CPI Inflation Report — Why You Can't Trust it

Financial Freedom
10 followers
Oct 1, 2025 #finance #financement
In today's video, let's review the trustworthiness of the government's economic data, the reports
that they give. In today's video, we're going to focus on the CPI inflation reports.
And the reason why I'm doing this is because I want to inform people of the situation,
and I want to tell, I want people to understand that this is a big problem for over 100 million
Americans. So let's start here. I want to show you the survey by YouGov. Do Americans trust or
distrust federal government data on the economy? The survey shows that a whopping 6% of Americans
completely trust the government's data. And it doesn't seem to matter if you're a Democrat,
if you're Independent, or a Republican. So take a look for yourself. It's 6% across all party
affiliations. Now, I just want you to understand that the CPI inflation report that the government
publishes is so important because the rate of inflation that they report affects the cost of
living adjustments for Social Security recipients, federal retirement programs, VA benefits, it even
affects the tax code. And we're talking about the adjustments for the standard deduction,
the tax brackets, the retirement plan contribution limits, EITC, etc. It also affects wages and labor
contracts, especially for union contracts. And it affects minimum wage laws in many cities and
jurisdictions. And it's just, I mean, at least to me, I guess you could say it's my opinion,
so obvious to at least me and many people that the government is underreporting the true rate
of inflation. Okay, with that being said, let's drill down deeper. Why and how is the government
underreporting the true rate of inflation? And let's start with the how. First of all, if you
want to measure the rate of inflation, then you would simply measure the change in the price of
something, right? You know, for example, if something costs a dollar 12 months ago, and now it costs a
dollar and 10 cents, then you would say that the rate of inflation is 10%. It's a simple method,
simple math, right? But that's not what the CPI Inflation Report does. The CPI Inflation Report
does not measure the change in prices. The CPI Inflation Report measures the change in the cost
of maintaining the same standard of living, which is highly subjective, which leaves a lot of wiggle
room for manipulation. I want to point out the flaws of the CPI Inflation Report's methodology.
So the first issue is sampling. The government collects price data from retailers and establishments
from 75 urban areas, and the government does not reveal the actual price quotes from the specific
stores or the providers. So in other words, we just have to take their word for it and their
numbers are not auditable. That's because they say that the information that they gather is
confidential by law under Title 13 and 18 of the U.S. Code, Census and Statistical Data.
And then there's the substitution effect. And you could tell me, like I can explain this,
and you could tell me if this is fair for computing the true rate of inflation. So the
substitution effect assumes that people are going to switch over to cheaper goods or services when
the price of something rises. So if you think about it, at least my opinion is that the substitution
effect is always going to understate the true rate of inflation. So I'm going to give you an example.
Like if I eat tangerines and the price of tangerines goes up more than the government
would like to admit, then the government's going to be like, Brian, tangerines are too expensive.
Switch over to eating grapefruits. Like it's similar. And then I would be like, well, I don't
want to eat grapefruit. I don't like grapefruit. It's too bitter for me. But the government's not
going to care. They don't care. For the CPI Inflation Report, they're going to act like
in my basket of goods, I switched over to eating grapefruits because the price of grapefruits
didn't go up as much as the price of tangerines. So they use the substitution effect to pad their
numbers. And then you have the hedonic adjustment. So for this one too, you tell me if you think
this is fair or not, or if this makes sense. So this removes price increases that are attributed
to quality improvements. So a lot of people don't know about this one. So for example,
if your smartphone, let's just say that it costs $800 this year. But five years ago, it was
$400 for a cell phone. The CPI method can effectively say that the price of cell phones
have not gone up in the past five years because the cell phones today are better than they were
before. So if a cell phone five years ago is $400, but now with these additional features and all
these quality improvements within the phone, if you take that into consideration, then the price
of cell phones did not inflate at all. They can say that. They're basically saying that
the price stayed the same and the additional amount that you're paying is for the improvements.
So there's no inflation there. And here's another major issue that a lot of people have a problem
with. It's the theoretical questions that do not reflect real prices. So for example, about 33%
of the entire CPI consists of the cost of housing. And for that, they rely heaviest on the owner's
equivalent rent question. So they asked the respondents, how much do you think theoretically
would you expect to pay to rent your home that you're living in? So this is not based on any
hard data or real market rates. Can you believe that your cost of living adjustments are based
on these types of questions? Now, if you think I'm being too skeptical or lacking in trust in
the government, then I want to show you this. So this is from the Library of Congress. So you can
go to congress.gov and read about this for yourself. So here's what the Congressional
Research Service says right here. So you can follow along. Questions have recently arisen
surrounding the reliability and usefulness of certain federally produced data, including the
And these concerns arise from the CPI methodology. Another concern, which is listed on page two of
the report, says that survey response rates for the CPI are falling, which is leading to a lower
quality of data. So it says the surveys are generally voluntary and have been exhibiting
a downward trend in the number of responses. Survey response rates are important for precision.
Higher response rates are typically associated with data of higher quality,
which means that lower response rates are typically associated with data of lower quality.
And as you can see, over the years, response rates have been falling, which means that the
data quality has been deteriorating over the years. But I mean, I'm not surprised. Like,
if the government solicited me with a survey, then, I mean, it's just me. I wouldn't participate.
Like, my perspective is that they should just look at the actual change in prices rather than
trying to survey people. I mean, from my perspective, we have something called the
internet, and they can see the prices online. And honestly, they could just automate the process,
probably save a lot of money in doing that. And they could also disclose the data so people can
actually audit it and trust it. All right, so what do we know? We know that their methodology
is questionable at best. We know that we can't audit their numbers. They don't disclose their
data. And we just have to take their word for it. We know that their survey response rates are
coming in lower, leading to lower quality of data. Okay, so here's the problem. As I stated,
a lot of people's cost of living adjustments or pay raises depend on the CPI inflation reports.
And for things to be fair, that inflation figure needs to be accurate. But a lot of people believe
that it's not. And I am one of them. When you look at other straightforward ways of calculating
inflation, like if you're going to look at shadow stats or even use the true living cost measurement,
it shows you that real life expenses are rising much faster than the government's reported rate
of inflation. Now, why would the government be incentivized to underreport the rate of inflation?
Well, from my perspective, it's pretty straightforward. It's all about the money. So
I'll just say my perspective is because the government wants to save money. There are 74.5
million Americans that receive Social Security benefits. Can you imagine how expensive it would
be if the government reported the correct rate of inflation and gave all 74 million Americans
a correct cost of living adjustment? Not only would the government have to pay 74 million
Americans more money each year, but the government would have to borrow more money each year.
And then, you know, borrowing that money, the interest payments would go up even faster.
So just much more expenses. And that's just Social Security recipients. That's not including
all the other, you know, millions of Americans that are affected by cost of living adjustments
associated and tied to the CPI. Now, another way to look at the rate of inflation,
you know, what it would really be would be to look at the money supply, like how much money
is out there. Right now, the rate of inflation, according to the CPI report, says that the rate
of inflation is running at about 3%, you know, whether you're looking at headline inflation or
core inflation. But if you look at the money supply, it's growing right now at a rate of 5%.
But honestly, right now, that's relatively slow. If inflation is running at a rate of 5%,
that's relatively calm compared to what we saw during the pandemic, during skyrocketing inflation.
But still, if the money supply is growing at 5% and they're reporting 3%, then that's still a
massive underreporting. You know, that's the difference between getting a 3% cost of living
adjustments compared to a 5% cost of living adjustments. And that's happening year after
year after year. It compounds. And again, this is a calm period. They reported 8% inflation,
you know, during the pandemic when it was really running at 15%.
Anyways, let me know what you think. My opinion, like my perspective is that they're
stealing our purchasing power. They're acting like we're naive. And I just want to call them
out on it. Again, let me know what you think. I look forward to reading your comments. Please
subscribe. I thank you for the support and I wish you a very nice day. Take care.
