noc18-mm20 Lecture 09-Activity and Thermodynamics of Regular Solution

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
2 Video Views·Dec 3, 2023
[Music]
[Music]
okay so welcome to this new lecture
lecture number nine and physically be a
course so we'll just recap what we did
in the last class
so in the last lecture we are talking
about binary solutions which are
non-ideal so non-ideal will mean that
you have three kinds of bonds if you
have a B binary solution let's say a B
then you have three kind of bonds a B B
and a B and depending upon whether or
not the a and we have affinity for each
other that is determined by Delta H mix
so depending upon whether this is
positive or negative so if it is
negative then you will have preference
for a B bonds and if you have positive
then a a and BB bonds are preferred and
this is manifested by another parameter
interaction parameter which is Omega so
if it is greater than 0 then you have
positive Delta H mix and if we if this
is less than 0 then Delta H mix is
negative and depending upon these
parameters you you have so if you draw
the free energy verses composition so if
you plot let's say this is xB sorry so
if Delta H mix is positive then this is
what is Delta H mix going to look like
ok so this is Delta H mix and this is 0
so this is positive this is negative
however minus T Delta s mix will look
something like that this is minus T
Delta s mix and eventually the free
energy of mixing may look something like
what you have in between so it might
look this might be Delta G mix so
depending upon the now you can have
another situation in which you know
Delta H mix is negative so if I draw
another plot
here for example instance so you have
another plot which a and B are there and
if Delta H mix is negative so that is
Delta H mix and if you have this is
Delta minus T Delta s mix and eventually
the free energy will be even for the
lower because both of the terms are
negative so this is Delta G mix so you
can see the driving force that is Delta
G mix changes depending upon the
relative magnitudes of Delta H mix and
minus T Delta s mix with respect to each
other so if Delta H mix is negative
which means the driving force for making
a solid solution is higher but if Delta
H mix is positive the driving force for
making the solid solution is lower
however even at higher Delta H mix it
turns out that in certain cases where
you have situations like this
positive/negative so here Delta H mixes
is greater than zero and it's positive
and minus T Delta s mixes also it's
negative but it's not usually negative
because the temperature may be lower as
a result the Delta G mix plot will have
behavior something like this so it will
not make a solid solution for throughout
the composition range but it will make a
solid solution of a and B and be in a
that's right so what is what this tells
you is that even though Delta H mixing
is higher and minus T Delta s mix is not
so negative the Delta G mix when the
system when the solutions are dilute
that is so this is a this is B so this
is solution of on this side you will
have solution of B in a so you have a as
major element and B as minor element on
this side you will have solution of a
and B so B is minor and a is minor and B
is major so even though they preference
for a B bounces very low adding a little
bit of be in a or adding a little bit a
and B lowers the free energy and this
can be proved by you take the derivative
for instance of del of Delta s mix del X
a and if you try to make it you know X a
tends to 0 this will be very close to
infinity and and the derivative of Delta
H mix as a function of del X a when X a
tends to 0 is is equal to
Omega so since the change in entropy
becomes infinity at pure compositions so
when you add very little so this is
sorry this is xB tends to zero and this
is again xB tends to zero so very little
amount of xB so at these compositions
that since the free energy changes and
repeat change is negative infinity the
free energy change tends to be because
of entropy because the enthalpy changes
finite and entropy changes in finite as
a result the free energy tends to be
negative at so basically these are the
regions which are dominated by you can
say regions dominated by minus T Delta s
mix contribution so configurational
entropy changes a lot and you add a
little bit of impurity in something so
you add a little bit of B into a a
little bit of a into B the configuration
entropy changes substantially as a
result even at lower temperatures impure
material is preferred over pure pure
state because of negative free energy of
mixing in the impurity state dominated
by the changes in the entropy and so as
long as T is greater than zero Kelvin as
long as T is greater than zero Kelvin
the Delta G mix will always decrease for
a pure component if you add a little bit
of impurity to it that is why in nature
pure things do not exist always
everything will always consist of kind
minut amounts of impurities which will
lower the free energy of that particular
phase resulting in negative Delta G of
mixing and which is mainly dominated by
the entropy term not the enthalpy term
and this is because of changes in
configuration entropy you can work this
out using the Delta s mixing pression
and Delta H mix expression which I have
showed before so these two expression
the balance between these two quantity
these two entities Delta s mix and Delta
H mix will determine negative free
energy of mixing at impure in the impure
States so basically the
what what you say that is so now you
know it's at it's a recap is over so so
what we have here is basically that what
we are concluding here is that dilute
solutions or small additions of
to pure element will result in a
decrease in Delta G dominated by
governed by decreasing minus T Delta s
dumb and mainly it is the configuration
entropy that changes so so as long as T
is greater than zero Kelvin then you add
impurity to a pure phase pure metal or
material pure element impurity addition
leads to changes and leads to negative
free energy of mixing which means impure
phase becomes more stable as compared to
pure phase and this is mainly dominated
by increase in the configurational
entropy as a result minus T Delta s mix
becomes more negative however this is
only to about the dilute solutions not
about the highly impure solutions so in
very very small the impurity has to be
presented as small quantities of course
a relative change will be governed by
the value of Delta H mix as well but
even though Delta H mix is very positive
every system can tolerate small amount
of impurities in it driven by
thermodynamic changes so now let us move
to another concept so what we have done
is we have learnt about chemical we have
basically we have started from ideal
solutions and following that we have
discussed the discussed so we have
discussed the change in entropy change
in free energy of mixing in ideal
solutions and then we invoke the concept
of chemically chemical potential which
is basically that changes in the free
energy when my new traditions are made
to an alloy of a or B let's say
then we looked at what happens when the
solution is not ideal it is a regular
solution which has whose Delta whose
enthalpy of mixing is not zero so Delta
H mix is not zero rather it is positive
or negative so depending upon the
magnitude of Delta H mix and
corresponding changes in minus T Delta s
mix you will have a system stability
predicted but in many cases wherever
Delta H mix is negative you will always
have stable solid solution and even
though Delta H mix is positive depending
upon the temperature and configuration
entropy changes you will you will have
either complete range of solid solution
which is thermodynamically stable or at
least at the ends of a and B you will
have thermodynamic stability of impure
phases so this is what we have discussed
so far in this lecture now we take
forward this take this forward by
introducing another concept called as
activity so activity is basically very
similar to chemical potential it it it
is it is a measure of
how active an element is so basically it
it is going it is determines whether or
not that particular element would like
to stay in the solution phase or it
would like to come out of solution phase
so depending about the magnitude of this
activity the solutions are made stable
or unstable so basically one can define
activity in such a manner so that
chemical potential is related to
activity as G a plus RT Ln a a and mu B
is equal to G B plus RT Ln a B this is
for an ideal a B alloy okay hello a
system or basically or solution solid
solution
all right so mu a is equal to GA plus
rtln
a a mu B plus G B mu B is equal to G B
plus RT Ln a B so basically what we had
earlier was that mu a was equal to G a
plus RT Ln X a and mu beef was G B plus
RT Ln X B we have replaced XA and xB by
a term called as activity which is a a
and a B now in general in general a a
for regular solutions is less than X a
and a B is less than XP or you can have
a greater than X a and a be greater than
X B so depending upon how active the
element is your activity can be higher
or lower than the atomic fraction of
that particular element in the alloy so
so in general they are not equal to XA
and xB is not equal to XA and a
graphically how do you represent it it's
like this so you make a plot of free
energy versus composition so a B in this
direction you have xB varying so when
you plot let's say free energy of an
alloy all right
so this is let's say point a this is
point B and this line gives the a rule
of mixture free energy of alloy okay so
basically this is you can say G mix GMM
which was XA g a plus XB g b before
mixing alright this point is G a this
point is G B and in reality you form a
mixture which is stable as a result this
is what is Delta G
and this is what we have done earlier
activity is determined by so you take it
so you draw a common tangent you draw a
tangent and this tangent intercepts on
so correspondingly you will have
chemical potential for a given
composition let's say this is X naught
so correspondingly you have chemical
potential of a and chemical potential of
B so for this alloy of composition X
naught the chemical potential of a is mu
a and chemical potential of MU B is mu B
in da in the alloy for this particular
composition and correspondingly this
term is minus RT Ln a a and this term is
minus RT Ln a B so you can see that the
previous relation the G B was equal to
MU B minus RT Ln a B and G a was equal
to mu a minus RT Ln a or so so depending
upon the activities now we will see how
how the how these two these things add
up so this is how we define activity for
now for a regular solution we know
we know that mu a is equal to G a plus
gamma into Omega into 1 minus se square
plus RT Ln X a and mu B is equal to G B
plus Omega 1 minus xB square plus RT Ln
X B so this term and this term they are
what becomes equal to RT Ln so RT Ln a a
is equal to Omega 1 minus X square plus
RT Ln X a and RT Ln a B is equal to
Omega 1 minus xB square plus RT and then
X B so if I if you now simplify this
what you get is Ln a a by X a is equal
to Omega by RT into 1 minus X a square
and Ln a B by X P R P into 1 minus xB
square and this is assuming that a and B
have similar structure so now if you
plot these activities as a function of
composition so this is as a function of
composition so let's say this is 1 this
is 0 this is pure a this is pure B so
this is xB and this is X a ok so then so
first thing I plot is a B the activity
of B
okay for the ideal solution
the activity of a a B is equal to X B
and this is basically given by what we
call as rules law okay and depending
upon now Delta H mix whether it is
positive or negative the activity
deviates so if you have a non-ideal
solution then
so this is for Delta H mix greater than
0 which means the B is more active a and
B do not mix today when Delta H mix is
greater than 0 which means elements are
more active they don't like to they
don't like to stay in the bound form
they rather prefer independent forms as
a result their activity is higher okay
and we'll come back to the slope later
on so basically this is Delta H mix
skater than zero and second state that
you might have is the other way round
and you have when you have Delta H mix
less than zero in such a situation when
a and B bonds are preferred then a and B
are not very active as a result activity
of B for instance is lower than its mole
fraction which is determined by the
ideal solution raoult's law in this case
the activity is lower because of Delta H
mix being less than zero and again we
can draw a slope at this point so this
this is 100% B this is dilute solution
when B is very small okay so so we can
say that for ideal solution you can have
which is basically rowels law
a is equal to X a and a B is equal to X
B and for non-ideal solutions to say if
Delta H mix is less than zero then a B
is less than X B if Delta H mix is
greater than zero then a B is greater
than X B and the ratio of so basically
ratio of a versus X for a given element
a I to X I is called as activity
coefficient of I so you can see that
when element is in ideal solution so
this activity will be gamma I so gamma I
will be equal to 1 for ideal solution
and gamma I will be greater than or less
than 1 depending upon so it will be
little more when Delta H mix is greater
than 0 it will be Delta H mix is less
than 1 when Delta H mixes
less than zero and this is what is
called as Henry's law so Henry law says
that so Henry's law says that for a
dilute solution of let's say a in B okay
that is X a is tending to be zero the
activity coefficient of a in B that is
gamma a is equal to a a by X a similarly
for a no real solution of B in a when xB
is tending to zero activity coefficient
of B in a would be gamma B that is equal
to a B by X B so similarly for dilute
solution of B in a gamma B will be equal
to a B by X B so for this solution your
when xB is tending to be zero so this is
basically xB tends to be 0 and gamma a
for such a system will be almost equal
to one so a the majority element will
act as if it's like a ideal thing and
whereas the minority element which is
that a looot element will act as a as
per the henry's law so this is this will
act as paroles law and this will act as
per henry's law
you can also plot similarly the a a with
respect to X this is 1 this is 0 this is
pure a so this was X B this is X a so
for a pure element hey we'll be here for
pure B a will be equal to 0 so ideal
case would be
so this would be a straight line when it
is ideal so this is a a is equal to X a
for now you can have two more cases the
first case could be like this the second
case could be like this so in this case
this is a a greater than X a when Delta
H mix is greater than zero and this is a
smaller than X a when Delta H mix is
less than zero so so this is at this
point your X a is 1 and X B is 0 at this
point xB is 1 and X a is zero ok so this
is how it will vary so in this so
basically the activity of an element is
equivalent to chemical potential so it
tells you that basically both of them
tell about the state of that component
in the system both basically measure the
tendency of the element to leave or
remain in the system ok so if your a is
greater than 0 it means mu is also
greater than 0 which means tendency to
leave the solution and if a is less than
0 mu is less than 0 it is tendency to
remain and basically what it means is
that when a is very when a is large and
mu is large the partial pressure of that
element is high and when a is small
Meuse small the partial pressure of that
element is low so this tells you about
the propensity of the element to remain
or leave the
system both these activity and chemical
potentials we will stop here in this
lecture will start the next lecture with
the further moving on to the real
solutions so we lived at ideal and
regular solutions now we will be looking
at the real solutions
[Music]
[Music]
