Critical Race Theory: The Anti-Civil Rights Movement | Interviews

PragerU
799 followers
1 Video View·Apr 2, 2025
Author, mathematician, and founder of NewDiscourses.com, James Lindsay joins Georgia Howe to discuss Critical Race Theory. While proponents of CRT claim that it's the modern day civil rights movement, James explains that it's actually the exact opposite. Is there any way to reverse this destructive societal trend?
This episode is part of a new series in partnership with The Daily Wire featuring in-depth discussions with PragerU experts about their 5-minute video topic.
Watch James's 5-Minute Video, "What Is Critical Race Theory?" https://www.prageru.com/video/what-is-critical-race-theory/
welcome to office hours i'm georgia howe
today we sit down with phd mathematician
author and founder of new discourses
james lindsey
james's new prageru video is titled what
is critical race theory
where he breaks down the controversial
theory that is dominating educational
institutions across the united states
while many people proclaim that critical
race theory is the continuation of the
civil rights movement
james explains why it is actually
fundamentally opposed to the great civil
rights movement of the 1960s let's jump
right in
[Music]
james thank you so much for joining me
hey thanks for having me
so i'm actually a huge fan i read your
book cynical theories
i watch a ton of your interviews so i'm
really pumped to have you here
oh that's exciting to hear thanks yeah
so something you brought up in the video
is that critical race theory is
explicitly anti-american
i want to play a quick clip and then i
have a question for you
here it is in the words of richard
delgado and gene stefancik
two leading proponents critical race
theory questions the very foundations of
the liberal order
including equality theory legal
reasoning enlightenment rationalism
and the neutral principles of
constitutional law critical race theory
therefore is not a continuation
of the civil rights movement it is in
fact a repudiation of it
to critical race theorists martin luther
king was both wrong and naive
white americans can never judge blacks
by the content of their character
they can only judge them always
unfavorably consciously
or unconsciously by the color of their
skin
the premise of critical race theory is
totally antithetical to what martin
luther king stood for
in terms of judging people by the
content of their character and not by
the color of their skin
and yet so many people millions of
people have been hoodwinked into
believing that this is the continuation
of the civil rights movement
how did that happen they've done a
really good job of branding themselves
as the
unique pathway to anti-racism they've
also branded themselves as the
inheritors of the civil rights movement
and the people who were seeing how the
civil rights movement
wasn't able to accomplish everything in
a fundamentally racist society
so they needed to propose a new way to
take it as they say beyond traditional
approaches to civil rights
into a new way that then kind of throws
the whole thing
out and and you know comes at it from
exactly the opposite premise
um the the it's very no it's not well
known but it's a very famous thing that
back in the 1960s they would march
in the civil rights movement with
placards that read i am a man
not i'm a black man you know they
weren't they weren't proclaiming their
their identity first
but if you actually read the civil uh
the critical
race theory literature you find them
saying things like
there's a fundamental difference between
a statement like i am black and i am a
person who happens to be black
because the second of those i am a
person who happens to be black puts
humanity
first and identity second whereas i am
black puts identity front and center and
allows it to be useful for a very
different kind of identity politics
that rejects what the civil rights
movement was all about in the first
place
well yeah i think of that iconic sign i
think that was the like maybe 1968 it
was the
memphis garbage workers protest and the
entire idea
of that sign was to emphasize the common
humanity
of those garbage workers with all the
other men or humans in society so
it's amazing actually how completely
completely opposite
this new approach is critical race
theory has been
really successful because it exploits
our achilles heel as a liberal society
um it really speaks to the things that
we're concerned about here
like justice and fairness and it really
hacks into human psychology
in a really genius way and once you
start to understand how it works
you start to see why people have really
latched onto it
does critical race theory have any
weaknesses
yeah it has actually a number of
weaknesses that are pretty easy to
exploit number one is that the the depth
of their analysis isn't very
isn't very deep at all so it's actually
if you spend just a little bit of time
with it it starts to become easy to see
through it
it becomes very easy to see that it's a
manipulation it doesn't have again very
much depth at all
so for example once people realize that
they say things that critical race
theory is a movement designed to reject
the fundamental tenets of the liberal
order all of a sudden the spell that oh
this is the liberal side of things
falls away when they say that we reject
equality theory this is straight out of
one of their books
then people say wait a minute but i
thought equality was the point
when they say things like that they
reject enlightenment rationalism legal
reasoning rule of law
the neutral principle of constitutional
law people get upset a little
uncomfortable with this so this opens a
door for people to say wait a minute
this isn't
what you're selling me right there's a
you're selling me a nice picture on the
outside of the box
but what's inside is garbage and then
it's already to the point where the
majority
of people who aren't caught in its sway
no longer if somebody says you're you're
a racist you're upholding white
supremacy they they don't go along with
it anymore so it's already to that point
where people are realizing that it's a
manipulation or even an extortion that's
being pulled on them from false premises
so it's weaknesses and it's in its
shallowness and
in fact it's cruelty and its willingness
to to be racist you know
one of the biggest cracks in the armor
has come up just recently this year
where there's rampant
anti-asian-american racism being
perpetrated and then defended
from within critical race theory by
saying that what needs to happen is that
the asians need to recognize that what's
really happening to them is white
supremacy
and that they have to then you know
interrogate their own anti-blackness
instead of the the clear things that are
actually happening to them right in
front of their own eyes and
asians by the way asian americans
especially immigrants from countries
like china
and vietnam are not really likely to
fall for this
they're not going to have it wait
explain that again so
this is their their own internalized
anti-blackness that is manifesting
as anti-asian uh discrimination
critical race theory holds that every
race that isn't
black and every political position that
isn't critical race theory
is inherently anti-blackness that's one
of its very simplistic assumptions
everything that's not it is anti-black
that's what they position
and so you end up with people like kanye
west who happens to be black
putting on a maga hat and saying i think
for myself and tana hissy coates writing
you know a day later um you're not black
anymore you have joe biden standing up
and saying if you don't vote for me you
ain't black
you know this kind of thing that they've
got this whole idea that everything
that's not
their ideology equals anti-blackness so
now you have
you have asian americans getting beat up
in the street they're hiding the fact
that many of these crimes not all but
most are being perpetrated by
black individuals and then they're
telling the asian community that you
have to
if you call for police that's you being
anti-black if you call these people out
that's you being anti-black
then they try to to leverage this idea
that asian americans must have
anti-blackness as well
and that they uphold white supremacy and
it's just ludicrously
cartoonish at this point for people to
have to deny the evidence of their eyes
and what's actually happening to them
uh meanwhile they're getting
discriminated against in schools and
that's being justified also in exactly
the same premises and
they're supposed to just ignore this and
pretend that it's not a thing and it
doesn't work
at a certain point the shallowness is
revealed
so you may you sound pretty optimistic
that you think there is a shift in our
consciousness about what's going on
i mean you know i do a lot of coverage
of uh some of the stuff going on in k-12
schools and i still see a lot of parents
are
afraid to speak up at these school board
meetings mostly because they'll be
called racist no matter what they're
opposing
pornography in schools most recently um
would you say that you think the
majority of people are starting to see
this or like
do you think we have a lot of silent
people what do you think is going on
for me more people are aware of it than
i
thought would be by this point as a
matter of fact nobody was supposed to be
aware of what was going on they're
supposed to everybody's supposed to be
way behind and not even clear on what's
going on
at this point in the progression if you
think of how they they've used this to
try to move through society and
lots of people are people are still
silent but people are also starting to
speak up
and we're starting to see people realize
i have to say something now it's not
going to burn out it's not going to go
away on its own
and that courage begs more courage and
i've been seeing this kind of snowball
of courage begin to roll
now the institutions are very heavily
captured and they're way behind
they're going to lag behind all of the
the stuff that's happening on the ground
but there's a lot of energy right now i
keep hearing from from political
candidates that are telling me in
different races
how much energy there is when they bring
up the idea that they're going to
challenge critical race theory and take
critical race theory out of our schools
out of our workplaces out of our federal
apparatuses out of the military like tom
cotton is attempting to do
so there's a ton of popular energy
behind that and if
politics actually does follow culture
then
the culture is already shifting very
rapidly so you made an interesting
comment about
you said that no one was supposed to be
aware of it by now in its progression
uh is there a sort of plan that you've
uncovered or where are you getting that
from
well i mean yes then it's not really
uncovered
they say it all the time it's in
basically everything they write that
they have this kind of intention to come
in
and infiltrate the institutions it's
sometimes labeled as the long march to
the institutions in the in the words of
rudy deutschke
uh and the the idea has been for a while
to mainstream this stuff and to push
this stuff
you know we're seeing these new
revelations about cnn and how they're
implicated in some of this and
the idea with the long march of the
institutions is that this goes back a
hundred years to antonio gramsci i
didn't don't mean to get heavily
philosophical with you but
the idea was to get inside of the
institutions and create a counter
hegemony a counterculture within the
institutions and then have it all burst
out at once
and that depends on the people not
knowing what's happening to them that
depends on using words in incorrect ways
or novel ways
so they don't realize what's happening
and something obscure like
critical race theory this is very
academic theory that uses very thick
academic jargon
and published in academic literature
that nobody reads
it wasn't supposed to have a public
groundswell against it
according to the people who wanted to
infiltrate the institutions and install
it at the level of policy
before people would be able to push back
against it it felt like critical race
theory really
kind of went mainstream around the early
2010s
um i was actually working on education
at that time and i got a little preview
of it
working in schools but it felt like it
really burst into the mainstream like on
university campuses and um in the news
around maybe 2012.
do you have any theories about why we
were so vulnerable to it at that moment
in time
i mean a lot of things were happening
then one of course is the
the quick rise of internet platforms
like blogging platforms and social media
that allowed
for very different capacities for
communication i guess
and so there's those kind of structural
issues
there's also the fact that uh it was
able to be mainstreamed on the back of
the reaction
there was a racist reaction that arose
when barack obama was
elected president in 2008 and that was
very easily spun into a narrative that
says look how secretly racist
american society really has been they
can't handle the first black president
and that narrative though that america
is secretly racist
is the heartbeat of critical race theory
so it was able to kind of start
mainstreaming there
uh also we had come to a point where the
march into the educational institutions
had
largely born fruit they had gained most
of the administrative and institutional
um positions of power in our education
system and our teaching colleges
and in universities by the early 2010s
furthermore the the theory had kind of
matured it was kind of
you know when they first came out people
would have to say well according to
critical race theory or in
critical race theory this they'd have to
you know remark upon the idea that
they're using a theoretical end so about
2010 or so in the literature
you see that's kind of stop and they
just say the things that critical race
theory says as though they're just true
and so there is a maturity of the theory
all kind of coming to the to a head at
that point as well
something i heard you say in a past
interview is that critical race theory
is like a vat of strong acid and it kind
of
dissolves anything you put in it can you
explain that a little bit
yeah i mean that's the idea of a
critical theory in general is that it's
supposed to tear at the
it's supposed to find and tear out the
alleged contradictions and everything so
it's supposed to pull up moral
contradictions you know we're supposed
to be a country that lives up to all men
are created equal
well look how unequal things are look
how how inequitable outcomes are so it
go
anything it attaches to it kind of eats
away
at it morally it also eats away at the
claims that it's looking into the
underlying assumptions and tries to eat
away
at those things it tries to take um
founding principles and kind of pervert
them
uh to say that those those values either
are never never meant to be lived up to
or that in fact they
they hide or mask white supremacy so it
slowly eats away at anything that's the
point of a critical theory
is to dissolve the fundamental like at
the level of
understanding the thing itself like
understanding who you are as an
individual understanding who you are
as a company or an institution it's like
dissolving those fundamental uh
values at the very basic level so that
you don't really have that principled
position where you can stand in yourself
and feel confident in yourself and say
no
you know this really we were on the
right track they try to get into that
and dissolve
everything by by this tool of
problematizing saying
here's where it falls short here's where
it's not perfect here's where it causes
harm
here's where you know one thing after
another after another revealing the
so-called contradictions
within everything so you sound a little
bit optimistic which i like
how hopeful are you in terms of our
ability to withstand this ideology here
in the us
we we are at an inflection point
actually if you would have asked me two
months ago i would have been much more
pessimistic
uh like i said this groundswell people
realizing that they can have courage
that they can speak up and some of them
will be removed from their positions or
lose their jobs
or be subjected to trials but in the end
that if each person who stands up you
know it creates a possibility to push
back against this you see the
the the person in allison collins and
the san francisco school
board for example is actually there's
something is moving there it was not an
easy fight
but she's being stripped of her power
and may end up recalled so we're
starting to see the ability to push back
wake up so i am a little bit more
optimistic than i was but i think we're
at a crucial
inflection point where we have to start
to remember what our values are
we have to remember who we are we have
to remember what we stand for as a
country
and that we stand best united genuine
unity not
what we're trying to have sold to us you
know um
and so i don't know but i still stand by
the claim
that if we keep allowing critical theory
to be mainstream and
dominant if we keep giving in to its
manipulations and tolerating its
manipulations
then eventually it will dissolve our the
the
sinews of our society and american
civilization it can happen here will
fall apart
western civilization will fall apart
well thank you so much james where can
people find you online
they can find me personally on most
social media outlets at conceptual james
my company is new discourses it's at
newdiscourses.com and it's on most
social media
at new discourses if you enjoyed this
conversation and want to hear more from
james lindsey
make sure to go out and pick up a copy
of his book cynical theories
and that's the end of today's office
hours make sure to tune in next week for
our conversation with a new prageru
presenter
i'm georgia howe thanks for tuning in
[Music]
thanks for watching this episode of
office hours if you'd like to watch more
interviews with prageru presenters
head over to dailywire.com subscribe and
become a member today
you
