Ukrainian Forces Destroy Russian Tanks with Javelin Missiles

China Insider TV
242 người theo dõi
14 thg 3, 2023
Russia's tanks were once seen as fearsome, formidable threats, but the war in Ukraine shows it doesn't know how to use them, or that Ukraine possesses a weapon that is more powerful than Russia's ability to counter it in this conflict.
Among the most noticeable weapons credited with standing up to overwhelming waves of Russian tanks has been a state-of-the-art, infantry-operated guided missile. The Americans who produced it call it the FGM-148 AAWS-M (for “Advanced Antitank Weapon System-Medium”), but many of its current users have come to call it “Saint Javelin, Protector of Ukraine.”
Russia's tanks were once seen as fearsome, formidable threats, but the war in Ukraine
shows it doesn't know how to use them or that Ukraine possesses a weapon that is more
powerful than Russia's ability to counter it in this conflict.
Among the most noticeable weapons credited with standing up to overwhelming waves of
Russian tanks has been a state-of-the-art, infantry-operated guided missile.
The Americans who produced it call it the FGM-148 AAWSM for Advanced Anti-Tank Weapon
System Medium, but many of its current users have come to call it St. Javelin, Protector
of Ukraine.
The Russian tank force has taken a beating.
U.S. officials have said on more than one occasion that Russia has likely lost as many
as half its main battle tanks while fighting in Ukraine, if not more.
According to an open-source intelligence analysis by Oryx, more than 1,780 Russian tanks have
been destroyed, damaged, captured, or abandoned since Moscow launched its invasion in February
2022.
Russia's staggering tank losses, which include the T-72, T-64, T-80, and T-90 tanks, can
be attributed to its failure to provide adequate fire support in combat, military experts told
Insider.
The Russian tank force has also shown extremely little adaptability and common sense.
These problems were underscored during a recent tank battle near the eastern Ukrainian
town of Volodar, where Russia lost scores of tanks and armored vehicles.
Moscow repeated detrimental mistakes it made during its assault on Kiev in the early days
of the war.
It sent columns of tanks straight into Ukrainian ambushes.
Russian tanks have fallen prey to Ukrainian soldiers using anti-tank Javelin missiles
because they're hanging out aimless in open fields, with little to no support or protection.
At the same time, they've been seen driving straight through minefields and exploding.
Due to the design of many of Russia's tanks, a hit can cause the ammunition to detonate,
killing the crew as the overpressure blows the top off.
What is the Javelin?
The FGM-148 entered service in 1996 as a replacement for the M-47 Dragoon.
The latest model is the FGM-148F, and an upgraded FGM-148G is in the works.
Weighing 49 pounds, the Javelin has advanced electronics that have progressively improved
to afford the operator fire-and-forget capability.
Using the attached command launch unit, the operator aims and fires, the missile being
spring-ejected before igniting and traveling on toward the target at a rate of 1,000 feet
every 7 seconds, guided by an infrared seeker in the nose.
Upon contact, the foremost of two tandem high-explosive anti-tank, or HEAT, warheads explodes against
the reactive armor, clearing the way for the second warhead to reach the tank's main
armor.
The Javelin's warheads can penetrate steel up to 23.5 inches to 31.5 inches thick.
With an effective range over 1.5 miles, the Javelin's warhead travels 213 feet before
it arms, but it does produce a backblast that the user must take into account.
Though its range falls below the 2.3-mile effective range of the BGM-71 tube-launched,
optically-guided, wire-guided, or tow-missile, the Javelin is much lighter and handier for
operation by a single-trained infantryman.
Like the TOW, however, it can be mounted on a vehicle if one is available.
How Accurate is the Javelin?
The United States has claimed that of the first 112 Javelins it used, 100 hit the targets,
both directly and on trajectories from above, where tank armor is thinner and more vulnerable
to penetration.
The command launch unit, which can magnify targets up to four times, can be removed from
the weapon system and used as a lightweight optical device and night sight.
Nor is the Javelin without its weaknesses, particularly its vulnerability to losing the
contrast necessary for a missile lock at dawn or dusk, or if the target shoots off clouds
of infrared-blocking smoke.
The principal complaint from Ukrainians about the Javelins, however, is that there never
seem to be enough of them.
They have already received more than 5,500 missiles, and the United States and other
allies have pledged to send more, but they are expensive and time-consuming to produce
6,840 per year at $176,000 per system.
In aiding the Ukrainians, the U.S. has sent off as much as two-thirds of its existing
arsenal, which cannot be immediately replaced.
Fortunately for the Ukrainians, they do have a supplement of other effective light infantry
anti-armor weapons and have become experienced in making every shot count.
Last month, Ukraine is claiming that Russia has lost at least 130 tanks and armored personnel
carriers in a three-week battle near the southern Ukrainian town of Volodar.
Coffee or Die spoke with U.S. Medal of Honor recipient Clint Romshaw about Javelins and
their use in conventional warfare.
Before Romshaw was awarded the Medal of Honor, he was a tanker well-versed in how Javelins
and other anti-tank missiles work against tanks and other types of armor.
He received extensive training while serving in armor roles, taking part in rotations through
Germany and South Korea, training to combat invasions as a tank crew member.
Romshaw said,
All of my training before 2001 was to stop a Russian invasion of Europe.
Romshaw believes Russian tanks and their reactive armor or Javelin shields won't stand up
to a Javelin missile.
He explained that the top side of Russian tank turrets, like most other tanks, are much
thinner in comparison to the other areas of the tank.
Romshaw said that even though the explosive reactive armor may stop some of the Javelin's
penetrating blast, it won't stop all of it.
He said,
It would still have oomph to punch through that and cause crew fires, cause fire control
system malfunctions, he added, it might not put a tank 100% out of commission.
But I do think it would definitely be down and sent back to maintenance to get refit.
It'd be down for a decent portion of a battle.
Romshaw explained that Russian T-72 and T-64 tanks, like the ones seen crossing Ukraine's
borders, store their ammo inside and underneath the tank's turret.
So when an armor-piercing round like the Javelin ignites the stored ammo via its own warhead,
the turret will go flying.
Romshaw said,
Typically, if you see a turret off a tank, that is because of some sort of top attack
round ignited the ammo storage inside that tank.
The evidence of this has appeared in different videos and photos circulating, with one video
highlighting a Russian tank turret that had been popped off.
The original poster of the video said that the popped turret rests in an area outside
of Kharkiv, Ukraine, where heavy fighting is still ongoing.
Javelins have a top attack setting, meaning they can be set to strike a tank in its weakest
spot, the top turret.
Romshaw believes that a metal shield can't prevent a Javelin warhead from penetrating
the tank, and even the reactive armor won't be enough to stop disabling effects.
The reactive armor is meant to prevent a shaped charge, but it's not enough to keep the whole
projectile from punching through the thin top turret armor, Romshaw said.
He said that there are two things a tank crew doesn't want to face in the open, Javelins
and unchallenged air support.
Romshaw said,
If you've got air power above you, a tank is just a sitting duck for that.
You don't want a tank and a fast-moving jet trying to battle each other out.
The tank is going to lose every time.
With Javelins being provided to Ukrainians and the country's air force still flying
in some areas, they maintain a formidable force.
He said,
Now if you could put one guy up on the side of a hill with six fucking Javelin missiles,
you're stopping an entire company of tanks with one guy.
They don't even know where that SH-T is coming from.
He explained that Javelins have a soft launch, so there's no smoke trail to show where they
are being launched from, nor a dirt cloud kicked up by missile backblast.
Romshaw said,
From the time of launch, the tank crew has maybe 10 to 12 seconds to try and evade, but
with the launch location remaining out of sight, there's little chance of evasion.
Romshaw also pointed out that a Javelin rarely misses.
He said it's one of the best fire-and-forget launchers that can be used against armor.
Lockheed Martin, the producer of Javelin missiles, boasts a 94% hit rate on targets with a firing
range anywhere from 65 to 4,000 meters, or about 70 yards to nearly 2.5 miles.
One serious misstep by Russia's military has been its failure to protect its tanks
with a combined-arms approach that provides additional support and integrate its armor
with other units.
There's the structural problem of not having enough dismounted infantry to provide security
for tanks, Jeffrey Edmonds, a Russia expert at the Center for Naval Analyses and former
U.S. Army armor officer, told Insider.
I'm just not seeing units do what you expect military units to do.
Russia is mostly relying on artillery, but would likely benefit from having more air
superiority so it can avoid carrying out complicated maneuvers on the battlefield, Marina Myrin,
a postdoctoral researcher at King's College London's Department of War Studies, told
Insider.
And it's questionable how well Russia's tanks are integrated into its overall operations.
I think that they are kind of fighting a war that they were not prepared for in tactical
and operational terms, Myrin said.
They have lost a lot of tanks.
A lot of them, probably most of them, just because of negligence.
And the tanks they are using are in no way superior to what the Ukrainians are using.
Russia and Ukraine have often squared off against each other using the same Soviet-era
military equipment, encompassing everything from tanks and infantry fighting vehicles
to aircraft.
Ukraine has lost less than 500 tanks throughout the conflict, according to an Oryx tally.
Russia started off with a larger tank force and thus had more to lose.
At the moment, Ukraine is waiting for a wave of advanced Western tanks, including German-made
Leopards and British Challenger II tanks.
These modern systems are better equipped than those that have largely dominated the battlefield
so far.
Even without these advanced systems, Kiev's military has still been able to inflict significant
damage on some of Russia's elite tank forces.
One prestigious unit, the 1st Guards Tank Army, has suffered heavy losses on multiple
occasions while battling against Ukrainian troops.
The Russians are not very good at using the tanks, and they're not very good at integrating
the tanks, Myrin said.
They could have used mechanized infantry to protect tanks, but it seems like they just
don't care.
Another issue plaguing Russia's tank force has been its lack of creativity or maneuverability.
For example, Edmonds explained, Russia has a problem with minefields, as was seen recently
in Volodar.
Clearing a minefield is a slow, complicated, and deliberate process that involves several
steps, but Russian tanks appear to drive right through them.
Some of the tanks blow up, some retreat, and some are hit with anti-tank guided missiles
like the Javelin, and the process just repeats itself when the Ukrainians lay more mines.
Edmonds said, it's just dumb, and you just see them do this over and over again.
He continued, I'm not seeing any tactical-level adaptability.
On one hand, there's no display of basic levels of training, like knowing how to react
to contact.
Additionally, there's no development or innovation from the Russians, which he attributes
in part to Russia's style of warfare, a top-down type of leadership as opposed to
something like the ground-level upwelling of initiative seen in Western militaries.
Edmonds said of the Russian tactics, you would think at this point maybe you would see the
better application of maneuver and combined arms, but I'm not seeing it.
Fortunately for the Ukrainians, they do have a supplement of other effective light infantry
anti-armor weapons and have become experienced in making every shot count.
For the time being, though, the Javelin has acquired so literarily iconic a place in the
Ukrainian arsenal that reports have come in of a local artist creating a piece of mock
traditional religious art depicting Mary Magdalene holding a Javelin.
Newborn Ukrainian babies have reportedly been christened Javelin or Javelina.
Thank you for tuning in to our video.
You can click the like to support our TDTV global team and hit that subscribe button
now for more great content.
Thanks for your support.
We'll catch you at the next one.
