Exclusive
An Inconvenient Minority: Attack on Asian-American Excellence and Race Communism | Kenny Xu

China Insights with Jenny
670 followers
14 Video Views·Nov 1, 2023
Kenny Xu is a lead insider on the Harvard case and a commentary writer for the Federalist and the Washington Examiner. In his upcoming new book “An inconvenient minority”, he explores the national Ivy League discrimination cases against Asian-Americans and the lasting consequences on America’s culture of excellence. In this interview Kenny discusses what motivated him to write the book, how the Left is trying to destroy traditional American values like Meritocracy, as well as why he is a conservative growing up in a liberal environment.
Hi, welcome to Focus Talk. Today we're going to have a conversation with Kenny Xu.
Kenny is a commentary writer and author of an upcoming book, An Inconvenient Minority.
Kenny, welcome to our show. Thank you so much for having me.
Well, Kenny, I want to first congratulate you on the upcoming release of this book.
When is it going to be released? An Inconvenient Minority. Thank you for
coming and talking about the book. It's going to be released in July, July 13th, 2021.
Wow. I saw that it's already, there's a pre-sale on Amazon now. So first,
please tell us about the book. What is it about and what triggered you to write it?
So I was always interested in, obviously, Asian Americans, in the way that elite culture views
Asian Americans in this country today. And we have all of these narratives today about race,
right? Particularly the idea that if you're white, you're privileged, or if you're a person of color,
you're oppressed. But Asian Americans actually inconvenience that narrative because they come
from oftentimes impoverished backgrounds. They come to this country without wealth.
They've been historically discriminated against, you know, Chinese Exclusion Act,
Japanese internment, everything like that. But if you look at the statistics today,
Asian Americans are accomplishing things in this country at a rate that is even higher than whites
in some cases. They have higher educational statistics. They have higher financial,
socioeconomic status. And you wonder, you know, because this challenges the whole idea that
if you are a minority, you have to be oppressed and you have to be sort of a victim of society.
But then it ties directly into this other case with Harvard University and Ivy Leagues.
Many Asian American parents, you know, I know growing up in my Asian American community,
my Chinese American community, many parents wanted, you know, to get their kids into the
best colleges. But colleges like Harvard use the fact that we're Asian American against us.
And I think it's a very damaging kind of thing that we're coming to. And this is why I had to
write this book, An Inconvenient Minority. Yeah, it's interesting that you brought up
this narrative that if you're white, you're privileged, you're the oppressor. If you're a
minority, you are the oppressed. Now, this narrative is very suspicious, but we'll talk
about it later. In terms of the Harvard case, this is a case that got a lot of attention,
not only from Asians, well, particularly from, of course, Chinese American communities,
but also from the mainstream societies. So tell us a bit about this Harvard case.
Tell us a bit more about what this case is about, how did it start, and how did you get involved?
So a group of Asian American applicants to Harvard sued Harvard University back in 2014
for discriminating against them in the name of admitting less qualified people of other races.
This includes blacks, Hispanics, and whites. And if you actually look at the admissions data,
it's so interesting because Asian Americans have to score on these tests 440 points higher,
according to the 2018 data, 440 points higher than a black applicant to have the same chance
of admissions at a place like Harvard University. And the reason why they do this is because
they have this idea that they don't want too many Asians there, they don't want too many
Asian Americans there. And so it puts together this directly contradictory ideals of diversity.
On one hand, you want diversity, but on another hand, we want to admit the best applicant,
we want meritocracy. And I think that that ideal of meritocracy is something that's not being said
so much in this culture today. And I made it my mission to talk about that in my book.
I think this diversity thing, I can understand if we want diversity, but in Harvard's case,
is it going to an extreme?
I think that in this country, right, in America, the whole idea of the American dream is that you
come to this country and you are treated not on the basis of the color of your skin, not on the
basis of your background or wherever you come from, but on the basis of the content of your
character, right? That's the central ideal that Martin Luther King said. It's a central ideal
that holds this country together and unifies this country. And I think that if we are to progress
as a country, right, if we are to progress as a country, then we need to let people who are
excellent at certain things be excellent at those things. And one of those things, you know, is
academics. And so I feel that we should be treating people on the basis of how they can
contribute and not on the basis of where they are on the skin color threshold.
I see. So in Harvard's case, they're using diversity as an excuse to actually, in the
opinion of this group that accused Harvard, right, they filed a lawsuit with Harvard,
they think they're discriminate against Asian Americans. On the other hand, you know,
Harvard argues that they have so many applicants, and a lot of them have perfect scores, perfect
grades, they can't accept them all. So they have to use this, they have to look at their personality
traits, so called personality score. So that's their argument. But on the other hand, my question
is, are they applying the criteria across the board among different groups? Or are they lowering
the criteria for certain groups and raising the bar for other minority groups? Is this an issue?
So this idea of the personality score is something that is very, very interesting.
I actually cover this a lot in my book, An Inconvenient Minority. So Harvard's personality
score, they grade applicants on three things, academics, extracurriculars, and this personality
score. The issue with the personality score is that it has been shown through the admissions
documents, and I reveal this in my book, but it's been shown through these admissions documents,
that the personality score is a proxy for racial balancing, for racial balancing.
Asian Americans score the lowest personality scores out of all of the races, according to
Harvard, even though there's actually no objective evidence to corroborate this,
because Asian Americans score in alumni interviews, just as high as white Americans,
teacher recommendations, a little bit lower than white Americans,
but higher than black and Hispanic Americans. And the relevant measurements of personality,
Asian Americans score just as high as the best. But in this final personality score,
it's seen Asian scores significantly lower than all of the other races. And that's the,
that's the score that's being used to put Asian Americans out of the final running.
So are you saying that they favor some minorities over others?
Yes, of course. It's a policy of racial discrimination. But because there have been
ideologues for the past 50 years that have suggested that it is okay to have racial
discrimination, as long as that racial discrimination so-called benefits one minority
group or a less privileged or less powerful minority group over another, then it's okay.
So the only way that Harvard is able to get away with something like this
is by asserting that Asian Americans are in fact a privileged group. That is Harvard's
cultural argument that they're trying to sell to the public. The idea that Asian Americans are
actually white adjacent, that we're like the privileged white class. And that's how they're
able to sell the argument that we need to privilege the narrative of other minority races
over Asian Americans. Now, when they say Asians are white adjacent,
I think they mean that Asians display similar characteristics as people who are white.
But it feels to me that what they're really attacking here is the characters,
or the traditional moral values, like the working hard, caring for a family, all of these
traditional moral values. So it seems like they're just using race as an excuse or a weapon.
I mean, this whole white adjacent thing, let's say if a Hispanic person displayed
the similar characteristics, are they becoming white adjacent too?
Well, you're seeing that start to be applied to other races as well now.
Asian Americans, I think, are particularly hard hit because the ideas of Asian Americans
as being white adjacent come from this idea that Asian Americans benefit from so-called
white supremacy, that we are the so-called model minority, that whites use us to prove
that racism doesn't exist. I mean, of course racism exists. I mean, you've seen every race
can be racist to another race. I mean, and Asians have experienced a lot of racism as well.
But they didn't get to where they are in America today because of their race.
They got to where they are in America today because of their cultural upbringing,
because of their values, because of how they value education, because of how they're able
to stick with two-parent family structures, because of their lower rates of crime,
and because of all of these other factors that don't have to do with race, but have to do
with the individual. Yeah, and I don't see anything wrong with these traditional values
and with all these characteristics. And you mentioned that Dr. Martin Luther King,
60 years ago, he advocated for a race-blind society. And I remember his famous quote is that
I have a dream that my children will live in a nation where they will not be judged by the color
of their skin, but by the content of their character, right? So the whole idea is to
judge people based only on their characters and merits. But then why do people today,
why do a lot of people today keep talking about race, keep talking about color?
What's the motivation behind it, you think? So there are a couple motivations behind it.
On the elite side, why does Harvard keep peddling this ideology? In my book,
An Inconvenient Minority, I trace the origins of the race ideology that has sparked the racial
division today. I trace it back to Harvard University, back to the Ivy Leagues. Why are
they like this? There are communist ideas that stem from these Ivy League universities.
But revolution of class is not necessarily what they want. It's more like they want to divide the
world into the privileged and the oppressed. And they want the oppressed to rise up against
the privileged. So in order to conform their Marxist ideology, they have to create a class
of people who are oppressed. And this is where they get into this whole idea of race.
Race is a way of saying that I'm oppressed, therefore give me things. And this kind of
ideology that is now into our classrooms through critical race theory, that is now into our
corporations with diversity quotas and diversity and inclusion, that is now, of course, in our
elite universities training the leaders of tomorrow to see race as the fundamental characteristic of
a human being. All of these kinds of things right now are creating this culture of racial division
that is reinstantiating itself onto our culture. And it's being led by the elite Ivy League
universities. Yeah, I'm so glad you talk about the origin of this ideology. It's interesting
that I have read this special series on Epoch Times. It's written by Epoch Times editorial staff.
It's called How the Specter of Communism is Ruling Our World. So in that book,
it has this paragraph, almost exactly like what you just said. It says, classifying the
members of the society into the oppressor and the oppressed in order to advocate for struggle,
liberation, and equality is exactly what communism does. So it seems like what we're
seeing in America today is exactly that. People are talking about equity today, but it's really
equality of outcome, not equality of opportunities, right? Yeah, the best way to think about equity
is race communism. That's the term I prefer to use. Equity is basically about ensuring
that all races have the exact same racial representation in a certain area. It's race
communism, right? And so if one group that happens to have values that encourage them in certain
aspects perform at a higher level than other groups, then that group actually has to be
tampered down. You actually have to discriminate against that group in order to elevate the others
because otherwise they will become overrepresented. That is what Asian Americans have become in the
ideas of the elite progressives in America today. They have become overrepresented. That is why,
in the research that I do with my book, An Inconvenient Minority, that is why you have
these gifted and talented programs in the United States. Thomas Jefferson High School in Fairfax,
Lowell High School in San Francisco, Stuyvesant High School in New York City, all of these elite
high schools are trying to lower the number of Asians in their public school programs. Why?
Because they believe in race communism, not equality.
Yeah. I think for immigrants like us, we immigrated to this country because it's a
country of a land of freedom, a land of opportunities, not a land of equal outcome.
And there's a fundamental logical fallacy here. I mean, there's a fundamental fallacy that that
is at play here when you try to advocate for the strict equal representation of races. Say you have
all of the races, 25% in a certain school, 25% whites, 25% blacks, 25% Asians, and 25% Latinos.
But let's say one of those groups just has values that are more encouraging of educational
excellence than the other groups. Let's just call them the Asian Americans. Then eventually,
what's going to happen is that even if you start out at 25% everything, eventually the higher
groups and the more meritorious will rise to the top. And that's going to skew outcomes again,
meaning that you will have to consistently and continuously discriminate against people in order
to get your desired equal outcome. And what's going to happen from that is it's going to
disincentivize excellence, is that no one will have any incentive to be excellent anymore,
nobody will have any incentive to achieve, and you will have fewer good things in our society
because you will have less people who want to do those things.
Yeah. You end up taking things that belong to one group of people and giving to another
group of people. And this is communism. We all see what communism and socialism
have done to the rest of the world, to a lot of other countries.
So this to me is like common sense. It's nothing complicated. But why do you think a lot of people
buy into this kind of argument nowadays? I think that I can only speak for
people maybe of my generation. But when you have the elimination of the idea of merit
in our society, then you start getting these ideas to really ingrain in our culture.
And what you've been seeing, the great liberal philosopher John Rawls in 1970s,
in his theory of justice, one of the most politically influential philosophers of our time,
the first thing that he did was eliminated the idea of merit. He said that everything that you
get, you get because of luck. The idea of merit is eliminated from society. And so if people stop
believing in the idea of merit, then they'll start saying, oh, the reason why you're up there
is because you've cheated, you've stolen, or in some ways, the system has benefited you.
And because we've eliminated that idea, you have these people that have great resentment
upon the people who are on the upper end of achieving things, and they want to take them down.
And this is why we have a society that we have today. I think as our society continues
to progress in a path where we reject meritocracy, I think we're going to
start to see the effects of that boil over. And I think Asian Americans are going to be
primarily affected. Yeah, actually, I think today a lot of Asian Americans,
a lot of young Asian Americans who were born in this country, who grew up in this country,
tend to be liberals, unfortunately. Or, well, the word liberal, I think the meaning of the
word is hijacked. But anyway, let's use the word. So they seem to lean more toward the left
ideology. But why are you a conservative? That's a great question. I grew up in a very
liberal society. My family worked very hard. When they came to this country,
they immigrated from China in 1990. And my mom worked as a waitress for a little while,
just trying to save up enough money, even though she was highly educated. And my dad
spent years in a PhD program to try to get a PhD in economics, and he was one of the few
to graduate. And so the idea of hard work was instilled upon me at a very young age.
The idea you can't get anything if you don't work hard. And I believe that very much.
And for me, people who say, oh, you should just be able to get free money. I don't think that
people should be able to get free money and free things if they don't work for it.
I really believe in the idea of a meritocracy. I believe that we need to create structures,
and we need to create governments and systems that incentivize people to work and to work hard.
Because that's what has made this country great for so long. All these immigrants who come
to this country, who sit down and come with no money, are able in one or two generations to
build wealth in this country and supply a great lifestyle for their people because they are able
to work hard. And so that is why I never saw in liberalism anything redeeming towards the spirit
of this nation. Yeah, I would say the so-called conservatism is actually just traditional American
values and traditional American principles. Unfortunately, what we're seeing nowadays,
it seems like some people, maybe it's a result of the education or propaganda. They're really
trying to destroy these traditions. And then this actually brings me to the next question,
because this is very similar to what happened in China years ago. And in your interview with
Tucker Carlson, you mentioned that, you made that comparison. So you compared the situation
in America today to the Cultural Revolution period in China 50 years ago. So tell us,
why do you make this comparison and what are the similarities? Right, so I did make that comparison
on Tucker Carlson, where America is going to the Cultural Revolution in China.
Under Mao's Cultural Revolution system, people were judged on the basis of background.
If you were children of a landowner, if you were children of a former Nationalist Party person,
you would have privileges taken away from you. Back in China, there isn't really a racial
consciousness the way that America had, but Mao was still able to create a privilege and
oppression hierarchy, the way the left is doing it today. In Mao's system, you had an
anti-meritocratic endeavor. The stinking old ninth was what Mao tried to get rid of, that is
the intellectuals. He tried to reform the universities by getting rid of standardized
exams and he pushed out intellectuals in the countryside, he hated them. And what was the
result of the Cultural Revolution, the anti-merit Cultural Revolution? It set China's culture of
excellence back for many, many years and they're still grappling with the effects of it today.
And I think America, if we're not careful, if we don't study history, if we don't see what Mao did,
we're going to go down the same path. Yeah, I think Mao and the Communist Party,
they've been advocating this class struggle or basically fight between different classes.
So initially they said, oh, the landowner were the oppressors, they need to be beaten down.
Then they said, yeah, the intellectual, like you said, and then they said, oh, the businessmen,
they're capitalists and they need to be beaten down. So they actually put different groups in
the same category, the oppressor, and then they motivate the entire society to persecute these
people. It was a horrible period. But you are very young and you've never lived in China.
How did it occur to you that there is the similarities? Well, I was doing interviews
for my book. I was able to, I had the privilege while writing An Inconvenient Minority to talk
with so many amazing Chinese Americans who are first generation, who really see the dangers
in dividing people on the basis of race, because they or their family members or their elders had
experienced it themselves under communism, under the cultural revolution. They came to America
because they believed that they would have a chance here to be judged not on the basis of
background, but on the basis of their choice and their character. And that was what inspired me.
And I realized even just talking with them and then going back and talking with my own parents,
that this issue is bigger than just a few spots at Harvard University, because the ideology
that they are propagating is an ideology that is dastardly similar to what went on in the
cultural revolution in China today. And so I've made it my resolve to fight it.
Wow, amazing. So I'm sure you interviewed a lot of parents and students in your book.
Are there any particular stories or cases that you'd like to share with us?
So that's a really good question. There, I think about in New York City,
the highest, the population with the highest percentage of poverty in the New York City
is Asian Americans. People don't seem to, people don't realize that. But New York City has
a ton of very poor Asian Americans who live in Chinatowns, who live in their ethnic enclaves,
who work as shopkeepers, who are just doing anything they can to make a living, to survive.
And I interviewed parents who lived in those places. And they see education as the one way
forward to allow their children, if not them, but to allow their children to live a good middle
class life. And so they train their kids day in and day out intellectually, to become better
thinkers, to get educated. They put their kids through enrichment, through advanced classes,
through whatever they can to help their children succeed. And these children study many hours a
week to try to succeed, these second-gen, third-gen children. And I just remember seeing
Bill de Blasio, the mayor in New York City, look at these striving young high schoolers,
middle school-aged Asian Americans with contempt and have his education secretary say to them,
oh, we don't want just one race taking over all of our schools because 70% of Stuyvesant
High School and more than 50% of their specialized high schools are Asian Americans.
And they view that as a racial takeover of their schools. And I look at that and I see, look,
these kids play by all of the rules. They studied so hard. They didn't cheat. In the middle of a
cheating academic, they studied as hard as they could to do the best that they can. And they're
being villainized for it. And I see that story as an example of why we really need to fight
for our culture. Yeah. Let the people excel at where they are good at, you know, and forget about
all this race and color thing. I mean, look at NBA. 70, 80% of people, athletes are black. Why
do you have to put more Asians to it? No, you don't have to because they are good at what they
do. Exactly, exactly. The NBA is a meritocracy, you know, and that's what makes it great. That's
what makes it a great sport because you know that the people who signed the big contracts,
the people who are successful in that sport really are the best of the best. And there are no
considerations other than that to help people in the NBA succeed. And I think that that should be
the way that our culture should function at that level because it produces the most excellent
people and it helps to unify our country. Yeah, I think all professions are equal. So let the
people who excel at that profession do their job, let them excel, let them shine through. I think
this entire society overall will be a very diverse society. You don't have to have the diversity in
each single category, right? Exactly. We are a diverse country. We're a very diverse country.
We have many different groups and we're proud of that. But every group and every person chooses
different things and chooses different paths in their life. If some people want to choose
to succeed by education, then we should let them. If some people want to choose to succeed in
business, then we should let them. But we shouldn't try to artificially reduce the value
of someone's choices or to discriminate against someone because of someone's choices to better
them and themselves and their families. Yeah, really. Totally agree with that. So lastly,
I just want to get your opinion on some of the recent, let's say, the recent trend. It seems
like there's an increase of anti-Asian incidents or attacks, whatever you call it. Now, many people
say this is because of the racism toward Asians. I mean, I don't know statistically how many more
incidents are happening nowadays compared to last year. But what's your take on this issue?
I think that there is racism from every community against every other community.
But if you look at the statistics with Asian Americans, particularly with anti-Asian violence
in 2018, the FBI data said 28% of the perpetrators were black, 25% were white, everyone else was of
other races. And what that shows to me is that it's not just a one-sided racial narrative that
we need to be focusing on. There are racists on both sides. There are people who hate Asian
Americans of every race. And by the way, there are Asian Americans who hate people of other races
as well. And if we're really going to foster a more just and peaceful society, we should stop
concentrating on the race of the perpetrators and start concentrating on the individual factors that
lead those people into the madness that they do. And I think that that is the only way that we can
heal as a society, not by focusing on the race. But in terms of this recent protest, there's also
something that's quite alarming. We see strange signs in some of these anti-racism protests,
where some Chinese hold signs that says, down with American imperialism. I don't know what does it
have anything to do with what's happening nowadays. But this is the type of slogan we saw often from
the 40s and 50s in China. So do you feel there might be some kind of organized efforts behind
all these protests? Are they genuine protests? Well, there was an article that came out yesterday
by a reporter named Jeffrey K. Wood. You can look him up. And he explored the roots of the Stop AAPI
movement. A lot of the people who funded that movement and who built that organization
are supporters of Proposition 16, which discriminated against Asians in colleges
and government contracts and employment. They've gone on the record saying that white
supremacy is the most evil thing that they could imagine. And so when you look at people like that
propagating this kind of movement, you realize that it's going to be one-sided, that they're
only going to advocate one side of the narrative. That is, this so-called white on Asian violence,
even though the facts don't actually support the criminal narrative that they're trying to
construct. And so I think that people of good conscience, people of good character, individuals
who care about this country and about healing this division and stopping violence, need to really
reject the racialization of the criminal narratives that are going on in society. And they have to
stop what they're doing and really take a good look and really think about what the facts really
are. Yep, I agree. Well, thank you so much, Kenny. I think I learned something from you today.
Thank you for sharing your insights on this important topic.
Well, thank you so much for having me on. If you guys want to follow me,
at KennyMXu on Twitter. And you can buy my book, An Inconvenient Minority,
at Barnes and Nobles or Amazon or Walmart or any stores that are out there.
Yeah, thank you for the information. I think this is, what we discussed today,
it's not only about Asian Americans. It's really about preserving the traditional American values
and principles, right? And make sure this is still a country of a land of opportunities and
a land of freedom. Right, right. It's something that we all need to fight for. And this is,
I think that this case brings ideals in consideration that are beyond any one
racial group, but really about the soul of America and the American dream in itself.
Yeah, couldn't agree more. Well, thank you again, Kenny Hsu. We'll hope to see you soon.
Absolutely. Thank you for having me. Well, thank you everyone for watching Focus Talk.
We'll see you next time.
