Lecture 02 -Terminologies in Simulation

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
2 Video Views·Dec 3, 2023
system; assumption; model; simulation, system complexity, application of simulation, popularity of simulation, advantage of simulation, disadvantage of simulation.
Very good morning again people and welcome to the next lecture, second installment of
the simulation of business systems course on NPTEL MOOCs.
And in the previous lecture what we have gone through our learning agenda, the main topics
was listed and of which we covered the nature of the simulation and the brief history of
simulation and we will look into new concepts today, mostly we will try to the focus ourselves
on this three, what is systems, models and the simulation, then application and the real
world applications and why simulation is needed, we will try to address these three aspects
in the today's class okay.
Probably will be little long because we are covering quite a lot of concepts in this,
so we will try to break it appropriately, so that you would not have any problem in
you know going through the concepts.
So the first thing that we are going to look into is the concept of system assumptions
and model okay, this is a people use these words in a very you know colloquial way in
most of the time but in simulation they do have very specific meaning.
So these following simplistic views okay the simplistic views that I am going to provide
to you are relevant to all simulation studies, it does not matter whether you are doing computation
fluid dynamics or anywhere but these approaches, these viewpoints that we are going to study
now has its applications relevant to all simulation studies.
So the first phrase that we need to know is system okay, people talk about system, system,
system, system, so what is a system?
In the simulation, it is not the systems engineering system, in the simulation what is being done
or what is being simulated is the system okay.
So the system is the stuff that is being simulated, whatever is being simulated or in a way the
object of the simulation study, object of what?
The object of interest okay, whatever you are interested in studying that or what is
being simulated that becomes the system okay, that part I believe it is clear.
Then we talk about assumptions and approximations, we say oh while building the model we have
to take so many assumptions, so many approximations, this assumptions determine this, that assumptions
determine this, those kind of things.
So what are they okay, so assumptions and approximations are to be made to study a system,
to study a system of interest okay, to study a system of interest you have to make assumptions
or approximations okay, these assumptions or approximations can be both logical and
mathematical okay.
So some of the aspects can be logical, some of them can be mathematical right and why
are these assumptions is to be made okay, they are to be made to know more about how
the system work, how the system works okay.
So an example of this is that if you are thinking about people standing in a line, so let us
say here is a shop, this is a ice cream shop okay and people are standing in line here
to buy ice creams or get into ice creams like this and by one by one they will buy
ice creams and they will get out.
So one of the assumption that you can make, a logical assumption that can be make is that
the lowest possible number, lowest possible number of people is equal to 0, you cannot
have negative people there.
So that is a logical assumption okay because it is and you can always say that the number,
the values, the number of people who are waiting to get the ice cream is always an integer
value, you cannot have 2.5 people, you can have an average but realistically if you think
about it, it will be the 2 people, 3 people, 4 people, 10 people, 200 people waiting in
the queue depending upon how popular the ice cream area is okay.
And then you can also write the same thing about the average waiting time to get the
ice cream is 4 and a half minutes and that you can write as a mathematical expression
which will become a mathematical assumption okay.
So these type of assumptions and approximations that we take to understand or study the system
better okay, so that is the main aim of taking the assumptions and approximations.
So then what is a model, all such assumptions or approximations we take to study a system
forms model of the system, hope now you understand what is a model.
These assumptions or approximations that we take to understand the system better results
in the model of the system.
So your object of interest or object of interest of study is your system or whatever is being
studied is a system and you take assumptions and approximations to better understand how
the system works.
And these assumptions and approximations that way translates to what we call as the model
of the system.
So then many a time people talk about analytical solution, people say is that equation of a
straight line.
For example is equation of a straight line is given by y equal to mx plus b where m is
the slope and b is the intercept but this is a model okay.
But when you say y equal to 2x plus 10 then that is the equation of a particular line
okay which is 10 units intercept and then the slope is 2 that means the slope is the
rate of change of y over rate of change of x delta y by delta x.
So then that means for every 2 units of rise in y you can see that how it works out right.
So I am not going to explain that but this becomes a model and this is a particular you
know line that represents that derived from that model.
But here there are certain assumptions that we assume that both x and y are in the Cartesian
coordination coordinate system and they are also like you know no imaginary values they
are all real numbers and those kind of things we assume as part of this.
So that is how this equation of line was derived ideally speaking okay.
So in an analytical solution when people talk about what is an analytical solution if the
model is quite simple then one can use mathematical methods to obtain exact information.
Exact information on the questions of interest so if you use mathematical methods or mathematical
approaches to obtain exact information on those questions that you have of interest
then that type of an approach is called as analytical solution.
So modeling a system using a mathematical equation modeling a system using a mathematical
approach or using a mathematical method to obtain the exact information to the questions
for a simple system the important aspect is system is simple then you will result in analytical
solving or analytical solution okay.
So now you know what is a system assumptions and approach model and what we also call as
an analytical solution.
So when do we not do analytical solution obviously the answer is when the system is very complex
is too hard to use mathematical methods to come up with the solution to the problem okay.
So let us study little bit more on the systems and models and simulation.
So let us see what are the other definitions that are part of this.
So the system the Schmitt and Taylor definition which is very popular among many of the people
okay then definition states go something like this a collection of entities okay what are
those entities?
Entities can be parts, people, machines, methods, money like this okay a collection
of entities that act together towards achieving some common goal that is what we call as a
the definition of Schmitt and Taylor's definition it is a collection of entities that act together
towards achieving some common goal.
Such kind of a collection is that collection of entities is what you call as a system okay.
So in practice the objectives of the study determines the system for example you might
be in a automotive factory automotive manufacturing facility and then you are more interested
in the time taken for completing a work at each workstation then you might be more interested
in studying the conveyor aspects of the system rather than looking into the other aspects.
So realistically the objectives of the study whatever you are wanting to study that determines
the system.
So you would actually be in a big factory and you would just probably focusing on the
overhead cranes you will be looking only at the material transportation system at that
point okay.
Another aspect is in practice also it might also limit the physical and logical boundaries
of the system.
So your study objectives might also limit the physical and logical boundaries of the
system.
So we are more interested in how long it takes the crane to move overhead in the factory
from one end to another then your study objective limits only the focus to the overhead crane.
It does not cares about what happens what is the electric supply how much is the illumination
in the factory what is the rate at which the water is flowing through the taps how much
of material is being removed you do not study those aspects because that is outside the
habit of your objective of the study.
The level of detail as part of the study is a judgment call is a judgment call made by
the researcher or analyst.
So how much detail you want to study okay how much detail you want to go into this study
is a judgment call the modeler or the researcher decides how much of details you want to be
included.
So we are studying about that rate the time taken for the crane to move from one end to
another carrying different weights you are not interested in what kind of color it is
being painted what is the color of the crane you might not be interested you might not
be interested whether the crane the driver cabin the operator cabin is air conditioned
or not.
You might not be interested too much on what is the power horsepower of the motor that
is driving the wheels of that crane you might not be interested in any of those.
So hence the level of detail that is part of the study is the judgment call depending
upon your objectives of the study.
Your study objectives determine how much detail you also need to go into and that way it also
determines the physical and logical boundaries of the system okay and the last part is okay
most of the studies would like to model time.
So in a system typical definition of the system the definition of the system the time is kind
of left out.
So the way is dynamic behavior of the system of the system or what we call as the time
dependent behavior okay how does the system behaves over time that is one important aspect
that is that many of the modelers would like to do.
And in study of the system when there is a collection of entities that act together and
all but in realistically the objectives of the study limits the system and as well as
the physical and logical boundaries of the system are also determined by the objectives
of the study and the research and analyst depending upon the objectives limits the level
of detail to an appropriate level.
So that unwanted things are removed out that is why you make the assumptions to remove
unwanted things and also one other aspect is an aspect of time the time dependent behavior
the dynamic behavior of the system also need to be added into the study because many of
the researchers would like to know how the system would behave okay.
Then we talk about another thing is called as a system state okay.
So what is the system state?
So by definition okay system state is a collection of variables along with their values that
is necessary to describe the state of the system at a particular time instant at a particular
time given time instant you would like to know the state of the system okay.
So it is a collection of variables a particular variables along with their values that is
necessary to describe the state of the system at a particular instant.
So if you think about the ice cream example that we talked earlier if I say that number
of people waiting okay number of people waiting is equal to 5 okay number of people served
or being served being served equals 1 okay and average time to serve ice cream is 3 minutes.
If I say something like this these variables put together okay and if I say this happened
at this is what is the status at t is equal to 20 minutes.
So after 20 minutes this is the state of the system then so this state of the system that
we just described now gives us a snapshot of the system how the system is at a particular
time which is at the 20th minute of the system.
So this kind of the system state it always depends upon depends upon desired objectives
of the simulation study and also the system output performance measures okay.
So at this point what is the desired objective of the simulation study let us say if the
desired objective in this particular case is find out that how many people were served
then you do not get an answer here.
So if I add is the number of people completed number of people who left with ice cream is
9 if I say that so then that means at the time t equal to 20 minutes 9 people have already
bought the ice cream 1 is being served 5 are waiting in the queue and average time of service
is 3 minutes okay whether this numbers are right it makes sense or so that we will talk
about it later but approximately this is what the idea is about okay.
So this aspect that we just started here this is more of a performance measure system performance
measures how many people you have already sold ice cream because if you do not sell
your ice cream then you would not really get money if you do not get money then your system
would not work.
So this is more of an output parameter and whereas this is more about the system state
parameter okay and this is more of a output or a performance measure.
I hope you guys understand this much concept in a way and what we will do is we will continue
now to extend these concepts but be sure that you guys when somebody says what is a system
when somebody says what is a system state when somebody says what is a model when somebody
says what is an assumption when somebody says what is an analytical solution you should
be able to be very clear in your mind about the concepts that we just discussed now.
So that you can understand what that person is talking about okay this language of simulation
is new to you and hence it is very important that you guys understand this language.
So we have been seeing the basic definitions of system, system state, assumptions and other
aspects and we also talked about why it is important to understand the state values of
the state variables to describe a system.
So now let us get into the next concept which is as related to this is called as a complexity
or system complexity okay some people also call this as the complexity of the system
we call this as system complexity.
So the general rule of thumb is this complex systems require models that are also complex.
So complex system models are usually complex why the most important question is why this
answer to this is because such models have to be valid.
So to ensure the validity of the model you have to build complex models in this regard.
So hence complex systems will require complex models so then simple therefore simple analytical
approach approaches fail you cannot use those simple analytical approaches.
So hence you have to study these things using simulation okay.
So what you do what do you do then answer is evaluate model numerically the most important
word is this numerically, numerical evaluation not analytically numerically and collect data
to estimate model characteristics.
So what we are talking here is instead of the analytical approach so this is the instead
of analytical approach okay instead of analytical approach what you do is you model numerically
you study the model numerically evaluate it numerically then you collect data and then
from that you estimate the characteristics of the model okay.
So a simple example of that is if you think about the ice cream so let us think about
you have a data collection where is called at the customer ID like this and then time
in and time out let us say you have collect data like that.
So customer ID 1, 2, 3, 4 like this the customer ID is going on and the first person comes
in at 00 and leaves at 1.20 the other person comes in at 2.30 and leaves at 3.45 and this
person comes at 3 and leaves at 5.15 and this person comes at 7 and leaves at 10 or something
like this.
So when you numerically study this so this is where you are simulated the arrival of
people into the ice cream shop individual people come into the system so the first person
came in when the ice cream shop opened and stayed in the shop for 1 minute 30 seconds.
So the time spent you can calculate here will be 1 minute 20 seconds.
This person came in at what 2.30 and left at 3.45 so this person spent close to 1 minute
15 seconds on this place this person spent 2 minute 15 seconds this person spent 3 minutes
on the shop something like this.
So then using this you can find the average of this if you sum this and divide by 4 then
you will be able to get what is the average time spent in the shop and stuff like this.
So this type of an analysis is what we call as a numerical analysis okay instead of a
mathematical model.
So let us think about a simple example an automotive manufacturing company okay a car
manufacturing company is considering to extend its plant okay.
So the one option is build the factory build the extension to the plant and evaluate whether
it will work out okay this is one approach.
But let us say you build the factory you build it and then you evaluate whether it works
out if it does not work out demolish and build something else and this process continues.
So what is the major issue with this approach?
The problem is it is very expensive approach and quite wasteful you keep on building and
destroying that is what you are trying to do in this case.
So instead the other option better option what is the better option is to simulate the
current system and then expand the model use the new model evaluate performance and then
choose accordingly okay.
So the simulation approach would be simulate the current system so build a this is build
a model okay of the current system and then expand the model to include whatever is the
extension of the plant.
So this expansion and this extension mirrors one another and then use this model to evaluate
the performance and decide whether you should do this extension or not okay.
So this is one other approach of how do you deal with the complex systems.
So simulation so in other way to do it is simulation provides better ways to handle
complexity okay.
So you can study complexity in a better way using simulation you can model complex systems
using simulation better alright.
So now let us look into the next concept which is the applications of simulation okay.
And what we are going to do is we are also going to look at the I will just add the phasor
here saying that major applications of simulations.
We are only going to study some major applications not all applications do not think that these
are the only areas to which the simulation is applicable.
These are some of the majority of the areas.
So the first one is the manufacturing systems.
In manufacturing systems the main aspects where simulation is involved is design of
manufacturing systems, analysis of manufacturing systems like analyzing the tag time or what
you call a cycle time, the throughput rate, work in process inventory etc.
Then inventory how much of stock is there okay, automation that is another aspect you
study, layout, material handling etc.
So these aspects of manufacturing systems the design, the analysis, inventory, automation,
layout, material handling etc. are all studied as part of the simulation.
Similarly in military simulation also finds a lot of application as I mentioned to you
guys simulation actually came from military only Monte Carlo simulation.
So in this case what we are studying is weapon systems then logistics okay military logistics
this includes troop movements etc.
Then tactics, tactics is you know short term, long term then what we call as bomb damage
assessment okay it is popularly known as BDA bomb damage assessment.
Then training providing training to the troops these are all aspects that you can use simulation
to.
So the training a very important thing is you can you might have studied something called
as flight simulators and all flight simulators etc. okay it teaches a pilot how to fly a
new aircraft.
So because if you give them a new aircraft to fly and then they crash it then the cost
will be very extensive or extraordinary.
So instead you make a simulation model of it and train the pilot to fly the simulation
model so that when the pilot actually gets into the real aircraft then the chances of
error are very minimal okay.
Similarly in computer systems we can talk about modeling of hardware components okay
what would be an optimal hardware components okay hardware components.
Then software systems when you design a particular software system how will it actually behave
what is the speed of it then modeling and analysis of networks okay the traffic, congestion
that aspects of it, database management systems or what popularly known as DBMS okay etc.
alright these are all aspects of computer systems.
Then designing an operation of transportation systems this includes airports then also you
highways or freeways then shipping ports okay it also includes subways or what is popularly
known as popularly known as metros and so on etc.
So like for example in an airport you want to study like for example in a big airport
like in Delhi you simulation is heavily used to determine which gate should be assigned
to which aircraft and you can see sometimes the aircraft will get delayed then the entire
gate assignment will go for a toss and immediately simulation can provide you a alternate solution
quickly so that you can minimize the taxiing time of the aircraft from the runway to the
gate and also as well as the travel time from the gate to the runway so that quick take
off and quick landing and quick movement of the aircraft the time to which an aircraft
that remains in an airport can be minimized because the job of the aircraft is to fly
not to stay in an airport.
So that can be taken care of by so that is a performance measure that can be built in
and you can use simulation to study the to make the operations of the airport better.
Similarly evaluating the design for service of organizations like hospitals okay deciding
where to put the operation theatres and stuff like that call centres okay how many people
are necessary for call centres you know how to do things like that then you can study
about fast food restaurants McDonalds is an example where they depend heavily on simulation
to study how many counters are to be opened etc like that post office okay then border
control etc control on another common time of this is called customs etc okay alright.
So these are the aspects of how do we do service organizations then business process reengineering
this is like a looking into individual business processes business processes and then suggest
improvements or reengineer.
So these studies when you come when you model these business processes can be complex business
processes can be easily modelled with the help of simulation and then study the possible
improvements and you can quantify those improvements before actually implementing the changes to
the actual process okay.
Similarly the last part is the analyzing the financial this is not the last part some of
the major applications in which financial and economical systems.
So you can study stock market using simulation is very popular tools available now then commodities
is includes gold, iron, silver, petrol those kind of things various pricing policies then
also you can think about studying is the you know public distribution systems okay which
we call popularly in India's ration shops okay the PDS those kind of systems can be
very well studied and improved with the help of simulation which will so by doing that
you will be able to come up with a better approach or better performance measure that
would satisfy the objective of the system okay alright.
So now let us talk about the popularity of the simulation okay how much how popular so
the question we are going to ask is how popular is simulation, is simulation now?
So the answer to this question is simulation is one of the the answer is very simple it
is one of the most widely used techniques in operations research and management science.
So in the OR field this is one of the most widely used technique the main reason is it
is no longer a last resort contrary to the earlier belief that people heard that when
everything fails approach simulation now it is no longer a last resort it is actually
it is in fact the only resort in complex system studies, complex system studies.
Now also just to give you some statistics simulation consistently ranks in the top 3
most important techniques, techniques in business.
So you can see that it is one among the top 3 most important techniques almost all the
time because people have been dependent on it quite heavily for doing better things.
So what does simulation allows us to do why is this technique so popular because simulation
allows us to model, model means it allows us to model complex systems in a very detailed
way okay it allows us to model the complex system in a very detailed way.
It also allows us to describe the system okay describe what describe the behavior okay
including time dependent behavior, time dependent behavior okay describe the behavior of the
system that is one other aspect.
Then is the construct okay it allows us to construct, construct what construct hypothesis
or theories okay hypothesis okay about observed behavior of the system.
So it allows us to frame intuitions why is it like this okay why is it actually do why
is the system doing this.
It allows us to come up with an explanation on the exhibited behavior of the system.
It also allows us to use allows us to use what use the system model systems model to
predict future behavior of the system allows us to predict the future behavior of the system
which implies okay the effects that will be produced by implementing changes in the
system.
So if you build up for example if you have build a model of a car manufacturer and you
say okay fine as of now I am using the factory and I am producing 200 cars in a day.
What would happen if I increase the car production to 250 cars a day?
Well you can say that oh well that is okay it will you will just start to come up with
additional raw materials and some more money and some more capabilities might not be true
you might when you do the simulation you will find out that oh well the current fire suppression
system that is created, safety system that is created is not sufficient or not capable
of handling any issues that happen due to the production of 250 cars.
So it is not just straight forward we will have to now come up with a new mechanism and
a classic example of this is the Brandenburg airport in the Berlin where you can know that
the fire when the airport is now being built and when it is completed they are in a situation
where the fire suppression system is found completely inadequate.
So they have to now come up with a option of redoing the entire fire system or demolish
the terminal building and build the entire thing new which might be cheaper at the end
of the day.
So such kind of really drastic or failure systems can be avoided because if you build
a model and use it and study what will happen in future when something gets changed in the
system and when you have a reasonably good believable answer that gives you the confidence
to go forward and implement the change accordingly.
And finally it also allows us to analyze it allows us to analyze proposed or modified
systems.
So simulation allows us to model the system model complex systems in a very detailed fashion
so that you can study the system why do you model the system?
So that you can study you can study properly okay you do not want to experiment with the
real system you want to experiment with a model.
You can describe the behavior of the system time dependent including the time dependent
behavior of the system.
You can construct various hypotheses or intuitions about the absurd behavior of the system why
is the system doing what it is being doing now.
And you can use these systems model that you have developed to predict the future behavior
of the system or the effects that will be produced in the system due to some proposed
change in the system.
And once you can quantify that then you can go ahead and decide whether to use it implement
the change or not.
And also it allows you to analyze the proposed or modified systems and once you analyze and
you can come up with a rational suggestion whether this proposed change or the modified
system is better or worse.
So now we will get into the next concept which is called as the advantages of the simulation
and the biggest thing that we should understand is the simulations greatest strength why it
is one of the top 3 most popular tool is its ability to answer the what if questions okay.
What if, what if we increase the production from what will happen if we increase the production
from 200 cars to 250 cars, what happen if we change the fire suppression mechanism from
the existing one to something else, what happen if we change the current lathe machine which
is running at 200 parts an hour to a lathe which can make 400 parts per hour, will it
bring profit, will it improve productivity that kind of things.
So this is what if questions because if the minute you can answer this that is what is
called as alternate analysis okay ability to analyze alternatives.
So these 4 points are kind of important the following 4 points are important to you guys
because once you understand this then it will help you in realizing why do we need to do
simulation studies.
So the first part it is the study the existing system okay study the given existing system
without disrupting this is the biggest advantage of simulation without disrupting ongoing operations
or what you are trying to do is you can study the existing system, the existing product
system will continue to do the production and then we will we can go from there.
And the second part is the second major aspect is you can test the proposed system test the
proposed system before committing the resources.
So before committing money, before committing people, before committing materials you can
actually test the proposed system okay.
The third aspect of the simulation is allow the control of time or study the time dependent
behavior this is I said earlier also this okay time dependent behavior of the system.
So you can study how the system will behave as time progresses and then the last part
is provide insight to those system variables, system variables are they describe the state
of the system that are most important to the system performance okay.
So these 4 aspects are the advantages of simulation that are so unique to simulation other than
compared to all other studies that are available.
So we will get into the last slide and we will kind of conclude today's lecture here.
Well obviously any system that has an advantage it will also have a disadvantage okay.
So the simulation is also not without its disadvantages and there is there are some
disadvantages and let us take a look into it.
Building of a model or a systems model is an art and a science that people make the
statement what does it means?
It implies that quality of the analysis using the model is dependent upon the quality of
the model alright.
So which implies quality of the model is dependent upon a skill of the model.
So the success of the simulation study okay or success of building the model is dependent
on the skill of the model.
Skill of the model is something so better skill the model is better the model will be.
So that is an issue so the model plays a very important part in the simulation study okay.
So the study is dependent on the skill of the model.
Sometimes the results are hard to interpret reason being is when a complex system is studied
there are many performance measures targeting one might worsen the other.
So an example of this is if you say that I want to minimize the scenario where the machine
and the worker should not be idle.
So I want as much as work pieces right next to them so that they can continue to work.
Well that would ensure that the worker and the machine keeps on working or they are utilized
heavily.
But then it will also create a disadvantage that the work in process inventory on the
shop floor will increase.
Also the third factor is that because you are continuously overworking the worker and
the machine if anything fails then your system will come to a standstill.
So you putting the focus on one particular aspect of a complex system sometimes deteriorates
some other someplace else.
So especially when you are studying very complex large systems it is very hard to have a holistic
view in identifying what is the best thing to do okay.
So that is one of the reasons why sometimes simulation results becomes quite hard for
a individual to interpret.
And sometimes you require a panel of experts to interpret the results okay.
Simulation analysis can be sometimes time consuming and expensive okay.
So another way is that should not be used this is a simple rule should not be used when
an analytical method can provide quicker results.
So if you can build a simple model an analytical model okay or a mathematical model and that
can provide quicker results then please go ahead and build the analytical model and use
it to get quicker results.
Do not get into the simulation because it can be time consuming and it can be expensive.
That is still simulation is a time consuming and expensive process.
It is compared to the analytical method it is way too time consuming and expensive.
So you should not use it when the models are simple okay.
And there is also an impression that simulation is just programming okay that lot of people
think about it that way.
So the trick here is the aspect is there is a need for careful design and analysis of
simulation models.
There is a careful need for design and analysis of simulation models or what we call as the
simulation methodology okay this is not simply programming.
So you need to carefully design and analysis the simulation models not just do the program
and then call it good it does never work okay.
And there is a lot more art in modeling than programming than just programming.
So you have to decide what all things to be kept what all things to be removed that
kind of aspects are also an important aspect of the development of the simulation model.
That is why I earlier said the skill of the modeler is one of the most important aspects
and it is also a good thing in the simulation and it is also a big disadvantage.
Because if you have a low skilled modeler then the model that come out might not be
of the sufficient detail and accuracy.
So if you have a bad model then you get a bad result.
So garbage in garbage out is really applicable for simulation analysis as well.
So I hope now with this overview you guys should have a clear picture of why simulation
is an important tool and why simulation is an important one of the 3 top important tools
for people in the operation research and management field for managing complex systems, studying
complex systems, identifying ways to improve complex systems, even study the system even
before it is implemented, provide training to people to operate the system better.
All these aspects which are very, very valuable aspects can be provided by the simulation
and also as I said earlier it is an expensive and as well as a process which is dependent
upon the skill of the modeler.
So any good system will also have its disadvantages and once you can cover up for the disadvantages
by becoming a very skilled and capable modeler then building a complex system will not be
a tough thing to do.
So from the next lecture onwards we will focus on how to build models, what are the major
aspects we need to consider, we will try to learn what is Monte Carlo simulation and then
we will go from there.
Thank you for your patient learning and continue to read the assigned readings and textbooks
for more information.
Thank you.
