Lecture 28

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Oct 23, 2023
Hello everyone, let us start lecture 28 and the course is corrosion protection methods.
And if we observe carefully for the last few lecture, we have been talking about effect
of environmental factors and associated corrosion behavior and subsequently corrosion protection.
We have talked about removal of corrosives and then we talked on the effect of oxidants
or oxidizers on the active metal as well as passive metal.
And we have seen that if we add oxidants in case of active metal, corrosion rate increases,
so their removal of oxidant would be helpful.
But in case of active passive metal, at times addition of oxidizer can be helpful to get
better protection because it will take the material into the stable passive range quite
easily.
Now, today we will talk about the effect of concentration of corrosive and here we are
not talking about oxidizers, here we are talking about only the corrosive.
For example, HCl is a corrosive, then we can talk about HNO3 as a corrosive, there
what happens if we increase the concentration.
Now we will also talk about effect of temperature, at times temperature increment can actually
reduce corrosion rate.
Now that is very specific to certain cases, that is very specific and we will have some
examples.
But most of the cases, almost all the cases increase in temperature actually increases
the corrosion rate, so if we have a low temperature corrosion protection is better.
So we will talk about and discuss those cases with lot of examples.
So let us at the same time we will also talk about effect of velocity because in most in
many of those practical applications, the solution or the electrolyte is not stagnant
rather those are flowing electrolytes and those cases situation could be different,
it is not like what happens in stagnant condition.
Sometimes increase in velocity helps in reducing the corrosion rate, for example crevice as
well as pitting corrosion that can be reduced if we have if we maintain certain velocity.
But in certain cases, we can actually increase the corrosion rate if we increase the velocity,
so those instances also we will try to look at.
Now when we talk about velocity, we would have to also look at, we have to look at the
mechanism, if the mechanism for corrosion is guided by the concentration polarization,
the situation could be something, but if it is guided by the activation polarization then
situation could be something and apart from that of course the velocity or the abrasion
part would come in where erosion becomes important.
So we will talk about those things in our following discussion.
So let us look at effect of change in concentration of corrosive or rather increase in concentration
of corrosive.
So we will have some examples, generally the curve pattern could be of this nature if we
try to find out the corrosion rate, this is the concentration, it is increasing this way.
In certain metals, the pattern looks like this and then once certain critical value
is achieved, the concentration value, then the corrosion rate increases at times exponentially.
So this is one sort of behavior, so we can see that there are two segments.
One is this one, segment 1 and there is another segment starting from this, so this is segment
2.
Now this kind of behavior we can notice, let us say in case of segment 1 where we can see
nickel in NaOH or 18, 8 stainless steel in HNO3.
Now in this case, this nickel if you dip, if we dip nickel in NaOH or dip 18, 8 stainless
steel in HNO3, immediately those alloys or metals will get to the spontaneous passive
zone.
So there is a passive zone will be achieved very quickly and then definitely it will maintain
that passive zone, it will, that material will be maintained in the passive zone for
a wide range of concentration and this particular thing is also related to the mixed potential
theory.
In brief, if we try to look at the mixed potential theory and this happens in case of active
passive metal, so this is potential voltage and then log i ampere per centimeter square.
Now if I try to look at the active passive metal, so it will have a curve like this,
so this anodic part, so it is going through active zone and then passivity is achieved
and then trans-passive starts.
So this is trans-passive, this zone is passive and then this zone is, if I try to look at
the equilibrium potential for the metal in that solution, equilibrium metal which is
dissolving in the anodic part.
So this is metal minus n e equal to m n plus, this particular current density corresponding
corresponds to I p which is the lowest current in that particular anodic part.
Of course let us not look at, if I try to see the interaction with the cathodic reaction
then this can be sometimes the lowest current density.
For example, if a cathodic current, then cathodic part interacts here, then this is
the cathodic part which is corresponding to IC, so then this becomes ICot.
Now if this reaction interacts here, so then definitely this is my IC, this is equilibrium
for cathodic reaction and this is cathodic reaction 1 prime for one type of cathodic
reaction and this is E equilibrium for cathodic reaction, let us say double prime, fine.
So in one case the potential equilibrium potential for the cathodic reaction is very high in
that potential axis.
Now we could see that if we compare these two situations as per Mc potential theory,
we have a very high corrosion rate which is located at this location, fine.
So there corrosion rate would be very high, but somehow if we have some other oxidation,
some other reduction process or cathodic polarization line that interacts the anodic polarization
line in the passive zone, then of course this becomes my ICorr which is equal to IP
or the passive current density which is much lower than the ICorr what we have observed
in case of situation where cathodic reaction polarization line and anodic reaction polarization
line they interacts at in the active zone, but here it is interacting in the passive
zone.
So we want this thing to happen in case of passive material, active passive material
because once we achieve passivity it can maintain at a maintain very low corrosion rate at the
same time if we somehow choose a if somehow that material shows a wide range of passivity
in a particular electrolyte where this material is going to be used, then definitely that
passivity will be maintained for a long long time as well as over the wide range of concentration
it can be it can maintain passivity, why rather how?
So if we try to see this if we increase the concentration let us say this is my concentration
initial concentration if we increase the concentration I know that if I try to look at the critical
concentration which will be crossing the I critical if we go back to our lecture 27 you
will get to know the importance of this I critical.
So this is just bypassing the I critical point which is the maximum point in the while
it the metal achieves while the metal goes or changes from active zone to the passive
zone.
So once it crosses then it this particular concentration of that particular corrosive
would allow the metal to get into the passive zone of course it has to cross that I critical
it should not touch it rather it should bypass it.
Now from this concentration as we increase the concentration just like increasing the
oxidant concentration the equilibrium potential goes up and up till this up till this it can
actually maintain passivity, but if we see that in that particular environment my passive
zone length is very high let us say this is my passive zone length instead of breaking
here okay.
So if this is the passive zone which is a wide range of passive zone okay.
So then I could see that this will be my limiting concentration of the corrosive where it can
if where if we increase the concentration little bit then it will reach to the trans
passive zone.
So we can see the from this concentration to this concentration level over a wide range
I can maintain spontaneous passivity that material will go to the spontaneous passivity
and then passivity will be maintained.
So that is what if we see that between this particular concentration zone I always maintain
the corrosion rate at a fixed value which is IP.
So that is what it is flat this particular flat zone is observed this particular zone
is observed and that happens in case of nickel one two such examples nickel in NaOH or 18
8 chromium and HNO3.
So there over a wide range of concentration the material can remain in the passive zone.
So that is what you have a constant current density equal to I passive and the corrosion
rate also remains almost constant.
Now if we in some cases it can follow both 1 and 2 okay and this happens when the material
shows low corrosion rate because of some surface film formation at a lower concentration of
the corrosive but at a higher concentration of corrosive that film can be soluble and
then once that high concentration corrosive dissolves that passive layer or not passive
layer is a kind of protective layer here immediately we can get to see a kind of exponential rise
in corrosion rate that happens one such example is lead in H2SO4.
So at low concentration of H2SO4 we can have PbSO4 or sometimes it can also form PbO film
but once concentration of H2SO4 goes up at some critical value this particular phase
dissolves.
So that means the bare metal surface is exposed and the material corrosion rate further increases
and sometimes it becomes exponential rise.
So that particular pattern is observed in case of lead in lead pipe let's say consider
lead pipe carrying H2SO4 at a low concentration it can maintain low corrosion rate but at
a high concentration definitely lead becomes highly soluble okay corrosion rate further
increases.
So that's what these two pattern can be observed in case of lead starting from low concentration
of H2SO4 to high concentration of H2SO4.
Now there could be one more pattern that can be possible so initially it's actually gradually
increases corrosion rate as the concentration of the corrosive increases and then suddenly
it drops and then it maintains a constant value okay.
So this kind of pattern can be observed okay.
So this let's say this is pattern A and let's say this is pattern B in pattern A we have
two segments one segment we have seen nickel in NaOH or 18,8 in 18,8 stainless steel in
HNO3 and pattern A with the segment of 1 and 2 Pb or the lead in H2SO4 can follow that
but pattern B is followed if the example let us say so these two cases are pattern
A.
So as we increase the concentration of the corrosive we have increase in corrosion rate
and then gradually the corrosion rate decreases and then reaches to the plateau.
So these happens in case of mainly acid solution let's say one such example is 18,8 stainless
steel in H2SO4 or another example is Fe in H2SO4.
So what happens as concentration increases H plus ion concentration also increases.
So as H plus ion concentration increases so that means equilibrium potential for hydrogen
also increases because hydrogen ion concentration is increasing and hence I would see because
hydrogen ion is basically an oxidant and we are increasing the oxidant concentration corrosion
rate increases.
But once the concentration reaches certain limit, limiting concentration the ionization
of acid decreases.
So once ionization of the acid decreases because of the increase in concentration hydrogen
ion generation also decreases.
So that means as hydrogen ion generation decreases and with increase in further concentration
the ionization becomes very limited.
So that's why at times for example iron plain carbon steel if we hold a concentrated H2SO4
we get to see a very, very low corrosion rate of iron because of the very situation
that concentrated H2SO4 doesn't ionize much and of course it is at ambient temperature.
It's not at a high temperature, the room temperature or low temperature.
So that case because we don't have hydrogen ion which is basically the source for reduction
process to happen and here we don't, we should not have dissolve oxygen fine.
So only hydrogen ion reduction is the cathodic reaction.
So if we don't have much of a hydrogen ion concentration definitely the rate of dissolution
of iron would also go down.
So it will be, it will be protected.
So this is the case where we can see the pattern B gradually increases because of the ionization
of the acid at certain limit of the concentration ionization start decreasing and at a very
high concentration ionization becomes very limited.
So then we don't have the active species for reduction process and the corrosion rate
of that metal decreases.
Now as you see that the behavior of the metal in a particular electrolyte could be different
as we increase the concentration and here we are not talking about the oxidants.
Now those behavior should be known beforehand and that's what experimentation in corrosion
protection is very much needed.
Now here you could see that certain metal like 18H stainless steel or nickel in NaOH
or 18H stainless steel in HNO3 at room temperature it can maintain very low corrosion rate.
Over a wide range of concentration of those corrosives.
But in case of lead interestingly though it gives you a very good protection at a low
concentration of H2SO4 but once the concentration goes up at and reaches critical value and
beyond that increase in corrosion can dissolve the corrosion product or the product that
is forming on top of it and that gives you the protection which is lead sulfate or lead
oxide and that can be dissolved at a higher concentration of H2SO4.
So then it will expose the surface and it will dissolve quickly.
So what condition will lead to a better corrosion protection or in other way low corrosion rate
or maintain low corrosion rate we should do a lot of experimentation in the lab scale
as well as in the pilot scale so that we have a better idea and then we go for change of
environment accordingly.
So now if I talk about temperature, temperature effect interestingly almost all the metals
if we increase temperature the corrosion rate increases exponentially.
Now why because all the corrosion is involving electrochemical reactions and electrochemical
reaction any chemical reactions with increase in temperature the rate generally increases.
So that is what the corrosion rate is also, corrosion rate also increases.
So that is what maintaining low temperature is better for better protection of metals
and alloys for better corrosion, corrosion protection.
So what I am saying that lower temperature would give you a better protection corrosion
protection for metals and alloys.
Now it does not mean that at a lower corrosion lower temperature though it gives you a better
protection from corrosion point of view, but it can lead to some other aspects like DVDT
or ductile brittle transition can happen at a low temperature and then the material can
be very brittle.
So that instance needs to be also considered.
We are only talking about corrosion point of view.
So hence decreasing temperature would lead to a better protection or low corrosion rate.
So if I try to look at the graph let's say temperature increases and corrosion rate so
it would also increase like it would increase at a very high rate exponentially.
Now in some cases with increase in temperature there could be a limited effect, but once
the temperature goes up beyond certain limit the corrosion rate can shoot up.
So it can be like this.
So let's say it maintains a low corrosion rate up to certain temperature range and then
suddenly it shoots up.
So this particular behavior can also be observed.
So that means we have two pattern one is pattern A and one is pattern B. So pattern A let's
say we can have examples of pattern A mainly in case of active metals this pattern A is
very much observed like nickel in HCl or iron in HF.
There could be a rapid corrosion in those solutions if we increase temperature.
Now pattern B can be observed in case of active passive metal let's say 18-8 in HNO3.
So this is interesting this is also can be explained with reference to mixed potential
theory.
What happens this HNO3 can have several reduction potential standard reduction potential.
So depending on the temperature its oxidizing ability increases.
So that means what do I mean by oxidizing ability increases with temperature increment.
Now let's say metal 1 and metal 2 at let's say ambient temperature, temperature 1 I could
have E0 value and here also I could have 1 E0 value.
So these two values are there at ambient temperature or temperature 1.
Now there could be possibility that this is little let's say if we consider reduction
potential.
So now if E0 M1 n plus M is greater than E0 M2 n plus M so here n plus is nothing
but I am talking about two reaction reduction reaction one is n plus plus n e equal to M1
M2 n plus plus n e equal to M2.
So both the cases their oxidation numbers are same.
Now if such situation arises at a particular temperature we can say that M1 has a higher
reduction reduction ability okay it as compared to n2.
It means that M1 ion n plus ion if it is present and M2 n plus ion if it is also present along
with M1 n plus then M1 n plus has higher ability to get reduced and then deposit on
the metal on the metal surface.
Now when we talk about this let's say if we consider n1 n plus plus M2 equal to M1 plus
M2 n plus.
So this would be reaction then because M1 n plus has got M1 has higher reduction potential
compared to M2.
So it goes to this so reduction and this one goes to this is oxidation for anodic process
because it's releasing n electron which are taken by M1 n plus.
Now we can say that this is oxidant and this is reductant.
Now we could see that when we have this reaction now we see that M1 has higher reduction ability
compared to M2 as well as we have written the equation where M1 n plus is acting like
oxidant and M2 is acting like a reductant and that's what we have redox reaction reduction
as well as oxidation.
Now when we have such situation we can also say that this one is actually oxidizing M2
but M1 n plus is getting reduced.
So M2 is reducing M1 plus so we can say M1 n plus oxidizes M2 and M2 reduces M1 n plus
and since M1 n plus has got a higher reduction ability so that means it should have higher
M1 n plus has a higher oxidizing ability oxidizing ability means it can oxidize other
metal with a lower reduction potential.
So here oxidizing ability means that particular acid this is a very strong oxidant and all
the oxidants have reduction oxidizing ability of other metal okay so that's what exactly
happens here.
So what happens as per mixed potential theory for active passive metal I can have a plot
like this so this is my active metal.
So now as per the previous understanding we are not writing all those details.
So this is the active passive metal anodic part or anodic polarization part and we see
a passive zone which is this one the passive zone, this one is basically the active zone
passive and then this is transpassive.
Now in this case initially the material is in passive zone so it maintains passivity
or let's say here it maintains passivity.
Now interesting is this is the cathodic part corresponding to IC or the cathodic current
density.
Now the corrosion rate would be here which is ICorr equal to IP since this is IP as per
mixed potential theory.
Now this particular point lies very close to this transpassive zone this particular
point.
Now if we increase temperature what happens the oxidizing power increases as we have seen
that a higher reduction potential means higher oxidizing power.
So oxidizing power increases means its reduction potential also increases.
So the reduction potential goes up okay.
Now since it is close to and as we go up it will have its own corresponding polarization
plot and we could see that it's cutting at different location and it is quickly getting
into the transpassive zone.
After maintaining this passive portion then it goes to transpassive zone definitely once
it goes to transpassive zone the corrosion rate again increases.
So now this is the behavior what we could see here, what we could see here.
So now here what happens initially up till this it maintains passive zone and as the
reduction oxidizing ability increases the reduction potential goes up, reduction potential
is going up and corresponding cathodic polarization line is cutting the active passive anodic
part initially in the passive zone and then goes into active zone which is nothing but
the transpassive zone.
So that's what the corrosion rate again increases like this.
So this is a typical of 18-8 stainless steel in HNO3.
So this is the effect of increasing oxidizing ability of the corrosive with temperature
or with increase in temperature.
So this happens there.
So this and that means we could see two aspects, one is ever increasing corrosion rate with
temperature and this happens in case of active metal since the reaction rate also increases
with temperature.
The second case there could be sudden increase in corrosion rate with temperature, temperature
increase definitely both the cases because of increase in oxidizing ability.
So there could be third instance where we can get decrease in corrosion rate with increase
in temperature.
So that instance is observed if we consider iron in seawater or freshwater.
So with increase in temperature if dissolve oxygen removes is removed actually.
So in temperature increases, dissolve oxygen concentration decreases and we know that oxygen
is basically the reduction oxidant which actually gets reduced and then that is the reduction
process it can be O2 plus 2H2O plus 4E equal to 4OH minus.
So if this concentration decreases so the reaction would not go at a higher rate definitely
the corrosion rate also would decrease.
So it's basically the deaeration effect of the medium or the electrolyte.
So there could be possibility of decrease in corrosion rate because you are removing
the active oxidant from the medium or the electrolyte.
So this is about effect of temperature on the corrosion rate.
So we can sense that there could be possibility of almost all cases the possibility of having
low corrosion or a better corrosion protection at a lower temperature.
But in some instances even with increase in temperature there could be possibility of
maintenance of very low temperature that but once the temperature crosses certain limit
it actually gets to a very active dissolution and that happens in case of active passive
metals as we have seen in the back in case of 18H stainless steel in HNO3.
But there could be possibility of also decrease in corrosion rate because of removal of corrosive
again here at the removal of corrosive happens because of increase in temperature.
So we will talk about one more important aspect which is the influence of velocity of that
fluid or the electrolyte on the metal corrosion and we can see whether there could be a possibility
of betterment in corrosion protection.
Till then thank you.
