To access the translated content: 1. The translated content of this course is available in regional languages. For details please visit https://nptel.ac.in/translation The video course content can be accessed in the form of regional language text transcripts, books which can be accessed under downloads of each course, subtitles in the video and Video Text Track below the video. Your feedback is highly appreciated. Kindly fill this form https://forms.gle/XFZhSnHsCLML2LXA6 2. Regional language subtitles available for this course To watch the subtitles in regional languages: 1. Click on the lecture under Course Details. 2. Play the video. 3. Now click on the Settings icon and a list of features will display 4. From that select the option Subtitles/CC. 5. Now select the Language from the available languages to read the subtitle in the regional language.
Dr. Vajpayee, I wanted to ask you something very specific, which I think many people would
have doubt about, we know of clinical psychologist, we right now also talked about it and we also
have psychiatrists, so besides their training that they undergo, in terms of practice, how
do you differentiate between the two? See, psychiatry also evolved almost at the same
time as modern psychology evolved, maybe but a terminology came much before that, I think
it was real, R E I L, who called the thing psychiatry, because the whole thing comes
from the Greek word, even psychology comes from there, which was psyche, which was soul,
mind was nowhere, because even the understanding of mind was understanding of soul, so psychiatry
evolved almost hand to hand with psychology of last 100 years, so when especially the
most prominent names were Breuer and Freud, who was actually trained as a neurologist
and they started treating hysteria with psychological mechanisms. Psychoanalysis was trying to
probe deep into the mind, that is when unconscious came in and catharsis and dream work and all
that stuff, which we know about psychoanalysis, so they were, although Freud saw very few
patients, so Freud was treating them, believing on his model of unconscious and conscious
and they were trying to treat people, who mind and brain was not understood, as it is
not understood fully even today, but Freud even at that time had a project on neurology,
on neurons, so he was trying to find out the mechanisms of this conscious and unconscious
based on the neuronal structure of brain, so he had that vision, which is coming true now,
because there is a resurgence of Freud now, but what happened after Freud, some people rejected
Freud and what came was a behaviour therapy, Pavlov, Skinner, that nothing comes from within,
you are acting to external stimulus, behavioural, so this was all part of psychology remember,
but it was used to treat phobias and anxieties, right and even at that time,
Kraepelin and all these people, they were the first group of people, who brought psychiatry
to focus and they were diagnosing illnesses like schizophrenia, dementia,
precox and all that. In fact, Albert Einstein's one son had schizophrenia and he was hospitalised
in Switzerland, but those days schizophrenia was called dementia precox, it always had a
downward course and it would lead to total cognitive disability and all.
So, psychiatry always was trying to treat people who were mentally ill, but it was easier said
than done because people were, so what do you think is mental illness, when you talk about
normalcy, we will talk about it, but people who are deviant suppose, so lot of time the
confusion was that whether they are criminals or they are mentally ill because culturally also,
in lot of tribes and all, they were abnormal behaviour episodes or with people who take
drugs and cannabis and opioids, so all these things were always there. In fact,
Ayurveda probably had a branch which was called Bhooth Vidya, so even they recognised the abnormal
behaviour, so like psychology which was philosophy, so all the psychiatry and psychology were stemming
from the same thing, so psychiatry took upon treating abnormal behaviour, so the major thrust,
so when all this treatment mechanisms were being used by psychology, psychiatry was already existing,
but the boundaries were pretty blurred. You see that say, there was a predominance
of usage of drugs in the stream of psychiatry. So, when the whole thing changed with the advent
of drugs, which was not very far, it is just 70 years back and the drugs were discovered
serendipitously, they were being used for something else and something happened,
like reserpine antihypertensive used to cause depression, ECT, one of the very popular shock
thing was accidental thing, right. So, when drugs came in, then the difference
between psychology and psychiatry became sharp. But still people say for instance,
right now you were also mentioning cognitive behaviour therapy for instance, rational
emotive therapy for instance, whether you are a psychologist, you are a psychiatrist,
if you are in practice, you use these techniques. So, what I am going to tell as you said in your
previous introduction that most people will not like, psychiatry is basically with a medical
background, but a good psychiatrist has to train himself in psychology, he has to train himself in
neurology, in medicine, in neuroscience, in everything, because for him to differentiate
that what has to be treated with medicines and what has to be treated with psychological
mechanisms is very important, what is neurological, what is medical.
So, I would say a psychiatrist actually should know more neurology than the neurologist,
he should know more medicine than the physician and more psychology than the psychologist. So,
both things came hand to hand, so the medical part of writing medication and all comes with
psychiatry and as psychiatry studied illness after illness after illness, then they devised
what we used to call or we still use called classificatory system. International classification
of disease, which is in its 11th edition and US had diagnostic and statistical manual. So,
this was a categorical diagnostic system, there were categories like mood disorder,
schizophrenia, psychosis, this DSM diagnostic and statistical manual is a dimensional thing,
it has axis 1, axis 2, axis 1 has a categorical diagnosis, axis 2 is developmental thing,
axis 3 is medical, then the global assessment of functioning and family situation.
These came in very early, why was it important? It was important because see,
there is a very subtle difference between psychiatry and psychology. When you say
intelligence suppose in psychology and if you just say intelligence to somebody sitting in
US, it may mean anything, unless you are using a formula of quantifying it. Psychiatry arising
from medical branch, the communication has to be the same, like when you say diabetes,
diabetes should mean diabetes across the world. That is why, otherwise how will people treat it?
So, because the onus of treatment of abnormal behaviour came primarily to psychiatry after
Freud and behaviourism, that is why classificatory system had to come in and that is where arose the
need of, because we still do not know the causes of many psychiatric illnesses, rather most of them,
but in 40-50 years, we have devised very effective drug treatments.
Also, say like over a period of time, differential diagnosis has increased. So,
people have become far more, I should say, they are far more now equipped to even draw a thread
between say disorder 1 versus disorder 2. So, if you look at initial 30-40 years,
the diagnosis is a very gross diagnosis and actually I can tell you briefly, it was very
simple. There is an organic, organic means everything is organic, it is in the brain,
but real organic meant that you can have a cause for some abnormal behaviour. You can have a fever,
you can have a seizure, you can have trauma, you can have a brain tumour, which diagnosis
became better with CT scans and MRIs and PET scans and all. Then, if it was not organic,
it was used to be called functional. Within the functional itself, it could be,
it could be psychotic, where schizophrenia and bipolar and I am telling you the simplest
classification in one line, but it still stands at this level only. It is functional, it is psychotic,
mood disorder, schizophrenia, it is non-psychotic, it can be anxiety, it can be mood, again depression
or something and third group was personality disorder, which we diagnosed much later.
So, broadly psychiatry was functioning within this. As people observed when large-scale
epidemiological study happened, then we, it was not known whether schizophrenia is happening only
in US or in Africa or India. It is the work of all those people who went to community and studied.
Now that we know, it was discovered that illnesses are universal.
You see, that is around 50s when the mental health movement took impetus at various places
around the world, especially in Europe. It was then when much more knowledge about
abrasions in the behaviour started coming and especially the aftermath of Second World War,
when extreme cases of symptoms would appear, which psychology or psychiatry had never
encountered in the past. So, it was a, see initially it was jail. Even before jail,
there were lot of persecution of these people used to happen, witch hunting, then jail.
Then jail, somebody people realized that jail is not the place for these people. They are
different. They do not have a, they have a problem. So, they were sent to mental hospitals.
What they used to call it as lunatic asylum. Then this social movement said that they are
not lunatic, they are mentally ill. But this understanding has come really later,
in the 30, 40, 50 years maximum, although Niemann's, the premier institute opened in 50s.
So, Europeans had realized that. Then the movement was to close down this lunatic
asylums and rehabilitate people into the society because they are ill. They are not
devious or they are not. So, along, so these social changes were already happening with
the changes in drug treatment. So, drugs, then this whole emphasis on medication.
Because what we found, that even if we did not know the cause, we knew how to treat it. And that
is the crux right now. They are very, very effective medicines. To the tune that some
illnesses have changed their course, which were almost very, very malignant type of illnesses,
which would take the person down in like schizophrenia. The prognosis for schizophrenia
has improved tremendously. People take medicines, the good medicines, less side effects. But all
this has come by huge cost of experimentation, of giving medication, which caused lot of side
effects to people. They created other mental illness. So, this trial and error and trial and
error. But this trial and error was not blind. That is what is very important. The categories
of illnesses, when we discovered that there is a 1% risk of schizophrenia all across the world,
everywhere. If one sibling has, then the risk goes up. If 2 siblings have, the risk goes up.
When 2 parents have, the risk goes up. So, all of us have the same genetic makeup. So,
these illnesses probably have come in our genes from evolution, right.
I want to take you back. Right now, while talking about psychology, psychiatry,
you did mention that there were, there was an attempt, which to a greater extent has
been successful in few countries. Especially in India, it has not been so successful. When
you make a mix of the mental health professionals, so, psychiatrist and psychologists are only 2
elements. We have the psychiatric social workers and we have the psychiatric nursing practitioners.
So, they also have an important role to play. And especially the psychiatric social workers,
who would be more instrumental in assisting, in assessment of the disorders. And as well as they
would be instrumental in extending the therapeutic intervention that is programmed. And they would
ensure largely, how good a person is finally rehabilitated in the society, absolutely.
So, this is a, I was about to tell you this. This was very interesting in 70s and 80s,
I think when they were studying the prognosis and long term factors and all. Actually,
the prognosis of acute psychosis, like acute psychosis is one diagnosis, which came from
third world. India was also in third world at that time. Sudden onset of psychosis,
which would resolve in few days. So, the criteria for schizophrenia was 6 months initially. Now,
it is 1 month. So, what resolves within few days is acute psychosis. Now, somehow all this power
dynamics goes in and people keep changing labels and all. But acute psychosis was a reality,
we see it in practice. The prognosis of schizophrenia was better in third world
countries. Why? Because even India was different at that time, if you remember, in 70s and 80s.
They were joint families, they were large family support system. Now, it will be interesting to
see after 20 years with the India, modern India emerging as other countries, where families have
largely broken off. What will be the prognosis of these people? But at that time, it used to be
good. Now, it may be good because of medication. If you keep taking medicine, but what are the
support systems? Therein comes the psychiatric social worker. Because they are the people who
can go and teach and really encourage people to bring out their resources to handle the patient.
They would also have played and they must be till today also, they are playing important role even
in terms of knowledge dissemination. Because what we consider as a particular disorder,
in a little what you call sugar coated format, they would be conveying this information. So,
the scientific information translated into kind of an information which will be easy to grasp by
the non-technical population. See, again as in psychology, you said it becomes social psychology
this and that. So, there is a lot of blurring of boundaries. But mental health, as far as we
talk of mental health, whether we talk of illness or prevention or prevention of illness or mental
health enhancement, it is a very composite multidisciplinary effort. So, one of the
perfect models which works is, I have been lucky to get trained in Nimman's Bangalore.
So, adult psychiatry unit has a psychiatrist and psychologist and psychiatric social work
and psychiatry nursing. So, whenever a patient person is discussed there, it is not just the
medical treatment or just the psychological aspect, it is a composite whole which is being
discussed. And then roles are allocated. Unlike medicine where the doctor can just prescribe. So,
it will be very unfortunate if psychiatry becomes like that. Because in psychiatry,
just giving medicine is never going to work. I would just like to highlight this thing.
As a student, when I saw the practice of psychiatry, as you said right now that if
you convert psychiatry also just into practice of medicine. My old experience is large number
of people would practice as if they are in search of certain keywords, features or symptoms,
whatever word you want to use. And based on those couple of symptoms, they would prescribe a
medicine which would be for say 30 days time period. And then say that again you revisit the
cleaning after these many days. Without going into the details of the issues that you are referring
to right now. That is because, I mean, I should confess it, we should not hide that the training
is very, very disparate. At least you have not been able to devise one curriculum. The other
is because as I said, we do not know the causes of illness. So, like a medical classification
of diseases is based on cause. For example, if you have, what should I say, a fever for example,
right. Or if you say you have a swelling in hand. Now, how would doctor look at swelling? He would
look at, is it because of infection? Is it because of a trauma? Is it because of some
endocrine disturbance? Is it because of something else? So, these are causes. And then he would
investigate those causes and treat them. Psychiatry is different. If a person is having
hallucinations, delusions, lack of insight, poor personal hygiene for one month, he will become
schizophrenic. Where is the cause? So, or vis-a-vis if a person is having depression,
if a person is having sadness of mood, loss of appetite, crying spells, you immediately try to,
whether this category or that category. The problem which you just mentioned in passing
was that final boundary is illnesses have also started changing their role, the pattern.
No, these days we rarely see pure schizophrenia, pure depression, it is all mixed up now.
A schizophrenia can have depression, depressive, some person can have psychotic symptom,
you understand, like OCD. So, what I am saying, so for most psychiatrists, what is important is
they are under tremendous pressure to treat, because they are seeing so much misery. And so,
the shortest and the easiest course is to clarify in the head, what is the nearest diagnostic
category which this person fits in. Because the moment you say it, then it becomes easy
for the doctor to decide whether you want to give an antipsychotic or whether you want to give in a.
One reason perhaps could also be that we have a skewed distribution of patient-doctor population.
That is also. So, you have very less number of psychiatrists versus the number of psychiatric
patients. But it is more actually, it is still deeper. And you would understand as a psychologist,
that when you are asking about the symptoms, what are the tools a psychiatrist has,
like for psychology, the tools are psychometric tests, for most of them.
Or forming, or talking to a person, you formulate your framework, which framework,
you are going to use a psychoanalytic frame or you are going to use a behavioral,
depends on your orientation. Psychiatrist, in spite of knowing all this psychology and this
and that, his tool is, see what is the crux of psychiatry, the crux of psychiatry is the
diagnostic process. For diagnostic process, we do not have, although we have lot of MRIs,
this, that, but believe me, there would be hardly 2 or 3 percent of psychiatric diagnosis,
which are made on any tests. So, when people come and say, doctor, you have not got any test done,
how can you know it is depression, you say we do not have a test. Someday we may have. So,
we are almost on a hunt for last 40 years, for biomedical markers, EEG markers, MRI markers,
there is a hell lot of physics and mathematics, which is working these days, to find out,
but till now we have not been, we cannot say actually, that you get this test done and we
will know. But interestingly, now, let me bring in psychology and the assessment tools that
psychologists use. Yeah, I will just complete. So, what I was saying, then it will be easy for
you to connect. So, the tool still remains what we call psychopathology. Now, the psychopathology
business came from existential philosophy and all that. Phenomenology, phenomenology means,
if what is the experience you are having in your head, cause comes different. So,
somebody comes and said that I am sad and I want to die, that is a phenomena,
it is depressed effect, you have to treat that. Somebody says that I get fearful. So,
that is a phenomena. Why is part two of the story? Somebody says that I hear voices talking to me,
right, which say that I, you are guilty. That, and if there is no voice source,
that is a hallucination, that is a phenomena. Why he is feeling guilty may be something else,
you understand. So, a psychiatrist in that short time or longer time has to differentiate between
the phenomena, because based on this phenomena, he will put him into diagnostic categories.
But there is life beyond diagnostic categories, because patients do not read the book before
coming. So, they will have schizophrenia with depression, this and that. So, it is up to the
psychiatrist to diagnose and then because once you decide the category, it becomes easier for
you to treat. So, the problem is with most psychiatrist is that they are, after all they
are from medical setup. So, they have to behave like a doctor. What does a doctor do? Treat.
So, once you decide phenomena, diagnosis, then you treat. Then if out of interest,
out of your own understanding, you want to go deeper, like Lord Krishna said,
why you get up and fight? That was the treatment. But he said, no, no, let us go there. So,
then you can look into why it is happening. But these are people who go deeper are the people
who are more psychologically oriented. So, the question that I was trying to put
forth you was that, say there are a lot many tools used by psychologists to quantify the
level of depression, for instance. Yes.
Beck's depression inventory, for instance, very popularly used across nations. How effective
these tools can be or are in practice for psychiatrists? See, most psychiatry clinics,
at least in countries like India and are very, very crowded. And they are very high pressure
jobs. Because the life is there and you are treating liver, you can still be detached.
But somebody is crying, you cannot be. So, in clinical practice, for treatment and all,
I do not think many people use it. They are used where research is involved. Diagnostic
confusion happens when there is an unclear diagnosis. Like older tests, you would remember
thematic perception, Rorschach, all those projective tests were devised to, they were
based on psychoanalysis only to bring out the unconscious of the person. So, they were used
more frequently actually. Now, depression inventory is Hamilton depression are more
of a quantification of, they are not very diagnostic. Some people use it, but ultimately
they do not. So, see, let us be very clear. If a psychiatrist cannot make a clinical diagnosis
sitting front to front, nothing else will happen. You may get confused, but you still
should have a differential diagnosis in your head. It is very rare that we get somebody
who we are not able to diagnose. It happens at institute level everywhere. Then we go and bank
on end of psychological psychometry. And also perhaps could there be a reason that the state,
the mental state of the patient or the person who suffers from a given state is not conducive
to participate in any of the psychometric tests. Absolutely no. If psychosis, obviously not. A lot
of illnesses where the person is not in the state. But even in depression, a depressed person will
not be willing to participate in a psychological assessment. Scales can help in quantification.
But for academic purposes, for research purposes. Or measuring the prognosis. But I do not,
if you ask me, I, my friends may become angry with me, but let me tell you, it is not of much
use in clinical work. Because if you and me give a seriously Hamilton depression scale,
90% people in this country would be diagnosed depression. So we will take up this issue now,
because we have, we will be touching upon the social and cultural side of psychiatry and
psychology later on. Yes. So we should understand this and probably this should be our point where
we have to bring into the common life. Because what we call as depression has definite criterias
clinically. What people use the term as I am depressed is something else. Something else.
So when somebody says I am depressed, I am anxious, I think we should not take it at the
face value. We should clarify what does that person mean by depressed. Because again,
as in psychology, there are lot of pop psychology which has come up. These terminologies have become
so commonplace that even a kid knows. Perhaps, perhaps see now with the exposure that you get
through different kind of media. Yes. You are aware of the words without knowing the layers
of it. Right. And especially the technical side of it. So depression just means sadness. No,
it does not. Because, so and then they will come for treatment. So lot of people who go
to physicians and to neurologists and all, they go and get treated and in India everybody can
write anti-depressant. But once you start, what you do not know when to stop it. Because over
years we have honed the skills and refined mechanisms by which we know how long one
medicine has to be continued. And this is what you should observe also. That is the difference
between good treatment and bad treatment. A doctor knows what he is writing, rational
pharmacology, how long when to stop. Just going and getting depression treated, it actually does
not work. So maybe I think now that we have tried to say see the commonality and the difference in
the approach that psychologist and psychiatrist will adopt. We will talk about. Let us take some
real-life example in the coming sessions, where we would be trying to decipher human behavior
from more, with more specific details rather I should say. Yes. But then still the details
would be non-technical as far as possible. So real-life example, trying to understand
it from a common person's perspective. And definitely I should thank Dr. Vajpayee for
this line of distinction between what psychologist would try to look at and what psychiatrist would
try to look at. And in the coming sessions, both of us would try to take real-life examples and
try to see it from both the perspectives. Absolutely.
Okay, trying to make it as far as non-technical, but still easy to understand kind of a thing.
Thanks.