noc18-mm20 Lecture 14-Phase Diagram construction:Partial Soluble Phases

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Dec 3, 2023
So, now let us again begin with the new lecture, which is lecture number 14 and in this lecture
we will talk about, we will further delve into different kinds of phase diagrams and
the correlation with the free energy composition plots. So, in the last lecture we just have
a recap of the last lecture. So, in the last lecture we only talked about, we just looked
at the completely miscible AB system. So, where A and B were completely miscible
in each other and we plotted G x curves at various temperatures and then looking at the
profiles of these temperatures and how different phases came to coexist with each other we
constructed a phase diagram. A phase diagram is basically a landscape of in two dimensions
for binary system it is between temperature and composition. So, you take the information
from free energy composition curve at all temperatures then you eliminate the temperature
and construct, eliminate the free energy and construct the temperature versus composition
diagram. So, for this kind of completely miscible system
between A and B we had a phase diagram something like that. So, above, so we had T m sorry,
so this is T m A, this is T m B. So, above T m A at for pure A and for all compositions
above this boundary which is curving upwards, which is called as liquidus only the liquid
phase exists. Between this phase boundary called as liquidus and the other boundary
which is called as solidus you have a two phase coexistence. So, for any composition
except pure A and pure B between T m A and T m B you will have only two phase coexistence.
So, for this composition you will have between this temperature and this temperature you
will have two phase. For this composition between this and this you will have two phase,
for this composition between this and this you will have two phase and for this composition
between this and this you will have two phase. And below this solidus boundary for all compositions
you will have solid phase which is S. Now, this is this phase diagram is obtained by
drawing free energy composition curves at various temperatures. And this was valid for
systems which are completely miscible in each other, which were soluble into each
other in both liquid and solid state. And this is this generally happens for systems
which are very which we do not have large difference between the melting points, they
have similar structure, similar valences, similar nearly similar ionic radii and so
on and so forth. Basically they follow the rule of Hume-Rothery rules very well, perfect
examples of Hume-Rothery rules. Now, the moment, but life is not easy in most cases
in reality A and B are hardly soluble into or they do not have complete solid solid solubility,
A and B do not have complete miscibility that is they have partial solid solubility especially
in the solid solid phase. So, assuming that they are miscible in, so
now we assume that they are assuming in liquid phase, but they have partial solid solubility
or partial solubility in solid phase. So, partial solid solubility, but complete solubility
in liquid and they do not have vast differences in melting point. So, A and B like each other's
company, but only to a certain extent in solid phase, in liquid phase they are completely
miscible. Now, if that was the scenario, so basically the first type of phase diagram
that we had, that we looked at this phase diagram is generally called as isomorphous
phase diagram. So, it is a phase diagram for isomorphous systems such as copper, nickel
best example of this kind of phase diagram. Now, let us look at this example where A and
B have partial solid solubility in solid partial solubility into each other in solid state
and in liquid state they are completely soluble. So, they make first phase called as alpha
which is basically solution of solid solution of B in A, it could be interstitial solid
solution, it could be substitutional by and large it would be depends upon the atomic
size and so on and so forth. If it is a in most cases it would be substitutional in case
of phase diagrams where the size is not very different, then beta phase is solid solution
of A in B. So, basically alpha phase follows a structure.
So, structure similar to A and it has a structure similar to B. So, we write solid solution
of A and B and then we have liquid phase. So, these are the three phases which are present
in the whole composition free energy temperature landscape. So, now, let us begin with first
temperature T 1. So, we take a temperature T 1 and this T 1 and also we say that melt
again you know A has a melting point of T m A, B has a melting point of T m B and let
us say T m A is slightly higher than T m B. They are not vastly different from each other,
but there is certain difference. So, what they have here is first the alpha and beta
phases here may have similar structure, but or they may have different structures also.
So, let us look at the case where they have they have different structures. So, at temperature
T 1 which is higher than melting point of A, we first draw the free energy composition
curve A and B into G. So, as it happens as you would expect the liquid will be stable
as compared to solid. So, this is G L, this is G S for all compositions your liquid is
stable as compared to solid. This is at temperature T 1. Now, let us look at temperature T 2 and
T 2 is less than T 1 and is greater than, but it is less than melting point of A, but
greater than melting point of B. So, I am not going to draw now at T m, because you
know that what will happen at T m A similar to previous case.
So, now let us make a phase diagram again. So, at this temperature when you plot free
energy versus composition, what happens at this temperature is that your this is your
liquid free energy and your solid is somewhere this is your alpha. Let me just use a different
color this is alpha phase and the beta phase will be somewhere. So, let us say the green
one is beta phase, this is your beta phase and for these two phase. So, you can see that
at certain composition let me just first identify this is G L, this is G beta and this
is G alpha. Now, let me draw the common tangent between these two. So, corresponding to these
two points. So, what do you see here? You see that below point A your alpha phase is
more stable than liquid phase. So, this will be alpha use a different color now. So, this
is alpha between A and B you can see that you can draw a common tangent between the
two curves and this is going by the previous rules this would be alpha plus liquid and
in this region you will have only liquid. So, this is the phase diagram versus phase
composition phase free energy versus composition at temperature T 2. So, you can see that as
you have gone from T 1 which was completely liquid you have gone to now T 2 which is lower
than T 1 lower than T 1 you have entered into a phase regime where you have for certain
composition you have single phase alpha and for certain compositions intermediate compositions
you have alpha plus liquid coexistence and then above certain composition B you have
complete liquid phase. So, you have solid starting to appear now as you further reduce
the temperature. So, now, let us go to temperature T 3 this T 3 is of course, lower than T 2.
So, let us say it is now lower than T m B. So, in the previous case T m B was lower than
T 2 in this case T 3 which is lower than T m B. So, naturally it is lower than T 2,
but it is let us not define it you know there is another temperature that will come I will
define that later on. So, it is lower than T m B and your situation is like this now
you have a phase diagram which is something like that you have pure A pure B all right
sorry G not T. So, your the as you further reduce the temperature from T 3 to T 2. So,
this was your liquid curve. So, let us say this is the liquid curve now what happens
is that the solid curve which color was it the blue one the blue one starts to lower
even further and what is starts happening is that your the green one starts lower below
liquid curve. So, you have this is G L this is G beta this is G alpha. So, you can see
now G alpha has shifted further to the right the minima of G alpha G liquid with respect
to G liquid on the other hand on the right side when you are the pure B regime the G
beta has started lowering itself with respect to G liquid.
So, now what you see is that in certain regimes alpha phase is more stable in the certain
regimes you have beta phase that is more stable and the region in which liquid is stable will
shrink. So, how do we do that we again draw the common tangent and again we draw the common
tangent here all right. So, this is let us say. So, previously we had point A and B now
let us say we had point C D E and F and if you apply the similar logic now in this region
you will have alpha in this region you will have alpha plus liquid in this region you
will have beta in this range you will have beta plus liquid and within this region what
will you have within this region only liquid is stable phase you will have only liquid.
So, you can see now you have 3 phases coexisting with either. So, 3 phases are there with 5
regions. So, the first region below composition C is alpha where solid alpha is more stable
between C and D you have alpha solid phase coexisting with liquid phase above the composition
D only liquid phase coexists and then when you move on to further E composition the beta
phase starts to appear and this beta coexists solid beta is a solid phase that coexists
with a liquid phase until reach point F and above point F only beta phase coexists in
the solid phase. So, now, you have entered into a temperature
regime which is lower than lower than the melting points of both A and B yet you have
a problem or you have a interesting scenario that liquid is still there. So, what happens
in certain cases. So, now, you reach a specific temperature. So, now, so, this is let me just
label it number 1 number 2 number 3 this is number 3 and now we come to number 4 which
is temperature of T 4 and at temperature T 4 what happens is that temperature T 4 is
lower than T m B and T m A of course, but it is equal to a temperature called as eutectic
temperature and this is a new temperature which I am introducing which is called as
eutectic temperature what happens at this temperature is as follows.
So, you have A you have B you have X B and this is the temperature T. So, let us now
draw the liquid free energy curve this is the liquid free energy curve and what happens
at this point is. So, the blue one is the alpha 1. So, which is let us say slightly
higher than for the sake of clarity let me just make slight changes here T 4 is only
slightly higher than. So, I would say there is a temperature T e. So, let us say we are
at T e plus. So, T e is the temperature called as eutectic temperature if you are slightly
above this you are at T e plus and if you are slightly below this you are at temperature
called as T e minus. So, we are at a temperature which is called as T e plus. So, at T e plus
what will happen is that green one. So, we can see that this is G liquid this is G alpha
and this is G beta and what you have here is you have common tangent which is like this.
So, we have now point. So, we have A B C D E F now this is point G H I J. So, we have
moved from alpha plus liquid, liquid beta plus liquid and beta. So, what you see now
here is beta and alpha have broadened liquid has shrunk and. So, are the 2 phase regions
beta and liquid which are which are not and then you reach point T. So, we were at number
4 we will be now at number 5 which is T is equal to T e. So, at T is equal to T e this
is your free energy curve this is your. So, actually at T is equal to T e these phases
will coexist with each other. So, as a result you will have. So, now, you will have liquid
alpha alpha plus liquid liquid liquid is very just a straight line and then liquid plus
beta and beta. So, this is of course, G liquid G alpha and G beta and then you go to a temperature
T is equal to T e minus the situation is very different then you have a scenario.
So, now, if you mark these regions. So, this G e basically are fairly similar. So, you
have you have this is. So, we had G h i j let us say these are k l m this is x p and
at T is equal to T e minus the scenario is very different scenario is this is your G
l and this is your this is G l this is G beta this is G alpha and what we have here is we
have a alpha region we have a beta region and we have alpha plus beta because liquid
free energy has now gone above. So, we can see that as we gone down as we have gone down
in temperature. So, this is T 1 where the solid free energy curve is higher than the
liquid. So, we can say in this case instead of drawing the solid one I should have drawn.
So, both the solids which means both either alpha or beta. So, I have not drawn both of
them, but both of them will be above. So, if you wanted to draw both of them one would
be like this another would be like this. So, this would be G alpha this would be G beta
they will be above liquid. Now, what we have at temperature T 2 the G alpha and G beta
start shifting down they go down this goes up this. So, this is a relative movement with
respect to each other. So, you can see that as you cross the melting point of a the alpha
phase stabilizes slowly when you further enter into two phase when you further enter
into lower temperatures below the melting point of b even beta phase starts to form
get stabilizes and you have different phase regimes now. So, again this is lowered this
is lowered with respect to G L what happened here is at T plus which is just when liquid
is about to disappear you have alpha beta and liquid free energy curves standing almost
at the same level the minima's are almost at the same tangent, but slightly different.
So, you still have very thin liquid region, but liquid is, but still there and then you
came to a temperature T e where minima's are absolutely at one line. So, you can draw
a common tangent which means liquid only exists at this in at this boundary. So, this
is the liquid boundary and again you have two phase regions single phase regions in
a similar fashion and the moment now you go below this temperature T e liquid phases liquid
free energy curve has gone up with respect to solid and liquid what you stabilize now
is a mixture of alpha and beta and this further this goes on until now you are in completely
solid phase and this goes on until you. So, if you further decrease the temperature it
will further keep evolving. So, now, let us draw the phase diagram. So, this was K L M
N let us say O N and O and if you go to even further temperature let us say 7 T is less
than T e minus. So, if you draw the free energy curve then. So, A B your this is G
this is X B. So, your solid free energy curve is somewhere here liquid free energy curve
is somewhere here this is beta sorry and your liquid has gone way up this is G L this is
G alpha this is G beta and it can draw a common tangent and these are two points. So, it is
L M N O. So, let us say this is P N. So, now, you have alpha plus beta and beta you only
have solid regime now we need to connect the dots. So, when we connect the dots. So, now,
let us say T X diagram A B you have X B this is temperature start from temperature start
from T 1 or liquid. So, let us say it is all liquid start from T 2. So, this is T 1 sorry
all right and then we looked at T 2. So, somewhere here you will have T M of A we are at T 2
we had two phase coexistence. So, we had one point here and another point somewhere here
which is A and B A B then we were at. So, T 2 had only let me just go back T 2 had only
alpha alpha plus liquid and liquid and then we come to T 3 we had a this kind of system.
So, we had five regions. So, in this case we had only alpha liquid plus alpha and then
liquid and now we are at T 3 and this T M B is somewhere here. So, this is T M. So,
now, we are at. So, this temperature is. So, let us say this is first temperature this
is second temperature this is the composition and this is other composition. So, we are
I have just drawn a little wrongly let us see undo. So, let us say this T M B was somewhere
here. So, this is T M A. So, this is T M B all right and now we are at a temperature
where we have which is T 3 somewhere. So, this is T 3 and we draw these points again.
So, we were at this composition let us say we were at this composition we were somewhere
here and we were somewhere and then let us say another define a temperature called as
T e. So, let us say this is my this is T e. So, at T e minus. So, this is T e minus and
this is T e plus. So, just above this temperature and this T e. So, three lines. So, in the
first case we were here and here and somewhere here and then and at this point we were here
we were here we were somewhere here and then at this point T e minus we were very close
to this point earlier and we had only. So, what we had in the phase regions was. So,
this is alpha alpha plus liquid liquid beta plus liquid beta. So, we will finish this
in the next class we do not have sufficient time to finish in this lecture it will take
about five minutes. So, we will further draw this completely basically what we have done
is we have drawn free energy compositions of various temperatures we will put them together
to get rid of free energy and plot them at temperature composition is skilled to do our
phase diagram to draw a phase diagram.
Thank you.
