著書は累計17万部を突破。英字新聞で毎週コラムを連載する他、コミュニティFMラジオでは冠コーナー「西澤ロイの頑張らない英語」が好評オンエア中。 インタビューが雑誌「CNN English Express」や英字新聞「The Japan Times Alpha」、北海道新聞の「ひと2014」欄に掲載された他、「プレジデント」「日経WOMAN」「THE21」等の雑誌や新聞、TV、ラジオなどメディア出演多数(ネットメディアを除いたメディア登場回数は合計1,000回を突破)。
I would like you to tell me how to distinguish between experience, continuity, and completion.
It's not about how to identify it, it's about how to feel it naturally.
Hello everyone! I'm Roy Nishizawa, an English doctor.
On this channel, we are publishing an uncommon learning method that makes difficult English easy to understand.
Roy-san!
Yes!
Currently, there are three requirements for completion, experience, continuity, and completion.
I would like you to tell me how to distinguish between them.
This is also a frequently asked question.
At school, you are taught that there are three requirements for completion, experience, and continuity, right?
Yes.
Because you are taught that there are three requirements,
you need to distinguish between them, and you need to tell me how to distinguish between them.
If you can understand the current completion system properly, you don't need to distinguish between them.
Eh? Is that so?
You can understand the meaning of how it is used naturally.
In this video, I would like to explain the current completion system from the basics.
The current completion system is a type of current system.
It's a current completion system.
If you talk about linguistics,
there is a thing called the present tense and the past tense.
And there is a current progressive system.
What is this progressive system?
Linguistically, it is called the so aspect, and it is an element that is added to the present tense.
In the present tense, there is an element called the progressive system,
and it is the present progressive system.
In the present tense, it means that it is still in progress.
And in the case of the current completion system,
there is a thing called the present tense plus the completion aspect.
In other words, it means that experience, continuity, and completion are added to the present tense.
By the way, there are also things that become the current completion progressive system.
This means that both progress and completion can be attached together.
And in the end, the current completion system is the present tense.
First of all, please keep that in mind as a basis.
Tony, how do you make the current completion system?
Is it a past tense behind the have?
That's right.
For example, if you eat,
in the present tense, it will be like I eat,
but in the current completion system,
there is a past tense behind the have,
so eat is eaten,
and I have eaten.
Here, the past tense eaten represents
the action of eating in the past.
I have eaten the action of eating in the past.
That's the current completion system.
Oh, I see.
But this have wasn't a verb,
it wasn't a feminine verb, was it?
That's right.
Grammatically, this have is classified as a feminine verb.
But have is have.
The meaning of have does not change when the tense changes.
That's why the basics of the current completion system
is to have the action of having in the past.
For example, let's think about breaking a bone.
There is an expression called I have broken my arm.
This is an expression of breaking a bone,
breaking my arm,
which is the action of having in the past.
What do you think it means, Tony?
Do you mean that my arm is broken now?
That's right.
If you classify this, it may mean that it continues,
but you don't need to classify it.
If you think that you have a broken arm now,
you can naturally feel the meaning.
I can definitely feel it.
How about this?
I have broken my arm three times.
Have you ever broken your arm three times?
That's right.
The moment the word three times came in,
the meaning changed to experience.
This is just an expression of such a past experience,
having three times now.
It's not about how to classify it,
but you can naturally feel it.
Let's go to the next example.
I have eaten lunch.
It has the action of having in the past.
Do you understand the meaning, Tony?
I ate lunch.
Do you know what the nuance is?
No, I don't know.
How about adding just?
I have just eaten lunch.
Oh, just after eating.
Yes, you can translate it like that.
But even if you can translate it into Japanese,
you will not always be able to understand English.
I want you to think about it here.
The present perfect tense is a type of present tense.
But isn't it like the past when you just ate?
Don't forget that it's a present tense here.
I'm having now.
I have an event that I ate in the past.
It's not the past that I ate,
it's the focus now.
Let's make it a question.
Have you eaten lunch?
It's a sentence like, have you eaten lunch?
But away from English.
As a Japanese story,
I want you to think about when you ask your friend,
have you eaten lunch?
What do you want to say when you say, have you eaten lunch?
Is it when you have plans after that?
Is it when you invite someone?
Yes, that's what it is.
If you haven't eaten yet,
you might want to eat together.
If you've already eaten,
you might want to invite someone to go somewhere together.
If you have a past of eating lunch,
for example, it's not hunger.
It means you're full.
The question, have you eaten lunch?
It's not asking if the fact that you ate is in the past.
It's checking if you're hungry or if you're eating.
That's why it's a type of present tense.
Is the main thing you want to hear about the present?
That's right.
It's not about the past.
There's an interest or focus in the present.
That's why I said, I have eaten lunch.
Or add just.
I have just eaten lunch.
This is focusing on the present.
I'm saying, lunch is already over.
If you divide it into both,
it might be complete.
But you don't need to divide it like that.
Let's look back at the three examples we've seen so far.
I have broken my arm.
I have a past of breaking a bone,
so it's still broken.
I have broken my arm three times.
I have a past of breaking a bone three times,
so I have that experience.
I have eaten lunch.
I have a past of eating lunch.
I have eaten lunch, so I'm not hungry anymore.
If you can feel that you have a past of eating lunch,
you don't need to divide it into both.
Don't hold back on the main thing.
If you divide it into both,
you'll need information like,
never, times, and experience.
When you ask for experience,
you have to ask, have you ever?
Have you ever seen this movie?
Like, have you ever seen this movie?
I remember asking for experience with ever.
You don't need to ask for it?
That's right.
Just say, have you seen this movie?
You're asking if you have a past of seeing this movie,
so you can take it as an experience.
That's right.
If you want to talk in detail,
if you add ever,
you'll emphasize it.
It's normal to say, have you seen this movie?
Then you can ask casually.
If you add ever,
have you ever seen this movie?
How do you emphasize it?
For example, you can make people curious.
If you say no to this question,
you can say, this is a great movie, so you should watch it.
If the other person's answer is yes,
you can say, I really like this movie.
How was it?
You can talk like that.
You can make people curious.
It's a detailed nuance.
You don't have to add ever.
I'm not going to emphasize that.
It's important to convey it.
I'm going to give you a little more example.
Have you eaten sushi?
How about this?
Tony.
Have you ever eaten sushi?
That's right.
I think you can naturally feel it as if you're gaining experience.
I'll set up a sentence here.
The person who is asked here
is a foreigner who has come to Japan many times and loves Japan.
He's been in Japan for about a week.
Let's say it's the fourth day.
In that situation, how about, have you eaten sushi?
Did you already eat sushi on this trip?
Yes, you can naturally get that meaning.
It doesn't mean, have you ever eaten sushi?
This is the perfect basis for the present perfect form.
So, there are three ways to gain experience, continuity, and perfection.
I hope you can let go of them.
Please remember that the present perfect form is a type of present form that overlaps what you did in the past.
The present perfect form was quite complicated compared to the past form.
It was just a type of present form.
If you have the feeling that you're overlapping what happened in the past,
you can understand the meaning without having to classify it.
I learned a lot this time. Thank you.
This time, I focused on the present perfect form,
but I'd like to explain the difference from the past form in another video.
I'd love to hear it.
Thank you for watching the video until the end.
If you found this video helpful, please subscribe, rate, and comment.
I'm so happy that I've been getting a lot of comments lately.
I'm happy, too.
I'd be happy if you could write in the comments what you think about the fact that you don't have to classify the present perfect form.
See you in the next video.
I'm Dr. Nishizawa Roy.
See ya!