Lecture 40 : Summary

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Dec 2, 2023
Hello everyone, welcome back to lecture number 40, well this is the concluding lecture, so
therefore we are going to take a summary of what we have done throughout in this course.
So what I am going to basically do is just go through one more time the most important
events that happened in the lecture and then would like to conclude the lecture.
So what we have started was basically just looking at the structure, the microscopic
structure of the surface and I also told you this is extremely important because now over
the time what you have seen is a structure of the surface which decides everything that
you want to do with the surface, its reactivity, its property, its electronic property, its
chemical nature, everything is basically just decided by the structure of the surface.
So therefore we have actually just spent quite some time on looking at the structure
of surfaces and we were focusing mostly on the FCC and BCC type of crystals but it is
not an issue you can now use this understanding in actually working out problems also related
to other surfaces of your choice.
So what we have actually just done is also to basically name surfaces and the name was
always related to the hkl index or the so called Miller index of a surface or a plane
given of a crystal and then we basically just named according to the plane through which
we cut the surface then we basically just name according to the plane through which
we cut the surface.
So that is basically what we have done and then we have also seen that depending on the
type of the structure or the type of the Miller index so being 1 0 0 or 1 1 0 or 1
1 1 surface they are going to get basically different shape and also in the previous lecture
you have also seen that this is also quite decisive in thinking about the reactivity
of the surface.
There we have learnt for example 1 1 0 and the 1 0 0 surfaces are much more stronger
in terms of their absorption compared to a 1 1 1 surface but well when you look at the
BCC 1 1 1 surface you see it is quite different that is also something you need to keep it
in mind that what is the type of crystal that you are looking at it is not just necessary
it is not just enough to conclude everything based on just the type of plane it is also
important to consider what is the type of crystal you are looking at whether it is an
FCC or whether it is a BCC and so on.
Then we also have looked at many different type of surface formation and then we also
have talked about so-called stepped surfaces when we used higher Miller indexes.
So when hkl values are bigger like in the order of 5 5 1 or 10 12 12 and so on so we
have looked at a few examples when the Miller index is high then we have also seen that
those surfaces could actually be also more corrugated.
So that means the surface roughness of the corrugation is also going to be dependent
on the surfaces yeah well that is what we have done and then we also have looked at
the typical Bravais lattice what we are interested is the 2 dimensional Bravais lattice.
So we have said it is typically 5 everything that you want to address the symmetry of the
surface can basically be just put under this 5 symmetry groups P2, P2mm, P6mm, C2mm and
P4mm yeah.
So they are basically just nothing but the oblique, rectangular, hexagonal, square and
centered rectangular yeah so these are the point groups where the number is basically
representing the symmetry so it is a 2 fold, 6 fold, 4 fold and so on and m and m these
are actually representing the number of mirror planes and the C is basically representing
whether you have something in the middle of the unit cell and that is called centered
and P depict basically the primitive cell yeah so that is basically something we have
done.
Now then we also have said that well although we can basically just look at an ideal surface
as we just cut a surface from the bulk it is not necessary that you are going to get
the surface as it is like you predict.
There is something called reconstruction on surface things are actually not simply stable
because you have low coordination on the surface yeah so the number of coordination so if I
would draw a line here you directly see a 4 coordination for the bulk but you can see
here I have basically 3 coordination so that means it is actually having something known
as dangling bones or low coordination site.
So whenever there is a low coordination the surface energy is very high and therefore
the surface atoms start to move around most of the time what they do is actually they
pair up in order to increase the strength of interaction and also they sometime get
retracted towards the bulk so that the strength of the interaction at the surface is actually
increased but you also sometime get something called a missing row reconstruction so we
looked at that particularly in the case of 1 1 0 surfaces we have also looked at 2 examples
then we see basically they can also have missing row reconstruction so ideally having more
atoms coming together and the most unstable atom that would come here which is basically
not present there yeah so that is what ideally happening.
So that is also something we have looked at and then we looked at a particularly a few
very complex reconstruction although it was looking very complex in the beginning of the
lecture later we have understood the philosophy of reconstruction is very simple that surface
always want to minimize the number of surface atoms that is the philosophy of the reconstruction
so always the surface depending on the material structure whatsoever the surface would decide
by itself you cannot basically decide what reconstruction you want to have so that is
basically why surface is always the choice of evil and not of the good.
So you see basically that the surface is basically deciding how many number of surface
atoms it should have like particularly in the case of a silicon 1 1 1 7 by 7 reconstruction
you ideally end up in just 12 surface atoms instead of the expected 46 or 48 something
calculation we have done that time so you can see basically it is reduced by about 25% is just
remaining every atoms is basically moved into the bulk or they rearrange in a way that you get a lot
of interesting type of atoms so then we said like we have this so called add atom, rest atom,
dimer atom and so on the philosophy is still to increase the coordination and minimize the
number of surface atoms on the surface. Well so this example particularly we have
focused a lot so we have also seen indeed the microscopic structure as you see here in STM
we have looked at the microscopic structure we have also looked at the electronic structure
particularly of this kind of a surface. And then we have learned something called
ultra high vacuum because I told you this ultra high vacuum is something quite important in
surface science because we want to understand the surface at a microscopic level it is important to
prepare something very clean yeah otherwise we are going to end up in understanding something
which is extremely difficult so like any surface that you take is quite complex so therefore it
is quite important that we prepare a clean atomically flat or atomically precise surface
so that we know what we are really doing it. So therefore we said that ultra high vacuum
is basically an important component in surface science and we have learned how to prepare or
how to generate vacuum and this is a typical example and using that ultra high vacuum or
most of the example that we have discussed was actually in ultra high vacuum but of course we
have also seen that we can prepare interfaces even outside in terms of the applications and
things like you cannot all the time afford ultra high vacuum technology therefore there
are also technique where you can actually prepare things in ambient condition so that is another
aspect of it but if you want to study the surface in a microscopic level in an atomic precision then
ultra high vacuum is actually kind of an important component. So then using that ultra high vacuum
we have learned about the different methodologies that you can use for cleaning the surfaces by
simple cleaving, annealing, sputtering and so on then we have also learned that how to prepare
hard layer or interfaces. So we have learned mainly two different type of methods one is
a physical vapour deposition and the other one was basically a chemical vapour deposition.
So both method has its own advantage and disadvantage so chemical vapour deposition
is something that you can think about when you want to prepare something much more bulkier or
much more larger scale but physical vapour deposition is a bit more expensive because
most of the time this is done in an ultra high vacuum or in a high vacuum chamber therefore
these techniques are more expensive but of course this is very very important if you want to generate
something with a low impurity and high precision and so on. What we have done is we have started
looking at the microscopic structure of add layer or over layer or interface they are all the same
so people call it in different names then what we have particularly looked at was the adsorption
sides and the relative reactivity. So we have already talked about that whenever an adsorbate
goes they will always try to go on a so called hollow side because it has the highest coordination
number possible and then once you have the adsorbate so this is basically the adsorbate
that is taking on the surface and then based on the arrangement of the adsorbate on the surface
we can basically just define the unit cell and that unit cell also comes under the same
two-dimensional Bravais lattice and looking at that we could also just name or so called
the nomenclature of the add layer was also done using two different methodologies Woods notation
or matrix notation, metric notation is more a mathematical representation a more correct
representation which includes even the symmetry of the add layer and then so on.
But then we also said well it is not necessary that all the time atoms are actually sticking
at this tame preferred position you can also have atoms that are sticking at odd positions
like this. So then what we have seen is that over a larger area so they are going to make
something known as a super lattice this is actually just something that we have learnt
that variety of adsorption side for the adsorbates but you can basically see at the end of the
day there is always a unit cell that defines the adsorbate add layer and that unit cell
is always represented with respect to the substrate lattice and that is why we call
this particular case this as the unit cell. So you can also just call this as the unit
cell that is no problem because you need to have always the corner atoms of the unit cell
to be at the identical adsorption site. Then you can basically define the unit cell
and this would be just the primitive cell but that is not really representing the entire thing
because the surface is always included particularly in the interface.
So therefore you need to represent everything using the surface lattice as well. So that is
what we have learnt basically and then we have looked at the most important thing so that is
the energies or the energetics of the adsorption itself. We said when the adsorbate is actually
having a very low concentration then we need to only worry about the interaction of the adsorbate
atom or it is also the same for molecules we have also seen that the adsorbate atom and the
surface interaction. So at lower coverage it is only enough to understand everything in terms of
the adsorbate surface interaction. You do not need to worry about the so called adsorbate
adsorbate interaction but as the coverage increases there is one more component coming
that is basically the adsorbate adsorbate interaction and then we finally said that
the total adsorption energy is going to depend on both these parameters called the e intra and
e inter. So this is actually a term that we have used it is not necessary that you have to always
follow this particular term you can choose any terminology as you like and then we said that
this so called difference in energy the sum of these two energies are basically going to decide
what is the total adsorption energy of the adsorbate on the surface.
But then we also said that it is not necessary that all the time that adsorbate adsorbate atom
interaction is coming at the minima here and also the adsorbate surface interaction is coming at
the minima here it is not necessary that you always have the adsorbate sitting here but you
can also have adsorbate sitting at different location like adsorbate can sit here for example
or adsorbate can sit here or adsorbate can sit here or adsorbate can sit here and so on.
So it is basically let me just use a slightly different color so you can have adsorbate
sitting here adsorbate sitting here then you can have adsorbate sitting here and you can have
adsorbate sitting here so it is always the different possible combinations that you have
to take into account and then you clearly see that there is always a minimum value for both
of them but then you see that sometime it is basically positively affecting one value and
in some other hand it is basically negatively affecting depending on where in the potential
energy diagram the atoms are adsorbing. So that means of course the total potential
energy surface that is given to the add atom or molecule to adsorb on the surface and it
actually has a big choice and that actually going to be important particularly when you
go to a higher coverage so that is something what we have to also see because you will
suddenly find that you might need to press the atoms together in order to accommodate
more atoms or sometime you would find that the atoms are actually just stretched apart
than the normal equilibrium distance and so on.
So that is also where we have actually just learned two more important components known
as the E-strain and E-dislocation this is particularly important when you consider
the growth of add layer and the growth of multi layer typically. So there for example we need to
consider all the time of course I told you that E-strain is really related to this one so they
are kind of connected basically but as the coverage increases or as the layer thickness
increases this E-strain and E-dislocation is going to basically just come into a larger
picture inside the system. Now we have also learned that we can basically also understand
so effectively it is not possible to understand all these different energy components separately
experimentally that is not possible but theoretically it may be possible but nonetheless
the so-called final adsorption energy can actually be calculated or can be experimentally determined
using thermal desorption spectroscopy yeah so that is something we have actually just said
we can so-called heat the surface and then let the adsorbate to desorb and then using a mass
spectrometer we can basically detect the amount of adsorbates coming out of the surface as a
function of time we can basically measure that and using that we can actually calculate the
adsorption energy. So this is something very commonly used in surface science in order to
understand the energies that controls the growth of add layer or in typical the adsorption energy
of the add layers and then we have also learned that these are the energies that is also going
to kind of control the type of growth modes yeah and particularly for atom like adsorbates we have
seen that there are three different type of growth which is basically one so-called layer by layer
growth another one which is like an island type of growth and another one which is actually a layer
first the so-called wetting layer and then an island formation.
So there were three different type of growth modes and then we have also discussed the
factors that controlling these growth modes they are really related to the energies so
that is also no surprise for sure and this is basically controlled by the energy so that is
something that we have also spent quite some time during the lectures and I would encourage you to
have a specific understanding on that because this is the most important part of the lecture
or in general the surface science aspect if you want to consider for the adsorption of
atoms and their growth and so on. Good and then what we have also looked was
the adsorption of molecular adsorbate so this was actually something we have looked at was a
phthalocyanin molecule and then I also told that using the same molecular beam epitaxy
yeah so using the same molecular beam epitaxy we can actually just perform something known
as organic molecular beam epitaxy and then we can prepare these kind of very nice and
uniform ad layers of molecules so you are not only just can make just one layer you can of
course depending on the coverage you can basically make many many layers on top of
each other so but you can of course investigate nicely and this is a low temperature scanning
tunneling microscopy image and you can clearly see the molecular adsorbates on the surface.
Now when it come to the molecule we also said in the energetics there is one important parameter
that you have to consider which is actually the so called symmetry of the molecule because that
is something you do not need to consider when you have an add atom or an atom like adsorbates
or small atom like molecules yeah so we also looked at a few example of carbon monoxide and
let us say oxygen or whatsoever there it is not important but for bigger molecule you can see
that this is actually the way the molecules are finally arranging and then we said that
the symmetry of the molecule is quite important and the symmetry of the molecule is going to
quite control the adsorption and also the final adsorption geometry or the final ad layer structure
yeah and then we also said that for the molecule particularly since they are larger the so called
adsorption geometry with respect to surface is quite important therefore there is also possibility
of having variety of adsorption geometry with respect to surface yeah so all those additional
factors need to be also considered in the case of molecular adsorbates and the outcome basically
was that we said that when you work with molecular adsorbate there is more possible ways that you
can basically arrange the atoms on the surface that is the interesting aspect that we have
looked at on the surface. Well then what we have done towards the end of the lectures what we have
also done was actually familiarizing a few experimental techniques with that we can
understand the microscopic structure because it is important that I want to see what is happening on
the surface so then I need a microscopy and I need a microscopy that actually can reach atomic
resolution yeah or a resolution down to the scale of atoms so that I can look at the process that
is happening on the surface at an atomic scale so this is quite quite important and that is where
we have learned this so called scanning probe microscopy it is a general classification there
are many scanning probe microscopy what we have focused was actually the scanning tunneling
microscopy in general known as STM and atomic force microscopy and in the atomic force microscopy we
have also seen a two additional variation known as the electrical force microscopy and the magnetic
force microscopy but then when you looked at the STM images itself it turns out to be that you are
not looking at the structure of the adsorbates you are instead looking at something called the
electronic electron density for example yeah you are looking at the electron density corresponding
to a certain molecular orbitals yeah so that is the interesting thing so what you are looking at
that electron density near the surface of a given adsorbate of a molecule it was particularly
interesting because we have seen that by selectively deciding or selecting the voltage
at which you do the experiment you can even basically see the LUMO or HOMO of the molecule
yeah so this is something you have seen or even the LUMO plus 1 or the HOMO minus 1 and so on yeah
but in the AFM what we have seen that we can reach ultimate resolution so this is again the
pentacene molecule so we could basically see the nice hexagons of the of the pentacene so
this is basically beautiful so that we can finally see the molecule as we wished this
is something interesting we have also seen that this is something to do also with the electron
density that is spread on the molecule so we are basically looking at something like that
but nonetheless at the end of the day this is actually an image that is giving you the
skeleton of the molecule so this is beautiful well we have also said that this is very specific or
very special kind of microscopy that is not something you are going to apply to everything
because it is an expensive technique to do because you are doing everything in an ultra
high vacuum using a low temperature STM AFM and also everything is done at an extremely
molecular level yeah but when it come to the to the application so looking at bulk material so
like let us say thin films of more layers and so on or if you want to collectively understand the
electronic property of materials then we said well microscopy is good to some extent but then
it is also sometime better to go to something like atomic force microscopy because that gives
you a little bit more global picture but you can actually also kind of characterize the microscopic
structure of the surface but well at the end of the day every technique has its own advantage
and disadvantage and scanning tunneling microscopy and the so called specialized
atomic force microscopy was actually the technique that we said can actually go down
to atomic resolution and resolve things at this scale well then we said well if I am really
interested in looking at the global electronic structure so then I can also just use techniques
like ultraviolet photoelectron spectroscopy or X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy so these both
techniques are working based on the photoelectric effect where you shine your material with a given
photon it could be like a UV photon or X-ray photon then you kick some electrons out of the
band or some core level so if you are basically removing the electrons from the valence band you
you can do that using just ultraviolet photons then what we are going to basically understand
is actually the density of state of the valence band so this is quite important because I told
you we need to know the electronic property particularly near the Fermi energy and that
is what is deciding the property of the molecules or property of the adsorbates or the surface or
whatsoever that defines really the reactivity the chemical property everything is decided
by the electronic structure itself but then we also looked at something called X-ray photoelectron
spectroscopy where you shine actually with the higher energy photon and then you are kicking
electrons from the core level which is extremely sensitive to the bonding nature of that atom or
the so-called oxidation state of that particular atom or the element that we are looking at and we
have of course taken a few case studies very specifically and we have actually just seen
that we can clearly clearly understand what is happening or what is the chemical nature
of a given element that we are interested in yeah so that is that was it.
Then I also just showed you that we can combine something called an inverse
photoelectron spectroscopy inverse photoelectron spectroscopy where instead of you shine photon
you actually inject electron into the system and then you look at the photon coming out of it and
then you can combine basically those two techniques UPS and inverse photoelectron
spectroscopy and then you can clearly get the complete electronic structure of the surface
or interface or thin films or so whatsoever you like yeah this is quite important because I can
basically know the band gap yeah so this is basically the band gap e.g. I can note relatively
the conduction band edge the valence band edge I know the density of state and so on yeah so this
is quite important so therefore we have actually just used and we also have used a combination of
XPS, AFM, STM and so on in understanding collectively for a few cases to understand
clearly how to apply these techniques in general. Well with that I come to the acknowledgement I
would like to mention the name of these people who have also contributed partly to these lectures
Dr. Prithvi Savha, Dr. Kushpu Yadav, Dr. Vipin Mishra these are also students who graduated
from my research group they have contributed partly to this lecture in terms of the research
components that I have used in the lecture and then also my current students Ms. Himani Malik,
Ms. Richa Arjaria, Mr. Hariyom Birla, Ms. Diksha Srivastava and Mr. Sunny Gautam.
So these are my current PhD students who are also helping me in in doing this lecture and
I also would like to thank the financial support from the Department of Science and Technology,
Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology, Government of India because
their money has been used in doing a lot of research that we do in the in the lab
and those components has been also shared with you in this lecture and I would also
like to finally thank you very much for choosing this particular subject.
This is of course an interesting subject which also has quite some fundamental importance and
also quite in the modern technology it also has a greater importance so therefore I thank you
very much for choosing this subject and also thought of popularizing my lecture.
I would like to thank you very much for your kind attention and looking forward
to also work with you in the during the tutorial and also during the evaluation time.
Thank you very much.
