Day 7 Phase Diagrams
Oct 14, 2023
0:00 reading quiz on phase diagrams
3:39 Why do we care about phases? Structure property relationships
12:16 unary phase diagram (water phase diagram)
16:50 triple point, phase boundaries, melting point
18:02 Gibbs phase rule
22:38 Where do phase diagrams come from?
25:17 Calculating phase diagrams from Gibbs Free Energy (sketching dG/dT and dG/dP)
32:02 Multicomponent phase diagrams
35:02 binary phase diagram with complete solid-solubility
39:17 solidus and liquidus lines. Identifying composition of phases
40:51 Vegards law and solubility limits
44:16 binary eutectic phase diagram
Okay, welcome to class.
Welcome to class.
Okay.
Happy Friday.
We will pick up right where we left off last time.
So let me first talk about the objectives, and then we're going to try and make sense
of the bizarre demo we saw at the end of class last time, and then we'll do a reading quiz
right after that.
So first up, our learning objectives for today are we're going to explore what variables
actually influence what phases are present, we'll do that in a unary phase diagram and
eventually a binary, we'll use something called Gibbs phase rule to predict something
called the degrees of freedom, or things we can change that won't mess with our system's
phase equilibria, we'll be able to sketch how free energy changes with temperature and
pressure when you account for different phases like solids, liquids, and vapors, we'll identify
things like solidus and liquidus lines which help us know what are the limits of solubility
within your different phases, and at the end we'll get into something called Vagard's
law which helps us predict solubility limits.
So maybe to begin with, actually let's do the reading quiz first, we've got three quick
questions for reading, so grab your clickers, let me make this bigger.
The first question says, in this phase diagram, if you identify region one, it wants to know
what are the phases present in region one, A, B, C, or D.
Okay, get your answers in for what is region one.
Okay, we're going to wrap it up in just 10 or 20 seconds, get your answers in.
What is region one, okay we're going to end it, what is region one?
Okay, most people realize it's alpha and beta.
Let's do the next one, what is region two?
What is region two?
Okay, another 10 seconds, this should be straightforward.
Okay, I'm going to end it.
Definitely beta and liquid.
And the last question is, what is region three?
And it's technically not a region, it's a point, if that makes your answer any easier.
Okay, get your answers in, the last reading quiz question.
Okay, I'm going to wrap it up.
What is region three?
Definitely a detected point, okay.
Okay, let's dive into chapter 10 then.
Chapter 10 is all about phases, right?
Phases of matter.
So let me just ask, what are we talking about when we say phases of matter?
Can I get some examples?
Shout something out.
Solid, that's a phase, what else?
Liquid, gas, is that it?
Critical, supercritical liquid, someone will say plasma.
Boside, is that it?
Those five, six things, is that it?
Is that all the phases that are out there?
I'm hearing yes and no.
Raise your hand for yes.
Raise your hand for no.
Okay, there's clearly more, then why can't we name them?
What else are we talking about?
Let me pick on Josh.
Ah, good question.
So you're asking, when we have that phase diagram, which was alpha plus liquid,
does that represent its own phase?
No, that's a multi-phase, that's a two-phase mixture in that case.
But are there other phases?
Anybody want to hazard a guess?
Well, let me answer with this.
Let's talk about the iron wire demo.
Last time, we had this iron wire.
We heated it up, and it started to get longer,
because most things expand when you heat them up.
And so the wire started to droop.
Now, we kept on heating it.
I never, it wasn't until the very end that I turned that lever back down.
So it's still turning it up, so it's still getting warmer.
And yet, you couldn't see it as easily on the heating up,
but actually, it drooped, and then it got higher a little bit,
and then it kept drooping like normal.
And then when I killed the power, it was really easy to see it.
It went up, and then it dropped down for a minute,
and then it went all the way back up to where it started.
Right?
So, how do we explain that in terms of phases?
Anyone want to take a stab at that?
Any guesses?
Yeah.
Oh, you're so close.
It did reach an equilibrium, but an equilibrium between what and what?
You're exactly right.
When we say equilibrium, that means that there's a reaction.
Right?
So in fact, iron at room temperature, we call it alpha iron.
Right?
Alpha, we'll learn what alpha means in terms of how the atoms are arranged
in like one more chapter, or two more chapters.
But for now, just consider that it's a way of arranging atoms.
Just like if I could take students, I could arrange them in like a square lattice
or a hexagonal lattice or whatever.
Right now, consider that as one type of lattice, and we call that alpha iron.
But there is a temperature when you heat iron up where it actually switches phase.
Right?
The atoms, even though they're all there in that wire,
they rearrange themselves to a different crystal structure.
And we call that, even though they're both solids,
solids is too broad of a term for a phase.
There are subsequent like individual phases within the solid category.
And in the case of iron, there's three different ones.
As you heat it up, it goes from one phase, alpha, to the gamma phase.
And then it turns into delta.
And I don't know who chose these letters.
That's just what people know them as.
So what we saw in that wire is we saw it transition
from one arrangement to a different arrangement.
Now if you had to guess, the high temperature phase,
do you think it's more densely packed or more spread out?
Why would you guess that?
Yeah, because, no, it's wrong.
It's the other way around.
Other way around, wrong.
Help us understand this.
Yeah, we were still heating this thing up.
So it should have kept on getting longer,
but it stopped and it went shorter,
meaning all those atoms, for whatever reason,
thermodynamics, they decided they would squeeze together
a little bit closer into a different crystal structure.
And then once they had completely,
all the atoms had squozen into some new different crystal structure,
then it's free to expand with thermal expansion just like before.
Squozen? I don't know.
How do you say that?
And then we saw the inverse happen when we cooled it down.
That high temperature phase, which was thermodynamically favorable,
as soon as you cool below a certain temperature,
the atoms say, eh, it's about enough,
and they stretch out to their more stretched out arrangement.
And then they continue shrinking, just like normal,
as you cool it down further.
So the reason I like the IronWire demos,
it draws attention to the fact that it's not just solid, liquid, and gas,
plus vapor, plus the other things that people said,
or whatever things you guys said.
It's actually a whole bunch of different types of solids that are out there,
like a gazillion different types of solids.
There's tons of them,
and we're just going to learn about a few of the important ones in this class.
So that said, why do we care about phases as engineers?
What do you guys think?
Why should you care about phases as engineers?
Well, just take the IronWire demo.
If you're an engineer who uses iron,
why would understanding phases be useful to you?
Turn to a neighbor and say something.
No one wants to talk.
Okay, what do we think?
Let me pick on, I think it's John in the black shirt here.
Yeah, so you'll be able to, like the phase diagram,
think of it like a map.
It's just like a treasure map.
It tells you where things are.
The phase diagram tells you what phases or what structures
are present as a function of what?
You said as you heat it up.
So as a function of temperature, for one thing.
Anything else?
Concentration, so let's call that composition.
We'll come back to that in a moment.
Anything else?
There's one more big one.
Pressure, right?
As you change the composition,
if you had like a two-phase mixture,
let's say like sugar and water,
you can change the composition of pure sugar
all the way to pure water.
The phase diagram will tell us what phases are present
as you change that.
As you change the temperature, it'll tell you.
And as you change pressure.
Now, pressure is less common to show phase diagrams
as a function of pressure.
They exist.
They're just less common.
Usually, they're plotted against composition and temperature.
Okay?
So again, why do we care about this?
It tells us structure.
So what?
Do we really need to know it?
How come?
Anybody else?
What else were you thinking when you were discussing?
Any other reasons why you ought to care about this
while you're in this class?
Or some advisor said,
let's make our mechanical and civil take this,
not just the material students?
Is there some reason?
Yeah.
Remember your name.
Yeah.
So absolutely.
In fact, there's something critical in material science
we call the tetrahedra of material science.
That is the nerdiest thing you'll hear all day.
Right?
You ready for this?
The tetrahedra of material science.
So you've got structure, property,
you've got processing.
Actually, no.
I can leave out the back corner.
I'm just going to do the floor, not pyramid.
Right?
You've got processing,
and then you've got a performance.
Sometimes they put performance and properties together.
The idea being that the study of material science
is all about understanding the linkages
between these four things.
Right?
So for example,
if you need a certain property,
a certain yield strength,
or a certain stiffness, right?
That is going to be tied to the crystal structure.
It'll not only be tied to the crystal structure,
it'll be tied to what we call the microstructure,
which is something at the micron scale.
And how do you achieve the different structures?
Well, you have to process them in different ways.
Right?
You have to process them in different ways.
And as you process them,
you can change the properties,
you can change the performance.
Right?
These things are all linked to each other.
So the study of material science
is about using things like phase diagrams
and lots of other tools we have
to understand these relationships
So you don't just build a car out of aluminum
and say,
aluminum is always aluminum.
You understand that actually,
it depends on what type of aluminum.
There's a whole bunch of different types, right?
And like in terms of composition.
And there's a bunch of different
microstructures we can achieve.
And we can make those microstructures
with different processing techniques.
So hot rolled versus cast versus plastic form.
There's all sorts of ways to make these things.
And you can't change one without changing the others.
Is what it's really getting at.
Okay.
So I'm going to skip that activity.
So let's talk about this one.
Let's consider the simplest scenario we've got.
Which means just one component.
Pure water.
Right?
Pure water.
As I increase temperature,
or as I increase pressure,
I can change what phase the water is present in.
Right?
You've got solid, liquid, and gas.
Or we call it ice, water, and vapor.
Or steam.
Whatever you want to call it.
Right?
So at high, high temperatures,
what should we have?
That's where you should have your gas.
Right?
At really high pressures,
what should we have?
Solid.
Yeah.
If you squeeze it enough,
you think you're going to have solids.
Right?
And then if you take a gas,
and you squeeze a gas,
what will you get?
Liquid.
First you're going to get a liquid.
Right?
So there must be a line here,
if you go from increasing pressure,
that you'll end up with a liquid.
Right?
Now water is unusual.
What do we know about ice and water?
Does ice float?
Yes.
So therefore,
that changes this diagram.
Right?
If you squeeze on,
basically,
well which one's more dense then?
If ice floats,
is it more or less dense?
Less.
Less dense.
Therefore,
it's unusual.
If you were to squeeze on ice,
since it's less dense than water,
you should cause it to transition to liquid.
Does that make sense?
If you took ice,
like a block of ice,
and I squeeze on it,
technically I should be able to push it
into the liquid regime.
Now in practice,
this is hard to do.
And a lot of people thought
this is why ice skaters
could ice skate for a long time.
They put all the weight of your body
on a thin little blade
and they thought,
oh maybe it's the weight of your body
pressing on that ice,
turning a thin little layer into water.
They've actually debunked that.
There's other reasons
why ice is slippery.
That was a pretty good guess.
Anyways,
this is our phase diagram for water.
Right?
Phase diagram.
This tells us,
as a function of pressure and temperature,
where you can find these different phases.
And this is just a cheesy sketch right now,
but it's still pretty useful.
For example,
anybody like to bake in here?
Any bakers?
Jeff.
Oh,
when we talk about it loud.
You can't answer.
Alright,
somebody else.
Matt,
do you like to bake?
Have you ever noticed
that instructions sometimes
give you two different times
or temperatures
depending on where you live?
Have you ever noticed that?
It'll say if you're
at a certain elevation,
double your baking time or whatever.
Nobody ever noticed that?
Anybody notice this?
Is it just me?
Some people have seen this before?
Absolutely.
So what's going on?
Where could,
let's talk about
that as it might relate
to this phase diagram.
How might that make sense?
Let's do Anthony.
So basically,
we went down in pressure
at high elevation.
Okay.
Liquid.
Oh,
you're really on the right track.
So think about it.
When you cook something,
it's oftentimes,
you know,
it's like,
it's high.
It's higher temperatures
than the water
would normally be boiling.
Right?
Or you're boiling the water maybe.
Now,
let me ask you this.
Does the boiling point
of water change
as a function of pressure?
How do we know that?
Because we have a line
right here.
This line represents
the boiling point
as a function of pressure.
Right?
So,
if I was going to draw
Salt Lake City,
Utah,
maybe it boils right here.
How will that compare
to Los Angeles?
Well,
Los Angeles,
do we go up or down
in pressure?
Remember,
think of the air like
it's an ocean of air.
That's why I remember this.
And we live high up
in the ocean
where there's less pressure.
Down in LA,
they live at the bottom
of the ocean of air.
Right?
So there's higher pressure
and smog.
So,
they are like,
they went up in pressure
from Salt Lake City,
wherever we're at.
They might be up here somewhere.
So,
their boiling point
is actually at a higher temperature.
So,
their water is literally
boiling at a higher temperature.
So,
they don't have to cook it as long
because it's hotter.
Right?
It's cooking your eggs
or your rice
or whatever's happening
at a higher temperature.
So,
these are actually kind of useful
not just for cheesy stuff
like figuring out
boiling temperature stuff.
They're really useful
for processing materials.
So,
let's keep going.
So,
the first point we're going
to talk about
is this point
where all three of those
come together.
We're going to call that
point A.
We're going to call
this one right here
point B.
This guy over here
will be point C.
And then,
this one out here
will be point D.
So,
somebody tell me
what is point A?
We call that
the triple point.
What does that mean
by triple point?
Why is the name
triple point?
Yeah,
what this means
is there is a single
temperature and pressure
and gas,
liquid,
and solid
all coexist
in equilibrium,
right?
All these things
will coexist.
Now,
what's happening at B?
What does B correspond to?
Salt and liquid,
what do we call that
in chemistry and science?
The transition
between salt and liquid,
we either call it
melting or freezing,
right?
That's the melting point
or the freezing point
if you're cooling down.
What about point C?
What do we call that?
Yeah,
we call that
boiling point
or the
condensation point?
I don't know
if that's what they call it.
Let's call it that,
the condensation point,
right?
What about point D?
That's just a guess.
We'll come back
to point D in a moment.
It becomes even,
I'll tell you what we marked
in just a moment,
okay?
Okay,
now the next thing
we want to talk about
is what's called
Gibbs phase rule.
Gibbs phase rule,
again,
this was the same Gibbs
like our very first PhD
in this country,
kind of an important person,
the same guy that
Gibbs free energy
is named after.
Gibbs came up
with this.
What else can we change
in our system
without changing
the equilibrium
of our phases,
right?
For example,
let's just work through it.
So this is the equation
for it.
It's P plus F
equals
C plus N.
What is
P,
F,
C,
and N?
Well,
P is the number
of phases present.
F is the number
of external variables
or the degrees
of freedom
that you need
to completely define
the system.
C is the number
of components
in your system.
And N is the number
of non-compositional variables.
So let's just
walk through these
one at a time.
Let's do it at point A.
At point A,
if we were going to apply
Gibbs phase rule
to try and calculate
the degrees of freedom,
we're going to do
P plus F
equals
C plus N.
How many phases
are present
at point A,
our triple point?
We've got three phases
present.
We don't know
what F is.
We're going to solve
for F.
So we're going to
know what F is.
We're going to solve
for it.
How many components
are there in the pure
water system?
Just one.
It's just water.
We haven't added
salt or sugar
or anything else yet,
right?
So just one.
And then what are
our number of
non-compositional variables?
Two.
We've got pressure
and temperature, right?
So in this case,
if you solve for F,
what is F equal to?
Zero.
So that's the degrees
of freedom.
We have no degrees
of freedom.
We can't change
anything in this system
and stay in equilibrium
that we had
defined at this point.
Because at that point,
you have solid,
liquid, and gas
all in equilibrium.
And you can't move
that point anywhere else.
You can't move it,
for example,
you can't go down
in temperature
or you get rid
of your gas, right?
You can't go up
in pressure
or you get rid
of your gas.
So there's just one
point where this happens at.
Now, what about point B?
What is Gibbs phase rule
at point B?
Actually, do this
for points B, C, and D.
So turn to a neighbor
and let's work
on these together.
Okay.
I think this is pretty
straightforward.
Somebody help me do this.
So for point B,
how many degrees
of freedom do we have?
One.
How do we know that?
Let's count our phase.
We've got two.
We say that we've got
one degree of freedom.
That's got to equal
one plus two.
Again, that's the only way.
We must have one degree
of freedom.
What does that mean?
It means we can change
one thing.
And then if we want
to keep equilibrium,
the system's going
to change everything else.
So let's show an example
of that.
Point B.
If I, for example,
I'm looking at the,
that's the melting
point, right?
So again, if I go
from Salt Lake City
to L.A.,
I'm going to go up
in pressure.
So if I choose
to go up in pressure,
then the system says,
all right, you have
to go down in temperature
so that you're still
on that line.
That's the only way
that you're going to achieve
the boiling point still, right?
So you can change one thing,
but the system will change
the other thing
if you're going
to maintain equilibrium.
Does that make sense?
Same thing over here.
This is going to be
two plus one equals
one plus two.
What about point D, though?
What's our degrees of freedom
at point D?
Two degrees of freedom, right?
So again, you've got
one phase there
plus F
equals one plus two.
So we,
F must be equal
to two there.
What does that mean?
It means that we can
change two things.
At point D,
we can go down
in pressure,
we can go up
in temperature,
and we're still
just a gas, right?
So we have two degrees
of freedom, okay?
We'll come back to this.
This becomes kind of useful
when we get to
more complex phase diagrams.
Again, this is a single
component phase diagram,
which is as simple
as they get.
They get more complicated.
Okay.
Let's move on.
So the actual
phase diagram for water,
by the way,
looks like this.
This is water.
It looks kind of like
what I drew.
One thing
that is really
a big difference
is look at the slope
of this line right here,
going from solid to liquid.
I drew that really
leaning that way.
That's a big exaggeration.
And actually,
water is incredibly unique
that it has that.
Water is one of
not a ton of substances
that actually has
the slope of water
that actually has
the slope of the line
between solid and liquid
as being negative slope.
And that is why
life exists on this planet, right?
It would not exist otherwise.
Because imagine,
if that wasn't the case,
then that means
ice wouldn't float on water.
That means ice would sink.
That would mean
that we could potentially
have completely frozen lakes
and oceans, right?
Because it just,
it freezes at the surface
and then just sink, right?
So it's a big deal.
It's a very big deal
that this exists
the way it does.
What else stands out to this?
Maybe something
you haven't realized
is that there are
two things.
One is that
maybe something
you haven't realized
is that over here,
in ice,
in the blue area,
which is ice,
there's actually,
what is that,
11 different types
of ice out there.
So there are a ton
of different ways
that water molecules
can solidify
and actually achieve
a solid molecule.
It's not just ice.
Ice isn't just ice,
isn't just ice, right?
And maybe you've seen this.
Skiers,
I had a student
who was on the Utah Avalanche team
a couple years ago
in this class,
and he's like,
yeah, absolutely.
Depending on the humidity
and the dew point,
the conditions,
your ice,
the snow that falls down
as ice, right,
is completely different.
Not only in terms
of the crystal structure,
but also in terms
of the microstructure.
In fact,
microstructure plays
a much bigger role
in the type of snow
that we ski on.
Whether it grows in rods
or platelets
or the flights
that you see
in the Disney movies,
totally depends on
things like pressure
and temperature
and the moisture level
in air.
And I think we'll talk
more about that
a little bit later on.
So I just want to show you this.
Now, the question is,
these are like actual values, right?
These are real temperatures
and real pressures.
So how did we get this?
Any thoughts?
How would you generate this?
How would you do it?
So yeah,
just like make an experiment
where you test these things,
that's one way,
and they do that.
People try and dial up,
but those are crazy pressures.
100 gigapascals?
That's bonkers, right?
Some of these temperatures,
anyways,
how you do that,
you can do it experimentally.
How else might you do it?
Anthony?
That's exactly what they do.
They'll take a couple data points
and then they use our old friend
Gibbs free energy
and they calculate
the Gibbs free energy lines for these
and they calibrate it
to a few known points,
but most of it is calculated, right?
So let's keep going.
The Gibbs free energy
calculates these things.
So how do we do that?
Remember, Gibbs free energy is
G equals H minus TS.
So we're going to teach you today
how to plot G versus T
or G versus P.
So let's put G versus T
and G versus P.
If we were going to plot it
for different phases,
how do we do that?
Let's do gas in purple.
Let's do liquid in blue.
And we'll do solid in red.
Okay.
Well, the first thing we need to do,
if we're going to plot G versus T,
we'd like to know
what the derivative of G is
with respect to T
so we can plot it.
So what is dG dt equal to?
We talked about this a few days ago.
Again, this is our G expression.
If you take the derivative of that
with respect to T,
what do you end up with?
Negative T.
Yeah, it's going to be proportional
to negative S, not T.
It'll be proportional
to the negative of your entropy
of your system, right?
Now what about dG dP?
Well, you have to remember
to make this easier,
you have to remember
that H itself equals U plus PV.
So now if you take dG dP,
what should it be proportional to?
Yeah, volume.
So if you're going to sketch these things
for these three different phases,
we realize that,
let's do volume first
because it's easier.
Which one of these three phases
has the largest volume?
Gas.
Therefore, the slope,
since we're doing dG dP,
that should have the highest volume
and therefore it has the highest slope.
Right?
So let's draw it.
It looks like that.
Okay?
Now which one has the higher volume,
liquid or solid?
For water.
Do it for water now.
Solid.
Solid has a higher volume.
So let's do the red.
So it might look something like that.
And then let's finally draw our last one.
We need blue.
Right?
I've drawn these with increase,
sorry, with decreasing slope
because we're going down in volume.
Now take,
this is where it really gets interesting.
You can then take this
and you can look at the points
where these things intersect
and how do we know
what phase will be present?
Oh, sorry.
Question?
Yeah, so they should have
the same starting point?
They don't have to have the same like,
they don't have to intersect
the zero point, for example,
as their y intercept.
Yeah, they don't need to have that.
Let me change that blue
and it's bugging me.
Let me redraw that.
All right,
so it still needs to be a positive slope
because it still has a positive volume.
Right?
At any given point in time,
how do we know
when anything happens in the universe?
It lowers its energy.
There will be a final exam question on this,
I'm sure.
Like how,
why do we know how anything happens
in the material science
and in the world?
Because it lowers its energy.
So you guys tell me,
if you had the option
of being these three different phases
at a different pressure, right?
If you're right here at this pressure,
right,
which one are you going to choose to be?
The one with the lowest energy, right?
You're going to want to be
all the way down here as a gas.
So at low pressure,
you'd like to be a gas.
Okay?
If you increase in pressure,
you're then going to become a solid
and then you're going to become a liquid.
And if we look at our phase diagram,
we can see where this happens.
Where do you go from gas to liquid,
sorry,
from gas to solid to liquid?
You do so right here.
Remember,
this line is actually a negative slope.
It's just very slight negative slope.
Right?
So right there,
as you increase pressure,
you started as a gas,
you turned into a solid
and then you'd become a liquid.
Right?
This make sense?
What if I wanted you to draw it right here,
that transition?
So you're at a different temperature.
You would have to change it.
You'd have to go from vapor,
liquid,
and then to a solid.
Right?
So the idea behind it is that
these lines just represent mathematical expressions
for your free energy,
which we can calculate,
which we will not do in this class.
Right?
But we can sketch them in this class
to make them match what we observe in a phase diagram
to teach this principle.
Does this make sense?
Let's do it for dG dt real quick.
dG dt.
This is now going to be the slope of the line.
We're just going to draw straight lines again,
but the slope of those straight lines
is going to be proportional to the negative entropy.
Right?
Negative slopes.
Which one of these three phases has the highest entropy?
Definitely gas.
So let's draw it right there.
It's going to have a high slope,
and it's negative.
Now then, which one's next?
Liquid or solid?
Liquid definitely has more entropy than solid.
Right?
So let's draw it like that.
And then finally we're going to draw solid as the...
And it's gone.
Where did it go?
And it's back.
But our lines are gone.
All right.
Thank you for that, Microsoft.
Right?
Fair enough?
We've drawn straight lines.
They have negative slopes,
and the highest slope is the one that has the highest entropy.
So just like before,
we can take lines and see where they intersect.
These points at which they intersect,
those represent melting points, boiling points, right?
These different things we talked about before.
So over here our lowest phase is going to be solid.
That's our lowest energy phase.
Here our lowest energy phase is going to be liquid,
and here it's going to be gas.
So let's take a look at our phase diagram
and see where we increase with temperature
and go solid-liquid-gas.
Where do we go solid-liquid-gas?
What temperatures?
This is a function of temperature?
Yeah, it's a function of temperature.
Yeah, so you pick a...
Exactly.
Above the triple point,
any of these pressures up above here,
if you take them and run across it that way,
you go solid-liquid-gas, right?
So that's the approach behind these.
This is a very, very simplified approach
because we're drawing straight lines,
and these things don't necessarily have to be straight.
But it's a good first-order approximation
to understand how you go from free energy,
which is something we can calculate,
to a phase diagram,
which is something that we as engineers can use.
On the homework, you'll have the opportunity
to draw some of these G versus P
and G versus T diagrams
for something that isn't water,
something like benzene.
Benzene, if you froze benzene,
it would sink to the bottom,
and you're going to have to rearrange that
to figure out how that's going to look
a little bit differently.
Or no, I think that.
Anyways, that's a typical problem to this.
Let's skip those for now.
At the end of class,
I'll go ahead and fill these things in
so you have them in the notes.
But for the sake of time, let's keep going.
And let's talk about multi-component systems.
Multi-component systems.
Now we're going to leave the pleasant world
where there's just one component,
like pure water,
and we're going to say,
what happens when you take pure water
and you add Kool-Aid packet to it,
or sugar, or salt, or something else to it?
How does that change what phases are present?
I used to teach this in greater detail.
I no longer do, but at the end of this,
if you scroll all the way to the bottom of this,
you'll see the notes.
If you want to see the full mathematical derivation,
it's there.
We just don't have time.
I don't think it belongs in intro class anyways.
So instead, we're just going to show you some pictures.
First off, let's start with sugar and water.
If you're like my son,
and you want your Kool-Aid with so much sugar
and not that much water,
you reach the point at which
you can't just stir the sugar in.
He's poured two cups of sugar into the pitcher,
and it's just not stirring in.
Why is that?
It's just sitting on the bottom.
Why?
There's a solubility limit, right?
There's a solubility limit.
So what does it look like for water?
Let me close up my notes.
It looks something like,
okay, you've got a positive slope,
and it's something out over there, right?
So if you plot temperature
against the weight percent sugar, right?
So maybe this is like 100% over here,
and this is like 0%,
and this is like where most people drink.
They're Kool-Aid.
This is where my son wants his, right?
There's a point at which
there's a line of equilibrium.
Over here, you have what we call syrup.
That's basically what you're drinking, right,
when you drink Kool-Aid.
And over here, you have what?
To the right of that line, what do you have?
You've got syrup plus sugar, right?
And then over here somewhere,
you've got pure sugar, right?
So here's our very first sort of phase diagram
that we can look at.
How do we know that that slope is positive?
Why didn't I draw it like that, for example?
How do you know that it's positive?
And it's gone.
It's obnoxious.
Well, we lost some stuff,
but it's mostly there, right?
Why is it not the other way?
Anybody taken something
and tried to increase the solubility?
You heat it up, right?
This is like Gen Chem first semester stuff.
If you want to increase solubility,
you stir it, and you heat it up, right?
You pick things that are like dissolves like,
but heating it up can make it better.
So the solubility,
you can put more and more sugar into something
and keep it a syrup if you just heat it up.
So this is the first introduction of solubility limits
that most systems, not all of them,
but many of them have solubility limits.
There's a limit to how much of your second component
you can mix with your first one
and keep a single phase.
Okay, so that's our solubility limit.
Let's talk about copper and nickel now.
This is one of the first phase diagrams you usually see.
If you start out with pure,
let me make sure I get this one right.
This is pure copper over here.
This is pure nickel over here.
The phase diagram looks a little bit like this.
Copper melts at a lower temperature than nickel
by a little bit.
This melts at 1085 Celsius, I think.
And this one melts at 1453.
I think those are Celsius.
They might be Kelvin.
But this is temperature on the y-axis, right?
So this would be the weight percent of nickel
going from 0% up to 100%.
So let's start to label this diagram.
What do we have if we take these two metals
and we heat them way, way up?
What phase will be present?
You're going to have a liquid for sure.
And if you cool it all the way down,
we're going to get rid of the liquids, right?
So we're going to call this,
let's just call it a Greek letter alpha.
We could have chosen any letter, right?
But that just represents that it's a single solid phase
because these two elements are so similar to one another
that we have what's called complete solid solution.
This thing, the fact that we can go all the way across there
and it's a single phase,
that represents complete solid solution.
And it's because they're so similar.
Yeah, complete solid solution.
Just like you can make a solution of liquids, right?
Sugar and water, it's a solution.
You can make a solid solution,
which is something kind of interesting to think about, right?
These are atoms, but they're perfectly mixed together.
Now, what about this middle region?
What do we have in the middle region?
Yeah, the way that you always do this,
anytime that you're labeling a phase diagram,
to figure out what's in a region,
you just look at what's on the left
and what's on the right at a constant temperature.
So at this temperature, on the left, we have liquid.
On the right, we have alpha solid.
So in the middle,
we must have a mixture of liquid and our solid, right?
Any questions so far on this?
Nope.
Yeah, you can write L plus alpha or alpha plus L.
Same difference.
It's just saying what phases are present.
A more important question are these two things.
First off, what's the composition of the liquid and the alpha?
That's our first question.
And the second one is how much of them are there, right?
So at this temperature, let's call this T1,
we'd like to know, first off,
what's the composition of the liquid and the solid present there
and how much of them are there?
So anybody from the reading want to take a stab at this?
How do we know what's what?
In the red shirt, I can't see your face.
Yeah.
What does the lever rule tell us?
That will tell you, well, it'll tell you both.
First off, it's mostly used to tell you how much, the amount.
How do we figure out the composition again?
Somebody remember this?
You drop, yeah, exactly.
So we're going to draw vertical lines down
from where it intersects these phase boundaries, right?
These represent our phase boundaries.
So we can drop this down and drop this one down.
This right here is going to represent
the composition of our alpha phase,
whereas this one here will be the composition of our liquid.
So what does this tell us?
If you go up or down in temperature a little bit
and let this thing reach equilibrium,
remember, all phase diagrams are assuming equilibrium,
but you don't always reach, right?
So phase diagrams are really imperfect in that way.
They assume equilibrium.
Sometimes that might take a long time.
But if you go up in temperature,
what do you do to your composition of your solid liquid?
I'm going to have to, it does not.
And now it's real mad.
I think we want to delete anything.
Still there.
I used flashback.
So if you go to a different temperature,
let's draw a different temperature
and hope it doesn't freeze again, right?
Let's go up in temperature.
We have two different composition values
for our liquid and our alpha, right?
Does this make sense?
So at any given temperature, I could say,
at this temperature, tell me the composition of the liquid,
or tell me the composition of the solid.
And you just have to identify, draw a flat line,
see where it intersects those two,
what we call the solidus and the liquidus lines.
Let's label these.
This here is called the solidus, S-O-L-I-D-U-S.
And this one up here is called,
this is just a really good punk that someone's doing on me.
The solidus and liquidus lines.
I might have to restart this in a minute.
Maybe, I don't think so.
Solidus and liquidus, right?
So you've got your solidus and you've got your liquidus lines.
Okay?
Any questions on this so far?
Again, this is a simple phase diagram
because these two elements are so similar to one another
that they can be completely dissolved one into another, okay?
So just because they can dissolve into one another,
that doesn't mean that copper and nickel are the same, right?
They have different melting points for one, right?
We can see that on this phase diagram.
They have different mechanical properties.
They have lots of different properties, right?
But what it does mean is that they must have the same crystal structure.
Again, crystal structure is the way that atoms arrange themselves.
If you imagine in a really simplified scenario
that you have like copper is like your atoms arranged like this
in some sort of square,
that they make sort of like this repeat square
that you could tile and fill space with.
You could just place atoms, right?
We can introduce a new parameter called the lattice parameter,
a lattice parameter.
The lattice parameter basically has to do with the separation
when you repeat these things over and over.
And if you go from pure copper to pure nickel,
even though they're the same crystal structure,
meaning that they're both a square arrangement,
that doesn't mean that they have to have the same lattice parameter, right?
So for example, nickel could be much larger.
It could have a much larger lattice parameter.
I don't remember which one is which in real life,
but that's the idea.
You could just vary it, okay?
And as you go from pure copper
and you slowly start to toss in nickel atoms,
your lattice slowly gets bigger and bigger and bigger and bigger
until by the time you get to nickel, it's that big.
Therefore, we can plot something called Vagard's Law.
Vagard's Law is this.
As you plot a lattice parameter
against your weight fraction
going from pure A to pure B component,
you should see data points that look like this.
It should be linear,
and if it stops being linear and then it stays constant,
what do you think that that suggests?
Maybe turn to a neighbor.
What does that suggest?
If you could somehow measure this lattice parameter
for all these different compositions
and it's increasing nice and linear, but then it stops,
what does that suggest?
Talk to a neighbor.
Okay, what do we think?
Who's never made a comment in this class before?
Okay, he's pointing, he's calling you out, bud.
What might that represent?
That's exactly what that represents.
You've reached your solubility limit, right?
Solubility says you can take one of these atoms out,
put another one in,
and it doesn't change the crystal structure.
So if this continues to increase,
then you must be switching atoms in and out
and slowly changing the size and structure, but not the type.
But all of a sudden, when it stops increasing,
that means that you've hit your solubility limit.
So one way to determine phase diagrams,
you know that this must be your solubility limit.
One way to do this is to make a bunch of these different alloys
at a bunch of different temperatures,
check their lattice parameter
with a tool that we'll learn in two chapters,
and then look what these things look like,
and then you could recreate a phase diagram, right?
That's kind of a pain in the butt way to do it,
but you could do that, okay?
So let's keep going.
Let's introduce a new type of phase diagram,
the next most challenging one.
We've done a simple one,
and we'll probably end on this one today,
is as following.
It's called the binary eutectic phase diagram.
So again, we're going to go from pure A to pure B.
There's pure A.
There's pure B.
This is temperature.
That's almost always what these are plotted against.
You could do it against pressure, but that's not common, right?
And we're going to show what happens here.
If it's a binary eutectic,
then that means we have to have a eutectic reaction.
A eutectic reaction is one that goes from a liquid
reversibly between two different solids,
say alpha and beta,
meaning that there is a eutectic point,
means that there's a certain point on this diagram
where if you cool down or heat up,
you'll undergo that reaction.
One liquid of a single composition
switches to two different solids
of different compositions, okay?
So let's draw what it looks like.
It might look something like...
Let me switch colors.
You've got something like this, okay?
So let's start labeling the different regions on here.
Like usual, the very top of the phase diagram,
that's when you've heated things up a ton.
That's where you're going to have your liquid phase.
Or, you know, if you kept on heating, I guess it'd be gas.
They don't ever show it on these diagrams.
But this is going to be your liquid up here.
Now, where else can we start to label?
The very bottom, that's where we're going to have what?
Alpha plus beta are two phases here.
And again, any time you have a region,
the things to the left and the right
tell you what's in here.
So we can call this one alpha and this one beta.
You can call it vice versa if you want.
Just convention is to do alpha on the left
and beta on the right.
And then again, these regions right here,
if you want to label it, you're just going to look
what's on the left and what's on the right.
So what about this one on the left?
How do we label it?
Yeah, alpha plus liquid.
And then the one on the right is beta plus liquid.
Now, where is our eutectic point?
At the bottom of this thing, where
it comes to the bottom of that V is our eutectic point.
Right there, that should be touching.
That is our eutectic point.
So the eutectic point has to have a specific composition.
We call this the composition sub E,
composition of the eutectic.
And we call this temperature that it
at the temperature of the eutectic,
or the eutectic temperature.
Any questions so far?
So this is a key point, because if you
have a liquid that's just above that temperature,
a few degrees above it, and you start
to cool down below that line, what that means
is that all of your liquid, without slowly converting,
it's all going to transform into a solid.
Whereas, imagine this scenario.
If you have a different one.
Let me switch color one more time.
If you start to cool it down right here,
that's not what's going to happen.
For example, as you're cooling down,
you're going down in temperature,
as soon as you touch that line, what happens?
The very first alpha begins to precipitate.
This isn't like a crucible or a beaker.
And you start to cool it down, your very first solid
is going to form.
Where's it going to form?
Where do solids form when you cool them in liquids?
It can happen anywhere.
Where does it tend to happen?
Anybody seen a water bottle freeze?
We'll talk about why that is when we get later
in this chapter on kinetics.
But it tends to start from the edges.
So you have little tiny grains, we call them,
grains of solid forming.
What's the composition of that alpha phase that's forming?
Anytime I ask what the composition is,
all you have to do is draw a little line over,
and you say, it's right there.
It's whatever this is, 5% or 10%.
You could look up what the value is there.
So as you continue to cool this thing down,
what happens as you cool down through that region?
More and more solid forms at the expense of your liquid.
So your liquid is going away as more and more solid forms.
And at the point just above this line right there,
just above our eutectic reaction,
do we have any liquid left?
By raise of hands, who thinks yes?
Who thinks no?
So which one is it?
That's a pretty even split.
A lot of people didn't vote.
So first off, because it's above that line,
we're in the alpha plus L region.
We must have alpha plus L there.
We haven't learned yet the lever rule,
which tells us how much.
But we know that there still must be liquid there.
And as soon as we cross below this line in here,
this says alpha plus beta.
Therefore, any liquid that we had
must have converted to a mixture of alpha and beta.
That's because when you go across this line right here,
that is the eutectic reaction.
Any liquid that's left over, be it a little bit or a lot,
at the eutectic point, it's all liquid.
And it all simultaneously converts.
And near these edges, it's actually
not very much liquid left.
But as soon as you cross that purple line there,
any liquid you have left undergoes
the eutectic reaction.
You get two solids.
We'll answer a couple questions.
We'll wrap up.
Yeah, question?
What does beta represent?
Beta represents, for the sake of this class right now,
it's just a different type of crystal structure.
If alpha was like a square arrangement,
this could be like a hexagonal arrangement.
One other question that I saw?
OK, we'll pick up here next time.

