noc19-ch17-lec05

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
2 Video Views·Dec 3, 2023
In this lecture we will discuss basic concepts such as definition of intensive variables and driving forces for temperature and pressure flow etc
Welcome back, in the last lecture we defined variables, temperature, pressure and chemical
potential. A temperature was introduced as a derivative of internal energy with respect
to entropy. Now it is rather odd abstract quantity such as entropy to temperature, okay
and thus it is important that the definition and the postulate which we have shown here
indeed fulfills the experience which we have with respect to the temperature, okay.
So I am going to write down a list of typical experience we have with temperature or the
observations we have. The temperature is basically intensive, okay. Second is if two system in
thermal contact and they will reach equilibrium and attain a same temperature and third is
if let us say there are two particular blocks of object at thermal contact having temperature
T1 and T2 with T1 greater than T2.
This basically would imply that the heat will flow from object 1 to 2, okay. So this
is something which we have feeling or intuitions or observations, okay. So what we are basically
discussing is temperature difference and heat flow, okay and how our observations is
basically can be related to the definition which we have or the definition of the temperature
in terms of the internal energy and entropy or the definition is basically satisfying
the observation which we are writing down here and the fourth if we raise the temperature
at constant P or constant V, we expect the energy should go up, okay.
So we expect energy to go up. So this particular observation 4 it is basically saying that
energy will be raised upon application or supply of heat. So this can be equivalently
stated as follows that adding heat raises the temperature. Now the first observation
that temperature is intensive is part of the definition of the first law, okay or in general
the definition indicates that T is intensive. So the first and second we can now look at
and the fourth we will be discussing little later.
So in order to prove that first and second observation holds with the specific definition
of the temperature, so let us consider these 2 object, okay. It is contact by this rigid
impermeable separator. So this is basically a rigid impermeable, okay but it allows heat
to flow, okay and now let us keep this particular 2 blocks. We will isolate it, okay. So this
is complete insulation here, okay and compartment 1 it has its own internal energy, volume and
number of moles, okay and similarly for the second compartment, okay.
So initially we are assuming this compartment 1 and compartment 2 already are the equilibrated
state. So they have this individual energies, volume and n. Now they have been put to the
thermal contact. Now what happens subsequently? So if you look at it the process the total
n here is fixed and total volume is fixed, V and n are basically fixed. However, because
of the exchange of energy, okay from the heat point of view the internal energy is
going to U can, so internal energy can change here basically, okay. Now this can change
but subject to the conservation restriction that is U1 plus U2 is basically constant,
okay.
So now let us try to understand that with this constraint what would be the condition
of equilibrium for this particular system. So let us make use of this constraint. So
if I take the derivative here similarly for the case of the volume because V1 plus V2
is going to be constant. So you can also show that dV1 is basically minus dV. However, since
V1 and V2 are constant because of the rigid separator this essentially means dV1 is equal
to dV2 is equal to 0. Now since the separator itself is impermeable that means it does not
allow any particle to go from one compartment to another compartment.
This means dn1 is dn2 is equal to 0. Now let us try to understand how to write down
our fundamental equation here. Now we can consider or take the Q from postulate 4 where
we say that the equilibrium state is attained when S is maximum, okay for this particular
isolated state at isolated system. So equilibrium will attain when S is maximum. Now S of the
system is basically S1 plus S2, okay.
So in other word your statement can be written as dS is equal to 0 or that it means dS1 plus
dS2 this should be 0, okay. Now we can write down the differential expression of S in terms
of the other variables u, v and n, okay. Now since dV is equal to 0 and dn equal to 0.
So the only term with respect to du will remain here. So this I can write down as the follows.
This is equal to 1 by T1 du. The other terms are going to be 0. So for the sake of completion
we can write down the complete terms also. So if we consider this to be pure system with
single component, so you can see here this is 1 by T du. So I can write down 1 by T du1
plus P1 T1 dV. So I can write down this in this form, okay. So I can actually write down
this as minus summation. So we are assuming this to be pure but this since the moles are
not changing in individual compartment, this part is going to be 0, okay.
Similarly, for the second compartment, okay and thus this part is basically 0 for both
the compartments. So I can simply write for the second compartment as 1 by T2 du2 plus
the other term which is 0, okay. So with this I have now an expression as 1 by T1 du1 plus
1 by T2 du2. Now since du1 is nothing but this, okay, so I can write down this expression
completely in terms of delta u or du2, okay, at basically constant n and V, okay. Now this
essentially means that if dS is 0, this tells you that this is, okay, the T2 is equal to T1.
So this is basically the conditions of thermal equilibrium, okay, which is attained when the
equilibrium is reached when S reaches a maximum value, okay. Now we can connect this expression
to heat flow as well. If you relook at the postulate, the postulate came that the unconstrained
variable in case of u2, so if the u2 is considered as unconstrained variable, so u2 is unconstrained
variable, okay. So it will arrange itself in order to maximize, arrange in order to
maximize the entropy, okay. So let us little bit look at it, what does it mean? It means
basically that you are going to have this kind of plot for S as a function of u, okay,
and this is going to be u2 where this is the case where the u2 is equal to u2 at equilibrium, okay.
Now it does not tell you which path is going to follow either this one or this side, okay. So let
us assume that that if initially T2 is greater than T1, okay. Now we look at this expression
again, this. So it tells you the following that dS by du is 1 by T2 minus 1 by T1, okay. Now if
T2 is greater than T1 that means this expression is going to be less than 0, okay. Now since dS
is greater than 0, okay, for this system before it reaches equilibrium, at equilibrium dS is equal
to 0 but until it reaches equilibrium the dS is greater than 0 which indicates that du of 2 should
be less than 1, okay. So this means that the internal energy of u in this case decreases,
okay. So if internal energy of 2 compartment 2 decreases, it essentially means that heat is
flowing from 2 to 1. This implies that heat flow is from object 2 to 1, okay, and in such case this
is the process here that would be u is decreasing, okay, for this particular case.
Now similarly if T2 is less than T1 or T1 is greater than T2 which essentially means dS by
du2 is basically greater than 0 which essentially means u2 is greater than 0 that means u is
basically of 2 is increasing essentially means that heat flows from 1 to 2. So this would be
the case for the system where you have T2 is less than T1, okay. This particular two expression
clearly explains you that heat flows from hot object to a cold object that is what we could
use and this means that our observation is in line with the definition of the temperature where we
have related to an abstract quantity such as entropy, okay.
So though we have used the concept of extremum, okay, we have not fully exploited the condition
of entropy maximum and where of course for maximum dS should be less than 0, the second
derivative of S. So we are not discussing at this point. This would be discussed when we
will be considering the stability and equilibrium which will be taken much later. So our focus at
this point is to make use of the definition of the temperature pressure and then relate to the
observation which we have. So having explained the temperature difference and the heat flow how
these are related, we can now move to the pressure difference and volume change.
So how pressure difference and volume change can be connected from the equilibrium point of view.
So this would be leading to some definition of finally in terms of pressure for mechanical
equilibrium, okay. So essentially what we intend to do is we want to show that delta P basically
lead to changes in volume, okay. So for that what we are going to do is we are going to consider a
container where fixed volume insulated where we have some kind of a mobile separator, okay,
which should be diathermal. So let us try to pictorially explain this. So you have this,
let us say container. This is insulated and fixed. So this is divided into two compartments,
okay, which is fixed by some hinge and this is let us say compartment 1, compartment 2.
So this has gas, both of them. They are at a different temperature and pressure. So this
will be let us say T1, P1. This is T2, P2, okay and similarly the volume is going to be,
let us say different, alright. So now you allow this partition to move, okay, by taking off this
particular hinge or you remove this hinge and so that it can move, okay. So if we allow partition
to move, now this partition will allow heat to transfer and of course it will be mobile.
So that means the volume of each compartment can change but it will not allow the particles or the
molecules or species to penetrate from one compartment to another compartment. So the
number of moles are going to be fixed, okay. So now let us consider this composite system
because it is insulated. So we consider this composite system based on compartment 1 and 2,
okay. So this is compartment 1 plus 2 which is closed and insulated which essentially means
that your U1 plus U2 is equal to constant. V1 plus V2 is also constant, okay. In addition to
that your dn1 is dn2 is going to be 0, okay. Before I write down the fundamental equation
here, we can differentiate this and write down this expression in the form of differential form.
Now this partition can move until this will keep moving until it reaches an equilibrium position,
okay. What we want to find out is the condition of equilibrium in such a case. So we will start
with the concept of again the entropy. Since it is closed and insulated essentially means
that entropy will reach a maximum or which can be now written in terms of this expression here,
okay. Since n is going to be 0, so we are not going to write the third term of differential
expression of S. So only the volume and U term is going to be there. So in other words,
I can now write this as, so this is for compartment 1 and then for compartment 2.
Now we make use of these two expressions and simplify this, okay. So I can now write down
ds as 1 by T1 given that this are unconstrained, okay. The U and V we are not controlling it. So
these are unconstrained for any arbitrary values of U and V, the falling is going to be 0 for at
maximum. So if ds is equal to 0, it means this is equal to 0 and as well as this is equal to 0.
So this expression, the first one will yield the following. The temperature should be equal of the
two compartment at equilibrium and a second one would yield P1 by T1 is P2 by T2 and given that
this is the case, this would lead to the equality of the pressure in the two compartment at
equilibrium. This is the at equilibrium we can talk about, okay, that this is the final condition
of the equilibrium. Now we are going to talk about if what happens to the flow of the volume,
if considering that one of the compartment has a higher pressure. So just to conclude this
discussion, we will be taking the case of, let us say, we will write it down for a special case.
Where we are going to just look at the compartment where the temperature is fixed
at equilibrium temperature, okay, the same expression. Now in case of temperature is
equal ds can be written as the second term, okay. So with T1 is equal to T2. So ds is 1 by T P1
minus P2 dv1, okay. So this is at constant T and 1 and now which means I can write this expression
as T del s by del v, total v is constant, total u is constant, total volume is constant and 1 and
then 2, okay. Now with this, okay, if P1 is greater than P2 which essentially means this,
this essentially implies that del s by del v1 is greater than 0, okay, which essentially means del
v1 should be greater than 0 which means that volume should increase, volume of compartment
1 should increase, okay. So this means that volume of 1 should increase, okay.
So what does this indicate, this expression? That means if the pressure of compartment 1
is more, it is going to expand against the compartment 2. So that means the volume of
compartment 1 should increase, okay and similarly for the case of compartment 2,
the volume is going to get suppressed or in other word, it will get compressed where the
compartment 1 is going to compress the compartment 2 until the pressure reaches an equilibrium.
So this particular observation or this particular results agree with our observation indicating
that our definition indeed fulfills the basic intuitions of our observation from our experiments.
So we will continue with this particular exercise with an example and then we will
talk about the chemical equilibrium and then we will conclude this particular subject and
then we will take it up some other subject in the next lecture. So I will see you again in
the next lecture with the continuation of this exercise, okay. Have a good day.
