1 Video View·Mar 14, 2024
Meeting the demands of next-generation technologies will require materials to be designed and qualified at faster rates than ever before. The ICME (integrated computational materials engineering) approach is at the forefront of this innovation, blending advanced computational modeling with experimental validation to accelerate the development of new materials and open up the possibility of concurrent design. In this episode, we sit down with Jason Sebastian from QuesTek to learn how they have successfully applied the ICME method to the design of aerospace alloys and ICMD® software they built to enable other companies to implement the method.
Selected References
• Wang et al. Integrated computational materials engineering for advanced materials: A brief review [LINK (https://doi.org/10.1016/j.commatsci.2018.11.001) ]
• Case Study: QuesTek’s Ferrium C64 & Additive Manufacturing Process Make Army Helicopters Tougher, Lighter, and Safer [LINK (https://questek.com/case-study-questeks-ferrium-c64-additive-manufacturing-process-make-army-helicopters-tougher-lighter-and-safer/) ]
• Case Study: QuesTek’s Single Crystal Nickel Answers the Department Of Energy’s Call [LINK (https://questek.com/questeks-single-crystal-nickel-answers-the-department-of-energys-call/) ]
This episode of Materialism is sponsored by QuesTek’s ICMD® software, a cutting-edge materials design and engineering platform for ICME in a cloud-based SaaS format. Backed by computational models honed through numerous engagements with industry leaders like NASA, SpaceX, and Apple, ICMD® empowers materials engineers to predict how various factors affect material properties such as strength, toughness, corrosion resistance, and fatigue - enabling rapid design, development, and deployment of innovative materials. Visit questek.com (http://questek.com) to find out how it help solve your materials challenges.
The Materialism Podcast is sponsored by Cal Nano (https://www.calnanocorp.com/) , leading experts in spark plasma sintering and cryomilling technologies. You can learn more about their work and services by visiting their website (https://www.calnanocorp.com/) .
This Materialism Podcast is also sponsored by Materials Today (https://www.materialstoday.com/) , an Elsevier community dedicated to the creation and sharing of materials science knowledge and experience through their peer-reviewed journals, academic conferences, educational webinars, and more.
Thanks to Kolobyte and Alphabot for letting us use their music in the show!
If you have questions or feedback please send us emails at [email protected] or connect with us on social media: Instagram (https://www.instagram.com/materialism.podcast/?hl=en) , Twitter (https://twitter.com/MaterialismPod) .
Materialism Team: Taylor Sparks (co-host, co-creator), Andrew Falkowski (co-host, co-creator), Jared Duffy (production, marketing, and editing).
Keywords: Materials Innovation AI ICME ICMD integrated computational materials engineering
I would like to describe a field in
which little has been done but in which
an enormous amount can be done this
field is not quite the same as the
others in that it will tell us little of
fundamental physics but it will tell us
much about the strange phenomena that
occurred just below our perception in
contrast to the Natural philosophers of
the past the scientists of this field
delve into the recesses of Nature and
show how she works in her hiding places
their Quest is to understand and create
the imperceptible after all there is
plenty of room at the bottom all right
hello and welcome to the materialism
podcast an exploration of the past
present and future of Material Science
my name is Taylor Sparks and I'm your
host joining with me is Andrew falowski
Andrew how you doing doing pretty well
it's been a busy morning but I'm glad to
be here recording it and we're also
joined by Jason Sebastian of questech
Jason would you like to introduce
yourself hi guys thanks it's a it's a
pleasure to be here I'm Jason Sebastian
of questech uh I've been with questech
Innovations which is a company in Evon
Illinois for about 18 years currently
the company president I'm involved in
all all sorts of things uh from Soup To
Nuts at the company uh technical to
governance to management uh but we are a
company that does uh integrated
computational materials engineering and
design and I I I'm here to talk about
some of the history of that and the
current status of that uh and again yeah
thanks guys pleasure to be here hey man
it's not every day we get the president
of the company thanks for taking a
minute that's pretty EX exting hey I
just I was looking at your CV and I
couldn't help but I got to ask you did a
double degree at in uh ceramic
engineering and philosophy good for you
man tell me about that I did I uh I was
at University of Illinois I'm from
Chicago and I started college a year
young so this idea of a five years doing
two degrees was not crazy uh and
philosophy in intrigued me uh of course
I was searching for the answers of all
the secrets of life and and and the
meaning of life but no no no it it was
fascinating it got me exposed in general
to Liberal Arts education made me a
better writer and
Communicator uh even got into some like
highlevel logic classes that get
borderline mathematics uh so uh no but
other than that I hardly remember uh
most of it and uh I'm a material
scientist but uh you know ceramic
engineering does not exist you know as a
specific degree anymore at Illinois I
was the last breed of ceramic engineer
it's now Material Science yeah but I
moved into Metallurgy mainly stuff and
characterization in graduate school and
and that's where I've been focused at
questech okay well today we've got a
super cool episode why are we talking
with the president of questech well uh
there has been a fascinating um
evolution of materials and in in all
areas but one of the really interesting
case studies where we've seen it evolve
dramatically over the last 100 years is
in aviation in aviation materials we've
gone from from wood to very very
Advanced Materials and the process of
that um will probably honestly be the
future of a future episode will be the
subject of a future episode but for
today we do want to talk with uh Jason
who's going to tell us about the most
recent tools that are happening right
now um to get us started you want to
tell us a little bit about a brief
history of Aviation materials Jason yeah
well we'll we'll we'll finish here on
some of the questech examples some of
the exciting new uh examples of alloy
design and and alloy concurrency
but we we we were talking about the the
history right originally Metallurgy as a
whole was kind of an empirical almost
accidental science you go back to the uh
the R Brothers right that's where
Aviation starts they had some
constraints on how heavy the airplane
could be and or the engine in fact and
and how many horsepower it had to put
out and it led them to the use of
aluminum Alloys and they knew these
aluminum Alloys these aluminum copper
Alloys could get very strong much
stronger than regular aluminum it was
kind they did not discover these Alloys
but the people that did sort of like
accidentally stumbled upon them and
everybody got excited and utilized them
this moved to sort of an empirical age
uh and and sort of empirical SL
accidental Discovery age um we were
talking a little bit a minute ago but
like the example of n andol this uh
shape memory aloy that material
scientists know and love this was sort
of an accidental Discovery at the uh
Naval ordinance lab that's where it gets
its name nickel titanium nav ordinance
lab this person I think ber ber was his
name I'm not sure if it's the ber of
metallography Fame but he was studying
these Alloys for their room temperature
properties he noticed as he was melting
things around EO Atomic titanium nickel
uh he he he was like moving something
out of the furnace it hit the ground and
made a thud but if he moved something
out of the furnace and and water
quenched it and then dropped it on the
ground it rang like a bell told him
there was some crystal structure thing
happening dampening effect at high
temperatures and he was like wow that's
interesting sobody he made it into a
wire and bent up the wire and then blew
their Pipe smoke onto it this is
literally what I was reading and the
wire straighten back out to to its
original form so this was like another
like accidental Discovery uh but then
they eventually under kind of understood
oh this is a Martin sight aite
transformation this is a shape memory
effect but the original Discovery was
the sort of accidental thing I've been
told the example of TI titanium
64 uh it's an excellent Alloys it does
the job it may not be optimal these
integer numbers are are are often not uh
but I was told it was came out of a uh
uh an empirical development program was
motivated by the SR71 Black Blackbird uh
the big supersonic plane uh in the 1950s
and 60s and they only had enough money
to test the even numbers I don't know if
that's true or not my go two's four 68
and you know we'll never know if Tai 13
was in fact the optimal solution no but
it was something like that it was an
empirical program looking at
compositions and I think even uh niobium
c103 which was the kind of a rocket
nozzle material that came out of the
Apollo program or the Saturn 5 program
this was like the 103rd test alloy in a
sequence right so this is all very
empirical yeah I think it is I maybe not
all three of them but it was like the
103rd designated sure yeah it's like
something like that but but so and and
but things have worked right and and
Aviation has proceeded even the initial
aluminum copper
Alloys uh you know those have evolved
into all the different classes 5,000
7,000 6,000 series uh Aerospace I think
it all started kind of with aluminum
copper in terms of the higher strength
but it's kind of proceeded to where it
is today um and that leads to to the
modern era right this this proceeds but
it doesn't proceed like you said fast
enough uh and and and the need need for
new materials now and the need for new
materials you know more rapidly is
greater than ever and that's what's led
to this current age of uh computational
modeling computational materials design
um and and it used to be called that hey
computational materials modeling or
materials design it wasn't until about
14 15 oh gosh maybe almost 20 years ago
now that the acronym uh icme was
developed I think it was in a 2008
National Academy report uh but Quest was
around before before that so we were
doing computational materials design
materials by Design is one of our
trademarks um and and then this field of
icme has come along so we can talk about
that and and what that's all about
Taylor but that was my quick kind of
History What's led to uh any one of
those could be a full episode we were we
were talking about this the history of
Aerospace aluminum right the history of
night andol I'd love to understand that
a little better yeah check out episode 9
we did a whole thing on night and Hall
oh really
yeah the funny thing about that was
something in the original empirical
melting of SE alloy sequences he this
was quoting this guy buer like my first
wife and I separated I spent a
tremendous amount of time working in the
lab so it was really because the guy had
a lot of time on his hands uh that he
was going through this empirical
sequence of nickel titanium Alloys but
anyway um I no I did not listen I'll
look up episode nine thank you yeah you
bet yeah listening to you going over
this brief history it really sounds like
in many cases we sort of got lucky and
the the dominant Paradigm was really
kind of like what Edison talked about
where it's you know 1% inspiration and
99% perspiration we're just trying
things over and over again and you know
having at least the need to maybe direct
that those efforts but not necessarily
those efforts being the most efficient
and so as material scientists we want to
know you know how can we actually tune
all of these um different parameters in
our in our materials how can we take
advantage of the the physics we
understand to make the material we want
but hopefully maybe faster and in a more
targeted way and that's where icme
really I think came on um the stage and
really allowed us with greater Fidelity
than ever before to actually start to
design Alloys and design materials so
maybe you can tell us a little about
questech and maybe your experience in
using some of these tools um to start to
design materials and and what is
involved in the icme process is it
analytical models is it calad or is it
is it even broader than that it it is
broader it is those things but broader
um yeah so uh questech was formed out of
the research of uh Greg Olsen he was one
of the co-founders from Northwestern he
was historically kind of a steel
martinside expert but he was looking at
all scales of of uh alloy modeling and
even the the Martin site uh and
steel uh experience led him to
thermodynamics and
calad for Quest act that's kind of the
foundation of of how icme Works you're
calculating uh the process structure
property relationships in a material so
this is not just quc this is icme it's
it's linking the process structure uh
property and performance relationships
in the middle of a material and the
process structure you know what
temperature do you process a material at
what what phases occur at that
temperature that's a cal those are caled
type models uh and and and so that's why
it sort of forms the foundation of
everything uh the the thermodynamic
databases behind those are really kind
of the Genome of IC C in that sense but
you link those up with um structured
property models right you you predict
what phases are there and and how big
they are we're getting into the kinetics
now uh the formation of things during
precipitation but you link the structure
property side of things uh like a
strength model how does the the uh
strength of a material relate back to
its grain structure or the size and
distribution of the precipitates that's
a structur property model uh and then
you link those to kind of performance
well not just strength but say
uh life cycles of of stress or something
like that an actual performance metric
all of that gets to uh kind of linked
together in an integrated way that's the
I and icme the computational part is
because we can do a lot of this in the
computer and yeah no no hate on Edison
he couldn't do these things in the
computer so we had to do a lot of uh
perspiration and trial and error we we
talk backwards in this sort of flippant
way like they they had to do things
empirically because you know they didn't
have the ability to calculate these
things they weren't willy-nilly
exploring all of the even numbers in a
space right they they knew through
knowledge and and and history that you
know certain boundaries existed but
anyway they didn't have the ability to
do it in a computer so that's the
computational part of of I so you link
across and then you link across various
length scales thermodynamics may tell
you about the phases in the material
that's kind of micro or Nano scale but
if you want to get down into the atomic
scale of like say cohesion at a grain
boundary you have to use different
methods like DFT uh and that those are
different methods of calculating process
structure and structure property
relationships so you're doing it across
the length scales you're doing it across
uh process structure structure property
uh and you're doing it in this
engineering way I guess the e in in icme
is engineering you're really taking an
engineering approach uh to Performance
right not not just atomic structure
because you because a phases crystal
structure is cool or something you want
to link that ultimately to
Performance so I that's been questex
experience with IC it used to be called
modeling and simulation uh but we
certainly started with the cow fad as
the foundation approach uh we certainly
look at things from a mechanistic
physics-based approach everything I was
just rattling off is is is fundamental
physics-based Material Science that
being said we we do understand the value
of you know machine learning AI type
approaches to to discern Trends and
maybe sift through data or ingest data
that is
ultimately made better or processed with
physics-based models and such we're
getting into a whole another tangent
here uh but that's IC to questech right
and that I think that's IC
to I don't think what how I just
described it would be uh different from
the way a lot of folks are using it and
practicing it but yeah the difference
these days is people can do the
computation much better than ever before
and they can link it across length
scales and I don't just mean d being a
CSV and reading it into another software
you can like kind of add software
LinkedIn this way I'll talk more about
questech uh and our software uh
initiatives these days later but uh it
can it can happen and and students
themselves are taught computational
Material Science even at the undergrad
level and and I'm old enough to remember
that H it was it was uh computation was
still sort of this different thing that
certain material scientists were doing
and wasn't really founded to to the the
mainstream Material Science
Community yeah so I get this impression
that IC is really I just from experience
I've seen these conferences it's really
aimed at Metals um is that is it broader
I'm clearly it can be Broad in that but
is actually finding application Beyond
just metal as an Alloys oh yeah
absolutely and Quest is done Ceramics uh
you know it's some of the same
thermodynamic debate databases can
predict Ceramics and phase stability and
Ceramics and then you can come up with
models of Ceramics strength their
hardness or toughness based on those
phases and and so Ceramics we've done
for sure um composits materials which
you know you've got a ceramic
interacting with a a a metal or
something like that full-blown polymer
ICM is happening it's starting to kind
of get some legs uh there was a sensor
that Greg Olson has managed it's still
ongoing uh with Northwestern and
University of Chicago and argon called
Shad the center for hierarch yeah yeah I
think good yeah Center for hierarchical
materials design so I don't want to uh
over they're Wanda Pablo down at
University Chicago is looking at how do
you build up the genomic databases and
take a a icme type approach to polymer
design so it's possible um questech did
a project on bubble gum for Wrigley
going back 20 years or something um and
and uh yeah that so icme and uh
materials design can be applied to
things other than Metals but absolutely
questech has focused a lot on the metals
um and more the and on the hard material
side Ceramics metal Matrix
composits okay so we we've heard a brief
history of how Aviation materials have
evolved you've given us a description of
what exactly icme is it's essentially
sounds like you know the cynic in me
would say like well that's just like
Material Science right as a discipline
we've been studying structure property
processing relationships but I think
what has changed is the tools have
evolved pretty wildly um and this idea
of doing it across length scales not
just picking a single relationship but
picking all of them that lead to the
development of new material that that's
a that's a bigger bite than just what
you know our Material Science friends
from 80 years ago were doing right so I
think I understand a little bit about
icme now could you tell us how this is
actually changing Aviation materials
today in the modern era well that's a
thank you good segue to what quest's
been doing in in the modern era the last
20 plus years uh we've been designing
steels for Aviation so I can talk about
some of those examples of some of our
fium steel uh design examples and and
maybe some non-steel examples of nickel
super alloy if we can get to that um
absolutely but yeah we we we questech
historically have done a lot of
Engagement type work for government
clients for corporate clients um uh so
I'll talk more about the government
stuff because I can talk about that
freely but and these are some of our
sort of banner success stories that you
hear about or see on our website but
we've done a number of Steel designs at
questech we call them fium that's one of
our trademarks and there's a couple of
varieties of fium out there um I'll
start with M54 fum M54 is a steel design
that we did for the US Navy this was
funded by US Navy small business
Innovation research type funding they
were looking for a very high strength
and toughness steel uh that would be an
alternative to what is essentially a
single Source steel out there that's
used uh and looking for solutions that
would minimize the amount of cobalt
right so they had the these were the
kind of performance things these are
perform these are economics right thing
has to be cheap it's got to have high
strength and toughness uh but another
dimension that concerned them was stress
corrosion cracking resistance if you get
to this level of super high strength
Steels you start to have issues of with
hydrogen embrittlement and stress
corrosion cracking particularly right in
in in the Navy environments on in salt
water environments on an aircraft
carrier uh so they were looking for this
kind of a steel they def the
requirements high strength High
toughness high stress corrosion cracking
resistance and minimal Cobalt like low
cost and that's where the quest Tech
design of M54 came into play and you can
read you can read about the design of
the steel um and you can even see that
we ended up making it into components
questech coordinated the delivery of 60
of these hook Shanks uh which are the
stick that catches the uh um the cable
on the aircraft carrier when the jet
lands so this has been a great success
story but in terms of the technical uh
the real uh icme if you will came came
into play the stress corrosion cracking
resistance right in these very high
strength Steels uh they fail in the
presence of hydrogen and they fail
intergranularly and you can see that
plain as day on the fracture surfaces so
the the grain boundaries are the weak
Link in the presence of hydrogen the
cohesion of the grain boundaries so what
can we do we can look at elements that
would improve the cohesion of those
grain boundaries and we can add those to
the steel and we can do it judiciously
not just throw in a dash right but we do
it in in a calfed context so in this
case we did a bunch of DFT calculations
you know like aono first principal stuff
looking at the impact of of Elemental
additions to the cohesion of the grain
boundaries and these types of Steels and
we found that uh tungsten tungsten is
the secret sauce that when you add it to
a steel um and it segregates it will
segregate to the grain boundaries uh and
it will improve the cohesion of the
grain boundaries significantly so when
you add it and you do and heat treat it
in a way that it can get to the grain
boundaries uh you can greatly improve
the stress corrosion cracking resistance
and you and that's shown in the fracture
surfaces if you if you take this M54
steel and you test it in a hydrogen
environment it's no longer intergranular
right so so there's still another weak
link out there but it's no longer the
the cohesion of the grain bounderies so
that was the I like how did you know how
did how did how did the I tell you to
try tungsten what what was the well we
were looking at which elements just in a
general sense which elements the would
segregate to a grain boundary would
would it be energetically fa favorable
and when they get there do they improve
or or or decrease the grain boundary
cohesion and those calculations were
done across the entire periodic table
kind of in a model uh setup uh kind of
way and that pointed directly to
tungsten being the one that could work
but then you got to turn it over to the
thermodynamics okay now if we're adding
tungsten to this steel starting without
it and you add it to the steel is it
going to be free to roam right will it
be garble gobbled up into the carbides
uh where it's going to compete with
chrome and malum for to form those
carbides which are already in the steel
or is it or is there going to be a
certain amount of it free in The Matrix
to roam so that so you have to do that
right and when you find that there's
some that's free to roam uh then it roam
you know during heat then you got to
look at the heat treatment okay if we
use a tempering temperature at this sort
of in this sort of a range would the
tungsten travel enough distance right
it's a big heavy element yes yes yes
okay good and let's put it into the
steel with that sort of a level and it
segregates to the boundary and and then
the proof proofs in the pudding uh the
uh the fracture surfaces are no longer
intergranular so that's how we learned
it would be tux I think actually the
better candidate from an energetics
point of view would be arenium but
that's much much more expensive right so
so you can survey the landscape with
these initial calculations and then you
got to kind of hone in on things and and
across the length scales with uh calfat
and with some of the kinetic
calculations about diffusion distances
so the steel works and that's why they
made the components out of it and it
does have the strength and the toughness
and by the way the low Cobalt that was
another constraint um and the improved
stress corrosion cracking resistance but
hopefully I'm I'm kind of articulating
how a number of different icme type
models were kind of looking at things
simultaneously as we did that alloy
design yeah that makes a lot of sense
one question I have so I I have some
experience working with some of the um
the ceramic side of some of these
thermodynamic modeling softwares and one
of the issues that we ran into was um
you know for some systems there just
aren't there isn't data in some of these
databases and especially when you're
trying to solve maybe um a new problem
or incorporate a new element or design
an alloy that hasn't been around before
you might not have a lot of data to be
able to perform some of these
thermodynamic calculations so so what
would what was the approach there would
it be to actually generate this data or
to maybe find workarounds of of you know
solving these problems without it first
of all I think some of the thermodynamic
some the thermodynamics databases for
certain ceramic systems have have
evolved quite a bit and there are you
know oxide thermodynamic databases that
you can use um but Ceramics are are
complicated and especially the
multicomponent space but in general when
you're trying to develop a new uh
thermodynamic database you're you're
going in there and you're studying the
the various binary phase diagrams and
binary heat capacities and stuff andary
heat capacities the Brilliance of the
calfat method is essentially that like
once you nail things down through binary
andary level you can extrapolate to
these uh fourth and fifth order type
terms uh with relative confidence
because those kind of out terms of qu
Quint Quinter type interactions are very
minimal on the overall energy so I'm not
I'm not a thermo dat database person but
you know if you got to start from
scratch then you look for the binaries
and the uh the turnar and you build out
from there until you run into strange
phases that wer weren't necessarily
predicted and then you got to adapt your
databases but that's been an iteration
and I think the modern status of
uh databases for oxide systems is quite
quite
advanced in my case I was actually more
on the um I was looking at uh ceramic
interactions with various actinide
species which are are not necessarily as
populated or if they are there
sufficient protections on them that you
can't always access them right yeah so
it I mean even some of the metallic
databases I don't know if they have all
those all the you know acdes and the the
full spread of elements some of them do
but not not to you know if you really
want to design with an actinide carbide
or something but the SEC the question of
like uh is it just do we have to go out
there no there are some in Taylor you
know this realm you know there are ways
to calculate energies of compounds and
stuff at 0 deg Kelvin right that sort of
form the Baseline uh enthalpy uh
parameters that would feed into new
databases so there are efforts I know to
build up these databases uh using first
principles or or you know computational
methods without having to build out
taries filling in the sort of missing
gap of zero Kelvin energies uh mixing
energies and enthalpies and things so
there is I know there is AI space and
stuff an effort to build up these
databases even more
rapidly well I will never see uh an
airplane take off for land on aircraft
carry the same without thinking about
this hook you guys made I think that's
pretty awesome what what else have you
work um another example would be a
nickel super alloy that we designed
single Crystal nickel uh alloy design
and um we're talking about the blades of
turbine jet engines now and um for jet
engines right for propulsion engines the
technology moved from nickel super
Alloys to directionally
solidified uh to now single crystals uh
they've been looking at and those are
the ultimate in creep performance and
stuff if you can get the the blade to be
a a single Crystal without any grain
boundaries and when you want to scale up
that sort of technology to industrial
gas turbine engines the blades are are
much larger right the blades in a jet
engine are like the size of a pack of
cards and these IGT blades are the size
of a loaf of bread huge and it's a huge
challenge to cast something that much
larger as a single Crystal so that that
was the uh challenge statement from the
Department of energy can we get single
Crystal nickel Alloys uh that have uh
that could prer industrial gas turbine
IGT engines that have the uh that take
advantage of some of this single Crystal
technology that aots were
doing I've got a stupid question for you
I should know this but every time I hear
cast single Crystal my brain is like
what how do you do that because you cast
something you're going to nucle all over
the the sides of the mold and I should
know the answer to this but are you
casting it and then you're doing like a
slow solidification like process to turn
into crystal that's how they do it with
these molds and I'm not an expert and
there's a lot of like secret proprietary
sauce but they start with a little seed
which is like a ground one0 nickel
surface or nickel surface and they put
that in a certain location in an
investment mold and then through a
process of keeping it heat super heated
and then slowly cooling it from bottom
to top they can make this whole casting
in in a relative in a complex shape now
into a single Crystal but it is amazing
and I've been to the places and you
can't really see how it's happening and
and I'd really like to know more about
it but yes to do and they do it with all
these internal channels right cooling
channels and stuff too and it's it's
already a complex blade shape but it's
got all this internal structure pretty
amazing um um so and then but scaling
that up like and maintaining the single
Crystal this right during that sort of a
process is is a huge Challenge and they
uh freckles are the things that develop
you can do that as carefully as you want
but these weird convective inabilities
can develop that sends like different
versions of the liquid uh in different
directions and then you end up with
essentially a grain boundary right no
longer a a single Crystal interesting
right and that is definitely related to
the density of the liquid as it
solidifies right it starts as a a dense
molten nickel super alloy uh but when
you want to add these elements like
arenium is often added to these Alloys
for creep resistance uh but that
exacerbates the solidification issue as
the the the material solidifies it be
the first to solidify is arenium Rich it
leaves the remaining liquid much less
dense and then you can have regions of
highdensity liquid low density liquid
and you get this sloshing convective
instability I guess uh that breaks up
the single Crystal process so it's
really hard to kind of uh maintain this
all and and and do it in a way such that
you can make the the blades much larger
uh so that's the challenge how do you
limit those liquid density differences
during uh solidification that's a
thermodynamic calculation you're
calculating the density of the liquid as
you as you fall along the liquid is
curve uhuh right and how can you do it
with minimum amount of those elements
well you could do it with zero of those
elements but you're going to still need
a certain amount of those uh heavy
elements like arenium for eventually the
creep resistance so this is what we did
this was the design challenge how do you
do you minimize the liquid density
differences during solidification but
maintain enough rium in in in the system
such that you get the good gamma gamma
Prime micr structure in the end and it's
highly creep resistance etc etc all
while making something that's eventually
homogenized it kind of goes through some
heat treatment steps that was the main
tradeoff there so we designed a uh 1%
arenium alloy that has the creep
resistance of the like 3 to 6% renum
alloy but essentially has the
castability of a 0% Maloy uh and and all
of that was done in you know
computationally icme in fact this was
done with multiple databases certain
thermodynamic databases are used to
predict the
uh the liquid density differences during
solidification other thermodynamic
databases are used to predict the gamma
gamma Prime composition and phase
fractions only because different
databases work different for different
uh parts of the problem uh and that's
sort of the integration of the icme type
side of things so yeah we we designed an
alloy patented it and it's castable at
Large Scale we actually worked with one
of these foundaries to produce a large
scale Blade with with an oem's mold so
it works and and it's got the creep
resistance of a a 3 to 6% rium alloy and
that's a huge big deal and it because
rium is is uh gosh thousands of dollars
an ounce or something so it's a show sto
so from going from 6% reum to 1% rum the
number of pounds that would equate to in
a large scale IGT gas turbine it's it's
a huge cost savings so I went through
that pretty quickly I I usually do it
with a uh with a whiteboard in front of
me or something but hopefully you can
appreciate there are different length
scales of modeling happening there
they're interplaying with one another
the outputs of one thing are looking
going into the inputs of another we're
doing it with different databases and
different parts of the calculation chain
right that we got to add that all
together and do it in multicomponent
eight element space to do these alloy
designs yeah we just did an episode on
nickel super Alloys episode 70 if you
want to go back and listen to it but I
think it was really great at describing
how these gamma gamma Prime you know
precipitates lead to the strengthening
which is so critical in those materials
I'm curious where you guys were trying
to tweak the the composition of the
overall material such that you avoid
these these gradients in the casting
process this is now a multi-objective
problem where you still still need to
preserve the the precipitates and they
have to do their job but now you have
this additional constraint what did you
run into instances where in order to get
the right you know density matching that
it would have negatively impacted the
precipitates or did you just get lucky
and it happened to work for
both no it's a trade-off that that is a
trade-off right if you add renum more
arenium to the system you're going to
get more precipitates but you're going
to get worse castability worse or larger
liquid density differences so you got to
kind of find that sweet spot it's not
just a a linear tradeoff of like a hatch
pattern or site right these are non you
got to look at a contour plot of of
those quality quantities as a function
of and show really where are you falling
down the going down the valley this way
but only slightly along the ridge line
of the other quop yeah property that
would be that would be ideal uh so
you're moving from one place to another
while one property is maintained but
another one is maximized so uh yeah
that's that's fundamentally the
trade-off and you do have to have some
rium in there and might even have it
medium actually I think segregates to
the uh the matrix it's right it doesn't
add to the phase fraction but I think it
goes to the Matrix and thus you know it
Gates the eventual cooning of the uh the
precipitates and so it slows everything
down that way the corsen right which
ultimately related to The Creep
resistance over a long time anyway um
maybe I've got it right maybe I got it
wrong but in any case yes it's a
multi-objective thing across length
scales uh there has to
there it needs to be a human operator
that say like hold on a minute that
doesn't make sense sometimes right maybe
not for this particular example like
hold on I must have something wrong here
uh this trend is looking to be in the
opposite direction but in any case uh
that's what quest Tech does and and that
allo is another success and it had been
it has been produced at scale and uh not
yet found its way into an actual gas
turbine so for all you gas turbine
manufacturers out there give me a call
so you've described your farum for the
hook you've described now a nickel super
alloy uh for the engine obviously uh
other examples you want to talk about um
I I you know I think I'd like to talk a
little about the kind of the next
Frontier now I think because I I think
uh without get too much into more Quest
Tech examples this idea of uh alloy
concurrency this is the exciting part
I've just described how we can how
questech and you know in general how
icme alloy design has has evolved and
how we've been practicing it the next
Frontier is concurrency this is but this
is happening now and and that's not just
designed to a set of property
performance requirements I want an alloy
that's this strong this tough this
stress corrosion cracking resistance
it's kind of merging the the the design
of a component the actual uh design of a
component to with the design of new
materials concurrency and Engineering
that right that's already been achieved
across the other disciplines they're
designing the mechanical engineering of
of your iPhone at the same time they're
considering the electrical engineering
of the the enclosure and stuff uh but
only recently well at Apple included
right have they also kind of brought
materials to that table uh and so
materials designed at the same time that
you're doing component design that
that's
concurrency right and that's only
possible if you have alloy design if
you've got the ability to
computationally and rapidly design new
Alloys so that's kind of why it's the
final
frontier uh um I can talk about some uh
industrial examples in this theme Apple
is is an awesome company they're very
materials forward um there's even a
questech connection that Jim murko
acknowledged uh at the 2022
TMS uh uh talk that he gave but in any
case apple is a company that looks at
new materials as they're starting to
design new devices the Apple watch was
an example of that you can look up the
patents they designed a new aluminum
alloy a new gold alloy a a new stainless
steel for the millanes loop uh bands
they designed these materials at the
same time they were uh doing the design
of this new product it all kind of came
together these days it's titanium right
uh they're touting the new usage of
titanium it's ti64 but no doubt it's a
probably custom tweaked version that
they've uh developed for their
particular application and needs that's
concurrency um another good example
SpaceX Tesla and there's a quest Tech
lineage there too Charlie cumin but more
on that later uh but they're doing
awesome things with at new alloy design
and and currency I know everyone knows
the example of the Giga
casting um the large scale castings that
Tesla's using you can look up the patent
they they had to design a new aluminum
alloy for that
application not just these huge presses
that are God they they h house uh and
all the engineering that goes into that
but they had they want they needed to
get an Al the Alloys out there that
existed didn't work they didn't have
that combination of fluidity
conduct thermal conductivity and
solidification
characteristics uh and ultimately
properties in the ASC state right they
didn't want to have to heat treat these
big casting so they designed a new alloy
that would meet the job so they were
doing this at the same time as they were
like kind of Designing this notion of a
of a gigac cast so materials concurrency
it's really it's it's awesome and it's
it's enabled by materials design you can
say boy this component would work a lot
better if the properties of the material
here in this little corn
were this these properties right and
normally someone would say well we can't
get that so just make it thicker there
but no if you could actually say well
what that would mean taking this
existing material and tweaking it in a
way that it gets to those sort of
properties not necessarily even tweaking
an existing designing an obur material
with those particular properties that's
concurrency so the example at Quest
we're excited about is some some of the
work we've done on arpa an arpa e
Department of energy Advance research
project Agency energy a program on the
design of niobium uh Alloys for turbine
engine applications so this is the arpa
ultimate program and Taylor I think
you've been connected to some of this
effort out
of this is concurrency too we worked uh
with pratton Whitney as the partner to
say what would really a niobium alloy
need to do uh what kind of properties
would it need to have in the case of a
turbine blade in the core of a turbine
blade uh because we knew from the
beginning that you know regular niobium
is not going to cut it regular niobium
even C13 does not have very says
horrible oxidation so you have to have a
coron niobium alloy that has creep
resistance and you have to grade that
into a case nium alloy it's closer to a
high entropy alloy by the way uh that
has the oxidation resistance and and the
concurrency there is is folks like Pratt
and Whitney telling us but yeah you can
it's not just about 100 degree bump in
operating temperature it's really going
to mean these particular uh increases in
the metrics of say creep resistance or
stresses and strains and and that sort
of thing telling you what the actual
requirements of a component of this
Source would be of this sort would be
and then designing the material to match
those requirements so we've and that's a
very complicated material right one
niobium alloy and the core graded to a a
case niobium alloy in the case you need
to make sure that case alloy is
uh then compatible with a bond code and
a coding the whole thing is is a very
multiscale icme intensive
exercise um and we've made some progress
there that program's moving to a second
phase uh it'll be a while before obom
Alloys are spinning in turbine engines
but this would be a huge big deal for
Energy Efficiency it's a cool uh program
to be involved with uh you know the
government is really kind of looking to
next the the the next Frontier
uh uh because making jet engines that
burn hotter would save just tremendous
they used to throw out these metrics I
should have them at the tip of my tongue
but 100 degree increase in operating
temperature it would be like getting rid
of half of the cars or something or
something like that but in terms of
anyway huge huge foresight and and we'll
get there eventually but it's definitely
uh an exercise uh for I it's not for
empiricism or accidental Discovery right
it's for icme computational design and
it's it's it's for concurrency this
particular alloy right has to be printed
the graded or this solution would need
to be printed to get the graded uh from
core to Case and so it has to be
processable into a powder and it has to
be printable by uh directed energy
deposition all these constraints that uh
you need to consider up front that's
that's also what we mean by
concurrency so Jason I'm kind of curious
if you know we have lots of listeners in
all sorts of different spaces if they're
hearing an episode like this and they're
like this sounds like exactly the
challenge that I face at my company um
you guys offer tools and a package of
tools that that people can sort of
utilize to address their own challenges
right you want to talk about some oh
yeah thanks uh Shameless plug time but
no this is awesome you know I've talked
about these questech stories and
histories that's the history of questech
the engagements and the Alloys that
we've designed but we're we're we're
currently going through a digital
transformation
ourselves a pivot to to a digital
company we're putting together all the
tools and models that we developed over
20 plus years nearly 25 years into a
package that folks can use uh icmd
integr and it stands for integrated
computational materials design a
combination of icme plus materials by
Design uh all the a lot of the models I
just talked about grain boundary
cohesion and phase stability and
strength models across various alloy
systems will be are part of this package
so folks can do what I'm describing and
I'm excited about that um we've done a
lot of successful things ourselves we've
helped companies uh do successful things
but now I think the workforce has
matured certainly to a point with you
know the knowledge and familiarity with
computational Material Science that uh
this is a product that a lot of people
can use uh we call talk about the
democratization of icme this this tool
allows folks to do quick models you know
you know you don't need to know the the
physics of Oran looping uh strengthening
you know you just want to be able to
predict the strength of a precipitation
strengthened alloy um so we're excited
about it it's called icmd check it out
um it it hit the street uh at the end of
last year or rather 2022 uh 2023 it's
started its uh uh market adoption
there's some press releases around uh
early adopters like Dao Steel in Japan
on questex website oh cool yeah so um
yeah but we also still do the
engagements in the services and there's
a lot of ways in which uh icmd can be
customized or uh can we can work to have
it integrated within a client system or
use a client's models it's all very
modular that way um and so yeah that
that's kind of the final frontier this
is what uh will enable more than just uh
a few companies out there but all of all
of the companies out there to do uh
alloy design and and materials
currency that's awesome so we will put a
link to this in our show notes if people
are interested uh you know Jason this
has been a hoot to chat with you um the
future is bright for materials design
it's very exciting to see more and more
tools coming online that can just really
deal with the stuff that we couldn't
deal with in the past that was too
complicated too multiobjective too uh
too many parameters to sort of consider
too many length scales to consider the
fact that we're coming up with tools
that can Bridge those challenges is just
a really exciting time to be doing
Material Science yeah getting them to
talk to each other was always one of the
biggest things right you could buy all
these softwares but then you had your
sort of discreet experts in each of them
and uh rarely did they talk to each
other and if they did it you know it was
often time hard to bridge that Gap and
communicate across that so seeing that
become more centralized and become more
accessible so that new problems can be
solved with it is really
cool okay Jason it's been a blast it's
been my pleasure I've been a fan uh fan
person for a long time so this is super
cool and uh you guys keep it up and uh
go
materialism thanks so much okay we'll
talk to you later
byebye this episode of materialism
podcast is brought to you by questex
icmd software icmd is a new materials
design and Engineering platform that
captures the power of integrated
computational materials engineering or
icme in a cloud-based software as a
service offering icmd helps Innovative
organizations design develop and deploy
novel materials at record speed the
software is built on computational
models developed by wtech to deliver
hundreds of material signs engagements
completed on behalf of NASA SpaceX apple
and many more with icmd materials
Engineers can see how a wide range of
variables will impact a material
structure and properties such as
strength toughness corrosion resistance
and fatigue or you can start with the
performance that is required and then
identify the composition and processes
that will help you achieve it to try
icmd and see what Innovations it can
unlock for your organization you can
visit
quest.com that's Q
s.com this episode is sponsored by
California Nano Technologies or Cal Nano
if you've listened to the podcast you
know that we are big fans of them we've
done a couple episodes with them and I
as a professor have used their services
multiple times over the course of my
career they have some really great
Services they've helped us with spark
plasma centering at an extremely large
scale way bigger than what you're
thinking they can make some huge
components I've always had great success
with them they turn out high density
Quality Parts to order and pretty quick
turnaround um and they also have some
other capabilities including cryo
Milling check out our episode on that we
think that they're an awesome company
and we're proud to stand by them as a
sponsor of the show The materialism
podcast is also sponsored by materials
today visit material today.com to stay
up to date on the latest happenings in
the material science field and read some
fantastic articles they have published
you can head over to el.com to find out
more about their journals books
conferences and related programs
okay thank you for listening to this
episode it was super fun to have you
along uh and as always we would love to
hear feedback from you so check us out
on Instagram we are at the ATM
materialism. podcast handle or you can
send us an email materialism. podcast
gmail.com and if you want to do me a
huge favor I would love it if you gave
us a review we are tantalizingly close
to stealing that number one spot in the
chemistry category nothing would make me
happier than to have a material science
podcast in the number number one spot of
our chemistry homies so hope make this
happen a review share it with some
budies that would just be Super Rad um
as always we're grateful to the people
that make the music for this that's
alphabot and kaby they make some cool
stuff check them out and we'll see you
next
time the inventors of fire electricity
magnetism iron lead glass silk cotton
the makers of tools the captors of
lightning the architect the engineer the
musician are all beneficiaries of the
materials of this world and are bound
only by their imaginations in
manipulating those
materials