The first 1,000 people watching this video to use my link will get a full year of Premium membership to Craftsy for only $1.49: https://go.craftsy.com/megwithbooks4/
🔮 Join me on Patreon! - Including a book club, weekly reading sprints, video plan sneak peeks, a bookish community discord, early access + more!! https://www.patreon.com/megwithbooks 🔮
Obviously I spend a lot of my time giving you guys book recommendations but today
we're gonna uno reverse that and I'm going to get recommendations from you
doing a video that I liked every year. Usually it's at the end of the year in like November,
I know it's March. The move changed some things, it's switching things up but today
I'm gonna be reading your best books of 2025. I asked on my YouTube community page and Instagram
what your best books of 2025 were and I'm re-reading the most popular ones from that.
I love doing this video every year, I always find some hits, you know, these books I find
are popular for a reason. So yeah, I think I always get at least like a five star or a 4.5
on this vlog so I can't wait to dive into it. Before we get into the reading though,
I want to talk about something that I hope is going to feature as one of my best
things of 2026. Let's get into it. So what I'm hoping might be one of my highlights of 2026
is crafting, is getting more into crafting hobbies. I know a lot of you feel the same,
I know a lot of us are like itching to get into knitting or crocheting or sewing or pottery or
painting or whatever it happens to be. And so yeah, crafting I'm hopefully making into a big
part of my 2026 and I want to give a shout out to the sponsor of today's video which is Craftsy,
which has been a huge part of me getting into crafting so far this year. I have an amazing
offer for you guys today with Craftsy, so stick around because truly I think this is one of the
most amazing sponsored offers. I've had it a few times and if you haven't made use of it by now,
what are you doing? Because it's truly amazing. Craftsy is your online resource for all things
creative. They have classes on all crafts you can imagine, be that painting, knitting, sewing,
cake decorating, crocheting, anything you can imagine. There are classes on there for all
levels, so if you're a complete beginner like me there are classes that you can take on there,
but if you are like a knitting profesh babe, if you know how to knit, there's also classes on
there you can take to really level up your knitting or whatever, whatever craft it may be.
So I've been taking the class Perfect Knits Every Time Understanding Knitting Patterns with Kate
Adderley. In this class it's all about teaching you the terminology that you need to know when
reading knitting patterns. Also how to follow knitting charts and keeping an accurate track
of your stitches and rows for accurate knitting. There are so many classes on there, so many
classes are constantly being added and being created. Like I say, there are ones for every
single level and every single craft you can imagine. It's truly an incredible online resource
if you want to get into crafting this year. So my amazing offer is that the first 1000 of you
watching this video who click the link in the description will get one year free of Craftsy
365 days for $1.49. Isn't that amazing? Honestly, I don't think you can lose at least going on
Craftsy and giving it a go, seeing if there's any classes on there you would like to take.
This offer is valid for new members only, but yeah, if you've never tried out Craftsy,
go give it a go down below. Okay, let's chat most popular books, what came up the most.
Let's start with the books I have read because by far and away the most popular book that anyone,
everyone said was their best book of 2025 is a book I have read, and it's no quinces. It was
my best book of 2025, Atmosphere by Taylor Jenkins Reid. The girlies loved it. What can you say? The
girlies loved it. And I am biased, but I do think it deserves it. Yeah, not a surprise to me. It is,
it's an outstanding book. It's an outstanding book. The other book that I want to shout out,
10 people said Project Hail Mary, which I have read. And I do want to say, I don't think I've
said in the vlog, I saw Project Hail Mary and I ******* loved it. I loved it. What a film,
cinema. That's cinema to me. Ryan Gosling. I don't know why I underestimated you. Like,
truly outstanding, done with physical effects. Read the book, watch the film. And you can do
that any order, I think. I was talking to my patrons about it. I don't think it's the kind
of film that watching it would ruin the book for you. Like, I think you could read the book,
then watch the film, or watch the film, then read the book, and you'll enjoy it either way.
Then it drops off massively. Five people said The Favourites by Lane Fargo. Four said I,
Who Have Never Known Men, which I think I read for this book the year previous. This vlog,
sorry, the year previous. We Used to Live Here, which I think I read for the vlog the year
previous. The books, certain books come up again and again in this vlog. But anyways,
let's get into it. So first book I'm going to be reading, 12 people said, and that is
A Dungeon Crawler Carl by Matt Dillerman. I am so excited to see what I think of this.
I have been meaning to read this for 10,000 years. People have been telling me to read
this for so long. I just know you've got Carl, the world ends, he ends up in this,
like, reality TV show that's in a fighting dungeon, and there's Princess Donut, who is
Deeda. Do you want a bit of Deeda cam? You're going to see all my washing though, but to be
honest, I don't care. There she is. Resplendent Queen on our moving boxes still that I haven't
moved. I will be moving them soon. We're going to be, um, we're going to be moving out of this
room soon. Let me just say that. But yeah, I'm excited to read Deeda in a book form. I've heard
such great things about it. So obviously if it's the number one book that I have not yet read,
that people said was their favorite book of the year. I am a bit intimidated by it because it's
been, this whole series has really blown up this past year, but I'm excited to see what I think of
it. I do big things with big deal people. And guess what? I'm a big ******* deal. Then with
10, 10 people said Wild Dark Shore by Charlotte McConaughey. Again, very intrigued about this. I'm
going to be honest, this one and the next one, I'm not as clued in the plot. This is a book that I
think was like on my most anticipated releases of 2025 that I've owned for quite some time. But do
I really know the plot? No, I know it's to do with like environment. I think it's environment,
an environmental thriller, almost a bit leaning contemporary. I think we're following a lot of
characters in this isolated setting, but that's all I really need to know. I don't want to know a
lot about this. I want to go into it to see what I think of it. But I have watched and heard so
many people love this. I remember Kayla loved it. Loads of people in my patron have loved it and
given it five stars. And I've never read a book by Charlotte McConaughey, but everyone tells me
that I'm really going to enjoy this. So I'm excited for that. Then 10 people did say Sunrise
on the Reaping by Suzanne Collins. I'm not going to be reading Sunrise on the Reaping because I
was supposed to read this for the Goodreads Choice Awards winner vlog. That makes it two vlogs where
I'm supposed to be reading this and I'm refusing. I can't do it. My heart is saying no. I have not
read any Hunger Games book ever, ever. And I know some people, when I said in that vlog, I'm not
reading it because I haven't read a Hunger Games book, they're like, oh, it's a standalone. You
cannot tell me that I would get the same enjoyment from Sunrise on the Reaping having never read a
Hunger Games book versus have. Like the people who love Sunrise on the Reaping are because they love
the Hunger Games series and how that book is referential to the rest of the Hunger Games
series or giving answers to what happened in some parts of the rest of the Hunger Games series.
However, I am going to be reading this before the year is up at some point this year, maybe close to
when the movie for this comes out. I don't know yet. I'm going to read every Hunger Games book.
I'm going to read the original trilogy. I'm going to read, what is the other one called?
The one about snow. I can't remember what this book is called. There's a snake on the cover.
Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes. I'm going to read that and I'm going to read Sunrise on the Reaping.
I'm going to read them all back to back. So I will be reading this before the year's end.
Shout out to everyone whose favourite book it was, but it's not getting read right now.
The rules don't apply. And then finally, nine people said Blood Over Brighthaven by M.L. Wang.
So this is going to be our third book for this vlog. Again, don't really know the plot about
this. I believe it's like a magic school book. That's what I really want to know. I did read,
however, Sword of Kaigen by M.L. Wang earlier this year and I gave it 4.5. I had a lot of 4.5
so far this year. 1.5. A lot of 4.5s. I loved the writing. It felt so accomplished. And so I'm
super intrigued to read what I think is her first traditionally published book. I love a magical
school, as I'm sure we all do. And so, yeah, I'm super intrigued to see what I think of this.
So I think these three books here, we've got a pretty outstanding selection. Two more fantasy
leaning. One more, I think, contemporary thriller environmental book leaning. I think I will start
with Dungeon Crawler Karl, because when I meant to do this video in November, I did start the
video and I read maybe the first just 30 pages of this before I had to give up and accept defeat
on not being able to get this video done in time. So since I have started this already, I am going
to start it again. I'll let you know my thoughts when I'm a little bit of the ways through.
Friends, I have started my first book for this vlog. I'm loving it. I'm 100 pages in,
so I'm not super far in, but I am obsessed. So it opens up with basically the world ending.
Karl, our guy Karl, he has to save Donut. Okay, now let me start again. Donut the cat dives out
a window. It's his girlfriend, ex-girlfriend's cat who he's looking after. And he goes out with
her and he's like, okay, Donut, we've got to get inside. And at that point, everything that's on
earth gets sucked down. And it turns out that anyone who was inside is dead. And he enters
this dungeon that is a reality TV show survival. You've got to kill everyone to survive. There's
these levels to it. And we go from there. Princess Donut, ******* icon. To be completely honest,
she needs no help because she is a diva. She's perfect the way she is. Everyone who's told me
that Dita is Princess Donut, very much, very much. Dita very much has Princess Donut energy,
totally and completely. I love Princess Donut. I love a cat, right? I love a cat. And I love,
I'm very passionate about this. If you're going to have a cat character who maybe, I don't want to
spoil anything, but maybe speaks or has some sort of inner monologue or whatever, they must speak
like a cat. It annoys me when there's a cat and they don't have the correct cat energy. And I
don't even need to describe what that cat energy is. You just know it's either got it or it hasn't.
And this has it. Like, doesn't give a ----, wants their way. They are the most important
thing in the world. Like that is essential. And this has it. And I'm enjoying, I've never really
read anything like this before. Is it lit RPG? Is that what the kids call it? I don't know.
This kind of gamification style thing. But I'm really enjoying it. I immediately want to recommend
it to my brother and my dad because my brother plays a lot of like Dungeon Dragons, which I
guess, I don't even know. I've never played Dungeon Dragons. I've got to ask him, but I guess
it's kind of similar to the vibes of this, like the loot boxes that they get and like the items
that they get for the fights. And I just feel like he would love it. And I feel like my dad would
really enjoy it too. So I need to recommend this to them. But I think it's really well written.
It's not fast paced. It's slow. I think this is a book that is meant to be savoured and enjoyed.
I'm intrigued as to like, there's levels to this dungeon, right? Is this first book all on the
first level? Are we going to have multiple levels? Is it a book per level? I have questions. But I'm
really enjoying the writing style. The audiobook is great. I feel like if you're going to read this
book, I recommend getting the audiobook because there's like different voices for the kind of
game announcers or like the game notifications that he gets. There's like a special voice for
those. I think it's really good. I'm having a great time. That's all I have to say. I'm 100
pages in, right? I'm not super far in, but I'm having a great time. I'm doing a readathon today
with my patrons. So I've just got off our morning sprints. We've got evening sprints later, but I
need to have lunch. We've got four and a half hours till our evening sprints. Four hours and 20 minutes.
I need to have lunch. I need to clean my bathrooms, which I really don't want to do, but I have to do it.
Clean my bathrooms. I'd like to go out for a walk perhaps. I'd like to also watch some of the Norwich
City game. I'm not sure how the walk and watching the game will overlap. How well that'll overlap.
Those are things that are on my goals list for the next four and a half hours. It seems a bit,
a whole lot to do in four and a half hours. A Norwich game alone is like two hours.
So anyways, I don't know, and the walk would be like an hour. I don't know how it's gonna work out.
I'm gonna, I'll let you know when I've read some more of this, but yeah, I'm really enjoying it so far.
It is sunny out. My neighbours are listening to the radio. Apologies if you can hear any sounds,
but let's chat Dungeon Corner Carl. I am giving it 4.5 stars. I loved this. I loved this book so much.
I've got to admit, most of my reading experience I did on reading sprints, my patrons who had like
exclusive weekend readathon this weekend, and I kind of just said to them after every sprint,
I'm loving it. I'm loving it. It was a very no thoughts, head empty reading experience for me.
I didn't think about it. I just read it. But for me, that often is a sign of a good book,
because I am obviously a book reviewer. And so often when I'm reading books, I'm like,
I'm thinking about it, right? I'm thinking about, do I like how it's done this? Do I like how it's
done this? I'm evaluating it as I read. This was a reading experience for me where I had no thoughts,
baby. I just sat back and let Matt Dinnaman steal the show. I really, really enjoyed this.
A lot of what I think I said, I can't remember what I said in the last clip, but a lot of what
I think I said still stands. You know, I love the video game element. I've already recommended this
to my dad and brother and be like, you need to read this because they love video games. I loved
the loot boxes. I loved defeating the bosses. I love Princess Stoneheart with my whole heart.
I'm obsessed. I am obsessed with Princess Stoneheart. Like genuinely, this book made me
laugh. And it, I think that's quite a high bar these days, a book to make me laugh. It doesn't
happen. It doesn't happen every day. And I chuckled many a time. I love Carl also as a main character.
I love their relationship and I'm so excited to see this world grow. I will say, I think many of
you should go in with the expectation, if you haven't read this yet, with the expectation that
this, I feel like doesn't quite have the usual story arc structure you expect for the book,
like a peak and then a denouement, you know, the usual story arc structure that you know.
I don't think it really has that. Like the ending, if you're wanting a traditional book,
could feel a bit disappointing, could feel a bit unfinished. But like this series is about
the series. Like we are telling a story across nine books already or something and eight books
at this point. And it's going to have like peaks and troughs, many peaks and troughs with each
book. So like I'd say one of the peaks of this book was kind of halfway through, right? It's
going to have many peaks and troughs throughout the book, but doesn't follow a usual story pattern.
And I don't hate that, right? I'm down for the long haul. I'm ready to start this series. I'm
ready to make progress on the series. And I'm so excited to read the second one already. I feel
like I need to keep the momentum going. Like I feel like I need to read at least another two this
year or something in this series to keep the momentum going of getting through it. But I love
the audiobook. I cannot recommend the audiobook enough if you haven't read this yet. And it was
just a great fun time. It's just not quite a five, but I am being so stingy with my fives this year.
That makes this my fourth 4.5 of the year. Like I'm giving out a lot of 4.5s. I'm reading a lot
of books that I really, really enjoy. I've given out one five. For some reason, the fives are
stingy. But I feel like this is a series that by book four, I'll probably be giving it a five. Or
maybe even earlier, you know, like you are with these characters for the long haul. I'm also
really interested in some of the like world political elements that we've only touched on,
like the corporation that is running this whole reality TV dungeon experience. Like we have a
character, I think called Zed or Zeb. Spoiler alert a little bit. Their contact, they're kind
of like manager almost, like appearance manager, because there's like talk shows that they can go
whilst being in the dungeon to like promote themselves. That was one of my favourite moments
when I almost called her Dina when Dona was on one of the reality TV shows. That was very fun.
And just like seeing the hints of that, like the wider world that I feel like Matt Dinnerman is
going to expand this into, wider characters and wider ramifications for what's really going on
here in this reality TV show fight to the death dungeon. That intrigues me a lot. So yeah, this
is a great recommendation. I can see why it was so many people's favourite book of the year. I
can't wait to make more progress. I like Mordecai as a character. I love like the little moments
where we get a description of like an item or like a monster that appears and like the description
that we get and their level. I think it's so fun. Also, I think I don't really have anything to
compare this to, right? I've never really read anything like this. It's a very unique book.
And so yeah, I just really enjoyed it. I had a lot of fun with it. It was a great time. I now
think I'm going to start Wild Dark Shore to break up the two kind of fantasy books we have.
And I'm super excited to see what I think of that. I can't speak fast. The audiobook for that has
also been highly recommended to me. I think it's got like four narrators. So I'm excited. I'm
loving reading. The sun is out. Life is good. I just love reading. I know I'm reading a bit less
this year. But I'm loving reading. Like I'm really enjoying my reading when I'm doing it.
And books are great. Books are what makes the world go round. Anyways, I'll see you a little
bit later this evening with my thoughts, initial thoughts on Wild Dark Shore.
Hello. I am about 120 pages into Wild Dark Shore. So I'm just under halfway through.
I fear I'm not getting it. No, that sounds bad, guys. And forgive me for saying it.
But that's how I felt. I'm not getting it. I'm not getting it. I'm not getting it. I feel very
similar to when I read My Friends, which is interesting considering they're number one and
two in the contemporary category in the Goodreads Choice Awards. But My Friends was also a lot of
people's favourite book of the year. It was fairly high on this list. I think maybe six people said
it. And obviously I've heard from a lot of people it was their favourite book of the year. And I'm
just not... it's not clicking. I can almost see why other people love it. But it's not clicking
for me personally. So the plot of this, you don't want to know too much going into it. We have got
this man and his three children who live on this extremely, extremely isolated island. They're kind
of the caretakers of this island. And a woman washes up on shore, almost dead, and they kind
of nurse her back to life. And it goes from there. They both have secrets that they're keeping from
each other. And when I heard people review this book, right, people would say like, it's so
poignant. The writing is so poignant. It has these like, observations on life or the world or where
we're headed as a society and stuff like that. Or people would talk about, you know, the character
motivations and like really, really well written characters, really interesting, dynamic, layered
characters that have very like compelling motivations for doing things. I'm... I'm not there
on either of those things. I'm a bit bored, if I'm honest with you. BORED SHITLESS! And I don't want
to admit that. I think like part of me, maybe 20 pages ago, was going to come and be like, oh, it's fine.
You know, I'm interested to see where it goes. If I'm truthful with myself, I'm bored. But I almost
feel like I shouldn't be. Like, I feel like that's sacrilegious. I feel like I can't say that. I'm not
particularly attached to the characters. They're not particularly interesting to me. In contrast
to My Friends, where I was reading that and being like, oh my god, there's moments where the writing
is really poignant. It says something about life that is so like hits home, so beautiful. I haven't
felt like that once. Nothing has been said where I'm like, oh, oh my god, yeah, you've connected
the dots. I'm not getting it. I'm not getting it. I mean, here's the thing. I'm under halfway through,
right? We have a lot of book left for it to win me over. I'm interested in like Fen, the daughter,
kind of what's been happening with her. I think she's the most interesting character so far. But
yeah, not very interesting check-in because I'm not very interested. I don't, I'm not connecting
with this book. But that's why reading is great because there are books, there's books I love
that I will recommend to you and you'll be like, what the heck is this? You know, some people don't
get The Strange Case of the Alchemist's Daughter. Some people do. You either get it or you don't.
That is one of my favourite books of all time. I can accept that some people will read that and be
like, that's ----. Even people who I have very similar reading tastes to, in terms of mysteries,
have read that and been like, it's ----. But then a lot of people also read it and be like,
greatest fiction known to man, greatest fiction known to man. So, you know, like, it'll be boring
if you all like the same stuff. But I am sad because I was anticipating this and I've heard,
I've heard so much said about this author, right? Like, more than other people, this author's craft,
this author's craft in terms of writing, this author's craft in terms of characters, and it's
just not clicking for me. However, we're going to go read on the beach now. We're going to walk
down to the beach. It's a sunny morning, so we're going to go walk down to the beach and I'm going
to do some reading there. But yeah, it's not, I'm not getting what everyone else seems to get.
Okay, I have finished Wild Duck Shore by Charlotte McConaughey. I'm giving this 3.5
stars. I feel very, very similarly to how I felt about My Friends in that I don't get it. I'm not
connecting. I didn't connect to the characters. They felt at a distance to me. They felt like I
was seeing them and the story through a fog. Like I could see the outline of the thing. I could see
what it was, what it was trying to be, what it was shooting for, but it felt, I felt disconnected
from it. How humiliating and degrading. I feel, I feel embarrassed about this one. I feel like it
makes me feel like my IQ is significantly less than everyone else's. You know, I really enjoyed
the setting we were in. It's a very visceral, overwhelming, insurmountable setting. And I
thought that added a really interesting element to the book. Now, the last 100 pages of this,
very strong. I originally was probably going to give this a 3 and it raised up to a 3.5. The
last 100 pages, everything starts to come together. You start to see answers for stuff. But I think
because this really is like a literary thriller, in a way, some of those answers felt small to me
because they were the kind of answers you would get in a thriller, right? A shock moment, a reveal,
but they weren't done with the same camp. They were done with like intelligence. They were done
with a deft hand. And I, I'm not sure I want that from a reveal like that. I want that moment to
feel more dramatic and big. But yeah, the ending definitely pulled around for me. Apart from
the ending ending, it does something that is cruel. And I think it's needlessly cruel. I don't
want to spoil it for anyone, but like it, it shoots for something, right? It makes a decision. And I
don't think it needed to make that decision. I don't think it really adds anything to what this
story is saying. And it just is sad. I don't think it really, I mean, that might be a severe misreading
of the book for me that I don't think it adds anything to what it's saying. But I think if
you're at a crossroads right at this moment, it goes this way. I think if it were to go this way,
which is a nicer ending in some ways, in a book that is already quite cruel, I don't think it
would change anything. I don't think it adds like a huge impact where it probably should. So yeah,
I don't know. I don't know. Obviously everyone loved this. It won the Contemporary Award for
Goodreads Choice Awards. It was so many of your favourite books. No, it didn't win. It came second.
Excuse me. I read my friends which won. But I did tell a bit of a lie there. But it came second. You
know, it was so many people whose reading tastes I trust, and I have a similar reading taste to,
gave this five stars. But I just think there's something about the writing, the characters,
that just isn't personally for me, right? I guess I can see how, but I don't, I just feel like I
kind of read a different book for everyone. But this is what I've been saying recently, right?
Some books connect, some books don't, right? I loved Dungeon Caller Karl. I can kind of see
how someone could read that. I mean, obviously everyone loves Dungeon Caller Karl, but I can
actually see how someone could read that and not connect and give it three stars, right? Not every
book is for everyone. And with both this and my friends, I just have this like overwhelming
feeling of, well, I guess it's just ain't for me. I guess I'm the only one. I guess I'm the outlier.
So yeah, not, what can I say? What can I say? That's where we are. I don't think I would rush
to read another Charlotte McConaughey because I think some of this was the writing. I think
there were moments, there was like two great lines, two great lines, two great moments where
when I almost cried, I was doing my makeup, otherwise I would have cried. But there were
moments where there were these end of chapter lines, you know, dramatic end of chapter line
where it was trying to be poignant and I was like, no. Sure, babe. Sure. I'm now going to read
Blood Ever Brighthaven. I'm going to read Blood Ever Brighthaven. I'm actually going to do quite
a lot of reading today. The weather isn't very nice. So my plan is to hopefully get at least
halfway through today. I'll let you know my thoughts when I'm a bit of the way through,
but I feel like, you know, I've already given Sword of Kaigen 4.5 stars and something about
the setting of this, from my understanding, is like a magical school, I feel like could be
five star material for me. So I'm excited to see what I think of it.
Hello, hello, hello, friends. I come at you being just under halfway through Blood Ever
Brighthaven by Emma Wang. Again, I'm not sure. I'm not sure. Stop while you're ahead.
So just a brief synopsis is we're following Siona. I'm just going to read out some of the
stuff it says in the back because it actually sums it up better than I can. She finally achieves
her ambition to become the first woman to be admitted to the higher magistrate at the university
and she is kind of tasked with, it's very complex, it's quite a complex magic system,
but like she is given quite an important job with this problem to solve with their magic.
And as a woman, she's obviously viewed a lot lesser by kind of like her colleagues. And so
she should have an assistant, but she's given the janitor who comes from a like class or an
ethnicity that is really viewed as lesser in this society and is there's quite a lot of racism
towards. And yeah, they're working together to unsolve, to solve this thing. Right. Okay.
Here's the thing. I'm obviously really comparing this to Sword of Kaigen, which I read in January
or February and I loved. I gave 4.5 stars. I just think this isn't doing everything for me that that
book did. So Sword of Kaigen feels, Kaigen, I say Kaigen, it's wrong. Okay. It feels very large,
it feels like a large world, a large book. You're following generations of characters. You're
following different families of characters. There's a lot of relationships. There's a lot
of characters who are all going through their own stuff. It feels so like dense in a good way
and like really detailed. In this, we're only really following Sayona. It's her story. She's
the star. She's the it girl. And so far we've mostly been just her and Tomil in the lab
working on this thing together for like 200 pages. And so they just feel like polar opposites to me.
And I think I preferred the vastness, the expanse of Sword of Kaigen. This feels quite
small, especially for a standalone fantasy. I think if this was a first book in the series,
I might be a bit more forgiving because I'm like, okay, it's going to go somewhere. It's
going to grow. This is a standalone. And I'm just not sure. I'm not sure. I'm enjoying it,
but on the back or on the front, it's like the best fantasy novel of the year. The people who
love this are like, oh, it's the best book bar none I've read all year. The people who love
this love it. And I'm not sure it's the best fantasy book I've read this year or best fantasy
book I've read by this author this year. I'm not sure about Sayona. Here's the thing. She's a bit
annoying at the start. She's a lot. She's a bit annoying. She has grown up in it seemingly. I
don't want to spoil anything, but she's been taught things that aren't wrong and is one of
those people that's incredibly intelligent, but also has allowed herself to be lied to really and
believe the easy truth. I just think she's not compelling enough character for me to have loved,
loved, loved spending 200 pages with. Now there's little hints. The way people talk about this,
it has to be more than what it is right now, right? And so there is a direction. I don't know
if it's going to happen, but I feel like it could turn into like, uh, I don't want to spoil anything,
but like a bit of a poppy war scenario. If it goes down that route, I will enjoy it.
I want it to, I want it to get a bit unhinged. I don't know. I might be down for that, but if that
doesn't happen, I think I might be disappointed. So that's where I'm at. I'm enjoying it. I think
it's incredibly Robertson, but just if I had to recommend people ML Wang right now, I'm still
definitely 100% recommending The Sword of Kaigen because it felt like that book was doing so much
and like pretty much achieving everything it was setting out to achieve. This one feels like,
to me, is not doing a lot. So that's where we're at. I'm going to go to the gym and then I'm going
to come back and finish this bad boy, but it's not bad. Like it's probably a 3.5 or a 4. I don't
need to get the impression that it's bad, but it's not The Sword of Kaigen and it's not what
I thought this would be by the way everyone has spoken about it. Hello. Um, in the hours since I
last spoke to you, I've developed a cold. So apologies for my disheveled appearance, but I
finished Blood Over Brighthaven by ML Wang and I'm giving this four stars. The second half of this
is so, so much better than the first. So much better. I loved the direction this went in. I
feel like it, the little hints I was talking about in the first half came to fruition. I really
enjoyed where it went and it took some swings. It wasn't afraid to take some swings and some risks.
I bet there'll be people who'll be like, oh, I enjoyed the pacing of the first half. And then
I'm not sure about where that went in the second half. I'm not sure about, listen,
I think it's great. That was me eating it up. That was me having a spoon to my mouth, eating
it up. Sorry. I wasn't, I really admire those swings it took in the second half. Now I do still
think Sword of Kaigen is such a better book. I was saying on reading sprints just now that I think
me giving this four, uh, four stars makes me consider, should I have given that five stars?
Because it's so much better. This has a lot of issues that that didn't have. And so I don't
really get that. I don't really get that. I think the writing is better than Sword of Kaigen. I
think the pacing, I think it's more interesting. There's more going on, but maybe that's something
that she could do in that kind of self pub book. And this being traditionally published, it feels
like it has a more typical story arc, which Sword of Kaigen doesn't have. It kind of has its peak in
the middle. Then you have like 300 pages of the aftermath, which is very unusual. You have no
aftermath in this, let me tell you. It's like bang, bye. I still don't get why everyone seems
to think this is the best fantasy book ever written. I think there's a lot better out there.
I think it feels, uh, a bit like an author in their infancy who is going to get better and
better and better. There were elements of this that felt a bit over-explained, a bit, you know,
long dialogues between characters that I didn't love. And I just want to clarify, when I said
in the first half, I don't, she's not annoying. In the first half, she does things and you know,
she could be so much better than that. You know, she could be so much more than that,
but she does things and says things. You're like, girl, that's why she's annoying. I don't want to
get that misconstrued. But yeah, I think this is a good fantasy book. I don't know if I ever
recommend this though. You know what I mean? I think I would always recommend Sword of Kaigen
over this. I think there's many fantasy books I'd recommend over this, but it was a good time and I
enjoy what this book is talking about. And it's talking about prejudice, misogyny, racism, you
know, systems and societies built on upholding kind of class structures or, you know, creating
an enemy, creating a subjugated class. Uh, I think it was all really interesting seeing that's
explored through a fantasy book. But yeah, I kind of don't get why it's everyone's favorite book.
I kind of like, just read Sword of Kaigen. There we have it friends. I hope you enjoyed me reading
your best books of 2025. I'm excited already to see what they are for 2026. Apologies,
this video was so late. But, um, yeah, let me know in the description if you've read any of
these books. Do you have a similar opinion to me on any of them? Did you not get Wild Dark Shore,
sadly, either? And let me know again if you didn't let me know on those original posts
what your best book of 2025 was. Thank you so much for watching and I'll see you soon in another
video. Bye