Produite, réalisée et écrite par le Québécois Mathieu Côté-Desjardins, cette websérie documentaire de 2010 (sélectionnée aux Prix Gémeaux comme finaliste en 2011) suit le créateur de la série étant nouvel enseignant fraîchement sorti de l'université. Dès les premiers jours de classe, il s'est demandé comment on pouvait offrir si peu de qualité aux jeunes. Puisant dans ses quelques expériences en cinéma et son maigre salaire de nouveau prof (et d'un emprunt bancaire de plusieurs dizaines de milliers de dollars), il décide de s'acheter une caméra vidéo, ce qu'il faut pour faire du montage et se met à filmer divers entretiens divers intervenants du système scolaire (et d'autres nullement liés à ce domaine). « Suis-je fou de penser que le système scolaire n'a aucun sens » ? Exutoire et thérapie sous format documentaire qui fut le premier pan dans sa quête de percer le mystère de la véritable éducation. La saison 2, intitulée LA RÉÉDUCATION, se trouve également sur cette même chaîne.
First of all, it's about reading.
Students are currently graduating from the Department of Education
as perfect educators.
When I say perfect educators,
I mean all sorts of banal people who come from California
and repeat what was said before in California.
Everyone looks at them and says,
California is so beautiful.
But in fact, if they started reading a little bit
of the great progressive educators who existed,
like Frenet, Macarenco, people like that,
they would see that they had developed other pedagogies.
It continued.
Even in the United States, which is currently the country
with the highest rate of education,
you have extraordinary pedagogues in critical pedagogy.
But critical pedagogy is not taught at the university.
It's not part of the official courses.
There are teachers who will talk about it from time to time.
But very few.
These teachers, in general,
they get beaten up regularly.
There are certain places,
like the Environment Education Laboratory,
where they are concerned about that.
It's interesting what's going on there.
But courses at the university?
Oh no!
Courses at the university,
it's not a question of having a course at the university.
I don't know how it's done,
but it looks like it shouldn't be done.
It's not important enough.
French is very important.
Me too, I think French is important.
But...
First of all, stop focusing on
the sacrosanct program of mathematics and French
as if not doing French or grammar rules
for a while was the end of the world.
Children will start learning a lot more
if they like school.
And so, for them to like school,
the class has to function in a pleasant way.
So don't sit in a mess in a classroom
and everyone shows up in a hurry.
And often, young teachers come in
and they want to teach so much from the first day
that the mess catches them immediately.
Because normally, in classes,
often like some schools I know,
you have to take a good month at the beginning of the year
to put the group in your hands.
Sorry for the expression,
but that means to have a relationship with the group
and for the children to understand that when someone speaks,
we raise our hand,
we listen to the others when they speak.
And that takes a good month.
And during that time,
we don't do a lot of French and not a lot of math.
Maybe we do a little, but not a lot.
But once the month is over
and the children understand that in class,
you have to respect each other
and that it's nicer if we listen than if we don't.
And if you speak alone,
it's not interesting if the others don't hear you.
So vice versa.
When they understand that,
the children start to have fun
and to have a more motivated reaction.
So that would already be an extraordinary thing,
that the teachers take a good month
to make a good class cooperative,
to set up what they call today
councils.
I don't remember.
It doesn't matter.
The real term is a class cooperative.
It was Frenet who invented that.
It's been a while.
We tried to reinvent words around that.
It means that you manage your problems
in a group in class.
And when one wants to annoy the others,
it's discussed in a group,
and the solution is taken in a group.
And it's not always the teacher's punishment
that's going to be the best solution.
It's often the reaction of all the students
to the chaos that will make them stop.
Twenty-five against one,
when one wants to impose his law
and the children stop being divided,
it stops right away.
It's extraordinary.
But we don't do it.
We don't do it.
There are so many specialists
who, right away,
when a child has a problem,
you identify it by saying,
well, he's a TTC,
he's a TTD,
he's a TH.
You know,
when you put your stamp on the front like that,
you have all the reasons in the world
to kick the child out of your class.
You're not going to be able to take care of him.
You're not going to be able to teach him anything.
He's a TED.
Well, when you want a TED,
that's it.
This argument
is contrary
to all scientific discoveries in psychology,
starting with what Skenner did in his time.
Skenner showed things to earthworms.
He was able to teach them to earthworms.
And now, frankly,
you know,
and mice,
and things like that,
he had no problem.
And he lobotomized them.
He took lobotomized people,
he taught them a lot of things.
It was really because
he believed
that everyone is able to learn.
And when you believe that everyone is able to learn,
it's all the difference in the world
that when you identify that the child is topsy-turvy,
if you identify that he's topsy-turvy,
you're going to act like he's topsy-turvy.
If you identify that he's sky-high,
you're going to teach him things
all the time he's going to be with you.
And he's going to progress, progress, progress.
And he's going to progress beyond
everything you can have as a pseudo-principle
as to why children are topsy-turvy.
Those are two currents in science
that are irreconcilable.
And those are currents where
the demonstration was made.
Every time someone said someone was topsy-turvy,
was it funny?
It wasn't true.
It was enough for someone to believe it
for the child, or even the adult,
to start learning, developing, etc.
We say, everything is finished by five years.
What is this stupid principle?
Everything is finished at five years.
Let's see. It's not true.
It's true that when you're young,
it's important to have apprentices,
and it's absolutely true.
And when you have a good support
from zero to five years old,
it's much easier.
But when you take a teenager
who gets to 13, 14 years old,
well, a teenager can look like
a deep idiot when he's drunk.
And if you give him a taste,
you'll see, at some point,
he's going to wake up,
and it's going to go fast, fast, fast.
And that's true for anyone in life.
When at some point you wake someone up,
when you hook him up to something,
he's going to start shining.
So, I think we are
black students in education
in many cases.
Not everyone. There are extraordinary teachers.
That, let's face it,
and that's very clear as far as it concerns me,
I've seen plenty of extraordinary teachers.