mod11lec52

IIT Roorkee July 201
61 followers
2 Video Views·Dec 5, 2023
Surface modification techniques: HVOF and Detonation spraying
Hello, I welcome you all in this presentation related with the subject fundamentals of surface
engineering and you know in the previous presentations we have talked about the other thermal spray
processes and more specifically the flame spray process. The flame spray process is
known as high temperature low velocity process, under which suffers from the various undesirable
features like coarse grain structure, porosity inclusions and limited bond strength.
So, we have also talked about the few methods which can be used to enhance the performance
of the flame sprayed coatings. In this presentation will be talking about the three processes,
these are the high velocity oxy-fuel spray process, detonation gun spray process and
the cold spray process. All these three processes are the combustion-based process where as
fuel oxygen gas mixture is burnt to generate the heat and then after accelerating the
particles to sufficiently high velocities the impingement of the coating material with
substrate takes place for the development of the coatings. So, these three processes
primarily differ with the velocity which is attained and the temperature up to which material
is heated during the spray process. So, we will be talking about each of these processes
one by one.
Like say, if we see the comparative plot of the various thermal spray processes, then
the particle velocity and the gas temperature, these are the two very crucial parameters,
the temperature which is generated during the thermal spray and the particle velocity
which is attained during the thermal spray. So, particle velocity decides the density
or the soundness of the coating as well as the coating substrate bond strength. And the
kind of splat bonding is also influenced by the particle velocity.
On the other hand, the temperature of the heat source or the gas temperature of whatever
is generated during the thermal spray process, that may cause complete melting of the particles
which is being is sprayed or it can cause the partial melting or it can cause the thermal
softening of the material. So, in case of the cold spray process, the temperature the
gas temperature is limited and the particle temperature is also 400 to 500 degree centigrade.
So, there is no melting as such and primarily thermal softening of the material takes place.
While in other processes, the temperature rises more. Like if you see the arc wire spray
process the temperature is in the range of 2000 to 4000 degree centigrade, while in case
of the plasma arc is process temperature can be even greater than the 5000 degree centigrade.
For detonation gun temperature is low like 2000 to 2500 degree centigrade same is true
for the high velocity oxy-fuel process, but it is higher than cold spray process like
1000 to 2000-2200 degree centigrade. But these are the flame temperatures, the
particle temperature, in all these cases will be lesser. And since higher the flame temperature
greater will be the particle temperature and which will be leading to either melting or
partial melting, softening tendencies. But apart from these there will also be tendency
for the interaction of the material which is being is sprayed with gases which are present.
So, this will be affecting the soundness especially with regard to the inclusion formation and
the second one, kind of the metallurgical transformations. Sometimes undesirable transformation
degrades the quality of the coating material which is being sprayed. Especially like W2C
like tungsten carbide can transform to the WC. So, this of the higher hardness of 25
HV while these is of 1800 to 2000 HV.
So, this kind of thermal degradation can occur if the coating material is exposed to the
higher temperature for longer time. So, if we consider these two aspects, then we will
notice that those processes where temperature is limited, they will be favourable with regard
to the inclusions formation are the undesirable metallurgical transformation point of view.
While the higher particle velocity will be leading to the more dense, less pores and
the good coating substrate bond strength. And apart from that when the particle velocity
is too high, then it will be leading to the development of the residual compressive stresses.
And this is found to be favourable under the wear conditions as well as this can also be
helpful in enhancing the mechanical performance of the component.
So, if we see, the more thermal damage will be occurring in case of the arc wire spray
and the plasma arc spray process. But the wire flame and the powder flame processes,
these are very low velocity processes. While in case of the detonation gun, high velocity
and cold spray process these are the high velocity processes. And so, they will be leading
to the much better much better coating substrate bond strength, development of the residual
compressive stresses as well as reduced porosity in the coatings.
Now, we will see the particular process in detail, the high velocity oxy-fuel process.
So, here oxygen and fuel gas, it can use number of fuel gases, it may be in form of like say
the propane, hydrogen, acetylene, liquid petroleum gas, ethylene, kerosene, methane etcetera.
And all these, we can select one of these fuel gases mixed with the oxygen and then
it is fed in the torch, so that the flame can be produced. So, we can see the oxygen is
fed and then we will see also that the fuel gas is also supplied.
So, oxygen and both fuel gases are supplied so that after forming a mixture, they can;
their combustion that can take place and sufficient heat is generated and the temperature rise
takes place like 2000 to 2500 degree centigrade. And this work is needed for either melting
or partial melting of the material which is being which is to be coated. And the material
which is to be coated is fed with the help of suitable career gas which may in form of
like say nitrogen.
So, material in form of the powder may be like say Nickel-Chromium-Boron-Silicon or
the Cobalt-Chromium-Tungsten-Carbon or the Nickel-Tungsten carbide powder mixture. So,
as per need, suitable hot air is selected and it is fed up with the help of the nitrogen
as a carrier gas. When it passes through this one, a very high velocity is attained due
to the heat generation as well as the compressed air is also used.
Combination of these things will be leading to the generation of the very high velocity
of the gases as well as the particles which are there. It will be like say, 500 to 1000
meters per second powder velocity. In this case if you see oxygen and the fuel gas mixture
is being burnt and at the same time as we are also using the compressed gas and powder
is fed with nitrogen as a carrier gas. Earlier we have just used the oxygen and fuel gas
mixture and in that one, we had fed the powder mixture.
So, because of the additional role of compressed air along with oxygen and fuel gas mixture
and the feeding of the powder with the help of the nitrogen as a carrier gas, all these
things will you facilitating the supply of the coating material in the flame which will
be heated to the sufficient high temperature, then it will be accelerated and when it is
accelerated to high velocity, the impingement of this material with substrate leading to
the development of the coatings.
So, we can say this is an advanced version of the fuel flame spray process and very high
velocity up to 1000 meters per second can be attained by the powder particles which
are being sprayed on to the surface of the substrate. And the temperature rise is also
high enough to cause either melting or the partial melting. Since the velocity which
is attained in this process is quite high and that is why the impingement of the powder
of particles with a substrate will be occurring at very high velocity with high kinetic energy.
So, it will be getting flattend and very firmly and that is why the pores which are left out
between the coating and substrate or other between the various splats, these are very
less and that is why we find very limited pores. So, the porosity in these coatings
in HVOF coating is less than 1 % and high velocity impingement with the surface of substrate
or already deposited material will be leading to the very good coating substrate bond strength
greater than 80 MPa.
We know that minimum acceptable coating substrate bond strength is 70 MPa, but when this process
is effectively applied, we get much higher coating bond strength. Since the particle
velocity through the flame is extremely high, so the material, spray of the material during
the flight from the torch to the substrate is very less. Duration, especially the duration
of the coating material in the flame is for very less period.
And therefore, the kind of thermal damage in terms of the undesirable metallurgical
transformations or the interaction of the coating material or material to be coated
with the gases which are present, all that is very less. So, what is important the duration
of the stay of the material being coated at high temperature is less in HVOF process because
of the high velocity and that is why thermal damage in terms of the undesirable metallurgical
transformations or interaction of these materials with the gases is very less.
And that is why we get extremely reduced damage to the material which is being coated on to
the surface of the substrate. And like say, particle velocity, particles of size 10 to
63 micrometer can attend the velocity in the range of like 300 to 800 meter per second,
especially at the time of impact. The kinetic energy of the powder particles at the time
of impingement is more crucial. So, that in turn also will be affected by the stand of
distance which is between the nozzles to the substrate.
So, it has to be optimised are so that the particles attain the maximum velocity and
at the time of impingement the particles are having enough velocity. And this kind of the
process can be effectively used for coating wide range of the materials which can be used
for enhancing the abrasion resistance, erosion resistance and since the deposition rate offered
by this process very high, so it can be effectively observed for at the industrial level for surface
modification, so that the resistance to the wear under the different conditions can be
enhanced. And considering the application, the HVOF is effectively used in the energy
generation sector like say in thermal power plants or in hydropower plants, like hydro-turbine
blades subjected to the slurry erosion, so if they are coated using suitable materials,
then they will be able to effectively reduce erosion.
Similarly, high temperature resistance is needed in case of thermal power plant. So,
erosion resistance at high temperature is important for thermal power plants. And for
that purpose, like thermal barrier coatings are used which will not only be reducing the
temperature of the main component, but will also be increasing erosion resistance. These
are also used, like in cement industry for resisting abrasion as well as erosion and
automotive industry and many other industries for enhanced wear resistance of the component.
In the next slide I will be showing the typical HVOF sprayed coatings of the Cobalt-Chromium-Carbon-Tungsten
system, and if we see this is the macroscopic image
of HVOF coatings of this material, this is the cobalt-based material which of these very
good abrasion resistance as well as erosion resistance. And we can see here this coating
thickness is about the 200 to 250 micrometre. And this is a coating is developed on the
surface of the mild steel to investigate what kind of the wear resistance.
If we see, hardly we have a very hardly there are major discontinuities, very fine pores
are there here and there and if we quantify these pores, these pores are very fine and
these are very less in terms of the percentage. And further closer look if you see, for microscopic
observation, then we can see there a lot of splats in the form of these are, we can see
these are the flattend particles which have been deposited over the surface of the substrates.
So, these microstructural features are completely different than what we normally observe in
case of the conventional crystalline material systems. And here, primarily we can see that
if there are discontinuities, so indicating soundness or what kind of the splats are being
formed and what kind of the bonding is there between them. These are the kind of the micro
structural features which we can observe and these features are completely different as
compared to that what we get in case of the conventional spray processes or conventional
material where the fusion followed by the solidification.
Now, we will see the second process this is called detonation spray process. This another
high velocity spray process wherein the velocity of the gas is too high like 3000 meter per
second, the temperature is 3000 degree centigrade. But since the velocity is very high and that
is why we notice that the stay of the particle at the high temperature is for a very limited
period and that is why exposure of the material being coated is for very less time.
And since the time is less at high temperature time of exposure at high temperature is less
and therefore the associated thermal damage to the material be coated is also less. That
is why despite of high temperature since the velocity is high, the exposure is for the
less period. And in this case only the, if the material is being sprayed by the detonation
spray, high velocity leading to the limited transfer of heat to the powder particle. So,
only the surface layer will be brought to the molten state, while core remains in the
solid state.
So, this is the situation of the partial melting. And in this case core is thermally softened,
which is favourable especially with regard to the development of the residual compressive
stresses. So, how does it work? In case of the detonation spray, we have to feed, say
this is another combustion-based process, we have to feed oxygen, we have to feed acetylene
and this mixture is burned or detonated by giving the spark through the spark plug in
very controlled way.
So, like say mixture is fed through this controlled like oxygen and acetylene is fed through these
control valves and then this mixture is detonated with the help of the spark plug. And as soon
as detonation takes place powder is fed in this barrel and so whenever this detonation
happens the high velocity gases will be moving towards the exit along with the powder particles.
And these powder particles during their travel through this barrel will be heated to this
partial melting or thermal softening conditions.
And once these come out, they will be directed towards the surface of the substrate, where
these are to be coated. And this distance is of like say 50 to 100 mm, so the barrel
to the substrate distance is about 50 to 100 mm. And after each like say, after each detonation
like for each detonation, we feed the oxygen and acetylene, spark plug will be detonating
and then powder is fed, the matter and all the material, the gases as well as powder
mixture will be directed towards the surface of the substrate.
And once this cycle is completed, the purging, net purging is performed of this gun barrels
with the help of nitrogen. So, all those burnt gases and the powder which has been fed can
be cleared from the gun and the next round of the detonation is carried out. So, this
process of the detonation is repeated a number of times. So, number of detonations in this
case may vary like say 1 to 10, number of the detonations per second and this will be
determining the rate at which the coating thickness will be increased.
Obviously greater is that number of detonations per second, higher will be the rate at which
the coating thickness will be increased. So, that is what has been explained in these points,
like the mixture is fed, spark plug will be detonating it, powder is fed and once the;
and then the things are accelerated towards the substrate and then particle is deposited
on to the surface of the substrate.
And then just to clean up the things, the nitrogen purging is performed, spark plug
performs detonation of the oxygen and fuel mixture, powder feeder is used to supply the
powder in very controlled way, the gas gun barrel so that we can deposit the material
at the required rate. The detonation can happen at a particular frequency of 1 to 10 and number
of detonation per second which in turn will be affecting the thickness, the rate at which
thickness being increased.
And, then since the velocity of the powder particles which is attained during the spray
process is very high and that is why since powder particles where just the surface has
been brought to the molten state and the core has been softened and when the impingement
of these particles happened at very high velocity, then it will be leading to the flattening,
with the very of firmness and with very soundness and it will be leading to the reduced pores
and a very increased coating substrate bond strength.
So, this is the good side associated with this process is that high powder particle
velocity of 800 to 1000 meter per second, leading to the very sound coating, substrate
bond strength, reduced porosity. And at the same time, since the coating material is getting
flattend in the solid state itself, that is why it will be under the plastic strain conditions.
So, when the material is flattened under the plastic strain conditions, it develops the
residual compressive stress.
So, whatever coating is developed through this process, if the coating at the surface
has the residual compressive stress. So, because of high velocity and limited heating or only
of the surface layer melting facilitates the reduced porosity, good bond strength and residual
compressive stresses. And this now, the typical result for the detonation sprayed material.
Here, these are the two micrographs which show that the Nickel-chromium material of
the powder particle size 40 micrometre is sprayed over the surface of the substrate
having spot diameter of the 25 mm and detonation spraying was carried out at the rate of 4
shots per second for developing the coating of the 300 micrometre, then we get the coating
structure of this kind. And here this is the low magnification structure of the coating,
which shows that coating is by large sound and free from the defects.
However, some of the limited bonding at the interface can be seen. But, this is primarily
because there is no fusion of the interface, fusion of the substrate and the coating only
the surface layer of the coating material powder is brought to the molten state. But,
if we see the closer look of the coating then, these splats can be clearly seen which is
been deposited over one over other and still some of the micro porous can also be seen
here and there.
Since in this process there is no complete fusion of the powder particles and primarily
high velocity only surface layer melting of the powder particles leading to the very sound
coatings with very good bond strength and that is why this process does not suffer any
kind of the thermal damage and thermal degradation, especially with regard to the formation of
the inclusion or formation of the undesirable metallurgical transformation. So, this is how we can say
this detonation spray process can effectively be used for depositing the variety of materials
without any thermal damage while developing the sound coatings which are with very limited
pores with very good coating substrate bond strength.
Now, I will summarise this presentation. In this presentation, basically I have talked
about the processes, one was the high velocity oxy-fuel spray process which leads to the
higher temperature as well as the high velocity. In case of detonation spray process also the
velocity is very high and the temperature rise of the coating material is very limited.
Thank for your attention.
