Lecture 33: Monetary Policy III

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Dec 1, 2023
[Music]
hi everyone so let's start we are going
to talk about the
the rest of the section that we have not
yet covered in the last section
or i would say last session so we will
be going and talking about the
monetary policy we were talking about
the multi policy dynamics and what are
the rules approaches through which the
central bank tries to minimize the
the inflation risk and also tries to
bring stability into the economy so
if you try and understand what we
covered in the last session so it was
about the credibility
nominal anchor that if the center bank
is going to play very important role in
deciding about price stability how
central government or or the central
bank make sure that it achieves the
inflation target the prices stability
target so in most of the
economies
you have dual mandate which means that
the central bank is given the task to
maintain the price stability plus the
employment level
now from the price stability side there
might be inflation target but from the
in employment level side there are no
specific targets
so sometime it becomes really difficult
for the central bank to
to bring
equality on both parameters which means
that ensure equality on both parameters
which means that
if the inflation rate if central bank is
targeting then it may happen that there
will be deviation from the output gap
side employment fluctuating
will be there and also
once i talk about employment flexibility
so it it also talks about how we can
understand the fluctuations in
the
the macroeconomic parameters
so in this particular session we will be
focusing on those dimensions and will be
trying to look at that
if we are saying that you have the
macroeconomic targets given and central
bank is having the utmost task to
maintain the price stability
then
in what all scenarios the central bank
will have difficulty in maintaining
the
the price stability and the output level
both same so the natural rate of
interest and natural level of
unemployment at what level the central
bank is able to maintain then will be
superimposing some more conditions
underneath initial framework
what are those conditions that if you
have zero lower bound
then how will be this reaction
if we have the inflation expectation so
in the last session we also discussed
about the inflation expectations
that if the credibility of the central
bank is really low then people will not
bother about the central bank targets
they will have the higher expectation
about the inflation
recent case has been the
the case
if you
are going through the newspaper then you
may find the case of turkey
where the inflation rate has gone up
quite substantially so the government
and the central banks are trying to
manage the inflation risk but
since people have very less credibility
about the government and about the
central bank about the institutions
so it is expected that whatever we have
the headline inflation reported in the
newspaper media the actual inflation
rate is much higher which means that
people uh have expectation that the
number coming out from the central bank
it is not very credible so the actual
number may be much more higher
these are the cases of credibility where
if the central bank is not efficient
enough to communicate effectively to the
to the commoners about the
inflation targets then they may have
some expectations about higher inflation
in future that that will further
destabilize the economy with respect to
higher wages price level will be higher
and then the central bank again react
with the rate of interest higher
borrowing cost will be higher and
inflation will be your investment will
be impacted further so overall your
business cycle may not function smoothly
so it will be very difficult to
it will be very difficult for the
economy to smooth out the the venous
cycle shock
so
all these dimensions are important and
then
post 2008 as i mentioned also i think in
the last session when we discuss about
that what happens if the rate of
interest has almost touched the bottom
but we do not see any rise in the
inflation so normally when money supply
increases inflation is supposed to go up
but when we are not seeing that kind of
situation then in those situations how
the central bank is going to react so
what will be the reactions of the
central bank now those
dimensions are really important and
there will be talking about forward
guidance so the term that we often use
so reserve bank of india also uses this
in most of the
unprecedented situations or uncertain
scenarios the central bank gives the
hint that
there will be a higher inflation in
future which means that people will have
expectation formation around and they
will be also reacting in the same way so
some kind of signaling mechanism works
in the market where the central banks
conveys through different means of
communication that the interest rates
and rus may also change because
inflation is going to be higher
but whether this particular announcement
is actually going to be met or not
that's a different situation right so
you may be reading in newspaper that
whenever you have some news coming from
u s that fed is going to increase the
rate of interest federal funds rate that
that is the policy that they have then
you will see lot of buzz around
this particular topic and there will be
lot of media debate and discussion which
means that
in some or the other way the fed reserve
tries to pass on signal to the commoners
that this is how the economy will look
like
interested scenarios will look like and
then the rest of the agents in the
economy it is up to them to decide about
how they should be
maintaining the equilibrium so those
dimensions are also important we will be
also touching upon the
the emerging schools of economic thought
which is the new fisheries where in they
talk about that
the inflation
the nominal interest rate increase will
lead to
increase in inflation
because if you are
if you are going to
break the liquidity trap or i would say
the zero lower bound then
the only scenario is that you should
increase the nominal rate of interest so
that your inflation should also go up
these are the
normal i would say
discussions and it will be interesting
to link it with the real life scenarios
and in this particular session we'll be
focusing on these dimensions and let's
let's complete the part
that we were discussing about different
approaches one was on the inflation
targeting
so for this session also
the reference book remains same the
mishkin i have referred and here you
have the bank for international
settlement as i had
also mentioned about unconventional
monetary policy
these two references are for the forward
guidance
if you want to know about zero lower
bound so all those dimensions are being
covered
but for the core part that we are going
to discuss nominal anchor credibility
and also about
the different approaches of central
banking so this comes from michigan
williamson we have referred for new
canadian school through that we try to
understand that how difficult it is for
the central bank to maintain the
equilibrium level of our output gap and
also about the expectations
about the inflation so here we will be
talking about those things so here we
are talking about the the conduct of
monetary policy different rules of
monetary policy central bankerability
and inflation targeting new fisheries in
school of thought that we had mentioned
i think this will remain same so now we
are going to the the role of central
bank credibility that we were talking
about so here we were talking about that
what will be the approaches through
which
the the credibility and the nominal
anchor problem ah becomes important
so here we have
first is the inflation targeting so what
is that here we are talking about the
keeping inflation under control this is
one of the main objectives of the
central bank
so here is that one is about the public
announcement of medium term numerical
target so there will be advance
announcement and this rate will be fixed
or this threshold of inflation will be
fixed for certain periods and then
the based on examination that whether
the central bank has been able to meet
the target or not then it will be
decided inflation targeting should be
part of the institutional commitment and
as long as strategy to ensure plastic
stability
multiple indicator approach will be used
right in making decisions about monetary
policy
transpiration i i would say transparency
in the
monetary policy through proper
communication so if you look at the
global figure
then most of the countries you will find
that they have gone for inflation
targeting mechanism
which is
new zealand australia canada norway
sweden switzerland united kingdom brazil
india
chile czech republic hungary israel
mexico peru philippines poland south
africa and south korea so these are the
institutions where they work
now here we have the
let's focus on india
how is the mechanism in india
so inflation targeting in india has been
adopted
in 2016 we adopted what is called
flexible inflation targeting which is
fit framework
and this has been incorporated into the
rbi act 1934 which still dominates the
monetary policy framework in india
now according to this act
government can set the inflation target
in consultation with the rbi for five
years
as of now we have gone for setting the
inflation target of four percent
with the tolerance level of plus minus
two
which means that the upper bound can be
six percent lower bound can be two
percent so four percent is the base
level the average
higher than this
will will create a scenario for
nominal interest rate
ah becoming higher
it will be talking about the increase in
the nominal interest rate
lower if it goes below 2 percent then
central bank is supposed to react but
tolerance level of 2 percent for the
case of india which is an emerging
economy looks quite decent and
acceptable
on that basis india inflation target was
set four percent with a two percent
extension in the upper bound and two
percent in the lower bound now
if you see the performance then what has
been reported and it has been found also
that after the implementation of
flexible inflation targeting the
performance of indian economy has gone
up which means that monetary policy
transparency has also increased and
there has been a further
substantiation in the monetary policy
transmission mechanism through which the
central bank passes on the benefits of
interest decrease to the
to the
commoners or the
or the household and forms or also the
increase in the
interest rate which means that if you
are going to land then you are going to
get benefit
now flexible information targeting which
is also called a fit has improved the
inflation expectation outlook
what is that that under inflation
expectation survey for household unlike
earlier where people were more bothered
about
just or they were having some kind of
expectation formation based on the
previous period inflation they were not
relying more on the past data and
multiple indicator approach they were
simply having a tendency to go for
adaptive expectation kind of scenarios
but with the recent improvement in the
flexible information targeting framework
and with the multiple indicator approach
it has been found that individuals are
also forward looking and they are
not weighing that much to just to past
inflation they are looking beyond that
which means that they examine certain
demands apply factors also not just that
in the previous period it was five
percent inflation so the next period
will it will be also five percent they
have some kind of rational expectation
mechanisms and and i have already
mentioned that if in the economy as you
have more and more
a well educated class they will always
look for
new data analyze their expectation and
then form the expectations based on that
so it will not be so smooth now second
which is very
interesting
is that appoint conservative central
bankers which means that if the central
bank governor is hawkish about inflation
which means that he is
inflation hours
which means that he does not take into
account ah
inflationary scenario he he takes very
seriously the inflationary scenarios and
he goes against the high inflation he
takes majors that kind of conservative
thought making governor or the central
bank head will make the difference paul
walker case in case of us during 1970s
80s
is quoted as the inflation champion and
he has been credited with the
heavy control of inflation in the case
of u.s when jimmy carter was the
president so at that time so paul walker
is a very famous name in the field where
when we talk about personalities playing
very important role there we talk about
that the central bank activism coming
into picture and through that they try
to control the inflation
so econ economists have argued that the
central bank should be headed by a
person who has a strong
aversion to high inflation
less tempted to pursue expansionary
monetary policy because if you are
pursuing expansionary monetary policy
one of the downsides of the
the inflationary
or expansionary monetary policy is that
it creates a very high expectation about
higher inflation in future and if the
central bank
fails to have higher credibility and
this will create a very i would say
discretionary kind of scenarios where
the short run adjustment will have a
higher impact on long term adjustment so
we are
talking about
that kenneth rogoff has characterized
these central bankers as conservative
although better prescription would be
tough or hawkish on inflation
these days when we are in the coed
period and where we are saying that we
are having
a constant increase in inflation
globally and most of the central banks
are finding it difficult to have a full
grip on the inflation rise
at these moments these topics have come
up again and you will find that with the
help of different types of data with the
help of different statement analysis so
if you are good in encoding anything
good in the
documentation reading kind of models
where you can find out the important key
words and work on so those we call it as
the textual analysis
through that also people try to
understand the
behavior of central bankers how these
central bankers when they are in a
position when they are leading the
institution then how they react to
inflation in which all scenarios they
expect that the higher inflation may not
be suitable and when they they see a
higher rise in inflation then how they
react to that so those angles are
quite important to understand so
approach 2 is quite
i would say
not easy to digest but these are the
angles
where people are focusing on so with
different set of
variables different set of data sets
they try to find it out then here here
you have the
independent central bank so in case of
independent central bank ah what
typically happens is that
here we focus on
ah here we focus on whether the central
bank should be
independent
if the central bank is going to be
independent then how this the inflation
targeting and also about the
the personality cut is playing important
role because it has been found that the
political business cycle which means
that politicians always try to
try to have some kind of influence on
the central bank
and they also go for populist majors at
the time of election so that they can
win the election and come back to power
there are also instances where in the
the strong governments have
compromised the independence of the
central banks and this has become an
important topic and it has come back
again so you will find that central bank
should have more independence
with regard to inflation targeting
because if it has more independence then
it can think about when it has to go
with the higher interest rate and when
it has to target the inflation
if the if the if the country is
following multiple indicator approach
then it also becomes really important to
what extent this particular indicator or
this particular central bank has to
react
the time inconsistency problem may arise
from politicians who are short-sighted
because they focus on pursuing policies
that will help them win the next
election so this particular angle also
matters a lot a politically insulated
central bank is more likely to be
concerned
with long run objectives and thus
be a defender of price stability so we
have to make sure that
that if the central bank is not going to
target the long term objectives and then
it if it is not
having the
the political in insulation then it will
create trouble and ultimately the
central bank may have ah may compromise
on meeting the long term targets and
this again will lead to what we call it
as
the
time inconsistency problem which means
that if the if the central bank is not
independent then it may happen that
that it will not have full control on
deficit financing linked a inflation or
also
on the monetary policy or inflation
targets
you will be surprised that in most of
the countries now we have the
we have
the
compromise central banking structure
where the government has taken over on
the space of the central banks even in
india we have formed the monetary policy
committee under that we have the
government nominated individuals and
they decide about the monetary policy
decisions because earlier it was found
that there was some kind of
conflict of interest between the
the government and the central bank so
in order to pursue a common goal of
price stability and the higher growth
they thought that is good to form a
committee and then
we can target but at the same time on
many
occasions we have found that the
reaction of central bank has not been
very hawkish when they see a rise in
inflation rather
they have some kind of
lags in reaction so those things may not
happen if you have the
independent central bank if you are
giving more power to the central bank so
in in that case
it becomes really important
if you look at the central bank
independence and inflation performance
in 17 countries so here the lower is the
score which means that least independent
higher is the score which shows that is
most independent so we find that in case
of germany in case of future land in
case of united states in case of japan
netherland canada and the the
compromised ah central banks are here
where you have the spain
new zealand then australia italy united
kingdom and this is the data from
1973 to 1988
on y axis we have the average inflation
in annual rate and on x axis here we
have the index of central bank
independence
now you can find that the countries
which are having higher inflation are
the most compromised which means that
the central bank in these countries is
least independent
and the countries which are having
independent central banks they have gone
for better management of inflation the
inflation rate is much lower that shows
that if you are allowing the central
bank to function independently without
much of the government interference then
your inflation outlook is going to be
better
you will have better grip on the
inflation targets whereas in case of the
compromise or the
the
the least independent central bank we
find that here you have a higher
inflation target higher inflation rate
so these economies experience higher
inflation because the central bank did
not have that much power so this is what
i wanted to mention so let me summarize
what we have covered so what we
have in mind that
if you are going to have proper
credibility if you are going to have
proper capability into the central
banking system then you have to identify
first the nominal anchor which variable
you want to target the most in order to
enhance the credibility these are the
approaches through which central bank
can go for one is the inflation
targeting second is about the
appointment of
the
the central bank head that can be a
conservative or he may be a more hawkish
on inflation rather than
simply tough so hawkish is the with the
popular term which we often
use in case of central banking
and then you have the most important and
crucial
approach is that there should not be
interference in the daily affairs of the
central bank central bank should be
independent so i hope these
dimensions have added
some kind of
have given you sufficient understanding
about how we can understand the
the role of the central bank in the
economy so here from here onwards will
be taking to the next level
where we will be trying to connect with
the new canadian school of economic
thought will be trying to see that will
be putting up the scenarios and will be
trying to see that how those scenarios
will work for the central bank if the
central bank objective is to either
control the inflation or go for
employment maintain or employment higher
employment level maintenance then in in
that case it becomes really really
important
so lets focus first on the inflation
when we talk about inflation then it
mentions that the high inflation it has
the
it has the impact on the value of of the
currency so here it it works that people
will not hold
people will not like to hold the cash
rather they will be simply
simply going for some alternative
holdings
the role of anticipated and
unanticipated becomes important so now
we are moving towards an understanding
where
we will be seeing that if you have the
anticipated
expectation or anticipated inflation as
an
exegenious variable and and and on
anticipated inflation gives you some
kind of price changing behavior for some
firms and some firms may not like to
change the price so typically in the
economy if you have inflation then the
the
individuals will be forming the
expectation about future whether they
should increase the price immediately or
they should have they should vote for
some more time when and
if they are if they are planning to wait
for some more time then they must be
having some expectation that when they
will get the next chance to revise the
price so most of the shopkeepers most of
the businessmen when they see rise in
inflation then you will find that they
may not be
be
revising their prices immediately they
will be waiting for some period and then
they see that okay after one month if
the inflation remains same at the same
level or if it it goes by two percentage
point then i will be changing or i will
be revising the prices but if some forms
which are not changing prices as per the
assumption if you are assuming that it
is very difficult for the firm to change
the price in the short run then in that
case it becomes really difficult that
how
some forms changing the prices based on
the expectation some firms are not
allowed to change so the profitability
or the demand scenario for both firms
will not be the same so that's why the
anticipated and unanticipated inflation
plays very important role
economic decisions are often impacted by
the inflation expectations that some
firms may be reacting if inflation is
unexpectedly high then this will train
to redistribute income think about
borrower and lender if borrower is if
the inflation rate is higher lender is
going to lose so with this understanding
will be moving to the new kinesian
school of economic thought and on the
new canadian school of economic thought
will be trying to see
the role of phillips curve in
understanding the
expected inflation and output dynamics
so i will be stopping here and in the
next session i will start from this and
will be talking more about the new
kingdom understanding thank you thank
you so much for your attention
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
you
