9/7/16 Intro to MSE phase diagrams,
Oct 15, 2023
Callister Intro to MSE ch 10 lesson 1:
phases, Gibbs phase rule, water phase diagram, free energy basis for phase diagrams, unary phase diagrams
OK, so there's a change in volume.
So the wire looks the same to us,
but if you could look at how the atoms are arranged,
there's a change in volume, because they
change in how they arrange themselves, right?
One is more compact, and one is less compact.
And that's what is that change in volume,
is that the atoms change their structure, right?
So those are two different what we call phases, right?
Phases are just different ways of organizing matter.
So ice is a different phase than water,
because it's just organized differently.
It's still water, it's still H2O molecules, right?
But in one case, they're all bonded together
in a specific structure, and in the other case,
they're zooming around in a sort of lack of structure.
We call that amorphous, right?
Or liquids are, by definition, amorphous, right?
So there's lots and lots of different phases.
When we say solid, a solid is not a precise enough term
for phases, because there's lots of different types of phases
that are all solids, right?
For example, the phase of iron that's more expanded
is one phase, and the one where it's more compact
is just a different phase.
And next chapter, we're gonna learn the names
of those phases and talk more about them,
but for now, all I want you to know is that
phases of matter are ways of arranging atoms.
If you guys are all students, are all atoms,
then right now I'd say that you're a cubic lattice, right?
I can see Vern here, and Derek, Ryan, and Rachel
are sort of like a cubic arrangement,
but I could just as easily put them
in like a hexagonal arrangement, right?
And so there's cubic versus hexagonal,
and there's lots and lots of other ones.
So we'll talk about that next chapter,
but for right now, it's just how things are arranged, okay?
So let's start by considering our simplest scenario,
which is a single component system like water, okay?
What do we know about water?
Well, we're gonna plot on our two axes.
Remind myself which ones I plot them against.
We're gonna plot temperature on the x-axis
and pressure on the y-axis, right?
So we've got temperature here,
we've got pressure up there, okay?
What do we know about water?
As you, let's pick one pressure, one atmosphere,
one atm, right, so that's room pressure,
that's where we live right now.
Well, we're a little bit less up in the mountains, right?
What do we know about changing the temperature?
What does it do to the phases of water?
Go to low temperatures, you get ice, right?
So somewhere we know that down here,
we're gonna get solid water, which is ice, right, right?
And then we heat it up a little bit,
and we're gonna cross over a point, right?
We're gonna get liquid water, right?
And then if you keep on going,
you're gonna cross over another point, the boiling point,
and it's gonna be, what, it's gonna be vapor or gas, right?
So solid, liquid, and gas, this is just for water, okay?
It's just pure water, we haven't added anything to it yet,
but just pure water.
What about pressure, right?
How does pressure change things?
When you guys cook a cake at Los Angeles
versus Salt Lake City, what do you have to do differently?
Cooking a cake's probably not a great example,
if you were to boil something, right?
What happens when you boil water
at Salt Lake versus Los Angeles, what's the difference?
Where, lower temperature where?
Here, why?
Why does it boil at a lower temperature in Salt Lake City?
It's true, it does.
Yeah, you gotta consider, like,
think of the atmosphere as an ocean of gas molecules, right?
If you're in Los Angeles, you're at the bottom of the ocean,
so pressure is higher.
Up here in the mountains,
you're not as deep in the ocean of gas molecules, right?
And so it's less pressure.
Well, think pressure, all that is,
it's just what's forcing the gas molecules in the liquid state
from coming back out of the liquid
and floating around the room, right?
So if you're in Los Angeles, you've got more weight.
It's not weight, it's pressure.
You have more pressure of gas molecules
pushing that water back into the boiling liquid.
Therefore, you have to do it
at a higher temperature for it to boil.
And we're less here, right?
So therefore, what do we change for,
how do we change that, how does that,
how do we draw lines for the different boundaries
of solid, liquid, and gas for our phase diagram?
Seeing this from Holly, that's exactly right.
You're gonna have something that looks like this, right?
Basically says higher pressure, higher temperature.
You're pushing that transformation temperature
of the boiling point, we're pushing it up, right?
As you increase pressure, you increase temperature.
Now, what about the other one?
Goes the other way.
Have an idea why, Polly?
Because chemistry, that's a great answer, right?
It's really unusual, actually.
It does something, I'm totally dramatizing it,
but, because it's not very, it's a negative slope.
I'm drawing it with a large negative slope.
It's actually very, very, very small,
but it's a negative slope, right?
So that's really unusual.
In fact, that's the reason why life exists on this planet.
If that wasn't the case, the oceans would freeze over.
They wouldn't have a film of ice.
They would freeze completely.
We'll talk about why, okay?
So, now we've got our very first phase diagram, right?
And we've just drawn it by hand
based off of what we've observed ourselves, right?
But we basically know that, all right, high pressure.
If you really press on something,
you're gonna get, generally speaking, you get solids.
Ice is the exception, right?
So most materials, just to clarify,
most materials would have this curve, like that,
meaning you'd go from a liquid to a solid
if you add pressure.
Ice is the unusual exception to that rule, okay?
Erase that for now, okay?
We know that if you go to high temperatures,
that you're generally gonna get vapors, right?
So this makes sense.
So tell me, what would this point be?
And how do we achieve it?
Like, what's happening there?
What that point is, basically, below that point,
as I go up in temperature, what am I doing?
Yeah, Matt, what can you say about this?
It's a triple point,
whereas the temperature is between the same point.
So think of these lines I'm drawing.
These are lines of equilibrium, right?
The boiling point is just nothing other than
the equilibrium between, what, liquid on the left
and vapor on the right, right?
So same thing here.
This triple point is at the equilibrium
of all three of these, what are called phases, right?
Ice, liquid, and water.
Or sorry, and steam.
Ice, water, and steam.
Solid, liquid, and gas, okay?
So that means that there's some pressure.
There exists a pressure at that triple point value, right,
where if you warm this thing up,
you go directly from a solid to a gas
without ever seeing a liquid.
Where do we see examples of this?
Dry ice, right?
So dry ice, we know that it's got a diagram
that looks not so different than this.
The slope of that solid to liquid line is positive,
as opposed to negative.
And we know that room pressure, one atmosphere,
must be below that triple point,
because at room pressure, where we're at,
it goes directly from a solid to a gas, right?
So this all correlates to stuff that we have seen before,
and it makes sense, I think, okay?
So let's label some points on here.
This is point B.
We'll call this point A.
Point C, and out here, we'll call that,
oh, sorry, out here, D.
Okay, so A, B, C, and D.
So we already talked about some of these.
Point B is just gonna be our freezing point,
or sometimes called melting point.
Same thing, it's just which way you're going, right?
Point C is gonna be our boiling point.
I guess you'd call it condensation point,
but people only call it the boiling point, right?
Point A, Matt said, that's called our triple point.
Point C, okay?
So we can now, now that we've got these things labeled,
we can introduce the first concept in this chapter.
Oh yeah, go ahead, Kyle.
So I was just saying, like,
if you're gonna put ice in a bag.
Yeah, that's what a freeze dryer is.
Those freeze drying systems are getting kind of popular now,
among kooky people that think the world's gonna end.
Like, they cost a lot.
They're like three grand for a freeze dryer.
But you can take your steak and eggs,
hot, prepared, ready to go,
throw it in the freeze dryer,
and turn it into like rich, more camping style,
like freeze dried bacon and eggs, right?
Or whatever I said, right?
It'll actually preserve it pretty well.
Because why food gets ruined is when you freeze it,
you go from solid to liquid, right?
And that's a problem because it like expands,
and that expansion makes things like tomatoes explode,
terrible things, right?
So, and then it goes the other way,
when you like, when you start out as a solid, right?
If you've got a frozen tomato and you take it back,
it has to go through that liquid phase first.
So it's just not great, right?
So freeze drying prevents that.
You freeze something, so what do you have to do?
You have to lower the temperature first, right?
Then you lower the pressure, right?
Then you can take it up there,
and you can avoid the transformation to a liquid,
or vice versa, if you wanna go the other way.
You can avoid liquid by going down in pressure first,
and then freezing it.
That's what they do with freeze dryers.
They go down in pressure from where you're at,
turn that liquid into a vapor, basically, right?
Right?
And get rid of it.
So freeze dryers are awesome.
We like freeze dryers.
And you can explain them with diagrams like this, okay?
So let's talk about Gibbs phase rule.
Gibbs phase rule is the first sort of equation
we're gonna see in chapter 10.
Yeah, Matt?
We'll talk about it in just a second.
I'm gonna use it for an example in Gibbs phase rule.
It's not a point, it doesn't have a name,
but we're gonna use it.
So the Gibbs phase rule is a rule,
the first thing to remember,
it is only to be used at equilibrium.
And these phase diagrams are only for equilibrium.
Meaning, if you let it sit long enough
and things totally even out and reach equilibrium, right?
It doesn't take into account kinetics.
You have to modify these when you talk about kinetics.
We'll do that maybe later.
It says the following.
It says P plus F equals C plus N.
Well, what is P, F, C, and N?
P is the number of phases present.
F is the number of external variables,
sometimes called the degrees of freedom,
needed to completely define the state of your system.
C is the number of components.
And N is the number of non-compositional variables.
So let's go back to our four points.
B, C, A, and D.
At point B, remember we're gonna do,
turn on draw.
What's happening?
That's really unusual.
Strange.
That's odd.
Okay, that's not working.
Okay, let's type it out.
What happens at point B?
How many phases are present?
Remember, it's gonna be P plus F equals C plus N, right?
So how many phases do we have at point B?
Oh, you know what?
If I add lines, it's gonna make bad things happen later.
We have two, right?
Is this really not gonna draw?
What have I done wrong?
Okay, we've got two.
I'll have to write it to the side,
because I can't go down without messing up the notes
later on.
Right, so we've got two phases, okay?
Technology strikes in the middle of class.
Okay, degrees of freedom is what we're gonna ask
in a moment.
We wanna know what is degrees of freedom,
meaning how many things can we change
without messing up the equilibrium, okay?
C, C is the number of components.
How many components do we have in this phase diagram?
We have one component.
It's just water, right?
There's different phases, but there's one component.
And then N is the number of non-compositional variables.
How many non-compositional variables
do we have in this phase diagram?
We've got two.
We've got pressure and temperature.
Try closing this real quick.
Ah, okay, so there's two.
So if we write that equation,
we've got two plus F equals one plus two.
Maybe it'll work.
Cross our fingers.
Nope.
Don't know why.
Can I draw a touch?
Two plus F equals one plus two.
All right, that's the most kindergarten thing
I've ever done in my life,
but two plus F equals one plus two.
Oh, the pen's not working.
Right, so therefore, F is what?
What does that mean?
It means I can change one variable.
I can change one variable,
but if I wanna maintain the same equilibrium,
I can't change more than one variable.
Well, where do we see evidence of that?
Let's say I change pressure.
I elect to change pressure on this diagram,
so I go up in pressure maybe.
If I wanna have equilibrium between solid and liquid,
it changes my temperature over to this point, right?
I can't choose both.
If I choose to change temperature by moving over,
it says you've gotta move down in pressure, right?
So that's just degrees of freedom, okay?
So if we do it at point C, what do we have?
At point C, it's the same thing.
We've got two phases.
So again, we only have one variable, right?
We're gonna move along this line.
What about at point A, the triple point?
How many phases are present at the triple point?
We've got all three phases, solid, liquid, and gas, right?
So P equals three.
F equals what?
I think the battery died.
So F is, we're gonna find out what F is.
What is N and C and N?
C and N is still the same.
It's just one and two, right?
Therefore, F can be equal to what?
Zero.
We have no degrees of freedom.
We can't change anything and maintain equilibrium.
Make sense?
Because where can we go in this diagram
and have all three phases in equilibrium, okay?
So this is Gibbs phase rule, okay?
What about at point D?
At point D out here, how many phases are present?
We've got one phase.
So now it's one plus F equals one plus two.
F is then equal to two,
meaning we can change two variables
and have still pure gas,
meaning we can go down in pressure, down in temperature,
and we might still be right here, still having a gas.
Fair enough?
Any questions on this Gibbs phase rule?
Yeah, Alex?
Not quite tracking on here.
So F is the degrees of freedom.
F is our degrees of freedom,
meaning things we can change while maintaining equilibrium.
P is the number of phases present in that equilibrium.
Also the ratio of them.
We'll come back to that in a bit.
And then we've got C and N.
C is the number of components.
This is a single component phase diagram right now.
It's just pure water.
Soon we're gonna make a new one.
We're gonna say water plus Kool-Aid, right?
Plus Kool-Aid powder.
It's gonna change it to now two components.
And then, let's see,
N is, oh, let's see,
C plus N is the number of non-compositional variables.
In this case, we can change pressure and temperature.
Okay, any questions on this?
Yeah, Kylie?
So does that equal, like if you're at point B?
Yeah, if you wanna maintain a mixture of liquid and water,
you gotta stay on that line is what it's saying.
So if you choose to change something,
it picks the other thing in this system, right?
And it says in some cases, like point A,
you can't change anything
if you wanna maintain equilibrium between three phases
because where on this diagram
can you find all three phases in equilibrium?
Only at point A.
So you can't change anything.
You have no degrees of freedom, okay?
Any other questions about this?
Okay, clicker.
Let me fire up the clicker.
Oh, we already did this.
So this'll be free points.
All right, we did this together.
Okay, that is the ID number.
This is the receiver number.
Pick our class.
10 and one.
That will show up.
I gotta close this.
Okay, now it should pop up.
So the very first question, again, we did these.
That's tiny.
Guys, technologies.
The struggle is real today.
I just switched back to my old laptop
and it's causing me grief.
I apologize for this.
I will get this fixed before next class.
There's our phase diagram.
It's the one we've just been looking at.
Nothing different, right?
So it's saying how many degrees of freedom at point A?
Is it zero, one, two, or three?
We just talked about this.
At point A, so your channel, gosh.
I don't even know how to get out of this thing.
This is going flawlessly.
Okay, channel 41, session ID right there.
I will just read it to you.
At point A, type in A.
So the first question, the answer is A.
We already did this.
If you were here, you would get credit
if you type in A for this first one.
Okay, everybody good?
Yeah, Matt?
So at point B on this one, it's a dip.
Condensed to supercritical fluids.
We will talk about supercritical fluids
only briefly in this class.
We will not go into depth in it.
A supercritical fluid, you can think of it
like when you heat a liquid up.
Good.
When you heat it up so much
that it starts behaving like a gas
and the distinction becomes really blurry,
that's a supercritical fluid.
We won't talk about it in this class.
Okay, at point B and C, the answer is two.
Type in C.
Get your points for being here today.
Sorry, one, one.
Type in B.
Sorry, I almost led you all astray.
Type in B.
Get your points.
I forgot that we were doing this as a clicker example.
I apologize.
That one's on me, 1% person.
That one's on me.
And then the last one at point E.
What would this one be?
Point E's out in the middle of the gas field.
Do we have zero, one, two, or three degrees?
Zero would be A, one would be B,
two would be C, three would be D.
So, C.
Okay.
Sorry I did our example.
Forgot about it.
Okay, everyone good?
Points achieved for the day, we're good.
Okay, back to the work.
Okay, so we're gonna come back to Gibbs phase rule in a bit
when we get to multi-component systems, harder diagrams.
But let's now ask the question,
how do we get this phase diagram in the first place, right?
Here's what the actual phase diagram for water, H2O,
looks like.
Like I said, this slope is barely negative.
It's not strongly negative, it's barely, barely negative.
Plus there's all this stuff.
What on earth is going on up here?
It's blue, which means it's solid.
And there's like 11 of them.
There's 11 different phases of solids of ice, right?
Anybody knew this?
Last year we had a student in my class
who's an avalanche expert, makes videos on this,
and he was desperate to go up on the mountains with me
and talk about the phases of ice,
because it has all to do
with whether or not avalanches happen.
It's not just the phase, but it's the microstructure,
how these phases come together and look, apparently.
But there's lots and lots of different phases, right?
And just like with water,
most materials have more than one solid phase,
especially when you start going to crazy pressures,
like 100 gigapascals.
That's like bananas pressure, right?
That's really, really high.
We're never gonna see that almost ever, right?
So most materials have multiple phases present, like iron.
Iron clearly has two.
We saw evidence of it
because the wire did something weird
in terms of expansion, okay?
So where did this diagram come from?
What do you guys think?
Anybody have a thought?
Experimental data.
So basically somebody took a vessel, right?
They changed the temperature or the pressure,
and they sort of peeked inside of it and said,
yep, looks frozen, sort of thing, okay?
That's one way.
That was like early on days of phase diagrams.
How could we be more exact about it?
What do you think, Alex?
They're probably diagramming like energy states work.
Bingo, that's exactly what they do now.
It's computed.
They take our free energy
that we just learned last chapter, huzzah,
and they use it for something.
Terrific, right?
They say what happens, thermodynamically speaking,
that's at equilibrium,
the one that lowers the energy the most.
So they say, well, what are the different types
of structures that could form?
They calculate the free energy form.
They see which one's the lowest.
Voila, you end up with a phase diagram.
You have the phases as a function of pressure
and temperature,
where the most stable phase is present, right?
There's lots of other experimental ways,
which we will probably not talk about in depth
in this class, where they get these things
and they use those to calibrate calculations.
But nowadays, yeah, they calculate these things
from thermodynamic data,
things like entropy and enthalpy,
things that you're like, we'll never use this ever.
They use it.
They make these great diagrams,
which we can use to know when avalanches
will happen and stuff.
It's actually pretty useful stuff, okay?
So they calculate, it's exactly right.
They use Gibbs free energy
because it's the lowest free energy, right?
So we remember this, that G equals H minus TS, right?
So we can now plot G versus T and P.
Ah, I'm not gonna be able to.
And it's back.
I'll take it.
I'm not gonna question why Microsoft
bestowed upon me the ability to write again.
I will just take it.
G versus T and G versus P, okay?
We're gonna plot G versus T and G versus P
for these three phases.
Let's do it for, which one do we do later?
If I still have it.
So let's do it for benzene.
Let's do it for a normal material.
Something that doesn't have that weird negative slope.
So normal material, something like benzene,
alcohol, right?
One of these things.
What will happen if we plot G versus T?
Well, we need to know what G versus T looks like
for the different phases present.
Solid, liquid, and gas.
So what is DGDT?
That's gonna be the slope, right?
I'm gonna draw a slope here of some lines
for our three different phases.
Well, what should DGDT be?
Look at our equation.
What should it be?
It should equal, if you take the derivative
of that energy expression, it should be negative S.
So the slope is what we're saying
should be proportional to negative entropy, right?
Fair enough?
We all agree about that?
And then pressure, same thing.
If you remember that H equals U plus PV,
now you have P.
You can say that the slope of DGDP must be somebody?
Just volume, right?
Volume, if you take the partial derivative
right there with P, you just get volume.
So that's great.
We can just draw lines,
and the lines are gonna be sketches, right?
These are not plotting, we're just sketching.
But we can sketch solid, liquid, and gas,
and we can sort of get a feel
for where these things come from, right?
So let's do it.
Let's say solid, liquid, and gas.
Tell me about the entropy of these three phases,
solid versus liquid versus gas.
Let me actually write these in different colors
for, you know, I don't wanna make it angry.
I'm not gonna mess with it.
It doesn't wanna erase.
I'm just gonna leave it.
Entropy is lowest for the solid, right?
Lowest, and then what's it highest for?
Gas, right?
Okay, let's go over now.
What about volume?
Generally speaking, not for water,
generally speaking, what has the highest volume,
solid, liquid, or gas?
Gas is gonna be highest volume.
Liquid will be somewhere in between,
and then this will generally be the lowest.
Ice floats because it expands when it solidifies.
That's the unusual part, right?
But this is not for ice.
This is for a regular material, okay?
Everybody agree with this so far?
So now we can draw these lines.
So let's say that solid is red.
Please work.
Liquid is blue.
Gas is green, okay, right?
So we're gonna say that dg dt,
the slope that we're gonna draw these things,
is gonna be proportional to the entropy,
and then we're gonna make it a negative slope
because it's a negative sign, right?
So the one that has the highest slope should be gas.
We all agree, right?
So we're gonna take our gas, green,
and we're gonna draw it right there, okay?
Highest slope.
Then we're gonna draw liquid.
It's gonna have slightly less slope.
Finally, we get to our solid.
Oh, I already messed up.
Sorry, game.
That's not right either.
Guys, technology is getting me down today.
I apologize.
Okay, and there's solid, right?
That should technically still be negative.
I just sketched it poorly.
Soraya's looking at me, or Ashley's looking at me like,
that's not gonna do.
All right, Soraya.
There we go.
We good?
Approved?
Okay, so we've got, again, this is solid,
liquid, and gas.
We almost have it.
Okay, so what?
Why do we care about this?
Is this useful at all to us?
It is.
We can say that this stuff,
this basically says what's lowest in energy,
so G, which one of these lines is lowest
at a given temperature, right?
At a given temperature, we can say that solid
is our lowest free energy phase, right?
And then there's a region here.
Let me switch to black.
There's a region where, so this is solid, is favorable.
Here we've got liquid as lowest,
and over here we've got gas as lowest.
So if we go back to our diagram, we can see that.
Let's go to the one that I drew.
It'll be easier to see, right?
Where do we go from solid to liquid to gas?
Well, right here, at room temperature, right?
So we sketched it for this room pressure.
It's not room temperature, room pressure, right?
It went from solid to liquid to gas
as we increased temperature, right?
So I could ask you to redraw this,
redraw this G versus T at a different pressure.
What if I asked you to draw it below the triple point?
How would we draw it differently, right?
Right here, right?
Below triple point.
If we wanted to draw below the triple point,
how would it look differently?
Well, it's G versus T, just like before.
If we go up to our diagram, what happens?
If you're below this pressure,
so we're somewhere in this region right here, right?
We're below the triple point.
As you warm it up, it goes from ice to gas,
and liquid is never present, right?
Therefore, it must never be the lowest phase.
So how do we draw it?
Any guesses?
Goes from solid straight to gas.
What do we do?
So let's start by just drawing the solid line like before.
There's our solid line, okay?
Here's our gas, right?
This temperature would be what temperature?
It would be whatever the temperature
is where it crosses this line at, okay?
That's the point where it goes from a solid to a gas.
So where's liquid at?
Any guesses?
Where should we draw liquid?
Higher.
It's gotta have the same slope.
It's gotta have the right slope
that we talked about before,
except now we're going to draw it up higher.
There, liquid, right?
So at no point is liquid the lowest energy phase.
Any questions about this?
So people that do calculations
and calculate thermodynamic phase diagrams,
all they have to do is come up
with free energy expressions, right?
And then know what the entropy is of these systems,
and they can start seeing,
okay, the entropy changes in such and such a way.
It's gonna modify our phase diagram
by just making plots like this and getting points
and then connecting the dots, basically.
Let's do a few more examples, right?
How about G versus P?
This time we're gonna fix temperature, right?
We're gonna hold temperature constant.
We're gonna change pressure.
What should it do?
It should be proportional to the volume, right?
So let's say volume is gonna be,
of gas is gonna be our highest, right?
Then liquid, and then a solid, right?
So again, this basically says as you increase pressure,
we should be seeing,
at least at the temperature where this happens at,
you should see it go from gas to liquid to solid
as you increase pressure.
Do we see that in our phase diagram?
Yeah, you betcha we do.
We go from, again, this is for normal materials.
It'd go from gas to liquid to solid.
It would cross that dashed red line.
For liquid, it doesn't work.
Liquid water has that funny slope, so it doesn't work.
Most materials, that would work, okay?
So does this make sense?
Are you guys catching how these things relate
to one another?
The concept I want you to take away with,
what I would ask you on a test is,
I'd say, sketch a G versus T or a G versus P
at a given temperature.
Maybe I'd give you this phase diagram,
and I'd say, ignore the other phases of ice.
Assume there's just one solid phase, right?
Sketch G versus P at this pressure,
or G versus T, sorry, at that pressure, right?
And you'd say, great, at that pressure,
at 100 pascals, if I sketch G versus T,
I know that it goes from a solid to a gas, right?
And we know that G versus T is proportional
to the negative entropy, so it's just gonna be
exactly what we drew before.
You're gonna say, all right, my solid must go like that.
My gas must go like that, right?
There's our boundary when it switches over.
Liquid must be up somewhere higher, right?
So I'll ask you to draw something like that
on the first exam.
Any questions on this?
You will have a homework where you'll get to practice it.
Yeah, Kylie?
Can you just go back to the?
Uh-huh, G versus P.
Okay.
So let's do another one, G versus P.
So let's do it for right here, right?
Let's say we're at this point, okay?
That's for water.
So we're gonna do the water system, right?
How would we draw it?
Let's do that.
So how would it look differently for water?
Let's erase that.
For water, how would it look differently?
So I want you guys to, with a partner,
sketch such that, let me draw it so it's clearer.
You're gonna sketch it for that temperature
where it goes right there, okay?
So turn to your neighbor and you're gonna sketch
G versus P for that temperature,
just to the left of the triple point.
Just to the left.
Can you see this?
Can you not see it?
Should I draw it one more time?
So I want you to draw it right here.
Okay, good?
So with your neighbor, sketch that real quick.
So we're plotting G versus P,
and remember, for water, it breaks the rule.
Solid is a larger volume than liquid.
That's not normally the case.
For water, it is.
So that'll tell you the slope, what the slope needs to be.
Okay, so sketch that, give you two more minutes.
Actually, we're out of time,
so we'll pick up here next time.
How about that?
I would have to print it.
I can send it to you.
Why don't you print it and email it to me
and I'll print it out.
Yeah, it's fine.
I'd always, I feel like I was taught once
that the reason ice expands is because it grabs inside of it,
or it's, you know, it's actually, it's like.
Fundamentally, even if it's pull-free,
the reason why you have to do it,
the stronger bond is.
Okay.
But it's, it's stronger bonding,
but it's a, it's different for structure.
So I can't answer that until next chapter.
Next chapter, it has to do with structure.
Yeah, Jim?
So, can you explain this why?
I can't, but my TAs can.
I have a rubric to explain it.
So Josh graded the, Josh and David.
So send Josh and David an email,
and they're happy to get together and explain it.
Okay, cool.
Okay, great.
So, is this how they get, like, the oxygen
and the air space there?
Exactly.
And it's just like,
you look at the diagram and say it's got pressure.
Just like some compressed gas,
and you spray it, it's pretty clean.
They just pressurize it to a liquid form,
and then it's thermodynamically,
it wants to go up to liquid or gas state
when you release that pressure.
And so it does, when you press that button, it sprays.
So they can't get too close to the air.
And that's something else, that's true.
But yeah.
Oh my God.
What's up?
Question on homework?
No, no.
He's great.
I really appreciate it.
If not, that's fine.
Get it today if you can.
Okay.
But as quickly as possible,
because I want to post the solution soon.
Okay, I just.
Okay.
Thanks.
Yeah, no problem.

