Lecture 33: X-Ray Photo-electron Spectroscopy (XPS): Applications-2

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Dec 2, 2023
Lecture 33, so in this lecture we will continue where we have been, what we have been discussing
in the previous class, it was about adsorption of carbon monoxide on two surfaces, so we
will basically try to summarise that and make our understanding clear.
And then we will switch to a new topic, this is basically about two-dimensional molecular
materials prepared on surface, so that is also something interesting, it is actually
a kind of new emerging material which is purely prepared on surface, so that is a pure two-dimensional
material.
So we will look into that as well and in that example what I am also just planning is basically
to bring together the scanning tunnelling microscopy, atomic force microscopy, X-ray
photoelectron spectroscopy, scanning tunnelling spectroscopy and so on together in order to
basically make some kind of a consolidated understanding of a given material, yeah.
So you will also understand how these methods can be together used in understanding a particular
type of material and also we can learn about this two-dimensional material as well.
So let us look at the example that we have been discussing about, it was about carbon
monoxide on nickel and then we have basically seen the X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy
as a function of coverage and then you have seen that as a coverage increases we do see
signature of carbon monoxide getting adsorbed on to top sites, bridge sites and HCP sites
and particularly at high coverages we do see that molecules are getting occupied on to
top sites which is normally not a favourable site, yeah.
So that is what we have discussed and now we can basically try to understand it a bit
more carefully.
So now you see that something else you can also do with the spectrum because we know
that this resonance is at a lower coverage is corresponding or the intensity of the resonance
is basically corresponding to the amount of molecules that is occupied at the HCP site.
So at this coverage I can basically say that 100 percent of the molecules are occupied
at HCP site, yeah this is something HCP or FCC site so I am here not distinguishing them
so it is with XPS it is hard to distinguish them.
So you can basically just say that but now you know that as the coverage increases what
is happening is that you are basically getting new resonances so that is basically these
ones which are corresponding to the top site, yeah and then you would also see that the
amount of coverage of the molecule occupying the HCP site would basically go down.
So in fact by analysing the intensity of this peak you can in fact make a summary of what
is exactly going on as a function of the coverage and that is what I am doing here, you can
basically see now I have the absolute coverage, yeah that is in monolayer of the carbon monoxide
occupying on the nickel 111 surface and you clearly see that at the very, very low coverage
100 percent occupation or these are the experimental data and the line is basically just to guide
you through and you can see 100 percent of occupation is basically at the HCP site, so
this is quite nice.
Now you keep on increasing the coverage and then you measure the XPS spectra and then
you can basically plot that intensity of the peak as a function of coverage and then you
can basically understand this and as you see here around 0.4 monolayer, yeah somewhere
around this 0.4 monolayer you see that I am starting to get basically the occupation of
the bridge site, yeah so that is the first thing, so you see basically it is branching
out and then clearly you see that the HCP site is going down, yeah so now this is a
systematic analysis.
Now as the coverage increases and then when you reach around let us say like 0.65, 0.55
to 0.6 monolayer you see basically the coverage of on top, the atop site is basically increasing
and definitely the HCP sites would go down and as you see when I reach a coverage of
about 0.6 monolayer you see in this particular case there is no occupation of the HCP site
and most of the molecules are actually occupying either at the bridge site or the on top site,
this is quite spectacular, so this is quite nice.
So you can basically understand, you can systematically understand what is going on at the interface
as a function of coverage, yeah as I told you always at the lower coverage HCP site
is the most favourable site and that is also an indication what is really the molecule
liking with respect to surface, yeah so that question is very obvious which is basically
the HCP or FCC site, yeah so that is something you can keep it in mind, so here when they
call it hollow site that is basically the HCP or FCC site, that is always the case.
But question is when you increase the coverage, so there comes the so-called molecule-molecule
interaction and the molecule-surface interaction and they start to now compete each other to
basically get into the most stable structure, so that is where you would finally find that
the bridge and the on top site is occupied and the HCP site is completely gone.
So let me just also show you the different type of structures that is basically assigned
a different coverage for this molecule on nickel 111 surface, so this is again indicated
by A here, A, B, C, D is basically the same as this one and you see at low coverage you
again have this root 3 by root 3 R30 degree structure that is exactly the same as that
you have seen also in the palladium 111 case, that is good, so you can see it clearly, so
this is the unit cell, so I am just taking a slightly different marker here, so this
is the unit cell, so you clearly see the unit cell, yeah so that is nice, so this is actually
a root 3 by root 3 R30 structure.
But now when you increase the coverage, so you basically starting to occupy the HCP and
also the bridge site, so that is these structures, so B and C are, B and C are structures that
are present in the intermediate coverage, yeah so there you can again see the unit cell
is marked again here, so this is an old paper 1998, that is why the figures are not that
good but it is a very beautiful paper explaining how things happens, so this is the 2 by 2
structure and then you can see here at moderate coverage I also have this occupation of the
top site, so this is basically you can see this occupation is at the top site and this
is the unit cell of the molecule and you can see I started to get already the top site
and also you can see this is nothing but the bridge site and this is the top site, yeah
so this is good.
And then when the coverage is basically increasing to higher coverage, so then you are getting
a completely new structure, so this is slightly different to what you have seen in the, in
the previous case, there you are basically seeing again occupation of the top site, so
that I am basically marking this unit cell with respect to the top site, so this is the
top site and then in between you can see here I have basically bridge site, so that means
as a coverage clearly increases to a very, very high coverage you only, only have the
occupation of the bridge site and the top site and that is exactly what you are seeing
and now you can see basically the density of the structure, yeah in the D, the case
D you see the density of the structure, so this is basically much, much more than what
you would basically expect compared to a low packing, so that means at the lower coverage
you basically have a very loose packed structure and as the coverage increases you basically
have a very high density structure, so that is the interesting thing.
Now with this you basically can make a nice analysis of the interface structure formation
of a molecular adsorbate on, on, on surface.
Now what I want to do is also to kind of summarise these two example and then to recap the energetics
that we have talked about, yeah, so that is something which we want to do, so in both
cases it is quite interesting, so both palladium and nickel 1, 1, 1 surface was structurally
they are same, so chemically there is a difference but the adsorbate is basically carbon monoxide,
so please excuse me for this, this is both carbon monoxide and not CO, cobalt.
So both carbon, carbon monoxide is basically adsorbing on these two different surface,
so now definitely we know that at low coverage both surfaces molecule is forming basically
the same type of structure, yeah, that is the root 3 by root 3 R 30 structure but when
the coverage increases you see it actually makes a too high density structure, so that
is the interesting aspect, yeah, so you make clearly a high density structure and the,
and also you started to see the occupation of the top side.
So now comes the question, so like let us look a little bit back into the energetics
that we have talked about, whenever we talk about the adsorption of a molecule on surface
we know that there are two major energy contribution that comes into picture at lower coverages
that is for sure, you have this particular periodic type of energetic that comes due
to the delta E inter and this is basically from the molecule surface interaction and
then you also have the other contribution that was looking like more or less like kind
of a potential, a mass potential and here again the energy is basically indicating something
like delta E inter, delta E intra that is about the molecule, molecule, so let us call
it like that molecule, molecule interaction and here it is molecule surface interaction,
so these are the two major energy contribution that is actually just playing a role and these
are the two which is basically calling to the so-called adsorption energy, so that is
something we have already talked about.
Now you see that whenever the coverage is very low, so we know that from the delta E
inter that all the molecule should basically be occupying this particular site that corresponding
to the lowest energy structure that is true, yeah and we know that somehow the top site
is not the most favourable because the adsorption energy at that particular site is not the
most stable one because it is actually having a lower coordination and that actually comply
with what we experimentally see but then the question is why is that the top site is
getting occupied when you basically increase the coverage, so that is of course something
that we have also talked about that whenever you have basically a surface and if you have
the carbon monoxide molecule coming together, let us call a few molecules this is indicating
a case of a very high coverage and now you see that they also start to basically repel
each other, so that would mean when the coverage is high you are not trying to basically just
keep the molecule at molecule-molecule interaction at this so-called minima instead you are probably
pushing the molecule to a position which is actually much closer than what they are allowed,
so in that case what would happen is that the molecule-molecule would start to basically also
repel, yeah so but whenever the coverage is very low so then most of the time you are basically
just you do not need to even consider the so-called delta E intra because the molecules are
too far away, so there you only have to consider this particular contribution but when the
concentration of the molecule increases you need to also consider basically the contribution from
the delta E intra because the molecule-molecule equilibrium distance is also very very important
in that case, so now you see that when you want to actually just occupy more molecule on the
surface now I need to make a compromise, so in that case it is not necessarily that you are
finally making this to be a thermodynamically stable structure, this is not thermodynamically
stable structure, yeah because you are definitely not letting the atoms to occupy in the most
favourable position, the most favourable positions are indeed these two positions,
so these are the most favourable position but you are probably trying to occupy the
molecule at this particular position, yeah or this particular position, so then of course you see that
energetically they are not very stable but there is something interesting that you also might have
noticed that in the XPS data that the energy corresponding to the top side was actually just
looking at a higher binding energy but just keep it in mind that is actually the binding energy
corresponding to the oxidation state of the molecule and that has nothing to do with the
energetics that we are talking here, so this is quite important but there it indicate that when
the molecules go on to the top side the carbon is basically much more oxidized, so most likely
the carbon is kind of giving away a lot of electron to the surface and therefore the carbon
is mostly kind of oxidized in that case, so that is probably is what is happening at the top side,
so that is probably the reason why you have a higher binding energy in the XPS top resonance
corresponding to the top side but that is not corresponding to the energy that we are talking
about here, yeah. So now let us just come back again to this particular case of molecule being
on the nickel 111 surface you also see that we have basically kind of a high density structure,
there also you can see your kind of trying to occupy the molecule inside into kind of
non-energetically very stable positions that is actually indicating that the coverage is
pushing it, so at the end of the day what I want to summarize here is that whenever you
actually just play with the adsorbate on the surface you can always form a thermodynamically
very stable, so this is a TD stable structure, yeah, so this is a thermodynamically stable
pattern and that is only occupied when you are actually able to provide so the so called minima
of both the energy contribution, yeah, but when the coverage is basically increasing you cannot
provide that because the molecules need to be put together and that is also why we are actually just
calling normally these kind of structures to be something like a kinetically controlled,
yeah, kinetic control because you can clearly see here the control parameter is the concentration,
yeah, so these are actually kind of kinetically controlled structure, so this is actually
possible, so now with what I have showed you in this example is that using XPS we
can basically determine a lot of chemical information about the adsorption of the
molecules on the surface and you can also look into the interesting details about the
molecular adsorbates, their adsorption position and things like that.
Now I want to take you to a little bit bigger example, so the bigger examples are this that
we want to look at the big molecules adsorbed on the surface and in this case the same example as
we have actually looked at in the UPS, this is that PTCDA molecule that is something I have
already told you it is a molecule that is being used in the organic molecule semiconducting
industry and here what you are looking at is actually the XPS data of the same molecule,
yeah, and it is also basically done from the same film, you remember that time we were also
just looking at the valence band structure, valence band electronic structure of the same
molecule of a 15 nanometer thick film and here what I am looking is basically of the same film
but I am doing the XPS that is actually to look how the molecules are interacting,
but that is the interesting thing, so UPS would basically tell me what is the electronic structure
of the valence band because that is quite important when you want to talk about the
transport property of the film but when you want to look at the chemical structure or how molecules
are interacting and so on, then you will have to actually just understand the XPS,
so what I am looking at is actually the oxygen 1S resonance of the 2 molecules,
one is slightly modified having a methyl group additional and that this 2 molecule and you
clearly see that I am expecting 2 type of oxygen in this which is actually a C double bond O oxygen
and then I also have a COC oxygen, yeah and as we have already discussed the COC oxygen is having
a higher binding energy that is something you expect and then you can also now assign their
energy and by looking at the energy shift compared to a molecule which is basically in
the gas phase you can kind of, not in the gas phase you can by just comparing a molecule which
is not in the film you can also basically compare what is the energy shift.
But you also see that in the case of dimethyl PTCDI, so you do have only one peak that is
corresponding to the C double bond O, so this is basically the C double bond O and there you
see just one resonance but now interesting thing is that this molecule both of them having a very
particular resonance which is marked here as a pi pi star resonance, so it is a new electronic
state that is coming up when the molecules are actually packing like in a stacked manner,
so the molecule is a planar molecule, so when you pack the molecule like above each other and
when they actually just grow like this, yeah or they would be basically growing like that but
whatsoever the packing is basically kind of a pi pi interaction then you would see these kind
of resonance which is very very particular when molecules are actually packing in this kind of
fashion, so this is quite something that you observe for molecules that are having large pi
electron cloud and when they interact like that you see this kind of resonance which is typically
an electronic state and this is a transition that happens between the pi to pi star.
So the interesting thing here is that both the molecules they are no true chemical bonds between
the molecule in the thin film itself but there is only some kind of weak pi pi interactions and that
is what you would basically find just due to the fact that you have this pi pi star kind of resonance
and that is an indication, so that is showing that both the molecules are actually just kind
of having a Van der Waals interaction through their pi pi electrons in the molecules, so this
is quite nice, so you can kind of understand what is going on in the molecular film in terms of
their interaction intermolecular interaction, so that is what you would gain in the XPS.
But now I can also do something interesting with this kind of molecular film what is in
this particular example I have chosen is that the same molecule but you take now the film and
then dope this film with magnesium, so that is like kind of a metal that you are adding inside
in order to kind of increase the transport property, I will show you in a greater detail
in an upcoming example something of this kind which is basically discussing about the importance
of doping in a molecular metal but this is not that important right now in the context but what
I want to show you here is that the magnesium concentration is basically increasing as you
increase the, as you go along this direction and what you are seeing is in the case of PTCDI,
so I would expect definitely 2 peaks that is corresponding to the COC oxygen and also the
carbonyl oxygen, so that is something I see but now when I increase the concentration of the
magnesium what you see clearly is after a certain coverage, so this is somewhat in terms of coverage
you have to see is that the COC resonance is almost absent and then the C double bond O resonance is
being actually shifted to a higher binding energy, so that is what your observation is.
So, this clearly indicate that the magnesium that you are doping must be going somewhere here,
yeah close to the COC oxygen and also to the carbonyl oxygen, so that means the magnesium
is somewhat getting coordinated to this particular position, so how do I see that? Because I see that
the resonance corresponding to the COC is almost vanished or may be shifted downwards and that is
what is written here with the O2 and also you can see the carbonyl peak is basically just getting
shifted also to the lower energy, so that means also this oxygen is getting a bit more oxidized
than its nascent state, yeah this is quite interesting. So, now with this kind of spectrum
I can clearly understand what is basically just going on at this kind of interface which is
basically where I am doping the magnesium into the film itself, yeah, so that means the molecules are
now getting partly connected by the magnesium atom, so this is quite interesting, you can also
do the same experiment with the dimethyl PTCDI, so there you also see something interesting but
quite different from what you have seen in the PTCDI case because you can see here the magnitude
of shift of the CO resonance in the case of PTCDI and the magnitude here is very, very, very small
that is indicating somewhat the magnesium is actually just going here but it is not as nicely
occupying to this space as you have seen in the case of the PTCDI, so that is actually due to
the fact that you have this bulky methyl group nearby, so the magnesium is not really going and
occupying there but of course what is happening is definitely at the site of oxygen, the magnesium is
somewhat interacting but the interaction is very, very weak because you can see the shift is very
small compared to this one because here the shift is basically very large, so you can read out from
the energy which is already giving you the bonding scheme inside, so this analysis eventually gives
me an indication about the bonding scheme of the molecular adsorbates inside the self-assembly
of the molecules. So, now in general, so what I have here is actually a thin film of the PTCDIs
and dimethyl PTCDI and what I have basically just done is I have added magnesium to dope basically
the surface, the film and then we have actually just looked at the way the magnesium is actually
interacting with the molecule, so you now see that with this technique XPS, you can basically
make a clear understanding about what is going on within the film, so in terms of the molecule-molecule
interaction, the molecule-surface interaction because that is also the reason why I have
discussed with you the case of carbon monoxide on different surfaces, you have seen there we can
even understand the interaction of the molecule with the surface and this is of course a case
where I am talking about a thicker film, therefore it is unimportant about the molecule-surface
influence that is also something we have actually also seen in the case of UPS,
if you recollect for this molecule, we have also done something like a thickness or the coverage
dependent, the thickness dependent experiment, there you already have seen that after about
a certain number of layers, you do not see anymore the influence of the surface,
so that is also something you have seen, so that means as a combination of UPS and XPS,
you can understand basically the entire valence band and also the core band,
so the valence band is important for us and to understand because that is the electrons
which is actually responsible for the reactivity of a molecule or when it comes to a charge
transport, those are the electrons that are basically going to be getting transported
because that is the one with the lower binding energy but the electrons that are lying deep
inside the core band is something which is also having that nice chemical information about how
the interaction between the molecules and also the interaction between the surface is going on,
yeah, so with XPS, we can therefore by looking at the oxidation state, we can clearly understand
the interface and also the chemical structure, so that is the thing about the photoelectron
spectroscopy, so with this lecture, I am trying to conclude the two photoelectron
spectroscopy methods and in the next lecture, we would be looking at the molecular material,
a 2-dimensional molecular material, I was planning to have that lecture in this but we will be
looking at in the next lecture, so there we would be also using again the same techniques but we
would be basically just using a combination of many techniques in order to clearly understand
the microscopic electronic chemical structure of molecular adsorbate on surface,
yeah, with this like, I like to conclude this lecture, thank you very much.
