Die Bild am Sonntag hat den Präsidenten der deutschen Industrie- und Handelskammer (Peter Adrian) zum Thema Fachkräftemangel interviewt. Dabei hat dieser unglaubliche Forderungen an das Kitasystem und die Erzieherinnen und Erzieher gestellt. Was Peter Adrian genau fordert schauen wir uns im heutigen Video genauer an.
0:00 - Einleitung 0:55 - Wo wurden diese Aussagen getätigt? 1:34 - Die Aussagen und Forderungen 2:58 - Kitas von 6:30 bis 21:00 Uhr öffnen 3:33 - Was ist mit "bedarfsgerecht" wohl gemeint? 3:58 - Die aktuelle Lage im Kitabereich 5:50 - Auf Arbeitskräfte zurückgreifen, die den Kriterien nicht genügen? 6:25 - Die Erzieherausbildung hat ein sehr hohes Niveau! 7:00 - Der Kita Kollaps droht 7:25 - Geflüchtete Ukrainerinnen und Rentner als Arbeitskräfte einsetzen 8:05 - Was mit diesem Interview deutlich wurde... 8:32 - Ein Argument, welches auch die deutsche Wirtschaft interessieren sollte
* Affiliate Link: Wenn du über diesen Link ein Produkt kaufst, unterstützt du den Erzieherkanal. Das beste daran: du zahlst KEINEN Cent mehr für dieses Produkt und der Erzieherkanal erhält dafür eine kleine Provision von Amazon. Also eine Win / Win Situation! ✌️😊
In order to fight the shortage of skilled workers in Germany, women who work part-time should simply work two hours more per day,
expand their opening hours from 6.30 a.m. to 9.00 p.m. and simply hire pensioners and refugees from Ukraine.
These are exactly the suggestions of Peter Adrian, the president of the German Chamber of Industry and Trade.
Even if the intro might seem like it's all a lot of fun, no, these statements have actually been made.
By now you can almost believe that there is a secret prize, which is about who in public can make the most miserable and worst suggestions
regarding the improvement of the welfare system.
With the statements from the interview, there is definitely hope for the first place.
But let's take a more serious look at the whole topic.
In the last few days, we have received several messages from you with an interview between Bild am Sonntag and Peter Adrian,
the president of the German Chamber of Industry and Trade, short IHK.
You can find the link to the interview in the video description.
Peter Adrian represents the interest of more than 3 million companies in Germany and thus represents this a bit with his position as president.
His statements and ideas regarding the classroom sector, work in early education and the elementary sector honestly shocked me extremely.
I don't really know where to start.
It's best if we just take a look at parts of the interview.
To the question of what needs to be done against the shortage of skilled workers in Germany, Peter Adrian replied as follows.
To this day, women are underrepresented in the workforce.
One reason, many women simply cannot work more hours because there is no reliable childcare.
If all women who are currently part-time employed would work an average of two hours a day,
that would bring as much as 500,000 workers.
To the question of how childcare needs to be set up, Peter Adrian replied as follows on Bild am Sonntag.
In the kindergartens, there needs to be an adequate number of children from 7.30 a.m. to 9.00 p.m.
We can only do this if we also take into account workers who may not meet all training criteria.
There are many refugees among the Ukrainians who could help solve the problem.
Many pensioners would also be willing to work part-time for hours.
This answer consists of three sentences that, in my eyes, really mean a lot
and are more than just a huge ass-kick for early childhood education.
Let's take a look at this answer in detail, sentence by sentence.
I will give feedback to each sentence and link suitable sources to the statements I have made.
I have already gone into many points in detail in other videos on this channel.
Exaggerating this at this point would go far too far.
In the kindergartens, there needs to be an adequate number of children from 7.30 a.m. to 9.00 p.m.
There is no doubt about the extended opening hours in general.
In my eyes, they are absolutely unbearable under the current conditions and conditions
in terms of childcare, care and, above all, supervision.
There is no need to talk about this at all.
In the course of the video, I will explain why exactly.
The issue of the need-based care might sound nice at first,
but this point is also absolutely not realistically feasible.
Another question that arises to me is,
by which needs does Peter Adrian speak here at all?
Does he even mean the needs of the children or those of the pedagogical professionals?
Or maybe those of the parents who want the best for their child?
Or maybe he does mean the needs of the German economy,
in which it is only about as many people as possible working as much as possible
to drive the economy forward.
This is at least in the main area of interest of the IHK.
Let's take a closer look at the current situation
of early childhood education and the childcare system in Germany.
In Germany, 384,000 places for children are missing in 2023,
despite a legal claim for a place for children.
By 2025, 179,000 parents and educators will be missing in Germany.
Despite the enormous increase in demand,
investments in the childcare sector have been further and further reduced by politics since 2020.
The investment deficit, i.e. the amount that would have had to be invested
to achieve a minimum of quality and quantity in the field of early childhood education,
is now 10.5 billion euros in Germany.
To assess the scale, let's make a comparison.
In the area of housing, the investment deficit is at 1.6 billion euros.
In public transport, it is at 4.1 million euros.
Employees are sick on average 19 days a year in Germany.
Educators are on average 34% more often sick,
i.e. 26.5 days a year.
The reason for this is not infectious diseases, as one might first think,
but the impact of the catastrophic working and framework conditions.
The main reason for the unemployment is psychological illnesses such as burnout, depression, and so on.
And of course, these conditions do not go unnoticed by our children either.
Due to increasing demand due to the pandemic and ever more miserable conditions,
the number of mentally challenged children has increased from 20 to 30%.
As President of the German Industry and Trade Chamber,
Peter Adrian will certainly be informed about this situation.
Therefore, with his statement of even longer opening hours,
he cannot mean the needs of children, parents, and pedagogical professionals in the area of increasing staff shortages.
Let's come to the second sentence.
We can only do this if we also look at the workforce in the kindergartens,
which may not meet all training criteria.
Training as a teacher is not for nothing a demanding multi-year training,
in which it is not about singing, clapping, and children's entertainment,
but complex theories and models from the areas of pedagogy, psychology, and sociology are conveyed.
At the same time, legal foundations, communication models, and so on.
The level of training for teachers lies in the German qualification framework,
in short, DQR, at level 6.
This is at the same level as a bachelor's degree or a master's degree.
The quality level of training is not given up for fun.
It must not be reduced to workforce that may not meet all training criteria.
In addition, there are numerous academic courses for work in the kindergarten area,
e.g. elementary pedagogy or childhood pedagogy.
This statement is another ass-kick for all those
who have completed this multi-year training or multi-year study.
As already mentioned in the previous area,
the quality in the area of early education is catastrophic due to the extreme shortage of staff.
More than 150 scientists warn of the threatening collapse of the kindergarten.
This has been reported in the public media for some time now.
In this respect, the staff involved are absolutely in agreement.
The demand of Peter Adrian to reduce the number of workers who do not meet the training criteria
seems like a fire extinguisher and will accelerate the collapse of the kindergarten even faster.
Let's come to the third sentence.
There are many among the refugees in Ukraine who could help out without any problems.
Many pensioners would also be willing to work part-time for hours.
It's not about getting a little help and being packed.
I could now add many points from earlier, but then I would only repeat myself.
In many cities in Germany, kindergartens are now completely closed
or the opening hours are massively restricted due to the shortage of staff.
In Tübingen, for example, only 4 out of 43 kindergartens are open until 5 p.m.
The reason is simply the lack of staff.
Everything else is no longer compatible with supervision and co-operation.
What becomes clear with this interview, however, is that Mr. Peter Adrian really has no idea
about developmental psychology, child development and early childhood education
and the great importance of all of this.
It should also be in his interest that children are promoted and challenged as early as possible
and not only preserved under catastrophic conditions.
The importance of the first years of life for the entire later life of a person
becomes more than clear in all books on pedagogy and psychology
in order to provide a compatible argument for the interests of the German economy
and the German Industry and Trade Chamber.
A well-functioning kindergarten system at a high level of education with high quality
and well-trained professionals paves the way for resilient, innovative
and well-trained professionals of the future.
This would also do the German economy really well.
How this could work can be deduced from the concrete demands of the position paper
for the threatening kindergarten collapse.
To put it briefly, this works through attractive training opportunities,
an attractive and fair job and better work and framework conditions
and not by replacing quality with quantity.
As it currently looks, the children of today will face completely different problems
in 15 to 20 years.
Click here to get to the most up-to-date video on the educator channel.
Leave a free subscription here.
For more information, have a look at the homepage www.erzieherkanal.de.
Thank you and see you next time. Simon from the Erzieherkanal.