reason but I
guess well even it's funny cuz
historically both sides go against the
Japanese but in modern day both sides
are going against the Japes during the
war it was against the Japanese
everybody hates Japanese but nowadays
like I'm saying it's more really not so
much about oh Korean Chinese you have to
dig a level deeper it's almost like you
Chinese are not doing a good job of
assimilating I feel like I'm not
speaking for everybody and a lot of
Koreans have told me this because we
have a lot of very lucid conversations
that a lot of people don't have they
feel like Koreans had a better
assimilation plan to American Norms
becoming a Christian country Etc than
Chinese do right and I would say
generally there there's something to
that but that doesn't mean that you can
go talk down on them like you're now a
racist white guy and they the not
knowing how to live fob like nothing
justifies what he says that CRA somebody
said man this guy definitely got a small
penis Vibe man he stepped to a chick for
all that what did she really do and
someone said is it okay for ABC to tell
a Asian fob to go back to the motherland
let let's just even assume he was
Chinese Andrew okay let's just assume
let's just play it out he's Chinese he
he's diasporic Chinese realistically a
Chinese not going to say that to a
Chinese but he's like of Chinese descent
from a different country and he's
assuming that she's Mainland okay does
it change
it it's still no that's wrong it's just
weird it's still wrong it's wrong but
but and this is not to justify anybody
but like I said it's really about being
on the same page about assimilation this
is like right this is it because like
listen I've played a lot of basketball
with fobs and I have friends that are
fobs I've dated fobs like it's them
being fob in itself is not an issue to
me at all in fact I appreciate it
because they can tell me things about
being Chinese that I don't know you
don't have in your knowledge base they
can translate things they can talk to me
about things talk to me about life in
China it's very insightful so I I love
having those friends but I cannot deny
that there have been frustrations that
I've had because there's a cultural
difference because we're not on the same
page about assimilation they're not
trying sometimes you know you meet a fob
they're not trying to be American I'm
like yo I'm trying to be American but
I'm also trying to be the good parts of
Chinese but like we got to be on the
same page here that we're trying to act
and at least understand the American
rules for sure and I want to be clear
here I think it could be a class thing
too cuz I dated a girl from chundu and
she was from a like a little bit more of
I guess an upper middle class family she
used to judge all the newly arrived
immigrants from a different class in
China and she used to say stuff like
yeah I wish they would go back to China
but like she wouldn't say it like the
way this guy said it but impli I I just
want to say that there is some context
for not I'm not completely there's some
class blaming just race it's class and
race and socioeconomic status and blah
blah blah blah blah and and like you
said I I guess I guess it's tribalism I
guess it's tribalism yeah yeah yeah yeah
um Andrew the next bunch of comments
came from a bunch of non-asians that
were like wait but he's never mind I was
not expecting him to look like this
basically this is a bunch of non-asians
they were just like wait what yeah I
mean to be hon yeah I think the more
interesting comments from the non-asians
are saying there's people who are like
oh Dominicans are black but they say
racist the black people or you see this
within our black population you see this
happen between Cubans and Mexicans how a
lot of people think Cubans and Mexicans
are similar but a lot of Cubans will
look down on Mexicans I'm not saying all
but I'm saying there's that stereotype
that's a stereotype type within the
Latino community that there are
interasian hierarchies corre yeah there
are hierarchies within larger tribes yes
that is true of course and there's even
I guess um like a white Latino to
indigenous Latino hierarchy as well
right like that's the reality of it
right and then this guy said y'all
laughing like most Prejudice doesn't
ultimately come from within our own race
and this girl said I'm from the
Caribbean but people think I'm from
Mexico so I've had Caribbean folks that
I got into argument with me tell me to
go back to Mexico but I'm actually from
the Caribbean myself but I could just
pass as a Mexican that's interesting how
much is it that somebody's just busting
that out just as a as kind of a ghetto
New York disc the second they just think
of where you're from like you're not
acting right you don't know how to
behave so go back to blah blah blah
where I believe you from or is that that
you can't write it off like
that it's interesting it's interesting
and I don't know it's so complex because
I guess like if you meet somebody who's
clearly from like the South
in New York like let's say they're from
Louisiana or they're from Texas and they
do something that you're just like go
back to Texas bro you whack you're
saying the people from Louisiana or
Texas taking up the entire sidewalk five
cuz I've seen it I've seen Europeans and
people from outside sub they' be taking
up six people uh shoulder Tosh shoulder
taking up the whole sidewalk do you but
so do you think like let's say for
example a New York Italian guy's like
hey go back to the South huh what are
you doing huh where where Maybe that's
where you you know you guys could know
how to behave because that type of
behavior is not acceptable here I think
any group can do this to another group
once they feel some type of cultural
superiority some sort of whatever reason
or moral leverage moral leverage moral
superiority cultural superiority social
superiority whatever it is you're going
to use whatever dish you can find
against that person right right right
somebody some sort of uh tribalistic
superiority somebody said the moment an
immigrant gets their citizen ship how
come all other immigrants can deserve to
go back to their respective countries
this phenomenon has been witnessed time
and time again as far as back as the
Irish and the Italians in New York City
is there a term for this and someone
said yeah it's like the Hispanics and
queens right now telling the migrants to
go
back well that are more and you're
you're seeing this all across America
right now right because it's like the
ones that do get along the ones that
came legally the ones that got amnesty
the one you know how like there's so
many different Pathways and then that
you maybe feel like your pathway makes
you more valid than another pathway
because of the situations that surround
that and the outcomes or probabilities
or whatever what I what I think really
to me that's really interesting about
this is because go back to your country
is usually something that is said from a
different race to another race but now
that it's the same looking type of
people even though they're not the same
group of people actually but to the
outside people were just like yo they
visually look the same so now some said
Ling Ling telling Mingming to go back to
Asia is crazy that's so funny it w be
Mingming telling lingling because Ming
Ming would be I'm assuming it would be
the male name uh I I I think that like
uh uh I don't know does this like you
think some non-asians that see this are
like going to justify when they say that
like they're like yeah see Asians even
say that to each other so I'm going to
say so they're saying oh so it wasn't
really just a racial thing I'm like it
wasn't me being racist I was just
sounding racial when I was criticizing
their behavior but but actually even
Asians can be racist to other Asians so
I don't know man it's so hard Ander not
just racist immigration wav or
assimilationist as well assimilationist
entari inist they are are
assimilationists and a lot of people are
that nowadays uh somebody said man I
just noticed in general Chinese on
Chinese crime is on the rise by the way
I think this person is using Chinese as
a word for Asian so a lot of people
don't know especially more uneducated
people Andrew they just use the word
Chinese for all Asians I I guess David
overall what can we learn from this or
is there is it just being like yo this
dude's tripping he's wrong like he
should shut up he he's he's wrong for
that we should but but are Asians going
to go out on a limb and try to track him
down and harass him on the internet uh
I'm sure he's had this video sent to him
several times cuz he looks like a guy
who probably got a Tik Tok a snap and
everything you know cuz he looked like
Jen Z I mean he's feeling some shame
right now I think so I it's pretty
embarrassing it's a it's a shameful
video because the girl's like she
doesn't deserve it I'm not saying that
you know she's a 10 out of 10 driver or
whatever but like you just can't treat
other people in the society this way to
be honest in a civil society I'm not
saying people don't Asians should know
better we come from a place where it's
generally not acceptable to act like
that I'm not saying it never happens in
Asia it happens at a lower rate um it's
unfortunate and I hope he can learn from
it I hope his life is not over to to me
it's not as puzzling as it is sad like
puzzling I get it like this person's not
Chinese he's frustrated with the way he
perceives Mainland Chinese people to be
acting right less assimilated than his
tribe or whatever he identifies as more
American eyes this lady is not being
American apparently by the way she
drives he's frustrated he's projecting a
lot on her so to me that's not as
puzzling he overreacted he's wrong but
to me it's sad cuz I'm like dang man
Asians lashing out on other types the
Asians well now I can expect non-asians
to lash out on Asians just as much or if
not more so right right I mean it's
almost like too much enemy fire to take
a friendly that's a Jay-Z line where he
was just like damn bro but it happens
man fire but but but of course when you
live in a world that's so Asian which
Elmhurst is very Asian do I think that
this is going to happen
in like uh Oklahoma you know the
interesting thing is I've heard this
always used to happen in the 90s when
all the Asian immigrants were newly
arrived and now it's happening again but
sort of in a different way I me listen
it's I've heard stories of a Chinese
American saying this to a Chinese fob
yes I've heard it yes yes yes so it's
not out of this world because at the end
of the day it's just to say you're not
on the same page and if you don't want
to be on the same page then go back to
your
Homeland in but in a more like malicious
way that's essentially what they're
saying do think it is true that
different yeah I mean I I'll say this I
do think that different groups
assimilate at different rates uh some
assimilate have a game plan to have
heavy assimilation some are medium some
are at a light assimilation game plan I
I think that that's fair to say that
different groups have different patterns
of behaviors in a macroaggregate like
median statistical sense and um yeah I
just hope we can deal with it better
that's my general feeling like I said I
I wish the best for everybody in every
community Community but yeah these
things pop up you know but like I said
not trying to you know no I don't think
anybody deserves to like have their have
you know it's just let it be a learning
lesson all right everybody let us know
in the comments down below what you
think about all this hit that like
button uh let us know if you enjoyed the
the conversation and found it insightful
and I'll tell you this Andrew one last
thing I learned from this post knowing
the difference between a Chinese person
and all Asians altogether Andrew that's
still not required knowledge to operate
in the US need to know nope nope nope
all right everybody until next time we
out
peace