Hello friends, it's time for a very important video and that is to discuss my worst books
of 2023 and god will there's some stinkers. Of course we've had some bad ones this year.
I have been pushed to the limit with this. To be honest though in previous years I've just felt,
I felt angry right? I get angry over bad books. This year I just feel sad. I look at these books
and I'm just sad of what could have been and how they could have been better and just how we could
not be in this situation. I don't know if I feel angry, maybe I'll get angry as I start talking,
but I just kind of, I don't know. I feel like the books that have been bad this year for me
have just been kind of just so painfully nothing. I feel like because a lot of the books that came
out this year in terms of 2023 releases were people's COVID books. I feel like you can kind
of feel that a little bit in the energy of the books. I've connected the two dots. You didn't
connect ---- but I've connected them. But let's just get into it shall we? I have ranked these
from least worst to most worst. I mean they're all worst. So we are going to work our way up to my
worst book of the year. We've got a few two stars and then I think I've got one 1.5 and four one
stars. So the top five are all you know particularly awful. But shall we just begin and get into it?
You're going to see particularly at the start of this list, in fact the first three books of this
list are all um Goodreads Choice Awards winners. Yep. Yep. Yep. Number 10. Coming in at number 10 is one
that it could just be on this list because I'm still bitter. I haven't gotten over it. But it's
The Housemaid's Secret by Frida McFadden. I did not enjoy this at all and I'm still, I don't
want to talk about the fact that it won. I don't want to talk about the fact that it won. Can we just not?
I don't. Trauma. Family trauma. Generational trauma. Family trauma. You know generational trauma.
Generational trauma. Generational trauma. Trauma. Not ready to discuss it as you guys saw in the
Goodreads Choice Awards vlog where I found out that this won. I was pretty, I was pretty heartbroken.
But basically this is the sequel to The Housemaid and we're following this woman who is a housemaid
and she is um cleaning and being a housemaid for this rich ass couple and she starts to think that
the woman is being abused by her husband and wants to try and help her out of that situation. For me
I mean it could be that it reminded me a lot of a other bad book that is higher up on this list.
A mix of romance and mystery didn't work for me. There's a little bit of a romance subplot going on
or like multiple romance. Oh my god I forgot about the other guy. And I just feel like the mystery
and the tropes are ones that have been played over and over and over and over and over again.
Maybe the reason this has been so popular is there's an element of familiarity to this. I know
there's been a lot of plagiarism claims. I don't know a ton about that but like you know I have
read this story 10 times before and yeah the writing isn't good enough to justify this being
as popular as it is for me. I don't, I don't understand the success of Miss Frieda. I know
at this rate because she puts out like ******* 10 books a year. I know at this rate I'm gonna have to
probably get another one of her books next year. If that wins I may stop doing those videos because
what is the point? What is the point? There'll be a new Lucy Foley that might save us. There'll be
the new Anita Prose. There may be some stronger competitors to take down Frieda McFarlane but like
you guys were telling me she's got these like fans on Facebook who like mobilize a campaign
to vote for her and I just, this is like evil, evil, evil, evil, evil, evil. I'm not into it.
And this probably has snuck onto the list. I'm gonna be completely transparent on this to you
because of how angry I am that it won. Like it's probably not number, there probably were a few
other two stars that could have snuck in at number 10 but this just goes on here. I'm, I'm angry.
Bitch. Mother ******* piece of s**t. And you know I said in the video it has some elements of
thrillers in terms of abusive husbands that I am not a massive fan of that I don't think are a
problem in an individual book but I've read them so much across so many thrillers that it does start
to annoy me when I keep reading them. I just read another book like that where the, the abused woman
can't leave because he, the husband is so powerful. He could track her down. He could chase her. He
has eyes all over the city. You find out who she is rather than just a woman not being able to leave
because of how difficult it is to leave abusive relationships. Again like I said it's not a
individual book but when you, when that's a trend it does annoy me within the thriller space. Um,
yeah. Miss Frieda I wish I could say I'm never gonna read you again but I know I am. I know I am
so. Then we've got a dual winner of a Goodreads Choice Awards. Let me, yeah, yeah, yeah. Dual
winner. Wayward. Wayward by Amelia Hart. It's not good guys. Don't pick it up. This won both
historical fiction and debut. God. Stop. It's actually painful to watch. We're following
three related women in different points in history who all may be witches and are all
going through difficult things. We've got one in the present day who's leaving an abusive
relationship. We've got one in 1940s who is very constrained within her family life and that is
kind of her storyline. And we've got one in the 1600s who is being tried for witchcraft.
Now, here's the thing. It is triple timeline. These timelines do not really converge in any
proper way. So you've got three separate stories, right? And it's 300 and whatever pages. You've
basically got three novellas, right? And there's just not enough of a connection between these
storylines to make me interested. I think that each of these storylines are such base level,
like, basic versions of these stories. Again, we've heard time and time again. I just don't
like triple timeline because none of these were interesting to me. None of them held my
attention and it didn't work going back and forth between them because I just didn't
care. I didn't care. I didn't care. Clap if you care. Clap if you care. And like I said,
each of the storylines I've read in a whole novel basically in better versions. There was nothing
original to each of these storylines. There wasn't enough of a payoff. It wasn't really
witchy. That is another really pet hatred of mine is when a book is marketed as witches and, like,
is the tiniest minuscule amount about witches. I just don't. This does not deserve to be
a dual winner in my opinion. And then eighth on the list. No, you won't be surprised to see this.
Fourth Wing by Rebecca Yarrow. Here's the thing. I know I'm somewhat in the- well,
I feel like it's a large minority, but I am in the minority because most people love this,
so I don't want to yuck anyone's yum, but it ain't good. It's trash, in fact. It is bad,
in fact. I just don't. I don't get it. I don't get it. I don't get it. I don't get how anyone
could like- you all know what this is about, so I do not need to tell you the plot. I don't think
worldbuilding is good. I don't think the fantasy is good. I don't think the plot is good. I don't
think the writing is good. I don't think the romance, which really this is romanticy, I don't
think the romance is good. Apart from maybe there was one scene that worked for me. On the whole,
there's no chemistry. There's no characters I care about. The only reason this was a two and
not a one style was the last page ending. I did enjoy that little twist-a-roony, but as time goes
on I do not think I'm gonna ever read Iron Flame for multiple reasons, which I'm sure many of you
know. We don't need to fully get into it, but I think that's all we need to say about a fourth
wing. Yeah, no thank you, Rebecca Yaros. No thank you. Number seven is a book that's not even out
yet and I feel bad. I think this is gonna be a big release next year and I feel bad that I, uh,
that I really did not like this and it is The Antique Hunter's Guide to Murder by C.L. Miller.
This comes out in January, no February 2024. I got an ARC. I'm so sorry. This book, I spoke to
you guys about it for so long, for so long, about how excited I was for it because it's murder
mystery meets antiques and if you've been here a long time you know every day I watch Bargain Hunt.
I'm an antiques expert. Any book wants to be written for me, this is it. It's also pictures
meets Indiana Jones. Right, let's get into it. My biggest issue with this book is that from,
I'd say the 100 page mark, we are in this stately home, country house place, right, where all the
characters, you know, you could see it as an isolated murder mystery but they can come and go,
you know, people aren't stuck there. We're not stuck in this house and I kid you not, nothing
happens. Nothing happens. You tell me Indiana Jones, I'm expecting heists and fast pace. They
just sit around and talk at this house for the whole book. It's so boring. Yawning. Sloppy. Lazy.
It's so boring. Really boring. I really hate books where nothing happens and in terms of like,
if it's a literary book where we're more going into characters' inner motivations and thoughts
and feelings, like, I can understand that, right? But in something that's pictured itself as Indiana
Jones, you best believe ---- better happen, you know? If you guys compare that there's a murder
club, which I think does so well, so much happening. It's got very short chapters, we constantly have
like three different storylines going on that we're kind of flitting back and forth between
and the plot is always moving along and we're going this place and that place and this person.
There's like five scenes in this book. Five scenes. Five scenes. It was such a disappointment
for me because this was one of my most anticipated books once I got my hands on it and
it's not great and I think this is going to be a big release next year. I mean, I could be wrong,
but it really did not work for me. I found it very, very boring.
Number six, we have one of the first books that I don't own. There's a few on here I don't own,
a few I can't find for the life of me. I might have on all of them. But we have Smoking 17
by Janet someone. I can't remember. This book, I've put it out of my memory. I read this for
the winners of the Goodreads Mystery Thriller throughout the years. This was one of the
earliest winners and no one was voting because I had it this way. This is number 17 in this kind
of cozy mystery slash romance series and I get what it's trying to do and I'm just not the audience
of what it's trying to do and I don't think it's doing well. From what I understand, there's these
two men in this woman's life. It's mostly about the romance, it's not really about the mystery
and it's trying to be funny, but it's really not funny and it's got some really harmful stereotypes
in it. But there's these two men and one's her boyfriend, like her boyfriend, like calling him
her boyfriend. And there's this other guy who she's sleeping with and she's like, oh, you know,
me and my boyfriend don't talk about whether we're sleeping with other people or not. Well,
then you're dating. He's not your boyfriend. Do you know what I mean? She just goes and
sleeps with this other guy. And I'm like, sorry. I always knew there was some type of scandal.
I felt it. If this was an open communication between you and your boyfriend, fine, I don't
care. But like, he could be thinking you're exclusive. Just go and **** this other guy.
And then there's multiple scenes where both guys turn up and it's just, oh, oh, and the mystery
was so bad. I can't even remember what the mystery was. She's like, is she a debt collector?
There's like a dead body. I don't know. It was really bad. It was like beyond bad. It was
beyond, I don't understand. These are, this is a very, you're going back in time. From what I
understand, quite a popular series. And I don't get it. I don't think it's funny. I don't think
it's engaging. I don't think it's hot in terms of the romance. I don't think that's enough of that.
Okay. Then we're getting into the 1.5 and then we'll get into the one. So my 1.5 this year was
What was this? I read this very early on in the year. So I've kind of got rid of it in my brain,
but we've got a girlie who's not like other girls and got this dark world that she lives in. And
there's something to do with shadows. Like if you lose your shadow or like you buy shadows. I can't
remember. And she's like weird and dealing, like trying to escape this world of criminals,
but can't really. This is a 9th house ripoff. Holly Black, what did you think you were doing?
You tried to rip off 9th house, but did it terribly. Yep. Yep. Yep. Yep. Yep. Yep. Yep. Yep.
I just thought this was terrible. I don't understand. This is my first introduction
to Holly Black and it just is. It's one of those books I can't really point you towards what's bad.
Like is the writing bad? Is the plot bad? But there's just something about it that just reeks.
It wasn't good. The ending wasn't good. I can see why this was so unpopular
when it came out. And yeah, I'm just surprised. Like I feel like a lot of those traditional YA
authors from back in the day are all making their switch to adult now. Like Leigh Bardugo did that
with 9th house. Cassandra Clare is doing it now. Holly Black did it with this. And this feels like
the least successful, if we're completely honest, of those. So yeah, I don't think I have anything
else to say. I've like forgotten everything about that book. Okay, let's begin One Stars. Coming in
at number four is The Murder Game by Tom Hindle. Now, this could have just been the fact that I
have very, very, very high standards for murder mysteries and this was one of the worst I've ever
read. Is it technically one star? Yeah, okay, it is. I read A Fatal Crossing by Tom Hindle and I
gave that like a three. But this one, it's pitched as there's these characters who go to this house
for a New Year's Eve party that's 1920s murder mystery game themed. I got excited because they're
playing a murder mystery game like Cluedo, but like in person at this party. But then there's
real murders, so it was a very exciting pitch to me. The murder mystery game never happens.
Never happens because someone dies and then they're just like, oh, we're not going to play a murder
mystery game now. My disappointment is immeasurable and my day is ruined. There are so many ways to
have done that synopsis in a much more interesting way, in a much more exciting way. It is wasted.
New Year's Eve party where they're playing a murder mystery game. Think of all the fun you
could have with that in this isolated, cold, dark house on the like in the, in this edge of a beach,
right? Just think of, just, I just want you to sit there and I'm sure you could imagine
lots of fun ways that you could incorporate the murder mystery game into the murders. That doesn't
happen. Someone dies and they will just sit around in a ******* house for hours until more people die.
Nothing happens. The characters were completely lacklustre. The writing wasn't great.
It wasn't good. And so that's me and Tom Hindle divorced, which is sad because he's one of the
biggest like UK classic murder mystery taking inspiration from Agatha Christie authors out
there at the moment. But I, I cannot continue. I can't continue in good faith. Very sad.
Coming in at number three is a book I never bought. I never got my hands on because I probably
knew I could sense it, my spidey senses. And that is The Stranger Upstairs by an author I can't
remember. These bad ones, I just can't, I, the authors leave my brain. I read this for Gabby's
Book Club. Yeah, it was bad. It's about an influencer who buys a murder house. So like
where a big famous murder happened, she's trying to flip it. And what else? There's like another
big, oh, she starts like losing her mind. And like, is the whole house haunted? Oh, it was bad.
First of all, I don't like when a book incorporates some kind of trendy career,
in this case, an influencer. It's not really clear. Does she have a blog? Does she do Instagram?
It annoys me so much when a book incorporates that, but doesn't get it. Like completely
does not get it, does not get how an influencer would conduct themselves. Don't do it if you
don't get it. Like she would be posting on Instagram, like at the end of an Instagram
caption, like any sponsors want to work with me? Like you wouldn't, you wouldn't do that.
You'd email them privately, but you wouldn't at the end of your Instagram be like, anyone want
to sponsor me? And it just went out the window. Like she was also a psychiatrist, but she...
I can't remember. I actually, there's more to this plot. I'm just forgetting it.
The romance, like her and her husband are on the ropes. That's stupid. It's all stupid. It's
stupid, stupid, stupid, stupid, stupid. I really hated it. I'm so sorry. Also, oh yeah, that was
it. The audiobook. The audiobook is bad. I listen exclusively to audiobooks. That's why I don't own
it. And like, she would, she like constantly like scream stuff. Oh, and that was it. There was...
This is like petty. These are little things that annoyed me, but basically in the murder that
happened back in the day, we read a scene about that murder happened back in the day, and like
apparently the daughter who didn't die, but like ran away, was like running down the street saying,
don't kill me! Don't kill me! But like then that would just, that was like a running motif
throughout the book that would just appear in a random scene when like our main girlie was just
going about her day. Then the audiobook narrator would suddenly be like, don't kill me! Don't kill
me! It really pissed me off. It really pissed me off. Like I can get easily pissed off by a book
and then just check out. So I know that's petty, but it really annoyed me. Then coming in at number
two is a book I did own. I think I must have unhauled it because I can't find it. I can't see
it! And that is Wild and Wicked Things. Again, can't remember the author. You'll see it here.
This was a book I read earlier this year for my patron book club, and it's pitched as witchy,
Great Gatsby inspired, but sapphic. And there's just a ridiculous amount of bad stuff that happens
in this book. It's a debut, and I just feel like this book was run too, too much. The live show for
this was really, really fun. Like the live show for this was a highlight for me because we were
just dunking on this book. We all pretty much didn't enjoy it, and I think a few people maybe
gave it a three, but I think that's really the highest that it got. We were just constantly
remembering things. Like someone would say something and we'd remember like another element
of this plot that happened and was ridiculous. We were like, no. I'm so glad that did happen.
The Great Gatsby-ness is kind of there at the beginning, but then dissipates. And you're not,
like it's been pitched by I feel like booksellers as Great Gatsby inspired, but like it never says
anywhere within the book, or I feel like the author hasn't said it's Great Gatsby inspired.
But like you can see there's moments where it's like, oh the blue light across the lake or whatever,
where you can see direct inspiration in some of the characters. You can see that, but then also
it's not. And the magic made no sense. I don't even know where to begin with you. I don't even
know where to begin. The writing wasn't good. There were so many plot holes. It wasn't good.
If I speak, I am in big trouble. In big trouble.
And then my worst book of the year, easily, is Every Line of You by Naomi Gibson. Oh girl.
This is YA, where I don't want to get into this too much. How much do I want to get into this?
Because some of this is spoilers, what I have to say. Let me give you a vague synopsis first. Okay,
well, a girlie makes an AI. She names after her dead brother. She's being bullied. Her AI is her
friend. Um, where do I go with this? No, I need to tell you. I need to tell you. I need to tell
you. Okay, we're getting into spoilers here because I need to tell you the ridiculousness
of what this book put me through. So her and the AI start to fall in love and he like gets her to
keep amping up what she's putting him in. So like in her phones, he can be with her at all times.
But then she tries to put him in a boy from school's body and is like cutting him open.
Maybe damaging his spine permanently, it turns out. But she gets caught and taken to a mental
hospital and like disconnected from Henry. Who, by the way, she's named after her dead brother.
She's named the AI after her dead brother. Okay? Okay, so a little bit incest-y. Like,
she's falling in love with the thing that she's named after her dead brother. And then, um,
there's this like agent, like hacking agent, who's been like watching her for ages or whatever.
He comes to visit her at this mental hospital. She- she corners him, somehow implants Henry,
the AI, into his body. They run away together. They- they- they have sex, which- let's just talk
about it for a second. Um, I don't think I can say that on- on- on YouTube without getting
demonetized. But we know that's not consensual. Because she's using that guy's body, who's trapped
in there, and apparently is like realizing everything that's going on. This grown man.
She's like, oh, me and Henry, no. No, you and that man, who you're forcing to do something
against his will. And then like there's this big scene at the end where like he gets- he gets
killed. Henry gets killed. But then he- maybe he's back and there's no- like by the end,
she hasn't realized what she's done. Oh guys, it's so- that's so bad. Evil, evil. And like,
this is YA, right? So if this was an adult book, her being like a villain by the end, or-
she's not clearly a villain, but you know, having not learned any repercussions really from her
actions, I'd be okay with. But like, I think with YA, you sometimes- when a character is doing as
terrible things as this character is, it's kind of romanticized at the end. Like her and Henry
might be reunited. This is a very unhealthy- you know, the AI is very controlling of her.
It's a very unhealthy relationship dynamic. There needs to be some sort of, um,
condemnation of this whole situation, and there isn't. The writing is terrible. I- there's like
this- there's a- there's- I don't know how much I want to get into this. This book is a rabbit hole.
This is completely alleged. This is completely alleged. This is completely alleged. I'm not
saying any of this is true, but there is a review on Goodreads that alleges that this book has been
written using AI with her book as like a basis. So it's like plagiarized her book with AI.
Like, it's a rabbit hole. This was terrible. It- there's no words. It was really bad,
and it is my worst book of 2023. So there we have it, everyone. That's my worst books of the year.
Let me know if you disagree with me on any of these. Did you love them? Did you disagree with
me on any of them? Did you hate them as well? But yeah, there were some bad books this year.
I feel actually cathartic having discussed it all with you. So thank you guys for watching,
let me know what some of your worst books of the year are as well,
and I'll see you very soon in another video. Bye!