The Strange Truth About Salisbury Steak

Cooking Traditional
465 followers
It's a TV dinner classic that fed millions across America,
but what do you really know about the retro entree known as Salisbury steak?
In the Civil War era, intestinal ailments were common in soldiers who subsisted on a diet low
in nutrients. Believe it or not, digestive illnesses such as dysentery killed more
soldiers during the Civil War than battlefield combat. As an early follower of germ theory,
New York-born Dr. James H. Salisbury was adamant in his belief that food could serve
medicinal purpose. Salisbury's work sat at the cutting edge of this kind of research,
so he performed most of his early diet trials on himself and a few other willing test subjects.
One such trial consisted of Dr. Salisbury eating nothing but baked beans for a few days,
which wreaked havoc on his digestive system and overall well-being.
In another trial, test subjects consumed only porridge for about 30 days. Salisbury finally
found his eureka moment when he tested a singular diet of lean minced beef,
which he determined to be the perfect alimentation — his word for food — for easy human digestion.
Salisbury began to distribute portions of what he called muscle pulp of beef to Union Army soldiers,
hoping to both provide them with sustenance and prevent potentially lethal intestinal diseases.
He continued to research the topic for a good 30 years.
Salisbury finally published his findings in the 1888 book The Relation of Alimentation and Disease.
Dr. Salisbury's book turned out to be a hit. The public was impressed by his findings,
and patties of muscle pulp of beef began to be seen as a cure for intestinal discomfort.
The food was eventually renamed Salisbury Steak, in honor of its creator, and it is now
widely considered to be one of the first American fad diets. Tired of shoveling in nothing but
forkfuls of Salisbury Steak, Dr. Salisbury suggested that eaters could switch to boiled
mutton for a similar effect. As civilians adopted Salisbury's low-carb diet,
the steak patty's status as a nutritious military meal carried on unabated.
The General Mess Manual and Cookbook, first published in 1904, included a recipe for
hamburger steak. 1945's edition of The Cookbook of the United States Navy also gives Dr. Salisbury
a direct shout-out with the inclusion of a recipe for griddle-broiled Salisbury steaks.
Salisbury, who died in 1905, recommended eating muscle pulp of beef three times a day,
accompanied by hot water to amp up its digestive cleansing ability.
While this may help alleviate acute stomach afflictions, like many fad diets,
it really isn't particularly sustainable in the long term.
Around the same time, Dr. Salisbury began promoting the healing properties of chopped beef,
a pounded meat dish called the Hamburg Steak was being cooked up in Europe. As its name suggests,
Hamburg Steak has origins in Hamburg, Germany, where it was known to be a popular dish in the
mid-1800s. It was introduced to U.S. kitchens through sailors and immigrants who landed in
Boston and New York City, and started showing up in cookbooks and on restaurant menus throughout
the 1870s and 1880s. A traditional hamburger steak is hand-pounded rather than ground or
minced, like a Salisbury steak, and then mixed with fried, finely chopped onions.
When the hamburger sandwich took the states by storm at the onset of the 20th century,
the hamburger steak's signature pounded texture began to change and was often swapped for ground
meat. Now, most hamburger steak recipes call for ground beef patties mixed with breadcrumbs
and onions before being pan-fried. Sometimes called the poor man's steak,
the hamburger steak is essentially a cross between fried meatloaf and a bunless burger.
In the mid-20th century, Swiss steak joined hamburger steak and Salisbury steak as typical
family dinner fare in homes across America. The differences between hamburger steak and
Salisbury steak are slight, yet still well-defined. But what about Swiss steak?
Well, it stands out from the other two steaks for a few reasons. For one, it's newer.
While hamburger steak and Salisbury steak gained popularity back in the 19th century,
one of the earliest known records of Swiss steak's existence comes from a recipe printed in 1915.
Another distinction is that it has a different texture, which also plays into how the decidedly
unswiss Swiss steak got its name. Swiss steak is a top-round, or rump cut of beef,
that is tenderized by a method referred to as swissing. Rather than being fed through a grinder
like Salisbury steak, or pounded into submission, Hamburg-style, swissing involves putting this
rough cut of steak through a machine equipped with tiny blades. The incisions made from the
blades break up the connective tissues responsible for the meat's less-than-ideal consistency.
Meanwhile, hamburger and Salisbury steaks are fried or broiled and usually served with a
healthy pour of beef-based onion or mushroom gravy. Swiss steak, however, is browned in oil
and then braised or baked in a stew-like sauce of tomatoes and onions. In modern times,
home-cooked Swiss steak is often prepared in a crockpot or Dutch oven.
During World War I, Americans said auf Wiedersehen to culinary words heavy with
German influence. Frankfurters were renamed hot dogs, sauerkraut changed into Liberty cabbage,
hamburgers became Liberty sandwiches, and the mighty hamburger steak merged with its
more patriotic cousin, Salisbury steak.
At times like this, I am proud to be an American."
Salisbury steak's spike in popularity was prolonged by the Great Depression,
which hit the U.S. hard in 1929. This was a time when resources were scarce,
forcing Americans to get creative with simpler ingredients. Salisbury steak fit in with other
Great Depression foods because it used inexpensive cuts and processing methods of beef. To make
matters even more stressful, the U.S. government began a nationwide food rationing system in the
due to the nation's growing involvement in World War II. It didn't take long for meat to be added
to the ration list, compelling Americans to stretch what they had as far as it could possibly go.
Salisbury steak continued to be a go-to meal, however, because it fed a whole family
and took well to being cut with oats or cream of wheat.
The Salisbury steak nourished American soldiers and civilians throughout some of the most
challenging times in the nation's history. But in the post-war era, its role would change
completely. Clarence Birdseye upended the frozen food game in the mid-1920s when he invented the
Double Belt Freezer. But his namesake, Frozen Food Empire, is not credited with creating the
first frozen dinner. That milestone belongs to Maxson Food Systems, a Long Island-based company
that used the Double Belt Freezer to make complete frozen meals called stratoplates in 1945.
These compartmentalized trays of meat, potatoes, dessert, and a vegetable were first marketed as
airplane food. As the 40s drew to a close, frozen dinner trays would turn up as bar food, courtesy
of Jack Fisher's Fridgie Dinners and as a regional novelty around Pittsburgh thanks to Albert and
Meyer Bernstein. However, it was mega-brand Swanson that made this idea iconic in 1954
when it sold frozen turkey as part of a compartmented tray meal, coining the term
TV dinner in the process.
"'Lucky me, my wife uses Swanson TV turkey dinners. And make your husband lucky too."
Turkey was the original meat sorts of a TV dinner, but with the convenience-over-cooking
trend showing no sign of slowing, variety was key. In the early days, Swanson TV dinners
were centered around turkey, fried chicken, meatloaf, and Salisbury steak.
The name TV dinner was inspired in part by the booming number of televisions that appeared in
more and more homes during the 1950s, and people's tendency to gather around it, even at
dinnertime. This was also a decade when American women were joining the workforce by the millions,
which meant fewer housewives were available to prepare dinner for their husbands and kids.
Just as the Salisbury steak had a place in the 19th century diet and the Great Depression era,
it found a comfortable place in the rapidly expanding TV dinner industry.
Too comfortable, perhaps? Banquet, a company known for its frozen meat pies,
quickly modified its business strategy to include an array of TV dinners that included Salisbury
steak.
"'I just put it in the oven, and by and by it was done. And I had a delicious buffet supper. Oh,
yes I did!"
Whether you were a kid whose parents worked late, a 20-something single person, or simply too tired
to cook after a long day, these frozen meals were a quick dinner solution. Newer brands such as
Stouffer's and Murray Calendar's quickly hopped on the TV dinner scene, many of them selling their
own versions of Salisbury steak. Today, Salisbury steak remains a popular choice for frozen TV
dinners. Sadly, due to being closely associated with the freezer aisle, it is rarely utilized
as a homemade dinner.
Dr. Salisbury would roll over in his grave if he knew that Salisbury steak is now considered
to be unhealthy. Flip over the box of a frozen dinner Salisbury steak, and you'll find a lot
of sodium, a lot of cholesterol, and, depending on the brand, ingredients ranging from the
concerning to the outright confusing. Surely this is not what Dr. Salisbury had in mind
back in the 1800s, when Salisbury steak was the health food of the moment. Unfortunately,
processed foods rife with sodium and preservatives have long been what TV dinners are all about.
If you had any doubt, consider the fact that the Environmental Working Group
rates Swanson's Hungryman Salisbury Steak Frozen Dinner a 10 on its concern level scale,
the worst score possible.
"'Hungryman,' it's to know the Swansons. Only much more of it."
That's due to its hardcore sodium level, the high chance of growth hormones in the meat,
and the dish's heavily processed nature. Even if you give frozen dinners the cold shoulder and opt
to cook a Salisbury steak on your own, the ground meat and gravy are still high in salt and saturated
fat. The modernized version of Salisbury steak is more comfort food than fad diet fodder,
so it's better considered a special treat rather than a daily meal. Sorry, Doc.
We know all about Salisbury steak's swaggering prowess in the frozen food domain,
but does that mean this is all it can ever be? Certain restaurants beg to differ.
One example is Grand Lux Cafe, a sit-down chain with locations across Las Vegas, Chicago,
New York, Dallas, and Houston. Grand Lux Cafe sees value in the classics and keeps
Salisbury steak on its menu, along with other home-style gems such as braised pot roast.
Then there's the more unexpected route. Hip New York eatery Sia's & Charlie
makes Salisbury steak cool again with a praiseworthy fusion called the Soulsbury Steak.
This dish is a playful marriage of Korean and Southern flavors that honors the owner's
Asian heritage and Atlanta roots. Unlike your ordinary Salisbury steak,
the Soulsbury steak isn't plated with the run-of-the-mill green veggies and mashed
potatoes, however. Instead, it sits on a bed of savory gruyere grits and features a Korea-inspired
galbijju in place of gravy. With such a storied legacy, it's not surprising that many label
Salisbury steak as a vintage comfort food. Salisbury steak as a TV dinner is almost certainly
here to stay, and that's not a bad thing. But in the 21st century, it wouldn't hurt to broaden
our expectations of this historical meal. The internet agrees, too. Chef John's YouTube channel
Food Wishes offers a Salisbury steak recipe, encouraging its 4.4 million subscribers to cook
the hamburger specialty at home. Recipes for vegan Salisbury steak are also plentiful online,
especially in the wake of renewed interest in vegetarian and vegan ground beef substitutes.
Fans of ready-made meals can enjoy much fancier types of Salisbury steak, too.
Cook Unity is a pre-made meal service that offers chilled — not frozen — dishes,
and they've got a Salisbury steak dinner of their own. The Salisbury steak entree is from
New York City-born chef Anthony Nichols, who elevated the frozen Salisbury steak by using
high-quality ingredients, adding caramelized onions, more sauce, and coupling it with more
refined sides. Time and time again, we've seen kitschy throwback items saunter back
into the spotlight, boosted by a renewed interest from the younger generation.
Maybe Salisbury steak deserves another turn as a food of the moment,
more than 100 years after the death of its legendary creator.
