Lecture 40 (Part 1)

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Oct 23, 2023
Welcome back to the course Corrosion Protection Methods, we are going to start lecture 14
and today we are starting a new topic which is based on Coatings and Associated Corrosion
Protection.
Now, if we look around us, we will see that coatings are everywhere almost everywhere.
Now, let us start with our households, if we see kitchen wares those are coated, if
we see our grills, window grills those are coated.
Now, if we see ACs, air conditions, if we see fans, almost everything is coated.
Now, some of the cases those coatings are done not to protect that material from corrosion.
For example, if we talk about coatings on beds, wooden beds or wooden chairs or something
like that.
So, those time we put we put a coating on top of it which is a paint.
Now, that paint is given just to protect those wood from getting attacked by termite.
So, but some of the cases for example, kitchen ware, let us say grill we paint the primary
the purpose is to protect it from getting degraded or protect it from corrosion because
if they will form rusting.
So, that rust avoidance we need to put coating.
Now, there is one more purpose for that coating.
So, sometimes we have to also improve the aesthetics, it should look good.
So, that is a purpose which is which sometimes becomes the primary reason, but it is actually
the protection of that grill material or fan material from getting corroded.
Now, if we go out and then look at other substances for example, automobile starting from a bike
from cycle, bicycle to cars to buses to trains everywhere we put coatings.
Now, come to transports for example, concrete.
In the concrete we use rebars, some of the rebars are coated like epoxy coated rebars
are available.
So, those coating actually protects the material, protects the rebar before it gets installed
in the concrete that means, let us say one set of rebar is actually getting transported
from one end to another end, that time if we have some sort of coating then definitely
it will not corrode during the transport fine.
At the same time when we put that epoxy coated rebar, there would be definitely flaws, those
flaws are called holidays and we will talk about that holiday.
So, those are some of the breaks in the coating and that break point where material is getting
exposed to the concrete.
So, those are the point of severe attack.
But if we use cathodic protection like sacrificial anode or impressed current cathodic protection
that time the total current requirement goes down.
Because as we have seen earlier cases in case of inhibitors, we have seen that if we use
sorry in case of earlier cases for example, in case of cathodic protection using sacrificial
anode, we have seen that in case of bare pipe, we need higher current or higher current output
from the sacrificial anode and if we use coated pipe that time we use we need a less current
output from the anode.
So the current output or the current requirement to protect that particular material if it
is coated rebar reduces to a great extent.
So there we also find coating.
Now if we talk about railroads fine, there also people do use coating because the varnish
for example, if we consider fish plates, in the fish plates region we do experience one
particular type of corrosion process where wear is also involved that is called fretting
corrosion near the fish plate where you have two plates which are fixing two joints, two
rails which are getting joined that means those are basically held together by the fish
plate.
So there we can experience fretting attack.
So if you put if we put lot of grease material over there that actually acts as a coating
because that avoids contact or that prevents moisture or oxygen to get in touch with the
metal or the steel.
This is one part.
Another thing is that that grease material also reduces the coefficient of friction.
So if friction reduces so that means the wear tendency will reduce.
So here that coating is actually serving two purpose, one is it reduces the coefficient
of friction, at the same time it provides a kind of barrier to the environmental corrosive
agents like oxygen, H2O.
Now if you come to aerospace, we have coated structures for example, if we talk about turbine
blades where we do use thermal barrier coatings like yttria stabilized zirconia fine.
So that particular coating helps preventing high temperature oxidation or high temperature
corrosion of the turbine blades.
Now we can also use stellite coating okay.
For example, in case of internal combustion engine, we do use stellite coating.
The stellite coating is nothing but the cobalt based alloys okay where we can also add little
bit of tungsten or molybdenum to improve its wear resistance.
Now stellite coating can also be used when we use a hard facing.
Now the purpose of the coating there mainly to serve wear resistance, a very high wear
resistance but stellite coating also provides a very good corrosion resistance.
Now you see many of those examples what we are seeing, coating does not only provide
one particular purpose, it is used for multipurpose applications.
For example, one such example let us say zinc coating on iron okay.
If we put zinc coating, it looks a bright white color fine that gives you a kind of
aesthetic but zinc coating provides one particular advantages, it does not expose the steel to
the environment.
Now if by chance there is some points where there is a scratch, so the underlying steel
surface is exposed.
Now since it is a zinc coating, galvanization is mainly zinc coating that zinc acts as a
sacrificial anode to the underlying steel.
So zinc would dissolve and the portion of the steel which is exposed to the environment
that particular segment will act as cathode and it will get protected due to a cathodic
protection fine provided by the sacrificial nature of zinc.
So this is that means there it has two advantage, one is of course it is acting like a barrier
and at the same time it is also giving sacrificial protection fine.
Now if we talk about let us say a nickel coating fine, nickel coating is basically nickel coating
on let us say a steel.
So now that nickel coating will be acting as a cathodic to the underlying steel surface
but if we put nickel and on top of nickel you can also use chrome coating.
So that will give you a very excellent corrosion resistance provided that particular surface
does not get peeled off or does not get scratched off.
So if the underlying steel is exposed to the environment then those cathodic those
are called cathodic coatings because that particular coating material is cathodic compared
to steel in that environmental conditions.
So that case only purpose is that particular coating purpose is it gives you a barrier
protection because it does not allow the environmental species like water, oxygen to get in touch
with steel.
So it will not provide you sacrificial effect.
Copper coating on steel for example some of the electrodes for example when we talk when
we talk about welding sometimes that coated material that particular steel material is
coated with copper.
So that coated steel electrodes are used.
So this copper also gives you a protection around it and the purpose is different but
it is coated.
It also protect it from corrosion provided it does not get exposed.
So the purpose of copper coated steel this is not part of our discussion but it people
do use a copper coated steel rod or steel wire for welding.
So that means we could see that coating has different purpose but our discussion will
concentrate on the corrosion protection part of it.
So if we talk about the purpose of discussion or the scope of discussion for our case okay
this is mainly first is it should cover up metal surface and provide a barrier to environment.
This environment could be gaseous environment.
This environment could be electrolyte aqueous environment.
This environment could be chemical environment some toxic chemical environment.
So this barrier to the environment and while providing the barrier so that means it does
not allow those chemicals or environment to get in contact with the metal surface.
So this gives you a very good corrosion resistance fine.
Now when we talk about barrier this barrier can serve different way for example it can
provide excellent resistance to diffusion of species like chlorine, chlorine ion or
hydrogen fine.
If it provides resistance to corrosive agent definitely so these particular agent for example
Cl- it may not participate in the electrochemical process but it can actually break the passive
layer on the metal surface.
So it can act negative to the passivity of the metal surface.
So that way it can expose the metal surface and continuous dissolution can happen.
Hydrogen can lead to hydrogen embrittlement.
Hydrogen embrittlement it can provide.
So if we stop diffusion of hydrogen by putting a barrier then definitely it can that particular
material will be safe from hydrogen embrittlement and this is actually lead to this hydrogen
embrittlement can lead to a catastrophic failure.
This is one.
It can also resist or it can also act as a passivating agent.
Sometimes the paints are actually impregnated with inhibitors which can actually passivate
the surface.
So when one can make the surface passive as we have seen in case of while discussing inhibitor
it can actually give, it can actually provide good amount of corrosion resistance.
Now this can also provide resistance to charge flow.
So now this coating for example if you have a, this is the metal surface and this is the
coating what you are using, let us say this is my coating region.
So this coating can act as a capacitor and then provide a kind of and also it will also
provide resistance path R to the charge flow okay.
So this resistance if it is providing very high resistance definitely it will give a
very good corrosion protection.
Now consider some ceramic coating that ceramic provides good amount of resistance to the
flow of either positive charge or negative charge because there the flow of charge happens
by, there are two segments one is p-type or n-type, one is through the flow of electron
or the positive charges.
So if we have resistance to the charge flow definitely it will increase the corrosion
resistance.
Now when we talk about a barrier it can also provide some sort of added advantage like
erosion protection, erosion corrosion resistance.
Let us say that the coating is very hard so hard means hard coating definitely the erosion
resistance go up because it will increase wear resistance but at the same time that
coating can also provide good amount of corrosion resistance.
So it again serves two purposes.
Now when we talk about hard surface it can also give a good amount of cavitation resistance
okay.
So that cavitation resistance also improves because of that hard surface.
Why cavitation corrosion happens or cavitation erosion happens?
Because you have a collapse of bubble due to the pressure difference and that bubble
collapse can lead to a shock waves to the metal surface and that shock wave can have
a deformation and those deformation zone can get extra bit of corrosion because we
know that whenever the metal surface is getting deformed dislocations are created and those
dislocation creation can lead to active improve increased activation of that particular segment.
So that will act like a local anode and it will dissolve.
So if we have a hard surface if the resistance to the shock wave that can be improved definitely
it will improve cavitation resistance and cavitation falls under erosion corrosion field.
So this is one such possibility that means it provides both the effects wear resistance
as well as corrosion resistance.
Now come to some other segments like if we talk about watches okay.
So the watches they are sometime gold coated okay.
So it actually improves the corrosion resistance but at the same time it actually improves
the aesthetic so that means look good okay.
So that is another purpose of gold coating.
So now when we talk about watches we actually wear them and when we have sweat the sweat
contains lot of salt.
So that means that salt containing solution can have a huge corrosion tendencies.
So if we have gold coating definitely it can resist that corrosion huge corrosive ability
of that particular sweat solution fine.
So these are I have just pointed some of the aspects that what it does when it provides
the barrier.
Now apart from barrier it can also serve as a sacrificial effect okay.
So this falls under anodic coating we will talk about that.
Sometimes we do use coating and then we go for cathodic protection and this cathodic
protection could be either ICCP which is impressed current cathodic protection or sacrificial.
Now if we have coating on that material let us say pipeline then the total current requirement
for the protection will be decided by the break that breaks that are there in the coating.
If we let us say this is a pipeline on top of it we have a coating fine.
So this is a kind of a break which is called holiday fine.
So this now question is how to protect this segment for that we have to send current as
we know that when current enters to the metal surface through the electrolyte that segment
is getting protected.
So here current enters so the total current requirement will be very low and the sacrificial
anode will operate for a longer duration or if you want to use ICCP the total current
requirement would be very low.
But still the material would get protected from the corrosion abilities of the surrounding
atmosphere where the pipe is placed.
So this is another purpose it can serve.
Now we can also have different other purpose like let us say turbine blades.
So this turbine blades operate at a high temperature.
So thus whenever we talk about high temperature we have to handle gaseous environment.
Now during that particular environment the major problem becomes oxidation and the second
part is hot corrosion because when that fuel is getting burned there could be possibility
of salt creation on salt deposition or salt environment there high temperature salt.
So there this particular would lead to hot corrosion and oxidation definitely we are
actually burning oxygen.
So that oxygen can lead to a serious oxidation on the surface.
So that time an oxidation we know that it is a corrosion process because when we talk
about oxidation okay so now if we consider a metal surface this is the oxide surface
oxide layer and let us say this is oxygen.
Now for whether this is corrosion or not for that we need to see whether there are four
components that are needed for corrosion.
What are those four components?
One is cathode where cathodic reaction happens anode where anodic reaction happens then electrolyte
and the fourth one is conductor.
In one of the circumstances that oxygen the metal would dissolve like this let us say
2 electron 2 plus and this 2 electron would move through the other surface which is oxide
gas interface.
So their oxygen can take 2 electron and then form O2 minus.
Now this metal ion which is forming at this interface that can diffuse out through the
oxide layer and then connect with O2 minus it can form MO which is the oxide layer or
oxygen can this particular species O2 minus this can also diffuse in and here M2 plus
can react with O2 minus and then form MO.
Now you see this is my cathodic reaction so this is this becomes my cathode here we are
having anodic reaction this surface becomes my anode and electron is flowing through the
oxide so it becomes oxide becomes conductor for the charge.
At the same time we are seeing that the metal metal ion is moving or diffusing through the
oxide so that means oxide is also acting like an electrolyte.
So now you see we have all four components so this can also be considered as corrosion.
So if we prevent oxidation we are actually preventing corrosion.
So turbine blade we use thermal barrier coating so these are mainly ceramic material oxides
like yttria stabilized zirconium.
So where we have we add around 8% of Y2O3 in ZrO2 it actually stabilizes the high temperature
phase and that is what you can get very good oxidation resistance which are exceeding to
the turbine blade.
And turbine blade what are the metal generally nickel aluminum alloys they are made nickel
aluminum titanium nickel titanium those are the alloys costly alloys which are used for
turbine blade making.
So that means if we have this particular coating this turbine blade can operate at a higher
temperature.
Now this is one such classical example that it can also provide barrier to the oxidizing
agents whether it is oxygen or moisture or CO2 it can provide a barrier.
So when it provides barrier the functionality becomes multi ways that functionality can
be served for example one case it can provide wear resistance one case it can provide oxidation
resistance aqueous electrolyte corrosion resistance or even chemical resistance.
For example we can have a glass coating or say or we can say cement coating so that time
this glass coating this is very important when we talk about using container for chemical
process of processing equipment let us say a very strongly strong corrosive agents corrosive
gases we if you want to hold it chemical reactor.
So there the outer surface definitely it is steel made of steel but the inner surface
we coat with the many times they are coated with glass and glass has a very very high
corrosion resistance it can prevent it can act as a very good barrier to the environment.
Now question is when we use that so this glass is brittle isn't it?
So when we have a brittle coating there we should be careful that there is a very little
impact on that metal on that particular coated surface.
So if it breaks then it can go away in no time because the corrosive effect of those
chemicals would be very strong.
So the chemical reactor we make glass coated reactor fine so this is one such example that
we make use of something with a purpose that it should provide very good corrosion resistant
or chemical attack resistance but at the same time we should also see that what are the
conditions at which in what are the condition for which this particular glass coating will
be will be will serve the purpose of protection.
So similarly cement coating also is brittle but if we don't have any impact then cement
coating can work for a longer duration and it can give a very good corrosion resistance
like that way if you see that every time it gives you a barrier protection but at the
same time we have to also consider some other factors okay like it should have a quite good
amount of strength it should be impervious to some of the species going through the particular
barrier layer on to the metal surface and then at the same time it should provide good
amount of resistance to charge flow it should provide good amount of resistance to the diffusion
of species.
So then it will act a fantastic barrier to corrosion protection.
Now so that means we could see that we have to also make sure that that the coating or
the barrier if it is active as a barrier then it must have must have some of the basic
properties what are those basic properties let us look into that basic properties.
Now when we talk about basic properties it should have high degree of adhesion that means
if we have a coating on a metal surface that particular coating should have a good bonding
with the metal surface.
So if the bonding is poor then definitely it will peel off or it can get removed from
the metal surface and disjoint from the metal surface then the purpose of coating is lost.
So it should have a very good bonding with the metal surface and depending on the purpose
or depending on the applicability we should use for example if we want to use some coating
where a serious abrasion is possible like let us say there we cannot use paint or the
paint can get removed quickly.
So there we have to use metallic coatings or ceramic coatings I am just giving one example.
So if you if you have heard about deck plates so deck plates are basically a huge metal
plates on top of which we have movement of conveyor belt and in the industrial scale
conveyor belt they are used for carrying coal, carrying sinter material.
Now those particular belt material they are actually it is basically getting supported
by the deck plates.
Now deck plate region is very dirty because it is open in environment now coals are falling
coal powders are falling on that there are lot of dust as well as if it is a rainy season
lot of rain falls on that particular deck plates.
Now if deck plate is to be protected from and the corrosion as well as wear is very
both are very severe in case of deck plate.
Now if we would like to protect that deck plate the better way to protect is not by
painting by using some coating which will be resistance to wear as well as corrosion.
So one of the better ways to protect is by putting some metallic coating which can serve
both the purposes.
Now so that metallic coating should have a very good bonding with the steel surface because
deck plates are made of steels.
Now for that generally the technique that can be used is basically HPOF there are techniques
HPOF high velocity oxy-fuel coating or APS atmospheric spray coating where that metal
powders which are to be coated on the steel those are forced and impinged on the metal
surface at a high temperature.
So that high temperature will fuse those metal particles and then those get attached to the
metal surface.
So we will show one such example for example if we talk about then okay fine.
When we talk about adhesion we should also talk about interface.
Interface between metal substrate and coating.
So that interface we should look at very critically so that adhesion is improved.
Now we will talk about more on this particular property.
Then we can think of another property it should have high degree of compactness.
So what does it mean?
That means it should have very little porosity or no porosity or very little porosity.
This porosity can actually take the electrolyte to the surface of the metal okay.
So that means it is better to have no porosity.
It should have quite a lot of strength good strength or we can talk about hardness and
if it is malleable so that is better okay or we can say a bit of ductility instead
of malleable we can use deformability.
At times there could be a bending load on to the coating.
So during that it should not get dislodged from the surface.
So that is why good strength hardness I am just giving one example hardness it can be
in terms of high degree of high level of tensile strength that is also a very effective as
well as if it has a good fairly fair amount of deformability.
So it should not get broken during the bending loading okay.
So this is a good strength.
Then definitely it should have a very high degree of resistance to diffusing species.
For example hydrogen or chlorine ion will have example for that fine.
Now third part is it must cover of surface completely as well as uniformly.
Now if we have a surface like this if the coating surface is wavy like this that is
not good because whenever you have a wavy pattern let us say it is sitting with another
it is attached to another plane this particular segment are vulnerable for breakage okay that
is not good.
At the same time if you have a coating surface if the coating is like this some region it
is thin some region it is thick then this region if there is a every chance that this
region can have a kind of a break or removal of that coating and then this surface is exposed.
So that means it should cover up completely and at the same time it should be uniform
thickness and that thickness when you talk about uniformity it should be fairly thick
okay at the same time it should not be thick if see this thickness of this coating will
be decided by the cost, cost of the coating material as well as process.
For example if we talk about galvanization that galvanization can be possible by doing
dip in the zinc bath you just dip the steels sheet metal that will be coated there could
be another process that sheet material or the particular part if we have to have zinc
coating we can also go for electro deposition.
So electro deposition generally the coating thickness will keep it at a lower end but
in case of other coating methods like HBF or APS coating or atmospheric plasma spray
we go to a fairly thick coating okay it is decided by what is the need of that coating
what or what is the purpose that coating has to serve and what is the what is the process
that we follow at the same time cost of the coating material.
Let us say gold coating on watches we that coating thickness hardly it goes to few angstrom
okay maybe 0.1 or 0.2 micrometer at the most okay.
So that means gold is very costly so the gold purpose is to give a protection okay at the
same time it gives a very good look and it also gives you a kind of protection means
towards the protection against the sweat solution okay.
So this is cost and process that will decide as well as the purpose those will decide the
application of that thickness application of the coating up to what thickness we wanted
fine.
Now coming to this interface the interface we look at separately if the interface is
smooth it is it is considered to be better but if the interface is rough there could
be a possibility of pore formation along those interfaces.
Now you consider that pore formation happens a pore formation is taking place along the
interface if there is a kind of a thermal loading this pore can actually expand and
there could be a possibility of peel off.
So we have to look at interface separately.
Now coming to any other aspects like long life so that coating should give a very good
protection for a longer duration long life at the same time ease of repair at the same
time when we talk about repair it should come up with maintenance fine it should provide
long life ease of repair that means if there is a breakage we should immediately we should
be able to immediately recoat it okay.
For example if we talk about dent or the scratch on the on the car okay.
So now that coating you can recoat it in a day time okay so you do not have to wait for
longer duration okay so that ease of repair maintenance long life those are basic traits
of having a better coatings.
So these are some of the aspects we should talk about.
So we will see that major purpose of the coating is to give protection to the steel from corrosion
okay and that corrosion could be either aqueous corrosion or chemical attack or high temperature
oxidation or hot corrosion those things we will talk as we go ahead okay.
So let me stop here we will continue our discussion on the coating in our subsequent
lectures.
