Counterfeit, Fraudulent, and Suspect Items: Managing Supply Chain Risks (Module 1 and 2)

U.S. Department of Energy
60 followers
Nov 2, 2023
The virtual training was created to address supply chain risks related to counterfeit, fraudulent, and suspect items (CFSIs) as used in terminology by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission and International Atomic Energy Agency. DOE uses the terminology S/CIs or Suspect/Counterfeit Items. The training is divided into two main videos:
Video 1: Module 1 and 2
Video 2: Module 3 though 6
hello I am Gabrielle hul I work for the
Department of energy and we'll be
speaking you today about counterfeit
fraudulent and suspect items
specifically this module will address
managing supply chain
risks the agenda for this module is
divided into six
sections section one is the introduction
section two is developing a plan section
three is analyzing and rating risks
section four is assessing risk processes
and controls section five is mitigating
risks and section six is preventing
counterfeit fraudulent and suspect
items in this first section the
introduction how many of you know or
understand supply chain risk
management first what is supply chain
risk management
the National Institute of Standards and
Technology nist defines supply chain
risk management as a systematic process
for managing supply chain Risk by
identifying susceptibilities
vulnerabilities and threats throughout
the supply chain and developing
mitigation strategies to combat those
threats whether presented by the
supplier the supplies products and its
sub components or supply chain such as
initial production packaging handling
storage trans portation Mission
operation and
Disposal each area shown here such as
environmental risks including hurricanes
floods tornadoes sources of Supply such
as risky suppliers fraudulence or
conformance issues controls such as poor
quality controls inspections tests and
inventory
Etc safety processes such as a worker
getting hurt or killed on the job or
work shut
down
processes such as poor Material Handling
shipping packaging storage controls that
cause damage and regulatory requirements
such as missing incorrect inadequate can
all contribute to supply chain
risks why do you think it's important to
manage supply chain risks please pause
the video at any time for group
discussion if
needed there's noong wrong answers and
participation is always
encouraged have you ever experienced a
supply chain
shortage have you ever experienced a
significant supply chain delay and have
you ever received a substandard suspect
or counterfeit product even if at home
these are some very important
considerations and great discussion
points if you're having this train as a
group another group discussion and
please pause the video to discuss as a
group do you think that counterfeit
suspect and fraudulent items would be
considered a supply chain risk and
why there's no wrong
answers have you experienced a major
recall do you suppose that this looks
good or bad to a brad brand owner when
they have have it have to issue recalls
have you ever experienced a counterfeit
fraudulent or suspect item and if so do
this impact your project or program did
it impact the costs of rework performed
and do you think that a counterfeit
fraudulent or suspect item could impact
your
work these are just some important
questions to ask especially if you're
doing this training as a
group this slide represents the
highlevel risk mitigation process that
we will be reviewing
today this short process will be
separated into much smaller segments for
each step and for you to better
understand all the elements ultimately
the risk mitigation process goal is to
create a list of risks rate those risks
assess your processes and controls to
see what gaps may exist in addressing
the risks and then produce an action
plan or strategies to lessen the effects
of potential threats in the next section
we will discuss the risk planning
process in depth the risk planning
process will address all these
components but at a much more strategic
level now at section two the objective
for this section is to discuss the
stages of risk
planning the goal is for attendees to
learn about counterfeit fraudulent and
suspect item risk mitigation planning
stages
this section is all about risk planning
throughout this section I would like you
to consider or think of creating a risk
plan for your organization or for a
specific project think about the
elements that you would want to address
in that plan I would also like you to
consider that often a risk plan is
completed at an organizational level but
it may also be completed on a project by
project basis to identify if additional
controls are needed for a project
besides what is already in place at the
organizational
level we are going to discuss the four
stages that are typically used to
develop a risk plan which include the
first stage identifying the risks the
second stage preventing and detecting
counterfeit fraudulent and suspect items
the third stage would be controlling and
managing processes that will prevent and
detect counterfeit and fraudulent and
suspect items and the fourth stage is
reporting and analyzing trends of
counterfeit fraudulent and suspect items
and this can include other processes
let's look at each stage in more
depth stage one of our plan is for
identifying
risks in this stage we might I might
Define and document the following
elements roles and
responsibilities graded or risk-based
approach the risks and how we will train
Personnel on the next slide we'll look
at each of these areas in more
depth it may be important within
organizations to reduce or prevent risks
by defining roles and responsibilities
at a level which is suitable for the
work being
performed actions for individuals should
also be
defined a graded approach or a
risk-based approach may be defined by an
organization and can be based on many
factors such as organizational and
business needs this could be the
organization has determined that there
are certain risks that are specific to
the business environment it may not
necessarily affect safety or security
but could impact the Integrity
reputation or investor
relations there may be Health
environment safety or other risks or
hazards that can define an approach to
grading as well as best practices
or operating experience that has been
trended and analyzed over
time this can be internal or external to
the organization but can benefit the
organization for instance Federal
organizations throughout the United
States often publish information on
Lessons Learned best practices or other
operating experience that can be shared
internal to their agency or amongst many
agencies and the general public to
Garner awareness around various topics
a graded approach or risk-based approach
may consider what
factors pause the video to discuss in
performing performing training in a team
setting some potential answers might
include organizational or business needs
the risks or hazards or best
practices
performing a risk analysis for
counterfeit fraudulent and suspect items
will weigh consequence or impact against
the likelihood of occurrence we will
discuss this process in more depth in
the analyzing and rating risk section of
this
training when performing a risk
assessment you weigh the likelihood
against what pause the video to gather
any
answers
the answer is
impact in stage two we'll be discussing
preventing and detection processes which
include the following source of Supply
acquisition clause and use and
verification inspection and test
plans our first element to consider in
preventing and detecting in stage two is
assessing source of supp supply and
supply chain this would include
developing processes and procedures for
acquisition Personnel to follow that
would help to identify or prevent the
purchase of counterfeit fraudulent and
suspect items When developing processes
or procedures we need to think about
basic supply chain risk the more steps
between a manufacturer to the end to the
supplier the higher the
risk on this chart you can see that the
lowest risk is when procuring items for
manufacturers such as original equipment
manufacturers and original component
manufacturers this does not mean zero
risk since fraud can occur anywhere and
has but the risk is typically
lower as you go through the chain the
next level of lowest risk res resides
with the manufacturer's authorized or
franchise distributor these are usually
Distributors that only sell the
manufacturer's Goods to identify an
authorized distributor for a
manufacturer you will usually go to the
manufacturer's website to find a list of
sellers this is especially true if the
manufacturer does not distribute or sell
their own Goods many manufacturers now
have warnings to only buy from their
dedicated list of sellers or you risk
buying a counterfeit or fraudulent
product manufacturers are also starting
to inform consumers and offer
counterfeit support hotlines I always
recommend going going directly to a
manufacturer's website for commercial
offthe shelf products whenever you find
a product that you would like to buy
this will give you insight about the
potential price Sales locations and even
other detailed information such as spe
specification sheets that might not be
available from other
sources as we continue down the list we
can see contract
manufacturers contract manufactur are
the manufacturers that are contracted
out by the original manufacturer to
produce their goods there is higher risk
with contract manufacturers because of
issues such as overproduction or what
may be called Moonlighting where there
is a shift that is dedicated to the
counterfeit or over production and
potential knockoff or cheaper versions
of the genuine products that they
produce on their other shifts these
cheaper versions may use substandard
materials and forego the normal quality
processes then we have independent
Distributors these are Distributors that
may sell many different Goods they could
sell primarily for a specific
manufacturer but will likely sell many
different goods for many manufacturers
and are not loyal to just one specific
manufacturer there is more risk with
independent distributors because they
may or may not use authorized
distribution channels it is important if
you use this type of distributor that
you perform more verification of their
sources the next source of Supply is a
broker Brokers may be individuals a
group of individuals or an entire
company Brokers will usually work to
find your products from anywhere to fill
a demand which is why they may have a
much higher risk they may not be aware
of the counterfeit issues or may work
with sources that are less reputable to
meet your
demands lastly we have the unknown or
individual seller these sellers may be
individuals or companies but there is
often little verification for their
business available because they are
selling through an ewarehouse site
online or other platform that may
obfuscate their information that is why
these sources are the highest risk and
why platforms such as ewarehouse sites
social media or other online retailers
should be used with the highest
caution this is only one example of many
potential scenarios this also excludes
other logistic factors such as shipping
in this scenario the business decided to
buy an item online from an independent
distributor independent Distributors are
known to distribute products for many
different manufacturers and may lack
controls over inventory that authorize
Distributors and manufacturers may be
required to maintain this could risk
introducing counterfeit items
accidentally or in this case
purposefully this could be known or
unknown to the management or owner of
the Distribution
Company this type of scheme is often
completed to save money create a source
of financial gain or boost stock due to
shortages if you are working to prevent
using this supplier UPF front and only
assess the direct supplier it will
likely be missed that the distributor is
using a warehouse that receives
substandard and counterfeit materials it
is important to understand that some of
the potential vulnerabilities in the
supply chain such as in this case if you
were to procure from this supplier it is
likely that you will find non-conforming
substandard and counterfeit fraudulent
and suspect item materials and if
monitoring the supplier could determine
the issue after some time
you may question how can I assess a
supplier that is not my own you can do
this when you assess your direct
supplier ask questions about how they
assess their supply chain and verify
that your business is Flowing down
Clauses that require your direct
suppliers to perform assessments you can
also flow down Clauses that allow access
to sub suppliers that are used by your
direct suppliers and require that they
flow these Clauses down to
them the warehouse distributor Inc sells
products to Sales Direct who is your
direct distributor Sales Direct flows
down contract Clauses to the warehouse
distributor Inc which allows you to
access their facility for assessment if
you are assessing the warehouse diser
Inc what might you review to understand
if they were receiving substandard or
counterfeit fraudulent or suspect items
you can pause here if discussing with a
group but I am going to discuss a few
tips look at a look at specific product
lines and ask for their sources who do
they get their products or items from do
they use their other distributors or go
direct to
manufacturers do they have invoices
certificates of conformance or other
documents from
manufacturers substandard materials that
are ordered will likely not have
documentation such as the genuine
materials that the company receives
directly from the
manufacturers documentation when
compared if they do have it may look
altered or different from manufacturer
documentation when comparing prices or
costs of materials from manufacturers to
other sources is there a vast difference
this could be another indicator of
potential fraudulence or or counterfeit
fraudulent and suspect
items when planning for acquisition
Clauses and use you might consider some
of the
following Clauses for specific scenarios
or requirements who reviews the Clauses
and changes when they are used what is
the approach to Clause use and how is
this understood and is their
training
inspection and verification plans and
procedures might Define who will be
performing the inspections will
inspection be performed internal or
external to the
organization what will be inspected and
to what requirements who is defining the
requirements your organization or a
customer when will the inspection be
performed is there a defined
timeline where will the inspection be
performed formed in a temperature
controlled environment or out in the
field during maintenance
operations why is the inspection being
completed is it required by the customer
or is it an internal
requirement where can they look to find
the details of these internal or
external requirements and do they know
how how will the item or materials be
inspected will they use visual
dimensional non-destructive or
destructive testing
methods now we are at stage three of the
risk mitigation plan this stage relates
to planning for the controlling and
managing of the products and processes
to mitigate the risk of counterfeit
fraudulent and suspect items process
considerations might include
traceability control material and parts
control obsolesence management and
non-conformance management let's review
these processes in more depth
dep product traceability allows you to
track your inventory movements from end
to end meaning you can track products to
where they were shipped or back through
their operational steps traceability may
show the chain of custody but it does
not indicate whether the part has been
properly packaged stored or handled or
whether it has been tampered with along
the way trusted sources throughout the
supply chain need to maintain effective
material controls to ensure appropriate
Material Handling and storage and to
ensure material with traceability is not
comingled with material without
traceability material imp Parts control
processes may include planning for
product handling which could also
include handling non-conforming
materials and counter counterfeit
fraudulent and suspect items storage
this may include the storage of all
items but could also include specifics
to non-conforming materials and
counterfeit fraudulent and suspect items
inventory validation which may include
inspection of inventory for counterfeit
fraudulent and suspect items inventory
processes that could preclude other
fraudulent activities such as accurate
counts cost estimates or traceability
activities even if inventory validation
is completed on a sampling basis it is
still valuable for businesses that
Acquire or hold inventories especially
if a large inventory is maintained or if
inventory is used in critical
applications and assessment of product
change notices recalls or product
alerts and implementation of Lessons
Learned best practices and other
operating
experience
obsolescence refers to materials part s
devices software services and
processes that become
non-procurement management is an
important element to any counterfeit
fraudulent and suspect item prevention
program obsolescence has been proven to
contribute significantly to counterfeit
issues and studies completed in the past
by the US government accountability
office demonstrated that when obsolete
electronic components are procured
they're highly likely to be
counterfeit GAO created a fictitious
company and gained membership to two
internet platforms providing access to
vendors selling military grade
electronic parts GAO requested quotes
from numerous vendors to purchase a
total of 16 parts from three categories
the first category was authentic part
numbers for Obsolete and rare parts the
second category was authentic part
numbers with post-production date codes
these are date codes after the last date
the part was manufactured which means
they were requesting parts that could
not possibly exist unless the company
came back with the proper date codes and
the third category was bogus or
fictitious part numbers that are not
associated with any authentic
parts to determine whether the parts
received were counterfeit GAO contracted
with a qualified independent testing lab
for full component authentication
analysis of the first two categories of
Parts but not the third because those
were all bogus part
numbers the part numbers have been
altered for the reporting purposes in
that report but 100% of all the parts
received were
counterfeit there are several drivers
for component obsolescence such as the
growth rate of Technology competitive
life cycles policies legislation and
planned obsolescence by the manufacturer
it is critical that organizations manage
obsolescence using a defined process
such as through a process shown planning
designing checking and
acting obsolescence plans should address
at a minimum communication that are used
or received such as product change
notices or pcns and end of life notices
such as eols Alternatives this could be
an alternative product alternative
manufacturer alternative design
executions if a product runs out or is
discontinued and obsolescence timelines
there are various methodologies and
tools available to forecast obsolescence
timelines proactive obsolescence
management
is best addressed at the design phase
ProActive Management of obsolescence
requires the identification of critical
parts that are at a high risk of going
obsolete will have an insufficient
quantity available after obsolescence to
satisfy expected demand and will
represent a problem to manage if and
when they become obsolete during this
phase Parts can better be identified and
a management plan set up prior to an
actual obsolescence event
ProActive Management does not require an
ability to forecast the obsolescence
risk for parts there are many methods
and tools available for this forecasting
such as obsolescence risk and life cycle
time series modeling machine learning
Etc the check process consists of
verifying notices such as alerts product
change product end of life such as
previously discussed usage reports and
documents to know where the items have
potentially been used and may need to be
mitigated and where in inventory are
obsolete products on hand are there
spares and how long will spares
last Act is our actions for Designing
refresh timelines into original Design
Concepts or understanding what parts are
most likely to go Obsolete and need
redesign and design for potential
removal or replacement of those items in
the future stockpiling may be another
option some items can be stockpiled for
long periods of time if you have an idea
of Maintenance schedules or if the part
is replaced infrequently and can be
stored for long periods of time then
this is an
option planning for non-conformances is
also an important aspect to counterfeit
fraudulent and suspect item prevention
and
control when what is a
non-conformance a non-conformance is a
failure to meet a spec specified
requirement why is it important to have
an effective non-conformance
process counterfeit fraudulent and
suspect items may be identified as a
non-conformance and if this process is
effective then the counterfeit
fraudulent and suspect items will be
processed accordingly and identified
effective processes will perform
analysis of metrics to determine if
there Trends which should be reviewed in
depth some non-conformance issues that
occur over time may be indicators of
fraudulent activities this could be that
A supplier is consistently providing the
wrong materials delivering substandard
products are delivering items that have
to be returned to them tracking
non-conformance related issues May
reveal Trends tracking issues such as
return material
authorizations specific non-conformance
issues related to vendors and costs
associated with rework extra testing and
inspection related to discrepant
materials may also reveal trends that
could be related to counterfeit
fraudulent and suspect items and this
could require more in-depth
scrutiny a risk mitigation plan might
include the following steps and defined
process and this is continued from the
last slide this stage four report and
analyze and this is handling counterfeit
fraudulent and suspect items reporting
and
collaboration investigating counterfeit
and fraud fraudulent suspect item
reports and monitoring and
trending handling counterfeit and
fraudulent suspect item processes may
include identifying or
defining how items will be segregated
there may be limits on what can or
should be segregated and where this can
or will occur how access may be limited
to items to prevent use maybe only a few
people have access to where items are
segregated to prevent use or maybe
individuals are trained not to access
the area how items may be tagged the tag
should clearly Define the status of the
item and any other pertinent information
it is always recommended that the person
who applies the tag is also named on the
tag that they can be contacted about the
item or the tag and how many items and
how items will be marked this could
include cases when they are stored
segregated tagged or if they are
evaluated to be used as is or remain in
place processes for reporting and
collaboration may also be documented
process May document how your
organization will interact with Federal
and Commercial entities in addition to
any tools that will be used to promote
internal and external communication of
counterfeit fraudulent and suspect items
depending on your location there may be
several tools available for
collaboration law enforcement entities
may also work directly with consumers in
some countries and locations where in
other locations these entities may be
more
separated
various investigations may take place
from or at the local organization all
the way through national law enforcement
levels for all investigations it is
important to have a defined process a
defined process may include evidence
maintenance and storage how are items
and information if the issue were to go
to law enforcement um going to be
handled is there documentation that is
needed such as chain of custody forms or
tracking forms for who has the items and
where it has been and documentation
maintenance and retrieval who maintains
records and documents related to
counterfeit fraudulent and suspect items
are documents traceable to the item or
investigation internal processes should
be well
documented and understood by those who
will use these processes this may mean
that addition training is required for
these
individuals although monitoring and
training may be performed at any of the
stages or steps this can be broken down
into a simple four-step process which
includes information gathering analysis
results and implementation of actions
When developing our processes for
monitoring and trending we may consider
each of the following steps
information gathering our issues or
information is monitored and tracked how
are they tracked what systems are used
or are available analysis how is this
information
analyzed is there a specific technique
that is used is the technique documented
who analyzes this
information results do in individuals
know what to review and how to validate
results what will happen with the
outputs and the results do they go into
a report do they go into a system how
are these easily navigatable and
viewable and implement the actions is
there a plan to implement or use data to
implement actions do actions need to be
implemented based on the
data we have discussed all four stages
of risk mitigation planning and what you
might include stage one was identifying
the risk stage two was preventing and
detecting counterfeit fraudulent and
suspect items stage three was
controlling and managing processes that
will prevent and detect counterfeit
fraudulent and suspect items and stage
four was reporting and analyzing trends
of counterfeit fraudulent and suspect
items and other processes I always
recommend to pause here and discuss as a
group any questions or discussion
topics
this is the halfway point of this
training and we will pause here for a
break before continuing into section
three
